The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Well quite. Exactly why activists push the language of ‘cis’ and ‘trans’ - to effect domination. We must accept their version of reality. Words shape thought.
Quotes a post by A1608; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You and many others! I think that is exactly what they did. Gay rights were won. After trans they can pivot to all sorts of fun and games. There will be sexual fetishes enough to campaign for until the end of time.
So what is the 'actual statutory test'? Can you tell me? If a child says being told to 'love your body' has caused them very serious harm and was done to persuade them out of being trans, then the offence crystalises doesn't it? Or can you point to the actual words of the proposed statute to show I am wrong?
If the intent is to persuade a child out of being 'trans' and if the child finds it extremely distressing, then the criminal offence crystalises. As @Jebadoo2 pointed out, the criteria of the offence are met by asking a child to 'love your body', if that makes the child very upset. It would certainly be met by refusing to pay for hormones or allow child to wear a binder. Do you think this is a sensible use of the criminal law? It's basic parenting.
So what IS proposed in a criminal Bill which sets out a maximum sentence of five years, if it is not to see people in prison?!?
O I get it! It’s ’criminal’ in the same way that a trans identifying man is a ‘woman’. You think words don’t matter but you want to use them to lie to people or scare them.
Quotes a post by T33623; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans identifying men are not excluded from the ponds. They have a choice of two ponds! It is without doubt and the law of our land, to allow and protect single sex female spaces.
Quotes a post by A1608; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Of all the nonsense propaganda about ‘trans’ this is in my Top Three of the most irritating and harmful. There was a massive change from about 2012, a huge surge in self ID and attempts to deny the reality and importance of biological sex. It is a very new issue.
Quotes a post by T26459; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Of all the misdirections, this is the most infuriating. ‘Trans’ is about taking a personal freedom - I declare myself to be whatever I want ! - and then seeking to impose it as an absolute truth on everyone else, in every situation, all of the time - and you will accept me as whatever I say I am!
It is not a ‘personal freedom’. It’s a forced compliance with a personal whim.
Quotes a post by T04132; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I am asking why paedophiles are excluded from the definition of transgender identity or sexuality because the Bill as currently drafted doesn’t say. Where do I find the exclusion of paedophiles, necrophiles, zoophiles, and furries?
Quotes a post by T08417; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Please confirm to me where these men are excluded in the Bill. ‘Transgender identity’ is undefined.
Please confirm where furries, necrophiles, zoophiles and paedophiles are excluded.
Quotes a post by T08417; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Can’t read this but concerned that the Times have wrong focus here - the problem is the CAFCASS guidance which is based on affirming ‘trans children’ and thus is very relevant to concerns about Conversion Practices Bill.
Quoting @thetimes: Social worker to sue over removal from case after pronoun row https://www.thetimes.com/uk/law/article/gender-critical-social-worker-sues-removal-from-case-pronoun-row-wnc87r7jk?utm_term=Autofeed&utm_medium=Social&utm_source=Twitter#Echobox=1793289046
What is the definition of ‘trans gender identity’ for this Bill please? Are furries and nappy wearers excluded? Are necrophiles and paedophiles and zoophiles?
Should we not be very clear about this before we start considering prison sentences?
Quotes a post by T16621; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If furries and adult nappy wearers are excluded, where do I find this exclusion? Are necroohiliacs and zooohiles excluded? Where? Is all the ‘+’ in or out? Where does it say that? Is a trans masc gender queer Demi boy in or out?
The serious harm is not defined as ‘life altering’. There is little doubt it will encompass a child who is desperately upset that his or her parents are not on board with a ‘trans gender identity’. Do you agree parents ought to be allowed to deny access to binders and or hormones? If not - why not? If they are sent to prison, where does their child go?
Quotes a post by T16621; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedchild indoctrinationdenialstate takes children
Because we know that in the current climate it is vanishingly unlikely that part of the law would ever be relied upon. But if the dark day comes that it is law, we might as well exploit it, and showcase just what a ridiculous, harmful piece of drafting this is.
‘Trans gender identity’ is not defined, exists no where else in law. Are furries included? Adult nappy wearers? If not, why not? Will expressing disgust for either now be a criminal offence? Haven’t we all got so much more that needs to be done?
Quotes a post by T16621; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Because I am very worried that children’s essential naivety and heightened propensity for fantasy, are being exploited by adults who will benefit from a growing army of ‘trans children’ - be it for medics to profit, vulnerable adults to seek validation or predatory adults to predate.
I use the word ‘magic’ to underscore what is being offered to children as some kind of ‘cure’ or ‘identity’ is not offered in solid ground, but is rather an example of a problem than a cure for anything,
Quotes a post by T17854; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
In terms of facts and figures, 2 years ago the spreadsheet for crowdfunders in terms of money raised was about £10 million. That will have soared now with the huge amounts wasted by the NHS in Darlington and Fife. Tribunal cases keep coming. So lawyers at least are doing very well out of this.
Money paid to Stonewall has slipped but Jolyon Maugham continues to raise heaps of money for his doomed trans causes.
Politicians remain wedded to unlawful notions as the Conversion Practices Bill shows.
Awful things are still happening and being funded, largely by the state. There is still a power behind this. I don’t think my language or my concerns are remotely hyperbolic.
Quotes a post by T29546; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
All the usual tropes of course. Hey! Trans identifying men are such a minuscule percentage, why do you care, all the way to the ‘research’ actually shows men have no advantage over women if they suppress testosterone and may even be disadvantaged because their mental health is impacted by all the attacks.
It has everything to do with it. The forced celebration of ‘trans joy’ becomes harder to enforce when people realise what exactly it entails. You don’t have to use medical terms or Latin words to talk about this. But ‘bottom surgery’ is a deliberately obfuscatory term.
Quotes a post by T00772; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
'life long medical pathway' are simple English words to accurately describe what happens to 'trans children'. They will have to take hormones for the rest of their lives.
Quotes a post by T15104; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Council of Europe called on all countries to ban conversion practices - what is driving this? Faika brings in wider European perspective - this is an ongoing political project. It’s about trans activists.
Trans rights activists already saying Bill should go further - no protection for therapists. Will impact parents and therapists. @[private account] report discusses this. Listen to @SexMattersOrg podcast. Parents want to protect child.
People are ‘trans’ in the same way they are religious. An often harmless delusion - unless and until they start thinking they can force others to believe what they believe or they impose irreversible medical/surgical interventions on children in support of this delusion.
That’s when we have a problem, you and I.
Quotes a post by T17539; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
That's only GRCs. About 120K identified as 'trans' in recent census but those figures may not be accurate due to poorly phrased questions. But, as I said, it doesn't matter if there is 1, 100, or a million. You can't change sex. The law recognises this.
I recall the investigation into the ‘trans Holocaust’ and if irrc they managed to identify 3 or 4 people at a pinch who were ‘trans’ and had been murdered by the Nazis.
Quotes a post by A0332; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The claim that there are only 80 trans people in the UK is wild - there are at least 5k people with GRCs. But it doesn’t matter if there is only 1 trans person in the whole world. The problem is that various organisations started insisting that it was possible to change sex and women just had to put up and shut up.
Doctors started irreversible medical interventions on children on the lie that they could change sex or their ‘gender identity’ was more important. The NHS funded this. Big scandal in court right now about Dr Hall in Brighton.
If being expected to obey the law and respect the rights of others makes your life ‘hell’ then I am sorry to hear it but it does not make you exempt from the law.
Quotes a post by T08438; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Do please identify the lies. And do please dial down this predictable, tedious and harmful constant refrain that I want trans people ‘eradicated’.
I simply ask that you obey the law. Just like everyone else. This is an entirely reasonable request. That it is inevitably met with such rage and escalating victimhood, tells us all a lot about this cohort.
Quotes a post by T17712; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I agree that as a group, men are the ones to worry about.
And given that you cannot change sex, trans identified men remain in the group that commits the overwhelming majority of sexual and violent assaults on women and children.
Quotes a post by T17539; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C2 false claimshand-codedchild predatordenialviolence terror
‘Excitement’ is rarely my dominant emotion, but the fact the IOPC have done anything at all is little short of miraculous. Last I saw they were waving trans flags with gay abandon.
The reverse Midas touch of Lynsay Watson is evident again.
Quotes a post by T19972; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is a pointless argument. In my view. There are people who believe themselves to be ‘trans’ just as people believe in gods and fairies. They are entitled to that belief, but not to our rights, our laws or our reality.
Yes. I have independently decided I am not 'anti-trans' because I know that wanting to recognise the truth and tell it is not 'anti-trans'. Nor is recognising the rule of law and wanting to protect it. Nor is concern for the rights of women and the safety of children etc etc.
People may be and do whatever they want that is within the law. What they may not do is coerce others into believing or celebrating something that can't be established as objective truth or existing law.
I am supported in this independent and subjective assessment by the failure of any agent of the state, including the police or my regulator, to take action against me, despite some years now of investigation and assessment.
Quotes a post by T01026; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yes, the corruption of the medical model from 'what the doctor says' to 'what the patient wants' has been an important weapon in the trans activists armoury. But doctors WERE arrogant and distant; I remember my experiences as a child in the 80s and still feel panic and fear to this day. The solution however was not to make them simple puppets of those with serious mental health conditions.
So bad news for the (majority of) trans people who do not pass! Your access to opposite sex spaces will be determined by how successfully you can mimic a sex based stereotype.
I wonder who will be making those determinations? Will Peter set up a committee, you submit your photo in advance and get a Dolls Recognition Certificate?
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Then explain what it means and tell me what I do that fits that meaning. If you can do so in words and not emojis, that would be great. I am not ‘afraid’ of trans people. I simply know you cannot change sex, and the law agrees with me.
Yes. Because they are. And a surprising number seem to get pregnant: they need protection for the rights that flow from this.
It was in fact trans identifying women who secured the Supreme Court victory. As treating them as men was a very clear revelation of the hot mess created by gender identity.
Quotes a post by T06038; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
And what of all the women forced out of their jobs? Kathleen Stock was threatened by masked men: nothing was done. Racheal Meade was suspended for two years because her regulator thought that a GRC changed your biological sex. Her regulator was of course advised by a trans activist lawyer and it folded very quickly when it realised its idiocy was about to be exposed publicly.
This has all cost millions of pounds and caused great harm. But these men think it’s funny and now tell us it’s time for mature debate.
We won’t forgot what we had to deal with.
Quotes a post by T25162; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It’s simply the logical end point of telling us all that our ‘identities’ are the most important things to exist in the History of the Known Universe Ever but also that these ‘identities’ are so fragile and ephemeral that they will be destroyed without constant external validation.
So of course you must surrender your own body to them any time and in any way this is demanded or you are an evil bigot.
BUT and very, very interestingly, the focus still appears on women being told who they must fuck. Still not seeing the push to shame straight men into having sex with trans identified men. I suspect that is because the reality of male disagreeableness and superior strength is still real enough even for delusional idiots to respect.
Quotes a post by T21233; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Except for all the ones raping etc, who clearly were never really trans at all, just pretending. But obvs we don't have any way of finding that out until after they have committed the criminal offence.
? Please read more carefully or at all. 'bullying' appears to be a highly subjective and slippery concept. I don't think it's effective in the long term - as the trans rights activists have demonstrated, over and over and over again. By all means, do not engage with someone you consider a 'bully'. But wanging on and on and on and on etc about him being a 'bully' to avoid dealing with the issues he raises is curious to say the least, particularly as the worst offenders are self identifying journalists.
Linehan made a joke about kicking a trans identifying man in the balls if he wouldn’t leave a single sex female space. For this he was arrested at gun point.
I suspect the men who frequently visit my on line space to threaten me are not joking and they are never arrested.
I shall now wait for the inevitable angry people for whom the problem with what I say here is that all the police at airports have guns, don’t I know anything, the guns are irrelevant, stfu you stupid old ugly bitch and so on and so on.
So yes, I support Linehan. He can at least focus on what is real and on what matters.
Quotes a post by T00823; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
He at least has sufficient self awareness to tell an anecdote against himself. He stewed for years over bullying at school in Cardiff and eventually emailed one of the bullies who replied he was bullied because he was very annoying and from the tone of that email nothing had changed. Strange he has such a blind spot around trans issues.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] How many of his trans friends had their puberty blocked? In 20 years the full horror of what was done to these children will be undeniable, in the wreckage of their adult lives.
It’s about reasonable categories of exclusion not saying trans identifying men are ‘the same as’ drunk drivers. This should not be a difficult concept.
Now do male conviction rates.
Now tell me the test for distinguishing trans identifying men from other men.
Your homophobia is an unrelated point. Children do indeed only have one father and one mother who creates them. But what matters more is who raises the child and how. Biology is no guarantee of kindness or safety,
Quotes a post by T17145; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
No attempt to measure likely success, no warning about inherent uncertainty and certainly no control over where your money goes when this crashes and burns
https://goodlawproject.org/crowdfunder/help-the-greens-protect-trans-members/
I am only afraid of the trans people who threaten to kill me, as I am reasonably afraid of all such people regardless of their sex or gender identity.
I am not ‘afraid’ of trans people per se but I am very angry with and exasperated by those of whatever sexuality or gender identity who dare to assume they can tell me what I may say or what I may think.
Quotes a post by T13400; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedspeech persecutionviolence terror
? I have been exposed to his smug trivialisation of the trans issue over many years. It makes me reasonably question what else he has been dishonest about. You want to read it, you go ahead.
I suspect it would be fairer to say 'people with socio pathic or narcissistic personality disorders' - it just seems that 'trans' has become their weapon of choice.
No, I stated explicitly that this man threatened to kill me if I didn’t watch what I said about trans people. Do you think this is acceptable behaviour from your cohort?
Quotes a post by T24700; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
But many of us do not care about gender and/or are horrified that it is taking the place of sex. I will happily acknowledge his 'gender' and have done so repeatedly. He was a trans identified male. I am not 'yelling at the family', I am posting on a public micro blogging site. If family members choose to read or engage, that is their choice. I am not outside their house, shouting through the letter box.
Off to Swindon Pride with my Trained Operatives to see for ourselves what the police mean by this ‘duty’ to support a marginalised community. If they interpret this ‘duty’ as requiring themselves to be wrapped in trans flags then I will make sure to capture these precious moments.
? He was a trans identifying boy. We know he wasn’t female because he was described as trans. If he was female then there would be no need for that descriptor.
Quotes a post by T19420; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Never claimed it was. I always said it was part. Which it obviously was and there is no sense in trying to dodge that. Some people really do hate trans people.
The judge found that hatred of the boy's transgender identity was part of his motivation to kill him. I am surprised and puzzled why you would wish to argue against this.
One of the killers was clearly motivated by hate for the boy’s transgender identity the other wasn’t. They were both very dangerous but fortunately for the others on their list, incompetent.
So no man who hasn’t been on HRT for a minimum of two years can be a woman? Not a bad test. Bad news however for the 80% of trans identifying men who have neither hormone or surgical intervention.
So what’s the test for a man versus a trans identifying man?
Both are men. Both say they are women. Does the trans identifying man take hormones and/or invert his penis? So men who don’t do either can’t be trans?
Or is it just a question of growing your hair and wearing makeup?
Can you explain? Women need to know.
Quotes a post by T13593; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
No. It means a ‘trans identity’ is just as ‘valid’ as any other identity. It’s important to you and you must not be abused for it. But it’s unimportant to most other people and they can’t be forced to celebrate or affirm it.
Adults can wreck their own bodies in the manner of their own choosing but I don’t think public money should be spent on adult delusions. Buy your hormones with your own money.
Quotes a post by T22487; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Transgender identity was slipped into the Legal Aid Sentencing and Punishing of Offenders Act 2012 - key example of smuggling. Focus entirely on the removal of legal aid.
No. Your assumption that the same rules apply to trans identified men as the rest of the population. They are subject to very different and indulgent approaches.
How about allowing trans identified males into female spaces? Do you accept about of women to in this makes them less safe?
Quoting @ZoeJardiniere: Trans women are women & trans men are men.
No one is going to convince me that forcing some poor trans dude into the female changing rooms or vice versa would make me or anyone else safer.
Why? Trans identifying people are a very small minority. They do not get to force all of us to abandon the organising category of sex. Men are excluded from female spaces. ALL men. Women are allowed into female spaces, unless they are cosplaying as men so successfully this will cause fear and distress to other women. This is the law. Seems simply enough to me. Why don't you put your energies into campaigning for better and safer unisex spaces.
This is not a very impressive commitment to the Far Right Bigot Pledge that you signed at the last meeting. I am afraid therefore that your monthly stipend of Shadowy Funding has been withheld until you confirm you have organised at least a medium sized genocide of your local trans community.
If any man can be a woman on his declaration alone then women’s rights are immediately and seriously impacted. We will not be allowed any single sex female spaces, which will put women at immediate risk of serious harm in sports and in prisons.
It is not ‘eliminating’ trans identifying men to expect them to accept there are some spaces they cannot go. It is asking no more than that they comply with the law that everyone else does.
Quotes a post by T18747; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Maugham is encouraging MPs to be targets, most notably Wes Streeting
1. JM uses extreme and inflammatory rhetoric to criticise both the Government and the legal system, to which his status as King’s Counsel gives undeserved credibility
a. JM asserts that the Government is ‘killing’ trans people Stuart Macintosh on X: "So I take it you didn’t get an invite? Don’t they know who you are? https://twitter.com/stueymaco/status/2071682563416994184/photo/1" / X
b. On 31 May 2026 he called Wes Streeting ‘the trans killer’ Paul on X: "@SVPhillimore @[private account] He once (just this morning) labelled Wes Streeting “The Trans Killer”. https://twitter.com/greasydunlop/status/2061041625887858772/photo/1" / X
c. JM calls the entire UK court system a ‘fucking joke’ for removing male prisoners from female prisons, calling this an attack on trans rights rather than a defence of women’s rights. For Women Scotland on X: "Jolly M repeats the line currently bandied about on Reddit - where was the representation of trans people? Here's the thing. Scottish Trans, Stonewall, LGBTYS etc were perfectly entitled to intervene if they so wished. They didn't. That isn't our fault or the fault of the court. https://twitter.com/ForWomenScot/status/2068009273183854716/photo/1" / X
d. JM asserts that he, as King’s Counsel, does not trust the UK legal system and that the Supreme Court was profoundly wrong to decide that sex in the Equality Act means biological sex. https://x.com/kamabi/status/2045466522559070413?s=20 (April 18 2026)
Quotes a post by T25830; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
He did indeed. From my 'Maugham dossier'
1. Maugham has published on line the following direct support for this group
a. April 2026 he posted above the image of a man in a balaclava wielding a hammer ‘the non-violent action promoted by Bash Back is the inevitable, and I would say legitimate, response to a society whose institutions, politics and media systemically dehumanise trans people. No pasaran’
b. When another poster objected to the image, JM replied ‘As you know, there is a long and proud tradition of non violent resistance. So this is hardly unprecedented. And I think a broad change ecology should also accommodate this’.
c. JM further attempted to justify his support of Bash Back by saying ‘how should you participate in a society in which the ‘health’ system systemically harms your health, the ‘human rights’ commission removes your human rights, the justice system refuses even to hear you and the ‘independent’ State broadcaster lies about’
d. He deleted his Bluesky account on 15 July 2026 which was four days after the arrest on 11 July 2026 of the suspect in the murder of Ann Widdecombe, who was struck 21 times with a hammer.
Quoting @LordWalney: Did he? That’s pretty serious
C4 targetinghand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
It matters because men are claiming to be women on nothing other than their declaration and demanding access to single sex female spaces. It matters because children are being lied to and suffering serious harm.
If ‘trans’ people were willing to treat their belief exactly as any belief - to be tolerated so long as it stays within the law - we would have no problem.
But they are not. They want their ‘belief’ to become everyone else’s reality and we therefore have a huge problem.
Quotes a post by T25211; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] @[private account] ? Trans women are men and trans men are women. This doesn’t ‘invalidate’ them, they can pretend to be whatever they want. They just can’t expect me to buy into it.
This reflects such an interesting and hard baked world view: that women exist and are of importance only to the extent that they support and service men. It really does explain why gender identity and its corresponding focus on trans identifying men, took such a profound hold.
Quotes a post by T20186; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Do you think men have a clear boundary between child and ‘fecund woman’? Girls can be ‘fecund’ at 13. Should men be ‘appreciating’ them? What I find most difficult here is that you are not listening: you are broadcasting your pet theory that feminists are responsible for ‘trans’ - because they teach women not to glory in their sexual power over men?!?
If you don’t understand the impact of the male gaze, you will not understand. Anxiety and depression will always be with us; ‘trans’ was sold as the lie to fix it. But people will always find a way to be mad.
Page 3 did not ‘celebrate young womanhood’. It celebrated a particular type of female body that was set out for the male gaze. Those women who met the standard were seen as fair game, those who didn’t were mocked or ignored. Young women responded with anorexia and cutting.
‘Trans’ is simply the current way for this anxiety and desire to escape a female body to manifest.
To suggest page 3 indicated ‘reverence’ that was a protective factor for women’s mental health is a bold take but not one that stands up to a moments scrutiny.
Quotes a post by A0662; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
At least this clearly articulates what ‘rights’ trans identifying people claim they don’t have. But they have never had this ‘right’.
The GRA 2004 didn’t give them this right - it excluded inheritance, parenthood, criminal offences and sport. The EA 2010 didn’t give them this right.
If they want this ‘right’ they will have to campaign to bring in a new law, not threaten, harass, abuse and lie about women.
This must be the most bizarre and stupid campaign I have ever seen. Are the ‘trans’ the apex predator? Or do only apex predators like the ‘trans’? Associating ‘trans’ with a massive shark seems unwise on any level.
Amnesty and the Good Law Project really need to listen to the trans people they purport to defend and support. It is especially interesting to see the growing realisation about the Good Law Project’s business model.
It is an utterly bizarre campaign as it’s impossible to work out what it’s trying to say, other than sharks, gorillas and T Rexes fully support the ‘trans’.
Quotes a post by T14006; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
What the actual fuck is this meant to be?
The shark is lying and trying to attract some nice juicy 'trans' into the sea as a snack?
Is the shark meant to represent the 'trans', trying to make friends with a seal?
Is this real?
If so how much did they pay for it?
Quotes a post by A0332; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Again. It doesn’t matter if people know a trans person or have ever met a trans person. What matters is the people who will apparently do anything, including lying, to force them to agree that they have to accept anyone’s self identification about anything at all.
How interesting that she knows full well she has to avoid ‘framing our message’ because it is such a simple and powerful one: don’t lie and don’t force others to lie.
Quotes a post by A2915; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
During my rare trip out to Bristol last night there were three immediately obvious trans identifying men. One in the female toilets - not acceptable. Two sitting in the pub looking anxious and uncomfortable in really unflattering outfits of teeny skirts etc . They weren’t visually appealing but so what? No one was asking me where I got my out fit either.
They sat in the pub having a drink. They weren’t visibly masturbating or pressing themselves against me. By what law can I demand they go and out some trousers on? Just what do people think this law should say and how do they propose it’s enforced?
Accept you can’t change sex, stay out of single sex female spaces and dress however you wish that covers up your genitals.
Quotes a post by T30849; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Very interesting trip to see David Sedaris in Bristol tonight. An obvious trans identifying man in the women’s toilets. Sedaris told an interesting anecdote about a person he called a ‘trans woman’ and ‘handsome not cute’. No objections from the audience who admittedly were all old enough to be nearly dead. But if transwomen are women there would be no need to identify him as such?
Walked to car past a number of clubs bearing trans flags and one with a man outside gyrating naked save for the teeniest Y fronts, his backing track announcing he was a freak and could I handle that?
Old age will hit this generation like a freight train on fire. Maybe it is only aging that makes you respect the limitations of your body.
He was gay and Jewish; that’s why he was targeted. Trans identifying people were not the main or any target of the Nazi Regime. I think only six trans identified people were murdered; the Jews suffered rather more.
The moment you agree to stop accessing single sex female spaces or pushing for medical transition of children is the day when with enormous pleasure, I will never need to talk or think again about gender identity ideology or people identifying as 'trans'. Until that happy day, expect much, much more from me.
Because it is not women's job to keep men safe. Trans identifying men can do what women had to do in the 1970s and set up their own refuges etc.
Women are not a comfort blanket or a shield for men who are afraid of other men. This is for men to sort out.
Quotes a post by T19594; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I am hoping this case brings this central and salient fact centre stage.
Baroness Hale may weep soft tears for the trans identifying man who ‘only’ wants the whole world to see him as a woman, but the ‘whole world’ is not under his nor any court’s control and people will continue to follow the evidence of their eyes and ears.
And must be allowed to do so, absent any direct abuse/harassment.
Quotes a post by T18069; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
My goodness gracious me. What ‘connotations’ exactly? That a man is a man! This would be my hard line. This person is not in the room. Trans identifying man is accurate.
Quotes a post by A2920; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
1st FWS case, Scot Gov devolved powers did not permit them to modify Equality Act. Scot Gov tried to include men undergoing GR within female sex. This was outside their powers. Sex under EA is biological. Then FWS 2nd case dealt with attempt to get men within definition of women if they had a GRC - certificated sex. Scot court said that’s lawful. Went all way to Supreme Court which held sex is biological. This was inevitable. Or the Act is otherwise unworkable. A trans identifying woman with a GRC who gets pregnant is not protected under pregnancy PC
We had Equal Pay Act and then Sex Discrimination Act in 1975. Sex did not depart from biological meaning. Parliament did not have in mind ‘non biological sex’ although trans people in the 1970s. First change the Cornwall case. Sex was broad enough concept to protect against GR discrimination as it was related to sex.
And that is one of its many problems. At the time of drafting, everyone assumed that the ultimate aim of trans identifying men was to cut their penis off. That is no longer the case, indeed its forbidden by the ECtHR as a requirement to change in gender/sex markers.
This is the fundamental mess. Discussion prior to the GRA was based on the assumption that what trans identifying men wanted was to remove their penis; this was their ultimate and logical goal to be seen 'as a woman'.
Clearly it was seen as a little harsh not to reward these men for such significant commitment by allowing them to be seen as 'women'. I think this view had and still has a great deal of support.
But then the ECtHR made it clear that changes to 'gender identity' or sex markers MUST NOT be based on any intervention that would sterilise, as this was a breach of fundamental human rights.
So now we have men, with a penis and testicles, and no intention of removing either, and no expectation that they must, claiming 'to be women' and relying on the previous sympathetic cases about the men who did want to remove their genitals.
Quotes a post by A0989; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Everything changed. We can see this from the screaming and hysteria that followed, the desperate attempts to deny the EHRC guidance as if this was some talisman that stopped the law.
It enabled me to reject with confidence an attempt to police my language via a regulatory complaint. It allows single sex female spaces to be protected once again rather than used as a totem of bigotry.
We got our law back and we got our rights back. You can’t change sex. Trans identifying men are men.
Quotes a post by T30005; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans identifying people can exist as much as they like. What they cannot do is force me to comply with their belief system.
I am an atheist. Christians, Jews, Hindus etc go on existing. They don’t demand I pray with them. I don’t desecrate their temples. We get along fine.
It is exactly the same with gender atheism. Obey the law and live as you wish. Try to force my compliance - we have issues.
Quotes a post by A3339; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans people remain the sex they are and must accept that this excludes them access from opposite single sex spaces. This has nothing to do with ‘culturally responsive’ training but with an acceptance by all that the world does not bend to serve their every whim.
Quotes a post by T15057; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Sorry my coffee break is only 15 minutes so I don't have time to get through that. Being gay and being trans are nothing to do with one another. One recognises sex is real and it matters; the other doesn't. Can you distil your point into something I can read in under 15 mins?
Yes. You can't change sex. Trans identifying men remain men. Most trans identifying men make no changes whatsoever to their bodies by either hormones or surgery. Men commit about 90% of all sexual and violent crimes. 80% of their victims are women. Men across every metric, every time and culture pose more of a risk to women than other women. Women therefore have a right to single sex female spaces.
No. This is irrelevant. Sex is real and it matters. Gay people are well aware of their sex: it defines their same sex attraction.
Trans people are also well aware of theirs otherwise they could not be ‘trans’.
Quotes a post by T14145; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Children parrot online prompts which they do not understand, and are not challenged to unpick. I represented a mother in one case where her teenage daughter was not asked a single question about fertility. Why do you think this is irrelevant to ‘trans’ being seen as the acceptable alternative to being gay? Something very odd is being allowed to happen.
And this isn’t one of them. With dame sex marriage legalised, homosexuals are fully protected in this country. So no wonder Stonewall had to turn itself into a trans rights organisation. An entirely different battle.
Quotes a post by T23945; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I agree. Sex is very important when it matters. It doesn't always matter but when it does, trans identifying people have no 'human right' to lie about it.
IF they are taking hormones. My point is that MOST trans identifying men don't. You seem to agree with that and say its my fault they can't get hormones. Try to be clear with what point you are making.
? It will prove what sex they are, which is important if they are trying to access single sex spaces. Most trans identifying men do not take hormones or have surgery.
? Are you not aware that the majority of trans identifying men do not undertake ANY medical or surgical interventions? Of course men have breast tissue but significantly less than women, their rates for breast cancer are correspondingly lower. Even those men who do take hormones, studies have shown their risks are higher than other men, but still much lower than for women.
Sex is the organising category, not gender. Trans identifying men should not waste NHS scarce resources in 'routine' breast cancer screening as men get much lower rates of breast cancer. Neither position is 'unreasonable' just because you dislike it.
A neat way of proving my point. Rather than consider that ‘anti trans’ views (I.e the protection of women’s rights and children’s safety) might actually be reasonable, it must be instead an entire legal system that is wrong.
It is so curious and so interesting an example of confirmation bias. It has rendered so many otherwise intelligent and thoughtful people, utterly incapable of rational thought or reasonable analysis.
Just how and why did THIS issue of all the issues work such a dark magic?
Quoting @Alonso_GD: One of the things you notice early on as a Civil-Law-trained lawyer in the UK is the massive importance that “reasonableness” plays in UK law. And then you look at anti-trans talking points and they are just so unreasonable. It just doesn’t add up
It is not hard at all to see how we got here. If doctors are perceived as ‘eroding’ a child’s ‘right’ to be ‘trans’, rather than under investigation for persisting in significant and irreversible medical interventions on children with no sound evidential basis… then little wonder that my legitimate criticisms of Weddell and others is reframed as cruel and obscene.
Reality has left the building.
https://northwestbylines.co.uk/opinion-corner/giving-a-voice-to-the-voiceless-a-trans-woman-investigates/
The GRA went far beyond what was required in Goodwin. If the ECHR attempts to say that the UK must permit self ID, then I will vote for whatever political party promises to take us out of the Council of Europe. That is a significant shift in my position from even a few years ago, but I am here because of the deliberate and beligerent stupidity of 'trans rights' activists.
You seem to forget that I have had direct contact with McCloud and therefore have very direct and very troubling knowledge of his inability to grasp the very fundamental tension between women and trans identifying men's rights. I am therefore very confident I am right to reject McCloud has any kind of useful 'expert' in this field.
Curiously, not a single 'trans group' applied to intervene in the FWS Supreme Court case. One can guess why. Regardless, having the Scottish Government and Amnesty international making your case, sounds like you are sufficiently well covered.
Quotes a post by A3339; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
What arrant nonsense. Both the Scottish Government AND Amnesty International presented the 'trans rights' argument. The 'other side' was certainly heard. It did not prevail.
It is clear from the first two paragraphs this has nothing to offer: it is framed entirely as a ‘set back’ for ‘trans people, rather than protection of women’s rights. It relies on McCloud as an authoritative source: in his dealings with me he clearly had no conception of the impact on women’s rights of promoting gender identity.
Quotes a post by A3339; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
? I don’t understand this comment. All people are capable of committing crimes. Statistics re incarcerated prisoners show trans identifying men have very high rates of conviction for sex offences. Women are entitled to be worried.
No. I have a legitimate and reasonable dislike of an ideology that promotes gender identity as more important than sex, because this causes harm to women and children.
If trans identifying people accept the importance of sex and do not attempt to enter single sex spaces which do not apply to them, I have absolutely no quarrel with them and wish for them long and happy lives.
If they do not, then I am afraid I will continue to resist their attempts to change the law in a way that I genuinely and reasonably fear will harm women and children.
Quotes a post by T18431; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The hysterical and vindictive hyperbole of this movement will be its downfall. I was first ‘radicalised’ on line by trans identifying men threatening me for saying sex is real and it matters. It will be a pleasing irony if we can come full circle, and this same vicious overplaying of their hand, will lead to a very public dissection and denial of their ideology in a public court hearing.
I can only assume he will say they are not 'proper trans people' and then again we come back to the eternal question - what is the test? Which of the men allowed into female spaces are True and Honest Trans and which are opportunistic fetishists?
It did not mean Barry was male did it? It meant Barry was able to fool people. Are you seriously suggesting that ‘trans’ simply boils down to how successfully you can trick others? Bad news for your brother Bricks if so?
So tell me. I have asked many times. What is ‘living as a man’? What is ‘living as a woman’? You surely can’t mean ‘successfully fooling everyone’ as that will disqualify 95% of your trans brethren.
In order to recognise that trans women are male you simply have to understand that their bodies formed along the male reproductive system at conception, and they were then born and remained alive.
It is irrelevant what ‘experiences’ they then had. They are male and always will be.
Quotes a post by T25366; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
She went no further than saying some trans identified men are motivated by sexual fetish, which is obviously true as these men proclaim it from the rooftops and are even proud of it.
She is allowed to have and express this thought, it is protected political speech and if you disagree Mark you know what to do! Call the GLP transphobia hotline.
Btw the reddit link requires age verification as the content is not fit for children
Quotes a post by T29461; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I think that is putting it a trifle accurately. I haven't checked how much is in the 'general trans defence fund' but it will easily be enough to pay all the costs in my defamation action and instruct at least 10 'regulatory specialist silks'. I think it is oppressive and a very sad deviation from the initial aims of the GLP
NC makes the uncontroversial and factual statement that some trans identifying men are indeed motivated by a paraphilia. Our difficulty is that there is as yet no ‘test’ to discern who is the True and Honest trans identifying man, and who is the risk. It would be more honourable for Maugham to acknowledge this fact and just how frightening this is for many women.
I do hope Lynsay will be including this exchange as he promises below. Both Watson and Maugham are driven by the same zealotry.
A trans person is one who believes they are the opposite sex or that their gender identity is more important than their sex. I don’t believe what they believe. Just as I don’t believe in gods.
Trans people exist. But they don’t have the right to force others to believe they are a different sex to the one they were born OR that their gender identity is a thing anyone else should care about. This isn’t difficult.
Quotes a post by T05869; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
But that is the problem Brian. Their ‘social reality’ is not MY social reality. Vast majority of trans identifying men have no hormones or surgery. Why is it incumbent on me to agree they are women? What about MY dignity and MY rights? Where is the balance here?
But they can’t and never will. Their thought process stops dead at ‘opposing trans rights is bigotry’. They simply cannot see, much less understand, the arguments before that thought terminating cliche.
This needs proper consideration. I was initially very hardline on this. Then I was told to consider these toilets ‘accessible’ which widened the group to beyond just wheelchair users. Most disabled toilets I use at courts etc have a nappy changing table for eg.
We are continually told ‘trans’ people are a tiny minority, so hopefully disabled people will not be pushed out of these facilities. But it needs careful monitoring. Many disabled people will have no choice and they must not be sidelined.
Quoting @Independent: "Is it right that hard-won provisions for disabled people can be so blithely co-opted into a nebulous 'third space' for those who can’t/won’t use either the Gents or the Ladies?"
Read more: https://trib.al/Nn2CRO2
Then read more and get back to me. You cannot discuss these issues sensibly with UK women unless you are willing to take on board what trans identifying men think is acceptable behaviour.
C2 false claimsactivist harassmentdenialviolence terror
As @[private account] had to remind me, Maugham is happy to admit that what he said about me is defamatory and would risk harm to my reputation BUT he was entirely justified because it was true and in the public interest to point out that I was cruel, vindictive and obsessive and responsible for creating a toxic environment in the debate for trans rights
https://goodlawproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/2026.01.30-Letter-to-Branch-Austin-McCormick-PUBLIC.pdf
‘Whiny trans panic’.
My claim against Maugham is for £50k. If I win every penny is going to FWS. I was going to hold a little something back for my whale cruise but to call the most egregious attack on women’s rights of my lifetime a ‘whiny trans panic’ is so infuriating and irresponsible that the whales must wait.
FWS has worked to ensure that women remained protected as a sex class. You cannot protect what you cannot define. How does this columnist intend to deal with abuse against female politicians when she does not even know what a woman is?
To frame this as a problem for not ‘including’ trans people is very telling. It should be framed as how to exclude men from the category of women, to protect the dignity, safety and rights of women.
Quoting @heraldscotland: "For Women Scotland rhetorically claims to be 'working to protect and strengthen women and children's rights', but in practice, its campaigns and legal actions focus largely on opposing trans inclusion.
"I scoured their website and statements in mainstream media and found no evidence of any campaign, statement, press release, or public condemnation specifically addressing online abuse, misogynistic trolling, threats, or harassment of women politicians in Scotland.
"Talk about invisible women – their silence is telling."
𝘐𝘔𝘈𝘎𝘌: 𝘑𝘢𝘯𝘦 𝘉𝘢𝘳𝘭𝘰𝘸/𝘗𝘈 𝘈𝘳𝘤𝘩𝘪𝘷𝘦/𝘗𝘈 𝘐𝘮𝘢𝘨𝘦𝘴
I had also forgotten para 17!!
...that your client is obsessive, vindictive and cruel in relation to trans people and that she is, as a result, in part responsible for the polarity of the discourse on trans rights...
Yup. Have a think on that. Not a single wheelchair user was deemed worthy of inclusion until 2026 when happily a trans identified man was found.
And when gender identity goes the way of every other social contagion I will bet all the money I have now and ever will have again, there will be no wheelchairs at the Met Gala.
Quotes a post by T02027; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans people exist, religious people exist, mad people exist. Refusing to participate in their belief system is a choice we all have. It doesn’t ’annihilate’ them - what hysteria! - or their belief. It simply says we are not playing.
Quotes a post by T08311; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
And we know he is direct contact with much younger trans identifying men who are going to be impulsive. I hope I am wrong but he is continuing to escalate and it will only take one mentally ill man to be encouraged for real harm to occur.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedmental illnessviolence terror
Yup. It is perfectly possible to hold that position but allow a man to call himself 'trans' if he wishes. It isn't a magic word. It doesn't change his sex.
What bit do you take issue with? Given that is is clear that nearly 100% of children on puberty blockers go on to cross sex hormones, the impact for fertility and adult sexual function is obvious and serious. I agree that puberty blockers in and of themselves, if used for a short time and natural puberty them permitted, are unlikely to have such dire consequences. But that is not how they are used with 'trans children' is it?
Well quite. But if they are arguing that trans women routinely remove their penises or chemically castrate themselves, they do need to deal with the men who have zero interventions!
Puberty blockers are used for a short period of time for children who otherwise would start puberty at a very young age. They are then stopped and the child goes through puberty. They are not immediately followed by cross sex hormones which do pose immediate risks to fertility.
Those who keep banging on about PB being perfectly fine simply ignore the inevitable progression to cross sex hormones for ‘trans children’ and in a just world, all adults promoting this would be in prison.
Quotes a post by T00948; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
They are annoying but as we have shown time and time again we simply go around them. I think they are beyond reach. They have sacrificed whatever integrity or independence of thought they might once have had to curry favour with their trans identifying children or trans ally children. Again, this fetishisation of the naivety and cruelty of youth, as if frantically appeasing it somehow stops the clocks for you.
At 32 Grace Campbell should not be presenting as 15 but I suspect it’s inevitable - every unmoored and unboundaried notion can only escalate.
Quotes a post by T20785; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is an interesting view. I get the fetishisation of youth, it goes hand in hand with the fear of death. What I understand less is that some afford the fancies of youth some concrete and important status given that they are of necessity fleeting and constantly changing. I don’t care if trans identifying men are doing well in music/fashion. Good for them! I was never interested in fashion. I like the music I like, not what I am told is culturally acceptable.
What I care about is that I am not made to agree they are women.
What’s real and important doesn’t change: the rule of law and its protection of freedom to think and speak.
Ella will join the ranks of the old and ugly soon enough, the youthful pop cultures she naively elevates as some Eternal Truth will shift and deride or ignore her. As is traditional for the young. They don’t know any better. This is something to be treated with compassion, not worshipped. I hope she’s ready.
Quotes a post by T20809; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
As they represent only 0.0187% of the population, this is not a meaningful argument. 99.9% of people are instantly observable as the sex they are. What makes a man a 'trans woman'? Other than his 'gender identity'? Is there anything else?
No, they explain HOW it was done, not WHY it was done. The 'how' is easy enough to explain - piggy back the controversial 'trans' stuff under the cloak of gay rights etc etc.
Again. I ask HOW. How did these ineffably stupid people get anywhere close to anything like the political, legal and social dominance they had for a decade?
On a rough estimate 95% of all trans identifying men who engage with me online will claim they had sex with my parents within at most five replies.
Given that my parents cremains have been in a jar on top of the dresser for the last 12 years, this is an impressive feat. As I highly doubt any of these men have known the touch of another human, it’s not surprising this is where they always ‘go’.
Quotes a post by T13275; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I was reading a Reddit thread about the film ‘I am thinking of Ending things’ because I didn’t have a clue what was going on and there was a fascinating exchange between some men who thought the Jesse Plemons character was being lusted after by two teenage girls when it was painfully apparent they were mocking him and indeed that was the whole point of the scene.
Is it really this simple? That trans identifying men are simply taking eroto mania to further depths?
Quotes a post by T22140; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
No. I mean trans identifying men. I know how ‘transphobes’ managed - primarily by saying ‘no’ to these men. What I want to know is how they gained any influence at all.
No, no, no, they are a fun real life extension to those well known dating apps where bored and lonely married men search for alluring trans identified men into whose DMs they can later slide.
I think you only have to look at how trans identifying men behave as opposed to trans identifying women, to see that your experience is the unusual one. But I am sure we can agree to disagree.
It’s quite incredible how so many trans identified men genuinely appear to believe they are routinely lusted over. I once knew a man like this. He seemed to believe that every woman who walked by him on the street was looking at him lustfully. He included schoolchildren. This appears to be a wholly male delusion.
Quotes a post by A2915; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I have seen some elements of the 'manosphere' state in all seriousness that a woman is 'past it' over 18 years.
Trans identifying men are some of the proudest flag wavers for the manosphere. At their core, they hate women and position themselves as innately superior - 'doing' womanhood much better than the Crones.
Quotes a post by T19428; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
So many words! To note the obvious failing - that the feelings of trans identifying men were raised above all other considerations and this was unlawful
Quotes a post by A0064; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The legalisation of same sex marriage has made this argument utterly redundant. A woman does not have to pretend to be a man to marry a woman and claim all the legal protections that flow from this.
A woman has NEVER been allowed to pretend to be a man and call herself 'father'. This is explicitly rejected by the GRA and confirmed in the McConnell case.
Again, the only 'rights' trans people are asserting they are denied, is the right to force people - including their own children - to accept something which is not true. You cannot change sex. A child has a right to know who his mother and father are.
Quotes a post by T29499; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
So Maugham would approve of my windows being smashed with a hammer so long as it was in the name of ‘trans rights’. This increases my fear and anger that he has so clearly made me a target of these men’s rage.
Quotes a post by T13251; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans activist group issues guide to ‘rarely legal’ direct action.
This is the group who follows and is followed by Jolyon Maugham on social media. https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/trans-activist-rarely-legal-attacks-j2hps6zp6
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
This is nothing whatsoever to do with ‘trans rights’. It’s about the age old constant of male violence, now supersized by its teaming with sexual paraphilia and narcissistic entitlement. While terrifying, it is at least now so screamingly public that even once captured institutions have to take note.
Again it depends on context. If I work with a man who is trans identified and I make a point of remarking that 'he is a man' every single day, even if I do it in a sweet voice, I don't think that is acceptable behaviour in the work place. Of course, I could legitimately object to him using single sex female spaces.
I think the ONLY success they had was the post Bell case about whether or not parents could give consent to medical transition when children were not Gillick competent. Court said they could. A v A case. Apart from that, every single thing they have done in the 'trans arena' has harmed their purported cause and made them a laughing stock - to every one apart from their army of vulnerable and gullible donors of course.
Of course, if medical transition was ‘life saving’ and those subject to it full of ‘trans joy’, you would expect them to be keen to share their experiences. But men such as Maugham have urged them to stay away: because he must know what life will be like for the majority of vulnerable children sold a dangerous lie.
Maybe they meant to say watch out 10 minutes or so after it ends, as then the streets of Brighton will be full of psychopathic middle aged women baying for trans blood?