The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
I'm not anti-trans. I believe in full civil-rights for trans people. I just believe biological sex is real and gender-dysphoric children should be treated with extreme care, not with ideological recklessness.
Every right I support for gay people I support for trans people. How to treat kids with gender dysphoria is a completely legitimate question, and takes no rights from anyone.
How nuts is the World Professional Association for Transgender Health? The "experts". I thought "eunuch-identified" people was bonkers enough. Now this:
Quotes a post by A0311; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Same with me and "LGBTQIA+". I'm not lesbian, bi, trans, intersex or asexual, let alone queer. "LGBTQIA+" is a way to impose a leftist political identity on every gay man. And the media repeats it.
Translation: "ads targeting *sex changes for* children." The headline about "targeting trans kids"is literally copied from activist groups' p.r. materials.
https://politi.co/3DpDFVn via @[private account]
I didn't say otherwise. It's a disgrace. Then there's this, which has the force of law, and is downright evil:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2022/09/23/texas-transgender-child-abuse-investigations/
@[private account] @[private account] My position is: complete medical freedom (and support) for trans adults; extreme caution with gender dysphoric children and teens. A simple line to draw. We draw it in countless cases.
@[private account] Minors. She repeats this is about children. That's a tiny fraction of "all trans health care". And controversial among medical experts.
Vox claims Lupron has been used to stop natural puberty in trans kids since the mid-20th Century. Untrue. It *has* been used historically ... to chemically castrate gay men, including Alan Turing.
https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/23281683/trans-kids-transition-medicine-surgery
"The medicine we use to treat trans children ... has, in actuality, been used to help trans youths transition ... since the mid-20th century."
This is untrue. Off-label puberty blockers were first used in the 1990s. Why lie?
https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/23281683/trans-kids-transition-medicine-surgery
I support the right of every single trans person to live his or her life freely without the threat of discrimination. Every single civil right. Stop lying about my views. Children are different. They need protection from fanatics.
Name a right I support for gay people that I do not support for trans people. The medicalization and permanent alteration of children is not a "right" under any definition.
Language note: the erasure of any distinction between gay people and trans people is now mandatory. You are either LGBTQIA+ or "Queer" (the capital Q is coming soon). The words "gay" and "lesbian" are being erased for ever. They tell too much truth.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2022/09/24/youngkin-trans-policies-harm/
That's how I feel, to be honest. I took my eye off the ball and assumed this was all about helping trans kids. I had no idea how extreme this medical experimentation on children had become.
@[private account] This is a lie. I haven't disparaged a single trans person. I've disparaged an ideology that uses trans people for its own revolutionary cause: the abolition of biological sex itself.
@[private account] From the piece: "some people really do deeply feel that they are one sex and yet biologically are the opposite one. It’s rare, but very real, and I have long supported care and protection for this tiny minority of marginalized people we now call transgender." Stop lying.
By a margin of 46 - 31 percent, Americans support making it "illegal to help someone under 18 with medical care for gender transition." By 64 - 10, Americans support protecting trans people from discrimination.
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/09/15/how-americans-view-policy-proposals-on-transgender-and-gender-identity-issues-and-where-such-policies-exist/
This is an important point. These cases do a massive disservice to actual trans people who simply want to live as the opposite sex and get on with their lives.
Quotes a post by T54763; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I just wish he didn't use the slur "queer" to mean gay and trans people. It's entirely an ideological project to rob gay people of our membership in mainstream society. It's regressive leftism to keep the gays in their place.
WPATH Explains Why They Removed Minimum Age Guidelines For Children to Access Transgender Medical Treatments: So Doctors Won’t Get Sued https://www.dailywire.com/news/wpath-explains-why-they-removed-minimum-age-guidelines-for-children-to-access-transgender-medical-treatments-so-doctors-wont-get-sued
What if the kid is gay and not trans? And it takes real therapy to figure that out. The rush to turn gender-non-conforming children into the opposite sex as soon as possible is wicked and homophobic.
The use by trans activists of the term "conversion therapy" to describe full mental health treatment of children is wicked. It's an attempt to turn as many gay kids into trans kids as possible. It's fueled by potent homophobia.
Quoting @jessesingal: It's REALLY bad to call things "conversion therapy" that aren't. "Watchful waiting" is not conversion therapy. The only semi-decent data we have on youth gender medicine comes from a watchful waiting clinic. Siiiiigh the misinformation on this subject...
We should not even "entertain the idea" of debating the question of sex changes for children. We should accept whatever trans activists demand and stay silent.
Quotes a post by T02452; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When he exposes the scale of the critical theory capture of liberalism, I'll applaud him. When he resorts to homophobia, trans-baiting and "groomer" bullshit, I'll call him out.
Grateful for any coverage at all at this point. But this, of course, is loaded toward critical gender theory, and minimizes the dangers of puberty blockers.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/28/health/transgender-youth-uk-tavistock.html?smid=tw-share
"The bullying, unfairness, and sheer illogic of the trans movement have all drawn strength from same-sex marriage." What a self-evidently absurd statement. What a completely reactionary editorial.
https://www.nationalreview.com/2022/07/republicans-should-reject-the-gay-marriage-bill/
That's about it. HRC is now an offshoot of BLM and paralyzed by internal race/sex/gender conflicts. The far left use trans people to break down the sex binary.
Believing in biological sex is "a common mistake for students in the first semester of a 101 class." Really? And Christianity is a function of a "bigot deity." Thank you for clarifying.
https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/07/the-just-asking-questions-anti-trans-campaign-is-working.html?utm_source=tw via @[private account]
Normie trans people, like normie gay people, are not represented by these upper-class, super woke activist groups. But the MSM conflates the two entirely. Laziness and wokeness.
The 4.7K comments on this piece of critical queer theory propaganda are priceless. WokePo completely out of touch with reality and its readers.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/arts-entertainment/2022/07/06/bette-midler-macy-gray-transgender-advocates/
The WokePo gives us some unfiltered propaganda. No attempt to present the other side fairly. But check out the comments. Almost all are absolutely sick of this bias.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/arts-entertainment/2022/07/06/bette-midler-macy-gray-transgender-advocates/?tid=ss_tw
"A quarter of the girls in my daughter’s class identify as transgender. Seven out of 28." I'd love to know the percentage of boys. Bet it's nowhere near. But this is the fruit of "queer" indoctrination.
https://pitt.substack.com/p/headline-when-a-quarter-of-the-class?r=7bjvz&s=r&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
Abortion inclusion = "women and trans men."
Woke ideology = "menstruators", "people with uteruses."
Not hard to see what's going on. They're not about "inclusion"; they're about erasing both women and men as categories of human beings.
A big advance agains the trans extremists' attempt to get people fired for believing in biological sex.
Quoting @MForstater: Here is my press statement:
https://mforstater.medium.com/press-statement-maya-forstaters-victory-in-employment-tribunal-a-win-for-free-speech-and-99365009baa1
Abortion affects "women and a comparatively tiny number of trans men". Why not that? No need to banish the word woman or to redefine it into having a penis for the sake of inclusion. Proof they don't want inclusion. They want to abolish the sex binary.
Quotes a post by T01952; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] Did Twitter suspend her account because she wrote a powerful piece in defense of women as a category of human beings that should not be deconstructed by the trans extremists?
Seriously? They suspended someone for writing a column in the NYT? Say it ain't so.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] Yes. Do either of them actually believe there is no difference at all between a trans woman and a woman? Of course they don't. Why not say so? Why not say we need to be much more careful about sex changes for children?
Pretty sensible. Describing extensive mental health therapy for kids with gender dysphoria as trans "conversion therapy" is a grotesque and deliberate distortion.
Quoting @SkyNews: "There are complexities and sensitivities when you move from the area of sexuality to the question of gender", says PM Boris Johnson, adding "I don't think it's reasonable" for children to "take decisions on their gender" without a parent's involvement.
https://trib.al/SrQ3ELK
HRC’s guide to teaching the under-8s. Biological sex is unmentioned. “Boy” and “girl” are terms exclusively reserved for gender, not sex, and you can be both or neither. Yes, this is indoctrination. https://welcomingschools.org/resources/lesson-plans-gender-identity-transgender-non-binary
The fringe idea, Ron, is rushing gender dysphoric kids into medication and mutilation. That’s what “gender-affirming” means. It means automatically assuming gender dysphoria means a kid is trans. You’re in a left bubble.
Walking the Transgender Movement Away from the Extremists https://www.americanpurpose.com/articles/walking-the-transgender-movement-away-from-the-extremists/
An admission that this is absolutely about indoctrination against the sex binary. Trans kids are being used by these fanatics. Gay kids are collateral damage.
Quotes a post by T50064; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is not even a gesture toward fairly presenting both sides of this question in this piece. It is proudly crude propaganda. You don’t even get a pro forma sentence explaining the argument of the other side - if only to dismiss it. https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2022/03/21/alabama-trans-healthcare-bill-activists/
@[private account] @[private account] Found little terrible in the formal curricula but if you read what’s outside that is very relevant. The trans mantra is ubiquitous.
Full civil rights have been granted to trans people in the Bostock decision. There is nothing I support for gays that I don’t for trans people. Nothing. Read “Virtually Normal.”
The vagueness of these awful bills is the point: terrifying teachers from talking about homosexuality and transgender identity. Kill or amend them. https://andrewsullivan.substack.com/p/the-backlash-against-trans-extremism-f09
This is the moment many of us feared. T extremism taking Gs and Ls down with it. https://andrewsullivan.substack.com/p/the-backlash-against-trans-extremism-f09
An awesome trans woman breaking barriers and increasing visibility by virtue of her brilliance and humanity. Such a break from some activist anger and toxicity. Love her.
Quoting @Jeopardamy: Some of you may have heard, but I quit my day job yesterday! It's a bit nerve-wracking to pivot from software engineer to... public figure, I guess? But regardless of the outcome I'm so excited to spend the next couple years at least tackling this new challenge!
New one drops. Many gays are now trans, apparently.
Quoting @SwipeWright: 🚨The Canadian organization @[private account], which serves as a primary resource on “2SLGBTQI” issues for many Canadian schools and organizations, defines being “trans” as someone who simply rejects what is “socially expected” of them due to their sex. Insane.
https://egale.ca/wp-content/uploads/articulate_uploads/introduction-to-2-slgbtqi-inclusion-building-inclusive-schools-raw-SoB2Ddgl-january142022/assets/DvfeiowPiUtEL-Dz_DXLvc69UZwpvnxL7-Glossary%20of%20Terms_2021.pdf
@[private account] Yeah I’d be shitting myself too. Bisexuals uphold the binary! Evil. But trans ideology disputes the existence of G as well. We’re just “genital fetishists”. L? It’s almost an obscenity now among the alphabet peeps. 🤪
If you're concerned about how kids with gender dysphoria are being treated, here's a recent documentary from Sweden on one of the top hospitals in the field.
https://www.svtplay.se/video/33358590/uppdrag-granskning/mission-investigate-trans-children-avsnitt-1
Yes, we can. But this person is a leader in the field at a major hospital. On mandatory mental health counseling for trans kids: "I don’t send someone to a therapist when I’m going to start them on insulin."
I think everyone expresses their maleness or femaleness in unique ways. Without even really thinking about it. But these formulae - "trans masculine genderqueer" - are silly.
Thought this might be a second news story in the NYT that aired the actual debate about trans women in female sports. Nah. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/24/sports/lia-thomas-transgender-swimmer.html
Have you asked anyone what it actually means, what it could mean, how it demeans the real struggles of trans people, how it leeches off the experience of being gay … when these people are straight and cis!
"What the trans movement is now doing, after Bostock, is not about rights. It is about a cultural revolution to dismantle the sex binary, to politicize biology, to deconstruct the family and to replace same-sex with same-gender orientation."
https://andrewsullivan.substack.com/p/the-trans-movement-is-not-about-rights-67e
Fascinating to read the comments under the first NYT piece that actually airs the debate about minors' transitioning. Almost all of them urge caution. Public policy and public sentiment on this are vastly misaligned.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/13/health/transgender-teens-hormones.html#commentsContainer
I think this is the first time that the NYT has conceded that there is a legitimate debate on the question. Amazing concession to reality given the toxicity of the subject. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/13/health/transgender-teens-hormones.html
With the Bostock decision trans Americans are fully protected federally against employment discrimination. Amazing the trans movement has done all it can to obscure this triumph.