The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Yes you’re right, we use trans as a shortcut but go deeper into it in the essays. Transgender ideation is the phrase I tend to use in long form.
It’s not uncommon for different conditions to hit different cohorts. For example ocd can overtake a 6 year old boy and a 60 year old woman.
A 16-year-old girl who binge drinks and blacks out every time she meets her pals because everyone in her friendship group is doing so, versus a middle-aged man who has spent decades drinking alone to manage longstanding psychological needs are both common enough scenarios.
Both may present with the same observable behaviour - problematic alcohol consumption - but the psychological pathways are very different.
The teenager’s drinking might be driven primarily by peer influence, social belonging, imitation and the developmental vulnerabilities of adolescence. The middle-aged man's drinking might be rooted in longstanding patterns of emotional regulation, psychological dependency or other personal difficulties.
The fact that both drink does not mean that they have the same underlying psychological problem, nor that they require the same therapeutic approach.
This feels like a breakthrough and I’m so thankful for @SwipeWright for hosting it and for @[private account] for suggesting it.
You can read Holly’s essay here and mine will be out next week
Don’t forget to vote!!
https://open.substack.com/pub/colinwright/p/the-repath-debate-should-transgender?r=7v0g9&utm_medium=ios
I can’t describe how THRILLED I am to FINALLY be having an honest thoughtful debate about a significant aspect of the trans issue.
When I first got into this, I thought there would be many such debates. Instead I’ve spent 9 years stuck at “you can’t experiment on children”
Quotes a post by T01773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
🚨I Was in Women’s Prison. Then They Let Men In.
New episode of Beyond Gender premieres 7pm UK/11am California/2pm New York
@[private account] is joined by @IWF ambassador @[private account] to discuss her experience in prison, California’s SB 132 (the Transgender Respect, Agency, and Dignity Act), the senator behind it, Scott Wiener, and the transfer of a man into her prison. They also cover testosterone in women’s prisons, medical experimentation in prisons, vulnerable groups and children, and California Senate Bills SB 107, SB 145 and SB 239.
https://m.youtube.com/@beyondgenderpodcast/
I loved this interview with @[private account] from @[private account]. We spoke about various complexities of the trans debate and the vital difference between totalitarianism and authoritarianism
https://youtu.be/_s3uMviK9Lw?is=1mRdm5oipcF1eJV6
“Transgender propaganda has been more successful than the communist propaganda in the Soviet Union.”
Our latest episode of Beyond Gender with @[private account] and Harrison Koehli is out now.
Jonni’s gender therapist sent him to a sex shop when he was only 13 years old.
Nobody needs to struggle alone with confusion around gender. Visit our Beyond Trans website if you, or a family member, would appreciate free, online support
🔗https://beyondtrans.org/welcome/
I wrote this article so as to have a document that tracks the ideological takeover of the Irish media. Trans activists managed to silence the most powerful voice in Irish media when they silenced @[private account].
I guess famous people look at @jk_rowling and @Glinner and they can’t face the onslaught.
Quoting @stellaomalley3: I often wonder what’s going on in the offices of @IrishTimes and @[private account] when scandals such as the latest “chest-feeding males” breaks. I’ve no doubt they want to slide back into credibility and pretend “we all partied” during Woke 1.0.
But we didn’t.
People had their lives ruined. People like me had their reputations ruined.
I tracked the exact actions of the Irish Times and RTE that led us from a basically civilised society in 2017 to “chest-feeding males” in 2026
@[private account]
I’m so angry to read this about Joe Duffy.
It’s a reflection of how powerful trans activists are that @[private account]- the most well known and popular voice of the underdog in Ireland- considered a careful discussion about the importance of the word woman and mother “ the most wounding period of his career with the broadcaster.”
I had already been cancelled by then and so I recently carefully tracked and documented the slide of the Irish media into shameless servility towards trans activists.
See images 👇
https://www.independent.ie/videos/joe-duffy-on-the-fallout-from-2022s-programmes-on-the-transgender-issue-accusations-from-tds-and-the-reaction-from-his-rte-bosses/a/163508826.html
Transgender ideation describes the preoccupation with being or becoming the other sex. An overvalued belief helps explain how that ideation may become entrenched and resistant to reconsideration. The question of clinical threshold is crucial - the point when the issue becomes sufficiently distressing or impairing to warrant clinical attention
We need to give clinicians, researchers, parents and the wider public the language to distinguish between experiences, beliefs and disorders. Without clinical clarity, everyone is left talking past each other.
These are all important points, but for me there’s an even more fundamental issue. The lack of clinical clarity from the mental health profession created a vacuum that led to chaos among lawyers, doctors, journalists, academics and others.
Imagine if anorexia emerged as a clinical phenomenon today and was understood primarily through an identity-based framework. Psychologists and psychiatrists need to offer a coherent clinical formulation for this issue so that other professionals can get on with their jobs.
The mental health profession’s responsibility isn’t simply to endorse or oppose medical interventions. It’s to understand and formulate the presenting psychological phenomenon. What are we treating? Why has it developed? What maintains it? What alleviates the distress?
I wrote about this a couple of months ago, and this diagram illustrates the problem. We’ve spent years arguing about the evidence for treatment without adequately examining what it is we’re treating.
The better starting point is transgender ideation itself. When did it emerge, and what preceded it? What problem does the person believe transition will solve? How strongly is that belief held? What intensifies or weakens the ideation? What psychological and social factors sustain it?
That is why clinical clarity matters so much. Without it, we end up debating treatments , as Hillary Cass does, without adequately understanding the phenomenon we’re supposed to be treating.
https://stellaomalley.substack.com/p/evidence-for-what
🚨 Trans Away the Gay: Gender-Affirming Care is CONVERSION THERAPY
Episode premieres 7pm UK/11am PST/2pm EST
Scott Newgent joins @_CryMiaRiver to discuss how experiences of homophobia and encounters with medical professionals led her to undergo sex-altering procedures that resulted in severe health complications. Now an outspoken critic of gender-affirming care, particularly for minors, Scott also discusses her upcoming appearance before the UK Parliament to challenge the proposed conversion therapy ban.
Great presentation by @[private account] speaking at the Genspect New Zealand conference about how detransition is “forbidden knowledge” among the trans community
To clarify, the “trans regretters” are people who have medicalised but now regret it. They don’t intend to detransition.
Another section is “medicalised but don’t regret it”, another is “trans identified” (haven’t yet medicalised) another section is “detransitioners”, there are Desisters too
There is however plenty of movement between sections - some regretters decide to detransition; some medicalised also decide to detransition
Quoting @stellaomalley3: Some numbers from a selected group of participants in our @[private account] programme. We welcome trans medicalised, trans identified, trans regretters, detransitioners and everyone in between
Some numbers from a selected group of participants in our @[private account] programme. We welcome trans medicalised, trans identified, trans regretters, detransitioners and everyone in between
The Beyond Trans support meetings are indescribable but very special. Some participants come every week, some go through phases of attending, some have just recently detransitioned, others are just finding medical transition hard. It’s a really welcoming and non judgemental space
Quoting @genspect: We welcome trans-identified, trans-medicalised, trans regretters, detransitioners, those harmed by transition and everyone in between at our @[private account]
free support meetings.
We don’t require anyone to stop hormones, or to believe in any theory; we just offer support
Why should we “treat” a trans-identified person by removing their healthy body parts when we wouldn’t “treat” an anorexic person by giving them liposuction?
From episode 3 of our REPATH series.
In the latest episode of our REPATH video series, @_CryMiaRiver explains how WPATH struggled with the contradiction at the heart of gender medicine: activists wanted trans identity depathologized, while medical treatment still required a diagnosis and a billing code.
“That’s where I believe Pandora’s box was opened.”
@_CryMiaRiver and I give a history lesson on the decades in which trans activism captured the field of gender medicine in the latest episode of our REPATH series.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=JoJNVqH267E&ra=m
This criticism of REPATH rests on a misunderstanding of both psychiatric classification and evidence-based psychotherapy. Psychiatry does not require a settled account of etiology before it can identify psychopathology or treat it. We do not possess a definitive causal theory of anorexia nervosa, anxiety disorders, depression, OCD or most other psychiatric conditions. Nevertheless, we can identify patterns of cognition, emotion and behaviour that become sufficiently persistent, distressing or impairing to warrant clinical attention, and we can test treatments empirically.
REPATH is, quite clearly, not arguing that transgender identity or gender nonconformity constitutes a mental disorder. Repath argues that transgender ideation can, in some people, cross a clinical threshold into psychopathology, becoming persistent, dominant and functionally impairing, potentially organised around an overvalued belief and capable of driving a person towards irreversible alteration of a healthy body.
That is an empirical and clinical proposition, not merely an ideological counterclaim to the assertion that transgender identity is a natural variation of human experience. The appropriate scientific response is neither automatic pathologisation nor automatic depathologisation. It is to investigate where the threshold between variation and psychopathology lies, just as psychiatry attempts to do elsewhere.
Nor must clinicians wait until the ultimate causes and complete natural history of a condition have been established before providing evidence-based psychotherapy. If that standard were applied consistently, much of psychiatry and clinical psychology would cease to function. Evidence-based treatment depends upon evidence concerning assessment, formulation, intervention and outcomes; it does not depend upon possessing a complete theory of causation.
That is precisely why REPATH is calling for the psychological dimension to be reopened rather than foreclosed.
This criticism of REPATH rests on a misunderstanding of both psychiatric classification and evidence-based psychotherapy. Psychiatry does not require a settled account of etiology before it can identify psychopathology or treat it. We do not possess a definitive causal theory of anorexia nervosa, anxiety disorders, depression, OCD or most other psychiatric conditions. Nevertheless, we can identify patterns of cognition, emotion and behaviour that become sufficiently persistent, distressing or impairing to warrant clinical attention, and we can test treatments empirically.
REPATH is, quite clearly, not arguing that transgender identity or gender nonconformity constitutes a mental disorder. Repath argues that transgender ideation can, in some people, cross a clinical threshold into psychopathology, becoming persistent, dominant and functionally impairing, potentially organised around an overvalued belief and capable of driving a person towards irreversible alteration of a healthy body.
That is an empirical and clinical proposition, not merely an ideological counterclaim to the assertion that transgender identity is a natural variation of human experience. The appropriate scientific response is neither automatic pathologisation nor automatic depathologisation. It is to investigate where the threshold between variation and psychopathology lies, just as psychiatry attempts to do elsewhere.
Nor must clinicians wait until the ultimate causes and complete natural history of a condition have been established before providing evidence-based psychotherapy. If that standard were applied consistently, much of psychiatry and clinical psychology would cease to function. Evidence-based treatment depends upon evidence concerning assessment, formulation, intervention and outcomes; it does not depend upon possessing a complete theory of causation.
That is precisely why REPATH is calling for the psychological dimension to be reopened rather than foreclosed.
Quotes a post by A1525; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You can see how in Iceland a “trans Jesus” was put on the side of buses in @[private account]’s powerful presentation at the Genspect conference in Lisbon
https://youtu.be/pGKBmtZUIJk?is=lKIdPPqE8VlM9Iud
‘The Stasi officers who enforced the rules cannot be the people who write the memoir about how terribly oppressive the regime was.’
In my latest for the @[private account] I analyse the @IrishTimes’ reporting on trans issues during the period of 2017-2026
High trust societies such as New Zealand allowed trans activists to insert policies and regulations when no one was looking. The impact has been dreadful on society and families.
I’m really looking forward to speaking at this event in 🇳🇿
There will be a live stream too!
Quoting @genspect: 🇳🇿 Reminder: Our Genspect New Zealand conference is on Saturday, October 17th.
You can view the conference programme below and purchase tickets here: https://www.tickettailor.com/events/genspect/2324381
Everyone eventually has a breakthrough moment with trans, where they actually see the wood from the trees.
Ireland seems to be having its moment this weekend
Quotes a post by T21300; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’m pro free speech, however John Stuart Mill’s harm principle is apt here. The Ardilaun hotel was hosting an event to explain to child abusers how to carry out child abuse on infants.
The hotel didn’t know what they were facilitating because of misinformation about trans issues
Quoting @stellaomalley3: I rang the Ardilaun Hotel and the male chest feeding event has been cancelled. The Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland have discredited themselves over this.
As Catherine Monaghan explains in this article, male lactation is child abuse
https://genspect.org/where-does-male-lactation-fit-in-breastfeeding-support-networks/
Nine 16- and 17-year-olds were granted Gender Recognition Certificates in 2025, three times as many as in either of the previous two years and the highest number since the legislation was introduced. The numbers are still small, but legally changing sex is a significant decision for a minor. Obvs trans is in the news much more and so the social contagion is spreading to young people. Most trans identified young people are much more obsessed with changing their bodies through hormones (because they hate their bodies) than with changing their legal documents so these numbers are not a reflection of what’s actually going on
Having spent too many years highlighting misinformation related to trans issues, I believe the only way forward is to make truth our North Star.
It’s much better for society if we can understand and enjoy our differences rather than suppressing information and smearing anyone who speaks the truth
Quoting @triggerpod: "The world makes no sense if you think everyone is born exactly the same."
@KonstantinKisin asks @[private account] what motivates him to tackle controversial topics despite pushback from all sides.
His answer: ignoring natural group differences forces society to blame "mystical injustice" for inequality, meaning there will be no peace until we accept biological reality.
New episode of Beyond Gender with @RoisinMichaux is out now:
https://youtu.be/iI1-qH31FVU?is=P8whR4TpFcv7oB93
Róisín explains how parents across Europe are engaging in trans tourism to obtain unevidenced medical interventions for their vulnerable kids
Thank you @[private account] !!
“In my mind, Genspect founder and psychotherapist Stella O’Malley got it exactly right, observing earlier this month in @spikedonline magazine that the reason the trans issue is spoken of so much is that it is the “clearest lens through which we can study the disintegration of almost every major institution across the Western world.”
Quotes a post by A0398; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Irish Times refused many, many editorials about trans issues during Woke 1. They didn’t take the view then “we don’t agree but we’ll publish.” If they had, then I wouldn’t be so angry.
The Irish Times chose to operate a policy of blanket censorship. They didn’t do their job. They allowed a student union to shape their output and they haven’t the integrity to admit it
Petra de Sutter the transgender individual who used ai hallucinations for his inaugural speech
Academia is eating itself
https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/en/2026/01/08/ghent-university-rector-petra-de-sutter-uses-fabricated-quotes-i/
Quotes a post by A2055; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Transgender ideation:
a psychological symptom that is characterised by a persistent or recurrent cognitive preoccupation with being, becoming, or identifying as another sex or gender identity
https://genspect.org/understanding-transgender-ideation/
Yes I wrote about it in @[private account] and @[private account]’s book
https://amzn.eu/d/02bg07OJ
Every change was crap and I shouldn’t have done any of them. But I was told the film wouldn’t go out if I didn’t. We had worked on it for an entire year, and we had the first detransitioner on mainstream tv; the first trans widow on mainstream tv ; the first TRAs acting in an objectionable way on mainstream Tv - it felt very important for the film to go out.
It was literally the day before. I hadn’t a clue what to do
For asking that question my good name was trashed by trans activists.
Kjk also started her smear campaign the very day the film was released in 2018.
I didn’t understand why then, but it’s obvious now; she would crawl over her dead granny for attention
4/5
For anyone who needs to know the 𝗲𝗻𝘁𝗶𝗿𝗲 𝗽𝗿𝗲𝗺𝗶𝘀𝗲 of the 2018 film ‘Trans Kids: it’s time to talk’ was to have someone entirely outside the trans debate present the problems.
I did this 🧵 because it was 8 years ago so it’s understandable that people don’t know
1/5
This is such a stupid comment. I did the film Trans Kids: it’s time to talk in 2018. That’s 8 years ago. Just like everyone else (including Dopey Dora here) I knew a fraction then what I know now.
All I can think is the old Dublin phrase - scarlet for your ma for having ye
“Don’t you get tired of talking about trans?”
This latest piece I wrote for @spikedonline is very dear to me- the trans issue might involve a small number of people but the fallout is an indictment of the entire western world
https://www.spiked-online.com/2026/08/06/why-ill-never-get-tired-of-talking-about-trans/
Parents following the trans debate should also want to look at what’s happened with autism diagnoses. The patterns behind both are surprisingly similar. I explore the autism issue in my latest UnHerd article
https://unherd.com/newsroom/the-autism-spectrum-has-become-too-broad/
Ten years ago I had NO IDEA that journalism routinely endured an omertà around certain issues.
We need to talk about Lucy Letby, we need to talk about child rape gangs and we need to talk about trans issues.
And if you’re a journo and you won’t? Then please get a different job
Quotes a post by A1558; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I was interviewed by The @australian about the individuals caught up in transgender ideation. I’m truly honoured to be delivering a keynote address at this vitally important conference in Australia this October.
“These were the most vulnerable kids,” Dr O’Malley said.
“They were the ones who had been diagnosed from five and six and seven with autism and OCD and anxiety. They’d had eating disorders. Gender dysphoria was one of a list of diagnoses, and suddenly these kids were medicalising before their parents’ eyes, and they were like, ‘Oh my God, my kid knows nothing. They have never been kissed. They’ve never had a boyfriend. They’ve never had a girlfriend. They’ve never had friends. They are really vulnerable. What on earth is happening that doctors are saying it’s appropriate for them to be medicalised?’”
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/leading-therapist-claims-a-different-level-of-fear-gags-australias-gender-debate/news-story/5a6549f027f60b219128cb2dbde117a7
Such an excellent paper by @[private account] and Peter Jenkins scrutinising proposed conversion therapy bans:
“This critique notes the risks of reifying human rights law as a unitary narrative supporting such a ban, requiring strict compliance by the UK; challenges the origins of transgender status as derived from grievance studies, rather than from analytic principles; contests the use of homosexuality as an appropriate ‘skeleton key’ for constructing psychoanalytic responses to gender identity; and opposes the affirmative drive to reverse epistemic injustice towards trans clients, as conflicting with psychoanalysis’ historic imperative to distinguish between fantasy and truth.”
Wow! Brilliant work
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14753634.2026.2703696
In this weeks podcast Dr. Michael Gurian discusses brain- and genome-based sex differences, his concepts of “sexgender” and the “bridge brain,” why boys are often disadvantaged in classrooms and therapy, and how these ideas inform his perspective on the trans debate.
https://youtu.be/7meAenKrMvk?is=ITBDcq7UJzi0kxLm
Myself and Dr Michael Gurian disagree on the Beyond Gender podcast- and “that’s fine!”
Dr Gurian believes that brain scans will reveals a “tiny number” of trans people while I beg to differ.
Answers on a postcard please 🤪
Is transgender ideation a mental health issue, or is transgender identity an identity that should be medicalised?
Many people believe a tiny number of people have a deeply rooted transgender identity. Dr Michael Gurian and I disagree on that question—but we’re nice about it
No I never believed in true trans. I always thought it was a psychological phenomenon. I certainly didn’t say I believed in “true trans” in the film or any other time in my entire life. However I was accused by many pseudo feminists and it became a myth about me. Basically horrible keyboard warriors being horrible and puritanical spread lies about me
I set out my stall in the forest article I wrote about this issue in 2017: http://www.stellaomalley.com/boysandgirls
Then I did my film in 2018 https://vimeo.com/304866757
Then I wrote this in 2022 https://genspect.org/a-therapists-understanding-of-gender-dysphoria/
When did you first engage in this issue ?
It turns out that loads and loads of people think there is such a thing as a trans child. I don’t. I call it “tiny numbers theory”. Hillary Cass believes it. So does Dr Michael Gurian, I just interviewed him
https://stellaomalley.substack.com/p/boys-brains-schools-and-the-trans?
My latest for @spikedonline on Labour’s Conversion Therapy Bill.
I’m literally furious that this crap continues to impede ethical psychotherapy
https://www.spiked-online.com/2026/06/30/the-conversion-therapy-ban-is-a-trojan-horse-for-trans-extremism/
Great speech by Evelyn Ball “The Addiction Theory of Trans Identity” https://youtu.be/pPQJwxkpsEs?is=TP6XlNLYjE6oj9-5
Certainly many trans-identified people I meet can act very like addicts, the highs and lows, the self loathing, the desire to escape reality…
This is so disappointing and also entirely predictable.
It’s quite clear that the NHS has not changed its understanding of the trans issue and they don’t yet realise they are implicated in this ongoing medical scandal.
The new regional centres are just GIDS mark 2.
Quoting @JamesEsses: 🚨Important Announcement: Puberty Blockers Judicial Review🚨
Following months of radio silence, I’m saddened to report that the government has announced that it is pushing forward with the puberty blockers trial, regardless of the significant ethical concerns raised that led to the temporary pause.
Most troubling of all is that they are now refusing to halt recruitment of children until the end of the Judicial Review that we are bringing.
As such, we have no choice but to seek an emergency injunction to block a single child being recruited and given this poison. There will be a hearing at the end of July to determine this.
Please rest assured that I and the entire team will be pursuing this Judicial Review all the way.
@[private account] - Just as with your predecessor, Wes Streeting, we implore you to do the right thing and pull the plug on this monstrosity of a trial. If you don’t, we will see you in Court.
Everyone knew the drill by the time @[private account] was targeted by trans activists. By that stage it had turned into a regime as @[private account] showed us
https://x.com/hothingsgirlsay/status/2064566125833167282?s=46
Quotes a post by A1240; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The trans activists weren’t given power. They took it.
We were operating within a high trust society at the time. Back then most people assumed that if a minority group were incandescent with rage then they must have something valid to complain about.
So most people self corrected, presuming they had missed something
Quotes a post by T20077; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans activists know how to hammer the point home. They go after the big names because the chilling effect spreads far beyond the individual target.
- Ken Zucker for gender services
- J.K. Rowling for writers
- Graham Linehan for comedy
- Joe Duffy for Irish media
Quoting @stellaomalley3: The chilling effect is most clear when you look at what happened to Ken Zucker.
In 2015 Dr Ken Zucker got sacked from his position since 1981 as clinical lead of the gender services in Canada. When Zucker was taken down, he was known to be the most respected world expert on gender issues in kids. Consequently, clinicians across the world immediately silenced themselves.
The thinking was that if trans activists could take down Zucker then they could take down anyone. I’ve heard GIDS clinicians from the Tavistock describe how the news of Zucker being sacked caused shockwaves at GIDS.
Zucker later won $586000 in compensation from the clinic but the damage was done.
The same chilling effect happened when the @IrishTimes pandered to trans activists in the student union in 2021. Journalists across Ireland released that if the Irish Times were toeing the line, then it’d be a brave fool who went against this.
(From then on I became blacklisted from the Irish mainstream media but luckily my work was valued elsewhere).
Then the following summer, June 2022, Joe Duffy allowed himself to be silenced by @[private account] and that was the death knell to free thought about trans issues in the Irish mainstream media.
Again the thought process was that if Joe Duffy could be silenced - and he could - then anyone could be. Just like Ken Zucker with gender therapy, the impact sent shockwaves through Irish journalism.
Sadly, rather than having the integrity to admit they’ve been silenced, the Irish journalists now try to keep their self-respect by pretending that they just have other more important things to write about.
It’s insult upon injury but this is where we are
The same happened with @jk_rowling , when the trans activists went after her, they were killing a million birds with the one stone.
Every writer less successful than her - which was basically everyone (just like Ken Zucker in gender, and Joe Duffy in Ireland) - was scared off
The chilling effect is most clear when you look at what happened to Ken Zucker.
In 2015 Dr Ken Zucker got sacked from his position since 1981 as clinical lead of the gender services in Canada. When Zucker was taken down, he was known to be the most respected world expert on gender issues in kids. Consequently, clinicians across the world immediately silenced themselves.
The thinking was that if trans activists could take down Zucker then they could take down anyone. I’ve heard GIDS clinicians from the Tavistock describe how the news of Zucker being sacked caused shockwaves at GIDS.
Zucker later won $586000 in compensation from the clinic but the damage was done.
The same chilling effect happened when the @IrishTimes pandered to trans activists in the student union in 2021. Journalists across Ireland released that if the Irish Times were toeing the line, then it’d be a brave fool who went against this.
(From then on I became blacklisted from the Irish mainstream media but luckily my work was valued elsewhere).
Then the following summer, June 2022, Joe Duffy allowed himself to be silenced by @[private account] and that was the death knell to free thought about trans issues in the Irish mainstream media.
Again the thought process was that if Joe Duffy could be silenced - and he could - then anyone could be. Just like Ken Zucker with gender therapy, the impact sent shockwaves through Irish journalism.
Sadly, rather than having the integrity to admit they’ve been silenced, the Irish journalists now try to keep their self-respect by pretending that they just have other more important things to write about.
It’s insult upon injury but this is where we are
Quoting @stellaomalley3: In August 2021 the @IrishTimes published this letter
https://www.irishtimes.com/opinion/bill-to-ban-conversion-therapy-poses-problems-for-therapists-1.4642164
and then, as a result, the Trinity college students union boycotted the Irish Times. https://www.thetimes.com/world/ireland-world/article/students-union-boycotts-irish-times-over-conversion-therapy-article-bw756rgzj
This created a chilling effect and by 2022 @[private account] were primed to pander to trans activists
In August 2021 the @IrishTimes published this letter
https://www.irishtimes.com/opinion/bill-to-ban-conversion-therapy-poses-problems-for-therapists-1.4642164
and then, as a result, the Trinity college students union boycotted the Irish Times. https://www.thetimes.com/world/ireland-world/article/students-union-boycotts-irish-times-over-conversion-therapy-article-bw756rgzj
This created a chilling effect and by 2022 @[private account] were primed to pander to trans activists
. @[private account] held a beautiful interview with @[private account] here. His reflections on the sham diagnosis and terrible treatment he received as a child expose just how absurd and damaging the trans industry has become.
https://youtu.be/etYjmF8zltM?is=seiT6GC_oHH6q31m
I commented here on the irritating insistence of politicians to make positive noises about so-called conversion therapy bans.
“Irish psychotherapist Dr Stella O’Malley accused the UK government of bowing to “political pressure from trans activist groups” to enact the new law..,
https://www.newsletter.co.uk/news/politics/dup-pledges-to-fight-against-labour-governments-proposed-conversion-therapy-ban-8549420
For today's episode on Beyond Gender, we talk with @[private account] - gender non-conformity, transgender ideology and gay male culture. @[private account] @_CryMiaRiver
PREMIERING on YouTube today 3pm ET / 8pm GMT. Link below ⬇️
My letter to the Irish Times yesterday… I can’t imagine why they didn’t publish it!
A chara,
The Irish Times seems increasingly determined to avoid a story even when it is sitting directly in front of them.
Genevieve Carberry’s piece, “Irish sisters in Miami: Weight-loss drugs have changed our plastic surgery business” (May 11th), presents Dr Sidhbh Gallagher as a glamorous Miami cosmetic surgeon enjoying a successful expatriate lifestyle. It is startling that Carberry omitted the fact that Dr Gallagher has become a highly controversial figure associated primarily with the medical transition of minors in the United States.
Here we have a doctor who built an international following on TikTok speaking about “yeeting the teets” of teenage girls - surgically removing the healthy breasts of deeply distressed adolescents - yet the article instead gushes about Pilates, paramotoring, dogs in strollers, and the “easy life” in Miami Beach.
Dr Gallagher became internationally controversial after being reported to the US Federal Trade Commission over allegations that her social media content aggressively marketed irreversible surgeries to minors.
The journalistic instinct to frame the medical transition of minors as progressive now looks badly dated. European health authorities are pulling back. Systematic evidence reviews continue to expose how weak the underlying evidence base is. Detransitioners are now speaking publicly in growing numbers.
I founded Genspect in 2021 to support families and detransitioners affected by trans medicalisation. We have helped over 5000 parents and over 600 detransitioners internationally. Yet much of the Irish media still covers this field with the breathless eagerness of a teenager newly admitted into the cool kids’ club.
I suspect that if a surgeon had built a public persona around removing healthy organs from any other vulnerable patient group, journalists might display rather more curiosity about this ongoing medical scandal.
Is mise, le meas,
Dr Stella O’Malley
Director, Genspect
Dreadful to see the Taoiseach of Ireland @[private account]
embarrass himself by saying children can be transgender. His ignorance harms autistic, gender nonconforming kids who are likely to grow up to be gay so long as reckless clinicians don’t chemically block their puberty.
Sometimes, a Mhichíl, when you don’t know the answer, you shouldn’t comment. https://x.com/griptmedia/status/2049057798722392309/video/1
The consequence of vulnerability arising from a difficult family background, combined with being cared for by mostly middle class women who are highly susceptible to prevailing trends, and reinforced by Tusla’s eagerness to support trans identification
Quotes a post by T26666; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The SPLC published an inaccurate and defamatory article about @genspect yesterday- and today they’re going to jail 😁
According to the fraudulent shysters Genspect promotes “anti-trans detransitioner narratives” 🙄🙄
https://www.splcenter.org/resources/hatewatch/detransition-narratives/
Quoting @KanekoaTheGreat: 🚨BREAKING: DOJ charges the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) with wire fraud, false statements, and conspiracy to commit money laundering.
The SPLC secretly funneled $3M+ in donor funds to violent racist extremist groups:
-Ku Klux Klan
-American Nazi Party
-Aryan Nation
-United Klans of America
-Unite the Right
-National Alliance
-National Socialist Movement
-Sadistic Souls Motorcycle Club
-American Front
To hide the payments, SPLC allegedly opened bank accounts under fictitious entities to conceal the source and control of donor funds.
Per the indictment: an SPLC field source was a member of the online leadership chat group that planned the 2017 "Unite the Right" rally in Charlottesville — made racist postings under SPLC supervision and helped coordinate transportation to the event.
FBI Director Kash Patel: "They lied to their donors, vowing to dismantle violent extremist groups, and actually turned around and paid the leaders of these very extremist groups — even utilizing the funds to have these groups facilitate the commission of state and federal crimes."
Acting AG Todd Blanche: "The SPLC is manufacturing racism to justify its existence. Using donor money to allegedly profit off Klansmen cannot go unchecked."
Scheme allegedly ran 2014–2023.
FBI calls it an ongoing investigation.
Insane!!!
Genuine question: I’m interested to know what you mean when you say that “some people are trans”? Do you think they have some sort of trans essence in their body?
I know a few doctors who stood up very assertively to trans issues and prevented these interventions from being carried out in the clinics and hospitals where they worked. I don’t know of doctors washing their hands of it? I do know very few of them know anything about it
Because it’s only zealots who are obtaining the blockers. Unlike most countries, the ordinary working doctors in Ireland never bought into the trans phenomenon. And so zealots parents are attending zealots clinicians and everyone else doesn’t really know what’s going on
I had to check back on something from the film that first led me into the trans issue, “Trans Kids: It’s time to talk”
It was made 8 years ago, lovely to see Magdalen Berns there, and @roseveniceallan giving it loads and lots of others like @bindelj
https://youtu.be/EuIi6wug0XM?is=1tzronNyqAzKrrfc
I think the lack of research in this area is reflective of the continued suppression of debate and we can only use the information available to date. Thankfully some quality research is beginning to emerge despite the strenuous efforts of trans activists.