The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
incels don’t have an excuse anymore, I don’t want to hear it.
if an incestuous autistic transgender crayola sonic artist can find a woman to impregnate, you can too.
I do too! lmao I love Tiffany to death so this isn’t a “drama” moment.
I come with some additional arguments here, as well.
Canada, for example, has a very similar governmental policy towards First Nations peoples as New Zealand. Very deferential, very kowtowing, very “this is your land therefore…”
That has resulted in some FN offenders receiving lenient sentences for the same crimes, as “historical trauma” is taken into account in sentencing.
So to put this into perspective for you and Tiff, who I know are passionate about women’s rights, take a look at this in application on “our level.”
I am sure you guys saw Reduxx report the news about Adam Laboucan (the trans-identified male who sexually assaulted a 3 month old baby). Laboucan is Indigenous. His treaty status is actually more important to the parole board than his trans identity. The parole board and his advocates have cited his Indigenous heritage in their ongoing efforts towards eventually getting this guy out of jail.
The “its his land” argument Tiffany made could equally be applied here. It’s his land, along with “tribal law should apply, why should white law apply, he has historical trauma, its settlers fault he’s fucked up,” etc, etc.
But tribal police have demonstrated a complete incompetency and/or unwillingness in jailing their own. Tribal organizations similarly don’t gaf (one actually welcomed Laboucan to attend a ceremony). Because that’s ultimately where race-based policies structured in oppression narratives lead you. So relying on these factions to deal with their own problems is proven to be a horrible idea. And any external policies will be assumed oppressive.
And who gets the shaft on all of these race-based justice policies the hardest? Women and children. Both on and off reserve. Their men aren’t held accountable, and they’re told not to hold their men accountable bc “it’s muh whities fault.” That’s how Canada got a MMIWG problem with a total lack of willingness to discuss who is actually causing it (psst…. it’s Indigenous men).
If you are going to have a multi-racial society, you need to have standardized laws that apply equally to everyone. No fractures. No hierarchies. No privileges.
We can fantasize about culturally insulated ethnostates all we want - but that is not practical within the confines of present reality.
And for what? Why did these young men fight and die, really?
For the ideology they represented to become synonymous with retarded, dysgenic, lazy gender goblins who spend their days writing substack fanfiction on “why Stalin would have loved trans rights, actually”?
For the symbol they proudly wore into battle to be plastered in the bio of every 35 year old obese unemployed polyamorous bisexual?
They fought to become a default political fashion accessory for mentally ill Redditors who hate their dad, and that is depressing. A slow, agonizing loss of the war rather than a quick loss of the battle.
Especially considering most of these men would be labeled "nazis" by the very people wielding their flag today.
Quotes a post by T07320; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I can basically tell you what this is going to turn into, after reading some of Khelif’s lawyers comments. Despite Khelif being a DSD case, not transgender, it is basically going to mimic a transgender argument, like it did with Semenya.
The concept of “femaleness” will basically be put on trial. Khelif is going to argue he is female despite the fact he has XY chromosomes, testicles, and a male-specific DSD. He is going to point to the fact that the majority of males with 5ARD prefer to live their lives as “female” instead of “male”. He is going to assert that his femaleness is in his mind, as opposed to in his body, and that it was just by happenstance of a simple birth defect that his body developed in opposition to his mind (which is a fantasy we hear troons repeat all the time).
Ultimately, Khelif is just a male without a penis. But that’s not what a woman is.
they’re not a risk to men full stop. from opportunities, as you said, to actual physical harm.
yet I see a lot of home of sexual men in particular crying and acting like their favorite poz spot putting up a trans flag or some bs is the direct equivalent of female inmates being locked up with male rapists
I like how Amnesty decided to use a stock image model instead of one of the plentiful photos of the actual “transgender woman” involved in this case.
it’s sort of an accidental admission on their part. they don’t see this dude as a woman. they know no one else will either.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
this sort of highlights something I’d been thinking of recently. Neither Khelif or Lin are trans. They have DSDs. That’s a very complex medical condition, and access to proper care is very difficult.
So I started this story having some modicum of sympathy for them because, in my estimation, they very likely didn’t know they were not female until very recently, and I have sympathy for that.
but the more it becomes obvious that they (especially Khelif) know, dont care, and/or put their feelings/desires above the integrity of the entire sport - my sympathy is running low (Lin) to out (Khelif).
I’ve spent probably the last week trying to tell people this isn’t a trans case and now we have yet another egirl posting selfies to pretend someone ever mistook her for a boy lmaooooooooooo
1. irrelevant
2. Not born female, not trans
3. Who cares
4. Yes I did thank you for the credit
5. Yes they did, because Khelif was found to be male after two different tests
And I will add:
Who has more motivation to lie here? And in the answer to that question you will find the truth.
The IBA and @[private account] have none. There is literally not a single thing they lost or gained by disqualifying Lin and Khelif. There is not a single benefit for them wading into this fight. In fact, it will only get worse for them as they continue to be derided and abused on an international scale.
The IOC, however, has A LOT at stake right now. The legitimacy of their already embarrassing Paris performance. Their decision to abolish sex-testing. Their decision to not do proper gender tests in one of the most dangerous contact sports. Potential lawsuits from female athletes. Their relationships with two country’s national olympic committees and potential lawsuits from them, too. And that is before we even get to politics of gender ideology itself.
I understand Lin and Khelif are not transgender, of course, but gender ideology is still a factor here as the refusal of the IOC to reinstitute sex testing is 100% the result of their desire to avoid accusations of bigotry.
I absolutely despise essay-posting but as the co-owner of the outlet (@reduxx) that broke the news about Khelif and Lin and started this wildfire, I feel compelled to put to bed some of the bullshit surrounding this story.
A rapid-fire FAQ:
1. "L & K are just women with high testosterone!"
Khelif and Lin were never tested for their testosterone levels.
The claims that they were disqualified from the 2023 Women's World Boxing Championship due to simple testosterone abnormalities were made by their respective national sporting bodies, who, obviously, have some motivation to lie here.
2. "L & K have female ID!"
Khelif and Lin are not believed to be transgender, and @reduxx made that VERY clear in our July 28 article.
They are believed to be impacted by a Difference of Sexual Development, in which there is a developmental abnormality in secondary sex characteristics. This is a medical condition which can manifest with children being born with ambiguous or disfigured genitalia. Male children impacted by DSDs are often "assigned female at birth" due to these genital defects, as there is a genuine assumption they are girls.
Thus, their identification documents would be completely irrelevant in this case. As is the fact they were "raised as girls." That's entirely expected for male children with DSDs.
Even more so for male children with DSDs in socially conservative countries.
Is a boy without a penis more likely to be raised as a boy or a girl? Exactly.
3. "The IBA never said they had XY chromosomes!"
On March 25, 2023, IBA President Umar Kremlev said that the boxers disqualified at the championships had XY chromosomes. He said this in a statement to TASS News.
There were only two boxers disqualified at the championships: Lin and Khelif.
4. "But Kremlev could be lying!"
Over the last 72 hours, the IBA has released two separate statements confirming that Khelif and Lin were not subject to testosterone testing, but had instead been subjected to a separate test validated by two independent laboratories.
That test confirmed they were not eligible to compete in women's boxing as per the IBA guidelines.
Crucially, the IBA defines "woman" as "an individual with XX chromosomes." In their guidelines, they also indicate that the gender tests they use to determine if a person is eligible to compete with women is a chromosomal test, not a hormone test.
In their second statement, the IBA condemned the IOC for allowing Khelif and Lin to proceed as they believed it was putting female boxers at risk and that they did not support "boxing between the genders."
5. "Why doesn't the IBA release the test!"
They cannot. It is protected medical information. They would be sued.
Khelif and Lin, however, can agree to have the laboratories release those tests themselves... Why haven't they?
6. "The IBA didn't let L & K appeal their disqualification!"
Yes they did. They have no choice in the matter. The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) is a fully independent tribunal which oversees all disputes in elite athletics. Every athlete has a right to bring a case to the CAS.
Lin did not challenge the disqualification.
Khelif challenged the disqualification but withdrew the appeal before it could proceed through the court.
Please ask yourself why. If they were genuinely female, why would they have chosen to refuse their opportunity to establish that in an irrefutable and legally binding way at a fully independent venue? Literally none of this would have happened had they simply submitted their tests to the CAS.
Buuuut... Consider that all decisions at the CAS are public information. It was through a CAS challenge that the world became aware that Caster Semenya had XY chromosomes, for example.
If Khelif and Lin had proceeded through the CAS, there would have been irrefutable evidence, documented by an independent body, that they were either male or female.
So why? Why did they not want the CAS to examine their tests? Why did they not want this information to be public? I think the reason is obvious.
7. "But the IOC approved their eligibility for 2024!"
The IOC stopped sex testing athletes in 1999. Since then, they have deferred to individual sporting bodies to ensure athletes were eligible.
HOWEVER, for the purposes of the 2024 Paris Olympics, there is no formal oversight body for boxing. This is the first time this ever happened.
As a result, the IOC created an ad-hoc boxing unit to temporarily oversee the boxing competitions in Paris. This unit has no guidelines for gender eligibility, and has apparently just been allowing boxers to compete "as females" if they have female gender markers on their passports/legal documents.
8. "The IBA is corrupt and cannot be trusted!"
The IOC has long had an issue with the IBA because the IBA has refused to disqualify Russian athletes on the basis of their national identity.
Claims of the IBA's "corruption" can basically be summarized to "Russia bad, Russians evil." The IBA has literally no history of bullshitting about the sex of boxers involved and it doesn't benefit them in any kind of way to do so.
9. "The IBA only disqualified L & K because they beat Russian boxers at the 2023 championships!"
No they did not. I started seeing this weird, completely false claim circulating over the last 24 hours.
Khelif beat Thailand's Janjaem Suwannapheng and was set to compete against China's Yang Liu for gold in the Welterweight category.
Lin beat Bulgaria's Svetlana Kamenova Staneva for bronze in the Featherweight category.
They were scheduled to fight no Russian boxers in either one of their categories, and only one Russian boxer won a gold medal in the entire championship (Anastasiia Demurchian, Light Middleweight).
India won the most gold medals (4) at the 2023 Women's Championship. China won the most medals overall (7). Kazakhstan won the second most medals overall (6). Russia only won 3 medals at the championship.
Also worth noting that another Taiwanese boxer, Huang Hsiao-wen, won gold in the Bantamweight category. So for all the Taiwanese mouthpieces claiming Lin's disqualification was just "discrimination against Taiwan"... lol no.
10. "L & K were only singled out because they don't look feminine!"
This idea that Lin and Khelif were singled out for not meeting some "western feminine beauty standard" is atrocious and quite easily refutable when you look at literally any of their competitors, most of whom do not meet that arbitrary standard themselves because boxing is a physically demanding sport for robust people, male or female.
Below is Khadija El-Mardi of Morocco, for example, who likely would be accused of failing to meet this supposed "western feminine beauty standard." El-Mardi won gold in the Heavyweight category at the 2023 World Championships. She is advancing to the quarter-finals in Paris as we speak. She's one of the best female boxers out there.
She is a woman. Her features and tall stature literally do not matter. She is biologically female. Sex testing would return an XX.
Women are adult human females. This is true regardless of their external appearance.
Likewise, men are adult human males. This is true regardless of abnormalities or defects in their secondary sex characteristics.
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨BREAKING🚨
Taiwan's Lin Yu-Ting has won against Uzbekistan's Sitora Turdibekova, beating her in all three rounds of the Women's Featherweight Boxing preliminary.
Lin had previously been disqualified from the 2023 Women’s World Boxing Championship for having "XY chromosomes."
A tremendous amount of idiocy in your “article,” and you don’t seem to have understood a single damn thing about this issue lol
1. The IOC does not test for sex. So Lin’s “eligibility” at the 2024 Paris Olympics was limited to that Lin had “female” identification.
2. Lin is not believed to be transgender. Lin is believed to have a DSD. DSD individuals often maintain the identification they have since birth. So there would be no identification change, identification is irrelevant.
3. Rowling never said Lin was transgender. Again, Lin is believed to have a DSD. This has nothing to do with gender identity.
4. Lin DID admit to violations in 2023. Lin did not challenge the IBA’s ruling, which all boxers have a right to do at the Court of Arbitration for Sport. Lin agreed to the disqualification, making the IBA’s ruling legally binding.
5. “The tests confirmed that she is fully eligible to compete” - Which tests? What was tested? Chromosomes? Testosterone? What is the eligibility? We know the eligibility for IBA is XX Chromosomes, and that Lin failed to meet this eligibility criteria.
People are born with DSDs - also known as Intersexuals. Their documents were never changed. They were “raised” as whatever sex their parents or doctors decided to raise them as. A birth certificate wouldn’t show anything abnormal.
Many people with DSDs can go a huge portion of their life before finding out their chromosomes are not aligned with their “birth sex.”
But DSDs are still sex-specific. They will still either have XY or XX chromosomes. In other words, be biologically male or female.
Males of any kind, including those with DSDs, should not be competing with women.
But everyone here is still incorrect about what a DSD is and that is part of the problem.
The Taiwanese yapping about this think we are claiming Lin is transgender. As in, Lin was born male and then decided to identify as a female later. That is not what happened here.
Lin was raised as a girl from birth. Lin’s documents will say “female.” Lin would have been with the girls from day 1.
But it doesn’t matter, because if Lin has XY chromosomes, Lin should not be playing against women.
No we absolutely do not bare any responsibility for the words and actions of other people.
I have as much responsibility for someone assuming Lin is transgender because they didn’t read the article as I do for you assuming we did say Lin is transgender because you didn’t read the article.
Reduxx is not responsible for anyone in our comments making uneducated statements or incorrect assertions because they didn’t read the article.
That goes for you. That goes for them. That goes for anyone here.
It’s not our problem.
All we exist to do is present facts.
It is a fact that Khelif and Lin were previously disqualified from a women’s tournament.
It is a fact that Umar Kremlev stated the reasons for the qualifications at this event were due to chromosome abnormalities.
It is a fact that they are suspected to have DSDs.
It is a fact that they have never claimed to be transgender.
It is a fact that the IOC has no sex testing.
Every single point in the article is factual.
We even went so far as to avoid any pronouns for Khelif or Lin because we are not making our own assumptions, we are simply presenting facts as we know them.
And at the end of the article, for anyone who actually got that far, we present quotes from the Independent Council on Women’s Sport calling for the IOC to end this confusion and reinstate cheek swabs so questions like this never arise again.
The whining, whether that be from Taiwanese radfems who didn’t read the article and believe we are claiming Lin is transgender, or from Gender Criticals who didn’t read the article and assume we are claiming both of them are, needs to stop,
Read the article before commenting. Simple.
@[private account] @[private account] @reduxx @[private account] Because you have no idea what you are talking about, that’s why. :)
Lin isn’t transgender. Khelif isn’t transgender. The article says this very clearly. But you didn’t read the article.
oh my God. none of you read the article. none of you. not one! 😭
This has nothing to do with transgenderism. Nothing. The article even says neither Lin nor Khelief identify as transgender.
I am going to repeat myself again for you: This has NOTHING to do with gender identity. NOTHING.
Please read that line over and over and over and over until it finally sinks in.
DSDs are MEDICAL conditions. Many people with DSDs don't even know they have a DSD. They are born and raised as one sex, only to later find out (if they ever find out) they are biologically a completely different sex.
Our article about Lin and Khelif has NOTHING to do with their appearances. And we have NO track record of ever criticizing a female solely on the basis of "appearance." We don't even mention their appearance in the article!
The fact you have had to make this self-soothing bullshit up to feel better is unbelievable to me.
Our article was grounded in direct, clear, unambiguous statements made by the President of the International Boxing Association indicating that the two athletes who were disqualified at the WWBC in 2023 had "XY Chromosomes." The two players who were disqualified were Lin and Khelif.
Stop coping. Stop lying. Stop spreading bullshit. Read the fucking article before you ever speak about it again.
Margaret also has had that name since birth.
I think you genuinely don’t know the difference between trans and DSD and that’s where your issue is coming from.
😅
And I remember this conversation so distinctly bc of how much it pissed me off that a trans activist was trying to claim TiMs won women their rights. It was a whole blowout on this app.
I’m begging you people to slow your roll here.
1) This offense took place in GREECE, which is not like the UK. Their definition of “rape”DOES NOT require penetration. Any unwanted sexual activity is considered rape.
2) The DM is referencing TWO cases in their article, one which involved a woman and one which involved a man. The DM also appears to have gotten some details wrong in their translation, as most Greek sources say the perpetrator was from the USA, and the victim was from the UK.
3) Every Greek source I have seen is referring to the perpetrator as female. There is zero mention of transgender identity, and, trust me, Greek media would not give a shit about saying stuff like that if it were the case.
4) There are so many examples of TiMs sexually assaulting women. You do not need to make them up. Basta.
actually saw this in person at the “family friendly” trans pride parade in Toronto and it was just a booth full of naked men 💀💀
https://x.com/thepublicanow/status/1806862297094124014?s=46
Quotes a post by T08383; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
last year the SPLC slimed my outlet @reduxx as akin to a white supremacist website because we’ve reported on trans sex offenders and pedophiles.
so I’m really glad the SPLC doing bad. inshallah it gets worse 💕
Quotes a post by T03988; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
there’s a reason trans activists never talk about the females LARPing as men who compete in male sports, and this is why.
not only are they embarrassing failures, but they completely disprove the fantasy that aesthetics and hormones can meaningfully alter biology
if someone believes humans can change biological sex based on internal feeling, there really isn’t any argument they could make against someone “identifying” as anything else.
I’ve seen TRAs try desperately to argue against things like trans-racialism. It doesn’t work lol
it seems like since the death of George Floyd the left has been cycling through stand-in Floyds with accelerating frequency, as though to try and keep its increasingly mentally ill adherents focused.
we had the COVID Floyds. Trans Floyds. January 6 AOC Floyd. Etc. now Fire Floyd
Quoting @Howlingmutant0: Absolutely powerful image, rest in pow - uh I mean RIP dude
SOMETHING TO NOTE is that there appears to be an increasing wave of trans-identified boys whose parents transitioned them at an EXTREMELY young age and are have actively hiding their biological sex from their peers.
We are likely going to see more of this.
every single death trans activists have rallied around and attributed to “hate” in the last year have ended up having nothing to do with hate at all.
they’re absolute desperate for their narratives of vulnerability to be true.
arguing with a lib and saying “the trans industrial complex is disproportionately incarcerating black men” and watching them commit ideological hara-kiri in front of me
The thing that kills me is the “may have been transgender.” what does that mean?
we already know these people think a woman wearing “men’s” clothes or having short hair means she was secretly transgender.
trans activists most definitely did accuse you of inciting hate. they accused you of hate speech, abuse, and a slew of other things.
that you think there is a difference in their mind between what you did and what this woman did shows a concerning lack of understanding of this issue.
So the number of trans individuals murdered in the UK since 2008 is 13. Most of those weren't even necessarily hate motivated.
That figure comes from Transphobia vs. Transrespect, which is a trans activist group tracking trans murders.
As for the figure on the other side, my source is me lmao I am the co-founder @reduxx, and we have reported on more than 13 trans-identified male rapists and pedophiles in the UK in the past year or so alone.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedchild predatordenialvictim dismissalviolence terror
it is so overwhelmingly obvious that the cries of trans-genocide/transphobia are just part of the fantasy of vulnerability these people have constructed.
primarily the porn-addled adult men who want to believe that anyone could mistake them for being petite coquettes.
there are more trans-identified males currently in custody in the UK for child sex offenses than there have been victims of transphobic murders since 2008.
Quotes a post by T03255; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You are correct!
As I also mentioned here, her dual identity may not even have anything to do with a trans status, but rather just mental illness.
https://x.com/slatzism/status/1757384215920837004?s=46
Quoting @Slatzism: There’s the thing: NO IDEA.
She did use multiple masculine and feminine names (“Jeffery”), and seemed to alternate between them. She was previously booked as Jeffery, but that doesn’t necessarily mean her legal name was Jeffery.
She was also severely mentally ill, and this alternate identity could very well have had nothing to do with a transgender status and instead could have been a split personality or some such thing.
There’s the thing: NO IDEA.
She did use multiple masculine and feminine names (“Jeffery”), and seemed to alternate between them. She was previously booked as Jeffery, but that doesn’t necessarily mean her legal name was Jeffery.
She was also severely mentally ill, and this alternate identity could very well have had nothing to do with a transgender status and instead could have been a split personality or some such thing.
Yes we saw. It’s a FtM apparently.
Extremely interesting that we’ve had two of those in the past year. I think this now outpaces non-trans F shooters for a large historical period
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @reduxx @[private account] where did we use cult lingo? explain. in detail.
identifying him as transgender is quite literally fundamental to the point of the article lmao
It also doesn’t provide any sources that she’s male, but many believed that right away.
I just did a bit of digging and while she has been made fun of for her looks for years, there is 0 indication she’s transgender, and I can’t find anything suggesting she’s intersex either.
I’ve also found many comments from people who state she is a natural born female and are upset at those who assume she’s male because of her looks.
I think GCs playing the “but this looks like a dude!!!!” game with zero concrete information is a bad idea considering how many times y’all have been wrong. It is also devastating to your own arguments about womanhood not being defined by appearance, and how hairy/unconventional/masculine-coded women are still women.
That being said: Many of the female rugby players from Oceana have very strong, defined features and facial hair, including several of Legona’s teammates who are of the same heritage.
Case in point: Fijian captain Ana Roqica. I had someone recently ask me if she was a male.
it’s just the feedback loop. every day we have trans activists blasting into our notifications to tell us we’re lying. we invite them to prove us wrong, they never do.
I’ve even offered $$$$ to people who claimed we had published a falsehood to show us. They never can.
We don’t have access to any special information. Anyone can get access to the info we have. They just won’t because, like with Paula here, it would mean they would have concrete proof they’re wrong, and they can’t handle that.