The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Voters rejected President Donald Trump and Republicans on Tuesday for reasons having to do with the war in Iran and affordability. Six out of ten said they were very concerned about grocery prices, while two-thirds said Trump’s policies had made the economy worse. Three out of four voters called the war a crucial or major reason for their vote. Sixty-three percent said it was the wrong decision. And when it came time to vote on core cultural issues for the Left, they often voted against it. In Washington and Colorado, for example, voters banned males from female sports, while in California, they voted against a billionaire wealth tax.
And yet many Democrats are acting as though they were elected to do something else. Colorado’s governor-elect, Phil Weiser, said the day after the vote that he would “take a look at these anti-trans measures and what adjustments are necessary and appropriate.” Washington’s Democratic Party chair said she would fight to overturn the ban in court. “DEI is back!” wrote Rep. Ro Khanna on election night. “We will rip ICE apart,” said Minnesota Senator-elect Peggy Flanagan. Maine Senator-elect Troy Jackson promised to “fight to abolish ICE.” Tech executives “are going to need to plant new forests for all of the subpoenas we’ll be printing,” wrote Sen. Ed Markey. Senate Democrats are weighing bills to vet AI models before release, which opens the door to government censorship of content....
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2118469797927112989?a=RYiHarBoqUgw-gg_L0w&s=20
Plesae subscribe now to support our award-winning journalism and to read the rest of the story.
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2118469797927112989?a=RYiHarBoqUgw-gg_L0w&s=20
The economy and Iran were behind the Democrats' victory. But now, many of the elected leaders are seeking to go against the will of the people on trans, race, migration, and the weaponization of government. Behind them is a radicalized base & ideological dream worlds.
The Democratic candidates who could win back the Senate for their party appear to be abandoning transgenderism in sports and medicine. Democratic Senate nominee for Texas, James Talarico, said “Absolutely” when asked in September if he would ban gender surgery for minors. He added, “I will oppose trans athletes playing in girls’ sports if it risks safety or fairness…There are not six sexes. There are two.” Democratic Senate nominee for Ohio, Sherrod Brown, noted that, “In Ohio, it’s against the law to perform transgender surgeries on kids. That’s right, it’s illegal.” Iowa Democratic Senate candidate Josh Turek ran an ad last month where he noted that he is against males in female sports and that the state already bans them. “I’m against taxpayers paying for sex changes, too. Anyone who tells you any different is lying,” he said in the same ad. Democratic Senate candidate Amy Acton said in June, “I do not support boys playing in girls' sports. This is already settled law in Ohio, and as governor, I will enforce and uphold the law.” And Democratic Senate candidate for Alaska, Mary Peltola, said in 2024, “No, I don’t think that we should have men competing in women’s sports.”
But there is less to these shifts than meets the eye. In September, a woman asked Talarico if he would defend her trans-identified nephew’s ability to compete against females in women’s sports, and Talarico said, “Always. The way I fought for trans kids in the legislature is how I will fight for them in the U.S. Senate… I think I have the most inclusive policy of any candidate who’s running.” CBS’s “60 Minutes” last night released an interview with Democratic Senate candidate for Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed. Correspondent Ross Douthat asked him about trans-identified males playing in female sports. El-Sayed was dismissive. “A lot of the culture war issues that get fought right now are about trying to distract us from the fact that we can’t afford our gas, can’t afford our groceries, can’t see a doctor, are worried about whether or not our kids are gonna have a good life. And instead, we’re out here talking about who gets to play what sport, which, you know, should be the question of the people who govern sports.”
Others have similarly dodged the issue. Democratic Senate candidate for North Carolina, Roy Cooper, in 2023 vetoed a bill that would have banned males in female sports, Peltola voted against a House sports bill in that same year that would have banned males from female sports, called it “bullying” and “federal overreach,” and Democratic Senate candidate for Georgia, Jon Ossoff, has repeatedly voted against federal legislation to ban males from female sports....
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2117382950912250199?a=xg3ETH0egTHAeT0LLiA&s=20
Please subscribe now to support our award-winning investigative reporting, debunking the mainstream media.
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2117382950912250199?a=xg3ETH0egTHAeT0LLiA&s=20
Whether Democrats take one or two houses of Congress, they and the media are about to pull off one of the most brilliant psychological operations in recent memory: convincing millions of swing voters they had moderated on trans.
Talarico made national headlines when he went on Fox to say he would oppose trans athletes in girls’ sports “if it risks safety or fairness.” Four days later, a woman posing as a supporter secretly recorded him saying, “my position hasn’t changed,” after she asked him to defend her trans-identified nephew's ability to compete in girls' sports. The media buried or ignored it.
On “60 Minutes,” El-Sayed called concerns over boys in girls’ sports a manufactured culture war issue meant to distract from high prices and said he was “not running to govern sports,” without ever saying he opposed it.
Every Senate Democrat present, including Ossoff, voted in March 2025, and again in March 2026, to block legislation that would have banned males from female sports. Sherrod Brown cast the same vote in 2021 and 2024. Peltola cast it in the House in 2023. None since have promised to vote differently in the future.
Meanwhile, Roy Cooper vetoed a bill that would have banned males in female sports, Josh Turek voted against Iowa’s 2025 health budget, which barred Medicaid from paying for surgeries or cross-sex hormones, and then ran an ad saying he is “against taxpayers paying for sex changes,” and Ed Markey made his support for transgenderism central to his campaign and defeated his moderate opponent Seth Moulton by 65% to 35% in the Massachusetts Senate primary.
One can only appreciate how brilliant the Democrats/media psyop was when you consider that 71% of the public opposes trans medical procedures for minors and 79% oppose males in female sports.
Even the share of Democrats who favor getting males out of female sports rose from 37% in 2022 to 45% in 2025, while the percentage of Democrats who believe changing one’s gender is morally acceptable declined 11 points between 2025 and 2026.
Republicans spent at least $183 million on ads attacking the Democrats on trans, which is at least $30 million more than they spent at the same point in 2024.
It wasn’t enough to overcome one of the Democrats’ most successful deception operations after over a decade of hugely consequential ones (e.g., Russiagate hoax, Charlottesville, BLM, Hunter Biden laptop, climate, Covid, etc.)
From borders & trans to Covid & climate, the Left said it knew best but got it horribly wrong. Instead of taking responsibility, it demonizes & silences. The Left’s War On Reality by Alex Gutentag (@[private account]) and me reveals a road to hell paved with bad intentions. https://tinyurl.com/bdcrpdym
As they spread hoax after hoax about Russians trans climate migration Covid race etc they demands mass censorship of accurate information and legitimate opinions about Russians trans climate migration Covid race etc
We have to change the words people use, say progressives, liberals, and leftists, in order to protect democracy, freedom, and the vulnerable.
In the US, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says health and medical workers should refer to “people with undocumented status” and not “illegal immigrants.” We should refer to “people with obesity,” not “the obese,” says The American Medical Association.
“Alien” is “an offensive term for a human being,” believes California Governor Gavin Newsom, who signed a 2021 law eliminating it from being used in the state’s laws.
In 2022, progressive New York lawmakers replaced the word “inmate” with “incarcerated individual” in the state’s statutes.
The Associated Press Stylebook, which most American newsrooms follow, tells reporters to avoid “the dehumanizing collective noun the homeless” and to refer to trans-identified men as “transgender women” and trans-identified women as “transgender men.”
The same is true across the West.
Britain’s Green Party recently issued an “Inclusive Terminology Guidance” that instructs its members to stop using words like “mothers and fathers,” “elderly,” “able-bodied,” “youngster,” “sexual preference,” “nutter,” or “lunatic.” The goal is to “avoid language which is harmful to people with mental health conditions.”
A video of a parliamentary debate in Wales went viral after showing candidates trying and failing to use the word “blanket” when referring to a new speed limit law.
Currently, policymakers in the United States, Britain, France, the European Union, and Australia are all seeking sweeping new controls over what people can say online, while the latter is seeking to use anonymous accounts, known as sock puppets or bots, to propagate government information.
And German politicians are now seeking to use AI to automatically monitor X, YouTube, and Instagram for ideas they consider dangerous....
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2105739899781423557
Please subscribe now to support Public’s defense of free speech and to read our award-winning investigative journalism.
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2105739899781423557
The more you know about it, the more shocking it is. That's why Democrats are guaranteed to regret not having rid themselves of the trans albatross sooner.
For years, Democrats won elections by portraying Republicans as cruel to transgender people.
In 2016, North Carolina Republicans passed a law restricting bathroom use by biological sex, and the boycotts that followed cost the state $3.8 billion in lost business over a dozen years. PayPal scrapped a facility that would have added an estimated $2.66 billion to the state’s economy. The NBA moved its All-Star Game out of Charlotte. That November, Governor Pat McCrory became the first sitting North Carolina governor to lose reelection, “weighed down by a law he signed limiting LGBT rights,” according to AP. I
n April 2016, Trump said Caitlyn Jenner could use any bathroom she wanted at Trump Tower and advised North Carolina to “leave it the way it is.” When Trump tweeted in July 2017 that transgender people could not serve in the military, voters told pollsters, 68% to 27%, that they should be allowed to serve.
Republican criticisms of transgenderism didn’t work. In 2020, the American Principles Project spent $4 million on transgender-themed ads against Biden in Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania, all of which Biden carried. Republicans and allied groups spent at least $50 million on ads about transgender children across at least 25 states in 2022, and Democrats concluded the ads had flopped.
Third Way noted that the Democratic governors of Kansas, Michigan and Maine had all beaten challengers who ran them, and wrote that “attacking transgender kids isn’t the political win some on the right seem to think it is.”
The next year, Kentucky’s Andy Beshear vetoed a ban on transgender medicine for minors, faced Republican Daniel Cameron’s charge that he and his allies “believe kids should have access to sex change surgery and drugs,” and won reelection by five points.
This year, Republicans view transgenderism as such a winning issue for them that they’ve made it a centerpiece of their closing argument for the midterms....
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2098773347668578373?s=20
Public does investigative reporting on transgenderism you can’t find anywhere else. Join the growing number of paying subscribers who make our award-winning journalism possible.
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2098773347668578373?s=20
Ten years ago, trans was a political advantage for Democrats. But now, a growing number of them agree with Republicans that males in female sports and trans medical procedures on children are “crazy.” Imagine their shock when they learn transgenderism is also a sexual fetish.
The idea that progressives won't ever wake up is silly defensive pessimism and ignores everything from heliocentrism to the germ theory to lobotomies.
On the trans medical scandal, many have already woken up, as I explain in the third paragraph, half the states have banned it, and the rest will too, hopefully sooner rather than later. Colorado voters are likely to ban it this year.
On race, it's almost already over. Look at Cambridge-Ghent Arday-Cofnas scandal. Read the liberal Atlantic. People are removing DEI references from their LinkedIn pages. AOC is trying to laugh it off. No major progressive is today defending the race madness.
On addiction, San Francisco has a recovery-focused mayor, not an addiction-enabling ("harm reduction" one).
Yes, LA, Seattle, and Portland are worse than ever but moderates have won there and will will win again and do what SF is doing.
On education, look around. Many progressive commentators are already insisting they were always already in favor of phonics and school discipline.
Pick up a history book. It is inevitable that all of these awful progressive policies will be repealed eventually. And many, many (of course not all, duh) progressives will wake up in horror — just as Nikki does in "Obsession."
News media organizations in the United States and the United Kingdom believe it is factually accurate and ethical to refer to people by the pronouns they prefer.
The Associated Press Stylebook says that it recognizes “the need for a pronoun for people who don’t identify as a he or a she” and instructs journalists to use neither “biological sex” nor “both sexes,” since not everyone identifies with male or female.
The BBC’s news style guide states that “We generally use the term and pronoun preferred by the person in question, unless there are editorial reasons not to do so.”
In fact, it is wrong for journalists to use inaccurate pronouns. Pronouns in English carry information about sex, and readers understand “she” to mean a female. A man who identifies as a woman remains male, because sex is encoded in our DNA and no amount of hormones or surgery can change that.
Journalists should refer to people by their chosen names and treat every person, including trans-identified people, with respect. Names are a matter of personal choice and always have been. Reporters have always called people by the names they use, from pen names to stage names. NPR’s standards editor in 2013 was right to write that whistleblower Chelsea Manning’s request to be called Chelsea was “one NPR should respect.”
But NPR was wrong to use female pronouns to refer to Manning. Dignity does not require a false description of a person’s sex. When accuracy and respect come into conflict, journalists should choose accuracy. A respectful sentence can still say what the person believes and also point out that it is inaccurate.
Many people have grown used to the entirety of the legacy news media referring to men as women and women as men, which is why so many people praised Public’s recent article, which described the trans-identifying rector of Ghent University as a “he.”
In reality, it is very strange that a profession committed to accuracy and ethics adopted language that is so totally inaccurate and unethical. How did this occur? How did people trained to verify facts come to print sentences they knew were false?...
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2091916934866669672?s=20
Public is entirely reader-supported. Please subscribe now to support our award-winning journalism and to read the rest of the article:
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2091916934866669672?s=20
I also think this is why the centrist Dems like @[private account] and others are having a hard time making their case. They are associated with supposedly more moderate/centrist Dems like Biden and Harris — but Biden and Harris embraced all the unpopular woke stuff. And so while they can blame the Party's embrace of the unpopular stuff, few can any more trust the centrists as able to maintain their supposed moderation after 2024. And now @KamalaHarris and other Dems are going to struggle to distance themselves from their open border, DEI, and trans policies. If they don't, they risk alienating swing voters. If they do, they risk alienating their base, which is unrepentant and dogmatic to the point of violence.
To understand why DSA keeps winning, it's important to understand that after 2018, the DSA wing of the party (@AOC) reached an accommodation with the establishment wing (@SpeakerPelosi). The establishment wing would embrace the Woke/rad-Left culture agenda of BLM/DEI radicalism, open borders, & trans, while the DSA wing would sideline its populist economic agenda. Even @[private account] went along with this when he ran in 2020. And that strategy appeared to work with Biden's victory that year.
But then, since 2024, the DSA and Democratic base have skillfully blamed their loss on the establishment wing of the party, even though the radical issues the establishment lost on (open borders, DEI extremism, trans) all came from the DSA/rad-Left. The DSA/rad-Left then pivoted toward affordability/economic issues and backgrounded the unpopular culture war stuff.
I think Nothing Left by @[private account] is an important book because it contributes to a better understanding of what exactly happened within the party over the last decade. Evan also credits the rise of the progressive/rad Left of the Party to its growing savvy at things like fundraising.
Quoting @shellenberger: Since the 2024 election, three distinct explanations have been given for why Democrats lost the White House and both houses of Congress, and why they remain unpopular with voters.
Moderates say the party went woke on migration, race, and LGBT issues. A Democratic pollster called the party’s orthodoxy “noticeably out of step with what was electorally optimal or viable.” His firm found undecided voters broke for Trump 52 to 38, with five of their top eight stated reasons involving immigration.
Progressives say the party failed to deliver a populist economic message. A Sanders-aligned autopsy found that the Kamala Harris campaign courted suburban Republicans while ignoring working-class voters, and that strong populist economic messages outperformed democracy-threat messages among Pennsylvania blue-collar voters, 57% to 45%.
And fundamentalists blame institutional factors, above all, former President Joe Biden and Vice President Harris themselves. One analyst noted that Biden’s approval in the high 30s and two years of recession-level consumer sentiment put the nominee on track to lose the popular vote by 4 points, and Harris lost by 1.5. Biden ran too long, the party held no real primary, and Harris inherited an inflation-poisoned incumbency.
In truth, all three explanations are correct and work together, and a Democratic operative turned tell-all author named Evan Barker explains how in a new podcast with Public.
Barker spent roughly a decade raising money for the party’s left flank, from the Bernie Sanders orbit through Justice Democrats-aligned campaigns to figures like Jasmine Crockett and Abdul El-Sayed, before writing the bestselling book Nothing Left.
In our conversation for Public, she explained that the party’s elites, the DNC and DCCC world, reached an accommodation with the progressive and DSA wing: the establishment embraced woke culture issues while both sides abandoned progressive economics.
“The Democratic establishment was also co-opted,” she said. “It embraced those ideas in exchange for not having to do the actual economic populism stuff that the Bernie Sanders campaign in 2016 really made their focus.”
The ideas the establishment embraced were open borders, defunding police, and “putting identity and race at the forefront of everything.” The donors preferred it that way. “The donors prefer that they focus on cultural issues,” Barker said. “They don’t really want to talk about economics. It’s a good distraction to their wealth, to be just totally blunt.” ...
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2090076368247935401?s=20
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2090076368247935401?s=20
Yes, DSA has a good ground game. But the reason it keeps winning is that voters rejected open borders, DEI, trans, etc, which the party establishment embraced to avoid economic populism. Dem. moderates and progressives “embraced each other's worst impulses,” says @[private account]
Puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries are life-saving for trans-identified people, said Democrats. In truth, they have resulted in the worst medical scandal since lobotomies. Now, a major new study finds the Biden admin facilitated the fraudulent billings that financed it.
Recently elected socialist Democrats really aren’t that radical, says CNN. And yet they support abolishing the police, trans surgeries on children, and expropriating apartments. A 150-year-old socialist strategy of deliberately deceiving the public explains their success.
Friends — Sometimes you have to take a step back and see the bigger picture. That’s what I tried to do today in my keynote speech to the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship, the third gathering of a remarkable group of civilization-positive people. I hope you enjoy it. — Michael
I have flown here from California to talk about saving Western civilization, which I am aware is a little like taking fire safety advice from a man whose house keeps burning down. These observations are based on research that my co-author Alex Gutentag and I conducted over the last three years.
Our remarkable civilization rests on several pillars, including law and order, national borders, meritocracy, equal justice, the protection of children, industrialization, free speech, and a widespread faith in its capacity to deliver a positive future.
I am not here to predict that these pillars will fall. I am here to report that the demolition crew has been hired, paid in full, and asked to submit a diversity statement.
Decriminalization, depolicing, and the enabling of illegal camping, shoplifting, open-air drug dealing, and use undermine public safety.
In San Francisco, authorities amputated the rotted feet of a mentally ill “homeless” woman — and then put her right back on the street. In the name of compassion.
Mass migration hurts working-class citizens, increases crime, and creates victims.
Biden’s open borders policy resulted in child trafficking and death, including of minors falling from rooftops while working.
DEI policies and other forms of racial and sexual discrimination subvert meritocracy and undermine public safety.
British police handcuffed and let 18-year-old Henry Nowak bleed to death because they believed the lie told by the murderer’s accomplice that Nowak was a racist and thus, by extension, the perpetrator.
Los Angeles politicians defunded and mismanaged the fire department and failed to keep the crucial water reservoir full because they were focused like a laser on DEI, resulting in catastrophic and utterly avoidable fires.
Trans surgeries on minors transgress historic protections of children like Fox Varian. Surgeons removed her breasts when she was 16 after trans-influenced communicators convinced her she was actually a boy.
Climate activists raise energy prices, deindustrialize rich nations, and work to stop poor nations from building natural-gas-fueled fertilizer factories.
Our schools, universities, and legacy media add insult to injury by programming children to believe they are stained by slavery, colonialism, and genocide.
And now governments around the world are seeking to deny them alternative sources of information that might contradict the establishment’s degrading narrative while simultaneously imposing digital IDs on the rest of us.
Many believe that these attacks on our civilization stem from ignorance, excessive empathy, or good intentions gone wrong. Indeed, the vast majority of people do not want to scrap the pillars of Western civilization. And many of them are motivated by compassion and concern for the most vulnerable members of our society.
But the intellectual pioneers who framed anti-civilizational policies as necessary for remedying entrenched and historical injustices do, in fact, want to destroy Western civilization as we know it, and replace it with something they believe will be more just. They believe that inequality and suffering stem from our social organization in general and from capitalism, industrialization, meritocracy, equal justice, and gender roles in particular.
They are, knowingly and unknowingly, heirs to Jean-Jacques Rousseau, who said society corrupted innocent children while abandoning all five of his children to orphanages. They believe they can, both through their policies and the transformation of language and thought, radically reorganize society in ways that dramatically reduce, if not eliminate, inequality and suffering.
Their complaint is not that the system is malfunctioning but rather that it’s functioning normally.
And a close reading of these anti-civilization intellectuals reveals that they are motivated not by empathy and love of humanity but rather by its opposite: the creation, projection, and hatred of cartoon villains onto others. Rousseau was the first in a long line of reformers who claim to love humanity but who hate humans. They believe the defenders of civilization are as evil as the system they defend and demand that they be silenced and removed from universities, social media platforms, and polite society. They view law and order, national borders, and meritocracy as strategies for villains to oppress victims. And they view reality not as evidence against their radical project but rather as evidence that their project has been insufficiently radical.
There are economic reasons for this. Our societies are directed by a professional managerial class whose claim to authority stems from its alleged expertise. They have sought and continue to seek to control practically every aspect of human life, from the productive sectors of the economy to popular culture to language itself. They benefit from an expansion of the state and of parastatal entities like NGOs, and thus need to maintain the fantasy that Western civilization creates victims and that, if only they had more power, they could reorganize it in ways that would finally allow for universal freedom, prosperity, and sustainability.
In other words, we are the first civilization wealthy enough to fund a tenured class whose full-time job is to explain why it should never have existed.
But what most drives the anti-civilization discourse and movement is ....
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2069816718990418381?s=20
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2069816718990418381?s=20
Open borders, "homelessness," trans, DEI, and other issues appear to have nothing in common, but they do. Each undermines a core pillar of civilization (i.e., law & order, child protection, meritocracy) in the name of compassion. Put them together & you have the end of the West.
Trump says UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer will resign tomorrow, which a populist German politician calls “a sign of decline for establishment parties.” The voter revolt against anti-civilization policies on mass migration, climatism, and trans is just beginning.
.@Keir_Starmer is going forward with his grotesque and immoral transgender experiment on children. He will be remembered for enabling the abuse of minors by grooming gangs and quack medical predators.
Quoting @JamesEsses: 🚨Important Announcement: Puberty Blockers Judicial Review🚨
Following months of radio silence, I’m saddened to report that the government has announced that it is pushing forward with the puberty blockers trial, regardless of the significant ethical concerns raised that led to the temporary pause.
Most troubling of all is that they are now refusing to halt recruitment of children until the end of the Judicial Review that we are bringing.
As such, we have no choice but to seek an emergency injunction to block a single child being recruited and given this poison. There will be a hearing at the end of July to determine this.
Please rest assured that I and the entire team will be pursuing this Judicial Review all the way.
@[private account] - Just as with your predecessor, Wes Streeting, we implore you to do the right thing and pull the plug on this monstrosity of a trial. If you don’t, we will see you in Court.
President Donald Trump is a grave threat to free speech, say Democrats and many in the media. The Justice Department this week indicted former FBI Director James Comey for a second time, charging him with threatening the President over an Instagram post last spring of seashells arranged to read “8647,” which the president described as mob talk for calling for someone to kill him. Federal Communications Commission Chairman Brendan Carr ordered Disney’s ABC unit to file early renewal applications for its eight broadcast licenses, days after Jimmy Kimmel joked that Melania Trump had “the glow of an expectant widow,” a quip that aired three days before a gunman opened fire at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner. Trump has gone after the media before, many note. He sued CBS over the editing of a 60 Minutes interview with Kamala Harris, later amending the claim to $20 billion, and Paramount, CBS’s parent, settled for $16 million last July. The Trump administration froze $2.2 billion in research funding for Harvard. A Trump executive order prohibits federal funds from going to K-12 schools that teach critical race theory or gender ideology. And another directs the Attorney General to coordinate with state and local prosecutors against teachers who facilitate the social transition of minors.
But these objections are rather rich coming from representatives of the same Party whose activists canceled colleagues, oversaw mass online censorship, and endorsed the assassination of their political enemies. The murder of Charlie Kirk last September inspired widespread celebration by progressives on social media. Trump’s latest attempted assassin, Cole Allen, was a radicalized leftist. Fifty-five percent of self-identified left-of-center voters said the murder of President Trump could be justified. Democrats and progressives inside and outside government built a sweeping Censorship Industrial Complex in the United States and Europe that censored millions of Americans for legal speech, including questioning Covid, climate, transgender, and migration policies.
Over decades, leftists drove moderates and conservatives out of the news media and the academy. Today, 60 percent of university faculty are left of center, while only 18 and 17 percent are moderate and right of center, respectively. And where the share of US journalists who identified as Democrats rose from 28 percent to 36 percent between 2013 and 2022, the share who identified as Republicans fell from 7.1 percent to 3.4 percent.
As for federal funding decisions, they are not censorship, and much of what the Trump administration acted against were policies that violated the rights of Asians, whites, and minors. The Supreme Court already ruled in 2023 that Harvard’s race-conscious admissions policies violated the law. Public schools are state actors, and what they teach has always been subject to democratic and legal control. And teachers and administrators who tell children they can and should change their gender are endangering their health and well-being, as the WPATH Files show....
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2050270673797296436?s=20
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative jouralism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2050270673797296436?s=20
The companies building the world’s leading artificial intelligence systems say that their products are politically neutral. Google states that its AI will “seek to avoid unjust impacts on people, particularly those related to sensitive characteristics such as race, ethnicity, gender, nationality, income, sexual orientation, ability, and political or religious belief.” Anthropic, the maker of Claude, claims a 94% “even-handedness” rating for its latest model and says Claude’s goal is to “treat opposing political viewpoints equally.” And OpenAI, the creator of ChatGPT, declared that “ChatGPT shouldn’t have political bias in any direction,” and says its newest models have reduced political bias by 30%.
But their track record tells a different story. In February 2024, Google’s Gemini AI generated images of America’s Founding Fathers as black men and women, depicted racially diverse Nazi soldiers, and created images of a female Pope and Asian Vikings. When users asked Gemini to create images of white people, it refused. The system had been programmed to inject diversity language into prompts, so that a request for a picture of a German soldier in 1943 would produce, as NPR reported, images of nonwhite people in Nazi uniforms.
In response to the controversy, AI leaders took action. Google CEO Sundar Pichai called the results “completely unacceptable” and told employees that the company “got it wrong.” Google paused Gemini’s image generation, pledged structural changes, and promised to relaunch with better guardrails. AI leaders across the industry reasserted their commitment to neutrality. OpenAI published a new framework for evaluating political bias. Anthropic released its own even-handedness metrics.
But they did not correct the bias. Wynton Hall, a senior fellow at the Governmental Accountability Institute and author of the new bestselling book Code Red: The Left, the Right, China, and the Race to Control AI, recently conducted a study using Google Gemini’s most advanced reasoning model, Deep Research. He asked it to evaluate all 100 sitting U.S. senators against Google’s own hate speech policies. The result: seven Republican senators were flagged as violators. Zero Democrats. The AI also hallucinated that Marco Rubio and JD Vance were still senators rather than the Secretary of State and Vice President. The specific “hate speech” violations involved statements about immigration and transgender issues. Senators Tom Cotton, Marsha Blackburn, and Rick Scott all responded publicly.
Multiple peer-reviewed studies have confirmed that most large language models exhibit measurable left-leaning bias, and even liberal users say AI has a liberal bias. While this may seem obvious to many, it is puzzling in that the AI companies have shown themselves to be so sensitive to not being perceived as biased, as the 2024 Google Gemini controversy showed.
Last year, Meta’s AI chatbot falsely implicated conservative activist Robby Starbuck in the January 6 Capitol attack and labeled him a white nationalist, a Holocaust denier, and antisemitic. Starbuck said that Google’s Bard and Gemini chatbots generated at least 22 false statements about him, including fabricated accusations of sexual assault, rape, and a shooting, and even invented fake news articles attributed to real journalists to support the claims.
The implications are significant. AI systems already shape what billions of people see in search results, social media feeds, and news recommendations. As Hall documents, AI is being deployed in government procurement, defense, and education. If these systems treat conservative, libertarian, and traditionally religious viewpoints as forms of “hate speech,” the result will be a powerful and pervasive censorship apparatus, or worse. AI-generated reputation scoring will feed into insurance decisions, mortgage approvals, and even custody determinations.
For example, Starbuck said he received death threats, his children were doxxed, and he could no longer attend public events without security. Multiple insurance companies denied him homeowners, car, and other insurance, telling him only that they considered him a risk. Police arrested a man in Oregon who wanted to kill Starbuck.
Asked to comment on the current situation, Starbuck told Public, “People need to imagine how dangerous this is when AI chatbots are deployed to swing an election, changing the way a few percent of the population vote by convincing them that one candidate is a criminal. Our next president could effectively be decided by biased AI. This is one of the most critical issues of our generation.”
Why is AI still so biased toward the left and against the right?...
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2037259708105728027?s=20
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech, read the rest of the article, and watch the full interview!
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2037259708105728027?s=20
The former Director of the National Counterterrorism Center, Joe Kent, says that the FBI did not properly investigate the assassination last fall of conservative leader Charlie Kirk. “The FBI was pretty forceful in saying we couldn’t investigate further,” he told Public. “I saw no action being taken.”
Tyler Robinson confessed to killing Kirk in a text message and a note to his trans-identified romantic partner. His defense team may now be able to use Kent’s allegations that the government is suppressing evidence and did not do a proper investigation to their advantage.
Kent said he knew that he might be called as a witness before he made his statements that a “foreign nexus” may have been involved in Kirk’s assassination. “I was definitely warned of that over and over again,” said Kent. “If I end up having to play that role, then I’ll do it. It’s not something I’m seeking.”
When pressed that his testimony could help the Robinson defense, Kent said, “Then, honestly, so be it. If it gets us to the truth… That’s obviously the risk I’m taking.”
Neither Robinson’s attorneys nor the prosecuting attorney responded to requests for comment from Public.
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2036462544819269728?s=20
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative reporting, read the full article, and hear the full, on-the-record interview:
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2036462544819269728?s=20
Democrats are moderating in anticipation of the midterm elections, according to many analysts. The New Democrat Coalition, a large center-left bloc of Democrats in the House, urged the party last week to adopt a “more moderate approach” focused on affordability and economic anxiety rather than “splashy populist promises.” Third Way, a center-left think tank, published polling last week showing that 55% of young men want the Democratic Party to become more moderate, while just 30% want it to move further left. In 2024, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez removed the pronouns from her bio. After the 2024 elections, Gavin Newsom criticized trans-identifying men being allowed to compete in women’s sports. And, over the last three days, Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton, in separate events, urged Democrats to moderate on immigration, homelessness, and “virtue signaling.”
But the analysts are wrong. On most of their major issues, Democrats remain wedded to the same agenda that lost them control of the White House in 2024. Clinton invited a trans-identified congressman, Sarah McBride (D-DE), to participate on her panel, “Girls Just Want to Have Fundamental Rights,” at the Munich meeting, despite overwhelming voter opposition to trans-identified males in female sport and trans medicine for minors. Newsom backed away from his criticism of males in female sports shortly after making it, and his hand-picked Attorney General sued the Trump administration to allow it to continue. During the House hearing on a bill to ban males from women’s sports, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said, “Bigoted folks love this bill. Assaulters love this bill.” Obama, in an interview, framed climate change as apocalyptic and proposed green jobs as the solution, which is identical to his framing in 2007, saying “We believe in government as a tool for good, as a potential force to create more jobs, and as a way to make sure that the planet doesn’t roast, to make sure that as we move forward and the economy grows, that everybody and not just some, are benefiting.” As for the New Democrats and Third Way, they have been making the same arguments for the last 20 years, a period during which the Democrats became a radical-Left party.
It’s true that there are some signs of Democrats moderating their agenda. Democratic Governors Abigail Spanberger and Mikie Sherrill, in Virginia and New Jersey, respectively, won office last year running on more moderate agendas. “Spanberger runs what would be considered a more centrist campaign,” noted Obama, “and Mamdani in New York runs an explicitly socialist, grassroots campaign… That can win in New York City. It probably could not win in Virginia. And that’s okay.” He also said, “We’re a nation of laws, we have borders, and we’ve got to figure out an immigration policy that is orderly,” while Clinton said, “It went too far, it’s been disruptive and destabilizing, and it needs to be fixed in a humane way with secure borders.”
And Obama on homelessness said, “We should also recognize that the average person doesn’t want to have to navigate around a tent city in the middle of downtown, and that we’re not going to be able to build a working majority… if we simply say, ‘You know what, it’s not their fault, and so they should be able to do whatever they want.’”
But continuing radicalism overwhelms signs of reform. Obama said in the same interview, “It is an atrocity that in a country that’s wealthy we have people on the streets,” reinforcing the dominant myth on the Left that poverty, not addiction and untreated mental illness, causes “homelessness” and that more subsidized housing will reduce it rather than make it worse, as it has for the last 40 years. Clinton, on a different panel in Munich, scoffed at a Czech politician after he said, “I think what Trump is doing in America is a reaction to policies that really went too far,” pointing to transgenderism.
Both Clinton and Obama addressed only how to carry out mass migration, not whether to do so. This focus on changing words, not policies, is true across the board, with Democrats moderating on rhetoric, not agenda. When Spanberger came into office, she ended the state’s cooperation with ICE and simply framed it as anti-crime rather than pro-migrant. She and Sherrill opted for law enforcement optics, but their agendas are little different from Mamdani’s. Obama, in his interview, gave lip service to free speech, but did not renounce his 2022 call for government censorship of social media platforms.
The lack of moderation also goes for race, where Democrats falsely accuse their opponents of racism for opposing mass migration, racial preferences, de-policing black neighborhoods, and reparations. Governor Newsom vetoed bills that would have established concrete financial reparations for black descendants of slaves, but also approved legislation to spend $6 million to research how to verify descendants of enslaved people so a future government can give them benefits. While Democratic leaders deprioritized racial justice as a standalone platform in favor of universal economic themes, namely affordability, there has been no “Sister Souljah moment” where a leader renounces the party’s left wing, as Bill Clinton famously did in 1992.
All of this could hurt Democrats’ chances of taking back the House and Senate in the fall midterm elections and of running a moderate agenda in 2028. If there was ever a time to moderate, it was in 2025, and it didn’t happen. Voters aren’t reliably liberal. In fact, where 35% of U.S. adults identify as conservative, 33% as moderate, and just 28% as liberal.
“Democrats have little credibility,” sociologist Musa Al-Gharbi told the New York Times last month, “because they have been supporting lots of censorship on everything from insufficiently progressive views on race and gender, to suppressing views on contentious political issues in the name of fighting ‘misinformation’ and more. They and their fellow travelers have spent the past decade lowering standards, defining things like standardized tests as racist (former Rep. Jamaal Bowman famously compared testing to ‘modern day slavery’).”
Political scientist Yascha Monk agreed, noting that “while Democrats may temporarily be de-emphasizing some of the rhetoric that made them so unpopular, most voters do not believe that they have had a real change of heart about wokeness or D.E.I. — much less that they have a coherent set of political ideas to fill the resulting vacuum.”
In January, a Wall Street Journal poll found that even though voters disapproved of Trump on many issues, including the economy, inflation, and immigration, they still favored Congressional Republicans over Democrats on those issues. “In other words,” wrote Thomas Edsall in the Times, “Trump is in hot water on a wide range of issues, but that has failed to translate into Democratic ascendance, signaling continued wariness and distrust of the party.”
Noted another political scientist, “Democrats must de-escalate acrimonious rhetoric, condemn political violence across the country, promote cross-partisan citizen dialogues, town halls, and deliberative forums nationwide, and reframe polarizing media content.” But they haven’t done so.
On the contrary. Fifty-five percent of people who self-identified as left of center told pollsters last year it would be at least somewhat justified to murder Donald Trump, and 48 percent said the same about Elon Musk. And 25 percent of people who describe themselves as “very liberal” and 17 percent of people who describe themselves as “liberal” say that it is sometimes justified to resort to violence to achieve political goals. Only 6 percent of people who describe themselves as “conservative” and 3 percent as “very conservative” said the same. That’s a nearly five-to-one difference.
So why is that? Why haven’t Democratic leaders and politicians sought to moderate their agendas, and not just their language?
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2023415347152359441?s=20
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2023415347152359441?s=20
After the 2024 election, Democrats appeared to be rethinking their radicalism. Americans had rejected the Left agenda on borders, econ., crime, race, trans, and climate. One year later, that’s all changed. Sensing a political advantage, they have returned to their comfort zone.
Quoting @shellenberger: Most of the debate since yesterday has focused, understandably, on whether the ICE agent acted in what he perceived to be self-defense. Whatever the case, it’s clear that, by encouraging people to interfere in law enforcement operations, the Left is getting people killed.