Track Trans Hate
Archive

Archived posts by @shellenberger, 2025

The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.

The profile of Michael Shellenberger

12 posts. Other years

@shellenberger Quote

For years, the media celebrated parents who said their children were “born into the wrong bodies” and thus required puberty blockers, hormones and surgeries to match them to their “innate gender identity.” The assumption by journalists was that children could give informed consent to these medical procedures. The WPATH Files proved that trans medical providers knew this was a lie and that children had no idea what it meant to permanently give up on sexual and reproduction function. So now, advocates of trans medicine are saying they don’t need informed consent but rather “informed assent.” What’s that? According to UK Health Minister @wesstreeting it’s children “repeating back to the clinician what the risks are and why they would want to go through them.” In other words, it’s a test of whether parents have sufficiently brainwashed their children. They’ve simply changed a single word in an effort to make a transparently unethical experiment appear ethical. As such, it is typical of the mendacity that has been at the heart of the trans medical scandal from the beginning. Shame on Streeting for this transparent effort to mislead the public into thinking that this experiment is any less barbaric than it appears. Every day that passes he further undermines his credibility and legacy. Shame on @Keir_Starmer for not having stopped it already. And shame on the UK medical community, including Helen Cass, for having either enabled or remained silent in the face of this crime against humanity. We are our bodies. Telling children that they have a “gender identity” separate from their bodies induces a psychosis that makes them vulnerable to medical predators like Prof. Emily Simonoff, the study leader and professor of child and adolescent psychiatry at King's College London (KCL). Blocking puberty puts children on an escalator to hormones and surgeries, as happened to @[private account] and thousands of others like her.

Quoting @shellenberger: The UK government has approved an experiment to block the puberty of 100+ children to see if it makes them feel better. It won't. A 2015 - 2017 study already found that. And it's unethical to experiment on children, who cannot provide informed consent. Keira Bell @[private account] is a survivor of the trans medical scandal. She is now leading the effort to demand that Health Minister @wesstreeting stop the experiment. Her efforts appear to be working, as Streeting last week said he was uncomfortable with the clinical trial going forward. It is essential that Bell and her allies succeed. Please share this so that @Keir_Starmer and Streeting hear her message loud and clear. Keira Bell: “There’s no excuse for experimenting on children” Survivor of trans medical scandal speaks out against UK government’s unethical puberty blocker study For decades, progressives have emphasized the importance of “intersectionality,” or appreciating how some people are oppressed in multiple ways. And so, for example, black female lesbians are more oppressed than women or black people, according to the Left. As such, special care should be extended to people burdened by multiple forms of repression. And yet it’s hard to see how this logic was in effect when it came to Keira Bell, a black female lesbian in Britain who never received a proper mental health screening before being put on puberty blockers. “When I was 14, I thought I wanted to become a boy,” she said in a new interview with Public. At 16, her doctor referred her to the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) at the Tavistock clinic, which “very quickly prescribed puberty blockers....” Full article and video here: https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2000322078424138056?s=20
C5 harassment child predator institutional capture medical harm mental illness parent abuser
74 replies 640 reposts 20 quotes 2,307 likes 194,274 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 21:35 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 21:35 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Fingerprint
3003bbe352aa47b2980b038112a27cf6526b41177b478aa931a2c528c03d2faa
Permanent address
/#post/2001636816173019620
@shellenberger Reply

Replying to @shellenberger

Doctors will block the puberty of children with “gender incongruence” as part of a medical experiment to determine the impact on their well-being, says the British government. “Right now, there isn’t enough information about the possible benefits or risks that young people with gender incongruence may experience when taking puberty-suppressing hormones,” says King’s College London, which is set to carry out the experiment next year on children ages 10 through 15. “The study will be overseen by independent advisory groups,” adds King’s College, “and will be subject to rigorous regulatory and ethics checks by UK regulators and the Health Research Authority.” If there are indeed ethical and evidence-based “UK regulators” who are in charge of “ethics checks,” they must stop this unethical and dangerous medical experiment on children before it begins. There is already sufficient evidence that puberty blockers cause significant harm to the brain and skeletal system upon which the entire body depends. Ninety percent of the children who receive puberty blockers will go on to use cross sex hormones, which can cause cancer, and many others will receive surgeries that sterilize and deprive them of sexual function. Puberty blockers don’t improve mental health. Data from a gender clinic in Britain that the government shut down because it was causing so much harm, Tavistock, found that more children see their mental health worsen than see it improve. Children are not old enough to give their informed consent for puberty blockers, and they are not medically necessary; the children can receive safe and evidence-based treatments for anxiety, such as family-based cognitive-behavioral therapy, and gender anxiety goes away for the vast majority of children once they go through puberty. Earlier this year, psychiatrist and former Tavistock gender clinic board member, David Bell, argued that the UK law demands that experiments minimize potential interference with a child’s “state of development.” And yet it is with a child’s “state of development” that puberty blockers are meant to interfere. The experiment will not allow the doctors or children to be “double-blind,” or ignorant of whether they are getting the chemical or a placebo. It is easy to imagine how doctors biased toward puberty blockers would treat the children receiving them in ways that might temporarily boost their mental health and distort self-reporting. And it is based on a pseudo-scientific ideology that posits the existence of a non-entity called “gender identity” in children’s brains. And, finally, the UK government already declared puberty blockers to be risky last year, which is why it prevented any doctor, not just those in the NHS, from prescribing them. The UK government says the lack of evidence for puberty blockers is why it must study them, and it was the author of last year’s report on trans medicine, pediatrician Hilary Cass, a Baroness in the House of Lords, who agreed to these experiments. Her review found the evidence for their benefits was weak and the potential for negative effects was unclear. She thus recommended clinical trials, noting that some clinicians, children, and families felt the drugs were beneficial. But the Cass Review also noted that “In 2011, the UK trialled the use of puberty blockers in the ‘early intervention study,” and “Preliminary results from the early intervention study in 2015-2016 did not demonstrate benefit.” By 2020, there was still a “lack of any positive measurable outcomes.” The fact that some families and clinicians said they benefited from puberty blockers is an extremely weak source of evidence for moving forward with these experiments. And there is some evidence that parents play a key role in the relative anxiety of their children. For example, family-based cognitive-behavioral therapy (FCBT) is more effective than Child CBT alone. It is difficult to understand Britain’s proposed unethical experiments on children. Most people in Britain are against allowing doctors to conduct such experiments on children. So why in the world did Baroness Cass recommend clinical trials, and why did the UK government follow through on them? Why is the UK moving forward with this disturbing and unethical agreement? And what will it take to stop them?... Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the full article, and hear the full video! https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1993061847336103942?s=20

Quoting @shellenberger:
C2 false claims hand-coded contagion ideology cult institutional capture medical harm
23 replies 51 reposts 7 quotes 302 likes 24,524 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 21:36 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 21:36 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Fingerprint
b44fe94671e090a3e2683ff1f15a5ce8782634de4ff9bf9de4a4caf86136c343
Permanent address
/#post/1993062687417549174
@shellenberger Reply

Replying to @shellenberger

It’s outrageous that President Donald Trump has threatened to sue the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC), say many in the media. “You have to admire the chutzpah,” wrote one columnist. “Donald Trump describing the BBC as ‘corrupt’ while threatening to take legal action….The man has never been known for his self-awareness, so it’s safe to say the irony has almost certainly passed him by.” But there is no question that BBC employees deliberately manipulated Trump’s remarks on January 6, 2021, to make it sound like he had encouraged violence. An independent outside auditor, Michael Prescott, wrote a major report on the BBC’s bias, which concluded that the BBC had “spliced together two clips” to create “the impression that Trump said something he did not and, in doing so, materially misled viewers.” Americans might think this story doesn’t concern them because it’s about a British media company. Few Americans listen to the BBC. But the story is highly relevant to Americans because US news media companies are guilty of manipulating their coverage of Trump, transgenderism, and race in nearly identical ways as the BBC. And given the BBC’s longstanding reputation as one of the most credible news organizations in the world, Prescott’s independent report has rightly sparked a major international media discussion. Over the weekend, the BBC’s CEO and its Director-General both stepped down. “The Future of the BBC is Now in Doubt,” writes Tim Stanley, an influential columnist, in the Daily Telegraph. Prescott’s report should inspire reform-minded owners of US news media companies to clean up their act. For example, CNN falsely claimed that January 6 was an “insurrection” that resulted in the deaths of five people and did a similarly manipulative edit of Trump’s speech, noted an investigator on X, @MazeMoore. “It may not be technically as bad as what the BBC did,” he noted, “because there was a quick flash transition, but the goal was the same. Make the speech sound worse than it was. Take everything out of context and put it together in an order that makes it sound as bad as possible.” Last year, we criticized CNN and other news media for deliberately twisting the meaning of Trump’s remarks about Liz Cheney for being a war hawk, and Prescott makes the same observation. “Mr. Trump was clearly criticising politicians who readily send US troops to war without thinking about the human cost,” he notes. And yet “the BBC repeatedly pushed this inaccurate version of what Trump said.” Readers of Public are aware that we have been critical of the BBC’s fact-checking program, “BBC Verify.” One purpose of BBC Verify appears to be to label stories with which the BBC disagrees as “misinformation” and thus as something that social media platforms should censor. Last year, the BBC’s Director General, Tim Davie, said, “Disinformation, propaganda, and partial news is [sic] weakening our shared understanding of the world, undermining trust in our institutions and our democratic process,” shortly after the BBC had buried a large package of investigative stories on the problems with giving children and adolescents puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones. BBC’s first “disinformation” reporter, Mariana Spring, apologized in 2023 after she was caught lying on her resume. Spring remains employed at BBC as its “Social Media Investigations Senior Correspondent.” Prescott described how BBC Verify spread misinformation. “BBC audiences were being encouraged to believe Britain’s major insurers were, intentionally or unintentionally, racist and charging high prices to customers based on their ethnicity,” notes Prescott. “The central claim implied causation, (that being an ethnic minority resulted in you being charged more), but the reporting and commentary did not consider other issues that can affect insurance charges.” Adds Prescott, “the entire report was taken down, which I understand is very rare. It had taken six months for the BBC to take decisive action about a story that was not fit for purpose and spread damaging misinformation. As far as I know, no one has ever been disciplined for this hugely embarrassing episode and worrying questions remain.” Another example of the BBC’s bias concerned a major story about doctors causing serious harm to children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults. Readers of Public will recall that in the Spring of last year, we released documents, The WPATH Files, which a whistleblower had given to us. “In March 2024,” writes Prescott, “there was widespread media coverage of leaked documents from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health [WPATH] which raised concerns about the quality of care given to gender-distressed children. It was picked up by the Mail, Economist, Observer, Washington Post, the Times, and others, but not the BBC.” Prescott points out other examples of the BBC's censorship and bias on transgenderism. It refused to cover detransitioners, people who regretted taking hormones or receiving surgeries in an attempt to change their sex or gender. It didn’t cover a major lawsuit by a group of nurses after their hospital allowed a man to use their changing room. And, beyond WPATH, the BBC gave little to no coverage of the trans medical scandal, even though the UK government has banned puberty blockers. By contrast, the BBC produced “a surprisingly high number of stories about drag queens,” celebrated a male wrestler who competed in the women’s category, and published an article last year headlined, “Transgender woman guilty of rape after night out.” Wrote the reporter, “Lexi Secker, 35, of Lowbourne, near Melksham, was living as a man when she attacked a woman in Blunsdon, Wiltshire, on 23 April 2023.” More information about the scandal may come out. Just today, Cath Leng, BBC’s former chief writer, says she was “forced out” in 2023 after 25 years because she was critical of transgender ideology. Prescott identified other areas of bias, including on race and the war in Gaza, all of which pointed to a single significant underlying problem. “My view is that the Executive repeatedly failed to implement measures to resolve highlighted problems, and in many cases simply refused to acknowledge there was an issue at all,” he writes. “Indeed, I would argue that the Executive’s attitude when confronted with evidence of serious and systemic problems is now a systemic problem in itself - meaning the last recourse for action is the Board.” All of this is deeply damaging to the BBC, regardless of whether Trump decides to sue it. “BBC staff have destroyed their own trump card in future negotiations over the licence fee,” writes Stanley at the Daily Telegraph. “The problem is this: in the modern, post-TV world, the licence fee is entirely unjustifiable. The BBC has to explain why, when there’s so much else available, it should be allowed to compel us to pay for it – just when tastes are diverging, national identity is fractured and the quality of the BBC’s output is in doubt…” What, then, explains the BBC’s fall from grace? Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video! https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1988023991353962952?s=20

Quoting @shellenberger:
C1 anti-trans rhetoric coverup denial institutional capture medical harm speech persecution
40 replies 171 reposts 8 quotes 822 likes 45,186 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 21:36 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 21:36 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Wayback Machine
Capture held by the Internet Archive (made by others; we have not checked what it shows)
Fingerprint
63572c5a2ea7e4544bd5084ce5fc732425bc8772df7f947c6df8cb3f5822d6af
Permanent address
/#post/1988024092369580483
@shellenberger Reply

Replying to @shellenberger

The Trump administration is attacking free speech, say the media and Democrats. On Monday, Attorney General Pam Bondi said, “There’s free speech and then there’s hate speech. And there’s no place [for it], especially now, especially after what happened to Charlie.” Fear of the Trump administration led ABC to abandon late-night comedian Jimmy Kimmel yesterday, said progressives. Kimmel had claimed the man who assassinated conservative leader Charlie Kirk was “MAGA.” Brendan Carr, chair of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), which regulates broadcast networks, said, in response, “This is a very, very serious issue right now for Disney [ABC’s owner]. We can do this the easy way or the hard way. These companies can find ways to take action on Kimmel, or there is going to be additional work for the FCC ahead.” However, prominent Trump supporters condemned Bondi’s remarks en masse, near-instantaneously, and she backtracked the next day, saying, “If you want to be a hateful person and simply say hateful things, that is your right to do so.” As for Carr, he dismissed the idea that his words played a significant role in ABC’s decision, telling Public, “the reporting is that Disney itself had their own concerns about the programming. A lot of folks want to point fingers here at convenient targets because they don’t want to see or deal with the broader market trends. Late night ratings are way down.” And yet it is difficult to believe that Carr’s remarks had no influence. It is reasonable to think that Nexstar may have feared that the FCC wouldn’t approve its acquisition of Tegna, which operates 64 stations in 51 markets, if it had allowed Kimmel’s show to continue. That purchase requires the FCC to allow Nexstar to go beyond current limits on broadcast station ownership. And, notes the Journal, Carr’s remarks may have indirectly impacted Disney: “Executives also discussed staff safety, including threatening emails staff on Kimmel’s show had received after Carr’s remarks and the posting of some of their personal information online, the people said.” The FCC repealed the “fairness doctrine” in 1987, since it required too much government regulation of content, and the FCC’s “public interest” power is not a license to police programs like Kimmel. Indeed, the FCC’s mandate today is largely structural with narrow content exceptions (e.g., indecency, children’s programming, and political advertising). As such, Carr’s remarks were “jawboning,” a term that refers to speech or implied threats by government officials to pressure private parties into actions that officials cannot legally mandate. Such jawboning can be a form of indirect censorship. President Biden engaged in similar pressure tactics when he publicly said social media companies were “killing people” by not removing Covid “misinformation.” Biden officials also invoked Section 230 to coerce platforms into greater censorship, and internal Facebook emails revealed that the company was worried about failing to secure a data deal with Europe if it did not comply with the administration’s censorship demands. The Left’s complaints about censorship are made in particularly bad faith, given its role in defending the Biden administration’s coercive jawboning and the resulting mass censorship during Covid. The Left also normalized “cancellations,” calling for countless public figures and private individuals to be deplatformed and fired for causing offense. In 2018, Kimmel mocked Roseanne Barr after ABC canceled her show after she posted an offensive tweet about a black former Obama administration official. The people decrying what Bondi and Carr said are the same ones who demanded sweeping government censorship of social media platforms in the guise of combating “misinformation” and “hate speech” in 2020 and 2021. Consider Barack Obama, who criticized Carr’s remarks. It was Obama’s people at the Department of Homeland Security, FBI, National Science Foundation, DOD, and CIA who put in place the Censorship Industrial Complex between 2016 and 2024. And it was Obama who gave a 2022 speech at Stanford laying out a vision for government “regulation” of social media platforms one week before DHS launched its “Disinformation Governance Board.” The Democrat-supported Censorship Industrial Complex was and remains, in Europe and elsewhere, a far greater threat to free speech than the angry remarks of Trump and Carr, as inappropriate and as unhelpful as they were. The Complex was embedded in the government, including the Intelligence Community, and operated secretly to manipulate information, public opinion, and “whole narratives.” New York Times columnist David French, who criticized the Trump administration for censorship, defended government censorship in the past as “correcting misinformation” and pointed to the First Amendment rights of government employees. It’s important to remember the context we are in. A little over one week has passed since an individual, who appears to be a Left-wing romantic partner of a trans-identified male, assassinated a major conservative leader, Charlie Kirk. Assassination is the ultimate form of censorship. And Kirk was a communications and organizing prodigy who many on the Right viewed as future Republican presidential material. Kirk’s killing comes after 10 years of the Left, broadly defined to include the media, Democrats, and the progressive NGO industry, dehumanizing Republicans. As such, many, if not most, on the Right hold the Left responsible for the killing of one of its most promising leaders, who also happened to be a family man and Christian. When it comes to public opinion, five times more people on the Left justify violence than those on the Right. A YouGov survey conducted after Kirk’s assassination found that 25% of people who describe themselves as “very liberal” and 17% who describe themselves as “liberal” say that it is sometimes justified to resort to violence to achieve political goals. Only 3% of people who describe themselves as “very conservative” and 6% of people who describe themselves as “conservative” said the same thing. A separate poll earlier this year found that 55% of people who identify as left of center say that it would be at least somewhat justified to murder Trump. But it is short-sighted for the Trump administration to do and say things that undermine its ability to demand free speech abroad, and hold the Left accountable at home. The Trump administration has rightly raised the alarm about censorship in Europe and Brazil of American social media platforms, and often of Americans. Carr’s remarks about the “easy way or the hard way” undercut the administration’s free speech diplomacy.... Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video! https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1969124685557481768

Quoting @shellenberger:
C1 anti-trans rhetoric hand-coded denial political enemy
60 replies 115 reposts 15 quotes 590 likes 43,136 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 21:39 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 21:39 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Fingerprint
7bfbcf845cd505d1ad79a21cb1489832c73701dcd6406ef32cdccaaf2597413f
Permanent address
/#post/1969405155906109688
@shellenberger Reply

Replying to @shellenberger

Charlie Kirk either deserved to die or was asking for it, said many on the Left yesterday about the popular 31-year-old conservative leader who was famous for debating college students. “He’s been one of the most divisive — especially divisive — younger figures who is constantly pushing hate speech aimed at certain groups,” said MSNBC political commentator Matthew Dowd, just moments after a sniper shot Kirk in Utah. “You can’t stop with these sort of awful thoughts you have and then saying these awful words and not expect awful actions to take place.” The author of a new Batman comic book spinoff, Gretchen Felker-Martin, posted “Thoughts and prayers you Nazi bitch. Hope the bullet’s okay after touching Charlie Kirk.” And some in the news media referred to Kirk as “far-right." But Kirk was not “far-Right” or a “Nazi,” and he did not spread “hate speech.” Kirk was critical of transgender ideology, the Left’s dishonesty about race and crime, and the message of contemporary feminists. Consistent with his Christianity and his commitment to the American Constitution, Kirk believed that he had the right and a moral obligation to speak unpopular truths, including that it is not possible to change one’s sex, that the rate of crime among black men is disproportionate, and that families provide social stability and fulfillment. Many on the Left expressed upset at Kirk’s assassination, and MSNBC and DC Comics fired Dowd and Felker-Martin. “I apologize for my tone and words,” Dowd said at BlueSky. “Let me be clear, I in no way intended for my comments to blame Kirk for this horrendous attack.” Governor Gavin Newsom immediately condemned the assassination of Kirk, whom Newsom had debated on a podcast earlier this year. Other Democratic politicians did the same. New York Times columnist Ezra Klein wrote about how one could vehemently disagree with Kirk, as he did, and still not believe he should be killed. But the extent to which people on the Left expressed joy at the killing of Kirk nonetheless remains disturbing. Many progressives agree with Dowd that Kirk is responsible for having created the environment that led to his death. Social media is filled with videos of leftists filming themselves openly celebrating Kirk’s murder. Hundreds of thousands of people liked social media posts justifying the assassination. And the mainstream liberal view is that Kirk encouraged political violence by spreading “hate” and “misinformation.” Dowd, in his apology, defended himself by saying, “I was asked a question on the environment we are in,” and apologized for his “tone and words,” not his message, which was that Kirk had contributed to and perhaps birthed the heated atmosphere that led to his killing. “Charlie Kirk isn’t a martyr,” wrote a progressive on X yesterday. “He’s a casualty of the violence he incited.” The post has over 12 million views, 46,000 reposts, and 360,000 likes. But the environment that led to Kirk’s death was created by the Left in its decades-long demonization and dehumanization of conservatives. For 80 years, schools, universities, and the media have used Hitler, Nazism, and fascism as symbols of ultimate evil. To call someone a “Nazi,” “fascist,” or “far-Right,” is therefore to imply that they are part of this evil, and like the historical Nazis, must be eliminated. Over the last 10 years, not just the radical Left but the mainstream news media, including the New York Times, and mainstream Democrats like Newsom, repeatedly characterized Trump and his supporters as Hitler-adjacent fascists. The New Republic openly depicted Trump as Hitler. A recent South Park episode implied that Kirk was a racist and anti-Semitic influence over young people, despite Kirk’s close relationship with influential Jewish conservatives and support for Israel that many on the Right viewed as excessive. This was all part of a deliberate dehumanization campaign. Kirk, Trump, and other conservatives, Democrats argued, are white supremacists and misogynists who “hate” black people and women, who are committing “trans genocide,” and who are destroying “our democracy.” For progressives who truly believe this rhetoric, killing such individuals would be as justified as killing Hitler and his supporters 80 years ago. After all, this act would not only save the lives of black and trans people, but would also save the entire country from an authoritarian fascist dictatorship. The same leftists who had for decades produced studies, books, movies, essays, songs, and poems about how the Nazis dehumanized their enemies dehumanized, without hesitation, MAGA conservatives. They falsely claimed Trump had praised white supremacists in Charlottesville in 2017. And reporters who had for decades covered Trump’s rise to wealth and power in 2016 reported as truth the outlandish conspiracy theory that Trump was a Manchurian candidate controlled by Russian president Vladimir Putin – another alleged Hitler-like fascist. Why did the Left spread so much hatred of Kirk and other conservatives? Why did they engage in so much dehumanization for so long?... Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism and to read the rest of the story. https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1966242372003725793

Quoting @shellenberger:
C1 anti-trans rhetoric hand-coded denial political enemy
225 replies 1,223 reposts 70 quotes 5,608 likes 353,384 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 21:40 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 21:40 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Wayback Machine
Capture held by the Internet Archive (made by others; we have not checked what it shows)
Fingerprint
c2f7f95874454e883530746ccd678f5f60d2c1c71f600f3a9f2b15d0a01c8d1e
Permanent address
/#post/1966249089114464484
@shellenberger Reply

Replying to @shellenberger

All doctors and medical professionals alive today should be prepared to answer the question of why, when the facts had become overwhelming that transgender “medicine” violated the Hippocratic Oath and the principle of informed consent, they didn’t speak out.

C2 false claims hand-coded denial institutional capture medical harm
43 replies 142 reposts 5 quotes 989 likes 32,865 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 22:13 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 22:13 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Fingerprint
ed4d64d5d8ce4d22eb6795d46515024ebf48c157711c8c34909ec923ac55f3bd
Permanent address
/#post/1938229912126533914
@shellenberger Post

Operating on the bodies of children so they look like the opposite sex is the future, said the media. It wasn’t. It’s increasingly the past. And it won’t come back, not even in CA. Historians will struggle to understand trans medicine alongside bloodletting, lobotomies & Tuskegee

C3 dehumanizing medical harm
289 replies 3,278 reposts 126 quotes 14,964 likes 307,480 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 22:13 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 22:13 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Wayback Machine
Capture held by the Internet Archive (made by others; we have not checked what it shows)
Fingerprint
9bb60ca1159a0f018895ba295b79bd779acf17c2218ea520c41e94049fc90b50
Permanent address
/#post/1938170146477965793
@shellenberger Quote

Allowing surgeons to operate on the healthy bodies of children in an effort to change their gender is liberation, say the media. It’s not. It’s barbarism. In fact, it’s one of the worst medical scandals in history. Happily the Supreme Court has upheld the right of states to ban it. Every state now should and if they won’t, Congress should. The court cited a crucial piece of video evidence (below) from the WPATH files proving that the doctors involved in this horror show know kids and their parents have no idea what they are getting themselves into. Read the WPATH Files below to see for yourself why Congress and/or the states should ban pseudoscientific trans “medicine” for children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults.

Quoting @shellenberger: THE WPATH FILES Advocates of gender-affirming care say it’s evidence-based. But now, newly released internal files from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) prove that the practice of transgender medicine is neither scientific nor medical. American Medical Association, The Endocrine Society, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and thousands of doctors worldwide rely on WPATH. It is considered the leading global authority on gender medicine. And yet WPATH’s internal files, which include written discussions and a video, reveal that its members know they are creating victims and not getting “informed consent.” Victims include a 10-year-old girl, a 13-year-old developmentally delayed adolescent, and individuals suffering from schizophrenia and other serious mental illnesses. The injuries described in the WPATH Files include sterilization, loss of sexual function, liver tumors, and death. WPATH members indicate repeatedly that they know that many children and their parents don’t understand the effects that puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries will have on their bodies. And yet, they continue to perform and advocate for gender medicine. The WPATH Files prove that gender medicine is comprised of unregulated and pseudoscientific experiments on children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults. It will go down as one of the worst medical scandals in history. https://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/wpath-files
C3 dehumanizing institutional capture medical harm
164 replies 1,898 reposts 71 quotes 8,467 likes 497,469 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 22:13 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 22:13 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Fingerprint
ea3c593c0053b8faabcb0ef58e88b58a7f5777d9537417d946eac95e1dab5589
Permanent address
/#post/1935405597295341856
@shellenberger Reply

Replying to @shellenberger

Democrats are today feeling more confident. President Donald Trump’s approval rating has fallen from the low fifties to somewhere between 43 and 44 percent — “a significant decline,” said longtime political analyst Ruy Teixeira, in a conversation with me today. “Democrats are licking their chops about a lot of the things that have gone wrong” for Trump. But, Teixeira says, Democrats have little reason to feel secure. The Democrats’ Senate Leader, Chuck Schumer, has a 17% favorable and 44% unfavorable rating, according to a new CNN poll. By comparison, Trump’s decline “was not cataclysmic,” noted Teixeira. “Moreover, at the same time as Trump’s approval rating has gone down, the approval ratings of the Democratic Party among young voters are absolutely through the floor.” Teixeira doesn’t downplay the president’s challenge. “He’s lost altitude among Hispanics, young people, and even to some extent working-class people. He’s definitely not in the spot he was after the election.” People agree “we need to cut the government, but don’t understand why we’re cutting what we’re cutting and how it’s all going to work out.” And, he noted, “people don’t feel any better about what Trump is doing than they felt about what the Biden administration was doing…Trump has lost tremendous altitude among young voters, including Gen Z.” But, Teixeira added, “That doesn’t mean they like the Democrats now,” and indeed Democrats rightly “feel consternation” at the loss of Gen-Z and minorities. Young people “don’t see their future in what Democrats seem to stand for.” In the past, Democrats appealed to dissatisfied young men who today “are not doing well mentally and physically.” The problem is that “they don’t see themselves as toxic and toxic masculinity is a trope in Democratic circles.” And while Gen-Z women are “more liberal than their male counterparts, even young women moved significantly in the direction of Trump, and are “not happy with the Democrats.” “We're seeing very significant evidence with Gen Z that they are, on average, more conservative,” explained Teixeira, “both in party ID and positions, than the millennials before them. And this has caused much consternation in Democratic circles. It certainly hasn't escaped their notice that young men in particular are acting like they're not with the program.” And yet, said Teixeira, Democrats are showing little willingness to question party dogma on all the issues the public has rejected them on, including gender, climate, and the border. “A good example is the Abundance book by [New York Times columnist] Ezra Klein and [Atlantic Magazine writer] Derek Thompson,” he said. “If you scratch the surface, they’re really interested in a socially liberal ecotopia,” Teixeira explained. “This isn’t what normie working-class voters want. They want a lot of energy, period. Cheap energy. Reliable energy. They want a dynamic fast-growing economy where there is a lot of upward mobility. It’s not at all clear that the goal of ramping up renewable energy is consistent with that.” Same story on mass migration. “While there is some more talk about border security among Democrats,” he said, “you don't see a lot of Democrats getting up and saying, ‘I think it's a good thing that Trump really closed down the border. We needed that. We need a reset for immigration policy… Maybe some of the people being deported deserve to be deported… But obviously Democratic attention has quickly shifted to Kilmar Abrego Garcia and various cases that are more or less dicey depending on how you look at them.” And the same is true for gender ideology. “You have this unscientific concept of ‘gender identity’ that is an innate characteristic but somehow biological sex isn’t? It makes no sense,” Teixeira said. “‘Somebody who's 12 years old should have access to all the gender affirming ‘care’ they want.’ None of this makes sense. None of this is scientific. But it becomes part of the blob, part of the Omni-Cause. ‘If you're for trans rights, you're for a rapid green transition, if you're for a rapid green transition, you're for mostly open borders.’” As a result, the Democrats’ behaviors are self-defeating. Their approach hasn’t been to deal with the reasons for their political unpopularity and rethink their agenda, but rather to short-sightedly grab on to any way of criticizing President Trump. The Democrats plainly want to regain power. Why then won’t they deal with the cause of their unpopularity? Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning reporting, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video! https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1918039147975196948

Quoting @shellenberger:
C1 anti-trans rhetoric hand-coded ideology cult political enemy
31 replies 28 reposts 3 quotes 261 likes 42,454 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 22:17 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 22:17 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Fingerprint
e7ad85b3401f99785d9c9dd09f18534f75122aadb8bb3a05fc6382995a67fa5e
Permanent address
/#post/1918060512048456084
@shellenberger Reply

Replying to @shellenberger

Now @GavinNewsom do the right thing and stop trans medical barbarism. 71% of the public opposes it

C3 dehumanizing hand-coded medical harm
38 replies 55 reposts 1 quotes 640 likes 36,458 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 22:20 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 22:20 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Fingerprint
dd40b751e5ba5dfb9a72e44dba54c2604dff93e04a97fb32f57f3f6ad13c0e57
Permanent address
/#post/1897664395783618806
@shellenberger Quote

Gavin Newsom has come out against allowing boys and men in girls' and women's sports. Finally. The preference cascade against trans madness is accelerating.

Quoting @shellenberger: Democrats appeared to fiercely resist President Donald Trump’s agenda during his address last night to Congress. They dressed in pink to symbolize “power and protest.” They held up signs that said “False,” “No King,” and “Musk Steals.” And at least one was evicted by security guards for refusing to sit down and stay quiet. But viewers of the spectacle left the evening without any clear idea of what Democrats were defending. Some said the pink outfits symbolized the defense of women, but why then had Senate Democrats voted unanimously just one day earlier to allow boys and men to compete in girls’ and women’s sports? The accusation of Trump as King, or dictator, or Hitler, etc, was also hard to take seriously, given that he won the popular vote three months ago and has a popularity rating 15 points higher than that of Democrats. And the Democrats’ heckling was risible given their condemnation just a few years ago of Republican members of Congress who had done the same to Democratic presidents. Nonetheless, Democrats likely scored points with the public. Some Democrats held up signs defending Medicaid, which is popular with voters, including swing voters and Republicans, and which some Republicans in Congress wish to cut. And Democrats have tapped into genuine anxieties over the potential impact of Trump’s agenda on women, his alleged authoritarianism, and the role of Musk. But the Democrats’ messaging on even their core issues was confusing and all over the place. The problem isn’t simply that they can’t decide whether to frame Trump as a liar, authoritarian, or cruel. It’s that they have lodged those accusations against him for eight years, voters still elected him president, and he hasn’t done anything to change their minds since taking office. The flip side of the same problem is that Democrats haven’t presented a positive agenda of their own that might define them as a better alternative to Trump and the Republicans. Most of the protests by Democrats, including their eviction from the speech last night, signified the lack of a core vision, values, and agenda for America. Little surprise then that 76% of viewers of Trump’s speech told CBS News’s pollsters that they approved of what they heard. “We’re becoming the metaphorical car alarms that nobody pays attention to,” wrote US Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania on X a few hours ago. In fact, the situation for Democrats is even worse than that. Not so long ago they said climate catastrophe was inevitable if they didn’t get hundreds of billions in taxpayer money to subsidize green energy. Now, Democrats are quiet about the large cuts to green energy subsidies and the abandonment of ESG policies by the world’s largest energy companies. Every Senate Democrat voted to allow boys and men to compete in girls’ and women’s sports, and yet no member of Congress last night held up signs saying “Transwomen Are Women”; many others had long since removed their pronouns from the X bios. And where during Trump’s first term in office, progressive leaders, including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, histrionically accused the president of grave human rights violations for his immigration policy, Democrats did not denounce the decline in border crossings last month to their lowest level in 25 years, thanks to Trump’s crackdown. The Democrats’ symbolically thin protests on some issues and their silence on others leave the impression that the party has few core convictions and is driven by vacuous emotionalism. If green energy investments are necessary to prevent the apocalypse, why didn’t a single Democrat wave a sign about climate change? If Trump’s insistence that there are only two sexes and that nobody is born into the wrong body is wrong, then why aren’t Democrats accusing him of encouraging trans suicides or even trans genocide? And if Trump is the white supremacist and racist Democrats have long said he is, why aren’t they defending the DEI programs Trump has eliminated? The obvious answer to all of these questions is that the Democrats’ positions on transgenderism, climate change, and DEI are wildly unpopular and only becoming more so as new evidence emerges. Nearly 80% of respondents to a New York Times poll last month said they supported a ban on males in female sports. The Department of Justice is investigating the misuse of a $27 billion climate program managed by the Environmental Protection Agency. “It appears the billions didn’t revitalize anything,” noted the Free Press, “except the coffers of a range of environmental nonprofits associated with former Obama and Biden administration officials.” And in the weeks since Trump signed executive orders against DEI, journalists have reported that the Department of Education, Department of Justice, and Department of Defense had allocated hundreds of millions for divisive, racially segregationist DEI trainings and initiatives. But that raises the question of why Democrats aren’t putting forward an original agenda. The two most high-profile efforts to propose an alternative agenda for Democrats came from center-left Substacker Matthew Yglesias and center-left think tank Third Way. But both of them simply recommended abandoning unpopular Democrat Party agenda items, including transgenderism, climate extremism, and DEI, to make Democrats appear more like Republicans. Neither offered anything new for Democrats to embrace other than a weak imitation of positions already embraced by Trump. The result is a kind of Democrat nihilism, where the party seems to stand for nothing and to be against Trump and Republicans for incoherent and emotional reasons. Why is that? Why have Democrats failed to create a coherent vision, agenda, and message? If you're not already a subscriber, please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the story, and watch the rest of the video! https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1897436254410526847
C3 dehumanizing denial mental illness women sports
1,044 replies 629 reposts 166 quotes 5,091 likes 1,081,477 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 22:20 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 22:20 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Wayback Machine
Capture held by the Internet Archive (made by others; we have not checked what it shows)
Fingerprint
d33933d204d6e8a062d59f7174efaba5af2d80925fdfa1e51c202be0d4209b5e
Permanent address
/#post/1897662468022755438
@shellenberger Reply

Replying to @shellenberger

Democrats appeared to fiercely resist President Donald Trump’s agenda during his address last night to Congress. They dressed in pink to symbolize “power and protest.” They held up signs that said “False,” “No King,” and “Musk Steals.” And at least one was evicted by security guards for refusing to sit down and stay quiet. But viewers of the spectacle left the evening without any clear idea of what Democrats were defending. Some said the pink outfits symbolized the defense of women, but why then had Senate Democrats voted unanimously just one day earlier to allow boys and men to compete in girls’ and women’s sports? The accusation of Trump as King, or dictator, or Hitler, etc, was also hard to take seriously, given that he won the popular vote three months ago and has a popularity rating 15 points higher than that of Democrats. And the Democrats’ heckling was risible given their condemnation just a few years ago of Republican members of Congress who had done the same to Democratic presidents. Nonetheless, Democrats likely scored points with the public. Some Democrats held up signs defending Medicaid, which is popular with voters, including swing voters and Republicans, and which some Republicans in Congress wish to cut. And Democrats have tapped into genuine anxieties over the potential impact of Trump’s agenda on women, his alleged authoritarianism, and the role of Musk. But the Democrats’ messaging on even their core issues was confusing and all over the place. The problem isn’t simply that they can’t decide whether to frame Trump as a liar, authoritarian, or cruel. It’s that they have lodged those accusations against him for eight years, voters still elected him president, and he hasn’t done anything to change their minds since taking office. The flip side of the same problem is that Democrats haven’t presented a positive agenda of their own that might define them as a better alternative to Trump and the Republicans. Most of the protests by Democrats, including their eviction from the speech last night, signified the lack of a core vision, values, and agenda for America. Little surprise then that 76% of viewers of Trump’s speech told CBS News’s pollsters that they approved of what they heard. “We’re becoming the metaphorical car alarms that nobody pays attention to,” wrote US Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania on X a few hours ago. In fact, the situation for Democrats is even worse than that. Not so long ago they said climate catastrophe was inevitable if they didn’t get hundreds of billions in taxpayer money to subsidize green energy. Now, Democrats are quiet about the large cuts to green energy subsidies and the abandonment of ESG policies by the world’s largest energy companies. Every Senate Democrat voted to allow boys and men to compete in girls’ and women’s sports, and yet no member of Congress last night held up signs saying “Transwomen Are Women”; many others had long since removed their pronouns from the X bios. And where during Trump’s first term in office, progressive leaders, including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, histrionically accused the president of grave human rights violations for his immigration policy, Democrats did not denounce the decline in border crossings last month to their lowest level in 25 years, thanks to Trump’s crackdown. The Democrats’ symbolically thin protests on some issues and their silence on others leave the impression that the party has few core convictions and is driven by vacuous emotionalism. If green energy investments are necessary to prevent the apocalypse, why didn’t a single Democrat wave a sign about climate change? If Trump’s insistence that there are only two sexes and that nobody is born into the wrong body is wrong, then why aren’t Democrats accusing him of encouraging trans suicides or even trans genocide? And if Trump is the white supremacist and racist Democrats have long said he is, why aren’t they defending the DEI programs Trump has eliminated? The obvious answer to all of these questions is that the Democrats’ positions on transgenderism, climate change, and DEI are wildly unpopular and only becoming more so as new evidence emerges. Nearly 80% of respondents to a New York Times poll last month said they supported a ban on males in female sports. The Department of Justice is investigating the misuse of a $27 billion climate program managed by the Environmental Protection Agency. “It appears the billions didn’t revitalize anything,” noted the Free Press, “except the coffers of a range of environmental nonprofits associated with former Obama and Biden administration officials.” And in the weeks since Trump signed executive orders against DEI, journalists have reported that the Department of Education, Department of Justice, and Department of Defense had allocated hundreds of millions for divisive, racially segregationist DEI trainings and initiatives. But that raises the question of why Democrats aren’t putting forward an original agenda. The two most high-profile efforts to propose an alternative agenda for Democrats came from center-left Substacker Matthew Yglesias and center-left think tank Third Way. But both of them simply recommended abandoning unpopular Democrat Party agenda items, including transgenderism, climate extremism, and DEI, to make Democrats appear more like Republicans. Neither offered anything new for Democrats to embrace other than a weak imitation of positions already embraced by Trump. The result is a kind of Democrat nihilism, where the party seems to stand for nothing and to be against Trump and Republicans for incoherent and emotional reasons. Why is that? Why have Democrats failed to create a coherent vision, agenda, and message? If you're not already a subscriber, please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the story, and watch the rest of the video! https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1897436254410526847

Quoting @shellenberger:
C1 anti-trans rhetoric hand-coded political enemy women sports
119 replies 500 reposts 42 quotes 2,764 likes 488,066 views Open on X
First collected
2026-10-29 22:20 UTC
Last seen on X
2026-10-29 22:20 UTC
Added to this archive
2026-11-11
Fingerprint
8e2a45217913e402896ff6817a42927865c3278c14b704db2d71bb816534de48
Permanent address
/#post/1897436761820946438