The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Democrats’ War On “Weird" Exposes Party's Authoritarian Turn
Liberals have lost sight of the difference between "strange" and "harmful"
Who are the weird ones? (Opening ceremony to the Olympics.)
You may have noticed that Democrats have been successfully labeling various statements and positions by Republicans in general and Vice Presidential candidate JD Vance in particular as “weird.” In response, Republicans have pointed out all the things about the Democrats that are weird. If both parties agree on anything, it’s that being weird is bad.
But that’s surprising because until recently, it seemed like Democrats and liberals were all about celebrating weirdness, which is really just another word for “strange,” or being a nonconformist.
For over a quarter century, the liberal city of Austin has had “Keep Austin Weird” as its unofficial and then official slogan. And Apple’s “Think Different” advertising campaign remains iconic for celebrating society’s nonconforming rebels, all of whom were somewhat weird and some of whom were very weird.
Celebrating weirdness has been at the center of liberal pop culture for decades. The liberal TV show Portlandia gently teased but also celebrated the weirdness of Portland. Hugely popular movies, from Breakfast Club to School of Rock and Booksmart, are all about recognizing the importance of strange and weird characters and showing how they really aren’t so strange and weird after all.
The chorus of one of the best songs of the 1990s is “Creep” by the uber-liberal band Radiohead: “I’m a creep, I’m a weirdo / What the hell am I doing here?/I don’t belong here.” The hero of most teen dramas isn’t the popular kid; it’s the weird kid who refuses to conform and even goes on to save the world.
Now, it’s true that most people fantasize more about being cultural rebels than actually being rebels. We love watching movies about nonconformists, but most of us don’t want to be nonconformists. The social consequences are simply too high. We might alienate family, friends, and colleagues.
But for seven decades since World War II, the Democrats have been the party most open to the weird and nonconformist, and it’s been the Republicans who have been the party of normality and conformity. Conservative culture traditionally doesn’t celebrate weirdness; it mostly celebrates order and conformity, from making your bed and going to work to getting married and raising children.
The problem for Democrats is that they have lost the ability to distinguish between what’s weird and what’s harmful. The problem with the trans movement is that it’s harmful, not simply that it’s weird. Giving drugs and performing surgeries to children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults in an effort to change their sex isn’t just weird, it’s harmful. And enabling addicts and the untreated mentally ill to camp, use drugs, and die on sidewalks isn’t just weird, it’s harmful.
Worse, when anyone criticizes Democrats for hurting people, whether on trans, homeless, or other issues, they turn around and accuse their critics of being weird for being concerned.
Today, Democrats are labeling things weird in the same way that some conservative Republicans have labeled things “deviant” since the 1950s. But calling something deviant or weird is simply points out that it is outside the norm, not why it’s wrong.
Consider that the Democrats’ main line of attack on JD Vance is for his statements in support of people having children. And yet his policies to financially incentivize parents to have children are hugely popular, including with Democrats, and thus, by definition, not weird at all.
As such, Democrats are making a fundamentally authoritarian attack on Republicans. In calling Republicans weird, Democrats are emphasizing not that they think Republican policies hurt women, children, and the environment, which is the traditional Democratic message, but rather that Republicans are outside the norm. Republicans like Vance, Democrats are saying, hold fringe, deviant, and strange views.
And it’s proven to be an extremely powerful line of attack, leaving Republicans to protest that Democrats are even weirder than they are, thereby accepting the Democrats’ framing of Republicans as weird and weirdness as bad.
So what’s going on here, exactly? How did Democrats go from being the party of nonconforming, rule-breaking, and weirdness to the party of conformity, rule-following, and enforcing norms in the blink of an eye? And why does the accusation appear to be working when, in so many other situations, weirdness sells?
You may have noticed that Democrats have been successfully labeling various statements and positions by Republicans in general and Vice Presidential candidate JD Vance in particular as “weird.” In response, Republicans have pointed out all the things about the Democrats that are weird. If both parties agree on anything, it’s that being weird is bad.
But that’s surprising because until recently, it seemed like Democrats and liberals were all about celebrating weirdness, which is really just another word for “strange,” or being a nonconformist.
For over a quarter century, the liberal city of Austin has had “Keep Austin Weird” as its unofficial and then official slogan. And Apple’s “Think Different” advertising campaign remains iconic for celebrating society’s nonconforming rebels, all of whom were somewhat weird and some of whom were very weird.
Celebrating weirdness has been at the center of liberal pop culture for decades. The liberal TV show Portlandia gently teased but also celebrated the weirdness of Portland. Hugely popular movies, from Breakfast Club to School of Rock and Booksmart, are all about recognizing the importance of strange and weird characters and showing how they really aren’t so strange and weird after all.
The chorus of one of the best songs of the 1990s is “Creep” by the uber-liberal band Radiohead: “I’m a creep, I’m a weirdo / What the hell am I doing here?/I don’t belong here.” The hero of most teen dramas isn’t the popular kid; it’s the weird kid who refuses to conform and even goes on to save the world.
Now, it’s true that most people fantasize more about being cultural rebels than actually being rebels. We love watching movies about nonconformists, but most of us don’t want to be nonconformists. The social consequences are simply too high. We might alienate family, friends, and colleagues.
But for seven decades since World War II, the Democrats have been the party most open to the weird and nonconformist, and it’s been the Republicans who have been the party of normality and conformity. Conservative culture traditionally doesn’t celebrate weirdness; it mostly celebrates order and conformity, from making your bed and going to work to getting married and raising children.
The problem for Democrats is that they have lost the ability to distinguish between what’s weird and what’s harmful. The problem with the trans movement is that it’s harmful, not simply that it’s weird. Giving drugs and performing surgeries to children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults in an effort to change their sex isn’t just weird, it’s harmful. And enabling addicts and the untreated mentally ill to camp, use drugs, and die on sidewalks isn’t just weird, it’s harmful.
Worse, when anyone criticizes Democrats for hurting people, whether on trans, homeless, or other issues, they turn around and accuse their critics of being weird for being concerned.
Today, Democrats are labeling things weird in the same way that some conservative Republicans have labeled things “deviant” since the 1950s. But calling something deviant or weird is simply points out that it is outside the norm, not why it’s wrong.
Consider that the Democrats’ main line of attack on JD Vance is for his statements in support of people having children. And yet his policies to financially incentivize parents to have children are hugely popular, including with Democrats, and thus, by definition, not weird at all.
As such, Democrats are making a fundamentally authoritarian attack on Republicans. In calling Republicans weird, Democrats are emphasizing not that they think Republican policies hurt women, children, and the environment, which is the traditional Democratic message, but rather that Republicans are outside the norm. Republicans like Vance, Democrats are saying, hold fringe, deviant, and strange views.
And it’s proven to be an extremely powerful line of attack, leaving Republicans to protest that Democrats are even weirder than they are, thereby accepting the Democrats’ framing of Republicans as weird and weirdness as bad.
So what’s going on here, exactly? How did Democrats go from being the party of nonconforming, rule-breaking, and weirdness to the party of conformity, rule-following, and enforcing norms in the blink of an eye? And why does the accusation appear to be working when, in so many other situations, weirdness sells?
If you’re not a subscriber to Public already, please subscribe now to support our award-winning reporting, watch the rest of this video, and read the rest of this article!
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1818399106517418038
Vance is on the same side as most European governments.
@KamalaHarris and @GavinNewsom want:
- doctors and surgeons to be allowed to experiment on children’s bodies;
- teachers to promote gender ideology;
- schools to secretly trans children and adolescents.
Quoting @shellenberger: I’m afraid I have some terrible news. The governor of America’s largest and richest state has just signed a law that puts 10 million children and adolescents in grave danger of medical mistreatment.
The media headlines have it wrong. They claim that California Governor Gavin Newsom’s new law protects children by stopping public schools from outing their new gender to their parents.
It does just the opposite. It makes children vulnerable to irreversible and lifelong medical abuse and mistreatment. And it is all based on the pseudoscientific idea that some children are born into the wrong bodies and that we can change a person’s sex through drugs and surgery.
For any of this to make sense, you have to understand what’s happening in Britain. Several years ago, the government appointed a well-respected pediatrician named Hillary Cass to investigate whether it was ethical to block the puberty of children, give them opposite-sex hormones, and perform surgeries on their bodies to make them feel better about their gender. Dr. Cass came back a few weeks ago and said no, absolutely not.
Around the same time, the British government banned puberty blockers nationwide. And, just a few days ago, the new Labor Party government affirmed that it would maintain the former government’s ban.
In her report, Cass said that the so-called “social transition,” whereby a child adopts the identity of the opposite sex, is not a neutral act and has psychological consequences. This means it is the first step toward medical intervention.
What Gavin Newsom has done is actively prevented schools from informing parents that their children have been put on a medical pathway.
This is an outrageous attack on the rights of children and parents. Children have a right to go through puberty. No adult should be able to block their puberty. And parents have a right to know if their child thinks that they are the opposite sex or were born into the wrong body.
We have seen with leaked internal documents of the leading gender medicine group, WPATH, that these medical interventions, namely puberty blockers, hormones, and surgery, are not only irreversible but result in sterilization and loss of sexual function.
Children or adolescents are simply not mature enough to understand the effects of so-called “gender-affirming care.” They cannot, in other words, give their informed consent.
The new law creates the grave risk that activist teachers, students, and outside groups will convince their children that they were born into the wrong body, and hide their “social transition” from parents, which will lead to harmful medical mistreatment.
As such, the law that Newsom just signed is the opposite of what both children and their parents need. We need schools to immediately warn parents if their children think they are the opposite sex.
After all, this is a diagnosable psychiatric condition known as “gender dysphoria.” And if your child has a psychiatric disorder, whether anxiety, depression, an eating disorder, or gender dysphoria, you have a right to know.
And schools must stop teaching children, or allowing other people to teach children, the pseudoscientific and dehumanizing ideas that it’s possible to be born into the wrong body and possible to change one’s sex.
As such, either the legislature, the courts, or a ballot initiative will be required to nullify Newsom’s law. Until then, it is important to spread the word to parents that California public schools are fundamentally unsafe for the millions of children who attend them.
.@GavinNewsom says his new law will protect parents’ rights. He’s lying. Gavin’s law will require schools to hide a dangerous psychiatric disorder from parents. He’s spreading disinformation to cover up his cowardly failure to protect kids from radical trans activists.
.@GavinNewsom says his new law will protect parents’ rights. He’s lying. Gavin’s law will require schools to hide a dangerous psychiatric disorder from parents. He’s spreading disinformation to cover up his cowardly failure to protect kids from radical trans activists.
Quoting @GovPressOffice: Careful out there.
No one is immune from spreading disinformation.
Get the facts —> https://x.com/govpressoffice/status/1813369590799618465?s=46&t=u5nGIYda7QJd4wcGLJVBHQ
For years, leading medical organizations, the mainstream news media, and Democratic politicians have argued that surgeons should be able to operate on the bodies of minors who identify as transgender. They argued that it would be immoral to prevent adolescents from removing and modifying body parts so they resemble those of the opposite sex. Indeed, they claimed, doing so could end up causing them to commit suicide.
Sure, some of those young people might regret it later, acknowledged The New York Times’s Lydia Polgren in an extended essay last December. But she said, “We allow children to make irreversible decisions about their lives all the time,” and “sometimes they regret those decisions.” Wrote Polgren, “how is it different, really, from the decision I made to quit competitive swimming?”
Gender medicine doctors, therapists, and activists have described such surgeries as part of a “gender journey.”
The Biden administration’s Department of Justice recently indicted whistleblower Eithan Haim, a surgeon at Texas Children’s Hospital, who leaked documents showing that the hospital was secretly performing trangender medical treatments on minors.
And a US Department of Health and Human Services fact sheet on “Gender-Affirming Care and Young People” promotes “gender-affirming care” including “surgery on genitals or reproductive organs.” At the same time, supporters of such procedures insist that they are too rare to be very worried about.
But now the Biden administration has abruptly reversed its position and come out against so-called “gender-affirming surgeries” for minors.
“The Biden administration said this week that it opposed gender-affirming surgery for minors,” wrote the New York Times.
This is far from a total victory for opponents of gender medical mistreatment for children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults. The Biden administration “expressed opposition only to surgeries for minors, not other treatments,” noted the Times. As a result, the Biden administration still supports allowing doctors to block the puberty of children and give adolescents opposite-sex hormones.
Even so, the White House’s reversal is hugely significant. After all, it comes less than a week after it came to light that staff members working for Admiral Rachel Levine, assistant secretary for health at the US Department of Health and Human Services, had in 2021 successfully pressured the World Professional Association of Transgender Health (WPATH) to remove age limits for breast and genital surgeries on minors.
And the reversal comes one month after the UK’s National Health Service banned the prescription of puberty blockers to children and adolescents confused about their gender, both in government hospitals and clinics as well as in private ones. Sweden, too, has banned puberty blockers for children and adolescents.
As such, the trend against gender mistreatment is clear. It is only a matter of time before other Democratic officials will be forced to abandon their unethical support for surgeries, puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones for minors and join the UK, Sweden, and Republican-led states in banning them for children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults.
Achieving that goal will take significant work in the months and years to come, to be sure. Surgeons, doctors, and therapists will cause irreversible damage to thousands of children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults in the meantime by sterilizing them and destroying their sexual function.
If we are to shorten the period between now and then, we need to understand why the Biden administration reversed course and why the tide is turning against gender medical mistreatment across the West.
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism and to read the rest of the article!
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1807089427845439869
Michael Patrick Leahy: "A Judge Doesn't Have The Right To Force Me To Do Something Unconstitutional"
Tennessee journalist faces jail for publishing quotes from the leaked writings of a mentally ill, trans-identified school shooter
One of the most famous moments in American journalism occurred in 1971 when The New York Times and The Washington Post published excerpts of what would be known as “The Pentagon Papers.” Daniel Ellsberg, a Defense Department analyst working for the RAND Corporation, had given the two newspapers top-secret documents. They showed not only that the US was losing the war in Vietnam but that the Pentagon had known the US couldn’t win the war for many years and kept fighting it anyway.
The Pentagon had tried to prevent the publication of the documents, but the Supreme Court ruled that the First Amendment protected newspapers' right to publish them, even though Ellsberg had broken the law by leaking them.
Thanks to the Twitter Files, we learned that individuals with links to US military and intelligence organizations have tried for years to convince reporters that they should no longer follow the Pentagon Papers principle, ostensibly since doing so could help foreign adversaries. They used this argument at the same moment that they were attempting to “pre-bunk” the Hunter Biden laptop, months before The New York Post published articles about its existence.
Now, a judge in Tennesse may violate the Supreme Court’s famous Pentagon Papers ruling and order a reporter in Nashville named @michaelpleahy to reveal the source of documents leaked to him. The leaked documents in question came from a trans-identified woman named Audrey Hale, who killed six people at a Christian school last year.
Today, June 17, Leahy, the editor of The Tennessee Star, will appear in court for what is known as a "show cause hearing." The judge will consider his arguments for why Leahy should not be held in contempt of court for having published excerpts from Hale’s writings.
The FBI had blocked the release of the documents, ostensibly fearing copycat killings by a "segment of the population more vulnerable or open to conspiracy theories." Someone leaked them to Leahy anyway, and he published articles that quoted from them.
The case is important for anyone who cares about free speech, a free press, and the Pentagon Papers principle. Leahy’s attorney filed an emergency motion last week, arguing that the Judge’s order would violate the First Amendment and Tennesee state law.
Leahy’s attorney also filed an emergency motion with the appellate court, but it has not yet responded to the motion. The Nashville police department is investigating several officers accused of leaking the documents. Leahy says he will go to jail before revealing his source. We spoke by phone yesterday.
To hear the full interview, please click below!
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1802683299720012246
Yesterday, the British government doubled down on its ban on puberty blockers for children confused about their gender. Earlier this year, the government banned the use of puberty-blocking drugs in the National Health Service. Yesterday, it banned their use in private clinics as well, at least until the fall when a new government will come to power.
Europe, in general, is cracking down on so-called transgender medicine in the face of widespread evidence of medical mistreatment of children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults.
Over the next several months and years, Democrats and progressives will have to address the rapidly growing body of evidence that gender medicine is, in the words of the Times of London, a center-left newspaper, “quack medicine.”
It will also be important for journalists to engage in some self-reflection. Why did they fail to cover this medical scandal properly? Why did journalists who believe themselves committed to science and caring for the vulnerable cheer on “quack medicine.”
To answer those questions, I want to closely examine a fascinating 2022 podcast between MSNBC host @[private account] and a gender medicine doctor named Dr. Izzy Lowell.
Hayes opens by lambasting Republicans.
Hayes: It's been fascinating, not to mention kind of disturbing, even horrifying, to watch the priorities of the Republican Party post-January 6th… They are criminalizing what's come to be known as gender-affirming care for trans youth.
Hayes went on to explain that the people who are concerned about transgender medicine are bigots who dehumanize trans people.
Hayes: There's this sort of long and gross obsession in mainstream culture and among folks who are not trans with like, you know, the specifics of the biology of trans folks, you know, like what exactly is, is, is happening physically with trans folks and there's this kind of Fetishistic and gross and, and, and dehumanizing aspect to that.
At the same time, Hayes said it was okay for people to want to know more about transgender medicine.
Hayes: There is also this sort of real question about like, what does this healthcare mean? And what does it look like? And what do you say to people who raise objections to it? Sometimes who don't sound like bigoted monsters. They sound like people with maybe good faith objections or, or worries about, uh, the hands that children will be in, in terms of, in terms of making decisions about their bodies.
And so Hayes interviewed a gender medicine doctor named Izzy Lowell.
Hayes: Dr. Lowell is a family medicine physician at a place called QueerMed, uh, that Dr. Lowell founded, which specializes in transgender medicine and treats trans patients in Alabama and across the Southeast and a lot of places where their healthcare is now under assault.
Hayes: And Dr. Lowell, it's great to have you in the program.
Lowell: Chris, thanks so much. It's really an honor to be here. I'm Dr. Izzy Lowell. My pronouns are she and her.
Lowell said she saw a rapid rise in demand for her services.
Lowell: I started a gender clinic at Emory in about 2015. And at first it was, there weren't very many people there, and then word sort of spread, and it became very popular, and people were traveling from all over the Southeast to see me.
Then, a few minutes into the podcast, Hayes asks about the evidence that the growing number of children who think that they're the opposite sex is a social contagion.
Hayes: One of the stories that people, particularly on the right, but not exclusively on the right, have told about the development of trans rights and trans equality is that this is essentially a kind of like a fad or a sort of cultural fashion that's like seizing the minds of young people who like want to fit in and I just wonder if you could talk about that.
Lowell responded by giving examples of trans people supposedly denied health care.
Lowell: I had a patient who reported that when, when they called our office, we were the 11th provider they had called that morning, and nobody else would agree to treat them. And this is in the Atlanta area. For patients in rural locations, there are just zero options.
But you see, Lowell never answered Hayes' question, so they moved on to something else. Hayes asked whether young kids can really decide whether they're the opposite sex.
Hayes: What are those consultations like? I mean, I think to the extent that people, again, I'm trying to sort of speak to an audience that I know is out there because they're in my inbox, who I think consider themselves enlightened and open-minded people, but have some anxiety or worries about the decision making of children, which I think is not crazy, but I just to talk through like what that actual conversation and consultation is like when you're talking about 10 year olds or 11 year olds and the choice to go on on puberty blockers or begin cross hormone therapy.
Lowell also says that she does a very thorough diagnosis.
Lowell: It's a long consultation that initially we go through their whole medical history, their whole gender history, and in terms of making it the diagnosis, quote unquote, even though it's not a medical problem
There, Lowell appears to recognize the glaring contradiction at the heart of so called gender medicine. On the one hand, gender medicine advocates say trans kids are healthy and normal kids. On the other hand, they're demanding that their transgenderism be medically treated with drugs and surgeries. Lowell tries to dismiss this contradiction.
Lowell: In medicine, we like to diagnose everything, even if it's normal. So we, quote-unquote, diagnose gender dysphoria, which is the medical term for that, for the discomfort of being in the wrong gender.
Lowell makes it sound like she has a rigorous process before giving out drugs. However, in a different interview with PBS, she admits that she doesn't even require a letter from a psychotherapist.
Lowell: In my practice, it's not an absolute requirement that teens have a letter from a therapist affirming that they do meet the diagnostic criteria for hormones...
Its like a David Cronenberg movie:
"GenderGP had prescribed testosterone for the teenager — a trans boy, referred to in court papers only as 'J' — who was involved in a legal case with close family over his treatment.
"The expert endocrinologist concluded that the level of testosterone in the youngster’s blood was 'dangerously high', placing them 'at risk of sudden death due to thromboembolic disease.' She said that she had “never before [in her 20 years in the field] seen such a massive dose of testosterone administered to a young person."
"The Times also spoke to transgender people trying to seek treatment from GenderGP. They were appalled to discover that the online clinic, which they trusted as the experts in transgender medicine, was using artificial intelligence to influence their course of treatment."
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/64287217-b742-4bb5-b941-b540a3337a07?shareToken=7744d3c5fe281416bfea4c0051833676
Gender medicine is deadly quack medicine
"The new ban was announced as a doctor running an offshore gender clinic, who was criticised in a government-commissioned review of gender identity services, defended the use of puberty blockers and hormones on transgender children, describing them as 'ideal care.'"
"Helen Webberley, in her first in-depth comments since the review by Hilary Cass, called puberty blockers “safe and life-saving”....
"Last month the High Court heard how Webberley’s online clinic, GenderGP, prescribed 'dangerously high' levels of hormones that could have resulted in the sudden death of a teenager.""
☠️
THIS IS SCARY
Yesterday, a group of people in Scotland protested a new hate speech law. "The irony of this hateful, spiteful law coming into play on April's Fools Day..." said one of the protesters. "Criminalizing free speech in this country is absolutely disgraceful."
While I was happy to see the protest, I am deeply alarmed that the Scottish government passed the law in the first place. @JK_Rowling rightly wrote on X that the law gives the government the power to arrest people who refuse to call male rapists and murderers “women” and “she” and “her” if that’s what those men demand.
The Hate Crime and Public Order Act of 2021 creates a new crime for "stirring up hatred," including related to trans identity. People can be arrested for things they say in the privacy of their own home. They can be arrested for simply being "insulting." And prosecutors need only prove your stirring up of hatred was "likely" not "intended."
You might think this all has nothing to do with you. You don’t live in Scotland. But it has everything to do with you. What you say online could be held as criminal hate speech in Scotland, simply by somebody reading it there.
And it’s not just Scotland. In the US, pro-censorship forces hope a Supreme Court victory will let them once again ramp up censorship demands by the Department of Homeland Security and the FBI.
EU officials are putting in place a sweeping online censorship system that far exceeds in power and scope anything attempted under Communism or fascism.
And last week, European political leaders weaponized their intelligence and security agencies in order to smear everyone from German farmers to conservative politicians as “Russia-linked.”
And yet the United States and EU governments pump far more money than Russia into “non-governmental” organizations like the Institute for Strategic Dialogue, the Aspen Institute, and the Atlantic Council to wage influence campaigns aimed at smearing ordinary farmers and truckers as “Russian-linked” and “far-right,” and influencing elections.
To understand how ridiculous and totalitarian the EU’s focus on “foreign manipulation” is, consider the fact that, during the Cold War, the US government’s Central Intelligence Agency not only allowed Americans to read Soviet newspapers but actually translated them into English and sent them to thousands of libraries across the United States.
Just think about it: do Europeans really need Russians, “Russia-linked” individuals, or “individuals echoing Moscow” to be angry about high energy prices and uncontrolled immigration? The entire “Russia influence” narrative coming from European politicians and intelligence agencies rests upon the monstrous insult that Europeans would be compliant were it not for Russians sowing discontent.
This is an old political trick: characterize your enemies as foreigners. It’s also a trick of totalitarians.
What’s driving all of this? Part of it is that EU politicians are trying to influence the June elections by demonizing their political opponents as puppets of Russia.
But another part of it appears to be driven by genuine hatred. Just listen to Scotland First Minister @HumzaYousaf condemning the Scottish government on racial terms. “Why are we so surprised by the most senior positions in Scotland filled by those who are white?" he said. "Lord President — white. Every high court judge — white!”
Humza suggests that the reason for all of this is because Scottish people are racist. But the real reason is that 95% of Scottish people are white. The fact that Humza, a nonwhite Muslim, is the highest-ranking Scottish politician is a sign of how non-racist the Scottish people are. For Humza to reach the top political job in Scotland and insist that the reason he’s so rare is because the Scottish people are racist is itself hateful, and pathological.
The bad news is that the censors are on the offensive and we are on the defensive. In the US, Europe, Scotland, Germany, Ireland, Canada, and Brazil, an alliance of government agencies, government-funded think tanks, and corporate media are demanding more censorship, whether through laws like the one enacted in Scotland or through executive actions by agencies like the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and FBI.
The good news is we are starting to find our footing. We have been proud to publish investigations that have uncovered government disinformation and censorship demands in Germany, the Czech Republic, Ireland, Canada, and Brazil.
These investigations reveal the same cast of characters, including intelligence and security agencies, mainstream news media, and ostensibly “non-governmental” organizations that happen to be heavily funded by governments.
As importantly, we can expose the hatred behind the hate speech policies, and continue to point out that the solution to hate speech is free speech, not censorship. The way to counter hate is to do what Darryl Davis did, which was persuade KKK members to see him as a human being, and to give up their white robes.
Davis will be the first person to tell you that he couldn’t have done his work with censorship, only with freedom of speech.
There’s much we need to do...
Bullying, Cowardice, And Careerism Behind BBC Disinformation On Gender
Current and former BBC journalists condemn the British media giant for corruption of language and failing to safeguard children and vulnerable adults
by @shellenberger
Tim Davie (left) Director-General of BBC (Getty Images)
The highest purpose of the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) is to “Pursue the truth with no agenda,” said its Director-General, Tim Davie, last week. BBC would do this “by reporting fearlessly and fairly.” In his speech, “A BBC For the Future,” Davie added that “Disinformation, propaganda, and partial news is [sic] weakening our shared understanding of the world, undermining trust in our institutions and our democratic process.”
To combat this disinformation, the BBC launched a special initiative, “BBC Verify,” last year. Last week, the BBC released a 9-page report to reporters that required a “careful and accurate use of language” regarding gender.
But according to current and former BBC journalists, the BBC itself is spreading disinformation, failing to pursue the truth without regard to any agenda, and behaving fearfully and unfairly on issues relating to transgenderism.
Three days before Davie gave his speech, The Times of London reportedthat BBC had buried a large package of investigative stories on the problems with giving children and adolescents puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones in an effort to change their sex or gender. Former BBC journalist Hannah Barnes said, “The BBC didn’t really back our work at all.”
It’s true that BBC ran part of Barnes’s article. She told the Times that it “wasn’t blocked.” Barnes went on to write a book, Time To Think, based in part on her reporting, which started at BBC. And in 2020, the BBC, after facing criticism, stopped working with a transgender advocacy group.
But Barnes told the Times, “There’s a really big difference [between running a story and properly projecting it].” Her documentary films “weren’t promoted across the BBC. It wasn’t like Panorama. You didn’t hear it on the news bulletins. You didn’t see it on the Six or the Ten [O’Clock News].”
And BBC buried a major part of her story, said Barnes. She had learned that the medical director of Britain’s main gender clinic, Tavistock, had “failed to mention a number of safeguarding concerns raised by [gender clinic] Gids staff in a review he had published of the service.”
The Times of London described Barnes’ scoop as “a turning point in the story: a revelation that prompted the Care Quality Commission (CQC) to conduct its own review, in which Gids would ultimately be rated ‘inadequate.’” The Times reported that none of it ran. Said Barnes, “It wasn’t anywhere on the BBC. The online piece was so buried that even though I had written it, I couldn’t find it.”
And two years after distancing itself from one trans activist group, in 2022, BBC gave seed funding directly to another group, “All About Trans.”
In response to our questions, a BBC spokesperson told Public, “The BBC is committed to reporting all stories impartially, in accordance with its publicly available editorial guidelines.” The BBC spokesperson referred us to BBC editorial guidelines, an article in Dateline about the 9-page reporting guide, and the transcript of testimony given by Davie and two other BBC executives to a parliamentary committee.”
For years, the BBC’s decision to refer to trans-identified men as “women” has inspired controversy. In 2022, BBC changed the pronouns of a trans-identified male attacker. The Times of London reported at the time that “The woman referred to her alleged rapist as ‘him’ but [BBC] insiders said that her words were changed to avoid ‘misgendering’ the abuser in an article on the corporation’s website.” BBC has, on several other occasions, referred to male rapists and male sexual predators of children using female pronouns
A male suspect of child pornography mis-identified by BBC as a woman.📷
The BBC Style guide requires BBC employees to use female pronouns with “a person born male who lives as a female… We generally use the term and pronoun preferred by the person in question unless there are editorial reasons not to do so.”
Barnes isn’t the only former BBC reporter to level concerns at BBC for bias. “The BBC is telling its journalists to lie about a person’s sex under almost all circumstances if the person requests it,” wrote Cath Walton, who worked at BBC for 25 years before leaving in 2023.
“How is a presenter or reporter to explain why there is a controversy at all about trans-identified men in, say, women’s sports or prisons if they are unable to say that they are male?” Walton asked. “It should be a requirement, not a punishable offense.”
And now, yet another BBC journalist has decided to speak out publicly and has even agreed to record a podcast interview, below...
The report notes that trans activists have stifled debate, undermined science, and inserted themselves in between parents and children in the name of preventing discrimination:
— "In France, as abroad, it appears that the scientific and medical debate on the subject is tense. Under the cover of the necessary fight against discrimination and for the rights of minorities, certain associations attempt to impose in national and international bodies the principle of the self-determination of the child, to the detriment of parental authority and quality scientific evidence."
Trans quack medicine is the greatest medical mistreatment scandal in recorded human history. Worse than lobotomies. Worse than Tuskegee.
https://x.com/shellenberger/status/1764799914918490287?s=20
Quoting @shellenberger: THE WPATH FILES
Advocates of gender-affirming care say it’s evidence-based.
But now, newly released internal files from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) prove that the practice of transgender medicine is neither scientific nor medical.
American Medical Association, The Endocrine Society, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and thousands of doctors worldwide rely on WPATH. It is considered the leading global authority on gender medicine.
And yet WPATH’s internal files, which include written discussions and a video, reveal that its members know they are creating victims and not getting “informed consent.”
Victims include a 10-year-old girl, a 13-year-old developmentally delayed adolescent, and individuals suffering from schizophrenia and other serious mental illnesses.
The injuries described in the WPATH Files include sterilization, loss of sexual function, liver tumors, and death.
WPATH members indicate repeatedly that they know that many children and their parents don’t understand the effects that puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries will have on their bodies. And yet, they continue to perform and advocate for gender medicine.
The WPATH Files prove that gender medicine is comprised of unregulated and pseudoscientific experiments on children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults. It will go down as one of the worst medical scandals in history.
https://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/wpath-files
The New York Times, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and other major institutions promoted WPATH after it removed age limits for genital surgeries.
A psychopathological trans cult has taken over key Western institutions. They can no longer be trusted.
WPATH President, Marci Bowers, can be seen in the video below falsely telling CBS News, "Face the Nation," that "WPATH standards of care are... science-based guidelines."
In the video, you can see other trans quack doctors making false claims:
"This repellent experiment — in which girls who like trucks or little boys who dress as princesses, and who invariably grow up to be gay, are corralled inexorably down a road towards life-changing treatments — belongs in the book of medical disgraces. As do the cheerleaders who raised money for [trans activist group] Mermaids and those who persecuted whistleblowers or damned journalists asking questions as transphobic.
"In 50 years, chemically freezing the puberty of healthy children with troubled minds will be regarded with the same horrified fascination as lobotomies — which, never forget, won the Portuguese neurologist Antonio Egas Moniz the 1949 Nobel prize."
— @[private account]
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/one-day-well-look-back-on-era-of-puberty-blockers-with-horror-07b36ldf7
"Quack Medicine"
Citing WPATH Files, The Times of London denounces "gender-affirming care"
Well, somebody had to say it. All the better that it’s one of the most respected newspapers in the world.
The prescription of puberty blockers to children is “Quack Medicine,” thunders The Times of London, one of the most influential center-left newspapers in the West:
"In the Western world at least, it is normal for new treatments to undergo rigorous testing before being accepted into mainstream medicine. Often, the complaint from those who might benefit from therapies is that approval takes too long. This excess of caution may be frustrating for those who need help but far worse would be a system in which patients became guinea pigs in unregulated mass experiments with potentially life-altering and irremediable consequences. Such is the case with puberty blockers, which for years have been fed to children in this country who are confused about their identity and sexuality."
The editorial accompanies a long news story and a column by Janice Turner. “One day, we’ll look back on the era of puberty blockers with horror,” Turner writes. “This shocking chapter in medical history, where the ideological objectives of trans rights campaigners trumped the welfare of disturbed children, is coming to an end worldwide.”
Turner cites the WPATH Files as evidence. “Leaks from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, the body which formulates guidance on “trans healthcare,” reveal doctors perplexed at how they should explain to an 11-year-old child that drugs will render them infertile.”...
The End Of The Transgender Craze Is Near
The backlash against “gender-affirming care” and trans-identified males in women’s sports and prisons is accelerating
by @shellenberger & @[private account]
Sir Keir Starmer, leader of the Labour Party, on February 18, 2024 (left) J.K Rowling (center) on December 19, 2023; collegiate swimmer Riley Gaines on Joe Rogan, March 7, 2024
To support "gender-affirming care” is to be on the right side of history, millions believe. To be pro-transition is basically the same as being pro-gay, they believe. Whether one is attracted to people of the same sex or believes oneself to be of the opposite sex, it’s just how people are born. Trans people, including children and vulnerable adults, deserve medical care so they can assume their correct gender and deserve to compete in the sports competitions of their preferred sex.
But it’s quickly becoming apparent that “gender medicine” is on the wrong side of history.
Last week, millions of people read stories at X, the Washington Post, the Economist, the Telegraph, and even the Guardian about internal files of the leading transgender health organization, the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), showing widespread medical mistreatment of children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults.
And yesterday, the UK government’s National Health Service England (NHSE) announced that it was halting the prescription of puberty blockers in government hospitals.
Of course, most Americans haven’t heard of the WPATH Files or the UK government’s decision. And the UK government will still allow puberty blockers in private clinics, and some people in Europe had already anticipated this decision.
But the UK’s decision was far stronger than had been expected. “It’s bombastic for sure,” Dr. Erica Anderson, a former President of WPATH,” told Public. “Everyone was expecting severe limits. Total ban? No.”
About 5,000 children and adolescents are on the waiting list to get into a UK gender clinic. Now, it’s likely that just a handful will receive puberty blockers.
And puberty blockers aren’t the obvious first thing one would expect the UK government to ban. Far more controversial are genital surgeries on minors, which are irreversible, resulting in sterilization, and likely also cause a significant, if not total, loss of sexual function or hormones.
And because over 90% of children put on puberty blockers continue with “transition,” a ban on puberty blockers will strictly limit hormones and surgery for youth. Some adults will continue to use radical medical interventions, but the effective ban on them for young people is likely to reduce the number from tens of thousands to a few hundred.
As such, the decision by the UK government to issue far more sweeping restrictions suggests the existence of a stronger cross-party consensus within the UK government than the glitzy pro-transition PR of recent years had suggested. There is a sense in which, after years of irresponsible healthcare teenagers having a wild party, drugging kids, and experimenting on their bodies, the adults have come home and started to impose order.
Before the backlash against gender medicine was the backlash against putting transwomen/natal males in women’s prisons. Around the world, men who are caught committing crimes, including violent and sexual ones, are using “gender self-identification” to claim that they are actually women and demand to be put in women’s prisons. Many Americans are unaware that this is even occurring, much less that it brought down the Scottish government in mid-February of last year, just two weeks after its Prime Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, said she had nothing to apologize for.
In terms of trans policies that cause real-world harm, women’s sports are also still an issue. Yet here, too, the backlash against natal males in female sports is gaining momentum. Former college swimming champion Riley Gaines has a new book out and is on the warpath. On Joe Rogan, Gaines told the story of how, despite having tied transwoman/natal male swimmer, Lia Thomas, the NCAA decided, on the stop, to give the one trophy to Thomas.
And the leader of the British Labour Party, Keir Starmer, said on Monday that “common sense has to prevail in terms of safety and integrity of sport” and that biological males should thus not be allowed to participate in women’s sports. Starmer pointed to the fact that some elite sports leagues, including athletics, swimming, and cycling, have already banned transwomen/natal men from competing in women’s leagues.
As such, it’s only a matter of time for liberal-minded Americans and Democrats to hear about the changes in Europe and start to impose reforms. That may happen as early as this year if Republicans turn gender medicine and boys and men in girls and women's sports into political issues. But even if it doesn’t happen this year, it will happen soon. Every day brings more writing on the wall....
Advocates of gender medicine, gender self-ID, and natal male participation in female sports say they're on the right side of history, but they're not. Governments are rolling all of them back. As such, it's increasingly clear that the end of the transgender craze is near.
Biden Should Follow UK Government Lead And Ban Puberty Blockers
Today, Britain’s National Health Service rejected the medicalization of gender distress, setting an example for the world
by @[private account] & @shellenberger
President Joe Biden speaks during a campaign event on March 8, 2024 in Pennsylvania. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
American medical organizations, liberal journalists, and Democratic politicians say all young people have an innate gender identity that may not match their biological sex. Some of these young people, they say, experience gender dysphoria and require puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries to resolve their unease. Without these crucial medical treatments, doctors and academics claim, children and adolescents are likely to commit suicide.
But today, the National Health Service (NHS) England confirmed that children will no longer be prescribed puberty blockers at gender identity clinics and that their only allowed use in the UK will be in scientific research trials. The announcement followed an independent review commissioned by NHS England, which found a lack of long-term evidence for children given puberty blockers.
This decision comes one week after the release of internal communications from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH). The WPATH Files revealed that doctors and therapists involved in “gender medicine” are aware that puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and genital surgeries have life-altering consequences to which children and adolescents cannot consent.
Efforts to protect children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults from pseudoscientific medical interventions are far from over. Most US medical organizations still support the use of puberty blockers for children experiencing gender distress. And in the US, President Joe Biden has repeatedly defended puberty blockers, drugs, and surgeries for children as “medically necessary health care.”
In 2022, Biden signed an executive order that called on the Department of Health and Human Services and the Department of Education to expand access to “gender-affirming care” and fight states that have sought to limit puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries.
But the decision by the UK government, after years of research, has put wind in the sails of advocates for non-medical treatments of gender distress.
"Now's the time for President Biden, Congress, or the FDA to follow the UK and ban puberty blockers for children," said Dr. Carrie Mendoza, a medical doctor and US Director for Genspect. "The UK and the rest of Europe are far ahead of us, but the science is the same. Children cannot consent to blocking their puberty. Being allowed to grow up is a fundamental human right."...
Journalist @benryanwriter has caught Marci Bowers, the president of the world's leading transgender medical organization falsely accusing him of misrepresenting her:
"On Sunday, I shared with her and WPATH leadership over email a detailed account of the contents of my New York Sun article draft... she emailed me back to falsely accuse me of misrepresenting her words.... As you can see, Dr. Bowers, who is a gender-affirming surgeon, does indeed consider gender-transition treatment and surgery to be a virtual panacea for mental-health concerns..."
This is not the end of the historic medical mistreatment scandal known as "gender-affirming care," but it's the beginning of the end.
The trance is broken. The trans house of cards to collapsing. And its collapse will continue to accelerate.
Here's Barnes' finale, in which she makes clear that trans activists the greatest enemy of good health and medical care for vulnerable people:
"There is a battle raging over how best to care for children and young people struggling with their gender identity, with ever-increasing numbers of European countries choosing to take a more cautious, less medical approach after finding the evidence base underpinning those treatments to be wanting.
"NHS England insists that new services will operate in accordance with recommendations of the independent Cass review, and that it is well placed to develop policies “in line with clinical evidence and expertise”. But it won’t be easy. There is already discussion among professionals working in gender services planning a pushback against Cass’s as yet unpublished final recommendations.
"It was difficult for [gender clinic] Gids [at Tavistock hospital] to stand up to external pressures, allowing the care it offered to suffer. At the same time, NHS England failed in its duty to provide proper oversight. Both they and those in charge of the new services must do better if they are to avoid the mistakes of the past. Without proper, evidence-based guidance on what good practice looks like, organisations like WPATH will continue to have influence."
After we published the WPATH Files, trans activists falsely claimed they weren't relevant to the UK. Former BBC reporter @[private account] demolishes their disinformation @guardian
"The views of WPATH matter to the UK. For years, the organisation and its SOC have been cited as a source of 'best practice' for trans healthcare by numerous medical bodies, including the British Medical Association and the General Medical Council—and still are. The Royal College of Psychiatrists refers to WPATH in its own recommendations for care."
In the fall of 2022, Jon Stewart had an argument with the Attorney General of Arkansas about that state’s ban on using drugs and surgeries in an effort to change the gender of children and adolescents.
“You’re suggesting that protecting children means overriding the recommendations of the American Medical Association, the American Association of Pediatrics, and the Endocrine Society,” said Stewart.
And he was right: those major medical organizations had indeed endorsed what’s called gender-affirming care.
But the attorney general of Arkansas was also right when she said there was never sufficient evidence for them to do so.
It’s true that gender dysphoria and gender distress are indeed serious psychological and psychiatric problems.
But there has long been strong evidence that other things, including autism, anxiety, and just being gay, are being misdiagnosed by children, parents, therapists, and doctors as gender dysphoria.
And now there are the newly released internal discussions from the World Professional Association of Transgender Health, known as WPATH.
They show that trans activists aggressively pressure doctors and therapists for the medicalization of gender dysphoria with drugs and surgeries before first attempting to address autism, anxiety, and other psychiatric disorders.
The question now turns to why the American Medical Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and the Endocrine Society advocated drugs and surgery for gender distress despite the lack of evidence.
There’s a short and a longer answer to that question....
There's nothing scandalous about the WPATH Files, say supporters of the organization. It's just doctors and therapists engaged in professional conversations about how to provide the best available care.
But anyone who bothers to actually read the WPATH Files will see that there's nothing professional and everything scandalous about them.
The WPATH Files show surgeons, therapists, and trans activists raising concerns about, but also opposing, any obstacle to drugs and surgeries for children and vulnerable adults diagnosed with gender dysphoria.
What is being described isn't just unprofessional. It's profoundly unethical and, in some cases, likely illegal.
On the X Spaces below, everyone agrees that we need to provide the best available care to children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults experiencing gender dysphoria or distress.
But it's clear puberty blockers, hormones, and genital surgeries are the worst form of care, not the best. And yet, they're the first and only form of care that WPATH members are offering.
On the Spaces call below, Jamie Reed @JamieWhistle confirmed that in her 10 years working in a gender clinic, she and her colleagues never turned down a patient seeking drugs and surgery, aka "gender-affirming care."
A medical doctor who fought the opioid epidemic, Dr. Carrie Mendoza @[private account] , said professional doctors do not talk like surgeons, therapists, and activists in the WPATH Files.
In the WPATH Files, you see trans activists demanding no barriers or "gatekeeping" getting in the way of giving drugs and surgeries to vulnerable children and adults.
Mendoza suggests it would be like having pharmaceutical salespeople in the room where doctors discuss treatment, urging them to prescribe more oxycontin.
What's happening is madness. Gender ideologues are misdiagnosing anxiety, autism, and being gay as gender dysphoria and prescribing pseudoscientific sex conversion therapy consisting of irreversible surgeries and lifelong medicalization
We all went along with this it because of the culture of caring and the culture of fear.
The culture of caring meant people confused caring with pure affirmation and no gatekeeping.
The culture of fear meant that trans activists sought to destroy the careers and lives of the people who really cared and urged caution.
But things have been changing. Europe is changing. Nations there are reassessing the evidence and increasingly not allowing drugs or surgeries for children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults.
The media is changing. Major new exposes have appeared everywhere, from the Times of London to the New York Times to News Nation, blowing the whistle on the continuing medical mistreatment scandal of "gender medicine."
And now there are the WPATH Files, which are 170 pages of evidence that what's happening is neither medicine nor scientific.
This medical mistreatment will end. The only question now is how many more people it hurts before it does so.
The way forward is demanding honesty and accountability from governments and medical institutions.
There's nothing professional or normal about what's in the WPATH Files. Rather, they expose a shocking scandal and signify the beginning of its end.
Last year, the mother of a transgender reality TV star, Jazz Jennings, triggered a controversy after she described waking Jazz up in the middle of the night to address medical complications from genital surgery.
I was shocked by the clip but didn’t think much about it afterward. In truth, I didn’t want to think more about it.
But then someone gave me internal discussion files of an organization called WPATH, which stands for the World Professional Association for Transgender Health. We released those files, all 170 pages, yesterday.
What they show is the widespread medical mistreatment of children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults. They show that WPATH members and gender medicine practitioners aren’t getting informed consent from their patients.
That appears to be the case with Jazz Jennings, who was not old enough to understand the implications not only of becoming sterile but also of never being able to have an orgasm.
As such, trans isn’t what many of us thought it was...
For decades, advocates of gender-affirming care said it was based on science. It wasn't. And now we have the newly leaked internal files of the main transgender medicine to prove it. Excellent @[private account] @NewsNation
THE WPATH FILES
Advocates of gender-affirming care say it’s evidence-based.
But now, newly released internal files from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) prove that the practice of transgender medicine is neither scientific nor medical.
American Medical Association, The Endocrine Society, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and thousands of doctors worldwide rely on WPATH. It is considered the leading global authority on gender medicine.
And yet WPATH’s internal files, which include written discussions and a video, reveal that its members know they are creating victims and not getting “informed consent.”
Victims include a 10-year-old girl, a 13-year-old developmentally delayed adolescent, and individuals suffering from schizophrenia and other serious mental illnesses.
The injuries described in the WPATH Files include sterilization, loss of sexual function, liver tumors, and death.
WPATH members indicate repeatedly that they know that many children and their parents don’t understand the effects that puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries will have on their bodies. And yet, they continue to perform and advocate for gender medicine.
The WPATH Files prove that gender medicine is comprised of unregulated and pseudoscientific experiments on children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults. It will go down as one of the worst medical scandals in history.
https://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/wpath-files