The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
“Harvard gets worst score ever in FIRE’s College Free Speech Rankings”
•From 2019 to this year, Harvard sanctioned four scholars, three of whom it terminated.
•In 2020, Harvard revoked conservative student activist Kyle Kashuv’s acceptance over comments he made on social media as a 16-year-old, for which he had since apologized.
•In 2022, Harvard disinvited feminist philosopher Devin Buckley from an English department colloquium on campus over her views on gender and trans issues.
•In 2019, Harvard was the site of a substantial event disruption when protesters interrupted a joint talk featuring former Harvard President Lawrence S. Bacow and Graduate School of Education Dean Bridget Terry Long by occupying the stage and refusing to leave.
https://www.thefire.org/news/harvard-gets-worst-score-ever-fires-college-free-speech-rankings
Why This One Simple Chart Will End Wokeism
By describing the psychopathological characteristics of extremist movements, we will reduce their power
by @shellenberger & @peterboghossian
Over the last few years, Woke progressives have behaved in increasingly odd ways. Black Lives Matter activists in Washington, D.C., screamed at and hovered over a woman sitting peacefully in a restaurant, demanding that she raise her fist in a salute. Climate activists threw soup at a Van Gough painting, dumped milk on the floor of a grocery store, and cemented their hands to an airport runway. And transgender activists claimed, falsely, that there was a “genocide” against trans people, even though there’s no evidence that trans-identified people are being killed at higher rates than non-trans people.
Some of these behaviors can be explained by the fact that Wokeism is a religion. Two years ago, the two of us published a chart, “Woke Religion: A Taxonomy,” and an accompanying essay, which described how race, climate, trans, and other Woke activists had created their own versions of original sin, taboos, and myths. We turned the taxonomy into a poster and sold hundreds of copies. Both of us still get emails from people saying that the chart helped them to understand why so many previously secular people appear to be in the grip of a deeply superstitious religion.
But over the last year, the two of us felt that something was missing. Wokeism is a religion, but its religious nature didn’t necessarily describe the madness that seemed to grip its most devoted adherents. Many people believe crazy things but don’t behave so narcissistically or psychopathically, without regards for other people, in the way that Woke activists do. And so we decided to create a new taxonomy, one focused on Woke psychopathology.
“Woke Psychopathology: A Taxonomy” is inspired by the traits that characterize what the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic Statistical Manual (DSM-V) calls “Cluster B personality disorders.” There are four of these personality disorders: narcissistic, anti-social (previously psychopathy), histrionic, and borderline. The traits, which run horizontally across the top of the Taxonomy, are Attention-Seeking, Grandiosity, Emotional Dysregulation, Excess of Empathy, Victimhood Ideology, Impaired Reality Testing, Lack of Empathy, and Splitting. Together, the traits form an easy-to-remember acronym: AGE-EVILS.
Along the horizontal axis are the three major categories of Wokeism: Race, Climate, and Trans. Inside each of the 24 boxes formed by the 3x8 grid are descriptions and examples of these traits. The result is striking. Attention-Seeking explains not only throwing soup on paintings but also Jussie Smollett’s hoaxed lynching and Dylan Mulvaney’s antics. Lack of Empathy (for those designated “oppressors”) explains not only BLM activists demanding fist salutes but also disregard for working-class commuters by climate activists and violence by trans activists against women. And Impaired Reality Testing explains not only the false claims of trans genocide but also the claim that racism is worse than ever and that climate change is making disasters worse.
The result is a crib sheet that we believe will be devastating to Woke ideology. The late Polish psychologist Andrew Lobaczewski, who lived under Nazism and Communism, argues in Political Ponerology that it’s not enough to condemn totalitarianism. We must also seek to explain it. And by explaining it, he meant to diagnose it psychologically. As such, in producing this Taxonomy, we are diagnosing Woke movements and the behaviors of their adherents, if not the individuals themselves, as psychopathological. We recognize that these claims, and the Taxonomy, will be controversial. But we think such controversy is necessary if we are to put an end to, or at least significantly reduce, the narcissistic, psychopathic, and histrionic behaviors that have come to define progressive politics.
Climate activists throwing paint at a Van Gough. BLM activists demanding they be saluted. Trans activists falsely claiming "genocide." Those aren't the behaviors of altruists, they're the behaviors of narcissism, psychopathy, histrionic and other Cluster B personality disorders.
The Malignant Narcissism Of Justin Trudeau
On the psychopathology of a man who: spreads disinformation while demanding censorship; freezes the bank accounts of people who criticize him; and smears ordinary Canadians as Nazis
by @[private account]
Last week, Canadian House of Commons Speaker Anthony Rota invited a 98-year-old man named Yaroslav Hunka to attend a speech by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. Rota called Hunka a “Canadian hero,” and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau cheered for Hunka alongside lawmakers. But Hunka, it turned out, had served in a Nazi unit during World War II, sparking outrage.
In response, Rota took “full responsibility” for the incident, and Trudeau called it “deeply embarrassing.” Trudeau then warned against “Russian propaganda and Russian disinformation.”
Trudeau’s non-apology and dismissal of criticism as “Russian disinformation” is especially hypocritical given his repeated denunciation of the Canadian Freedom Convoy as a Nazi-linked movement.
About the truckers, Trudeau said, “We are seeing activity that is a threat to our democracy, and that is undermining the public’s trust in our institutions.” Trudeau, one day later, compared the truckers to Nazis and American racial segregationists. "Conservative Party members can stand with people who wave swastikas,” he said. “They can stand with people who wave the Confederate flag.”
It should not have to be said, but it does: Trudeau had zero evidence then, and none today, that the truckers were racists or Nazis. The swastikas printed on flags at the convoy were not hate symbols - they were intended as criticism of the government’s overreach through a comparison to Nazi Germany. Yet Trudeau condemned a Jewish member of parliament for being sympathetic to the convoy and for supporting “people who wave swastikas.”
Trudeau’s colleagues participated in his conspiracy theory. One Liberal MP said that truckers’ “Honk, Honk” slogan was a coded message for “Heil Hitler." There was never any evidence for any of this then or now.
As such, Trudeau was spreading disinformation. Naturally, Trudeau has, for the last three years, been accusing others of spreading disinformation and demanding that social media companies like Facebook and Twitter censor the people he disagrees with.
Canada’s political troubles may seem trivial and unimportant. The country is not a significant military power. It has fewer people than California. Its economy is the ninth in the world; California’s is the fourth. Trudeau has just been engaging in the usual progressive rhetoric of accusing his opponents of being Nazis, something both sides do, as the controversy over last Friday’s applauding showed. Many people outside of Canada may understandably conclude that the general awfulness of Justin Trudeau just isn’t very important.
But Trudeau is important, and what he’s doing in Canada should terrify everyone in the Western world who cares about being free from government tyranny, censorship, and disinformation. That’s because Trudeau is pioneering a new way for governments to take control over the information environment — spreading disinformation and demanding censorship — that is similar but different to efforts we are seeing in places like California, Australia, and New Zealand.
People across the Western world were rightly alarmed when Trudeau last year invoked, for the first time in Canadian history, the Emergency Measures Act and froze bank accounts of people who had simply donated to the Truckers’ cause. It was brazen thuggery that Trudeau justified by calling ordinary Canadians Nazis and racists.
Trudeau’s crackdown on the Freedom Convoy protestors was followed by efforts to regulate and control the internet. His Online Streaming Act and Online News Act gave the government expansive new powers to regulate what happens and what you see online.
The atmosphere created by Trudeau and his party is completely upending Canadian society, leading to the persecution of his detractors and limiting speech and expression.
Earlier this month, a liberal judge in Calgary sentenced a Christian pastor to two months in jail for what he said during a 20-minute speech to the truckers’ Freedom Convoy.
The College of Psychologists of Ontario recently ordered conservative psychologist Jordan Peterson to undergo social media training because they believed his tweets and opinions were problematic. An Ontario court then upheld the College’s decision.
And now, Trudeau is attacking parents who believe they should have to consent to whether their children under the age of 16 can change their sexual identity. Once again, he did so by accusing his political opponents of truly awful things.
“Far-right political actors are trying to outdo themselves with the types of cruelty and isolation they can inflict on these already vulnerable people,” Trudeau said of parents. “Well, trans kids need to feel safe, not targeted by politicians.”
All of this may seem shocking to people outside of Canada. To Americans and much of the world, Canadians are kind and friendly people. We have taken pride for decades in being nicer and more polite than Americans.
But what’s clear is that what’s going on in Canada is anything but dull. It’s terrifying. In looking to defend minorities and promote culture, Trudeau’s Liberals are everything they once feared. They are authoritarian, anti-democratic, and illiberal. And what’s happening in Canada is not separate from what’s happening in the US, the UK, Europe, and Brazil, but intimately connected to those nations. Trudeau isn’t so different from President Joe Biden, Vice President Kamala Harris, Governor Gavin Newsom, and most other Democrats in the US.
The difference is that he is ahead of them. Trudeau has taken Wokeism to another level. As such, to understand where the Woke global war on freedom of speech is headed and how we can resist it, you have to understand why Justin Trudeau is so awful.
Psychopathy And Misogyny Behind Trans Attacks On Women
Another violent assault on women in San Francisco, home to the women's rights movement
by @buttonslives
People in San Francisco and California have long prided themselves as global leaders in the movement for the respect and freedom of women. California was, in 1911, the sixth and largest state to give women the right to vote, proving decisive for national victory. In 1955, four lesbian couples founded the Daughters of Bilitis, the first national lesbian activist organization in the U.S. And between 1968 and 1970, progressive women’s rights groups met in San Francisco, giving birth to the modern feminist movement of the following decade.
But that commitment to respect and freedom for women was nowhere to be found last week when a group of six masked trans activists dressed in black climbed over a locked gate and aggressively pursued two women’s sex-based rights advocates, K. Yang and Meghan Murphy, in downtown San Francisco. The two women were speakers at the Women’s Declaration International (WDI) USA's second annual convention. The terrifying event was captured in a video.
According to the San Francisco Chronicle, the women’s rights campaigners were anti-trans. “Anti-trans group, advertising as feminists, descends on S.F. for an annual convention,” read the headline of an article it published on its homepage. The WDI, according to the Chronicle, was pushing "anti-trans policies.” The Chronicle quoted an organization claiming that WDI members were “bigots masquerading as feminists” and linked them to organizations labeled as hate groups.
But neither Murphy nor Yang is anti-trans, and both are women's rights advocates in the same tradition of the women’s suffragists and other progressive women’s movements. Yang is a lesbian and former trans activist, and Murphy is a long-time campaigner against the sex trafficking of women and other feminist causes.
Murphy was terrified by the attempted assault. In the video, she had to flee to the safety of the hotel. “I've never felt such fear,” she said. “I've never had to flee from someone, let alone a group of intimidating men. Their intentions seemed hostile, possibly even violent."
Initially, three officers from the San Francisco Police Department were present, anticipating the planned protests. Then, as the number of trans protesters grew to around 100, additional officers from multiple districts arrived, totaling around 20. Police chased and detained one activist who vandalized property.
Murphy had intended to attend the opening night of an art exhibit presented by Women Are Real, an independent non-partisan organization advocating for women's sex-based rights, but said, “After the day's events, I was too scared to step out.”
The next morning, the art exhibit attendees discovered that the venue's windows had been spray painted with the antagonistic phrase, “NO TERFS ON OUR TURF!” TERF is a derogatory term for feminists who do not think a man can become a woman through drugs, surgery, or mentality.
It wasn’t the first violent assault on women’s rights activists in San Francisco. Earlier this year, activists reportedly physically assaulted Riley Gaines, a female champion college swimmer, and prevented her from leaving a dangerously crowded room at San Francisco State University.
Trans activists chanted slogans and held signs with aggressive messages. “Millions of dead TERFs,” read one sign.
The events shocked many San Francisco residents, including many women. The violence raises the question: what in the world is happening to San Francisco? How did the city go from celebrating women’s rights to assaulting women?
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedactivist harassmentdenialmental illnessviolence terror
San Francisco was a longtime world leader in pioneering love, respect, and freedom for women. Now, the city is synonymous with psychopaths and misogynists, claiming to be "trans activists," violently attacking women's rights advocates. @buttonslives
C3 dehumanizingactivist harassmentmental illnessviolence terror
California May Take Children From Parents Who Oppose Their Gender Transition
Governor Gavin Newsom could soon sign radical legislation pushed by state lawmaker who encouraged her child’s gender transition
by @[private account] @[private account]
California is the true freedom state, says Governor Gavin Newsom. In response to the passage of a bill to counteract “book banning” in schools last week, Newsom stated that California is “a place where families — not political fanatics — have the freedom to decide what’s right for them.” With civil liberties under attack around the country, California is a beacon of individual rights and parent empowerment.
"There is no state in America that supports local control and parental engagement like the state of California,” Newsom said in August. “No one comes close. It's written into our rules.”
And yet, at this very moment, the California state legislature and Attorney General Rob Bonta are taking extreme measures to undermine parental authority. Last week, the State Assembly voted 57-16 to approve AB 957, the Transgender, Gender-Diverse, and Intersex Youth Empowerment Act. This bill, if signed by Newsom, will make gender affirmation a factor in custody disputes. What that means, practically, is that parents who do not support their child’s supposed transition to the opposite gender may lose custody to another parent.
At the same time, Bonta has filed a lawsuit against the Chino Valley Unified School District to prevent what he called the “forced outing” of transgender students. Bonta is seeking a preliminary injunction on the school district’s policy that requires schools to tell parents if their children identify by a different gender or go by a different name at school.
Said Bonta, “It’s discriminatory, and it’s downright dangerous. It has no place in California, which is why we have moved in court to strike it down.” The state’s position now appears to be that parents must affirm their child’s gender identity but that they also have no right to know about this identity in the first place. This creates the dangerous possibility that a parent could lose custody of their child if a school staff member encourages the child to transition without the parent’s knowledge.
It’s true that children who identify as transgender and gender nonconforming are especially vulnerable and often struggle significantly with mental health and suicidal ideation. These children, like all children, deserve caring parents, privacy, and safety at school.
However, there is no proof that social affirmation and medical intervention for minors reduce the risk of suicide. In fact, there is a growing body of often censored evidence that indicates the rapid onset of gender dysphoria is a social contagion. It is also well-established that medical treatments at an early age can have long-term adverse effects. This is why some progressive European countries are changing their guidelines to limit puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgery for people under 18.
Not only are California’s policies lacking scientific evidence, but they also violate the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, which protects parents’ rights to make decisions about their child’s education, medical care, and religion. The US Supreme Court has, in multiple cases, decided that this clause allows parents to raise their children how they see fit.
Because the term “affirmation” is ill-defined in AB 957, it is likely that parents who even support their child using a new name or pronoun could lose custody for opposing early medical treatments. “We will be the first state in the nation to say that any parent who is not affirming their child’s gender identity, regardless of age…is abusive and is undeserving of their kids,” Erin Friday, a California Attorney and co-leader of Our Duty, a parent-lead support network, told Public.
Last year, Newsom signed a “sanctuary state” bill that allows minors from other states to seek gender-affirming care in California without parental permission. Under SB 107, California courts can assume jurisdiction over custody disputes from other states if the child is seeking transgender medical treatment. This means that a parent who wants to transition their child against the other parent’s wishes can kidnap the child to California and sign them up for medical treatments while being shielded from criminal or abuse investigations. The law makes California’s radical legislative efforts a national issue.
Lawmakers are also now considering AB 665, which critics fear will allow children ages 12 to 17 to seek mental health treatment in residential care facilities if their parents do not socially or medically affirm their gender identity. Although AB 957 will only apply to divorces and custody battles for now, it opens the door for the state to remove children from parents who are still together. If a refusal to “affirm” is considered to be abuse under the law, parents could be subject to investigations by Child Protective Services.
California parents may soon face a disturbing dilemma: either consent to transgender medical care for their child or risk losing their child to the state.
Why is the so-called “freedom state” attempting to violate parents’ most fundamental rights to make decisions for their own children? And why are schools trying to keep gender transitions secret from parents?
C2 false claimschild indoctrinationcontagioninstitutional capturemedical harmstate takes children
Republicans are hyping the stories of a handful of detransitioners, people who had sought to change their sex either through drugs or surgery and then changed their minds, even though detransition is rare, according to the New York Times.
“As Republican-controlled state legislatures have passed over a dozen bills banning transition care for minors this year,” wrote Maggie Astor, detransitioner Chloe “Cole and fewer than 10 activists like her — people who transitioned and then changed course — have become the faces of the cause, according to a New York Times review of news coverage and legislative testimony.” But, noted the Times, “Most people who transition do not change course.”
Astor went on to claim that just 2 to 13 percent of individuals who transition decide to detransition, but those numbers are almost certainly wrong. The 2% number appears to have come from a study of trans people in Sweden between 1960 and 2010, a population very different from the trans population today. At that time, adult males made up the bulk of referrals to gender clinics, whereas in the last decade, there has been a surge of adolescent females identifying as transgender and seeking medical treatment.
The 13% number does come from a more recent 2015 study. It is of 17,151 trans-identified individuals. And they are all from the U.S., not Sweden.
But the data is drawn from the US Transgender Survey of 2015 and only includes trans-identified individuals who temporarily detransitioned and thus excluded permanent detransitioners.
What’s more, the number of minors diagnosed with gender dysphoria rose sharply after 2015, from 15,172 in 2017 to 42,167 in 2021, in the United States, according to a report by Reuters. This can be explained in part by the Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria (ROGD) hypothesis, which disproportionately affects natal girls.
Researchers are also likely to undercount detransitioning because so many detransitioners tend to, understandably, avoid going back to the same health care providers who transitioned them, undermining the extent to which we can rely on medical records.
Trans people are celebrated, with an entire reality show dedicated to documenting in celebratory fashion the sexual reassignment surgery and hormone use of a trans girl named Jazz Jennings. And few places are more celebratory of transgenderism than California.
All of which raises a question. If there’s no evidence that “hate incidents” are rising, abundant evidence that tolerance is rising, and overwhelming evidence that the media created a moral panic about racism, why are nations and nation-sized states like California urging mass spying and creating blacklists?
We get to the bottom of the phony "hate crisis" in our latest investigation. Please subscribe now to read it!
https://twitter.com/shellenberger/status/1655964510530985985?s=20
Prejudice still exists in the United States. The California church shooting from May 2022 was motivated by political hatred. And the recent mall shooter in Texas may have been motivated by racist ideology.
But the ideologies don’t line up neatly politically. The California church shooter was Taiwanese and motivated by an obscure political grievance. The Texas shooter may have been racist, but he was also Latino. And the recent shooter in Nashville was trans and targeted Christians.
Need To Keep Masses Afraid Is Behind Elite Embrace Of Wokeism And Censorship
For the last half-decade, elites in government and the media have created a culture of self-censorship on race, climate change, and trans issues. In the workplace, in schools and universities, and online, politicians, activists, and journalists instilled in ordinary people a paralyzing fear of saying the wrong thing and finding oneself accused of being a “climate denier,” a “racist,” or a “transphobe.”
It’s now clear that, at this very moment, media elites are seeking to turn this culture of informal self-censorship into formal government censorship. They call their legislation, which would destroy free speech, based centrally on their hatred of the masses, “pro-democracy” and “anti-hate.”
To be sure, Wokeism is a genuine grassroots religion. It demonizes and scapegoats heretics, journalists, and truth-tellers. And it demands sacrifices from ordinary people in the form of more expensive energy, the sterilization of psychiatrically disordered children, and self-censorship.
But it is also a state religion. News media and social media elites took Wokeism from being a marginal cult into being the dominant ideology of every major institution, from NBC and the CDC to the AMA and the CIA.
“Think tanks” and “journalists” behaved as propagandists, leading much of the public to believe that police were wantonly murdering thousands of unarmed black Americans, that climate change threatened human existence, and that surgeons can (and should) “change the sex” of children.
Over the last decade, elites created a fear-based Woke culture of self-censorship on race, climate, trans and other issues. Now, they are seeking to turn this culture of informal self-censorship into formal government censorship in the US, EU, Brazil and around the world.
The de facto legalization of streetwalking was done in the name of trans rights but in reality the law makes it harder for police to rescue people being trafficked