The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
The reason UCI policy on trans men (that is female, not “trans males”) has engendered no debate is because females in men’s sport creates no threat to fairness (unless said F wants to take T in women’s sport). It’s not a trans issue, it’s a males in women’s sport issue. So poor
Can’t believe Mosier still compares regulation of women’s sport to how trans men (that is, females, not “trans males” as written) are allowed to compete. That a journalist has framed this as “notably” suggests that neither actually understands (or wants to) the issue of fairness.
...considerably from them, he also lost some time at the start and on bends, so they argued "We just can't know". Which is kind of what they've done with the trans issue too - "we just don't know if they have an advantage after T suppression". Even when CAS heard the Semenya case
...rather male T levels and function in women's sport. "Between" as opposed to "within". The surge in discussion and cases of trans women will also strengthen their position if this were to go back to court - it makes that principled point even more clearly.
Biological reality: Trans women are male, they go through male development from conception to adulthood. That is what creates issues for sport. That's not "Ross' prejudices". Also, by way of counter, "Section 195(2) of the Equality Act". Appeals to cherry-picked authority are fun
Because, as you may by now have realized, either way, you're calling someone by what they really are - male or female. Whether you write it as XY or M, or XX or F, or leave out "TI" or "trans", it ends up at the same place - the reality & importance of biological sex, not gender
Clearer is "trans(identity)" (eg Transwoman/man), but I, like you and many others, have no issue with how people identify, especially not in this sporting conversation, where it's all about sex. And so to be accurate & relevant, "male" really needs to be stated & understood.
I've read lay articles that use Trans-"Sex" all the time, which makes it impossible to know why "trans" (which means, of course, 'across, beyond, so as to change') is required. And if that's the case, then you don't know why there's any issue at all. Which may be their intention
Because it clarifies the noun. Should that not be really, really obvious to anyone with even a modicum of comprehension. "Trans-identified" is an adjective. Male is a noun. The key point, for the sports issue, is the noun.
Exactly. Some people have, maliciously or stupidly, changed word-meaning such that 'trans female' can no longer be understood. Is it a biological female who is trans (identifies as a man)? Or is it a male who identifies as female (thinking, as some do, that sex can change?)
Trans - "across, beyond, so as to change".
Identified - Indicative of choice, gender identity
Male - biological term, relevant to sport issue
In this debate about sport, where biology is what matters, it is perfectly appropriate, & less confusing than TW. Subtle, though, Rog
It's accurate Roger. And if I "hide behind science", at least I'm standing behind something I understand. Biology is real, and then there is your identity politics. the term TIM expresses the key points - "male, who identifies as female, thus TRANS (as per its latin meaning"
The most accurate, of course, when discussing the sporting issue, int he SPECIFIC context of MALE sex advantage, is to use trans identified MALES because that is, after all, the issue - MALE advantage. So I use it not as a dog-whistle, but it help make clear what the problem is
Because, Roger, in biology, they *ARE* males. And they identify as trans. Not a right wing dog whistle - you guys can keep your daft politics to yourselves, and I'll keep my accurate biology. I'm not trying to be subtle, just right. It's either TIM or TW. Same thing
- We also cover the latest (sigh) in the ongoing transgender debate, discussing @[private account]'s coverage of the issue, and why the CONTENT of the argument should matter, not its maker.
- We talk concussion & long-term health in sport, with new research:
https://podcasts.apple.com/za/podcast/news-special-tour-de-france-lance-armstrongs/id1461719225?i=1000618630630