The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Is Josh saying there is no discernible difference between trans women and females? Or between pre and post in trans women? If it’s the latter, then that would be true for many variables! Very little to zero changes from T suppression across the long-term studies published
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles Genuine question - if you had ZERO idea of what was going on, no biological data at all, and were asked whether trans women should compete in women’s sport, would you say “yes, until proven otherwise”, or “No, until proven otherwise”? If you answer the former, then it means you
So if I have anything to declare, it would be this: my position on trans women inclusion in sport is guided by current evidence from peer reviewed studies and the physiology of performance benefits of androgens in sport. World Rugby prioritized that evidence, and I was part of a
My position is one on trans participation in sport. That is what I have been consistent in explaining. The points made in this thread that relate to that issue are correct.
You still have not made a coherent argument for why the biology I explain re trans performance advantages are nonsense. Incapable, perhaps. As for “attacking”, Tom made a weak, uninformed point here. I replied. Pretty simple
…that they both effectively say that there is unfair advantage created by male androgens, and that fairness can be ensured if T is lowered below 5 (or 10, in some sports and the IOC trans regs). So they’re the sane, but they were developed almost in parallel with diff evidence
@[private account] No, the trans guidelines precede the DAD guidelines. The trans guidelines that the IOC developed, starting in the early 2000s aren’t based on any study! They ignored the ones showing retained advantage after lowering T. What the DSD policy and trans policy have in common is
What you think is lack of discussion with trans athletes is another diversion. Do you think I have not heard and assessed all the arguments for and against inclusion? I can assure you there’s nothing that hasn’t been considered. It’s just weighted in favor of quality evidence
Thanks @[private account] & @[private account] for the back page of this week’s paper, for an article analyzing the fairness-inclusion tension, and biological realities of sport in the #transgender athlete issue.
…trans women who are tracked over time, which show the retention of the biological differences, their T levels usually go really low, to under 1. It’s really hard to target the drug to change final T level. I remember in Semenya/DSDs, the same was true - it was all or nothing
I spoke to @KayBurley on @SkyNews this morning. It was a brief chat about the #transgender athletes in sport controversy. I’ve put a version of it up on IGTV at this link if interested: https://www.instagram.com/tv/CQiTnYlKzaR/?utm_medium=copy_link
…instead of:
one cis female
one trans female
rather use:
one lightweight boxer
one heavyweight boxer
with same skills, strength, speed, power etc.
It’s a bogus comparison. It’s an equal outcome, because the lightweight is exceptional, the heavyweight is relatively poor.
Because they’re not equally exceptional athletes within their own categories. Do you really not understand this concept? If they have the same strength, given the 30 to 60% male advantage in strength, then that female must be very strong and the trans women relatively weak within
@[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] I am. I am trying to explain to you that in order to stay within your parameters, you have to take an exceptional female and a mediocre male (who is a trans woman), and then you can find attributes that are similar. So it would be equal, because you're comparing great to average
@[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] They’re not. By definition, if they are matched for those attributes, the female is at the very top of their population and the trans woman is in the middle. This is the whole point. Please don’t make me explain this to you again, I haven’t the patience for stupidity.
As a result, this comparison that you’re contriving is between an exceptional female & a relatively mediocre biological male. If they have the same strength, the female is maybe at the 90th percentile among females, & the trans athlete is at the 60th percentile. It’s good vs poor
@[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] Luckily those trans athletes are not very good, then. As for the niece disproving the point about social factors, I am not sure how much more can be done with your level of understanding (read: ignorance). Of course records are broken, it happens all the time. That’s what
Also, I don’t think anybody is denying that trans people are real. I mean, that’s pretty ridiculous. What the original tweet says is that it’s false to call it a ban from sport. It’s regulation of category, and the analogy of weight categories (63kg lifter is not banned) is right
Yes, this is of course an artefact of how those policies involved. Worth recognising that World Athletics have set their T limit for trans women at 5 as well, so theirs is consistent with DSDs. But inconsistent with other sports! And…neither has been shown to work.
Yes, though this was soundly rejected by the trans community, who feel it is merely semantic and another way to label them as men. We (World Rugby) discussed this, but in the end went with appropriate regulation by biological sex, and ultimately what happens then anyway is that
Thanks Mark. The “open” category idea has been discussed - when we (World Rugby) created our policy last year, it was suggested as a direction. The trans groups fight that very strongly - their view is rigid, trans women are women and so any name change is seen as ‘semantic’ to
…going to determine the final level reached. I suspect that in the elite female, that T effect is not going to be enough to create an elite male - we all know that some people tried this in the 70s and 80s! But the studies that have looked at trans men over time have found that
I also wrote an article for the @thetimes on the transgender controversy, explaining some key issues, from the meaning of sport to biological advantages (it’s not like height!), and why a “T fix” doesn’t work. Thanks @martynziegler for the invitation:
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/evidence-suggests-inclusion-comes-at-expense-of-fairness-t6pf3sz6z
And so the analogy is to explain that the dearth of trans women dominating is a result of the males who make the transition simply being too far behind the elite females they’ll then compete against for that retained advantage to be sufficient to see them win.
Or, like with someone who uses a bike with a motor, is only able to ride at 200W before they get a motor. They definitely have an advantage in both cases, but they won’t dominate because the base on which the advantage is placed is too low. The same is true for trans women so far
Lundberg, Hilton, even Harper, a trans woman, has written a review recently, and argues for trans inclusion, has recognised the retention of advantages. It’s a pretty well established biological fact now. You might want to do some academic reading. List the names of authors of
Where they become different is on the medical-ethical side, where Semenya is being asked to take meds to lower T against her desire, whereas in trans athletes, that’s already happening as part of gender re-identification. But both could, in theory, compete with lower T levels
@[private account] No, not at all. And it’s worth remembering that Sememya could compete if she lowered her T levels (exactly like Hubbard, actually). So, even though they’re different cases - one is trans, one is a DSD - the sport has basically the same policy for them.
@[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] Now you’re showing your ignorance in another domain (you really are accumulating these areas impressively). DSD cases are not trans cases. They can be managed with a different policy (and they are, as you know, surely?).
@[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] There is actually. It’s based on gametes. It’s a biological reality. For the relatively narrow purpose of sport, it’s similarly easy to govern trans individuals. XY plus androgen sensitivity (that is, exclude DSD) is a candidate case. XX is excluded. Pretty basic, actually.
…in order to compete. For the DSD cases like Semenya, this creates a medical ethical concern that is also unique. for Trans athletes, I think the pertinent question is “Does it work?”. And the evidence suggests not. So even the current policy to reduce T seems not to succeed
Well, Semenya is also XY - see CAS decision. The biggest issue is that in DSD cases, they can’t use T in the normal way, whereas trans athletes don’t have that consideration. But sport views them basically the same and tries to “solve” the problem by requiring BOTh to reduce T
As expected (NZL was never going to follow science on the issue), Laurel Hubbard named in the Olympic team, so will become the first transgender Olympic athlete. Here is our podcast exploring the meaning of sport & key biological issues for fairness: https://podcasts.apple.com/za/podcast/why-transgender-athletes-threaten-fairness-in-womens/id1461719225?i=1000522515770
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] No, because trans women don’t have a DSD where they cannot obtain the biological effects of T
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] Men’s sport is the open category, which means it’s not protected. So anyone can compete there. If a person wishes to compete in the protected category (women’s sport) then the protections afforded those in that category must be defended. Including doping with T in those trans men
Yes I agree but I think the original point is also that allowing so much more T in trans women is unfair to women who have much lower natural T levels. That’s in addition to the fact that lowering it doesn’t work, PLUS what you’re described here in this thread.
We do know that females have very low T levels compared to males. 99.9th percentile was 3.1 if memory serves me, so only 1 in 1000 females has T above 3 (PCOS, usually). And so yes, the implication, which I think you’re raising, is that the current IOC policies for trans women
@[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] I have seen it, yes. Was involved in a bit of discussion of that analysis. The IOC justifies this because their fear of being seen to discriminate against trans individuals is greater than their desire to support women’s sport & their understanding of the physiology.
Recording our next podcast. The subject will be “Use it or lose it: what happens when we stop or reduce training?” We will aim to get it out later this week. Til then, here’s our previous episode, on transgender athletes & fairness: https://podcasts.apple.com/za/podcast/the-real-science-of-sport-podcast/id1461719225?i=1000522515770
…everyone, and then a protected category on the basis of androgen’s effects was certainly discussed. It was soundly rejected by the trans groups we consulted, which is why we ended up not pursuing it - it wouldn’t have changed anything in practice.
So to be quite blunt, the reason you’re not seeing trans athletes dominant is because the base level of those athletes is too low. Go to a local marathon and look at what % of males are within the necessary 10% of the female winner, and then adjust your earlier 1% by that %age.
She literally says “this issue”. I don't see how this ‘misappropriates’ the views in the podcast. If she ever says “Listen to this, this is why trans women should also not XYZ” (then extends it to areas where biology isn’t important & there’s no colliding rights), then I’d reject
At best, the social arguments cancel out, because of the rights of women to have fairness & safety, and the rights of trans women to self-identify. But I think we explained quite well that sport, as a space, cannot balance these, nor should it. So ultimately, they’re a ‘wash'
What is the science of exclusion, if not for the retention of physiological advantage, which we discussed in detail? Or do you want more detail on the studies? The first trans podcast we did in about October last year has more on this subject. As for the impact on trans people,
Our transgender sport podcast is out. We explore misconceptions & deceptions, incl:
🚨 “Tall girls & short girls”
🚨 Sporting fairness vs inclusion: How women’s sport creates meaning
🚨 Testosterone & performance denialism
🚨 Overlaps & absence of winners
https://podcasts.apple.com/za/podcast/why-transgender-athletes-threaten-fairness-in-womens/id1461719225?i=1000522515770
No problem, it happens. It’s a hugely emotive issue, so the reactions are to be expected. Thanks for the positive feedback. We have a podcast on the trans issue coming out soon, hopefully today!
...transgender guideline”, it should come up, either the final PDF or the cover release with a link to it. The images in this thread come from that process, accompanying the guideline. Also, for the scientific literature, two reviews have described the research recently. They are
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] It's about male and the biological advantages that are acquired during typical male development. Gender is a different issue, but the reality is that trans women, having gone through puberty DO acquire those benefits. So the point is that it's male-advantaged physiology
The absence of trans athletes from elite sport is however not proof of anything. All it says is something about baseline level of the biological male making the transition. IN the same way that a cyclist using a motor who doesn’t win can’t be said to prove that motors don’t help
What’s the difference between trans women and cis men in terms of initial biology and thus interpretation of what T suppression causes? You can’t treat some as a subset of the whole because it’s convenient. Sport is biology, those two are the same.
Yes, of course. We hid nothing. There are 2 pages in the WR guideline with that heading. Go and read it. There were 12 on trans individuals underling T reduction, and then a complete discussion of what athletic training might do. Now answer my question - what’s your hypothesis?
What’s more important is for people to read the guideline and understand the basis for the decision and why this big “gotcha” you think you have is actually entirely incorrect. There are now 13 studies on trans bodies with T reduction, all cited. Try read up.
Where is this joke about trans exterminators? I haven’t seen that. Unless you’re applying a 2 degrees of separation thing. As for data, I those limitations have been acknowledged and can quite easily be understood within known physiological models and plausible understandings.
…trouble in the Semenya case because identifying a ‘case’ required some subjective assessment of who might be one. That’s a recipe for trouble. Similarly, any trans policy, whether it requires T reduction or exclusion, needs the authority to be able to identify the person who
that said, one solution that has been proposed is this move to “open” and “female”, as you suggest. That is resisted by trans advocates, they want to compete in the female class, not the open one. So all it does is change a name, but the debate remains the same!
If you’re after evidence for the exact statement you’re responding to, then it is really remarkable. If you’re talking again about trans athletes, then the error here is that of thinking advantage is assessed as A vs B, when it should be “within A, pre to post”.
Unless what you’re asking for is some testimonies from trans women, their emotional appeal for inclusion? Is that what you feel is missing? Because if I include that, then I’d also do the same for biological females. But then of course it’s no longer evidence, just emotion
Slogans derived from desires & wish lists (eg: trans women are women) & labels (transphobic) barely register when it comes to this sports participation debate. Neither does personalisation of it. Don’t believe me or anyone else. Rather look at the biology & data, dispassionately
I’m also thinking about impact. Specifically the impact of lying & presenting alternate versions of reality on the integrity of discussion. This does not affect only the trans community, but also women’s sport. I think the truth matters, & the impact has integrity only if true
But involvement is assumed by people to be tacit acceptance of ALL the arguments, which bothers me. I argued hard against some of them. And yes, I’ll admit, I do feel sympathy for the DSD athletes’ situation. That situation is so much harder than the trans athlete one.
Note that we should avoid using DSD cases to argue about trans issues, because a. unresolved issue remains the degree to which androgenization affects their performance to begin with. However, since you introduced this spuriously, I’d point out that it really doesn’t support you
When World Rugby developed the transgender guidelines last year, we did recognise & discuss (intensively) 2 issues now being raised by a union proposal, namely selected screening & thresholds for advantage within a category. We summarised the discussions in the guideline FAQ:
Exactly right. What this does is separate a category within a category. You had “women”. Then you had “biological females” and “trans women”. Now it’s “biological females”, “trans women exempt from screen”, “trans women to be screened”. And the screen is arbitrary.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] And to be clear, this is not an exception. The debate if framed very clearly as one affecting trans individuals, not DSDs. I believe I have been consistent that the issue with biological sex for sport is androgenization. That applies here too, and it shows why DSDs are different
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] After all that had been discussed on this, do we still need to emphasize why DSD and trans should not be conflated, or does this part of this thread illustrate it well? As for no androgenization due to puberty blockers, remind me of what I wrote for the WR guidelines?
These comparisons are all out there, in multiple studies. Pre vs post, trans post vs biological female, trans pre vs biological male and female. It’s the whole basis of the argument. What you’re proposing simply doesn’t work, no matter what you compare, unless you cherry pick...
So would the comparison of trans women post treatment to biological females be the one you’re after? Because there’s data on that. As for point 2 above, the different distribution is the whole point, necessitating a separate category. For about the 20th time. You can slide your
If you do it your way, you’re arguing basically that a trans woman should be treated as a special case among biological males, who for no reason other than identity, should be exempt from regulation despite having physiological advantage that is excluded by that regulation.
Basically, you’re playing “spot the difference” after first insisting that all the differences are removed. That’s dishonest. But we know where trans women fall - after T reduction, they retain significant advantages over a matched cohort of biological females. That should end it
…is that sport then is the trigger for a gender identity-sex mismatch at some stage, and there are also questions over the medical-ethics given the size of the advantage. So quite different from trans cases, but biologically, the same principle
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] Trans women are individuals who are biological male, who have undergone development under the influence of androgens, and thus, who, as a group, have physiological advantages over females. Therefore, the comparison is trans women to females, which is the same as a comparison ...
Because (I’m persistent this way), you don’t seem to understand that you can’t treat a trans woman as a special category of biological male who just didn’t get the normal male attributes. You need to do that to suit your ideology, but it’s invalid. Male sex is male sex for sport
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] You seem really stuck on this concept. The process is quite simple - typical male has an advantage of X vs typical female. T reduction removes only a small part of X. The assertion that a trans woman is not a typical male is the crux of your objection, I know this argument well.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] No the debate is whether a trans woman has advantages after T suppression relative to before. Your method of comparison would argue in support of, among other things, doping, provided a doper isn’t winning. But that says more about their base level than the existence of advantage
In fact, this is really the crux of it. You could find trans women (biological male) with sufficiently low muscle mass, height, strength etc, but then you’d be selecting out relatively inferior athletes, say, 25th percentile, matched to 90th percentile to force an overlap
Yes, I noted the same. A disappointing article, though I will say it is true that values are driving policy DESPITE the science, because that’s the only way anyone can argue for inclusion of trans athletes in women’s sport - social values, science be damned. I take offence at
Aside from this, the expert in that original article makes two more poor errors in only two sentences. First he invokes the “trans athletes aren’t winning everything” argument to suggest no advantage. So poor. Advantage is relative to self, not others. Just like a cyclist with a
This is amazing. How is this the place to start when assessing whether transgender women have advantages? Funny thing is, earlier he cites the Bermon stat about 140-fold over-representation of athletes like Chand (DSDs, generally) in women’s sport. What would that mean?
It is a considerably more complex situation than the trans one, for a few reasons. Physiological, social, and ethical. I think it would be fair to say that those with 5-ARD are genetically male, have testes, high T levels, but atypical use of T, resulting in “unandrogenized” dev.
I think the thing you’re either misunderstanding or deliberately ignoring is that people can take a given scientific finding, X, and apply it in different ways. But they don’t dispute X. And so here, X is that trans women retain advantages in physiology that are relevant to sport
Then, the second paper there by Harper is interesting. Look up Harper systematic review BJSM trans athletes, and see what she concludes from actually looking at the data. You really need to actually read the studies here, not just repeat slogans.
Which studies? Have you looked at any of the 13 now published that track biology in trans individuals over a period of T reduction? When you personalise it with a label of what the authors are, you abandon a reasoned scientific discussion.
If that’s your understanding, then your understanding is incorrect. The paper linked to above cites a dozen research papers that are specifical longitudinal intervention studies in trans men and women. The focus on hormones is the whole point here.
Oh sorry, I read trans women, since that’s what we were talking about. Concentration, my bad. If trans men take T, they can compete in men's sport, not women’s, as there is no current allowance for TUE for that purpose. That’s the correct decision for now.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @laurenboebert Yes, and I’ve told you why you are not seeing this (three times, now). And as for trans men, see earlier - they’re entering the open category. It’s not protected, so their disadvantage is not relevant to this discussion.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @laurenboebert I am not sure if I can explain the same thing a fifth time. I’ve explained the reason sport is not dominated by trans women, it’s about the baseline level of the candidates in the cohort. It doesn’t prove disadvantage. Advantage is only proven within a case, pre vs post.
If you took, say, EPO and it gave you an 8% advantage, would you win the gold medal in the Marathon at the Olympics? If not, does this prove EPO doesn’t work? Or does it say something about your base level? That’s the trans answer too.
So you only regulate the categories down, since those are protected from humans who possess advantages (like heavier weight in boxer, like sex for males vs females). If a trans man wishes to enter women’s events, then provided they’re not supplementing with T, it’s also no issue.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @laurenboebert So if you have a case of a trans man wanting to compete in men’s sport, it’s not relevant because the open or highest category is unregulated. It’s like saying that a middle weight boxer can fight up in weight class, it’s not a problem (though it may be unsafe for that person)
By plenty, in an event like the 100m, there are perhaps 4000. So I guess that’s plenty, in absolute terms. It’s only 1/1000th of a medium sized city though. Now overlay the prevalence of trans women in any population. Is it a huge surprise there hasn’t been a medalist yet?
...reason we won’t see a “tsunami” of trans athletes dominating women’s sport - the base level of athletes still needs to be high enough such that the athlete is better than 99% of women after conversion. But that’s not the point - there’s no acceptable level. It is unfair at n=1
Next, “FACT 2”, which is the weakest of the lot. This is pure gaslighting. Their athletic ability will vary, obviously. It’s irrelevant though. As is the fact that women will beat trans athletes. This says nothing about advantage, which is measured relative to self, not others
Quoting @ACLU: FACT TWO: Trans athletes do not have an unfair advantage in sports.
Also, the guideline, as I’m sure you’re aware, excludes trans women from women’s rugby, which is an important distinction. Good to be accurate on these matters, no? It regulates the necessary categories, it doesn’t ban anyone from the entire sport
But now you’re making a different argument. Previously, you said that boys would “use transgender protections”, which one would reasonably read as boys deliberately exploiting inclusive policies. That’s what I don’t think anyone has implied. This argument, in your follow up,
I think the magnitude of 140x is affected by the baseline prevalence in populations who are also good athletes, so in all likelihood, it’s a bit lower. But still suggestive of an advantage. The base rate issue is again in play for trans athletes, btw. As is their base performance
No, I think you’ve mischaracterising it if you believe this is “any anti trans opinion”. I’ve been very clear about the context, the reasoning and the arguments for why women’s sport must exist as a category because sex rather than gender.
One could, for instance, challenge the assertion that "the real takeaway from Roberts’ study is that transgender women ultimately do reach parity with cis women in athletic tasks”. The study actually shows the opposite. And the strength tasks have quite nuanced interpretation too