The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] The reason for the decision is explained. And the issue about trans rugby players not part of the cohort is also explained in three pages acknowledging the study limitations in the guideline and again in the FAQ. It’s very transparent, no sleight of hand. The problem with this...
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @FondOfBeetles @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] Corrections:
- Not permitted to ask a question. Rather, invited to challenge everything and discuss all presentations as much as desired
- All data presented was published in peer-reviewed journals at the time of the meeting
- TWO groups were present to represent views from trans
...as a research limitation in the World Rugby guideline, and spent some time exploring the implications. I guess as a concept the key question is this: “if there was ZERO research on trans biology, would you allow inclusion or would you advise exclusion?” If the former, then you
…the sports are taking the lead, and the countries are following (or happy to comply). If a sport decided to regulate women’s sport as a closed category (like World Rugby has done), then a country that wants to go with a gender requirement would be prevented from picking trans
@[private account] the initial difference between M and F is the entire premise for separation for the purpose of sport. It’s the real, universal finding, so I’m not sure how it can ever be ignored. The trans women hit the men’s average initially because they have the same biological advantages
We did a podcast on this recently. It precedes this study (though I knew this was coming), but it explains the other dozen studies, the concept of balancing imperatives & why WR reached a guideline that keeps women’s rugby closed based on evidence to date: https://podcasts.apple.com/za/podcast/why-rugbys-controversial-new-transgender-guidelines/id1461719225
The study includes 46 trans women (TW) and 29 trans men, all in the Airforce. It capitalises on the practice of physical fitness assessments every 12 months to track how performance in push-up, sit-ups and 1.5 mile run changes when T is either reduced (TW) or increased (TM) (4/)
New study on transgender & performance. The paper’s title could've been “Significant endurance & strength-endurance advantages are retained for up to 2 years despite T reduction in TW: Implications for the assumptions of fairness in current policies”. Some thoughts to follow
…understanding the reason it was done, or what it shows. They pretend it portrays trans women as typical males, when actually, the whole thing is based on the consistent finding, in a dozen studies, that TW retain significant advantages over CW after T suppression. She also...
Next she says the policy is based on modelling. No, the model was offered to illustrate a principle after the trans lobby challenged us to explain why it even matters if there are size, strength and speed advantages. What they’ve done is to take that model and attack it without
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] If you have a link, let me know. But I am absolutely certain that the position was based on a dozen studies in trans women. I’ll even provide the references to you if you’d like to examine those and see their conclusions.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] But we don’t. We base the evidence on a dozen studies of trans women. I don’t even know which study on cis men you think was used. The analysis of who wins or loses is conceptually flawed, as mentioned. A motor in my bicycle won’t let me win the Tour de france. It’s still unfair
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] I’m not sure which study you’re talking about there, the one on cis men. There are a dozen studies, every one of which has studied trans women. They all show relatively modest changes (sometimes none), and large retained advantages compared to a reference group of females.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] Actually, all the studies are of trans women who underwent HRT. Their T levels were usually below 1. That’s a dozen studies that have assessed changes after 12 months, then compared them post HRT to a reference group of females. This is literally the only evidence that exists.
…that actually matter can be discovered through competition. Same thing for sex - being trans is not an ability, it’s a category crossing difference. Also, to the last statement, if there’s any good evidence of this, please let me know.
I tried to use the very next paragraph to then return to the principle that matters for Semenya/DSD & trans, which IS that of male sex biology and performance advantages. I felt like that did let the reader know that Semenya does have the benefits of male biology.
Because the article was about trans issues, but the paper wanted mention of Semenya for the SA audience and I couldn’t get more words/space to go into detail. So I had to squeeze it in there. It was the only ‘bridge’ I could think of to move from Semenya back to the trans issue
@[private account] @[private account] The IOC’s (and many other) trans guidelines were trying to facilitate inclusion by making low T the requirement, because they hoped (prayed, I imagine) that it would “fix” the issue. It clearly doesn’t. But they were trying to capitalise on what is done in medical treatment to
If you look up the World Rugby transgender guidelines, there’s a full document there that contains a summary of those studies and their full references. I can look and send you the link later, when I’m at my computer again, but that should do it
A thread I posted yesterday, starting with an article I wrote on trans women in sport, developing into some questions, and ending with an appeal to at least own & admit your priorities in this important debate (especially the scientists, answer Q1 before you offer anything else).
Quoting @Scienceofsport: The @[private account] asked me to do a piece on the trans woman in sport issue. It’s necessarily short and high level, but here it is. Writing it made me realize there are some key questions everyone who wades into the debate upfront should answer. Wanted to share them here (1/_)
And as you’d know, I have pretty fervently tried to avoid conflating trans and DSD issues when discussing this. However, it remains true that the principle or key question - is there a performance advantage due to T during development? - is the same for both. What happens next,
As for the thread, it’s trying to focus on trans issue, hopefully it’s read as such. I suppose one could immediately see why this separation is important because one’s answer to the first question might differ for the two cases.
I did try in the piece to emphasize that semenya is not trans and in fact, if it was up to me, this entire piece would not mention DSD. But, SA paper, that wasn’t an argument I was winning, so I tried to navigate it and steer it away from DSD towards trans athletes only.
Those good studies are unfortunately not directly in athletes, but they are the ones that should really make sports organizations sit up and take notice. They show, without exception, that trans women who have suppressed T lose only small amounts of mass, muscle mass & strength
The first question, before any other “shots are fired”, should be:
“If there is ZERO evidence for what happens to performance and/or biology in trans women undergoing treatment, what should happen for sport? Would you allow inclusion, or would you exclude until it exists?” (2/)