The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Well, this is sport’s most complex issue (see also how it plays out with transgender athletes). There’s no solution that satisfies everyone. My feeling was that an upper limit on T was the fairest compromise for all athletes, and I supported the PREVIOUS IAAF policy, the one
Yeah there is a separate transgender policy that has a limit of T at 5 for 12 months before you can compete as female. You don’t need surgery or legal recognition, just the lowered T levels. That may be challenged soon too
That’s an interesting question. Ok theory, I think the IAAF or any sports body will say you must be recognized in law as female to compete as female. That said, in the transgender issue (so change from male to female) you DONT need to be recognized as female in law! Minefield!
It doesn’t allow other women to raise their T levels but it will further contribute to the shifting lines between male and female, which in elite sport poses a challenge. You see this in the transgender issues. This is not quite the same concept, but the two areas may be combined
Yes. I’m not 100% sure where the 5 comes from. It used to be 10 (for IAAF and Transgender), but was reduced recently. There is a complication here - some people may need more for normal function because of differences in the sensitivity to T. So it’s a contentious limit.
In intersex cases, yes. In some countries and cases, a decision about the sex of a child is delayed for years, until puberty, because it can be that difficult. Gender is different. Biological sex is the issue, IMO. And then there’s transgender females, similar, parallel issue
Define “mere simple sex”. Because transgender females surely don’t fall into that category of “simple". And intersex? The T level is an attempt by sport to accommodate shifting sex & gender definitions. It’s unfortunately not as simple as height or mass
The new transgender policy would allow this. A male with T levels below 5nmol/L can race as a woman without requiring surgery or legal recognition. All that would be required is the T level and a declaration. This is where we are.
Yes, that’s true, but I’m not sure a general difference between XY & XX is required for the argument when you have cases of XY with widely varying sensitivities, as happens with AIS. For transgender females, much bigger issue. For DSDs, minor compared to case by case sensitivity
…is unable to respond? If I look at the transgender guidelines, I see the same issue - society is going that way, sport is trying to accommodate, but is unwilling to simply fall into step (which I believe is correct to do). Then people demand evidence that can never be provided.
@[private account] @[private account] Yeah exactly. And so I think sport has been forced into trying to accommodate certain societal changes, and it can’t. This is most obvious in how it’s trying to deal with transgender females. Different from this in specifics, but similar in concept.
In this instance, it’s very obvious that T has performance advantages - if you increase it, people improve (doping), if you decrease it, they get worse. 100% of the time (intersex athletes 2012-2015, and transgender). Is this unfair? That’s a different issue, one worth debating
@[private account] Well, when talking about one person, sample size of that one is perfectly appropriate. If you want to expand it, look for Bermon 2015, and also look at every transgender female in history.
And this applies to both intersex and transgender situations. This is not a simple matter of forcing certain stereotypes, IMO. There are legitimate questions around fairness that should not be shut down with this blanket statement.
The T policy of 2012 was a radical change from the previous policy. Huge shift. It was an attempt (similar to the transgender guidelines) to respond to an evolving understanding of sex/gender. Unfortunately, the science is not up to the challenge laid down by the law.
Interestingly, the new IOC policy guidelines for transgender athletes says that you only have to show that your T levels have been below 5 for 12 months, and declare yourself female. No surgery is required.
In fact, now that you mention it. A man can compete in female sports under the Transgender policy, which says that they have to show their T levels are below 5 nMol/L for 12 months.
To an extent. But I understand what he is getting at. He should perhaps be using challenges of binary sex assignment for Semenya. I think as it pertains to Trans athletes (same principle of T below a limit applies), then it’s what sport has tried to do.