The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
“Of course trans people aren’t saying they are the opposite sex!!”
Quoting @MythinformedMKE: The transgender self-imposed struggle session that Trevor Noah is undergoing here is priceless. He knows men aren’t women, squirms and squirms.
I have encountered trans people I think are going into surgery with their eyes open, but I guess she strikes me as powerfully as someone that hasn’t done that.
Lots of people make bad decisions though, and again, if she wasn’t trying to advocate, I wouldn’t go out of my way.3
Thanks Emma, but I don’t know if there is any conversation to be had. (Long text coming, too busy this morning to make it concise--sorry!)
Jane jumped on a random tweet that was a specific response to a specific claim—not a brag or an invitation to compare level of proficiency. She’s is setting up a standard in which the only way for me to “win” would be to spend the next 5 days writing essays. Obviously, I can’t do that. So she wins.
Regardless, my main criticism of feminism has nothing to do with her questions, but I’m not very inclined to speak with her about it. We all have our emotional limits—and mine is that I can’t stand condescension or intellectual gatekeeping. I don’t believe one needs to be able to recite Butler/Serrano by heart to hold substantive criticisms of trans/queer identities, for ex—common sense and logic really do go a long way. (I am also annoyed at insults I’ve been receiving from feminists who have no idea of who I am. But I won’t hold their 1st world privilege against them in debate—I don’t think it is required to critique my claims).
This debate reminds me of a similar one I had a few years ago re: intersectionality. I critiqued it on its practical effects on women’s rights (an effect I knew well from my experience in activism), and many began demanding that I “read Crenshaw”. But in fact I *had* read Crenshaw, or at least the majority of her published works that are available online. The truth is, however, I only read them for one reason: I didn’t want to be accused of not having read Crenshaw. It is obvious from reading even one piece of hers that you are never going to be hit with some genius insight. And I never was.
Similarly, I am not particularly impressed by most modern feminist writers and thinkers. My level of familiarity with 2nd wave is largely due to a similar impulse—to avoid being discredited by the Dr. Professor PhDs of the world. Now I wonder whether even that even that was a waste of my time—as, evidently, familiarity is not enough. I have to submit full blown essays. To hell with that, then.
But I did see that Jane responded to my initial question about a definition of Patriarchy. It is good, and meaty. I appreciate that, Jane, thank you.
It does always seem to happen this way because females (both trans-identifying and otherwise) are less willing to tolerate social disapproval in order to get what they want.
It’s not a moral defect, but a consequence of being the smaller, weaker animal.
https://x.com/therealpocus/status/1682012885923364864?s=46&t=9UDy8KqpGJL4PDPwEWSPwA
Quotes a post by T38332; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The last school shooter who was trans was ftm too. I don't recall whether they were "medically transitioning", but I would bet that they were. The relevant factor here is testosterone.
C2 false claimshand-codedmedical harmshooter attributionviolence terror
“What happens to trans people when there is no more gender ideology?”
They continue to live their lives! Except now, they accept the reality of sex + fantasy of the soul-like “gender”, and largely give up ingesting synthetic hormones and surgically removing healthy parts.
Of course teenagers have no capacity for understanding the horrors they are signing themselves up for--in large part, no one really does.
There is no settled science, almost nothing at all to give informed consent *to*.
https://www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids
The thing is, Greer is wrong (and her denial isn’t unrelated to the deeper denials of the trans movement).
Female is real, femininity is real. The latter is induced partially by social expectations, sure, but primarily defined by biology.