The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Some assume that this means I hate trans people or whatever, and this is where I extend the analogy.
Whatever my feelings towards faith, I don't hate believers. My family is filled with them!
Why is it hard to accept I don't hate people who don't share my views on gender?
Even if I had nothing but hate in my heart for all trans people, it wouldn’t make the point itself incorrect, nor would it eliminate harm to the women in question.
You should consider why you think it more important that I have the correct internal state than whether I am right.
Because in the past, self-ID did not grant men into female spaces. It does now, because trans activists have demanded that self-ID be the criterion by which we determine "gender".
If all you need to be a trans woman is self-ID, AND being trans grants you unfettered access to certain exclusive spaces, it is *a certainty* that some will lie to get access.
Anytime I bring up the mere possibility, my replies are filled with deliberate obtuseness. “Are you saying trans people are liars?!?”
As if this is the one population of humanity that would not deceive for personal benefit.
The average person might be sympathetic to trans people, but they are largely confused by this issue, don't understand gender ID, and do not believe social norms / legal categories should be destroyed in favor of it.
They’ll ignore that too—they will pretend it would have happened anyway, that the norms which prevented men like this from entering women’s spaces do nothing.
At some point, that tune will shift to one of negotiation: how man women hurt vs how many trans people “validated”?
I remember, very clearly, being told that trans people understand that they are biologically the opposite sex, and instead are making a claim only about a deep-seated internal sense called "gender".
Increasingly, however, I see instead claims about sex.
What is going on?
The assumption, as always, is that someone either "is" or "isn't" trans--as if it is an inherent, immutable quality and not a modern construct deeply influenced (even, determined) by culture, peer group, and politics.
Quoting @janecoaston: Yes, therapy aimed at making people not be trans is conversion therapy, and conversion therapy is bad.
Every time I tweet something vaguely critical about gender ideology, I get abuse by (what appear to be) trans women.
Not many socially acceptable contexts remaining in the West where biological males can treat females this way.
Many trans people believe that trans status is simply what you are - in a deep, inherent, unchangeable way.
GC/Terfs seem to believe that transgenderism is due to a whole host of factors, but that it is not necessarily "inherent" or unchangeable (like, say, being an anorexic).
I was not quite a tomboy (I did not like roughhousing) - but I was close. I preferred legos to dolls, hated "girly dress" and the idea of becoming like the women I knew. I was envious of boys and men.
I would have found the trans narrative extremely enticing.
Quotes a post by T54722; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Purely anecdotally, one of the (many) reasons I dismiss the "I have a lady/man brain" theory is that all of the trans people I have met (and I have met many - I am in activism, after all) retain much of the behaviors and mannerisms of their natal sex.
There are people who believe the are meant to not have one limb or another, and go through great lengths to remove said limbs.
Do you believe these people are analogous to trans people? And what does that mean in terms of policy?