The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
When people are facing real issues, and the economy is usually number one, wedge issues like what other people allow their kids to do doesn't even register in the top ten. I also think normies have trans fatigue at this point.
Yeah, this has been my stance on this whole thing. Why the need to share such a private thing with the world, and also why do so many people care? Adults can do what they want with their bodies, but it doesn't make it need to know public information. And I swear these stories are jut there to rage bait people which ends up hurting the trans community in the end.
What I don’t get, is the solution seems so simple. Have an GBT wing of prisons (some already have this because gay and “trans” are assaulted at high numbers in prison) for non-violent criminals, and for rapist and murderers they can go in the regular male prison.
Exactly, and I can see why the strategy for this has been to tell this suffering in silence that they are not alone. I was thinking about this more, because I’m in an interesting place. As a combat vet, I have seen the military fight just to get Soldiers to seek help, but that goes against their mental wiring, they see it as being a burden and weak. On the other side I have seen the “trans” community basically turn it into a foregone conclusion if a person doesn’t get their way. They have more so planted the seed in many people’s heads as if it is normal and acceptable. same solution, same outcome, but for very different reasons.
Idk, but we will have to sit down and talk about it sometime.
Imagine thinking that someone who says ‘live your life how you want, but don’t try force others to participate’ is “Hate-filled.” The constant attacks on @jk_rowling, a moderate on the issue, are destroying the acceptance of “trans” people.
Quoting @TheAdvocateMag: The Harry Potter author has made no secret of her hate-filled anti-trans views. https://www.advocate.com/news/people/jk-rowling-transphobia-ranked?utm_campaign=mrf-twitter-TheAdvocateMag&utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&mrfcid=202609016a941b4025f0945b0a0db6c7
You can correct me if I’m wrong about her views, but there is no moderate position that thinks minors should be allowed to medicalize, or that trans women are women. And if im not mistaken doesn’t she think it is a her right to use the womens room?
I hate that she has to continue to say this. I agree with everything she says in this statement. JK Rowling is not the “trans” hating boogeyman the activist want to make her out to be. In fact she is quite moderate on the issue.
Quoting @jk_rowling: My position is that gender dysphoria is a real, painful condition and that for some adults, the only way they may feel able to resolve that inner conflict is transition. If that’s the road they choose I wish them long life and happiness and I would vigorously oppose any discrimination against them when it comes to employment, housing or voting rights.
I do not believe children have the capacity to consent to treatments that may leave them infertile and, in some cases, anorgasmic. Multiple studies have shown that gender dysphoria in childhood and adolescence is not uncommon, for gay kids particularly, but it also occurs in, for example, straight girls who hate the idea of becoming women and sometimes, tragically, in children who’ve been abused. The available evidence shows that in the majority of cases, gender dysphoria resolves after the person has gone through adolescence. I am strongly opposed to the experimental treatment of blocking puberty in dysphoric children. I believe trans activists have behaved hugely unethically and irresponsibly in pretending that there is good evidence that these treatments are beneficial (there isn’t), that puberty blockers are completely reversible (there is a mounting body of evidence to suggest they aren’t) or that children are likely to kill themselves if denied blockers (there is no evidence to support this and suicide prevention charities warn against making such statements, due to the very real danger of suicide contagion.)
Of course, not all trans-identified people are dysphoric. Erotic transvestism, also known as autogynephilia, (getting a sexual thrill out of dressing as/pretending to be a woman) has been around for a very long time. I believe lesbians are entitled to exclude straight, cross-dressing men from their dating pools without being accused of bigotry and worse (same goes for gay men with trans-identified women). It’s profoundly homophobic to attack gay people for being same-sex attracted.
I don’t believe anyone, adult or child, is ‘born in the wrong body.’ That is an unfalsifiable, quasi-religious belief. A person may *feel* as if they’re in the wrong body, but humans cannot literally change sex. However they identify, men don’t belong in the single-sex spaces for which women fought so hard.
Not really, John Money claimed that nurture could be used to overcome nature. What it inevitably showed is that there would have to be some nature made scientific reason for someone to have dysphoria and for taking hormones to work as treatment. His horrible experience showed that you can’t make someone gay or “trans” nature will eventually catch up to them. A parent can influence patterns but that will eventually result in desistance as the child gets older.
So Blaire White doesn’t belong in a homosexual group? Eventhough she is a homosexual? Because from my perception, drop the T means the T is a disqualifier. And you can read above why they were connected in the first place, because the public prejudices were the same, and really no matter the relationship type they are in. Also, you may be able to answer this, what were the laws on trans getting married? Because it would seem like in alot of instances it was also banned.
Yes, and I have been fighting the ideology for what the last 6 years publicly (and really even longer when I was kicked out of trans Reddit groups back in 2018). My point is it doesn’t make sense to drop the transsexuals, because there is a common fight from the same prejudices.
As far as how far it goes back, the first bottom surgeries happened in the early 1900s. So it’s not exactly new, but the queer activism is, as queer theory was developed in gender studies courses in the 90s (with roots going back further) and only hit mainstream in the last 10-15 years.
Just describing non-homosexuals as fetishistic doesn’t make any sense. Again, I’m bisexual, and also had sex based dysphoria from my earliest memories. So are you saying children have fetishes? Also, the last part you have moved the goal post, but again, since most “queers” again are female. For insight females makeup nearly all the NB crowd, which makes about about 28.5% of the “trans” community. Where FTM is around 30%. What happens is you get a confirmation bias, or a feeling that it is all fetishist because that is who gets the most attention, when in reality they are a very small percentage of the group that creates the preception for the group as a whole.
I am a former LCR GA member and content creator for OutspokenUSA. And while I am bisexual and don’t use the trans label anymore, it sad to say that I don’t feel welcome at an organization which I did so much work for. Because from my perspective it seems that when it comes to the drop the T orgs, it doesn’t matter if you are LGB, (I’m bisexual) if they would classify you as T, then that is a disqualifier.
Your stats are wrong. The vast majority are homosexual, and over the last 10 years the ratio shifted to being overwhelmingly female. In fact those that are transsexual males make up about 28% of the “trans” population.
Also, they do have a lot in common, and it really comes down to prejudice received. Me for example, (now I don’t use the trans label other than for ease of private conversation, but let’s go with it) I’m bisexual, if I’m in a relationship with a man, that’s a homosexual relationship, so technically part of the G, but socially it only brings up anti-gay prejudice if someone knows I’m a male, but it happens. Now, if I’m dating a woman, it gets perceived as a homosexual relationship socially, eventhough it’s not, and it brings all the prejudices that come along with it. And even then once a bigot knows one of the people is male, they are still targeted for being feminine.
Lastly, with these drop the T orgs, my perception is that even if you are LGB, if you fall under the T it’s a disqualifier to be included. And to me it’s sad to feel like another organization, LCR, that I have done so much work for (paid and volunteer) feels now I’m not welcome. But I guess this is why I did away with the collectivist orgs and labels a while ago.
I mean you’re not wrong. Though I would add that it wasn’t really the “trans” community (which is now dominated mostly by females) it was leftist in general. I think much of the harm came from the AWFL “ally’s” who thought they should be an authority to speak for “trans” people.
Texas Children's Hospital settles lawsuit for $10M and Detrans clinic after being sued by whistleblower @[private account] the DOJ, and Texas AG took forth the case for False Claims Act violations in relation to trans related care.
You can’t change your sex. It is physically impossible, so the term trans simply means using extreme body modification to appear as the opposite sex. And without biological sex informing gender, then gender is meaningless.
I can’t believe this is something we are still arguing over. Of course “trans women” are a subset of men. Otherwise how do you define man or woman if not based on sex?
However this is why they continue with the language traps. To keep us from discussing the actual issues.
It’s not transphobic to say girls should not compete against biological men, and “trans” people don’t need “ally’s” out here that are actually doing more harm to their acceptance. But what would I know?
To get so wrapped around the weeds of a single word is retarded. A man is an adult human male, 90% of the population use male and man synonymously. So her saying "biological men," is not transphobic, in fact it is making a distinction between trans men and males. Where saying biological males is redundant.
But this is the language trap being played, they want you arguing over terms used rather than the issue. I use sex based terms for this reason, but 99% of the population doesn't, and it makes it impossible to have a conversation about the real issue, which is males don't belong in female sports...
Around 20% of trans identified adults served in the military while 9-10% of regular adults do. So they served at nearly 2x the rate. Facts don’t care about your feelings…
I don’t have an issue with this as a policy, as I knew a ton of soldiers on TRT when I was in. However, the issue I have is that they use the excuse of “not being able to get medication in combat” as a reason to kick trans identify people out. Historically trans veterans are over represented in comparison to their general population, and most did their job and did it well.
I think there would be a lot of conservatives defending him if he said he didn’t want to works for a black, Muslim, gay, or trans person, tbh. Though many would draw a line in different areas, and the vast majority call it out for all.
True, lets honestly stop shaming everyone who has a preference in who they date. It's not transphobic to not want to date trans people, it's not racist for not being attracted to certain races, its not homophobic for not being gay...
Absolutely, she (and you) have always been consistent. And your part in that article, is basically identical to what Rowling has stated. I have apparently been so tuned out to the gender space for so long that there are now new words I didn't know, Like the "ultras." And it is interesting because we are now seeing these groups try and put people like you or Rowling through TRA type struggle sessions for not agreeing 100%.
I think the only thing I have changed on is my use (or lack there of) of gendered language. Gender is simply meaningless at this stage. Which also means I really don't even use the term "trans" or LGBT "community" at all either. I'm done with the tribalism of it all.
Absolutely, she (and you) have always been consistent. And your part in that article, is basically identical to what Rowling has stated. I have apparently been so tuned out to the gender space for so long that there are now new words I didn't know, Like the "ultras." And it is interesting because we are now seeing these groups try and put people like you or Rowling through TRA type struggle sessions for not agreeing 100%.
I think the only thing I have changed on is my use (or lack there of) of gendered language. Gender is simply meaningless at this stage. Which also means I really don't even use the term "trans" or LGBT "community" at all either. I'm done with the tribalism of it all.
Absolutely, she (and you) have always been consistent. And your part in that article, is basically identical to what Rowling has stated. I have apparently been so tuned out to the gender space for so long that there are now new words I didn't know, Like the "ultras." And it is interesting because we are now seeing these groups try and put people like you or Rowling through TRA type struggle sessions for not agreeing 100%.
I think the only thing I have changed on is my use (or lack there of) of gendered language. Gender is simply meaningless at this stage. Which also means I really don't even use the term "trans" or LGBT "community" at all either. I'm done with the tribalism of it all.
Did you know that it is ok to not like individual trans people? Or to disagree with people publicly? Hateful means you treat everyone in a group negatively simply because they are part of said group. And she fights for freedom of speech, and har you call discrimination is not…
100% with all of this. Freedom of speech comes with freedom of association as well. Say what you want, and a can choose to associate with you or not.
The other issue with linguistic prescription, is that it tends to be what I call a language trap. Where we end up arguing for ages about language used rather than debating solutions to problems. I mean, look at how much time you have already spend debating your choice to use “she/her” for a friend. This is why when discussing “trans issues” I have removed all gendered language from my vocabulary, it’s meaningless at this point. Sex-based terms are still rooted in reality. I also don’t even use terms like “trans” or LGBT, etc. because those can be used to derail debate.
It’s incredibly insane. In her next comment down, she refers to her male trans friend as “she/her.” That is going to piss a lot of people off in the rad fem movement, but she takes basically the same stance I do. If I respect you, I will call you what you present as, if I don’t, I will use your name for the sake of argument.
The issue with non-profit activism organizations is that once the issues that they work on are solved or even get better, they don’t just shut down, they either change their mission, or they have to create the problem they are supposedly against. For the SPLC, hate was not profitable anymore, so they manufactured it. For the Pride movement, after gay marriage was legalized, they created a problem with a supposed solution (Trans rights), and it has been profitable for nearly 10 years…
So the SPLCs was supposedly to fight hate, but because there wasn’t enough hate to fight, they funded the hate so that their donors would give them more money? Do I have that right?
It’s actually just like the Pride movement after gay marriage was legalized needed a cause to rally donor support so they created a problem with a solution in Charlotte, NC which kicked off the “trans rights” after the normal gays went home.
Also, there have been a lot of LGBT employees and former employees over the years consistently defend the company for being great to work for, even some “trans” people saying when they came out it was positive.
That’s not true either. Trying to convince them that they are trans for being a GNC gay, yes, but not if they came to it themselves. Conversion therapy is the act of actively trying to force them into acting how you want. Nurture doesn’t beat nature
Which I don't think she actually has selected the entire group, as she has always been nice to me, and still posts reasonable views. but you can't fault someone who has been relentlessly attacked, with very few in that group standing for them, and not form a negative opinion. I don't believe in holding views of entire groups based on the actions of a few either, but I don't view trans activist in a good light, especially when their ideals allow bad actors to put others safety at risk.
No male can ever get to female performance levels, they will always have an advantage. That has been proven. If you were right, Trans men would compete with men...
The idea that these people are still trying to claim that @jk_rowling is “transphobic” for saying “I know and love trans people” but sex is real, and to deny that stifles meaningful conversation is baffling to me. Like this is why the movement is a joke, and has lost almost all global support. Good job…
Quotes a post by A2140; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
In order to be trans you have to medicalize. yes... Otherwise you're just a gender non-conforming person. Dysphoria doesn't magically appear later in life, but it does present in teen years after trauma, or due to a social contagion. But true dysphoria is lifelong. But that doesn't make one trans...
Are you capable of understanding that "trans people" are those with sex-based dysphoria and permanently medicalize, and since kids can't consent to medicalization, they simply can't be "trans." Sure their are dysphoric kids, but the vast majority grow out of it...
Absolutely, that elevation put “trans” in the main stream and made being “trans” cool, this amplifying the social contagion. Then doctors used it as the catch all diagnosis for all mental health issues. Thousands of kids permanently harmed because people were too afraid to question “the science.” Between this and COVID, the medical community has done immense harm to its own credibility.
Why do trans people want to work for companies that hate them? I never understand these “civil rights” arguments. Why do you want to force people who don’t like you to take your money or force them to keep you employed in what would probably be a pretty hostile environment?
It's not really the same hormones. It's more the same as they give post-menopausal women. My thought is that "trans" is the symptom, rather than the cause of the issues that are going on. We have a mental health crisis in the world, most of the people medicalizing for sex based dysphoria don't, actually have it but are suffering from multiple other co-morbidities, that are going untreated as doctors see this, along with SSRI's as the easy fix, when it's just surface level.
Erica has been consistent on this, and is honestly one of the most dangerous people against the gender ideologues an medical associations. I remember her (and Marci Bowers) interview with @AbigailShrier back in like 2021 warning against this. https://quillette.com/2022/01/06/a-transgender-pioneer-explains-why-she-stepped-down-from-uspath-and-wpath/
Saying ‘dress how you want, call yourself what you want, but don’t demand others to do so…’ isn’t “anti-trans” it’s in fact a reasonable compromise. If you are a person who goes against cultural norms and are happy, then by all means, but if that means you won’t be happy until society bends to your will, then you won’t ever be happy and you weren’t ready to medicalize in the first place, and you never will be.
Well you follow me so you know that people with dysphoria don’t actually believe you can change sex or that trans women are women… you also know it’s the opposite of a delusion, as it is an uncomfortability of what is actually there.
She never even said that… she said she may have said things in the past that were hurtful to trans people in general, as the half sibling of her son is trans. No where in there does it say she is ok with medicalizing minors.
Except she never even entertained the idea. She showed regret for how she spoke about trans people in the past and how that may have hurt her son's "sister" (Elon's estranged child Vivian).
This makes sense. Fat in general tend to be high in calorie, so if you don’t reduce calories elsewhere to account for high saturated fat content then it’s going to be harmful and really cause inflammation. I am kinda fascinated by nature in this way. Your body needs fat to process protein efficiently. Well in red meat and fish it gives you both. Eggs, you need the fat in the yoke to process the protein in the whites. Then unsaturated fats like in avocado do wonders for the body, and if you don’t use it you get rid of it. Trans fats are what people need to worry most about. Good vs bad fat, just like good vs bad glucose.