The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
You know when you put something in quotes you actually have to post exactly what they said. Your clip doesn’t show them saying “if you were born a boy.” The clip appears as though she is saying we need to stop shaming boys and men for simply being masculine. Nothing to do with trans males.
Yes that’s what this means. NB could mean anything, I don’t consider it to be trans, but the ideologues do and so does the latest study. It could mean medical intervention though so it’s still significant, that 80% of females ID that way.
Yes. A recent study showed it was around 33% trans women (males) 34% trans men, and the rest “non-binary” which we don’t have the breakdown from the study yet on them, but others have shown NB to be around 80% female.
I mean we are still in a state where the vast majority of the population don’t even understand what gender dysphoria is. This includes a lot of people who claim a trans identity, saying it’s about “feeling like the opposite sex.” (It’s not) The other side thinks it’s a “delusion” when it’s the opposite.
Until there is a common understanding, we will always be stuck at square one. Second, the vast majority of trans identified people are females. A fact that seems to escape everyone. While everyone focuses on males, gender ideology is swallowing the young female population. And as such when coming up with policy changes, no one thinks about where those females go when proposing solutions, and how the law must act equally based on sex. Though I think the two examples (prisons and sports) are fairly easy to make sweeping legislation.
In reality I think we need to stop using the term “trans” or transgender, as it has been captured by the woke, and use “dysphoric” and “medicalized.” Because “trans” is a choice, having dysphoria isn’t. So it’s more clear.
I’ve personally just stopped using gendered language, as it’s meaningless. As at its core a trans woman would simply be a man, not even necessarily in a dress or makeup, but I would argue with these people that it’s only ones who medicalized and attempted to blend into society (that doesn’t work for them though) so it’s pointless for me to play into the language traps.
So I use terms like dysphoric males, medicalized, etc. and personally just try to be an individual, and not part of any collective, because I really don’t fit into any of the “communities” around this or any boxes people want to created around the issue. And I think that’s the way forward. Collectivism causes division, while individualism creates nuanced solutions.
I wish more were willing to stand for rational dysphoric people, while still being able to to call out the extremes in the trans community. Unfortunately I’ve lost too many friends who said they supported me, then eventually turned their backs when the collectivist mindset took hold.
Oh yeah, I have talked extensively on the second and third order effects on the issue. Here is me talking about it on chatting with Candace last spring. The NC law failed because of how many women got labeled trans and got assaulted and arrested. https://www.instagram.com/reel/DJ7xksCzI63/?igsh=cDdmdXk3YTljNmQ2
Yeah that’s true, the trans-identified male population is the vast minority of “trans” people. And I’ve talked about the 14A aspect to these things. And I’ve often advocated for 3rd spaces in gov buildings so I have no issue with this bill. As long as they don’t do what NC (and CA) did and violate private property rights.
Yep. When you grew up in the 90s gay and dysphoric males tended to overcompensate by trying to be masculine because anything feminine was bullied and shamed. Yet, now all trans identified males who medicalized later are assumed as fetishist, simply because they overcompensated for their femininity in their younger years.
Veterans are more likely to complete a suicide. And I doubt you understand why the rate is so high for trans, even after full transition, or realize that it would be higher if they banned adults from being able to try to deal with their dysphoria.
Yep. I see it on a more localized level with the transgender overtaking transsexuals, but that is just the Q moving left. The TS was the easiest since it’s the smallest, but I do fear their goal is to destroy the entire community with their Marxist ideology.
Where in the bible does it designate being Trans as a Sin? And if it does do that, does that mean TRA's are right and that Trans people have been around forever?
Wait, so what clothes you wear determines if you are trans or not? have there actually always been trans people as the TRA's claim, going back to the bible? Also what era of clothes? Because that gets confusing too. hmm. so much to ponder.
This is what I don't get from these types of "christians." How is being trans a sin, if you fully acknowledge your sex but decide you don't want to live according to sex based stereotypes? Is ever person who has plastic surgery sinning for doing so, because they didn't accept the body god gave them as is? See to think simply being trans is a sin, you have to think there were Trans people in biblical days. Which means that you have to believe that the TRA's are right in the fact that trans has been around forever. Because if they were not in the bible, then how did the bible designate it a sin?
I covered this a couple years ago. It's the leftist ideology, Antifa transformed to Trantifa. Also a little bit of internet bias. https://humanevents.com/2023/04/08/sara-higdon-how-progressives-have-co-opted-the-trans-community-to-push-their-hateful-ideology
They have zero self awareness, and have zero idea how to win hearts and minds. Seriously if they want to points out issues with passing sweeping bathroom legislation, they wouldn’t have sent trans women to break the law, but trans men into the women’s room to show the flaw in the law.
Trans was never anything but Transsexuals until about 2 seconds ago. It’s funny watching my people l (on both sides of the trans debate) not have a clue what words mean. TV is one of the most obvious ones.
Yeah, the "Family" locker room at the gym I go to has like 7 locked rooms for changing, and no minor is allowed in there without a parent present. This should be seen as the easy compromise for trans people in gyms.
Yes, I use unisex spaces where available, and follow the rules where ever I go. In the end, I leave it to private businesses. I think in the end, it would lead to more single occupancy spaces, and floor to ceiling privacy like in much of Europe. And yes, prior to 2016 it was basically passibility. Because otherwise you have to pass a law like they tried (and failed) in North Carolina, which saw more masculine presenting females getting arrested for using the women's, or like the trans man (female) who was assaulted and arrested in South Carolina a couple months ago for using the women's.
I think that is up to each business to decide. Then people can choose to support or not support based on their rules. Thats capitalism, and private property is the base of all liberty. Because the other option is females passing as males, being forced into the ladies room. Though personally, I'm at the point of requiring surgery before you can legally be considered trans.
I was thinking this the other day. I kinda wish they did name Elliott because trans-identified males make up about 33.5% of the Trans population (and only about 12% of them are actually dysphoric) but they are the ones that get all the attention. Maybe if Elliott won, the guys would actually care about losing their titles. On the other hand, I don't know if men would actually care, but maybe hollywood men. 🤷♀️
It’s amazing that these things are happening where government has forced selfID regulations. And when NC tried opposite legislation, it failed. In SC a few months ago, a trans identified female was assaulted and arrested for using the women’s room as you wish they would. The free market solution solves for all.
California has forced selfID, the gyms hands are tied. This is why we should advocate for private property rights, rather than thinking the state should dictate their rules. Because some states will make rules you like, and others you don’t. I’ve spoken out alot against Californias laws, since the first article I ever wrote about the Wi spa incident. But I also disagree with the 2017 North Carolina law that had many unintended consequences (like forcing trans men in womens spaces, and masc lesbians being kicked out of women’s restrooms too) I think the free market should decide. So while I don’t know if it’s fair to put this on the gym (we don’t know their policy) if we lived in my system I would agree with you here.
Idk about these gyms that cater to adults, but those that are family gyms do. Which is what I use where ever available. The biggest issue here, is that California law promotes this. They have forced SelfID laws, so the gym is following the law. If the states respect private property rights, the gyms can police this up, without forcing trans men in the women’s to cause just as much confusion. These people wouldn’t use the unisex space regardless, so it should be up to businesses to set their rules, and then allow the free market work, by people choosing where to spend their money. Right now if you live in CA you can’t escape this.
Yes. do you understand that a "higher rate" is not the same as saying a larger population? Think of it this way there are 33 million veterans, because that is 10% of the gen population size. There are 294,000 trans veterans because that is 21% of the trans population, That is a higher rate, not a higher population.
OMG. do you know what "at a higher rate means?" It is not a percentage of overall Soldiers, it is a per-capita in a population. 21% of trans people in 2014 werer veterans. While only 10% of the general population is. Thus Trans people serve at a higher rate than the general population. 10% of 330 Million, is of course going to be higher than 21% of 1.7 Million (total trans population in 2014)
Its not false. About 10% of the general population serves in the military, about 19% of the Trans population has. The study was conducted even before you were allowed to serve openly as a trans person.
You realize you just said you served during DADT right, so how would you know who was trans? But here is a study from 2014 (before they were allowed to serve openly still) see they get out, before transitioning. Prior to 2016, most tried to use the military as a way of curing dysphoria or at the very least over compensation for it. https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/publications/trans-military-service-us/
True, but i think it is as I predicted two years ago (which stemmed from a 2018 prediction I made as well) Progressives SelfID in for queer theory, then selfID out when they destroy the acceptance rate. I'm happy it is happening though. https://humanevents.com/2023/04/08/sara-higdon-how-progressives-have-co-opted-the-trans-community-to-push-their-hateful-ideology
If this is accurate it seems the second half of my prediction is coming to fruition. (and thank god) Progressives used self-ID to commit violence in the name of queer theory. Now the acceptance rate is in the tank, they will selfID out. https://humanevents.com/2023/04/08/sara-higdon-how-progressives-have-co-opted-the-trans-community-to-push-their-hateful-ideology
Quoting @epkaufm: 1/ NEW: trans identification is in free fall among the young
(h/t @[private account] data in particular)
C2 false claimscontagionpolitical enemyviolence terror
Yes and no. Right now the best data we have shows Dysphoria is associated with the chemical imbalance in the womb also known to cause homosexuality. It’s why people happy with their decision to medicalize are almost always people who knew at their earliest memories they wanted to be the opposite sex, and that incongruence persisted until adulthood. But your talking about transgenderism the ideology, which thinks dysphoria can come on at any age, and that makes a person “trans” though often it is something else going on. Which is why you would be correct in the assertion that simply claiming to be trans is not innate. Fact is though human rights are not based on identity, they are equal for everyone. (Which is something that society has forgotten as well with giving protection status to certain identities)
Not only that, most “trans” people are homosexual or bi, so this doesn’t do much. It is the Q that co-opted the “community.” Not that the T but all of it.
The Q is an ideology rooted in postmodernism. It co-opted the T, changing it from transsexual (dysphoric people who still live within the binary) to transgender where anyone can be as long as they say they are. Originally it was LGBT because most TS were homosexual, and received the same prejudices when coming out. And where this prejudices still exists today they still do. Also perception, while a trans woman in a relationship with a man is homosexual, it appears to the general population as straight, (if the person passes) while if that TW is dating a woman, it’s a straight relationship, but appears as a gay relationship to society and will receive the same prejudices where they exist (which is not many places). Now however the Queering of the “community” having overtaken the OG transsexuals has really just made everyone think the whole group are crazy selfID loons. I mean more people in the community now ID as “non-binary” than trans men or women…
Yeah I look at this video and I don’t think Charlie was saying it was “wrong” to be trans or in a gay relationship, but that it’s not ideal. I agree with that. Ideally we would all fit into these nice moral boxes, but none of us do. Like you said it doesn’t mean he hates the person, I think the fact he befriended people like Buck is a testament to that.
I did an interview recently where I agreed that social norms where good where there was a standard deviation of people who fit in that norm, and the outliers where not necessarily celebrated as the norm but still allowed to live authentically.
I’m sorry to hear this. I agree with @chloecole post. Log off and work on yourself. I understand not fitting in with the TRA community, but also not fitting in with TERFs. I started using “post-trans” to be done with the labels and just be you. https://x.com/sarahigdon_/status/1882182232682434591?s=46&t=qBTO5wUE433lYo1qpiO7wA
Quoting @SaraHigdon: Moving on from ‘Trans’: Why the label no longer suits me.
It is time for me to enter the era of "Post-Trans," and eliminate the use of collectivist gendered language used to distract.
So do you believe in "dog whistles" now too? Essentially that is what you are saying. He could have been talking about the rhetoric of the right prior to the shooting, he could have been pointing how people blamed the Trans community, the gamer community, etc. all to score political points. Since that is what he said right after "themselves." this is what the left did with the "fine people" hoax. They say "we know what you meant."
Also when watching the clip he didn’t say the shooter was MAGA, as so many are claiming. You could interpret it that way. Another interpretation is he was criticizing them blaming it on the trans partner, the trans community, every democrat, etc. it was delivered as an opinion, I think it was in bad taste, but an opinion none the less. and the FCC has no justification to go after them.
The "feels like a woman" was a way for people to describe it in a way that people would understand. It really meant "want to be a woman." because its obvious that you can't actually feel like something that you have never lived as, thus dont know how they feel, And I would assume that even women could not describe what being a woman "feels like" since every single person feels differently. The term however morphed and was used by activist to create this "trans women are women" as a way to control the population and push their post-modern agenda.
And yes I should say it is an uncomfortability with both primary and secondary sex characteristics. I would feel this way no matter what. Like I was uncomfortable being naked by myself. I was a person who tried to be more masculine. Heck I went into the Army hoping that getting jacked and being around hyper masculine dudes would help me feel more comfortable with my body and how I was born. It didn't, nothing helped until I explored myself for about 3 years.
Testosterone use in females is really tricky and yes can be dangerous if not monitored correctly, and there is something with the formula they use in the US which is causing issues in females. Which is actually why so many trans-identifying females end up coming off of it once they get the desired permanent effects. Now, Estrogen in Males is not as harsh, and tends to calm them down, also kills the sex drive. Part of the issue is so many who claim a trans identity are not doing anything other than claiming it so SelfID is a major issue. Using Testosterone on a male can bad on the body too, we see all these issues in gym rats who take more to get ripped.
I’ve never said I was. Even the DSM diagnosis criteria shows this. The misconception started when it changed from Transsexual to Transgender, and it use to be a way for people to describe a concept that is hard to explain to people who have no idea the feeling. Then activist ran hard with it to force acceptance on society.
The shooter was in a homosexual relationship… “Trans woken” make up 32.7% of the “trans community.” “Trans men” make up 34.2# and”non-binary” (which are overwhelmingly female) make up 33.1%. Only 23% say that are “gay” which in their terms means heterosexual. So this statement makes no sense.
You’re the one making the accusation… the burden of proof is on you. But the answer is 5 mass shootings committed by a trans person in the last 5 years out or 2,796. So .1% of all mass shootings, from a population that is 1% of the overall population…
@[private account] I see the way that people talk about post-op trans people, and feel for the detransitioners who can’t reverse that, but still have to feel the vile comments even still.
Which goes to my point. They don’t believe in transsexual, because it still fits within the binary. Gender is a meaningless word, which they used to take over the T with postmodern ideology the moment they began using TG. I don’t use the “trans” label anymore because it’s not a community, it’s become an ideology rooted in critical theory that people can selfid into. I don’t fit in the so-called community.
Fully agree. I wrote this article two years ago, about how and why the critical theorist co-opted the T and pushed Queer Theory after the CRT push of 2020 failed to have the effect they wanted. https://humanevents.com/2023/04/08/sara-higdon-how-progressives-have-co-opted-the-trans-community-to-push-their-hateful-ideology
I don’t line using the term transgenderism, because gender ideology is only a small part that co-opted the T to push the queer, leftist, postmodern Marxist agenda that has spread among young people. they needed a “marginalized” group to garner sympathy. https://humanevents.com/2023/04/08/sara-higdon-how-progressives-have-co-opted-the-trans-community-to-push-their-hateful-ideology
Well if they used the actual definition of GD to consider people trans then it makes sense. The issue is selfID and other issues making it so the true dysphoric people have become a small minority in their own “community.”
I know exactly what he said. I have no issue with what he has said because the clips I have seen come from a place of faith. I think there is a little bit of ignorance he had based on what the trans movement has presented in terms of what dysphoria is, but I also know that wouldn’t matter, because in his faith he would be against any and all body modifications. This may be where we respectfully disagree like he did with Buck Angel, and agree to live and let live and not allow lifestyle choices divide us on what really matters and pray for each others souls.
So part of the issue is that they use “transgenderism”, the ideology, with a wide net which is usually hair queer theory. So we would have to first get terms right first. So should queer theory be ostracized from society through civil debate. Yes. It has been what most of my public life has centered around. However, idk even know what eradicate what “trans” means, because should adults be allowed to live as they see fit, have the extreme body mods that make them feel comfortable? Yes, same as anyone who goes under elective surgery. Should they be respected as members of society, I think so, but there should be no force in either direction. (Freedom of association works) the answer to me is open, honest dialogue. Adults can live their lives as they see fit and you don’t have to agree, but in no way should these things be force on kids, or should they ever be able to get life altering procedures (this includes breast implants, etc, for 16yr old females too)
It says that the roomate provided txt messages that helped nab Robinson, so it appears that this person tipped police off. If that’s the case, I think it should be show as an example that even some leftist trans people have a heart and will do the right thing for this one did so
If I’m not mistaken, Jeffrey has moderate views. He’s called out the Non-binary bs in the past too. Especially since the Q is erasing GNC gays with “trans”
No it’s accurate. When it’s a white Christian who does something wrong it’s not one to blame all white Christian’s, when a cop does something wrong it’s not ok to blame all cops, when a trans person does something wrong it’s not ok to blame all trans people, and when a black person does something wrong it’s not ok to blame all black people, when a Jewish person does something you don’t blame all Jews. Yet depending on what group you have a prejudice for, people will always try to cherry pick, pointing out their own hypocrisy. People are individuals and we should not judge them based on the identity groups they belong to.
Wait… so this is not about race, but two weeks ago it was about trans? Can we agree that we should not judge groups of people based on the actions of a few? https://x.com/defiyantlyfree/status/1960802803221455163?s=46&t=qBTO5wUE433lYo1qpiO7wA
Quoting @DefiyantlyFree: DHS confirms the shooter was transgender.
And I don’t want to hear a word about leftist virtue signaling or making the aggressors the victims.
There is no violence against transgender people.
Last I checked transgender people aren’t being hunted by mass sh**ters. It’s vice versa.
You missed the point. The drug addict was used by the left to say all cops are bad, the woman on her phone is being used to say all blacks are bad, both are politicization of a tragedy. Not two weeks ago, the school shooting was used to say all trans people are bad. It’s not about the victims anymore.
True. Everything is becoming a political puck. Two weeks ago it was the trans shooter, next time something bad happens it will be the next one. Agreed we need to teach people to be aware of their surroundings and what to do to stay safe, because there are crazy people of all groups.
This is why non-binary and trans have to be separate categories. You have Lauri, doing absolutely nothing but self proclaiming to be trans, yet clearly doesn’t have to deal with any actual social stigmas IRL because most people just see female. There is not transition to this “trans person.” Then she is sitting next to @blairewhite who has fully transitioned and integrated into society as if she were female, and Laurie is speaking as if they are the same.
Quotes a post by A1132; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It’s the watchful part of the exploratory model, with constant questioning them on their identity, and waiting to do any medical interventions. It’s what was done before 2018 and the current trend. Affirmation model is simply accepting that they are trans if they say they are and moving towards medicalization.
Yeah, I think changing it from Transexual to Transgender and making up Non-binary caused the biggest spikes. The T was added around 1990, and was about 1.4M people until just a couple years ago, yet now it’s 2.1M, just crossed 1% of the population, and 33% are NB. (So not actually trans) and the vast majority are female when historically males were mostly “trans”
I wrote about this a couple years ago after the Iowa shooting. I don’t think it is so much the “trans” identity, or gender dysphoria, especially when they are on Estrogen which is usually calming, but it is a big issue in the mental health profession https://humanevents.com/2024/01/08/sara-higdon-is-the-mental-health-community-using-trans-ideology-to-sweep-real-mental-health-problems-under-the-rug
If you believe true gender dysphoria is something that can be “taught” into someone, then you are on the side of John Money. The issue is that therapist today dont understand the DSM diagnosis, nor do they care. SelfID is king for them. Most “trans” don’t have GD.
Yep. This rise goes back to an article I wrote a couple years ago, about why the activists have made the shift, using gender identity to push their violent ideology (critical theory) https://humanevents.com/2023/04/08/sara-higdon-how-progressives-have-co-opted-the-trans-community-to-push-their-hateful-ideology
C2 false claimshand-codedideology cultpolitical enemyviolence terror
5 out of all the mass shootings in the last say 10 years, is not a high percent. Trans is actually under represented in that stat. I think there is more of a conversation to be had in regards to how the left has co-opted the label to perpetuate violence, (because yes there is a big issue with violence after antifa rebranded as trantifa) as well how the mental health community has failed by throwing pills at issues, which I think is closer to the root cause.
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentpolitical enemyviolence terror
I don’t think it’s hateful for discussing this. It ties into issues that we are seeing in that community and the mental health care community as a whole. There is a much bigger discussion that needs to happen. What I do find “hateful” is lumping in an entire group of people (who was co-opted by an extremist agenda) and blaming all for the actions of a few. I think that does a disservice to those who actually want to work on solving this issue. I have been discussing in depth the problems that culminated into the actions of the shooter yesterday, but because I live my life how I do, people think I should be locked up (or worse). I know that isn’t what you are doing here, but I do think that narrative also works to perpetuate this and masks the root issues, because it’s easy to blame “trans people” it’s hard to really understand the complex issues happening.
Bruh, facts don’t care about your feelings. How many trans shooters do you think there have been in say the last 10 years? Now how many mass shootings have there been? Just because your echo chamber ignores them when they don’t fit their narrative, doesn’t mean the data isn’t real.
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
Pretty much agree. Gender dysphoria is very rare, but currently it’s being overtaken by something different. And most for most of this new generation there is a combination of ideology, and medical incompetence at play. Therapist ignore more severe mental health issues in favor of claiming transitioning is the cure, then stack hormones with SSRIs, instead of really digging to the root of what is going on. Affirmation instead of the wait and see model has forced kids into the adult political sphere where they are made to fear and hate people who will “take their rights.” Which even for the general minor population, the political involvement and them being part of adult problems, is a problem and has severe effects on their mental health too. Lastly, many of the “trans kids” are like the goth kids, mostly loners looking for a place to belong, which just so happens to be the MO for most mass shooters (minus the goth kids part)
C3 dehumanizingcontagionmental illnessviolence terror
Not likely. Depending on how long the person has been on them there is a period where things feel a little irrational (a lot more emotional) as your body gets use to them. A lot of people who don’t understand the effects of hormones like to mistake correlation with causation. I have theories about a lot of this, but it’s mostly to do with co-morbidities not being treated, and trans pushed as the cure all. Brain development especially with the use of puberty blockers, but also the fact they love to stack SSRIs on top. Not to mention the politics being pushed onto minors and making them fear society and angry from lies told by leftist parents and teachers.
There have been 5 in the last 10 years, and are about .1% of all mass shootings. There was the hoax last December but it was actually a female not trans.
Here are the 5 in the last 10 years Grok mentioned. And remember the one in December which claims the girl was trans were completely made up? https://x.com/i/grok/share/M8MDPdCmFgdCahL5hctG3I7s9
I meant to note, that is a percentage of how many trans people were the perpetrator of a mass shooting between 2015 and 2023. Grok just noted to me though it is still about .1% of mass shooters that are trans
This doesn’t surprise me. I explained why a couple years ago. And now the “non-binary” aspect makes up 33%, transmen (females) 34%, transwomen (males) 32%. https://humanevents.com/2023/04/08/sara-higdon-how-progressives-have-co-opted-the-trans-community-to-push-their-hateful-ideology
Social contagion, most of it. They are counting “non-binary” which makes up 33% of this. The vast majority of this group are females, on top of 34% identify as trans men. On top of it 700k of that number are 13-17 years old. Speaks to a fad. Before 2018 it was about 1.4M.
Absolutely. And when you look at the evolution of who identifies this way, it went from males being the highest population, to being mostly females who identify as trans. Looking at the numbers. Most people who id as NB are female, by a lot. https://x.com/sarahigdon_/status/1959325905811046593?s=46&t=qBTO5wUE433lYo1qpiO7wA
Quoting @SaraHigdon: In 2022 that number was just 1.6 million. The 13-17 age group went from 300K-724K in just 3 years… now tell me there isn’t a social contagion aspect to this. This also shows that “Non-Binary” is 33% of that. One thing they don’t separate it based on sex, with trans identified females being a larger portion than males, I and perception of the NB crowd and historical data, I will assume that females probably double the amount of males in this population. 🤔
It use to be, until leftist ruined the acceptance rate of the community. There use to be an unwritten contract between trans women and women. That changed with SelfID laws.
First you forget public urination also gets an indecent exposure charge. They are attempting to prevent harm against women. It’s a double edged sword they will learn when trans men use the space. But you are never going to win the battle of public restrooms, and demanding access only comes across as a creep who wants access to women. So you have to compromise, you choose to medicalize and live your life this way, and part of that is waiting for the 3rd spaces. That’s how it works. Now, I will protect private property rights every day, because it’s on me and everyone else to vote with our dollars.
Listen I have said that the bathroom sign is about as good at stopping predators as a gun free zone sign is at stopping shootings, especially when forcing trans men into the women’s room, but in order for the debate to end, the reasonable agreement is 3rd spaces in government buildings.
In 2022 that number was just 1.6 million. The 13-17 age group went from 300K-724K in just 3 years… now tell me there isn’t a social contagion aspect to this. This also shows that “Non-Binary” is 33% of that. One thing they don’t separate it based on sex, with trans identified females being a larger portion than males, I and perception of the NB crowd and historical data, I will assume that females probably double the amount of males in this population. 🤔
Quoting @LeadingReport: BREAKING: Approximately 2.8 million people in the United States aged 13 and older identify as transgender.
You actually want an answer? It’s prejudices. No matter what a trans persons sexuality they will always receive the same prejudices as homosexuals. For one most are bi or gay, and if they are if they date the same sex it may appear as a straight relationship from the outside, but it’s still homosexual. If they date the opposite sex, it may be heterosexual, it still gets perceived and discriminated against as if it is homosexual, so yes the prejudiced received are the same regardless of their sexuality.
Yep. I wrote about this a few years ago, and how queer theorist took over the T? And then the entire alphabet. However, I don’t even think the court will take up the gay marriage case, and if they do, not much would change if they overturned Olbergfell https://humanevents.com/2023/04/08/sara-higdon-how-progressives-have-co-opted-the-trans-community-to-push-their-hateful-ideology
I won’t lie, it’s good to see someone in Rep. McBride’s position who gets it. Obviously I have a number of issues with Sarah, including reading queer theory books to kids, but at least she understands how detrimental the Queer activist with the help of progressives have been to trans people’s acceptance. This is a big step to getting the Q out of the T for people to realize transsexuals and transgender is not the same.
I also offered up some advice to trans identified people when it comes to this, and seeking validation through force. The answer is don’t seek validation through others because they will always let you down.
Quoting @freethepeople: "If you give people power over you, they’re going to take it."
Watch part 2 of Real Unity: Freedom To & Freedom From Transitioning, with guest @sarahigdon, on YouTube or listen wherever you get podcasts. (link in bio)
@[private account]
Maybe. I think before about 2016 most there wasn't really an issue of trans women either. With the movement shifting, it made them hyper aware, and selfID laws allowed predators to create a need for them to be as well. There was never really an issue before that. I also think most people in their day to day wouldn't clock trans people, as they tend to be more focused on themselves in general. Whereas on the Internet there is a confirmation bias, and even still females get called men quite often, (IE. Ilona Mahr)
However they do use the mens room. When they use the women's they get assaulted and arrested. The reason is that men either simply don't care, or because Trans identified females tend to pass better. Third spaces and respecting private property rights solves all of this.
They do, but so does just recognizing private property rights. The OP is missing the clear reason though as to why Trans men don't "demand" access, They just use them, and either men don't care or they don't know because they tend to pass much better the TW.
My actual views on the issue of women’s spaces.
BLUF: I believe in private property rights over government force.
So a lot of people are again talking about my views regarding males using female space, and a lot of straight-up lies and/or misrepresentations about what my beliefs and solutions are. So first off, I don’t believe males have a “right” to use female spaces. I actually think the word “rights” has been overused and misconstrued in our society as a whole, but that's for another time. I have also never “demanded” access to said spaces. In fact, I have never demanded anything from anyone regarding trans issues.
Here is what I do believe. I believe that in any publicly funded building, there should be 3rd spaces, not just for trans-identified people but for parents of children of the opposite sex to use as well. And most places have these. Now, where people have the biggest issue is that I believe in private property rights. I don't think the government has any business telling private business owners what their rules have to be inside their establishments. The free market does a much better job of regulating. I never understood why someone would want to force a business that doesn’t hold their values to take their money. We boycott Target, Bud Light, Nike, etc, yet when it comes to the local pub, gym, etc, people want to force compliance on them. Let's look at the criticism we have of the Queer activist who continuously goes after the Colorado cake baker. We say, “Why don’t they just go to another cake baker?” And that would be my question for anyone who wants the government to enforce bathroom laws, “Why don’t you just go to another establishment that holds your values, rather than forcing them to comply with your beliefs?"
It's like free speech and freedom of association. Don't you want people to speak freely, so you know who not to associatewith? Shouldn't a business be able to make its rules so you know who not to support with your money?
Secondly, the laws in the US would have to be written in such a way that they could cause more harm than good. It’s what North Carolina found out after they tried to pass the sweeping 2016 bill. See, under the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment, it holds that a law can’t discriminate based on sex. So, regarding a bathroom bill, they can say that all males have to use the men's, but also that all females have to use the women’s. This puts trans-identified females (who appear as male) in women’s spaces, and it would be a violation for them to use the men's. Under the NC bill, masc women were arrested using the women’s restroom because people thought they were trans-identified males. About a month ago, a trans-identified female was assaulted and arrested in South Carolina for using the women’s room as well. On top of all that, a predatory man can also simply claim that they were born female (but "trans") to gain access, and the bathroom sign becomes about as good at stopping predators as gun-free zones are at stopping shootings. However, without government interference, private businesses are not beholden to the 14th Amendment, which is a restriction on government and public property, not private. So, if a business's rules are to allow males and trans-indemnified females into the men’s room, but only allow females in the women’s, that’s ok, but not if the government has a bathroom bill in place.
What ends up happening is that businesses will self-regulate to what makes sense to their customer base because people who agree with their values will go there, and those who don’t won’t. They will spend their money at places that DO hold their values, rather than forcing those who don't to take their money. The idea is that I, nor anyone else, has a right to demand the rules of private businesses. We just have the right to not associate, but if we choose to, we are consenting to their rules. If we allow the government to force the rules, you end up with the failed North Carolina law, or the California/Australia law that forces selfID on businesses, no in between. We should be able to agree that Sal Grover has the right to exclude whomever she wants from her app; however, because Australians believe in government control, she can't. And at the same time, a TRA should be allowed to exclude anyone they want from their businesses as well.Centralized solutions are not the answer; capitalism is. Once you accept that the government can control private property, they will also do it in ways you don't like.
A lot has also been placed on what I do personally, and I have always said, "I simply follow the rules." When I started going to my gym, I asked what their rules were. They told me the women’s, so I did. But to be clear, I have never taken a shower or changed in the open at the gym. The only time I ever use a locker room is to lock my bag because they don’t allow them on the fitness floor. If I had to change (which has been less than a handful of times), it was in a locked stall. About a year ago, though, I began using the “family” locker room because I realized some of the older folks used it too, because it is locked rooms with showers and just a row of lockers, so it is simply a unisex space for people who were not comfortable using the open locker rooms. Most public places already have third or single-stall spaces, which is what I tend to use. I was at a Trump rally last year, and I found that space. While waiting for it, one of the workers pointed me to the women’s, but I still waited. Last month, in Palm Springs, I found a “gender-neutral” restroom, and I went out of my way to use that. The point is not to claim to be virtuous; it's not, but to show that I am not someone who is demandingaccess to female spaces, but someone who simply wants to find a solution that makes sense to everyone and is not taking away anyone's rights, especially their private property rights.
Y'all are free to disagree with my free market solution, but stop lying or misrepresenting my views, and even my actions.
Absolutely true. This is how the leftist activists like to use manipulating language. Trans people can still compete in sports that match their sex. Just like no one is banning books, we just don’t want sex books in school libraries. It’s all lies.
Are you saying that Dr. Debra Soh, one on of the most respected nueroscientist and Sexologist in the field of trans issues is making up studies, in a book in which is highly recommended by some of the most well regarded scientist out there including Richard Dawkins?
With all the talk about my views around these issues, I think people would expect me to disagree with this bill. But I don’t. Just read both bills listed (they are the same) but they designate based on sex in publicly funded buildings and leave private businesses to make their own rules. They list a multitude of reasons for making a 3rd space as well and none of them are a trans-identification. Given the title I was curious if it would violate the equal protection clause in the 14A, but it doesn’t, it’s pretty much how I would expect this to be written.
Quoting @txvalues: 🚨 BREAKING: Governor Abbott Adds The Texas Women's Privacy Act to the Special Session Call!
It’s time to make it clear in law that women and girls should NOT have to share their sex separated private spaces with men! Thank you Governor @GregAbbott_TX for making this bill a priority!! #txlege
Read more about this bill here: https://buff.ly/bJkfJ9c
That’s not what happened with Marcy. Marcy let them know she would be breaking their reasonable bathroom bill, after it had already been in effect for a year and a half with zero issues. Now Lilly, yeah, I have seen some of the messages in the trans support groups and they don’t have many nice things to say either
I monitor some of the trans community support groups online, and even there, I have never seen a nice thing said about Lilly Tino. I think this would be welcomed as they also recognize the harm Lilly causes to their community.
Quoting @DramaAlert: Trans TikToker Lilly Tino is now under investigation by Florida's AG for filming in a Disney World's women's bathroom.
Tino is facing up to 5 years in prison and a $5,000 fine if convicted.
I read that and was like “I don’t think she ever claimed to be… 🤨” also doesn’t they just prove your point that changing your hair doesn’t make you trans or “non-binary”
Simone didn't speak up about Nassar until after he was convicted and her statement was only used for sentencing, and after many other women came forward. Her pattern seems to be to only speak out for women's safety when she feels it is safe to do so. I know a few people who saw Nassar (one was a victim and testified against him), so it would be interesting to hear what Simone would say if he came out as Trans, and wanted to be placed in the women's prison. 🤔
She went after women who don’t want males competing in female sports. You should ask her if she would support transferring Larry Nassar to the women’s prison if he comes out as trans…
Why don’t women gymnast do the rings? Males don’t belong in female sports. This isn’t about being a sore loser. And if you really care about trans people in general then you would understand that this is an 80-20 issue, and all you are doing is harming the trans community, and actually the entire LGBT community. Because of this issue, the acceptance rate is declining, to the point where gay marriage could be lost in the next 10 years.
Absolutely. I was just having this conversation with @[private account] about this. Now, minors can’t consent, period, but even for adults there tends to be this manipulation happening. (And not just for trans stuff)
Who said that? The government can’t force private property rights owners to renovate their businesses, and they can’t determine the rules, but you can consent to go or not go there based on their rules, and the free market can solve the problem. If government tries to solve it, you either get California where it’s mandated selfID, or you get North Carolina, where trans men have to use the women’s looking like men. There is no in between.
No, private property rights reign supreme, and you don’t have to go there if you don’t like their rules. And again, if you want to make them single sex, you get situations like this, where Butch women, detransitioners, and trans men get questioned.
So trans men are men, and trans women are women? I thought trans women were men on the account they are males, and trans men are women on the account they are female. Ergo this person is a female, ergo a woman, ergo used the women’s restroom. 🤔
No, it is a shot at TRAs who claim there is a trans genocide happening because they are “unaliving” themselves due to lack of medical care. (Not me saying this) as you can see there are other words most use for this. “Killed himself” would not be flagged either.
@[private account] No law is needed unless in publicly funded buildings. Private businesses can make their own rules, and people can choose to go there or not. The NC law failed because it ended up effecting trans men, detransitioners, and butch women more than it did trans women.
I actually understand this completely. “Ex-trans” makes sense, for the same reason I came up with “post-trans.” You are an individual who has their own experience and are comfortable with yourself. We just landed in different spots.
I think this is why non-binary has become so enticing to so many young females. Many of whom feel they want to opt out of womanhood, not necessarily that they have gender dysphoria, (at least the DSM definition of it) and rather than work on the root issue, therapist are affirming that the person is trans and throwing pills (or injections) at the issue.
What we are seeing from the trans community is the same as we saw amongst much of the LGBT as a whole when the Queer theorist pushed in, and I guess the left in general during the Walkaway time. People challenged the cult mentality and were then forced out. Then the cult, in order to scare others from speaking out, relentlessly attack the person who was pushed out. Right now you are seeing Transsexuals realizing the Queer theorist took over with their push for the transgender umbrella, adding “non-binary” and what not, and it has come to harm transsexuals and their acceptance, and ability to just live in peace and blend into society.
If it was about the mental illness they would also be discharging the 5-10% of service members currently taking SSRIs. I like you Sara, you know that, but as a combat veteran I can make the case for trans people to serve, but banning surgeries for them.
You don’t even seem to be able to understand your own argument. You say that because trans people don’t try to compete with men they shouldn’t serve, but fail to understand that women serve, and don’t have to meet the same standard as men. Then you use an ad hominem attack, because you can’t articulate an actual point.
@[private account] @MrAndyNgo Yes, this shows your basic ignorance of trans people, especially those who serve. Because they meet the standards like everyone else. And tend to be more conservative
You are simply regurgitating what you have heard, and not what is reality. People continue to serve with severe PTSD, trans people are not non deployable because of their medications. People who contract aids cans still serve in a non-deployable status. 5-10% of service members are on SSRIs, and don’t get discharged… you can think about this emotionally, but understand you are thinking in a way that’s not reality
People with PTSD continue to serve, there are between 5-10% of soldiers on SSRIs, and 40% taking anti-depressants or narcotics pain meds. 20% of the trans community has served on the military, while only 10% of the general public has. I was highly decorated and highly rated, while suffering in silence with dysphoria, and high functioning anxiety, as well as undiagnosed ADHD. I was good at my job, and it should be an individual basis.
The issue is that she’s not wrong, and I know Jo. Which she doesn’t believe in males in female sports. A lot of people have a basic ignorance about who is allowed to continue to serve, and about gender dysphoria. Trans people have served at higher rates under a DADT policy, and that isn’t going to change. Many suffer in silence with dysphoria, while being high performers in their jobs.
Doubtful. Part of the reason people go on SSRIs is because they were sent to war. The military can’t afford to push out their experienced combat vets, because they broke them. They also can’t afford barracks lawyers telling troops that the way to get out before your contract is up, is by going to see mental health. Which happens a lot anyway, even with troops that never deployed.
Though I think there is an issue to be discussed about surgeries, I do think that the ban is a political football. All I can say to trans people is just be glad you can’t be drafted. 🤷🏼♀️
The prescription meds don’t make sense to me when looking at the data. The only thing I can think is the diagnosis, but then they don’t discharge people for PTSD unless it’s extreme. Unfortunately I think it’s simply political points. The points made are the same points used to justify DADT, but then they also use the surgery issue. Because as i believe as well, they create readiness issues. But they also ignore other military members can get plastic surgery and so can spouses. The thing is historically gender dysphoria has not stoped people from serving, about 20% of the trans community has served when only 10% of the population has. I was highly decorated and highly rated (top blocked 100% as an LT) while suffering in silence.
I will say I have spoken to Jo, I don’t believe she is for males in female sports, and from what I can tell is where I was about 4 years ago on the issues.
There isn’t an issue with drugs here. 5-10% of service members are on SSRIs, 4/1,000 males in the military are on TRT. Over 60% are on some kind of medication. 41% being prescription pain meds or anti-depressants. Jo’s point is valid. If we let women serve, and trans women are stronger than women, and we let others serve with other issues, then why not?
I’m not in favor of surgeries, but if a person can do their job like me and 20% of trans people, then what’s the issue?
And yes women in the military can get plastic surgery too. And tbh, if you want to know, I don’t think trans service members should be allowed surgery. Not for the moral issue, but because it puts a person on profile, but if you can do your job, then there should be no issue
Did you know your tax money goes to pay for spouses to get plastic surgery? You didn’t serve, and so again your opinion is based on feelings and not facts. I served as an officer for 7.5 years, highly decorated, highly rated, while suffering with gender dysphoria the whole time. 20% of the trans community can say the same, yet only 10% of the general population can. 🤔
Have you ever served? Because you seem to be playing off of assumption and feeling, and not fact. You also don’t realize trans people have historically served at higher rates than the general public, but more under the DADT guise and in many cases are highly rated with distinct honors. You also seem to fail to recognize that 5-10% of the military are currently on SSRIs, they don’t discharge for PTSD, and dysphoria doesn’t make you unstable.
Bisexual really doesn’t describe this though, and in the world of dating apps for example, different terms are needed. So no, I would not ascribe someone who likes women and trans women only to be bisexual.
Technically, but it doesn’t accurately describe what is actually going on. Again if a man likes the female form, and that includes trans women but not masculine men, then it’s not really fair to call him bi. Especially if that trans woman is post-op. I mean they makes a large portion of the male population bisexual since trans porn is one of the most popular categories.
@[private account] @[private account] The B has historically been used for those who line the masculine and famine form. It doesn’t alway accurately describe someone who dates trans people. Like Blaire White labeled it as needing its own label if you date only trans women and women.
Ben is also gay… I know some pretty well known lesbians who have said they would consider dating a post-op trans woman, because they simply like the female form. Though recently I came across the word homoflexible, and heteroflexible which seem like good terms to use to describe someone who’s not exactly bi, but will date trans of the opposite sex.
I’ve recently stumbled across the term homoflexible, and heteroflexible and these seem like good words to describe gay men who like the masculine form whether it is a trans man or not, or a lesbian who likes the feminine form regardless of actual sex. Seems to be the best way I can think of it.
So you don’t know the diagnosis criteria for dysphoria? I served 7.5 years suffering in silence with dysphoria, top rated, and have a bronze star from a deployment as direct support for an infantry battalion. Not dysphoria is an uncomfortabilty with secondary sex characteristics, not an apprehension of their sex. You seem to adhere to the gender ideology view of trans though.
What you also seem to be missing, the main post is about trans women, so males. There is no issue with medication for them. And alot of trans men, end up coming off T after they get the lasting benefits anyway. Yet males can take T all they want, no issues. hmm
Do you not understand that most trans men use injections that don't need refrigeration, not gel? Same as the 4/1,000 males that also take TRT injections in the military.
the number of trans service member is estimated at .2% so even if the number is 6% on SSRIs why are we not looking at them as well and only targeting those with gender dysphoria, if the argument is that they are not mentally fit?
All of them. Just like all trans people that are simply on medication are deployable. There is a reason im against allowing surgery, but not an outright ban.
Yes. I'm also asserting that 20% of the trans community has served in the military (Though usually under DADT), when only 10% of the general public has, and that isnt going to change because of the ban. withttps://x.com/i/grok/share/uwDKY95nnsQaXa9oKOnZ9WkPM
The point is accurate. Women also serve in the military, and since trans men and trans women are both stronger than women, why can't they serve? Many will point to the mental health aspect, but then why arnt we addressing the 41% that are on SSRI's? or the 4/1,000 men on TRT? I disagree with profile inducing surgeries, but as long as a person can do their job, like 20% of the trans population has, then why not?
Maybe, I support a job based PT test TBH. The Army had one for a few years. My point, is that Trans women and trans men are both stronger than women, so it's clearly not about physical strength to ban them, and historically trans people serve at a higher rate than the general population. I don't think they should allow body modification surgeries, but if they can do their job effectively they should be allowed to serve.
Have you served? look up the stat, 20% of the trans population has served, compared to 10% of the general population. Gender dysphoria hasn't ever stopped anyone from doing their job.
False, historically trans people are twice as likely to serve in the military than the general public, even when it was under the DADT guise. Medication doesn't make you non-deployable, if it did the 4 out of 1,000 military males on TRT wouldn't qualify either. Where I will say is that we should not be allowing body modification surgeries while in.
Jo has a point though. Trans people are twice as likely to serve in the military than the general population. There are women who serve in the military, so the idea that a trans person is too weak to serve doesn't make sense if it is clear they are stronger than female athletes. This won't prevent dysphoric people from serving, it never has in the past, we are just going back to DADT days, like when I joined.
I agree to an extent. There are a lot of people who do care when a trans identified person changes their first name, unlike a woman who changes her last name when married. I do wish using a persons name instead of any pronouns could be a compromise for a GC person who wants to respect people , but don’t want to use wrong sex pronouns for people. It’s what I typically do to avoid language traps when talking about people I don’t really care for in the trans community.
How many people in the military are diagnosed With PTSD? Also, you can deploy with medication, they actually have protocols for it since most people take meds for different things. Did you know that trans people are twice as likely to serve than the general population? 20% of the trans community are vets, while only 10% of society have served.
First, my military friends were the most accepting when I came out (and I was out so it wasn’t forced), if unit cohesion is an issue, it’s not a trans issue, it’s a personality issue, or a unit issue. No one cares who you are in the military as long as you can do your job. It’s also not hard to create spaces without males in the military. Like only house trans women with other trans women. In the field it’s not an issue, as most times it is just a giant tent anyway. Medically surgery is the only issue, not taking meds, as alot of Soldiers take medication, and they have processes for that on deployments.
The top range is 38%. Also, historically (typically under a don’t ask don’t tell model) there is a higher per capita of trans people who serve in the military than live in society. I for one, was one of them.
I agree. I obviously blame the leftist ideologues for obfuscating this issue to the the point that people don’t even recognize the DSM diagnosis criteria, and instead think there is such thing as “born in the wrong body” like there is some metaphysical thing happening, or that trans means you are actually changing sex. It’s infuriating.
Um, but that is not the diagnosis criteria for gender dysphoria, which is the basis to transition. Until about 10 years ago this was the idea, and there is scientific evidence that would describe dysphoria as a more advanced version of gender non-conformity. You're confusing "trans" with "gender ideology."
Why would I make money trying to stop trans adults from getting treatment, when I myself take those treatments? But, minors can’t consent, and it’s not possible to truly diagnose dysphoria until adulthood.
This is definitely not true. There have been trans people since about the beginning of time. In fact the first surgery happened in 1930. And yes it was mostly males, since about 2016 it has flipped and become mostly female, and the male numbers have gone up minimally.
I find the transvestigations quite funny. All it does is prove that when it comes to trans people there is often a confirmation bias as to who passes. Accuse enough females of being males, and eventually you get one right. Or no a person is a male beforehand, and then of course you see everything that outs them. This is actually why a lot of trans people have body dysmorphia on top of dysphoria.
I didn’t say that woman = attractive. All I did was explain the law of online interactions. I will say there is also the law of confirmation biases, where of course Hunter is clockable, when you know she is trans. On the street, not really. At the same time when you are constantly trying to figure out who is trans, a lot of women get accused until you get it right. Like there was a video yesterday of a woman getting kicked out of a bathroom because it was assumed she was trans. Ilana Mahr is a great example of this on the internet.
These kinds of witch hunts only hurt the Gendrt Critical cause. The “we can always tell” when they tend to see all women who have some masculine features as trans. Ilona Mahr is prime example, many even claimed Katy Ledecky was a man during the Olympics.
Full agree. We exist, and there needs to be a simple term to describe us. No you can’t change your sex, but you can change the physical body, to appear more like the opposite sex to a degree that society sees you that way. That’s what the term trans or transsexual use to mean. The issues is most people couldn’t tell you the definition of gender dysphoria, and they confuse it with a deeper version of body dysmorphia. The notion of born in the wrong body is the absolute wrong way to describe it. But to say “there’s no such thing as a trans person” is to really just deny that gender dysphoria is a valid condition.
Nah, it’s only the youth who try to replicate a period, because it’s all for attention. The older transsexuals historically have sought to limit attention because until a few seconds ago being trans was shunned.