The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
If the first thing you think of when you hear “men claiming to be women” is “trans” then you’re proving that you know that “trans” is just men claiming to be women or women claiming to be men. It’s your instincts at work. Trust them.
How weird that I didn’t even mention trans in my post, but evidently you know that the men claiming to be “trans” are just men otherwise you wouldn’t have responded as you did.
I’m optimistic about the Federal Court appeal but simultaneously prepared to go to the High Court in 2026 if that is what is necessary. I’ve said from the beginning that I’ll go all the way if that is what it takes.
The law is certainly written poorly due to the 2013 amendments which clearly need to be removed for the sex discrimination act to be able to function as it was intended to & still needs to. However, it’s the AHRC’s interpretation of the law that causes the biggest problem, really.
When the AHRC intervened in TvG, they clearly stated in their original submission that there is a conflict in the law. Knowing that, they should never have supported a single AHRC complaint on the grounds of gender identity v sex. The law should have been given clarity before negatively impacting any private citizens. Instead, they interpreted the SDA through the lens of transgender activism and relied on judicial activism rather than truth, reality and evidence to continue the farce of gender ideology. The AHRC has clearly abandoned their responsibility to acknowledge the human rights of *all* Australian citizens, and for that I will never, ever, forgive or respect them.
There will be major updates on the case in the coming weeks/months, including interveners, dates & much more!
2025 is going to be a big year and I’m ready for it.
And when it’s all over, and truth has succeeded, I will very happily move on with my life and never think about men who claim to be women ever again 🙋♀️
The manipulation that trans activists care about sex equality is enraging. A decade has been spent gaslighting society that sex is irrelevant and or changeable. Laws have been changed to reflect this nonsense. To now use “sex equality” - which requires the reality of immutable biological sex - to scare people into supporting child mutilation is the epitome of how evil gender ideology truly is.
Ensuring laws relating to sex based rights are actually based on biological sex doesn’t exclude people who call themselves trans. It just makes them follow the exact same rules as everyone else, which is about as inclusive as it gets.
Mr Wu, as JKR once said “Dress however you please. Call yourself whatever you like”, but laws were changed to validate identity over reality at the expense of women, children, freedom of speech & belief. There is no moderate trans solution when identity overrides reality.
The self proclaimed reasonable middle ground of trans activism will continue to erode women’s rights & perception of reality because some dudes like to talk about hair, & the craziest thing is that some are accepting this is middle ground. It isn’t. It’s exactly what got us here.
Yes. And they have nothing to do with men who claim to be women or anyone claiming to be “non binary”.
For someone who feigns ignorance on the issue, you sure do know the trans activist talking points.
The added insult to injury is some people - like Joyce - are so quick to unquestionably accept men as women or that “trans” is a real thing, while absolutely refusing to acknowledge the reality of what women are talking about. They think they’re being reasonable but they’re being ideological.
I always check in, ground myself in reality, look at the evidence and ask myself “Am I overreacting? Is gender ideology as bad as I think it is?”
Then I see that lesbians are being told they have to accept men (who claim to be women) as women & intimate partners, women prisoners are in women’s prisons with male sex offenders (who claim to be women), schoolgirls are refusing to use unisex bathrooms (implemented for “inclusion) because of the treatment from schoolboys, kids are being taught lies in school & university, women & girls sport is in shambles because men & boys have invaded it due to identity, and overall people (like yourself) will believe a man’s claims that he is a woman over women’s insistence that he is not. All because some men say that they’re women. An obvious lie.
Aside from the risk factors of men in women’s spaces, we’re dealing with an attack basic truth & reality here. Humans don’t change sex, no one is born in the wrong body, no man can possibly actually be a woman, and no one should be forced to accept someone else’s perception of themselves. That’s not how it naturally works.
Remember, once you can be forced to believe that men are women, you can basically be forced to believe any nonsense that won’t even be as absurd as that.
If you’re operating from the premise that gender ideology/trans is “real” because you’ve be told it is, you’ll dismiss everything I’ve said. If you’re at all curious as to whether there really is a problem, you can do your own research. Which all of us opposed to gender ideology did. I’d start by reading bc the work of Helen Joyce and Kara Dansky. Also, Google “autogynephilia”.
Oh, and if you think I’m just being hysterical & have no actual experience in this madness myself, just know that I have been taken to court for 3 years and counting because I saw a man in a woman only space I created. I was 15 weeks pregnant when it started (and found out I was having a daughter at 20 weeks into pregnancy, not “assigned at birth” like gender ideology will tell you) and my daughter will be 3-4 years old by the time it’s all over. The mental and emotional toll of being told that a man can be a woman has been horrific and has destroyed my trust in many people & institutions, but I continue to fight in part because of my daughter & the fact that I want her to have rights that a man cannot identify himself into. The appeal (Giggle v Tickle) will happen mid next year. Stay tuned to see if the law continues to say that MEN can be WOMEN (when they so obviously cannot be) and whether women have the right to say NO to a man no matter what he claims about himself.
It may seem like nothing to you. But you don’t get to set the boundaries and perception of reality for everyone else. Taking rights away from other people is actually not a human right, but it’s exactly what transgenderism/gender ideology has done to women, whether you’re aware of it or not.
Men are not women.
http://gigglecrowdfund.com
It is so obvious that if laws & society allow men to claim to be women, which will grant them unfettered access to women, the absolute worst men will indulge it. A predatory with a loophole to prey. This is as obvious a fact as humans not changing sex.
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-female-inmates-forced-to-share-shower-with-trans-identified-male-convicted-of-murder/
The concept of “trans kids” exists to prop up the concept of “trans adults”, so that trans can be sold as either immutable or a lifelong affliction.
Like, no one has sympathy for a middle aged autogynephile but if he’s “born in the wrong body” - BAM - sympathy.
It’s all a sham.
People who call themselves “trans” have the same rights as literally everyone else, to use sex-based spaces that correspond to their sex. That’s equality.
Demanding access to opposite sex spaces is not a right, nor equality, and actively takes away other people’s rights.
FFS.
If we’re going to make up new words, we don’t need one for the opposite of “trans”, we need something simple for “I don’t believe in it. It’s nonsense. A lie. Complete bullshit.”
“I’m not ‘threatened’ by someone because they say they’re trans. I just don’t believe it.”
Full (very fun) chat:
https://youtu.be/0iV98PX3VFE?si=F6Dcr_JoHgqJp86C
At any point, all the men who advocate for “trans rights” could work together to ensure that men’s bathrooms are accepting of men in dresses.
(Yes, he blocked me 😂🤷♀️)
See, this is the issue: “real trans people”.
It is an unfalsifiable claim. Literally any man claiming to be a woman can claim to be a “real trans person”. That is the problem. It’s how we got here!
Pushing the concept of a “real trans person” will continue every one of the issues @Caitlyn_Jenner claims to want to solve. It’s history repeating itself. It’s doing the exact same thing but expecting a different result. It’s the definition of insanity.
I also note that he don’t mention “men in women’s spaces” on his list and can only conclude there is a reason for that: he considers himself a “real trans person” and “real trans people” (who are actually just men, like every other man) are entitled access to women’s spaces.
NO.
Jenner part of the problem, not part the solution.
No.
See, this is the issue:
“real trans people”.
It is an unfalsifiable claim & it does not get society back to acknowledging reality.
Literally any man claiming to be a woman can claim to be a “real trans person”. That is the problem. It’s how we got here!
Pushing the concept of a “real trans person” will continue every one of the issues you claim to want to solve. It’s history repeating itself. It’s doing the exact same thing but expecting a different result. It’s the definition of insanity.
I also note that you don’t mention “men in women’s spaces” on your list and can only conclude there is a reason for that: you consider yourself a “real trans person” and “real trans people” (who are actually men) are entitled access to women’s spaces.
NO.
You’re part of the problem, not the solution.
Because they’ve pushed the concept of a “trans child”, which is child abuse. Rather than admit to that, they are doubling down on everything to avoid it.
No. As I said, you’re welcome to believe in trans ideology or religion. You just can’t make other people believe it. It’s not discrimination to not be able to force other people to believe it.
I am happy to tell you what women have been saying, of which listening to was the entire point of my post:
Let’s start with the first principle that no human being changes sex, because it’s a physical impossibility. At most, someone can take pharmaceuticals & undergo procedures to *imitate* the opposite sex.
Trans ideology insists that humans have a “gender identity”, and for some people it is different to their biological sex. This is an unfalsifiable claim, much like the Christian soul, and yet it’s the core belief of trans ideology. You’re welcome to believe it, but in a free society you can’t force other people to believe it.
So, for clarity, a man can believe he is a woman but he cannot force anyone else to believe it. Therefore, he can’t force anyone to accept he is a woman, and then, he can’t use female spaces such as bathrooms. Because doing so will be enforcing his belief about himself on other people, violating their rights.
It is wrong to think that each side of this “issue” has equal weight. One side is based on a giant lie and taking rights away from other people (we’ll get to the extent of that in a second) and the other side is based in reality and wants to maintain rights for all. @NancyMace is on the latter side.
So, why is the “bathroom issue” so important? Well, basically, it’s the tip of the iceberg for everything else. Much like the “pronoun issue”. Think of them as gateway drugs into trans ideology and the destruction of everyone else’s rights.
Remember, *everyone* has the right to freedom of belief, speech & association. These are the bedrock of a free society. Trans ideology obliterates all three (“trans women are women”, she/her, women’s spaces).
Then there are women’s rights, specifically. See, they were kind of the canary in the coal mine and at this point many women are furious that we have been ignored for so long. We’ve been warning everyone for years. Rather than listening to us, we’re labeled bigots. But the moment a man is in a woman’s space, it’s no longer a woman’s space (and they are men, and we have the right to believe/say it on the basis of fact). What he thinks about himself is irrelevant. In reality, he is an adult human male and his presence in a woman’s space violates the boundaries of every woman who doesn’t want him there. Consent is a thing and it can not be overruled by a man’s thoughts about himself. Women’s spaces are (but not limited to) bathrooms, change rooms, prisons, rape crisis centers, DV shelters, hospital wards, breastfeeding groups & any other even fun recreational need women have.
Remember, women only spaces exist to shield us from the bad men. Good men don’t even think to break the social contract of violating a woman’s boundaries. The moment a man is insisting he has a right to go into a woman’s space, you’re not dealing with the best of the best of men. You’re actually faced with the reason why women’s spaces exist.
It’s also worth researching “autogynephilia”. It will dispel the myth of “vulnerable minority” in three pictures or less. Autogynephilic men make up the majority of men claiming to be women.
Which brings us to lesbians. The L in the LGBT. Men who claim to be women are, for the most part, heterosexual men. And they’re insisting they’re lesbians. I’m sure you can reach the horrific conclusion of that claim.
So while some say this is a small, or fringe, issue, it isn’t. Trans ideology attacks our basic human instincts, our boundaries and the bedrock of a free society.
What Nancy Mace is doing should have been done by many more people in power a long time ago.
If you want to cater to men who claim to be women, do so without taking away the rights of literally a single other person. That’s the challenge.
Everything I have said is probably true.
Without a doubt it only helps one sex - “sex is changeable” doesn’t even help females who think they’re male or males who think they’re something absurd like “cloudgender”. Both of them rely on their sex based rights, like women.
Sex is changeable only gives privileges to males who claim to be female.
I think the rejection of gender ideology helps. I suspect the Trump administration could have a “true trans” contingent, which is how we got into this mess. If they continue to push it, it will cost them.
The rejection of gender ideology is the biggest thing and it’s beyond political parties. They have to catch up.
That this guy is being positioned as a “rational trans voice” shows just how insane trans activism is.
Why fall for it? It’s what got us here.
There is literally nothing rational in what he is saying, starting from the claim he is any kind of women, followed by WTF this is:
The common sense is:
• Think whatever you want about yourself but don’t force it upon a single other person
• Wear what you want but keep your fetish behind closed doors
• Don’t involve children in any part of “trans”
• Keep ideology out of legislation
• No man is a woman
“Normal trans women” ≠ normal women.
This is the same lie as “trans women are women”, but pretending it’s not.
It’s doing the same thing but expecting a different result. It’s insanity.
The political climate is rapidly changing as citizens get opportunities to reject transgender ideology in society.
In response to this, some autogynephilic men are trying to position themselves as the sensible middle ground - while still claiming to be “trans”, wearing women’s clothes and worrying that under new laws they won’t be able to falsify their birth certificates or use women’s spaces.
But this is not sensible or the middle ground. This is actually exactly how we got into this mess to begin with. It’s why we are where we are.
Remember, insanity is doing the same thing again but expecting a different result.
Their position is insanity. Complete & utter insanity.
So, um, it’s not actually a right to force other people to accept your perception of reality, or falsify identification documents with a lie, or to tell nonsense to children. Trans rights were never rights. They were always privileges, at the expense of everyone else’s right to freedom of speech, belief & association; privileges above & beyond what anyone else has, while packaging it as oppression.
And it’s all nonsense. But there is a way forward.
The sensible middle ground with transgender ideology is simple. It is: think whatever you want about yourself but don’t force it upon a single other person, wear what you want but keep your fetish behind closed doors, don’t involve children in any part of it & keep ideology out of legislation. Anything less than this is insanity.
Oh, and instead of platforming men who claim to be sensible women, just platform a sensible woman. There’s plenty.
Children are being sterilized & told there is no such thing as biological sex.
Any protections women can have away from men are obliterated if men can be legally women and override our “NO”. Spaces, sports, services, scholarships. Everything & anything reserved exclusively for women.
Remember, if men can be women, there is no such thing as a woman.
People have had their lives destroyed just for acknowledging free speech and freedom of belief against transgender ideology.
Trans is a man made concept and it’s complete and utter nonsense.
A deal breaker? Yes. 100%.
Trans activists get @reduxx deplatformed by the likes of Patreon because they’re desperate for no one to know about the reality of their activism.
It’s baby r*pists in women’s prisons & women punished for stating the damn obvious. Thats the reality.
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-female-inmate-assaulted-by-canadian-transgender-child-rapist-in-womens-prison-sustained-broken-ribs-eyewitness-reports/
I’m on the record, almost daily, for saying that women’s rights & LGB rights are the canary’s in the coal mine & gender ideology negatively impacts everyone due to the attack on freedom of belief & speech.
But there is a reason they lead with “trans women are women” & not “trans men are men”.
February 2021, Sky News gave me a platform to speak almost one year to the day from when trans activists had first come after me. Forever grateful they did.
“They’re not boys. I’m not going to listen to transphobia. I’m not going to listen to you call a trans girl a boy.”
So much of the fight against gender ideology is a fight for free speech. The moment you articulate reality, gender ideology crumbles.
“Trans girls” are boys.
Trans activists aren’t trying to eliminate the categories of men and women, they’re trying to invade them.
His argument makes no sense.
He wants the categories to exist, he just wants them to be meaningless while simultaneously validating identities.
It’s all nonsense.
Some people haven’t been listening to TERFs, so I’ll try to condense it here to make it clear & simple:
If you know anything at all about this issue, you’d know that women claim to be men for very different reasons than men claim to be women. While both are a horrible lie, the former certainly deserves more sympathy than the latter, basically because most of the time one is trying to identify out of objectification while the other is desperate to identify into it.
The women labeled TERFs speak up about women claiming to be men *constantly* and include them in the fight for women’s rights because it’s all about the basis of sex.
There is every chance that the woman this guy wants to mock is desperate to escape a trauma that was caused specifically because she is female. I’m not going to trivialize that.
Male only spaces for privacy, dignity and recreation definitely matter, and again you can find many TERFs saying this. But, because males & females are different *on the basis of sex* the issue is different. For example, males are not unsafe with a female in a male space. The female, however, is. So we talk about the issue differently.
The principles are consistent, they’re just not *identical*. This really isn’t that hard to understand.
Many men like Peter use gender ideology to express misogyny just like trans activists do, he just does it in a different way. The “gotcha” he attempted just proves his own ignorance on the issue and how little he listens to the women who are actually actively fighting against gender ideology.
Obviously, you haven’t been listening to TERFs, so I’ll try to condense it here for you:
If you know anything at all about this issue, you’d know that women claim to be men for very different reasons than men claim to be women. While both are a horrible lie, the former certainly deserves more sympathy than the latter, basically because most of the time one is trying to identify out of objectification while the other is desperate to identify into it.
The women labeled TERFs speak up about women claiming to be men *constantly* and include them in the fight for women’s rights because it’s all about the basis of sex.
There is every chance that the woman you want to mock is desperate to escape a trauma that was caused specifically because she is female. I’m not going to trivialize that.
Male only spaces for privacy, dignity and recreation definitely matter, and again you can find many TERFs saying this. But, because males & females are different *on the basis of sex* the issue is different. For example, males are not unsafe with a female in a male space. The female, however, is. So we talk about the issue differently.
The principles are consistent, they’re just not *identical*. This really isn’t that hard to understand.
Many men like you use gender ideology to express misogyny just like trans activists do, you just do it in a different way. The “gotcha” you attempted just proves your own ignorance on the issue and how little you listen to the women who are actually actively fighting against gender ideology.
Man is simply an adult human male. There is no judgement with character, personality, tastes or motivations by calling someone a man. Man is just a category of humans. Trans women are adult human males, therefore men.
It is getting easier and easier to publicly say that gender ideology is nonsense - “trans insanity” @megynkelly - and it will continue to get easier as more people realize that validating men as women and cutting body parts off young people just simply isn’t a good idea.
“respect my trans homies or I’m gonna identify as a f***ing problem” is just proof that you all know the identities you’re fighting for are not innate.
“This is the biggest women’s rights court case in modern history in Australia & no one would speak to me. Even now when [media] does report on it they call it a transgender rights case. No… it’s sex based. It’s women’s rights.”
Thanks @Riley_Gaines_ 🩷
https://video.outkick.com/m/fVMaFi7w/the-global-impact-of-gender-ideology-gaines-for-girls?list=HYH6RvlJ
If “no woman has a penis” is anti-trans then it can just as easily be argued that “some women have a penis” is anti-woman, and once again we’ve established there is a massive conflict.
Which is the entire point of every woman speaking out against “trans”.
#DeemingvsPesutto
The funniest thing is, you don’t realize that you’re admitting that you know TW are men.
See, the issue is “TW” want access to female “segregated” spaces because they claim to be female. It seems these “segregated” spaces matter a lot to “trans people”.
Get to know the issue.
Actually, he is receiving threats from trans rights activists.
Quoting @salltweets: 🎈TERF TV EPISODE 1.10🎈
I have a super bad flu, so this weeks episode is just an interview... but it's a good one.
Listen to my chat with @josh_seiter, the guy who just trolled TRA's by pretending to be a man pretending to be a woman. It's gender ideology inception!
Full ep:
The problem when talking about “trans” is we’re talking about infinitely different things, as “trans” is completely subjective by definition of its fiercest activists.
Different conditions that need to be addressed in different ways exist. “Trans” in any meaningful way does not.
“NY high school students will participate in statewide walkout against BOY athletes competing in girls’ sports”
It’s equally important to accurately report what is being challenged as it is to stand up against this nonsense.
“Trans” is irrelevant.
Imagine having so much power you can get the United Nations to think that men are lesbians.
Men aren’t lesbians and trans aren’t marginalized or oppressed.
"A phobia is an irrational fear, therefore transphobia would be an irrational fear of people who call themselves trans. But we’re not talking about irrational fears. This is not like having an irrational reaction to a clown, although admittedly there are some similarities."
“Sall Grover now says she is ready for “round two” after last week filing an appeal against August’s federal court judgment, a major gender identity ruling that declared that sex is “changeable and not necessarily binary”.”
Let’s go 🙋♀️
https://nypost.com/2024/10/07/world-news/female-only-app-founder-appealing-court-ruling-in-favor-of-transgender-woman/
“Ms Grover insisted “somebody’s biological sex is immutable” and it was a “natural human instinct for us to be able to tell this.”
As controversial as it may be, I stand by this. 🙄🤷♀️
https://www.news.com.au/lifestyle/real-life/news-life/femaleonly-app-creator-says-trans-rights-taking-away-human-rights-as-she-appeals-gender-identity-case/news-story/1bd822ffe17b433e932c360f2c0749cc
“We’re told constantly that trans rights are human rights but human rights cannot be rights that take away other people’s rights, that’s not how it works… and it’s not only that they’re taking away our rights, we’re actually being coerced into giving up our rights.”
“We’re talking about women’s rights, freedom of speech, believe & association. They are talking about trans rights & how they don’t want to harm this ‘vulnerable’ group. A group of people who can get laws changed in stealth. I don’t think oppressed people can do that.”
From today. The article is basically just a rehash of the Guardian article.
https://www.thepinknews.com/2024/10/03/founder-of-female-only-app-appeals-against-trans-discrimination-ruling/
At what point will they realize, all they have to do is work out a way to protect the “trans & gender diverse” community without taking rights away from everyone else.
Isn’t it amazing how “transgender” & “cisgender” are so different when they need that to be the argument, and other times it’s “MEN WHO SAY THEY ARE WOMEN ARE WOMEN NO DIFFERENCE”.
Looking forward to a future documentary called “The Age Of Bullshit”.
Basically, your argument is “if they commit a crime, they’re not trans. If they’re a victim of a crime, they are trans.” See the issue?
Quoting @salltweets: Literally nothing changes when a man claims to be a woman. Not behavior, not reality, nothing.
Respect women & stop indulging these men as any kind of woman.
When men are able to invade women’s spaces & sport on the basis of “gender identity”, women are immediately discriminated against on the basis of sex.
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-australian-womens-football-club-with-five-trans-identified-male-players-continues-to-dominate-competition-wins-womens-championship/
“This is why the TERFs are fighting so hard. We did our research. We learned about things we would prefer to not know about. The people fighting for so called “trans rights” need to do the same & explain why they’re a men’s predatory sexual rights movement in women’s clothing.”
Legally female men are not vulnerable, nor are they oppressed, marginalized or women.
https://reduxx.info/germany-violent-transgender-shoe-fetishist-could-avoid-charges-of-exposing-his-penis-to-women-because-hes-legally-female/
The women there were literally advocating for *females* who claim to be “trans”, on the basis that they’re *female*. But ya’ll never think about them, do you?
Quoting @salltweets: “I will be referred to as a woman, as female, as a feminist… there isn’t a misogynist alive who has the chops to change my mind. But they’ll call me a TERF regardless & Im at the point when I just don’t f***ing care”
It is worth listening to every bit of this magnificent speech
Do you want to know what the women called TERF’s believe?
Buckle up. Here it is:
Women are adult human females.
Men are adult human males.
No man is a woman.
Woman, man, boy, girl, female, male are all sex based terms.
No human being has or can change sex.
Femininity and masculinity are socially created and imposed.
Being feminine is not a condition of being female.
Being masculine is not required to be male.
Men and boys can be feminine.
Women and girls can be masculine.
"Transwomen" are men.
Lesbians are women who are sexually attracted to other women.
Gay men are men sexually attracted to other men.
Legal sex just means a man has changed his identity documents to claim to be a woman.
Gender ideology is bullshit.
No child is born in the wrong body.
Puberty blockers and cross sex hormones are sterilisation of primarily homosexual or autistic youth.
"Trans" isn’t a coherent demographic of people.
"Trans" is a man made concept.
Safeguarding of women’s boundaries is important.
Safeguarding children is paramount.
Female spaces are necessary.
No males in female sport.
When we say female, we’re saying it to reference both women and girls. Otherwise, we’ll be specific about women or girls.
Nonbinary is the equivalent of emo or goth, it’s a phase and doesn’t deserve or warrant legislative validation.
Females are oppressed on the basis of being female, aka sex. Don’t believe us? Look to women in Afghanistan.
While males are also entitled to male only spaces, they’re very different in society and law to female spaces.
Women’s rights matter.
From the full episode of TERF TV episode 1.4
Can you comment on the phenomena of females with a “trans” identity competing in the female category while males with a “trans” identity also compete in the female category? Worth mentioning, I think.
“The trans demographic have no problem doing trans events, having trans only spaces… they exist in a world where we’re happy to be excluded from their stuff, so we don’t protest it… We want what’s equal to that.”
Full conversation:
https://youtu.be/YimxWR3DfWU?si=Ma9LQRrB-5Tk9o8M
“I just wanted to try & get as educated as possible, and that was one of the things the Trans Activists kept saying. ‘Educate yourself!’ And I was like, ok that’s a fair comment, I will. Turns out, massive TERF.”
Full conversation: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/sean-oscar-presents/episodes/SALL-GROVER---ACCIDENTAL-ACTIVIST--BECOMING-THE-FACE-OF-THE-TRANS-DEBATE-e2kr1jo
Females with a trans identity are welcome, if they want, in female only spaces including apps. Your “twansphobia” nonsense just doesn’t hold up. It’s not “trans” we care about. It’s MALES. It’s utterly dumb to not realize this - just tell males to FO from female spaces 🤷♀️
“A victory for Giggle in the High Court would not strip transgender individuals of human rights as activists try to claim… Blurring the lines between biology and identity creates further mischief…”
Full article:
https://www.spiked-online.com/2024/04/13/sall-grovers-fight-for-womankind/
I am strongly against women's and girls' rights and protections being dismantled to accommodate trans-identified men, for the very simple reason that they are not women and reality matters.
“I often wonder with all the ‘progressives’ all in on ‘trans rights’, say it was a man who calls himself a man taking me to court, they’d be on my side. It’s because a man calls himself a woman that suddenly I’m the bad one.”
Nothing material has changed. Just definitions.
Giggle always was inclusive of *females* with a trans identity. It just excluded *all* males, regardless of gender identity. It’s male exclusionary, not trans exclusionary. But that’s why ya’ll are pissed off. We know you never think or care about *females* with a trans ID.
And fuck off with your racism. It’s not welcome here.
This is the issue with gender ideology superseding sex in law: the only people who benefit from it are men who claim to be women.
Females with a “trans identity” rely on their sex based rights for sport. As do “nonbinaries” and every other “neo gender”.
Everyone has a biological sex, and in certain circumstances, it really matters.
Gender identity superseding sex in law excludes everyone but men who claim to be women.
It’s part of how we know we’re in the midst of an extreme men’s rights movement.
@[private account] 100% of trans rights activists have not changed sex. In another timeline, they could have lived much happier lives. Instead, they choose to direct their repression fuelled despair back on to themselves & others who accept reality. It is tragic, and sad.
🤷♀️
Was this the video of Carol? I watched it. She’s awesome & her insight is fascinating. As horrible as it is being on the receiving end of the trans cult, it sounds absolutely horrendous inside it too. The whole thing is just a mess.
Trans activists do not want women to be heard because what we’re saying is the truth:
No human being can change sex.
No man is a woman in any way, shape or form.
No man is a lesbian.
No child is born in the wrong body.
Puberty blockers are modern day gay conversion therapy.
The behavior of so called “trans activists” at a Women Will Speak event speaks for itself.
Police wouldn’t even be necessary if trans activists would just accept women speaking.
FFS.
Exactly. We can have many conversations about people with DSDs, but it sure as shit isn’t going to help with the Self ID argument, of which all of “trans” is.
“Usually in Australia media they’ll do any story praising ‘trans’ people… Why aren’t they writing stories like ‘yay the fight back with [Tickle v Giggle] is so necessary for trans rights!’ But nothing. They don’t mention the case in Australian media.”
https://youtu.be/t-yO0oomTPA?si=sqIYHV3WOI-UKfjj
Marginalized and oppressed people cannot get laws changed in stealth, which is what “trans people” did.
They are incredibly powerful, and if you don’t believe us, call a man who claims to be a woman “he” and find out who has the power.
Trans people are welcome to go into the same sex-based spaces as every other human - on the basis of their sex.
That is equal rights.
To regard a man as a woman would be a privilege afforded to him, one at the expense of women’s actual rights.
Trans people *also* have sex-based rights, because like every other human being on the planet, they have an immutable biological sex.
In fact, females who believe themselves to be men rely on their sex-based rights to participate in sport, as they continue to compete in female competition due to the reality of biological sex necessitating it.
“Trans & gender diverse people” with identities such as Cloudgender & Genderfuck, etc, also rely on their sex-based rights, as there are no specific rights to cater to the cloudgenders.
Gender identity laws *only* benefit *men who claim to be women* because they give them privileges above and beyond what anyone else has, while simultaneously taking rights away from everyone.
Sex-based rights ensure “trans people” have the exact same rights as everyone else & that everyone has rights. There is zero oppression in that.
So, no, I’m not the one oppressing “trans people”. I’m the one who understands the situation.
It absolutely blows my mind that anyone would be stupid enough to believe that “trans & gender diverse people” are oppressed in Australia at this point.
They got laws changed in stealth, with no mandates to do so.
They have the AHRC & governments defending their nonsense.
They have media control & censorship.
Don’t believe me? Say no to a man who happens to believe himself to be a woman and see who has the power.
The one thing they don’t have is control over everyone’s perception of reality, and that’s what pisses them off the most. It’s why they go so hard on everything else.
Published in today’s @[private account].
Just a reminder, the AHRC has intervened in Tickle v Giggle, the landmark court case of gender identity v sex, and is on the side of gender over sex. They are actively discriminating against *women*. It’s women’s human rights at risk, not “trans”.
This is fantastic!
Just a reminder to everyone, the AHRC has intervened in Tickle v Giggle, the landmark court case of gender identity v sex, and is on the side of gender over sex. They are actively discriminating against *women*. It’s women’s human rights at risk, not “trans”.
If trans women were women they would just be women. There would be no issue. The fact that you have to try to defend them this much is simply because they’re not women & all you’re doing is proving that you know that.
Females with a “trans identity” always continue to play in female sport, exercising their *sex based rights*, as they should.
Males with a “trans identity” always move to play in female sport, exercising their *gender identity privileges*, as they should not.
See it now? 🤷♀️
The AHR launched a consultation on “trans & gender diverse human rights” but blocked women who know what a woman is from participating, yet men who claim to be women who want access to women’s rights can participate, proving the AHRC knows exactly who is a woman & who is not 🤷♀️
Trans activists will look you in the eye and say “biological sex and gender identity are different” while changing laws to replace biological sex with gender identity.
Everything they’re saying, the opposite is true. Everything.
Biological sex is binary & “transgender people” have a biological sex. It’s the biological sex they were born with, like literally everyone else. Biological sex is completely & utterly inclusive.
@[private account] @SethDillon Females who claim to be trans are welcome on the platform, but none of you ever think about them.
It’s about *sex*, not “trans”.
“Trans” students are welcome to compete in sport. They simply have to compete according to the *exact* same rules as everyone else and compete in their *biological sex* class. That’s inclusivity. Absolute *no one* is excluded this way.
When males are on female teams, females are excluded.
On February 7, 2020, trans activists discovered my start-up & infiltrated the App Store & Google Play with 1 star reviews, purely because the app was for women and not men who claim to be women. (They never once stopped to think about the fact that *females* with a trans identity were welcome). They basically put the startup into an algorithmic black hole that may be impossible to get out of but we were determined to stay and work through it, while not giving in. I had no knowledge of this issue prior to February 7, 2020, and it was a horrible circumstance to have to undergo and education of utter insanity. I have not given in and in 6 weeks, I go to federal court because a man who claims to be a woman is suing me over the app. It has been the hardest 4 years of my life but never once have I considered giving in or giving up. The truth, freedom of belief & women’s rights are simply too important.
This is my long way of saying, never give in. They’re horrible. But the moment you give in, it makes the fight harder for those of us who won’t.
I genuinely hope they’re not as cruel to you as they have been to me & countless other women.
@[private account] I’ve sent you a case that shows you that “trans” was used as a loophole around sex-based legislation.
You’re so far gone, you can’t be reasoned with. Blocking you now.
@[private account] What are you talking about?
From 2001, a full 16 years before gay marriage was legal, “trans” people could marry despite being same sex. It’s all SEX based.
Learn your history because you sound like an ignorant fool.
http://classic.austlii.edu.au/au/journals/UWSLawRw/2002/10.html#:~:text=Introduction,-What%20does%20it&text=The%20case%20of%20Re%20Kevin,the%20validity%20of%20that%20marriage.
There literally is no other issue than male entitlement.
They can’t even call it “trans exclusionary”. *Females* with a trans identity are welcome, as they are still women whether they want to be or not. They mostly stayed away from it as far as I know, but it was there for them if they want it.
The lie of gender ideology goes so deep that trans activists have spent years saying “sex & gender are different!” Meanwhile, they have been changing laws to ensure that ID sex markers are changed based on “gender identity”.
The ideology is gaslighting everyone who believes it.
While the fight back against gender ideology in the UK is the Equality Act/Gender Recognition Certificate, in Australia the fight is legal definitions culminating in the concept of “legal sex”. Legal sex is gender ideology.
In 2013 Australia’s sex discrimination act got some pretty amazing amendments, including taking out the definition of “sex”. Yes, they removed the definition of sex from the *sex* discrimination act. They also took out the definitions for “man” and “woman”.
Chaos has ensued. It is what has lead to “Tickle v Giggle”.
When a person with a “gender identity” wants to have legal documents to reflect that GI, they don’t get a GRC in Australia. They change the sex marker on a reissued birth certificate. Subsequently, the goal is to make the undefined concept of sex a legal concept (what is said on your legal document) not a biological concept (what you are). Hence, men can be women in Australian law.
Obviously, this is very crazy because for most people, what is listed on their legal documents is their biological sex. But for some people, what is listed on their legal documents will be the *opposite* of their biological sex, and that is the problem, as it obliterates women’s sex-based rights that are to required to exclude males by definition & were once the very essence of the *sex* discrimination act.
Legal sex is a legal fiction. The legal fiction often cited in defense of the legal sex fiction is adoptive parents. However, this isn’t an analogy that works at all.
The commonality in biological vs adoptive parents is they have a child in their care. The child is the deciding factor. We don’t legally recognize people who have never had a child in their care as a parent. There is no commonality in women and men who claim to be women. Men who claim to be women are like people who have never had a child in their care. The legal fiction doesn’t work.
What someone identifies as is their own personal business & should be protected in that context, i.e you can identify as whatever you want but the identity doesn’t trump reality when reality is what matters.
Definitions in law are what matter most in the fight back against gender ideology in Australia. Man must be defined as an adult human male & woman must be defined as an adult human female, as this is reality. It is the truth. It is the most inclusive way to categorize people under the law & protect everyone’s rights (not privileges).
And the definition of sex, as a biological concept, must be reinstated to the sex discrimination act. Every person has a biological sex, including the people rejecting theirs & they need it for rights.
The reality of biological sex is actually utterly inescapable & if anything, that fact is only highlighted by gender ideology, even when disguised by legal sex, and the change from biological sex to legal sex ultimately also harms the demographic (trans) it claims to be helping and it does so *on the basis of biological sex*.
In a world structured around legal sex, not biological, it is *only* men who claim to be women who legally benefit. Females who change their legal sex to male suddenly loose the rights they had to sport, e.g. They can’t adequately compete against the men for biological reasons & their biological sex based rights are what was allowing them to continue to compete in the female category. Men who claim to be women, however, will dominate women’s sport, which puts women at a disadvantage *on the basis of their sex*.
Additionally, we’re told there are at least 72 gender identities, therefore 72 potential legal sexes. But how should they be catered for in any practical way? Should every club have 72 individual exclusive change rooms? Or is this just fucking nonsense & a society based around biological sex, of which everyone has one of two options, is literally the most inclusive way to go?
So, legal sex doesn’t even help all “trans” people. It just gets males into female spaces & sport. And that is the problem.
I’m not going to do anything to them. I hope the people who believe themselves to be “trans” lead happy & full lives. This involves knowing that no one can change sex, no males in female spaces or sports & no punishing people for not believing in gender ideology. Is that clear?
1. The reviews were infiltrated by trans activists leaving the app 1 star reviews. Nice work, boys.
2. If the app is as horrible as you morons claim it to be, why would a man take me to court to be able to gain access to it?
3. There are plenty of trans-exclusive apps and some of them even use AI technology.
Men aren’t women and women are allowed a digital space away from men. You’re allowed to just ignore woman-only spaces. You don’t have to make a big thing about it.
I disagree on the basis that no one changes to anything. There is literally no “M2F” or “F2M”. It never happens. It’s always just M or F. “Man with a trans identity” or “woman with a trans identity” works, but so does “man” and “woman”.
@[private account] @[private account] Be “trans” if you want. But to say there is “nothing wrong with it” is incorrect. There is a lot wrong with it, starting with it being built on lies, is an authoritarian ideology, and leads too many people to have unnecessary surgeries that do not do what they claim to be doing.
Which is a separate conversation, because of social contagions amongst teenage girls.
But like, if the father had removed his daughter because a female with a “trans identity” was in the dorm, it would be specifically about the trans issue. But he did it because of a *male*. It’s a biological sex issue.
Four years ago today, February 7 2020, I was introduced to the existence of Trans Rights Activists. They tried to destroy my life.
In April 2024, I go to Federal Court to fight for women’s sex-based rights. I will not give up.
Men are not women.
http://gigglecrowdfund.com
“A TikTok star amassed thousands of followers claiming to be a 'proud trans woman' - but she was really a paedophile using her new identity as a 'mask', her victims have told a court.”
He. HE. For fucks sake.
https://mol.im/a/13050211
I didn’t even mention transgender people in my post let alone deny their existence, you did, proving you know that transgenderism is just a delusion that people can change sex.
Anyone is welcome to believe it. They’re not welcome to force others to believe it.
Australian women spent 2023 traveling the country with a “Why Can’t Women Talk About Sex” tour to discuss sex-based rights until… Tasmania decided to prove our point by stoping us from talking about women’s sex based rights.
Way to go, dickheads 🙄
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/tasmanias-antidiscrimination-chief-investigates-blocking-of-transgender-critics/news-story/bc0af53ce824a17885b13cca886d260a
*ahem*
Any issue with “transgender” marriage prior to the legalization of same-sex marriage was on the basis of *sex*.
Whenever you’re confused, just remember “on the basis of sex” and things that make sense to 99% of people will start making sense to you.
Hi Rodney,
I would have been one of the speakers at the event Louise was organizing. You categorizing it as anything against the “LGBTIQA community” is proof that you need to listen to what we are saying.
If you sincerely care about the “LGBTIQA community”, then you’re going to need to understand that the communities within it have different needs that have to be met. Ignoring that does nothing to help the community you claim to support.
For example, lesbians require female only events & the right to say “no” to males. Currently, there is a conflict of legal rights due to the presence of “gender identity” in law. Sex-based rights matter now just as much as they did during the fight for same-sex marriage. Gay men also require the right to so “no” to females.
Furthermore, even within the trans community different demographics require different accommodations. For example, females with a gender identity have different needs to males with a gender identity, and without sex-based rights in law it is trans identified females who are shortchanged, not trans identified males. To refuse to acknowledge this is, arguably, anti-trans.
You could listen to all of this, and find out more, and help your community. Or you could punish women who are trying to do the work you should be doing. It’s your choice and, evidentially, you have made it.
How absolutely dare you refer to @[private account], me and all of the other amazing women who speak up for women’s rights as anything derogatory when you have absolutely no idea what we’re actually saying.
In desperately trying to stop males from being discriminated on the basis of gender identity, you are discriminating against women on the basis of sex, thus further proving the conflict of rights that we are trying to resolve.
I am happy to talk about this with you in private if you can’t handle women speaking in public. You’re welcome to DM me.
Kind regards,
Sall Grover.
I mean, if you’re happy for “transgender men” to be included in the definition of women, which they are as per above, we’re in agreement.
Read things carefully before assuming they confirm your bias, otherwise you’ll look like a fool.
People can tell the biological sex of a person by looking at them, it is done completely subconsciously every day as you’re interacting with people. It is an understood & necessary skill. When you’re actually paying attention, it’s even more obvious.
Even “trans” people know what their biological sex is, otherwise there would be no reason to be “trans”. They’re just attempting to reject their biological sex. Which is a fools errand, as it is utterly impossible to escape the reality of your biologically sexed body.
What is possible, however, is to escape the stupid social customs that are often placed upon a biologically sexed body. In fact, this has long been the mission of many feminists. The same feminists who are now called “TERFs” and “bigots”.
We all live in this colorful world together and there should be no problem in there being male-only spaces, gay male only spaces, female only spaces, lesbian only spaces, and if desired, trans only spaces. You can even get specific if you want and have Cloudgender only spaces. The world is your oyster! The inclusivity is in everyone having someone to go when they need/want it. What wonderful equality that is. If everyone just respected these places of refuge, there would be no need to police them in any major way.
So, rather than mocking, I’d suggest create what you want & need and allow other people to do the same. That would be actual progress.
Genuinely think that if Woman’s Hour is going to give this much uncritical airtime to people who acknowledge the reality of biological sex, then for balance the BBC should have a Trans Ally hour where we get to complain about the reality of biological sex _the entire time_.
🙄
“We went from ‘believe women!’ to ‘if you care about women you’re a bigot’. It’s no accident & I don’t think anyone high up in media gives a shit about ‘trans rights’. I think a lot were scared of being MeToo’d & wanted it off the front page.”
Full ep 💗: https://www.youtube.com/live/R21hLiz1MHA?si=oUhY3Tie6fZH-DoG
“It gets sinister pretty quickly when you think about why they would be pushing for the concept of a trans child. Basically for the ideology to seem innate it needs to be that children are affected when it reality it’s older men with a sexual fetish called autogynephilia…”
Quotes a post by T02505; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You are female, therefore completely entitled to use female spaces. However, the thing about female spaces is no female is obligated or forced to use them. You are welcome to self exclude. Ultimately, it is your choice. You using male spaces is between you and men, and if they say no, you’re going to have to respect that on the basis that you are not male.
If you think there is a chance that women & girls will mistake you for male, and it’s a possibility as full beards like yours doing a lot of heavy lifting for females claiming to be male, and you don’t want to make them uncomfortable, scared or have to explain the reality to them, and that is your reason for not using female spaces then again that is your choice. It is, however, simultaneously confirming why no *actual* male should ever be in a female space and that you do understand that.
If I were you, I’d put my energy into finding a solution to accommodate you, such as unisex third spaces, rather than trying to force all of society to bend around your identity. Unisex spaces would be a benefit to “trans” people, but also fathers with young daughters, and so on. Basically, you could do something worthwhile instead of just calling women bigots and the like for a large portion of your time while nothing gets done.
I’d never heard the word TERF before I created an app for women and was introduced to the concept by thousands of Trans Rights Activists who bombarded the App Store & Google Play with 1 star reviews in an attempt to “cancel” the app. Due to the accusations of transphobia (despite the fact that *females* who claim to be trans were always welcome), all media who had been eager to promote the app for women suddenly went silent & have never responded to an email from me since. Then a man who claims to be a woman did an Australian Human Rights Commission complaint against me & the company citing gender identity discrimination. In just under three months, the federal court case will be heard and if we win, at the very least, the precedent will be set in AU law that sex has weight in the sex discrimination act over gender identity. I’ve lost friends IRL. My life has been completely turned upside down. All because I know what a woman is. But I won’t stop until it is clearly established in law and society that men are not and cannot be women. Anyone who wants to try and stop me on this is welcome to get in line and kiss my ass.
🙋♀️
@[private account] I didn’t mention trans in my post. You saw “man thinks he’s a woman” and immediately thought of “transwoman”, proving that you know they are men.
🙋♀️
For me, gender ideology and the concept of “trans” is an attack on every persons freedom of belief, freedom of speech, freedom of association, and then there are women’s rights, LGB rights & children’s mental, emotional and physical well-being. I don’t not support a single part of gender ideology. None of it. I think it’s an evil ideology. The world will be better off without it.
But I do think there are many ways to defeat this dangerous nonsense. The fact is, we don’t yet know what it is that’s going to defeat it. We’re all doing our bit and our best. There are some approaches that I vehemently disagree with, but I will never criticize because it could be the thing that works, and if it is I’ll be the first in line to admit it and congratulate. I just want this hell to end.
The one thing I will never do is become what I hate most and that is authoritarian. Freedom of belief is my north star.
No woman has to 100% agree with me and I don’t agree 100% with all women. What unites us is our biological sex and one common goal. There are many ways to achieve it.
💗
Why don’t you tell that to your “trans” child while they use the change room that corresponds to their sex (male), thereby following the same rules as everyone else (inclusion!)?
Does this idiot realize that a “trans” category was created in swimming *for dignity & fairness* and none of the men masquerading as women went in it. His hypothetical solution has already failed.
Males competing with other males *is* treating them with dignity. Follow the same rules as everyone else, boys. That’s inclusion.