The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
If they truly believe this, that males & females are basically the same, why be trans?
They don’t even realize that their stupid ideology makes zero sense.
The binary SEX system is just reality. Best to come to terms with that.
Trans activism has *created* a binary gender system that states any boy who likes dresses & makeup is really a girl and any girl who likes trucks & pants is really a boy. What a horrible, regressive & dangerous idea to impose upon children & adults alike. Throw in medicalization & surgery and the current *trans imposed* gender operating system is outright evil.
Every person has the right to develop personality & tastes and reject any cultural norms they feel are imposed upon them on the basis of their SEX. However no person has the right to make other people believe they are the opposite SEX, which is what trans activism has become.
Male, female, man, woman, boy & girl are all SEX based terms. Actual progress is accepting that men & boys can be feminine if that is their personality/taste, and women & girls can be masculine if that is their personality/taste. Accepting this will free everyone and make the concept of gender obsolete. How lovely!
You be you. Enjoy it. An adult human female, a woman, who likes masculine things. Embrace it. There is nothing wrong with it.
“In the face of reality, where “trans people” are unjustly claiming it doesn’t exist and women’s rights used as pawns, I will stand firm as the MP. Brighton Pavilion, let’s unite against reality. Together, we can take away rights for all & replace it with rights for some.”
This video is old now, but there are many apps exclusively for “trans” available. “Trans only” events happen all the time.
Part of the reason for this is, none of us want to use these apps or go to those events. Thus, they’re left to enjoy them.
Sigh.
Let me put it really plainly:
Gender identity *does* exclude *women & girls* who believe they are trans. They don’t compete in the male sports category. They rely on their sex-based rights to compete in the female category. Taking away their sex based rights & making categories based on gender rather sex, will *only* benefit men & boys who believe themselves to be trans.
That’s how fucking stupid your stupid ideology is.
“Trans kids want to be in sport for the same reasons as everyone else.” Great! And they can follow the same rules as everyone else and compete in their second class. Case closed.
FFS.
I understand why more women aren’t standing up against the assault on our rights: trans activists will try to destroy their lives. I know. They’ve tried to destroy my life.
The best thing men like @piersmorgan can do is platform every woman who has spoken up. Every. Single. One.
“The AHRC has intervened in the case… they literally say biological sex is not binary but it can also be changed & a ‘trans woman’s’ desire to be pregnant would mean they are a woman. And you’re like, what on earth are you talking about?!”
For more info: https://gigglecrowdfund.com/
And furthermore, if there are no differences between men and women, why be trans? What is even the suggestion of a “transition” if there are not differences between the sexes? What are you “dysphoric” about? They don’t even realize how stupid their own ideology is.
It’s amazing when they so blatantly conflate sex & gender like this for all to see.
Every human has a biological sex, hence why positive sex-segregation when needed/wanted is the best way to order spaces, services, etc.
“Trans & non-binary” students also have a biological sex.
If we’re going to talk about it, let’s talk about it honestly.
The “transgender identity” is being used as a reason to change sex markers on ID documents, which is bizarre for a few reasons, the first being that biological sex isn’t changed in reality. Ever. We’re constantly told that “sex & gender identity” [“transgender identity”] are different, which is definitely true because only sex is objectively true. A man being classed as a woman could only be pretending, because he isn’t a woman in reality. But, nevertheless, there remains an attempt to give this pretense legitimacy. Then, this lie, “gender identity”, is being used to override the rights of other people, through freedom of speech, freedom of belief and freedom of assembly, all rights you have too. But your freedoms cannot override other people’s freedoms, and vice versa.
A supposed “condition” like dysphoria cannot override the rights of everyone else in society, and forcing it to happen certainly does not make that “demographic” powerless in any measurable capacity. It makes that demographic terrifyingly powerful, and authoritarian.
You are welcome to “identity” however you want, dress how you want, call yourself whatever you want, and basically express yourself how you want/need to live your best life. But the *moment* you expect or demand anyone else to accept your perception of yourself as objective reality, and give up their own rights in the process, expect resistance.
People with a “transgender identity” have to accept that many people will never see them as they see themselves. But this is a challenge basically every person faces, it’s part of life, and it’s just that for most people it is not pathologized or weaponized.
Either @stonewalluk doesn’t actually think TWAW or they know literally nothing about history, because if this dude was “trans”, and therefore “literally a woman” or whatever bullshit Stonewall is currently pushing, he wouldn’t have been an emperor.
This is a marvelous self own.
You’d think, if it’s true that 71% of “trans” young people have considered suicide, politicians would want an inquiry into why that is and how to get this demographic better support. Obviously *something* isn’t working well.
“Gender criticals” do not say this.
We say “men are not women”.
At least know what we’re saying.
Trans men are thinking women can be men. They cannot be.
The goal should be for everyone to co-exist fairly in this world together. We don’t all have to be friends, and you can not be friends with whoever you want for whatever reasons you want, but a positive goal is often a good one.
The issue is, what you deem “transphobia” is actually *womens rights*. It’s not “trans rights vs transphobia”, if you’re being honest. It’s “trans rights vs women’s rights”. If you want to be even more honest, it’s “trans rights vs freedom of belief for *everyone*”. And if you want to be *even more* honest, it’s “trans privileges vs women’s rights & freedom of belief.”
See, anyone has the right to believe whatever they want about themselves (or they should have that right). So a man can believe he is a woman, for example. But there is an issue - a conflict - if that individual is demanding other individuals believe what they believe. So, in a free society where everyone’s rights are being accounted for, a man can believe he is a woman and another person can not believe it to be true without fear of legal or social punishment. That is fair. No one has to be friends. But a mutual respect for freedom of belief keeps things pretty damn friendly.
Women are called “transphobic” by the likes of you because we want female only spaces & sport. But we’re not transphobic. We simply care about our *own* rights & needs and are not willing to give them up. Trans people are welcome to create everything they need for themselves, whether it’s trans-only services & categories or “women + trans women” spaces, etc. There is nothing stopping you. There is only a conflict when you’re demanding that all female only spaces & sport *must* include men who claim to be women, thus requiring women to give up our rights for trans privileges, and leaving no female-only options for the women & girls who want them. That is ignoring both freedom of belief & womens rights.
So you can blame & mock other people all you want, but if you really care about “trans rights” you should go out and ensure all trans people are catered for *without* taking rights away from anyone else. The ball is in your court. For whatever reason, you don’t do it. But you can be sure as shit that the conflict will not be solved by just trying to name call people into submission. 🤷♀️
*sigh*
1. Practical implementation:
Do I agree with you that it’s pretty unrealistic to expect society to restructure everything around “trans & gender diverse” people? Yeah. So now maybe you can understand how absurd it is to expect *women* restructure everything we have fought for & built around “trans & gender diverse people”. FFS.
But, “trans people” are not the first group of people in the world who wanted (or needed) their specific needs catered to. Women actually worked for female-only spaces. We put in the work & got them. Disabled people put in the work to ensure their needs are catered to & they are. If the governments, institutions & activists who claim to care about “trans people” *so much*, then they should help them. Don’t expect other demographics to just give up their rights. If you really need these things, do the work. Get what you need.
2. Accessibility:
Obviously it’s impossible to create spaces in every building for every gender identity. I mean, how many “Aliagenders” are there in the world? What is the expectations of an aliagender? Are they realistic?
It’s almost like there is a simpler way to categorize society, one that works for absolutely everyone, and that’s… biological sex. 🤷♀️
3. Discrimination & segregation:
To use the example of women & disabled people again, we don’t think it’s discrimination & segregation to have spaces & services specific to the needs of women & disabled people. Why TF is it discrimination for trans people?
It isn’t.
A man is not a woman. In a sane world, it is not discrimination to not recognize him as a woman. Because he is not one.
4. Inclusivity: Providing spaces & services for trans people *when they need & want it* is the epitome of inclusivity.
Female spaces, by definition, do not include males. Males are going to have to cope with it.
Female spaces are inclusive of *all* females, regardless of their identity. Male spaces are inclusive of *all* males, regardless of their identity. What is more inclusive than that?
What you’re describing is “demands met”. Grow up.
5. Legal and Ethical considerations: In a fair discussion, the legal & ethical considerations for “trans people” need to also consider the legal & ethical considerations of women. If women’s rights are not part of the conversation, and trans rights are only the focus, it is not a fair discussion. Trans needs are not the only needs in the world that need consideration.
When you have a conflict of rights, compromise has to be found. The entire tweet you’re responding to is about that compromise.
Compromise is not “you will give up your rights so I can have my privileges.”
6. Understanding diversity: If you want to “identify” out of the gender binary, that is your right. It doesn’t mean that the world is going to suddenly bend to accommodate you.
As I have said, you’re welcome to create anything you want. But you can’t expect female-spaces to be changed due to males identities. Females with any identity are welcome in female spaces.
See how categorizing by sex is actually the best solution for everyone, as it effortlessly caters to everyone.
7. Potential for abuse: Allowing any male to identify into female spaces certainly does have a massive potential for abuse. Now you’re seeing why women are saying “NO!” Ffs.
Trans people are eventually going to have to realize that the world does not revolve around them. It’s that simple.
I’m saying that ironically because this is so possible. There is really no challenge. So many governments & institutions are all in on gender ideology. They constantly tell us how marginalized “trans people” are. Surely they’d do anything they ask, like create spaces for them. 🤷♀️
Gender, in the way it is used in trans issues, is an identity. It is a subjective, constructed concept. Sex is biological sex. It is reality and an objective concept. The debate isn’t about “trans people”. It’s about rights.
It should not be discrimination to say a man is not welcome in a female space. trans people are welcome to live their lives and we’re happy to support spaces so they are accommodated in those lives. What more can anyone do?
No, sorry, you’re wrong.
Organizations worked out how to cater to disabled people, for example, and it is a nonissue now. We wouldn’t think to create buildings that didn’t cater to disabled people.
Every other demographic has done the work to ensure their needs are catered to. Every demographic has specific needs. Disabled people, women, men, children, gay men, lesbians. “Trans people” are just another category of people with specific needs. How inclusive is that! FFS. The only demographic not doing the work is “trans people”. They’re expecting everyone else just to forget about their own needs and cater to theirs. No.
If the people who say they care about “trans people” (above all else, in most cases) are not willing to cater specifically to “trans people”, what are they fighting for? Are they fighting for trans people or just here to fight against women? I simply do not accept “it’s hard, so women have to give up their rights.” No. FO.
Put in some effort. If it is so necessary to cater to “trans people”, do it. Move hell & high water. But don’t give me defeatist “its too hard boo hoo”. No other group ever got what they needed that way.
JFC.
While the constant attacks on Kath are horrific, the silver lining is any rational person will read this & know Kath is right in what she says, and if trans activists had any actual arguments against her they would use them instead of ad hominem. But they also know she is right.
Yes we can.
Disable people had to campaign to get public bathrooms, despite being a small percentage of the population, and guess what? They got it.
They didn’t complain about being “othered” by having specific needs. They did the work and got what they wanted & needed. Rightfully so.
Trans people are simply a demographic with specific needs. Every demographic has specific needs. Either you want them catered to, or you don’t.
If you don’t think “trans people” are worth campaigning for to ensure their needs are adequately met, maybe you’re actually the one who doesn’t care about “trans people”.
🤷♀️
The gender debate is really very simple and finding a solution is even more so.
It is paramount to start from the (correct) premises that human beings cannot change sex and no one should be forced, through fear of legal, professional or social punishment, to indulge another persons identity.
It is also true that, in a free society, anyone can think whatever they want about themselves. For example, a man is free to think he is a woman. It is really no one else’s business (unless he makes it other peoples business). Freedom of belief is a necessary right for *everyone*.
So, there are the both sides of the argument covered, fairly.
Now, what is the solution? How does society function smoothly when one side does not want to believe that men can be women and the other side insists that they have to? What is the compromise? Is there a compromise?
The compromise certainly isn’t to force people to believe in identity or to let men who “identify” as “women” into female spaces. They are not women and there is nothing they can do to become women. Therefore, allowing men into a female space isn’t a compromise. There isn’t even a compromise in “well, if he’s had hormones & surgery, that man can be in a female space but if he hasn’t had any hormones or surgery but just says he’s a woman he can’t.” That would involve treating people with identities differently to other people with identities. Hardly fair, for both the men with identities and women.
What is a compromise is creating spaces for all demographics who need them. For example, if it is established that spaces specifically for men who claim to be women are necessary, and wanted, create them. Create bathrooms, changerooms, hospital wards, various services, anything needed. Invest in these people if you care about them so much. There is really nothing stopping this from happening.
Other than… the men who claim to be women don’t want their own services, evidenced in part by the recent announcement from World Swimming that no one entered the category especially created for “transwomen” and therefore they are shutting it down. Often, men who claim to be women say it is “othering” to create their own services for them. But that argument doesn’t hold up. When women were campaigning to get female only bathrooms & sport established in society (and women did have to fight for these rights), they weren’t saying it was “othering” to create a space specific to their needs. They understood the necessity to create spaces & categories specific to their needs.
See, we all co-exist in this colorful world together, and we do so pretty well. We all pass each other on the street, work together, sit in movie theatres together, and generally live & enjoy life in each others company. It’s just that sometimes, there are places that one wants to or needs to go that requires single-sex status. It may be for traumatic reasons, for example a woman has to go to a rape crisis center and requires it to be female-only to aid in her recovery. It may be purely recreational, like a man likes to go to a male-only barber shop to relax for some “guy time” or a woman wants a female only gym. It is only fair that these places can exist. It doesn’t mean that “women + men who say they’re women” establishments can’t also exist. They can! Nothing is stopping anyone from creating them. But in a free society, the “other side” also needs to be catered for with the female only or male only options. Trans only refuges & recreation can also exist, & do.
Basically, the solution is simply: cater to everyone. That is kindness & civility. If men who say they’re women don’t want to be catered to, that’s their choice & they’ll have to use male spaces, because they are male.
As I said, a phobia is an irrational fear and therefore transphobia is an irrational fear of trans people. So, a comment or action that is “transphobic” would have to be a comment or action that is indisputably displaying an irrational fear of trans people *on the basis of transness*.
The problem is, a vast majority of the time the people accused of “transphobia” are accused of it when they’re commenting on or acting in relation to biological sex. Even the acknowledgement of biological sex is often called “transphobic”. But it’s not an irrational fear of trans people to acknowledge biological sex. In fact, acknowledging biological sex is treating trans people the same as everyone else, as everyone’s biological sex is acknowledged.
What would actual transphobia be, in this day and age? Is it possible to have an irrational fear of someone else’s identity they’re demanding you to accept? I’d argue, no.
I’d argue that every action towards trans people is on the basis of biological sex, and therefore “transphobia” is a misnomer at best and a derogatory slur at worst.
A phobia is, by definition, an irrational fear. Therefore, transphobia is an irrational fear of trans people.
JK Rowling and all the women you would call “TERFs” do not have an irrational fear of trans people. We have a rational fear of *males* and we make choices accordingly. However, gender ideology has decided that women are bigots for making choices according to biological sex, and thus we have had to work to regain the right to do so. It is necessary for women to be able to acknowledge biological sex.
In fact, it is necessary for all people to be able to do so, if they want to. People also need to be able to have a choice as to whether they indulge someone’s perception of themself, especially when that perception (identity) contradicts reality. So there is also a rational fear that the rights to freedom of belief and freedom of speech are being eroded, in addition to the damage being done to women’s rights, in the name of trans activism. I can’t imagine that you would want to be told what you can think & say, and I assume you wouldn’t like it if you were slurred as a “bigot” simply because you wanted to maintain the right to believe whatever you want.
So, while TERFs would fight for your right to freedom of belief - ie, believe you’re a woman if you want - would you fight for our right not to believe it?
People who call themselves “trans” should have the exact same rights as everyone else. But males wanting access to female spaces on the basis of “gender identity” are not the same rights as everyone else. They’re privileges at the expense of another demographics rights. Males wanting to be called women & punishing anyone who won’t do it also isn’t a right. It’s authoritarian. So while I would march for your right to freedom of belief, freedom of speech & freedom of expression, I will not support any attacks on women’s rights to female spaces & sport and societies overall right to acknowledge reality that contradicts your identity.
Good luck with your show.
I don’t know a single person who wants to shut this show down.
Like, do your show. Have fun. Say whatever you want. That’s what happens in a democratic society, dude. Do I think it will be a horrible show? Yeah. But that’s just my opinion. If you can’t cope with people not liking your work, get out of the arts.
But, actually, while we’re on the subject of “coming after us”, let’s look to who is sending death threats to women & taking women to court… It’s men who think they’re women. Trans. No women are “coming after” these men. In fact, we’d like to get away from them in the manner of *female only spaces*. I look forward to the section of the show about that...
There are 14 apps *exclusively* for trans people on the App Store. 14. No one cares.
There was 1 app exclusively for females on the App Store. 1. It was inundated with abuse & now a federal court case.
Gender ideology is exclusively focused on men invading women’s spaces & sport.
Honey, if I held an event that said “Trans people are allowed but not encouraged” would you be cool with it? I’ll hazard a guess & say “NO.”
Have trans only events. I could give less of AF. Have them every day of the week for all I care. I’ll help make the posters.
Just accept the fact that trans people will have to live in a world where *some things* are classified by biological sex and some people do not believe in gender nonsense. Like female only spaces & sport, and lesbian events.
We all co-exist in this world together. Get used to it.
Should we read this book to discover the humanity of trans activists, or does it not help your argument?
https://nypost.com/2022/04/22/writer-gretchen-felker-martin-under-fire-for-killing-j-k-rowling-in-novel/
It’s really beyond time for politicians to articulate how they plan to get these “trans rights” *without* taking away women’s rights, LGB rights, everyone’s freedom of belief & freedom of speech, and unnecessarily medicalizing children.
Please, pray tell.
What is your plan to get these “trans rights” without taking away women’s rights, freedom of belief, freedom of speech & unnecessarily meedicalizing children?
Oh I am so excited! @[private account] is amazing, this film about trans widows is going to be heartbreaking but so necessary - finally, their voices are properly being honored.
Gender laws came in to Australia before same-sex marriage. So, they had actually already chosen gender over sex when they passed same-sex marriage. They kept that quiet, didn’t they?
Interestingly, the same-sex marriage case for “trans” was in 2001. Two females. Basically, the federal court allowed the marriage between the two women because the parties involved believed one of them was a man. Which is interesting reasoning, imo.
“Sex Discrimination Commissioner Anna Cody dismissed Giggle for Girls' arguments that sex was a biological, binary characteristic under which someone could simply be classified as either a man or a woman.”
Some days, you just have to laugh. 🤷♀️
https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/8364549/sex-changeable-commission-backs-trans-womans-case/
Trans activists could stop every single discussion about the reality of biological sex and it will not change the reality of biological sex.
Human beings will continue to not change sex, men will continue to not be women & gender will continue to be a man-made concept.
Oh FFS.
Not being able to speak honestly about anthropology because of “trans” only proves that the truth of anthropology destroys the fantasy of “trans”.
Every aspect of gender ideology is a lie & it’s the exact opposite that is the actual truth:
They say men are women, but only women are women.
They say men who say they’re women are lesbians, but they’re just heterosexual men.
They say “trans” are oppressed, while having all the institutional & government support & power.
They say “trans” are discriminated against, while they’re actively discriminating against women & lesbians in order to appease “trans” demands.
They say “trans rights are human rights”, when what they’re demanding is privileges beyond what anyone else has.
They say the want “inclusion”, while happily excluding anyone who disagrees with or challenges them.
They say “sex & gender are different”, while changing the sex marker on their official documents on the basis of “gender identity”.
It is an exercise in grand scale gaslighting that can make you feel crazy, but it’s gender ideology that is absolutely insane.
The date of “February 2020” mentioned in this article, when Glinner & Hadley stopped messaging, is relevant to me. It’s the month TRAs first came after me. February 7, 2020, to be exact. The day my life changed forever.
Trans rights activists have *tried* to take everything for me. My company, my reputation, and my sanity. It’s through sheer determination from me & my family that they have not succeeded, and will never.
When I first looked to Twitter, in February 2020, I found everyone I could who was speaking out about this issue. It was 90% women (of course & thankfully). The high profile group I first encountered (like most of us did) was Helen Joyce, Julie Bindle, Jane Clare Jones & Kathleen Stock. And @Glinner.
After an introduction via Baroness Nicholson, I emailed with Graham a few times. Eventually, I took the risk of rejection and asked him to help support my company through investment, and he did it. He put his money from the cancelled career where his mouth is and helped financially support a female-owned company for females that 99% of investors were ignoring. One of the more poignant rejections from an investment firm was that they wouldn’t work with us because of the “trans open wound of bad publicity” (😳).
I will forever be grateful to him. Not just for helping me but for helping all women. Maybe you don’t always like his style. So what? There’s lots of styles of activism within the “GC community” I’m not a fan of but I don’t care. Everyone is doing their best, and the diversity of people within the movement is the strength of it. The simple fact is that Graham’s profile & unapologetic approach to this issue has given it more attention and that is a very good thing. We’d be much worse off without him.
None of us know how we’re going to behave or handle having such a large scale attempt to destroy our lives for saying really basic & obvious truths (I say attempt, because I don’t think anyone has succeeded in destroying Graham’s life. It’s certainly a different life to what he was planning, like me, but it’s far from destroyed). Some people have been lucky and they can dip into this issue when it interests or benefits them. For some of us, it is consuming. We didn’t ask for it. We’ve just handled it. But it is consuming. An issue of this magnitude, in my opinion, should be consuming to everyone. Still, we’re all excited for the day when we can think about something else, especially those of us who have been consumed.
And, when that day comes, all of us involved in it will look back on this era with jaded bemusement and for anyone who missed out, “Graham Linehan presents TERF: The Musical” is going to be fucking brilliant.
I’m being taken to federal court for alleged “gender identity discrimination”, so I for one am *fascinated* to find out that “trans women” don’t even believe in “gender identity”.
“If gender identity supersedes sex in law, if you have 50% men in government or boardroom & 50% trans women, is that sex or gender equality? What about 50% men & 50% trans men? What I’m trying to show is that gender is completely & utterly incompatible with sex [in law].”
I am SO FUCKING SICK of “trans allies” suddenly knowing the difference between men and women when they want to belittle the men who have supported the women who’s lives & livelihoods have been threatened or destroyed by trans activists purely because we know that men cannot be women, because we know men and women are two distinctly different categories of people.
If any of the men you’re belittling suddenly said he was a woman, you’d have no choice but to accept it or be labeled a “TERF”. That’s the real catch-22 you’re in, and I can understand how it would make someone feel very fucking sick.
"trans people have always existed!"
Oh really?
So, "transwomen" coped really well with not being able to vote, own property, get bank accounts or wear pants (etc) but women saying "we want female only spaces, services & sport!" was their limit & abuse ensued?
Cool story, bro.
“If Gender Identity needs to be in law it needs to be in a general discrimination act, as it’s in complete conflict with sex. Sex is male or female. A gender identity is going to be the opposite of that, otherwise why are you trans”
Full 1hr interview:
https://watch.adh.tv/videos/ep222i-the-other-side-interviews-sall-grover-founder-and-ceo-at-giggle
💗👏💗👏💗👏💗
Fantastic, as always.
I’m very interested in TRA terms of discrimination and exclusion. Because, as I see it, they don’t oppose either.
For example, if they wish for “gender” to trump “sex”, and therefore “transwomen” can be in female-only spaces, wouldn’t that mean that they would happily exclude “trans men” from those spaces? It would have to, wouldn’t it, to validate the “trans” identities. So, they’re still excluding and potentially discriminating against groups of people. It just suits their overall agenda of validation to do exclusion and discrimination this way.
For example, with Giggle, the claim is “gender identity discrimination”. But “transmen” were welcome. We were never “trans exclusionary”. We were male exclusionary. I didn’t discriminate at all on the basis of gender identity, because females with a gender identity were welcome and males were excluded *regardless* of gender identity. It wasn’t like “males are welcome *except* males with a gender identity” (which, potentially, could be gender identity discrimination). Just males in general were not welcome. Because gender identity was, overall, irrelevant. A female was welcome to have one on Giggle.
To have to allow males with a trans identity onto the app, by their own logic, I’d have to exclude any female who didn’t have a “woman gender identity”. So exclusion would still be happening, but it would be happening to females who were once included. It would potentially even exclude me, as I do not believe that I have a “woman gender identity”.
So I just don’t think that exclusion and discrimination are actually something TRAs or the AHRC have a problem with. So long as it works in a males favor, which is what happens when “gender identity” trumps sex. Funny how the division, no matter which way you look at it, is still sex based at the end of the day, isn’t it? Sex is inescapable.
Hey Barbara, when trans activists speak at parliament, women don’t protest outside. We *let them speak*. What are you afraid we’re going to say? The truth?
Quoting @salltweets: “So, was due diligence done? If it was & these very obvious realities were ignored, but gender identity was still put into the Sex Discrimination Act, was it done in malice? If due diligence was not done, but gender identity still put into the SDA, it’s gross incompetence.”
@[private account] “trans women lesbians” are men. Men have no business being at a lesbian event. Sorry, I don’t make the rules. I just acknowledge reality.
No. You are worryingly confused here.
Feminists have always *challenged* what is *expected* by men and women of women and girls. Prior to the capture of language to suit men who claim to be women, they spoke clearly to challenge both sex and gender *expectations*. Many a trans activist has tried to use that as proof that men are women, because *they captured the fucking language*.
And I don’t give a shit who started it. I’ll finish it.
MEN ARE NOT WOMEN.
A simple fucking DNA test will prove this.
But, to be honest, I’m actually not going to have this debate with you. I muted the previous conversation because it is a waste of everyone’s time, and I don’t like to get angry. But for some of us, this isn’t fun theories to test out on Twitter to get a response and a rise out of people. A nod to a bygone era of academia. It’s our lives. It’s our livelihoods. It’s our actual rights in law. Guess which sex I’m talking about. I bet you know.
If you’re on Team Tickle now, go be on Team Tickle. I don’t care. He doesn’t have to raise money, incidentally, he gets a free ride to attempt to destroy my life *based on a lie*. While everyone is testing out theories on gender, old fashion sexism is alive and fucking well.
If Trans Activists want to start talking about consent, I’m ready. But they’re not going to like the conversation.
Let’s start with men in female spaces, shall we? Ahem. We don’t consent.
Trans activists use images of me without my consent all the time. Men also go into female spaces without our consent. Children can’t consent to puberty blockers & cross sex hormones. I can tell them right now, they don’t want to start a conversation about consent. They will lose.
@[private account] @[private account] I’m not leaving out information. The post *literally says* “you can’t come (unless you’re trans)”. I know you don’t want this kind of hypocrisy to be true, but it is. Better to deal with it than make a fool of yourself.
@[private account] @[private account] If that’s what you really think of lesbian events, why are you so desperate for “trans women” to be included in them?
@[private account] Exactly.
The event has actually already happened. No protests. No objections. Everyone else just found countless better things to do with their time.
I’m all for trans only events. Stay at them, for all I care.
Thank you for highlighting that men will spend their time attempting to destroy a female-only space, while trans-only events occur without protest or interruption.
You’re proving my point.
The Victorian Pride Center, who denied lesbians the right to host a “female-only lesbian event”, allows “trans only” events, in case anyone was still wondering if those who claim to be for “inclusion” & “LGBT equality” are actually just totally full of shit.
🤷♀️
I know you desperately don’t want it to be true, so that you don’t have to challenge your thinking, but the reality is that an organization that allows trans-only events does not allow female-only lesbian events (like there’s any other kind), thus providing more evidence that gender ideology is misogynistic & homophobic nonsense. You’re going to have to acknowledge it eventually. Pick a day to start.
And on top of that injustice, that same Victorian Pride Center allows “trans only” events, in case anyone was still wondering if people who claim to be for “LGBT equality” are totally full of shit.
So, if we we’re supposed to think it’s just a joke when they say “punch a TERF” I think it’s only fair that we also just take it as a joke when they say “trans women are women.”
🤷♀️
These idiots don’t seem to realize that “trans people” have “trans only” events all the time and women don’t protest them because we’d, literally, rather go anywhere else. Or, specifically, to places were men are not present.
When do the “GC TERFs” you speak of try to close down trans related events? Trans-only events happen all the time! This event has already happened. No one banned it or took it to court or protested it. 🤷♀️
Translation: more people realized what is really going on & that they can speak up & not pretend that human beings change sex, so Trans Justice Project and Victorian Pride Lobby interpreted that as “anti-trans hate” rather than reality that needs to be accepted.
There. Fixed it.
What these idiots don’t realize is that when they say stuff like this they’re actually admitting that they know “trans women” aren’t female. It is actually quite funny.
It’s really important to establish what would be discrimination for a “trans” person.
At the moment, one claim is if you don’t validate a man who says he’s a woman as a woman and let him into a female space, that is discrimination.
The demand for “trans rights” is actually a demand for privileges above & beyond what everyone else has. Then, if those privileges aren’t adhered to, the accusation of discrimination occurs.
It’s also important to note that, under the rules trans activists have created, everyone else in society is discriminated against, either due to freedom of belief, speech, or women & girls being discriminated against when being forced to accept men in our spaces & sport.
This is, as you’ve noted, completely incompatible and unsustainable in a liberal and pluralistic society.
So, I think it’s time to really establish what is meant by “trans people should be free from discrimination” because saying it in general terms just isn’t working for any of us, including trans people.
Homosexuality confirms the reality of biological sex, transgenderism denies the reality of biological sex. So even the example you have given is in complete conflict and highlights that you haven’t thought this issue through.
I’m for gay rights.
Trans activism is not.
Exhibit A:
@[private account] @[private account] There is a mass indoctrination of girls and women into thinking themselves as boys and men.
https://www.amazon.com.au/Irreversible-Damage-Transgender-Seducing-Daughters/dp/1684510317?nodl=1&dplnkId=8a722b6d-1d86-4ac7-bffa-080598a7e9b6
@[private account] As I said, identify however you want. It’s just that no one has the right to force anyone else to believe it. Trans people also should have freedom of belief.
“For men to be able to say they’re women, they need to be able to say they’re born in the wrong body, all of this nonsense they’ve come up with. It creates the concept of a trans child. Then it’s a lifelong struggle, not that this is just a guy that actually is an autogynophile.”
How many examples of women being injured by men do you want?
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-trans-identified-male-seen-injuring-female-player-during-womens-league-game/
I’m a woman you don’t know, so allow me to introduce myself:
I created a company, an app, exclusively for women. Trans activists attempted to destroy it before it was even launched & continue to defame it. A man who claims to be a woman is taking me to federal court to gain access to the platform that trans activists have spent the past 3.5 years saying is “racist/doesn’t work/data mines” amongst many other demonstrable lies. (If it was as bad as they claim, why would someone sue to gain access to it? 🤷♀️🤪). You’re welcome to Google “Tickle V Giggle” for more information. The app features a lesbian dating platform, which should make it extra clear why men are not welcome on the platform.
Prior to this experience, I had never been called “phobic” of anyone, I had never been called a bigot. But the moment I said “Men are not women in *any* context”, trans activists attempted to destroy my life. They will not succeed. I will.
@Glinner was one of the first high profile people who supported me in 2020. No media would speak to me, while calling me transphobic with no right of reply. The strength he found to support me while he himself was under attack is very profound to me and I will remember it and be grateful for it until the day I die.
By the way, I support abortion, always have & always will. The reaction I receive when I voice my pro-choice stance is *nothing* compared to what trans activists do. It’s unlike anything else. You should know. You’re contributing to it.
Not only are men who claim to be women the problem, so are you. The men who back them and then attempt to use certain women to make yourself seem virtuous. We’ve seen at all before. You’re nothing new.
Glinner is right in what he is saying and I guarantee that one day you will pretend you always agreed with him.
Honey, trans ideology is the most homophobic ideology in recent memory, telling men they can be lesbians if they identity as “women” and women they can be gay men if they identity as “men”. Trans ideology aims to obliterate the reality of biological sex which thus makes same-sex attraction obsolete. FO with your attempts to care about homophobia.
The only solution is to have diversity in the market place, where everyone has choice for where they want to go. Want a dating app with everyone in it? Go to that one. Want a dating app exclusively for trans people? go to that one. Want a dating app exclusively for lesbians? Go to that one. And so on…
It is essentially impossible for one platform to cater to everyone. It will end up catering to no one, or at least only a select few, and thus be exclusionary no matter what.
Trans activists did this to my company - an app exclusively for women - inundating it with hundreds of 1 star reviews before we had even officially launched, rendering a normal launch plan absolutely impossible. We couldn’t do online marketing because it’s linked to star ratings.
I mean, “trans” people still have a biological sex and they’re still male or female even if they don’t want to be. I don’t specifically ban “trans women”. Like, it’s not like Giggle welcomes males *unless* they have a gender identity. It bans males, regardless of their gender identity. Trans identified males are just being treated the same as all other males. “Ban” is even almost the wrong word. It’s just *for* females. I assume the barber shop is in a similar position, albeit for males not females. “Trans men” are welcome in a female space as far as I’m concerned, because they’re female. I think banning “trans men” from a female-only space would be “gender identity discrimination”, or at least closer to it than banning males from a female only spaces is. I assume “trans women” are welcome in the male only space because they’re male. If they choose to self exclude from the spaces that align with their biological sex, that is their choice. But it definitely wouldn’t be discrimination if that’s the case. For non-binary people, it’s their choice to reject the reality of binary biological sex, so I can’t fathom why they’d want to be part of something that acknowledges the reality of biological sex. But that’s they’re journey to work through 🤷♀️🙄
All of this is proving that single-sex spaces are necessary, wanted, needed & biological sex has to supersede gender identity in law to protect *everyones* rights.
And yes, a Tickle V Giggle win for Giggle will mean that lesbians can have female only events, services & spaces 💗
I answered your serious question with the serious reality of the situation. I asked you, what rights are you willing to give up for trans rights? Freedom of belief? Freedom of speech? Freedom of association? We have to be able to have these conversations because when you seriously research what “trans rights” are demanding, it’s that you give up all of these rights. And more.
I, personally, will not be doing it.
Do I support people having whatever “identity” they want? Yep. Of course. But I do not support having to participate in that identity at the cost of my own rights.
So, I suggest, before you go around saying “trans rights”, and being facetious to women who have been on the front line for years and have either risked or lost everything for it, look into what you’re actually talking about. It’s a big deal.
Anyone can believe whatever they want to believe as an individual. Now that we’ve got that out of the way, we have to consider if that is being reciprocated.
Women’s rights are the canary in the coal mine of trans ideology. We’re the first to be expected to move over and give up our rights. A lot of people simply expect that of women, don’t care and just don’t understand why women are fighting back so seriously.
But the evidence of why is everywhere.
Trans ideology forces people to ignore what they see with their own eyes (“that’s not a man, that’s a woman”). Trans ideology punishes people who don’t believe in it (There are countless examples of violent threats from trans activists to women). Trans ideology punishes people who don’t use their language (thus suddenly, words are violence). Are you willing to give up your critical thinking faculties, your freedom of belief & your freedom of speech? All in the name of one ideology that is demonstrably false? I assume you’re not. Historically, religion did do that to the societies it had power over. Thanks to enlightenment values, that is no longer the case in the western world.
No one is marginalized because they’re attempting to live a lie. To make it worse, the group claiming to be oppressed due to that lie are actually taking away rights & discriminating against the real deal of the group they’re desperate to be included in. And we should find compromise in this? No. Compromising on this is what has lead to the current mess we are in.
Believe what you want. And until trans ideology also accepts that value, it is an ideology that harms others.
There is no such thing as a man being able to “live as a woman”. If a man is wearing a dress & makeup, or whatever else he equates to “living as a woman”, he is a man wearing a dress & makeup. That is his authentic self. There is nothing wrong with a man liking feminine stereotypes. But, again, it just makes him a man who likes feminine stereotypes. To attribute any other meaning to it is to degrade women, turning “woman” into an idea rather than the biological sex class of adult human females. That is the definition of misogyny.
As a society, we could be part of a zeitgeist to allow superficial gender stereotypes to be fluid between the sexes. But we’re not. We’re in the midst of a zeitgeist of lies and ideology, a total regression. And if you give an inch with any of it, a mile will be taken. That’s why we’re in this situation.
The existence of trans women is either men whose instinct for femininity has been weaponized against them to the point of much internal distress, or a man who gets sexual gratification of the idea of himself “living as a woman”. I have a lot of sympathy for the former and zero for the latter. What both of these demographics of men have in common is they are not and never will be women, and at no point do women have to accommodate them at the expense of our own rights & dignify.
@[private account] is no more transphobic as you are for advocating for female only spaces.
It is so simple. They have confused it. Because they don’t have facts or reality, they have to use confusion to get what they want.
Gender can be a very useful framework to explain or analyze stereotypes and expectations of both sexes (women = wear makeup, men = don’t cry. That’s gender).
A truly progressive movement would say “while there are sex-based stereotypes and expectations (ie, gender), these stereotypes and expectations can be ignored by any individual. Men & women, boys & girls can have whatever tastes, fashion sense, interest, career paths (or lack of) and goals they want. No one changes sex and it isn’t even necessary to lie that people do in order to express yourself how you want.”
In the western world, and especially in major cities, this is basically how it was up until a few years ago. Men can wear dresses. Women can not be mothers, etc. *insert stereotypes and flip them here*. The *only* restrictions are the necessary ones: like males can’t go into female spaces and sport. But they can “live as a woman”, whatever that means to an individual, everywhere else.
The sex-based restrictions that exist (female only spaces & sport, eg) still exist because they’re necessary. For safety, privacy, dignity, fairness and equality. They’re positive sex discrimination (as opposed to how it used to be, ie sex discrimination like not letting women vote based on no positive reasons at all).
Because a “trans woman” can basically just “live as a woman in society” with little to no interruption, the validation that they *are* women isn’t there. That desperation for their delusion to be validation is a very powerful force, it turns out. The only way to get that validation is to be able to go into female spaces & sport. It’s the final frontier, really. Confusion & lies is the only way they’re going to get it.
Trans people still have a sex. All their protections are sex based, just like *everyone else*. Sex protections do all the work. Gender identity protections only *take away* sex based rights from females, while giving extra privileges to males.
Trans rights activists constantly say “trans women are women like black women are women”. That is fundamentally racist while also being unbelievably sexist.
I’m genuinely laughing at the suggestion @ThePosieParker has refused a debate. Cute. 🙄
I will debate any trans activist. There is not a single one I am intellectually afraid of. Not one.
I watched the Sinead documentary last night. It’s just devastating. A woman’s career utterly cancelled because she spoke unpopular truths. They tried to say that she’s the reason pop stars can speak up about issues like “trans rights” now. No. Thats simply not true. There’s no risk in what’s popular. Sinead’s is the warning to any “TERF” female singers who wants her rights back. We need more Sinead’s now. Brave, honest women who don’t give AF about what’s “cool”.
https://youtu.be/-VLy1A4En4U
I cannot wait to see this film and for “trans widows” to finally get some attention. They really are one of the most forgotten about & ignored demographics in all of this mess, and being utterly gaslit by the organizations that are supposed to help them.
To donate to the Trans Widows documentary "Behind The Looking Glass" fundraiser, click here:
https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=EMKWNQ5HBJFCU
I am so excited to release this podcast tomorrow with @[private account], an amazing filmmaker & woman's rights campaigner, who is making a documentary on Trans Widows.
Until then, listen to the trailer & watch her first film "Dysphoric", available on YouTube @ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8taOdnXD6o&t=12s
Those against Gender Ideology are women, men, atheist, Christian, Jewish, Muslim, liberal, conservative, rich, poor, gay, straight, bi, trans, married, single, black, white, asian, latino.
We may agree on nothing but humans cant change sex & that’s our strength not our weakness.
Cool. Now, go research “trans widows”, women who married a man and have to divorce someone they’re forced to call “she”. Find out what they’re going through and fit that law into it. Again, godspeed.
See, I think you’re actually right that we’re not the same in a way. You seem to attach yourself to whatever cause will give you social clout, whatever is the fad issue of the time, while I don’t. I don’t care if what I’m fighting for is not “cool”. I care if it’s true & fair.
If you have been fighting for “trans rights” all along, then you’ve been against gay rights. Because gender identity and sexual orientation are in complete opposition with each other. Evidenced by the fact that males cannot be lesbians and females cannot be gay men.
One day, I have no doubt, you’re going to wake up and realize you’ve been advocating for mens rights and actively working against the rights of women & same sex attracted people. It will be a daunting day.
And the *biggest* difference between you and I is that on that day, I won’t hold it against you and I will still work with you. I understand that no one is immune from falling for bullshit. We’re all human.
And that means,
Men aren’t women.
Women aren’t men.
Human beings can’t change sex.
No one is born in the wrong body.
Lesbians are only attracted to women.
Gay men are only attracted to men.
Bisexual refers to the biological sex binary.
Men should be able to be feminine.
Women should be able to be masculine.
No one should be medicalized & lied to because of this.
Celebrate people for who they actually are, instead of who they are not.
We sometimes believe stupid things, like the opposite of all of this.
Now, seriously, I’m done here. I have a family. I’m tired. Have a nice night.
Well, Sally, finding commonality with people you otherwise disagree with is noble. In fact, it’s how the allied powers defeated the *actual* Nazis.
If you actually listened to the women you call TERFs, you’d know what we’re actually about. Instead, you stay willfully ignorant. That’s your choice to make. If you’re ever curious, I’d recommend reading Helen Joyce’s book “Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality”.
In the meantime, side with men who say they’re lesbians and send death threats to lesbians who say they’re not. You do you. I hope it works out for you. Godspeed.
“Trans Rights are human rights” allows a lot of white men to fantasize that they're the victim of bigotry and discrimination, but it just shows that they have no idea what actual discrimination is and would shatter like glass if it ever really happened to them.
🤷♀️
Exactly. My point is, female spaces are for females, non-negotiable. If a politician is all about “trans rights”, find a way to accommodate them, but the solution is not men in womens spaces.
At the moment, when there are “third spaces”, they’re not used because the female spaces have been opened up. But if they’re legally not an option, one part of this puzzle has been solved. Not all, just one.
I think third spaces will inevitably become another male-only space, but I think some people need to see this nonsense through to its logical conclusion to be convinced.
I feel honored to be speaking in NSW parliament today with these amazing & brave women.
To me, the solution to the gender wars is incredibly simple: create all the unisex & trans things you want. But female-only spaces, services & sport have to stay. Oh & don’t enforce ideology.
I’ve gotta ask, if it’s a “fake app no one uses which uses racist facial recognition software to try to kick out trans woman from the app (which fails anyway)” why would anyone be so desperate to use it that they’d take me to federal court to gain access?
No, not to trans activists it is not.
Gender was just a polite synonym for sex. Some feminists also had arguments about gender expression and the pressure of women to conform to feminine gender. This is all very different from current-day trans activists.
@[private account] @[private account] They never think of the “trans identified” females, do they? It’s only ever about the males. Males, males, males.
🙄
I don’t specifically “ban trans women”. I ban males. Gender identity is irrelevant. It’s not like some guys are welcome but a certain demographic isn’t. It’s just males, across the board, who are not welcome in a women-only space. That’s what makes it a women-only space.
There are plenty of trans-only, and LGBTQ+ only, platforms that I am not welcome on. Because I’m not trans or part of the LGBTQ+ community. What kind of asshole would I be if I tried to force my way into them because I didn’t feel included in something not intended for me?
I think that female-only spaces need to be able to coexist in society & the marketplace, along side all of the spaces for specific demographics. That is actual diversity & inclusion: everyone having choices & places to go.
There are many women who want & need female only spaces. To ignore them is not a virtue, nor inclusive. It’s men’s right activism.
It sounds like you have been to hell & back. I’m so sorry. I know how hard it is to stay in reality when everyone around you is telling you up is down (or man is woman).
Ignoring trans widow voices just proves how inherently misogynistic this abhorrent trans movement is.
💗
So, “trans widows” can’t use the word “widow” because their ex-husbands are still alive but men can call themselves women despite not being a woman?
If you’re going to give AF about language, start with what trans windows are talking about in the first place.
No one is calling for trans people to not participate in elite sports & it’s humiliating for @[private account] that their CEO does not know this.
People are calling for trans people to participate within the *same rules as everyone else* by competing in the category of their bio sex.
Evidentially, Kieren Perkins did not spend a lot of time thinking about the fact that the most inclusive policy in sports is for “trans people” to follow *the exact same rules as everyone else* and complete according to biological sex.
Women aren’t men with low testosterone.
The current state of “trans rights” are in direct conflict with many other rights, including freedom of speech & freedom of belief.
If a “trans person” feels discriminated against because they can’t force someone to see them how they’re not, it only proves the conflict.
Over the past 10 years, women & gay men have increasingly become political targets, including from far-left groups. Reuben Kaye should invite some on the the panel to have an honest discussion about the conflict of trans privileges & women’s & gay rights. It’s about time.
I want biological sex recognized in law when necessary, like for female only spaces and sport, and it established in law that a woman is an adult human female.
I will support “trans people” in campaigns for additional unisex spaces, 3rd & even 4th spaces if necessary, so that *everyones* rights are catered to and protected. That’s actual diversity. When it comes to sport, trans people should follow the *same rules as everyone else* and compete according to their biological sex. That’s actual inclusion.
I want it established that no one is forced to adhere to an ideology they don’t believe in. The reality is that the current state of “trans rights” are in direct conflict with many other rights, including freedom of speech & freedom of belief. If a “trans person” feels discriminated against because they can’t force someone to see them how they see themselves, that only proves the conflict. It is a major problem that needs to be solved in a manner that benefits and protects *everyone*.
Society does not revolve around trans people.
@[private account] @JamesEsses Not being transgender doesn’t require any clarification. I do not believe in gender identity ideology. I reject the whole thing. Call yourself whatever you want but don’t impose it upon other people.
*ahem*
Predatory men will try anything to gain access to women. Women need to have the right to stop them and be heard.
Gender identity ideology *takes away* womens right to be heard and stop men from being in female spaces, therefore having a remedy for predatory men. Having female only spaces reinstated the right of women to have boundaries & be heard when we say we don’t want a man to break the boundary.
The ones making it easier for predatory men are trans rights activists. Go and learn about what you’re fighting for. Don’t waste my time with attempted “gotchas”. You will fail.
We’re done here.
Every government flying trans flags could end the conflict between “trans rights” & women’s rights in a day by initiating third spaces & new sports categories for the demographic who want them while ensuring the protection of women’s rights. It’s that simple and they don’t do it.
OMG I can’t stop laughing.
Women have been saying *for years* that men will lie about being trans to gain access to female spaces & we’re told we’re bigots for even thinking it.
This is too good.
*ahem*
I have absolutely no doubt that a predatory man will try any loophole to gain access to women. Which is why spaces should be restricted based on *sex* and any man who violates the boundary be removed. Gender ideology is trying to *take away* that boundary by allowing men into female spaces so long as they say they are women or, as your argument demonstrates so spectacularly well, “transmen”.
Ok Andrew, I’ll answer it for you:
Buck is female, and therefore is *legally welcome* in a female space. However, the thing with female spaces is that no female is *forced* to use them. Females are welcome to *not* use female spaces. (This really isn’t that hard to understand). For females who have gone above & beyond to look like men, and in some rare cases “pass” as men at first glance, their presence may be initially unsettling for women who confuse them as actual men. These females often use male spaces. If these females use male spaces, that is between them and *males*. It has nothing to do with advocates of female spaces. Men and “trans men” can battle this one out amongst themselves in the event that men don’t want “transmen” in their spaces.
For me, I think transmen are the demographic that requires a third space, as their presence can be unsettling to women and they could be in danger in a male space, once predatory men are aware that a female is present. Governments & organizations could be campaigning for third spaces, so *everyones* rights are catered for. But they’re not. Because, ultimately, they don’t really care about this issue. They care about the easy virtue signaling. Once it has no social clout, they’ll never bring it up again.
So while the likes of Buck are *legally allowed* in female spaces on the basis that *they are female*, if they don’t want to use them, they don’t have to.
The main issue with female spaces is that *males* are legally & physically kept out of them.
There. Your patronizing “gotcha” question is answered.
Four women went to a “One Women Project” event in Brisbane & were escorted out by security because they dared to question trans dogma.
It’s a rather amusing tale featuring $11 margaritas & lots of “civil disobedience in modern activism”.
Full clip:
https://www.youtube.com/live/fp0GmeqPQ7c?feature=share
Just like how we’re not mad about trans-only spaces (there are dozens of trans-only apps, for instance), we’re not mad about trans-only sport. Have fun! Go for it! We just want there to be *female-only* sport & spaces. What you do beyond that is your business.
FFS 🤷♀️🤦♀️
Helen Joyce wrote “Trans: when ideology meets reality”, a Sunday Times best seller, published a year before MW’s documentary was released.
Kelly-Jay Keen has created a global movement of women, started by the first “Adult Human Female” billboard she put up in 2018.
Maya Forstater was fired for saying sex is real & took her employer to court. She eventually won & ensured that acknowledging the reality of biological sex is a protected belief that people cannot be discriminated again.
Kathleen Stock was pushed out of her job for speaking up about gender ideology. She wrote “Material Girls” & was in the just released documentary “Gender Wars”.
Julie Bindle has been speaking up since around 2003, written countless articles & platformed all the women who have come along to speak up for our rights.
Womens Liberation Front in the US has worked with countless politicians in various states to ensure women’s right is law, including protecting the definition of woman.
Kara Dansky, a former ACLU lawyer, wrote “The Abolition Of Sex” specifically about the legal issues of gender ideology & womens rights in the US. It was published in 2021.
Riley Gaines, a former U.S college swimmer, has brought more attention to the issue of men in women’s sports than any other US athlete. She raced against Lia Thomas.
Allison Bailey, a lesbian barrister in the UK, successfully sued her chambers over discrimination on the basis she says men aren’t lesbians & was punished. She won.
Meghan Murphy was one of the first women to get punished for speaking out & was punished severely for it. Every effort was made to silence her. It didn’t work. She is still writing articles weekly.
Katherine Deves single handedly made gender ideology front page news in Australia in 2022, breaking years of silence. It came at huge personal cost to herself.
JK Rowling spoke out about gender ideology specifically for the first time in 2020, bringing the issue to the attention of millions of people all around the world, inspiring more women than anyone else to speak up.
All the women listed here work together, like the thousands of women around the world speaking out, and are all parts of the puzzle to ensure truth & reality will prosper. Matt Walsh made a documentary titled “What Is A Woman” and called none of them.
Does that answer your question?
That is exactly what trans activists did to my company, an app exclusively for women. They left thousands of 1 star reviews of a platform they hadn’t used purely because men are not women & therefore can’t use it.
There are plenty of apps exclusively for trans people. I support them all. It makes total sense to want to have a real life or digital space to want to go to for a very specific reason. I just want spaces for females to be able to co-exist. Like most of us do 💗
Excuse me. The app is not “anti-trans”. It’s just female only. Which means it not for males. If you call that “anti-trans”, all you’re doing is admitting that “transwomen” are indeed male.
If I was a “Trans Rights Activist”, I would have dedicated my time to campaigning for TW exclusive spaces & services and telling governments to give funding instead of raising flags, rather than demanding 50% of the population to just accept men as women. But that’s just me. 🤷♀️
Tickle V Giggle is going to Federal Court.
I want to take this opportunity to say I’m not trying to ban trans spaces or women + “transwoman” spaces. I’m fighting for female spaces to also exist & ensure no woman is forced to see a man as a woman.
https://gigglecrowdfund.com
I’ll answer:
No oppressed class has ever managed to get laws changed in their favor without fellow citizens being aware of it, but trans activists did. Women became aware of it & we’re fighting back.
The oppressed group isn’t trans here.
Oh & widespread corporate support negates your point, too. What they’re doing is purely tokinism, of course, they don’t actually give AF, but they’ll pretend for cheap praise. Actually oppressed groups don’t get that luxury because the people with the money don’t think they’re worth it.
What trans activists are demanding are privileges, while taking away women’s rights.
Until men decided they are women, and some people took that seriously, women did have female only spaces & sport.
Want trans only or women + “transwomen” spaces? Campaign for them. Create them.
Trans ideology:
That men are women if they say so.
That women are men if they say so.
That sex change is possible.
That biological sex is not binary.
That people are born in the wrong body.
That males should be granted access to female spaces & sport.
That trans people are oppressed.
All of this is demonstrable bullshit. But it is believed as fact by a loud minority of people, all of who are male or & female whether they like it or not.
There is no ideological “leader” that I’m aware of, although there does seem to be many powerful men with the fetish for wearing women’s clothes who have a lot of influence.
One of the goals is, without a doubt, eroding womens rights. And women are fighting back against that.
The only reason to deny “transwomen” from serving time in a women’s prison is they are men.
There are many vulnerable men in prison. Gay men. Young men. Old men. Police officer men. No gang affiliated men. Trans identified men are just another demographic for the *male prison” to accommodate. They’re not women’s problem.
You would think that once people understood that Transgender Ideology leads to things like male rapists being put in a women’s prison, people would concede there is an issue. But people like you seem to be fine with this reality. So, she persists in explaining why you’re blatantly wrong and ideological.
If you would like to use unisex spaces or create more spaces, branded as “women + trans women spaces”, I’m not going to stop you. Godspeed. But you can’t force all women to accept men into female spaces. Female spaces can co-exist along side everything else. That’s diversity.
Finally, the above link is not a petition. It’s a site to fund the court case. I’m The respondent in the case, not the applicant.
My point is, if they want to boast about women’s response to the question, how are they defining women?
“Men who claim to be women are for trans rights” is just obviously how that cookie is going to crumble.
@[private account] @OliLondonTV What Lego said 40 years ago is genuinely positive & progressive, and in direct opposition to transgender ideology which says, among many ridiculous things, that if a boy likes “girls toys” it means he is a girl or a girl liking “boy toys” is a boy. It’s nonsense.
If you’re going to tell the story tell it factually, otherwise it’s not journalism & there is no point.
https://reduxx.info/italy-trans-identified-male-arrested-after-stripping-in-front-of-school-threatening-people-with-hiv/
What I’d add:
- Even adults need to understand that taking hormones & having cosmetic surgery does not turn someone into the opposite sex. There is literally no such thing as a “sex change”. At best, one can emulate the opposite sex. Emulating the opposite does not mean you get any of the rights of that sex. This should be understood completely before undergoing irreversible procedures.
- many different kinds of female only spaces exist. They are for females. If there is a need for trans only or women + trans identified male spaces, create them. In a diverse world, female only spaces co-exist with all the others.
- freedom of belief is a fundamental human right & if someone doesn’t believe in “transgender ideology”, it’s not because they’re a bigot. It’s because they don’t believe in your ideology. Simple. Cope with it.
- “preferred pronouns” aren’t trivial and should never be enforced. This current zeitgeist didn’t *start* with calling male rapists “she” and “her penis”. It started by normalizing calling men “she” in other contexts.
- Leave children out of it completely, and that includes not allowing men who think they’re women to chemically “lactate” to “breastfeed” an infant.
- If people truly care about the marginalized, they should listen to “detransitioners”. This is a group of people who have experienced gross medical malpractice & have a lot of insight into this current zeitgeist. They should be heard & defended.
@[private account] @[private account] Why is a “trans man” more comfortable being called “a body with female sex organs” than a woman? That’s an issue that needs to be worked on, not indulged.
“By including transgender women in a category that’s designed for female equality you are excluding the whole group of people that category was designed for. So you will be excluding females from their own races.”
Watch the full video by @[private account]: https://youtu.be/KFQLkDHqf84
The problem with saying “trans woman” is that people picture a woman in their mind. But we’re not talking about women. We’re talking about men. It’s a mental manipulation, pushed further by being told we’re not being “kind” to say men. The truth isn’t always kind.
It’s like, people who call themselves trans exist like every other human who has ever been alive on planet earth. They don’t exist any more or less than anyone else. Part of existing civilly is being aware of those around you and they’re not acknowledging the existence of others.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] All city councils & most state governments are flying the trans flag. Go and get them to give you funding. They all claim to support trans rights, get them to put their money where their mouth is. No more virtual signaling. Do the work.
Unisex spaces should accept everyone.
Female spaces should accept only females.
If you want more specific catering, and to ensure that trans specific issues are catered to, create trans only places. If there is a need, create it.
Instead of spending your days Tweeting, go & start a nationwide trans-only organization in every capital city for refuge. Do the work, get the funding, lay the bricks & help. Don’t sit back & expect women to open our doors. Go on.
BTW the e.g you’re citing is lie. Still, go on.
Let’s say a “trans man” “passes” for a man & is using the male bathroom with no problems. Then, she stops to buy period products in full view of all men using the bathroom.
Is that female less or more safe now that men know they’re in a room with a woman?
I’m goin with less.
Trans Rights is the first “civil rights” movement that demands more rights than everybody else while simultaneously taking away rights from everybody else.
We’re constantly told theres a “trans genocide”, that trans people are the most in danger demographic in the world. So when I tweeted about an actual danger, sexual deception to straight men, I naively thought there’d be agreement. A truce.
No.
TRAs have attacked me for 24hours
So there is a risk of male violence for a “trans woman” using a male space but no risk of male violence for “trans women” putting them in a sexual situation? Are you hearing yourself?
@[private account] Yeah, I do. Why don’t you care about the safety of trans people?
https://www.9news.com.au/national/hector-enrique-valencia-valencia-court-sydney-new-south-wales-kimberly-mcrae-death/079cf670-22c5-4ae8-b31f-12a0c50eeb25
@[private account] When you research “trans murders”, 9/10 the cause is attempted or actual sex by deception. It’s horrific.
It’s crazy to me that TRAs have spent the past 24hours attacking me for highlighting the one danger “transwomen” actually do face. It’s all insanity.
https://www.9news.com.au/national/hector-enrique-valencia-valencia-court-sydney-new-south-wales-kimberly-mcrae-death/079cf670-22c5-4ae8-b31f-12a0c50eeb25
This is what I’m getting at, Tom.
I’d prefer it if trans women weren’t killed. I’d also like men not to be sexually deceived.
The whole situation is a mess with no winners. Let’s try and ensure it doesn’t happen, okay?
https://www.9news.com.au/national/hector-enrique-valencia-valencia-court-sydney-new-south-wales-kimberly-mcrae-death/079cf670-22c5-4ae8-b31f-12a0c50eeb25
Actually, I’m thinking of the safety of trans women. Why aren’t you?
And I’m not a womens rights campaigner.
Jeez, any time you speak to me, you’re wrong. I’m almost embarrassed for you. Block me again, please, for your sake.
Because men can be violent, especially when they discover that the “she” they were about to hook up with is actually a he.
It’s so interesting to me. We’re told there is a “trans genocide” & they the most in danger group. Then you state an actual danger & suddenly I’m a bigot 🙄
A male being attracted to a male, no matter what hormones or surgery have occurred, is homosexuality.
It’s literally that simple.
There is nothing wrong with being homosexual & men are entitled to be attracted to trans women. It just isn’t heterosexuality when they are.
You have to ask, if privacy and safety are the main concern for trans people, why isn’t the focus on just creating third & even fourth spaces? Why make *everyone else* in society change something that works for us?
So if no one is being attacked, why can’t “trans women” use male bathrooms?
The claim is that it’s too unsafe. Evidentially, it isn’t.
See, what you’re exposing here is that *validation* is the most important factor.
Whoops.
🤷♀️
I fear trans activists are going to discover that heterosexual men having their sexuality attacked are significantly less patient and willing to talk about the issue than lesbians have been.
@[private account] @[private account] I completely agree with you. However, I’d say, until the inherent homophobia in transgender ideology is addressed, it’s not just the acronym that is atrocious.
Im so sorry & I hate that you’ve experienced homophobic violence & I’d do anything to help you stop it.
“We’re told [trans] is the most marginalized group in society but gender identity was put into the SDA without us knowing about it… this is a group who got laws changed in stealth. If you believe these people are marginalized I suppose you’d believe anything, like men are women”
I think trans activists are going to discover that heterosexual men having their sexuality attacked are significantly less patient and willing to talk about the issue than lesbians are.
It’s super rare for Trans Rights Activists to so clearly state what they believe trans human rights are, but here it is & it can be summed up as “ignore all of your instincts. Your human rights are irrelevant.”
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @theserfstv Trans athletes are welcome to compete for medals within their sex class, thus following the *exact same rules as everyone else*.
If trans people compete according to their “gender identity”, with males in female categories, they will win. Females in male categories will not.
@[private account] I completely agree. I will not hold anything against women who - for lack of a better phrase - fell for the trans cult. No one is above believing bullshit from time to time. No one is above falling for nonsense. It’s part of what makes us human. I welcome with open arms 💗
“Whether it’s Dan Andrews, John Pesutto or Shannon Fentiman, they are making a bigger drama. We need adults in the room to have a mature, fact based, rational discussion about the conflicts of womens rights & trans rights & move forward. At the moment they’re making it worse.”
Trans men have not transitioned to male. They are female people.
No human being has ever changed sex.
Trans men are not forced to use female spaces & if men have a problem with them in male spaces that is between men and trans men.
@[private account] I’m happy for there to be trans only spaces & women + men who think they’re women spaces if there is a market for it. We all co-exist in this wonderful world together but to have unique places to go to should be a right of everyone. I just want there to also be female only spaces
Exactly. They’re not “female spaces + some men”. They’re just female spaces. It’s that simple. Trans identified males aren’t excluded from female spaces on the basis that they’re trans. They’re excluded because they’re male.
“We both know I have written to many GC feminists seeking a private discussion on trans issues and to de-escalate the ‘debate’. I am sorry my approaches have been rebuffed.”
Quoting @salltweets: I emailed Jolyon Maugham inviting him to a public debate about the “conflict” between women’s rights and trans rights, as he publicly claims he wants to do but insists it is feminists refuse.
He replied and refused.
I’m fighting for your daughter, my daughter, myself & every woman & girl in the world. Even the women who say they want “trans women” in the locker room. They don’t. They’re not picturing this 👆when they say it. They’re picturing you, the man who would not go in the first place.
If any man can call himself a woman, how do you know that it’s women who are more supportive of trans rights & not just men claiming to be women being supportive?
Furthermore, why is sex-based data suddenly important to you when you’re trying to say that sex is irrelevant?
🙄🤷♀️
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @SkyNews You should tell that to trans activists & politicians who call women Nazis because we want female only spaces.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @SkyNews That’s your prerogative. Godspeed. But if you try to say that trans women’s place is in female spaces & sport, expect a lot of pushback from women. Expect “NO”. Because you’d be telling us to give up rights, while giving a demographic of men *more* rights, even more than you have
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @SkyNews No it doesn’t. Trans women simply *are* a demographic of man. The *only* prerequisite to be a trans woman is to be male. I can’t be a trans woman because I’m female. Lying about this is not helping trans women. You’re just lying to them. How is that the moral high ground?
Do you ignore the death threats that come from the trans community to women because it doesn’t suit your narrative or because you just haven’t bothered to acknowledge them at all?
I don’t want dignity stripped away from women & girls who want female only spaces. Transsexuals are also people & all people deserve dignity. But not at the expense of someone else’s dignity. Transexual spaces are an option for privacy, safety & dignity of trans people.
It’s hilarious to me that Trans Activists while try and do the mental gymnastics of “the app was so shit but you banned people from the app that is apparently so shit!” If it was so shit, why would men who think they’re women be so desperate to use it? Both can’t be true.
Learn how to Google. It’s the first thing that comes up.
https://www.theguardian.com/media/2022/dec/31/transgender-woman-sues-female-only-app-giggle-for-girls-for-alleged-discrimination
When Trans Activists first came for me in February 2020, it didn’t occur to me to apologize or clarify. I just looked into what they were saying. That led me to see what women were saying. I “educated myself”. And I found out the truth:
It’s women’s rights that are under attack.
I agree that one can support women while recognizing the rights of trans people. But it will include ensuring that female only spaces & sport are female only, no males included, and if trans people need their own spaces & sport let’s work towards that.
Females with a trans identity are welcome on female spaces.
Female spaces are not trans exclusionary. They’re male exclusionary.
If you want unisex rape crisis centers, go & create them. Godspeed.
“I also don’t think the High Court would regard the meaning of ‘woman’ as being eternally fixed under the Constitution in applying a treaty,” he (ACU constitutional expert Greg Craven) added.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/femaleonly-app-ceo-defends-barring-trans-woman/news-story/1e5639dc4a998899dc7cbb4abb8042ec
This is actually discussed in the episode.
If we were having a conversation about a category of “trans” being legally created, that would be a different conversation & an interesting one.
But we’re in a situation where people are saying they’re the opposite sex. And they’re not.
@[private account] @[private account] Cool story.
Creating a “women + trans woman”, male & TERF space options would just be creating unisex, male & female space options. There is no getting around this.
Oh and if my app was so off the mark, men wouldn’t be desperate to be included in it. But they are.
🤷♀️
She was not violent at all. None of the women who are speaking up for womens rights are violent. Trans Activists, however, very much are. There is no “both sides” here to compare.
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentviolence terror
Female spaces are for females. Women of color are females. Trans youth is welcome in sport, just follow the exact same rules as everyone else & compete in your sex class. That’s actual inclusion! 🙋♀️
Trans people literally want special treatment.
And it will involve taking away rights from women.
No man has the basic right to go into a female space or female sport. Good men don’t even think about doing it.
As long as people like you gaslight us - we’ll always fight back.
@[private account] @[private account] I want trans people to live happy & healthy lives based in reality.
I am aware that trans is transgenderism. And if you’re going to make an argument that sex & gender are different, I agree. It’s why I think gender identity should not be in the sex discrimination act.
@[private account] @[private account] I can’t reread it, because I am blocked. I could read it initially, when I wasn’t blocked.
From memory, the Tweet was about trans people feeling attacked. Trans people will continue to feel attacked if they are lied to about changing sex & told they’re female when they’re male.
I want you to see this. Over a quarter of a million people have seen it. The violent misogyny in the “Trans Rights” movement has been exposed. Posie Parker never loses and she hasn’t. But she sure has exposed a lot of losers.
Quoting @salltweets: Trans Activists show why women want and need female only spaces.
They’re welcome to self-exclude. But if they wanted to be part of The Lesbian Project, they would be welcome.
So to say that it is trans exclusionary in any way is just factually, demonstrably, incorrect.
Do you realize that *trans men* are included in The Lesbian Project? Trans people are not excluded. Just *males*, including *males* with a trans identity. But females, even females with a trans identity? Welcome!
We’re all getting pretty tired of this mens rights movement.
Everyone is suffering. But yes, there are people with gender dysphoria who know exactly who they are, they acknowledge their biological sex & just want to move about in the world in a way that is psychologically less distressing for them. Trans activists have done them no favors.
New Zealand trans rights activists really don’t want anyone to hear women speak about womens rights to female-only spaces, female sport & protecting lesbians.
Men are not women.
#LetWomenSpeak
As your focus is coercive control & domestic abuse, I suggest you read the accounts of trans widows, women who have been abused in their relationships with autogynophilic men & whose plight is all but ignored by society.
https://www.transwidowsvoices.org/post/tseveas-story-the-man-in-the-mirror
C3 dehumanizinghand-codeddenialfetish fraudviolence terror
Why don’t you just work to make male spaces accommodating for men with “trans/gender diverse” identities? That’s the obvious solution here to actually get progress. I can’t fathom why no one is doing it…
No. And I give you credit that you can read, so you know exactly what I said.
Be comfortable with whatever you want. But if other women are not, it doesn’t make them a bigot. It’s a woman with different boundaries to you.
Want women + trans women (unisex) spaces? Create them!
Tasmanian trans activists yelled “shame” at an elderly disabled lesbian telling her life story of working for women’s rights & with gay men during the 1980s AIDS epidemic. It was all recorded. You have absolutely nothing to be proud of.
I’ve never seen a group so desperate for people to be Nazis than trans activists are. It’s deeply offensive & antisemitic.
Women want to be a recognized in law as sex class that men cannot identify into. If you think that is “Nazism”, you have been grossly misinformed on Nazism.
@[private account] No. I didn’t. I’ve never seen a group of people so desperate for people to be Nazis than trans activists are. It’s deeply offensive & borderline anti-Semitic. Women want to be a recognized sex-class in law that men can’t identify into. If you disagree, give a good argument.
They are. They may not want to be, but they are. Even the doctors administering hormones & performing surgeries know trans women are male, so they know what drugs to give & what surgery to perform. If they weren’t male, they wouldn’t be trans. Lying about this helps no one.
I didn’t say you were trans or that you are lying. But lies are being told about women.
There are many women who want & need female only spaces. To make it illegal for women to have boundaries from males is not progress.
No. No men are welcome in female spaces. Not gay males, not males who think they’re women, not any males. It’s not like they’re “female spaces + the good guys!” They’re female spaces.
Want women + trans women spaces? Build them. Godspeed.
“They’re absolutely not associated with me whatsoever. I absolutely abhor anything to do with Nazis. It’s preposterous they even exist in 2023” - @ThePosieParker
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/immigration-new-zealand-reviews-entry-for-uk-anti-trans-activist-kellie-jay-keen-minshull/FQNQMWZQ7NFKVMWIJ4RUUELZJ4/
If you think that what women are saying aligns with Nazis, you’re grossly and offensively misinformed on Nazism.
My entire point is Trans Activists are gleeful that women are being associated with Nazis because it satisfies the desire to shut women up. You’re proving my point.
They succeeded in deflecting attention off women speaking about womens rights, which is what the trans activists want to do. It’s why both trans activists and Nazis were at the rally.
The point of my Tweet is Trans Activists are happy Nazis were there because they can use it to punish women and you all just keep proving my point for all to see.
I’m going to say out loud what we’re not supposed to say:
The only group that has benefited from Nazis invading a Let Women Speak event are Trans Activists, who are using it as a tool to stop women being heard.
If Nazis are *benefitting* your movement, you’re in a bad movement.
Would you care to offer support to the women who have been defamed & threatened due to the Nazi and trans activist presence? Or do these women, who want women’s rights, not even enter your mind?
The presence of Nazis at the event has resulted in women being terrified & guilt by an association they never asked for, while Trans Activists celebrate the presence of Nazis as a way to discredit women. Nazis aren’t benefiting women. They’re benefiting the Trans Activists.
@[private account] I don’t claim to.
If women want to have men in their spaces, they are welcome to. Create as many “women + trans women” only spaces as you want. You have my full support.
I have never once done interviews “attacking trans women’s access to bathrooms and healthcare reflecting their gender”.
Trans women are welcome to use the male bathroom & I hope all trans people have access to proper & appropriate healthcare.
Louise was suggesting bathrooms & change rooms exclusively for trans people so they also get privacy & dignity, which additionally would close up a loophole of predatory men being able to use transgenderism as a loophole to gain access to women. What is “hateful” about that?
@[private account] The speech I posted was Louise campaigning for trans-only bathrooms & change-rooms, which I support. Most LGBT people are as aware of their biological sex as I am, as biological sex is very relevant in every part of the LGBT.
I am sick & tired of men calling us whatever they want because we know that men are not & never will be women.
We’re not anti-trans campaigners.
We’re not transphobic.
We’re not bigots.
We’re women who want female only spaces & sport. We want womens SEX BASED rights.
“Emerging research shows that trans women retain a male pattern of criminality including for violent crimes” - Australia has another hero political woman brave enough to speak up, Tasmanian @[private account] 💗
(It’s worth noting the eye rolling from the man sitting next to her)
I have no doubt that you’re able to use Google to find this information out for yourself.
https://www.newsweek.com/jk-rowling-books-burned-tiktok-transgender-issues-1532330
While “TERFs” are constantly told we’re the same as the “christian far right”, the reality is that the two groups who have banned & burned Harry Potter books are the Christian far right & trans activists, and this commonality should be mentioned more.
#TheWitchTrialsOfJKRowling
You’re on the right track but your language/conclusion is wrong.
Men are men
Women are women
Gender identity is an idea, and a bad one
No one is born in the wrong body & humans can’t change sex
Trans as a prefix is a lie
@[private account] My tweet didn’t mention a) trans people or b) violent criminals. You came to that conclusion on your own.
But I will say, I have never & will never accuse all trans people of being “violent criminals” & it’s unnecessary to do so. Even nice men can’t come into female spaces.
If you must know, I’m against *every* law that says a man is a woman. Every single one. Laws specifically for *trans* people should not involve 1. lies and 2. taking away the rights of other people.
We’re done here.
I prefer the Graham Linehan who stands up for truth, women, children & reality, and I also know that he would happily debate a trans activist offline but “surprisingly” there aren’t trans activists willing to do that.
I support female only spaces, male only spaces, gay male spaces, lesbian spaces, trans spaces & while I personally wouldn’t use them, I also support women + trans women spaces if there is a demand for them.
This is actual “inclusion & diversity”.
🤷♀️
@[private account] For a trans woman to have the *exact* same rights as me, it would mean that they don’t have the right to go into a space reserved for members of the opposite sex. Hence, they don’t have the right to go into female spaces like I don’t have the right to go into male spaces.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] A simple Google search will confirm my last point.
https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-news/nj-trans-prisoner-impregnated-2-inmates-transferred-mens-facility-rcna38947
"We're sold this idea that trans women should be allowed in womens sports & it sounds like we're talking about a type of woman. It's mental manipulation. But when you say 'should men be allowed to participate in womens sports' most people go 'no'. And that's the correct answer."
If you want women + trans women spaces, create them. Godspeed. They can co-exist alongside female only spaces. If it’s “diversity & inclusion” you want, this is the actual way to get it.
🤷♀️
Can you please provide evidence of “cis” and “trans” being used for “centuries” in science, specifically in relation to gender. Something academic & scientific from at least the 1750s. Thanks!
I get that many, many people have long thought they were advocating for the rights of innocent trans people, but it’s about time they acknowledged the abundance of evidence & realize they’ve actually just been advocating for the rights of violent men.
Me too. I also support the creation of some women + trans women spaces, however think that they will very quickly becoming male-only spaces. But give it a try. So long as female spaces & male spaces can co-exist, have all the other ones. That’s true inclusion & diversity.
Beyond the fact that using an app isn’t a human right, if you want women + trans women apps to exist, create them. God speed. You have my full support.
Like so many people, I’ve had such a journey with this.
It started with “trans women” out of politeness. It went to “trans identifying males” with increasing exasperation. And now, for me, it’s “men who think they’re women” to convey some clarity.
“There is a fine line between an MRA and a TRA, and it’s drawn with an eyebrow pencil” - 😂👏😂 @[private account]
https://www.spectator.com.au/2023/01/twitters-free-speech-threatens-radical-trans-activism/