The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
If you think my Tweet and the attached news story is about trans people, that’s your problem. Do I think that predatory men can use trans laws to gain access to women? Yes. Evidenced by the attached news story.
Amused that mother replacing "birthing parent" on a Medicare form was the 4th most read article in 2022 for @[private account]
Incidentally, "Grover, who runs a social media app that has a policy of excluding transgender women" is actually "Grover runs an app that just excludes males"🤷♀️
Even if we were to accept the terms “cis women” & “trans women” it would just be spitting women into binary groups of “female women” & “male women”.
It’s almost like they didn’t actually think this through…
🤷♀️🙄
@[private account] @[private account] That was not your question. But I’ll answer it:
self ID laws are being passed to appease trans people. They are requesting the ability to be legally recognized as the opposite sex while knowing that women & girls cannot self ID out of oppression they experience.
There you go.
Trans youth can follow the same rules as everyone else & play in sport competitions or teams according to their biological sex. That’s inclusions, having the same rules for everyone.
You’re advocating for special rules for a specific group, while taking rights away from women.
Honestly, I wish I hadn’t joined this conversation.
I wish you well, you’re doing great work with trans against gr***mers, I hope you’re safe & happy. Merry Christmas. We’re done here.
Once upon a time, I did it as a social courtesy too. Then I thought more about it and stopped. The social courtesy is the entry point. The trans people I am friends with aren’t people who dictate the speech of other people. That’s part of why we’re friends.
While I sincerely doubt their is one, a biological element to being trans would destroy self ID laws & the TWAW mantra as the “trans” part would be cemented.
However, as you have proven, a biological element didn’t even need to be found for these motivations to be revealed.
I will be on @[private account] with @[private account] at 9:30 EST tonight talking about Queensland’s anti-women self ID law, having my email blocked by the QLD attorney-general when questioning the law & ABC cancelling an interview with me about it all due to trans activists interfering.
Females with a trans identity are welcome. Males, with or without a trans identity, are not.
Ergo, it’s males that are excluded. Not trans people.
But they never phrase it this way, do they?
If it turned out that there is an actual biological element to transness, it still wouldn’t make trans people the opposite sex. It would cement the “trans” part of “TWAW”. And it’s clear that is their problem with it.
First of all, I was called a “TERF” long before I had a baby.
2nd, trans activists photoshopped a picture of me liking trans porn.
The reality, that you just choose not to acknowledge, is women care about our own rights & fight to protect them when men are trying to destroy them
So let’s work with people who have a trans identity to help them live lives they enjoy & have a purpose beyond their identity, which can’t possibly be mentally healthy, & lower suicide rates and suicidal ideation as much as possible. Let’s not use suicide statistics as a threat.
People like yourself don’t hate Giggle because the onboarding security doesn’t work. You hate it because it does work.
All females are welcome to use it, and do, including females with a trans indenting. Female is the only requirement.
Just an FYI, every doctor who aids a trans woman with transition has to acknowledge they are male so that they administer the correct hormones & medications. It is a reality that cannot be escaped. While I understand that is distressing for some people, it must be acknowledged.
I’m talking about predatory men. You’re talking about trans people. self ID means any predatory man can call himself trans. I don’t think think they should be able to & it’s one of the reasons I am against self ID laws.
I’m highlighting that predatory men will appropriate trans people to gain access to women, thereby potentially giving trans people a bad name for crimes committed by men. You just accepted he was trans because he said he is a woman, thus proving the dangers of self ID.
There is actually currently a trans children’s charity in @[private account]’s own country that is currently under investigation in part because they sent breast binders to girls with no consultation, but I don’t want to spoil the surprise for when she bothers to read about it 🙄
Maybe listen & learn 🤷♀️
Maybe some people are concerned that some young girls could *possibly* be trying to escape abuse & “womanhood” & it’s being misinterpreted as “trans”? Surely one should at least be able to ask these questions?
In the past 4 days
- the QLD AG blocked my email
- ABC cancelled an interview with me about it
- the host who invited me on was accused of liking trans porn
- trans trolls created screenshots of me liking porn, proving it was all sabotage…
All because I know men aren’t women.
Honey, acknowledging the reality of SAME SEX ATTRACTION is not homophobic.
All you’re proving is that you’re not listening or informed.
Trans activists want to obliterate the definition of sex & replace it with gender. *That* is the homophobia.
Talk to these people & learn.
@[private account] I’d hate for you to spread information, so just an FYI-
Giggle, the app for females, which is currently closed for renovations & expansion, is not a “Gender Critical” app. Women who think TWAW are welcome on it. Trans identifying females are welcome on it.
It’s just no males 🤷♀️
No.
There are Disorders of Sex Development (DSDs), which were once called “intersex” conditions. Certain DSDs affect males, certain DSDs affect females. Nothing to do with trans.
Gender dysphoria was, colloquially, called transsexualism.
Autogynophilia was known as transvestism.
@[private account] It’s time for them to put their money where their mouth is. They go on about trans rights all the time. Now they have to back it up.
Do I think they will? No. But I would happily work with trans people to campaign for third spaces.
@[private account] I have spoken a lot about my fears for trans men in mens bathrooms. I don’t think it’s safe. But the solution to unsafe mens bathrooms is not to open the door to any male who wants to use the womens bathroom. Then it is unsafe too. Create a third option if need be.
@[private account] @[private account] I don’t blame trans people as a whole. I blame law makers who took away womens sex-based rights to single sex spaces.
@[private account] Homosexual people *didn’t* have the same rights as everyone else and there were people who were happy about that.
Trans people *do* have the same rights as everyone else. What they don’t have is *extra* rights that override other peoples rights on the basis of being trans.
@[private account] Don’t put words in my mouth.
Trans identified people exist and have the same rights as everyone else.
But males don’t have rights to female spaces or sport. Males aren’t lesbians. Females aren’t gay men.
Most men, obviously, have no interest. Buy Jordan is right in saying there is a demographic of men who fetishize trans women. It would t be one of the top porn categories if that wasn’t the case.
@[private account] I recognize trans identities. My feminism includes trans men. I just acknowledge that feminism doesn’t include males. It never has and it never will.
@[private account] I simply acknowledge the reality of biological sex, which all trans people also have to acknowledge otherwise there is no such thing as trans, and the reality of womens & homosexual rights. I don’t think there is anything unfriendly about that.
He seems to want people to judge the people in this photo based on appearance alone, though it isn’t clear at all what is “wrong” with the picture, yet if we judge “trans people” based on their appearance and correctly sex them instinctively, we’re bigots.
He’s a fucking moron.
Pink News blocked me when I brought it to their attention that they know trans women are male.
Quoting @salltweets: The quote I gave Pink News is, “Giggle is a social networking app for females. Males are excluded from the user base. There is no other specific demographic that is excluded from the app other than males.”
PinkNews made the decision to run a headline associating TW to males. 🤷♀️
You do realize that trans people who are L, G or B are welcomed by the LGBAlliance? It’s just that their transness won’t be the center of attention, which is probably what the real issue is here.
They fail to realize that it is incredibly easy to tell if someone is “trans.” No announcement is necessary. No one else lives in their fantasy perception of themselves.
A woman known for defending womens sex-based rights arrives in ER in critical condition. Some of the staff have trans identities.
Will she be denied care?
They don’t even love trans people. They only like anyone who unquestionably follows the ideology. They would side with a “cis straight white guy” who adheres to gender ideology over a trans person who doesn’t.
Who knows, it could be the greatest show of all time. Good for them. The point is, exemptions aren’t a right exclusive to trans people & they need to accept that.
I do wonder how they’d react to people turning up who self ID as trans & then hurling abuse at them, which is what happens to female-only spaces & lesbian-only events.
I fully support “transgender only” theatre shows, but I want the same respect given to female spaces & lesbian-only events.
And I’d say the main difference is, “cis people” will respectfully keep their distance. Males do not do this for female spaces & lesbian only events.
Who the hell is for male [alleged] child abusers being called women? Who??? Beyond the male [alleged] child abuser, who does this benefit? Children? No. Women? No. Trans people? No. Men? No. So, please, tell me, who is this for?
Here’s the thing, @[private account]. We in the “Rowling camp” don’t want to call these people trans. We call them male, which they are. It’s *you* & your ilk who insist they are trans. Because you do that, you then have to justify why they should be given special treatment.
Good luck.
Quoting @salltweets: Gender Identity ideology created a loophole for predatory men to appropriate people with gender dysphoria to gain access to victims, power and empathy. And they’re using it, proudly & daily.
We don’t want these people under the “trans umbrella”. You do. 🤷♀️
So not only will you turn on a trans person simply because they say something you don’t agree with, what it is that you don’t agree with is stopping boys from being in a girls change room while they’re all naked.
JFC 🤯
@[private account] @[private account] First, no one is debating your existence. Calm down.
I personally would like trans ID'd females to use female bathrooms etc because I don't trust predatory men at all. It's as simple as that. I don't want you harmed.
However, if you want them, create TW & TM only spaces.
@[private account] Would you say that to these women?
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11268259/Transgender-paedophile-moved-prison-wings-starting-relationship-female-inmate.html
It’s always worth noting that it was PinkNews, who blocked me on Twitter because of this correction incidentally, who interpreted my mention of males as trans women.
Quoting @salltweets: “Grover told PinkNews: “Giggle is a social networking app for females. Males are excluded from the user base. There is no other specific demographic that is excluded from the app other than males.”
Imagine doing something “just” for 50% of the population?! 🤷♀️🙋♀️💗
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] Are you going to look anyone in the eye and say this is not a “straight white man”?
https://www.itv.com/news/meridian/2022-09-27/transgender-woman-jailed-for-sexually-abusing-children-when-she-was-a-man