The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Being a woman seems to have sealed the deal for most of us, David 🤷‍♀️
(I’m blocked by Paisley because I asked him if he’d ever date a trans man. I was genuinely interested…)
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @PennyRed I suggest you research the stories of trans windows, to understand the context of Laura’s tweet, and go from there.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] "I really doesn't matter what you accept"
I said nothing of trans women. Literally nothing.
Do not respond, get off my timeline and leave me alone.
Did @[private account]'s investigation lead to talking to any women and girls or understanding that transgender students ARE NOT banned from sports, but rather have to follow the exact same rules as everyone: ie, compete in your sex category.
Yes, but I mean for “trans kids”. Like, if you put a gender dysphoric child on puberty blockers at 9 and they didn’t take cross sex hormones, are they going to experience puberty late in life if at all?
I agree!
I think there could be something in feminists and trans women starting the activism for third spaces.
Let’s change this damn narrative and work together for solutions! 💗
There are many trans women who “pass” yet respect female only spaces. I have endless respect for them for doing so. They could easily ride this wave of misogyny but don’t. Respect can be done.
I want to work with these TW to create third spaces. I think that is the compromise.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] I think it is important to understand the reality of the situation, and ignoring it is intellectually dishonest. Furthermore, I think it is possible to support trans rights while also acknowledging the severe abuse women receive for standing up for our own rights.
Katelyn, I tweet about women’s rights, hypocrisy and advocate for third spaces.
Furthermore, can you please point to the specific part of this Tweet that mentions trans people?
So, let's all work together to create third spaces for trans women. I'm all for this.
The abuse needs to stop and we all need to move forward. There can be female-only spaces, unisex spaces, etc. There is plenty of room in the world for everyone to have their own space.
Grace, I support trans people & I want to work together to ensure trans people have safety & privacy.
If that’s what you want, too, then we’re on the same page.
BUT… Female only spaces & sport will & should still exist.
That’s how my life is improved, thanks for asking.
@[private account] @[private account] I don’t think it’s impossible at all. The apparently elusive “middle ground” is creating 3rd spaces, to have protection for trans people. Trans people have the right to campaign for 3rd & 4th spaces. But No one has the right to take away other people’s rights.
It’s really simple
This stuff is so important. I would hate for you to be overlooked or missout on important healthcare, checkups, very important “life” stuff, because of… ideology. It would be devastating for a trans man or trans woman to have a serious health problem because biology was ignored.
The skewed media coverage is that while women are completely accepting of trans people’s existence, we still want female only spaces and are called “bigots” and sent abuse because of it.
It’s that simple, really, and it should not be controversial to point it out.
Exactly! A phobia is an irrational fear. I DO NOT have an irrational fear of trans people. I want them to be protected, safe & fear to live their lives in peace like everyone.
But I do have a very rational fear of being harassed.
Paisley blocked me because, while he was chastising other people, I asked him if he himself dates trans men. I guess we'll never know if he practices what he preaches...
I don’t want apologies from the people who have called women who fight for our own rights “TERFs”, “bigots” & “anti-trans”.
I do want feminists to be given a loud voice in the media narrative and female spaces & female sport to be celebrated for the wonderful rights they are.
It’s absurd, isn’t it? Aren’t there trans people who *work* at Pink News? Why didn’t Benjamin give the interview opportunity to one of the Pink News staffers & let’s a trans person speak for themselves?
Did you listen to the first half of the segment? *No one* is saying transgender people should not exist.
Of course transgender people exist. And as a society, we should all be able to work together to ensure everyone has rights & no one else’s are taken away. It’s that simple.
From the moment he started. The rage, the rudeness, the lies, the gaslighting. Like, he didn't even have to do the interview. He could have given the opportunity to a transgender staff member at Pink News. But he accepted the opportunity and then complained about it. Nonsense.
You realize you could have turned down the interview & referred BBC to a transgender person to speak on behalf of themselves, right? You weren't forced to do the interview.
Furthermore, you most certainly did not keep your cool. For someone in media, you are *horrible* at media.
Just listened. What an absolute train wreck of an appearance.
First, blasting them for not speaking to a trans person about the issue when he blatantly accepted the invitation (could have given the opportunity to a trans staff member) and then proceeded to lie & rant. A mess.
Joss, with all due respect, this conversation is too stupid to continue. All I'm learning is you will equate anything to do with women with trans women, even if they're not mentioned, & justify any treatment of women if she disagree with you. I already knew that. Block me.
Oh for god sake, ok…
As it wasn’t about trans women, I jumped to the conclusion.
Do you who else was called the looney fringe? Suffragettes. Study some history, as the OP says.
My tweet was about a woman being arrested & charged for tweeting.
Can you please show me where in my original tweet I mentioned anything to do with trans women? Why did you immediately equate a tweet about the history of silencing women to trans women?
@[private account] @[private account] Ahem.
It’s is the trans rights groups who call women “feminazis.”
It is the trans rights groups who are using an alt-right term.
Of course trans people exist. I have no issue with that. The only issue I have is women being expected to give up our hard won rights.
We *could* all work together to create trans spaces, sport & ensure safety, privacy & respect for trans people.
Nope. I have absolutely no problem with trans men & trans women existing. I am just not prepared to give up women’s hard won rights. That’s all. I want us to work together to ensure safety & fairness for trans people. I don’t think I’m being unreasonable.
I’m in support of female only spaces, male only spaces, trans only spaces, women + trans women only spaces, gay spaces, lesbian spaces, etc.
We all co-exist in this colorful world together but sometimes we have a specific need or require refuge.
I’m for diversity of choice 💗
Honestly, thank you for saying “women & trans men”. That is how you do inclusive language and everyone knows who you’re talking about. It’s that easy & I genuinely commend you. 💗
Here’s just one example.
Do yourself the favor of researching all of the others. I’m not going to do it for you.
If you’re OK with women’s boundaries being obliterated, thats your stance. Fine. I simply vehemently disagree with you.
https://news.wttw.com/2020/02/19/lawsuit-female-prisoner-says-she-was-raped-transgender-inmate
@[private account] Trans athletes are allowed to compete. Sport is about rules, to create fairness, safety & good competition. Trans people have to follow the same rules as, literally, everyone else.
If you can't see the difference between sport based on sex & racial segregation, that's on you.
Her voice matters.
Listen to women & girls.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2021/05/22/transgender-athletes-girls-women-sports-track-connecticut-column/5149532001/
I respect that not all females identify as women, but I refuse to be insulted in response. And all of these words are insulting to women.
Please explain to me what is wrong with saying “women, trans men & non-binary people”?
@[private account] @[private account] I have no idea what you’re talking about but this is just one piece of evidence of what I’m talking about.
Maybe you’re ok with predatory males appropriating gender dysphoria & trans people for their own psychopathic desires, but I’m not.
Quoting @salltweets: This is one of 8295858282 reasons why I unapologetically advocate for female only spaces.
https://www.news.com.au/national/crime/serial-killer-reginald-arthurells-new-life-as-regina/news-story/f44a32ed46b1edc28cd6841dcb31cb00
The response to this is:
We are talking about predatory males who will appropriate gender dysphoria to achieve their own psychopathic desires.
We can either allow them to do that or set standards as a society that help us all, including vulnerable trans people.
It’s important.
I have no problem with platforms being trans inclusive. Just as I have no problem with platforms being for females. But I do have a problem with "feminist" platforms denying women a voice & having a conversation. We don't have to all agree but I think it is important to talk.
@[private account] @AyoCaesar It's not discrimination to cater to different demographics of people.
It's why I advocate for working together so that trans women & trans men can have public spaces of their own. Then we're all equal. 🤷‍♀️
How much of a 🏳️‍⚧️ ally are you if you're telling a trans person to "please stop"? Can't trans people speak the truth, have opinions of their own & base their lives in facts?
@[private account] No. Blocking has nothing to do with an image of you. Do you know how I know that? Because I created Giggle & you didn't.
Giggle supports trans people. Giggle welcomes trans men. Giggle is an app for females.
If you can't respect that, it says more about you than it does Giggle.
I have a rebuttal for this.
As they use Chandler as the example of “trans misogyny”, why can’t we use Chandler to show the effects of parental transitioning on children. Why would it be wrong to say that Chandler has an internalized childhood trauma?
That is part of the misogyny, isn't it?
There is no push for trans men to be in male sports. No cries for men to accept trans men.
It's just, "Look! A trans man had a baby!" like that is the only interesting thing about them.
🙄
@[private account] @[private account] Ah ok! Trans men are welcome however, to be honest, have so far ignored Giggle. Buts it’s there if they need/want it 💗
There are LGBTQ+ apps, gay apps, trans apps, muslim dating apps, jewish dating apps, christian dating apps, apps just about fishing(🤷‍♀️)
There are 1000s of different apps that cater to a specific demographic.
So... tell me, why is the one app for FEMALES the most controversial?
Oh no. No no.
I just added “trans women are trans women”.
Of course trans women should have rights, etc. But women also have rights, and those rights include female spaces, sport & language.
@[private account] Trans women are trans women. They deserve equal opportunity, health care, a safe community & workplace, and they deserve to play sports. They have a right to have their identity respected without conforming to perceived sex and gender identity standards.
@[private account] @[private account] I have no doubt that medical transition is a necessary option for some trans people, and I support that.
But I don’t support the affirmation method & transitioning children.
@[private account] I don’t believe it is a “trans rights movement”. If it was, they would be elevating the voices of trans people who are against all they stand for.
@[private account] How about you spend some time reading factual examples? Maybe listen to women? Learn the biological of all human beings? There are many things you can do.
In the mean time, care to explain why you're not pushing for "trans men are men"?
https://x.com/salltweets/status/1390620411579179013?s=20
Quoting @salltweets: "I've had female weightlifters come up to me and say, 'what do we do? This isn’t fair, what do we do?' Unfortunately, there's nothing we can do because every time we voice it we get told to be quiet"
https://www.reuters.com/lifestyle/sports/females-told-be-quiet-transgender-issue-ex-weightlifter-2021-05-07/
No one is against trans girls playing sports. No one.
But everyone has to follow the same rules: sport is divided by sex, unless in specific unisex situations
All sports have rules we follow. EG, some players on the field can’t start throwing the ball in soccer with the goalie.
It has absolutely nothing to do with trans women and everything to do with the necessity of female only spaces, and that women are entitled to have them as an *option* to use.
There is nothing radical about advocating for females.
It’s fine to have female spaces. It’s fine to have spaces for women & trans women. It’s fine to have LGBTQ+ spaces. Fine to have male spaces.
There’s enough room for it all while we coexist in this colorful world together.
None of this is controversial.
Anyone who posts a death threat on Giggle will be removed.
Giggle is unapologetically an app for females. I support platforms for LGBTQ+ people. I support platforms for women & trans women. I support platforms for men. But I created one for females. This is not bigotry.
Of course it's not hard to find the answer. There are no trans men threatening men's sport. There's a reason for that.
The bigger issue is lack of listening to women.
https://x.com/salltweets/status/1390620411579179013?s=20
Quoting @salltweets: "I've had female weightlifters come up to me and say, 'what do we do? This isn’t fair, what do we do?' Unfortunately, there's nothing we can do because every time we voice it we get told to be quiet"
https://www.reuters.com/lifestyle/sports/females-told-be-quiet-transgender-issue-ex-weightlifter-2021-05-07/
This doesn't need to be a "conservative v liberal" fight.
You can just listen to women.
https://www.reuters.com/lifestyle/sports/females-told-be-quiet-transgender-issue-ex-weightlifter-2021-05-07/
"I've had female weightlifters come up to me and say, 'what do we do? This isn’t fair, what do we do?' Unfortunately, there's nothing we can do because every time we voice it we get told to be quiet"
https://www.reuters.com/lifestyle/sports/females-told-be-quiet-transgender-issue-ex-weightlifter-2021-05-07/
A few *facts* for you:
1. Giggle is a social network for females.
2. Giggle has security because men, on a whole, don't respect female spaces & leave them alone.
3. Trans identifying females are welcome on Giggle.
4. I have never harassed a gay man on Twitter.
Leave me alone.
@[private account] Thank you.
It’s like... obviously we know that trans does not equal serial killer. But we also know that self IDing as a woman is a very easy way to gain access to vulnerable women.
This does not help women or transsexuals like yourself. đź’—
@[private account] @thedailybeast Trans women are human beings like all of us and deserve human rights.
However, sport is split into biological sex classes to ensure it is fair, safe & fun for all.
We *all* follow this rule.
I would absolutely love it if The Biden Administration prepared to directly confront the rash of misogyny, including misogyny coming from supposed Trans Rights Activists.
@[private account] @[private account] It’s just a game of hate, isn’t it? It’s like a competition to see who can be the worst version of themselves.
It never ceases to amaze me how many of these so called “activists” don’t engage with trans people who disagree with them.
It’s why I know it’s not a rights movement.
There are many young girls who have sport as an gateway into more opportunity, like through scholarships. So there are many people “who give a shit”.
Trans people have every right to play sport and compete. They just have to follow the rules like everyone else.
We're in a realm where a trans woman and former elite athlete apparently doesn't have the authority to talk about transgender people in sports. 🤷‍♀️
@[private account] @[private account] @lavern_spicer @Caitlyn_Jenner What about a trans woman & former elite athlete? Do you trust her expertise on the issue?
*Ahem*
Just because you disagree with someone doesn't mean they're "anti-[whatever]".
Men or women who disagree with me aren't instantly misogynistic. They just disagree with me🤷‍♀️
Caitlin Jenner is a trans woman AND was a professional elite athlete. Maybe listen & learn?
I would think it was part of your responsibility as an MD to help your patients deal with truth, reality & facts.
You have the most famous trans woman in the world and an elite athlete stating facts & you’re dismissing the information.
A healing conversation could be had here.
There are apps for gay men. Apps for trans people. Apps for men who identify as lesbians. 1 app for females.
Guess which one gets attacked?
(There are apps for periods, which makes them for females. But it’s not progress if we’re only allowed apps for our reproductive cycles)
There are apps specifically for the LGBT community. There are apps for gay men. Apps for transgender people. Apps will far smaller demographics than Giggle has.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @POTUS @[private account] Hi Emma. I am the founder & CEO of an online platform for women. I receive death threats, rape threats & demands to kill myself from the "trans rights activism" community because of this. When the app did allow trans women to join, "KILL TERF" profiles were created.
There is SO much racism towards black women in this whole mess. How black women are compared to trans women, how black womens voices are ignored. I’ve cried over this as well.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] Do you support spaces exclusively for trans people, for refuge or recreation?
Do you realise that you have just done what you don't want others to do? You have been a reactionary and called someone anti-trans, and then ignored a potential petition, purely because she cares about the rights Orthodox women.
The reactionary here... is you.
Do you realize that @[private account] is a trans woman? Care to listen to an opinion that doesn’t valid yours? @[private account] is not the hateful one here, Man Who’s Twitter Handle Refers To One Of The Most Infamous & Brutal Killers Of Women.
I am over people telling me who I am (TERF, transphobe, anti-trans, etc) but I am apparently not allowed to tell them who they are (male, female).
The former is incredibly detrimental to mental health and the latter is completely necessary to overall health & well being.
What is interesting, in my experience, most if any of “these people” haven’t spoken to or met trans people who are aware of biological reality & against the transing of children. They’re just as abusive & vile to these trans people as they are to everyone else.
I have 2 interesting conversations with trans men yesterday who felt validated when Giggle’s onboarding system rejected them. That’s what they wanted to happen.
But publications like @[private account] don’t think about that. They just print ignorant, misinformation & hope I’ll stay quiet🤷‍♀️
Professor Donna Hughes wrote this amazing article:
https://4w.pub/fantasy-worlds-on-the-political-right-and-left-qanon-and-trans-sex-beliefs-2/
Please sign this petition in support her of right to free speech & employment:
https://www.change.org/p/dr-david-m-dooley-tell-the-univ-of-rhode-island-to-support-professor-donna-hughes-right-to-free-speech
đź’śđź’śđź’ś
That is a completely different conversation to “no trans voices are rational”.
We’re definitely in a very awkward, unfortunate & dangerous era. But I appreciate the trans voices who have lived their lives for 20-30+ years & are critical of the current zeitgeist.
I was talking to a HS teacher today. 1 girl in his class came out as trans. Now there’s 3.
In my HS class, there were 0 trans kids & still 0 trans adults.
But it was the early 2000s & we did have a lot of girls with eating disorders... I can’t help but think “social contagion!”
I’m sorry. Up until today, I was not aware that you were trans.
I don’t discredit your experiences or your life. I wish you nothing but happiness.
I am just against affirmation care for young kids who may be heavily influenced by social media/Internet & not experiencing GD.
I imagine that trans men are not interested in something designed for women, as you don't identify with being a woman. Is that right?
So, trans men have left Giggle alone. Trans women, however, do not like me at all. (I, personally, have no problem with TW & wish them the best)
You are female, you can use Giggle if you would like to. However, you would just have to contact Giggle HQ directly & we would sort out the onboarding.
Interestingly, & I would love your thoughts on this: trans men have stayed away from it. My theory is:
From my knowledge, Giggle users have never called the app “trans-exclusionary”.
It’s media and people who the app is not designed for who call it “trans-exclusionary”.
But that is to be expected in the day & age where doing anything for women is frowned upon, isn’t it?
Trans identifying females are more than welcome on Giggle. It’s an app for females, not an app where you have to think a certain way.
However, I will say, trans men have so far had no interest in Giggle. Which I understand & respect.
As someone who has been called "transphobic", I can say with all certainty that I do not wish what is described in this video to happen to any trans people. Not one.
I will, however, always fight to ensure that women have female-only spaces & refuges away from these threats.
Quotes a post by T03742; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Me too!
I'm still 100% an ally to trans rights in that I believe all human beings should have human rights. However, it is no ones right to gain access to female spaces & sport unless they are... tada... a female. It's pretty simple.đź’ś
If the objective & obvious fact of binary biological sex was acknowledged*, then compromise isn’t necessary.
We can all celebrate people for exactly who they are: female, male, trans.
*Biological sex is binary. It’s how babies are made. Ask your mum or dad.
And this is why I don’t believe for one second that the men who speak the loudest about “trans rights” & call anyone who asks a question “anti-trans”.
Rather, they want everyone to agree with them & submit to their version of reality, which involves extreme misogyny & lies.
No.
Thank you đź’—
Giggle is many apps in one. We do have a dating category exclusively for lesbian females
There’s platforms to find roommates, freelance work, support & a public social media feed
I get sent death threats & am called transphobic, despite trans females being welcome 🤷‍♀️