The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
One of my most rightoid coded opinions is that most women have no business being cops or security guards where they would be in a position of needing to physically restrain someone.
How is this even a question? Seems more important than trans in sports.
Quoting @AnnCoulter: Wouldn't it make more sense for this pretty young girl to be a nurse rather than a "security guard"?
Hospital Patient Beats Security Guard to Death
<<“She was the most kind-hearted soul,” who would always stroll the hospital, chatting with staff and patients.>>
https://nypost.com/2025/12/30/us-news/minnesota-hospital-patient-accused-of-beating-security-guard-to-death-while-trying-to-flee/
When people say Vance won’t denounce Groypers, they’re comparing him to his baseline level of anger. The guy is very mad at “cat ladies,” trans, people who understand free trade, etc.
In that context, the hesitation when it comes to racists is striking. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/jd-vance-is-the-white-kendi
They put the TA on leave.
I told you all this wokeness stuff was based in political power at its root.
Now college administrators in red states are standing up for the rights of students to call trans individuals demons in papers and get the grade they want.
Quotes a post by T08762; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
To be fair, I think it’s likely that if she said “as a trans woman of color, I feel X,” similarly without using evidence, she would not have gotten a zero. But making a different form of stupidity acceptable doesn’t counteract the form of stupidity we already have.
It's become clear that an obsession with trans stuff, while looking somewhat reasonable at the time, was a red flag for having real psychological issues.
Quoting @MattWalshBlog: This is correct. Everything that’s happened over the past two months has signaled to the left that assassinations work. Take out one of our leaders and we’ll start eating each other. That’s the message we’ve conveyed, loud and clear. And it puts us in serious danger. They aren’t going to stop now. Someone else will get taken out in the not too distant future. I’m very confident about that.
"Democrats made their entire moral universe center around oppressed minorities, so one couldn’t expect them to denounce black trans activists.... The equivalent for the right is the young male who is racist, angry, and sexually frustrated – the Groyper." https://www.richardhanania.com/p/groyperization-accelerating
I wrote about why the entire arc of conservatism bends towards Groyperization.
Modern conservatism can't condemn them any more than Dems in 2020 could condemn black trans. The logic of your movement elevates their concerns and narratives over all others.
https://www.richardhanania.com/p/groyperization-accelerating
Asking Trump-era conservatives to denounce Groypers is like asking a Democrat to denounce black trans activists in 2020.
Groypers are the ultimate avatars of right wing politics now. Just like the left centered around a hierarchy of victimhood, the white racist guy who hates feminism and immigrants is the logical endpoint of the Trump-Vance movement.
You can’t denounce them without discrediting the whole project.
Me in 2022, calling the decline of trans after Elon took over X:
All of this has implications for what’s going to happen if and when Elon Musk takes over. I think, in the short run at least, you won’t see much damage to feminism or Ibram Kendi Thought. Gender ideology, in contrast, is extremely brittle. Other liberal beliefs surrounding identity issues might be false, but they usually present scientific theories that one can at least argue about. To what extent are group disparities caused by discrimination? Are standardized tests or certain police practices fair to black people? Why are women underrepresented in STEM? One can present different kinds of evidence on these things, and Silicon Valley has allowed us to have such debates in relative freedom.
Gender ideology is a completely different kind of issue. Instead of making empirical claims like disparities are caused by discrimination, which one can at least in theory rebut, it operates purely through fiat. It’s about definitions, not empirical arguments. What is a woman? The question doesn’t have an objective scientific answer. Language is a democracy: words generally mean whatever the speakers of the language say they mean. Most people define woman as “human with XX chromosomes,” but we could just as easily define woman to mean “all human beings who weigh between 110 and 135 pounds” and that would not be scientifically true or false. According to gender ideology, woman means “anyone who identifies as a woman.” If liberals want to use the word that way, fine.
But it’s something completely different to demand everyone else accept that definition. If language is a democracy, trans ideology is January 6. I’ve never liked the claim that wokeness is analogous to a religion. Wokeness is mostly just bad ideas. But trans ideology is closer to a religion than it is to most political beliefs, with ritual being deeply woven into the faith. When we are supposed to “affirm” someone’s gender identity, we’re not being asked to accept an empirical claim, but assert a metaphysical truth.
Why the trans movement has been most harmed by the removal of censorship on Twitter.
It was the one place where people were more afraid of censors than their friends. The censorship was more extreme than the social costs of speaking out, which is rare. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/why-gender-ideology-cant-survive
When Elon bought X, I predicted that it would lead to the decline of trans ideology. This was the one view that needed censorship to dominate. Now the evidence has come out showing 2022 was peak trans. I think this held up well. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/why-gender-ideology-cant-survive
I wrote an article about how you should be much angrier about government banning kidney markets than any kind of over diagnosis of trans, and it’s not even close. Conservatives seem to passionately hate these types of arguments. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/kidney-markets-and-gender-affirming
“The judge also said that a lower sentence was warranted because of an executive order issued by President Trump mandating that transgender women be held at male-only federal facilities, which she said could interfere with her continuing to receive gender transition care.”
Plan to kill a Supreme Court justice, get off easy because you’re trans. This should probably be a Republican ad.
Too many leftists are still completely out of their minds on this issue.
Yes, the Palestinian and trans flag people are reacting as you would expect, but don't forget that JD Vance has spread a conspiracy theory about financial firms keeping the prices of homes high.
If you think socialists are morally questionable, you should also denounce the rhetoric of Vance, who advocates a kind of Hillbilly Socialism that matches the worst kinds of leftist resentment.
Quotes a post by T02015; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
NYT publishes op-ed by an Evangelical Christian who is quitting the army over Trump's transgender ban.
I'm sure this view is highly representative of his demographic.
My God, foreigners in New York City, what has the world come to?
Seems like he's realized the trans thing is over and is just doing the white nationalist thing now. His next movie can be "What is an American?"
Quoting @MattWalshBlog: 40 percent of New York City's population is foreign born. Not just second and third generation immigrants. Foreign born. Almost half the city wasn't born in this country. NYC isn't an American city anymore by any reasonable definition of the term. It's a tragedy and a disgrace.
How Biden understood trans issues, according to a former official: "The Republicans are using the power of the state to stop kids who feel gross about their bodies from seeing a therapist.”
It was the left banning "conversion therapy"!
He just had no clue what was going on.
Quoting @ICEgov: 📺ICE acting director responds to political rhetoric causing anti-ICE sentiment and threats to federal officers and their families: “I’m not asking them to stop — I’m demanding that they stop.”
They’re still doing trans women in sports! Don’t they ever stop to think the country has bigger problems? Not even men’s sports is worth this much political coverage, and it’s the one people want to watch.
This is just not true. Biden Title IX regulations ended up allowing districts to keep trans women out of sports. There are many examples of Democrats compromising on this issue. One should not confuse the most aggressive activists on the left with the left as a whole.
Quotes a post by T01330; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You'd think that a trans woman beat this one by scrambling her brains in a boxing match rather than in swimming.
Quoting @Riley_Gaines_: Woahhh. RFK admits that Biden's HHS department was a "collaborator in child trafficking, sex, and for slavery."
If true, this would be a really really big deal. Arrest and prosecute!!!!
The analogy to step-parents is correct. If trans women aren't women, step parents and adopted parents aren't parents. This explains how those who insist on a biological definition of "woman" don't apply their principles consistently.
Quotes a post by T01941; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Scott Alexander:
Get rid of twitter censorship, every third tweet becomes praise for Hitler
Start by talking about trans women in sports, end up facilitating a world where hordes of morons answer everything with HOW MANY GENDERS ARE THERE? BET YOU CAN’T ANSWER THAT HAR HAR HAR!
We're so used to thinking in terms of backlash to woke, it's time to consider that some of the wokes might have sensed something in the culture that that the rest of us missed and needed to be opposed.
MAGA is so corrosive to the social order because it depends on unspoken norms about ways to behave and how to deal with opponents in good faith. Ideally, there is some point where people are just embarrassed, we can all look at something and say "oh come on" and come to an agreement it's bad. You hope your political opponents have it in them to stand with reality every once in a while. It kind of holds this whole thing together, to believe they're not past redemption or impervious to reason.
Take Biden's age issue. Conservatives criticize liberals for having been in denial or lying about it. But after the first debate performance, the left showed that if things got bad or obvious enough, they could admit that they're wrong. There have been similar corrections on trans issues and policing.
It's just hard to imagine anything similar happening with MAGA. Actually, Trump has been getting more deranged over time and the cult only grows stronger. Right after 2020, some would admit he lost the election. Then every Republican had to say he won. Now Trump talks about how he should've won all 50 states each time he ran, and I wish the media would ask members of his cabinet if they believe that. I'm sure they would be afraid to contradict him.
I saw some rightist here complaining the other day about the media asking Obama or Biden a soft ball question about ice cream. It's fundamentally different from asking the White House spokeswoman about how buff Trump is, or congressmen introducing bills to put him on Mount Rushmore or a $250 bill.
This cult is an infection on the body politic. I genuinely don't know how you have a healthy relationship with these people.
No wonder this woman was so angry about losing a swim competition to a trans athlete. She probably never imagined she could make a living with her mind, but the current conservative influencer space has opened up a lot of opportunities for the differently abled.
Quoting @Riley_Gaines_: Trump should be studied in business schools for years to come.
Tuberville: “We have entire men’s teams across this country now that are turning trans. Women’s team are turning trans.”
Seems a bad strategy for the women’s teams to do that.
The biggest sin of the trans movement is that it created a generation of rightists who believe they can stop trying to learn anything and always reply “what is a woman?” as the answer to all social and political questions.
The thing I appreciate about liberals is they’re having discussions about real problems people face like housing and big questions like technological progress.
What do conservatives do? They work completely backwards. They start with the premise that they don’t like foreigners, and make up a narrative blaming foreigners or trans or whatever the enemy is for problems.
Has there been a popular conservative book in recent years that is not about the culture war or Trump? I can’t think of one. I can't even imagine a conservative argument on housing or technology getting any attention if you don't tie it in to Mexicans or Pfizer or some kind of conspiracy with Nancy Pelosi.
It’s looking like all thinking people are going to have to be liberals now because there’s just no room for intellectual content on the right.
I was thinking about this after I talked to Derek Thompson about his new book Abundance with Ezra Klein, which is the best recent effort I’ve seen to put forth concrete solutions to major problems. Whole thing here. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/boomer-liberalism-must-be-overcome
A very thoughtful and enlightened outlook on misgendering and making one’s way in the world. I continue to find inspiration in the struggles of trans women and their efforts to make us all better.
Quoting @AriDrennen: There was a time when I corrected every misstep. I'd hear the wrong pronoun and feel heat behind my eyes, my breath tightening, the moment souring. I'd push back, insist, make sure they knew they were wrong. And sometimes, they’d fix it. More often, they’d just get defensive. 🧵
Gavin Newsom tells Charlie Kirk that he is against trans women in girls sports. He also denounces Latinx, admits BLM is corrupt, and calls defunding the police lunacy.
This is Republican's greatest nightmare.
Reminds me of the trans movement trying to shut down debate: "if you question my transition I'm going to DIE!!!"
These people think that the DOGE crowd should be able to remake government without anyone knowing who they are.
Trans and the gender nonconforming are not only suited for security jobs because they’re high IQ.
They’re also likely to be very loyal to the society that accepts them. Who are they going to go undercover for? Putin? China? Iran?
They are the most reliable Americans. 🏳️⚧️🇺🇸
What evidence is there that AfD is "Nazi" or Nazi adjacent or whatever? Because they oppose immigration and trans rights and stuff, like most right-wing parties? Is there something else there?
Pentagon removes “a biography about Albert Cashier, a transgender man who served in the Union Army during the Civil War” from the schools it runs. Sounds like an interesting story.
I can’t remember the left ever being routed so badly on an issue. The trans movement has lost.
Quoting @ForecasterEnten: Trump's action to ban transgender women from women’s sports is probably the most popular thing he's ever done.
Most Americans overall (79%), Dems (67%), indies (64%), & GOP (94%) agree with Trump.
Moreover, the share who want the ban is up 17 pts (62% to 79%) since 2021.
In 2007, Stephen Joseph Hayes murdered three people in Connecticut: a woman, her 17 year old daughter, and her 11 year old daughter.
Hayes and his accomplice named Joshua Komisarjevsky broke into the home of the Petit family in the early morning hours. They beat the father unconscious and tied him up in the basement.
The attackers then terrorized the family for hours, forcing the mother to withdraw money from a bank under duress. Upon returning home, the mother was raped and strangled by Hayes, while Komisarjevsky sexually assaulted the 11 year-old girl. The house was set on fire, killing the two daughters through smoke inhalation. The father managed to escape to a neighbor's house for help.
Both perpetrators were sentenced to death in 2010. In 2015, however, the Connecticut Supreme Court ruled the death penalty was unconstitutional, and they were given life in prison.
Where is Hayes now?
Happily living his life as a woman, according to Newsweek. Hayes now calls himself Linda Mai Lee. He blames anger over hiding who he is for the murders.
The vast majority of inmates in Oregon State Penitentiary are men, but Lee said she is able to wear makeup, eye shadow, foundation, eyeliner and even lipstick on occasion. She also cherishes her jewelry, including rings and necklaces, as well as bras, panties and what she called a "slightly feminized" uniform. That had eliminated her thoughts of suicide. She's now seeking breast augmentation and hair replacement therapy since male pattern baldness drastically enhances her gender dysphoria.
Lee said that she had initially been diagnosed at the age of 16 with the condition - a feeling of distress that can happen when a person's gender identity differs from the sex they are born with. But Lee said she wasn't told of the diagnosis at the time and that "intolerance" simmered inside her for decades.
"I hurt, so I hurt others," she said.
Had Lee accepted herself earlier, Hawke-Petit and her daughters may still be alive, she said.
"I think about them every day and regret my part in what happened and all the pain I caused," Lee said. "That is why I want to use my life today to prevent someone else from doing what I did."
Aren't you glad that liberals in Connecticut abolished the death penalty? Just think, if Stephen Joseph Hayes was executed years ago, the world would've never heard the beautiful story of Linda Mai Lee and her triumph of transphobia.
I hope this causes the Trump administration to rethink its views on both trans issues and the death penalty.
It doesn’t say that requiring others affirm your identity is grounds for not being in the military. It says expressing a trans identity is enough. So it’s a complete ban on trans individuals serving.
Trump just signed an Executive Order saying transgender individuals are too mentally ill to be soldiers, and too lacking in honor and discipline in their personal lives. Really.
Consistent with the military mission and longstanding DoD policy, expressing a false “gender identity” divergent from an individual’s sex cannot satisfy the rigorous standards necessary for military service. Beyond the hormonal and surgical medical interventions involved, adoption of a gender identity inconsistent with an individual’s sex conflicts with a soldier’s commitment to an honorable, truthful, and disciplined lifestyle, even in one’s personal life. A man’s assertion that he is a woman, and his requirement that others honor this falsehood, is not consistent with the humility and selflessness required of a service member.
Slate headline: “The DEI Ban Is Working Exactly as Trump Intended.”
As the author explains
At the U.S. Department of Transportation, the policy statements on harassment prevention, whistleblowing, and the advancement of people with disabilities were taken off the wall. A Pride chat in the office Teams software was deleted at the Federal Emergency Management Agency for fear the membership list might fall into the wrong hands and the admin could be targeted. “Everyone’s scared,” said an employee at a Commerce Department agency who, like many government workers, has filled out annual statements attesting to how her work advances diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility, or DEIA. Now it feels like those statements could be evidence against her.
On Wednesday, just about everyone who works for the federal government, from NASA to the Department of Justice, got a boilerplate emaillaying out the changes necessary to comply with the president’s “Ending Radical and Wasteful Government DEI Programs and Preferencing” executive order. All DEIA program staff have been ordered onto paid administrative leave, and agencies must submit plans to fire people by the end of the month. Not only was the Trump administration taking steps to end all federal jobs and contracts related to DEIA, but the Office of Personnel Management—a kind of HR department to the U.S. government—had also established a tip line for reporting cases where “coded or imprecise language” had been used to hide those initiatives from Trump’s investigators.
Yes, as you might suspect, there are tears.
But the call to rat out colleagues or face consequences was also chilling. “Like something from 1984,” one staffer said. Several federal workers told me they had seen people crying at work. Email directives arrived without signatures.
Because the people who work on DEIA jobs and contracts often hail from underrepresented groups themselves, the actions seemed to target some employees more than others—as if Donald Trump had come to drain the swamp not of corruption and self-dealing but of staff members who happen to also be Black, gay, trans, and disabled people.
It’ll be decades before we have any idea of the downstream cultural effects of all this. We are living in fun times.
One of the worst influencers out there ended up in this role after getting beaten by a trans swimmer. She’s the perfect representative of Americans who get behind MAGA, start out with reasonable concerns and then end up spewing all kinds of unrelated retardation.
Quoting @Riley_Gaines_: Here’s a map showing Chinese-owned farmland conveniently located near 19 U.S. military bases.
But yes, please tell me more about how banning TikTok is because we have a government deeply committed to protecting our national security.
Trans women should not be harassed in public.
It’s funny that there are women out there who think of it like blackface. As if they’re so proud to be a biological women and have to protect against people taking away from their accomplishment.
One reason I think China won’t invade Taiwan is their leaders talk like midlevel corporate PR hacks.
Putin has always talked about traitors getting whacked and trans in bathrooms and so on. That guy is the type to launch a major war.
These guys aren’t.