The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Links for December. I discuss my evolving views on trans, why so-called "race science" is being buried in academia, and many other topics. Check it out. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/enjoying-trans-women-the-end-of-race
Woah. Disney literally just said parents don’t want their kids to see trans and we’re fine with that.
The Blue site tried to warn us. Jesse Singal has won.
Quotes a post by T07213; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
My friend @[private account] and three of her trans friends confront me over past transphobic tweets.
All I can do is explain that I was once not nearly as enlightened as I am now. I’m thankful that trans women have been so gracious and forgiving.
You’ll always be she/her to me.
My friend @[private account] asked whether she counts as Elite Human Capital. I explain how to understand the concept to her and three of her trans friends.
Quoting @MeghanEMurphy: Brianna Wu always says the quiet part out loud.
Friendly reminder that yes, this is why a certain contingent of adult men think minors should be administrated puberty blockers and hormones: to create fuckable, feminized males.
They think sterilizing and mutilating the bodies of kids is justifiable if they end up with a pornifiable result
The case of Alliance for Fair Board Recruitment v. SEC involved Nasdaq requiring corporations to have a board member who identified as a woman, and one who identifies as a minority, gay, or trans.
But it was even more sinister than that. If you don't meet the criterion, all you had to do was explain why you were so racist and sexist. Nasdaq offered its own diversity recruiting as a way to overcome your racism and sexism.
Where was the statutory basis of this from? The Securities Exchange Act allows the SEC to approve rules that promote just and equitable principles of trade, open markets, and other generalities. On that basis, you supposedly get diversity quotas.
The decision was 10-7 along strict party lines. Every Republican-appointed judge was against this, every Democrat judge was for it.
The dissent argued that investors wanted the rule. Nasdaq was just making their life easier by standardizing reporting. So it's a disclosure rule, not a hiring quota, and therefore subject to approval.
The diversity nonsense is corruption, up and down the line. From investors pushing it, to governing bodies and government officials going along or instigating it, to parasitic diversity consultants and networks seeking to benefit every step of the way.
Republicans keep stacking the judiciary for the next four years and hopefully we can bury this stuff.
Bad night for Tuckerism.
This is the ideology that America is the root of all evil in the world, and any foreign enemy who isn’t Islamist or pro-trans is actually “based,” on your side, super competent, and rising as America declines due to DEI.
Courter tells Hinkle that North Korean officials met with their supporters in Germany, and the Germans spent the whole meeting talking about defending trans rights. The North Koreans didn’t know what that was. Hinkle seems shocked pro-DPRK Germans would be obsessed with trans.
I don’t think tax-payer funded trans surgeries are a real economic concern of the “struggling working class.”
Quoting @bungarsargon: For well off elites, immigration, environmental policy, and taxpayer dollars going to trans surgery are cultural issues. For the struggling working class, they are economic issues. Wokeness is being used by Left AND Right as a smokescreen for the real divide—the class divide.
You can’t go just say “but what about trans” to everything that happens in the world. I sometimes try to engage pro-market types for example on what they think of the rise of economic nationalism on the right. They’re not interested in any ideas unless there’s tribalism involved.
NYT today. I guess the self-reflection on the trans issue was short-lived.
Honestly, Mace is behaving obnoxiously. But liberals have to learn not to take the bait. This is a cause you're just going to have to sacrifice to move forward.
Once again, I can define woman and also think RFK should not have any position of power or authority. I don’t know why most critics of woke ideology seem ok with the most prominent anti-vaxer in the country at the head of HHS because they reject trans ideology. Diseased thinking.
Quoting @peterboghossian: To those enraged about Trump’s “crazy” appointments, where were you when Biden’s Supreme Court Justice nominee couldn’t define “woman”?
Former writer for John Oliver's show explains the phrase "there's no evidence that trans girls pose a threat to safety or fairness" must've started as an activist talking point. Oliver's show andjust Jen Psaki used the exact same phrase. They're just reading talking points.
Shellenberger's take on Trump's unusual appointments is to talk about the Iraq War, DEI statements, and trans ideology. You should wonder exactly what this has to do with Matt Gaetz' ethics scandals or RFK's crazy views on health.
Washington Post editorial board on the Seth Moulton controversy, says that people should be able to disagree on trans women in sports.
In athletic competition, male puberty confers significant advantages. While those biological differences vary by skill and sport, a 2023 paper by medical researchers in the United States and Italy noted that “it is well established that the best males always outperform the best females when the sport relies on muscle power, muscle endurance, or aerobic power.” The hormone therapy that many trans women take reduces some of those advantages over time, but research into how much those advantages can be mitigated, and over what time frame, is still ongoing. Other advantages, such as height, are fixed by the end of puberty. This poses obvious fairness and safety questions.
The question is whether those who want to push back on woke on the left will be as persistent as the wokes. Trans activists will still be pressuring people in the coming weeks and months to take the party line and cancel people who don’t. Will those calling for more acceptance of disagreement within liberalism be doing the same?
Trump won Hazelton, which is 63% Latino, most of them from the Dominican Republican.
One Hazelton store owner who voted for Trump says “I’m worried about gay marriage and transgender.”
John Oliver explains how Democrats can respond to the trans issue.
All they need to do is tell people there's no evidence that trans girls are at an unfair advantage or pose a threat to safety in athletic competition.
"Power lesbian", employee at Blue Origin, married to a trans reported from The Daily Beast (biological man), murders her elderly father on Election Day with an ice axe. She told the cops the murder was an "act of liberation."
So much going on here.
Sam Harris on the trans issue:
“I know people who haven't been touched by this issue personally, for whom it was the only issue that decided their vote. In fact, it is the issue that fully radicalized Elon, and he's spoken about this at length. Do you think Elon continuously messaging to 200 million people on X, and going to Trump's rallies, and donating over 100 million dollars to the campaign, and supporting him on podcasts, and doing everything else in his power to get Trump elected, might have accounted for a few votes? Honestly, I think a doctoral dissertation, and perhaps several, could be written on how trans activism completely destroyed Democratic politics—without most Democrats knowing.”
Former staffers and interns of congressman Seth Moulton are circulating a letter chiding him for being anti-trans in women’s sports and calling pronouns weird.
It makes perfect sense now. Why do Democrat politicians never stand up to wokes? All the pressure comes from below.
One of my pieces that has held up best:”Why Gender Ideology Can’t Survive Elon.” I argued that the trans movement was more dependent on censorship than any other cause. It’s too absurd to survive debate. Now even Dems realize they went too far. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/why-gender-ideology-cant-survive
I’m on her side! I’m making fun of her for worshipping Trump, and the fact that her experience on the trans issue would push her towards this bizarre cult.
I appreciate the kind words.
Start out losing to trans in swimming, end up with whatever this is.
Quoting @Riley_Gaines_: Tonight we prayed over President Trump. We prayed for his safety, his strength, a unified country, and God's will to be done. 🙏🏼
May God continue to bless Donald Trump
A decade ago, Elon Musk was hanging out with Barack Obama.
The media talks about a “racial reckoning,” but they need a reckoning themselves on Covid, trans, and BLM and how madness on these issues turned so many people against them.
The California Costal Commission exists to protect the environment.
Over the objections of the US military, it just refused a request by SpaceX to increase its number of launches this year, with members of the Commission citing Elon Musk’s tweets about trans issues, his lack of deference to labor unions and political activities.
We’re lucky they were stupid enough to admit this, as it makes for an open and shut First Amendment case. I hope a lawsuit is coming soon.
From anti-trans activist to being the protector of white womanhood in sports.
I don’t know if it was intentional or not, but the rightoid obsession with protecting Caitlin Clark, who is not one of them and liked Swift’s Kamala endorsement on IG, is pathetic.
Quoting @Riley_Gaines_: Look at DiJonai Carrington smug smirk when asked about it she intended to gouge Caitlin Clark's eye.
Why do they hate Clark so much?
So much going on in this picture. Black conspiracy theorist obsessed with trans invited on Fox to talk about a conspiracy theory involving a black women they think is trans.
The conservative movement now.
Mark Robinson story just dropped.
He was posting on a porn website called "Nude Africa," which included a message board attached.
Highlights:
-Talked about being 14 years old and watching women in the gym showers. CNN is sparing us the details. Read between the lines, it seems that he was probably masturbating to them.
-Discussed how he got turned on by watching transsexual women having sex with cis women (the ones with vaginas).
-Says he didn't care about celebrities having abortions, he just wanted to see their sex tapes.
-Called himself a "Black Nazi" and said he preferred Hitler to Obama.
-Robinson: "I’m not in the KKK. They don’t let blacks join. If I was in the KKK I would have called him Martin Lucifer Koon!”
The irony is if only he was this moderate on trans and abortion he probably would've been a better candidate.
Kamala Harris has just put out a campaign policy page.
It is 5,093 words long.
The document is remarkably devoid of wokeness.
Let's do some text analysis. Here is a count of the appearance of various terms.
Race/racial: 0
Black: 1 ("Black-owned businesses")
Latino: 1 ("Latino...owned businesses")
White (excluding "White House"): 0
Asian: 0
AAPI: 0
Native: 0
LGBTQI+: 3 (twice in reference to Project 2025)
Trans: 0
Equity: 0
Diversity: 0
DEI: 0
Middle Class: 14
Border: 15
Prosecute/prosecutor: 5
Crime/criminal: 10
America/American: 69
She's playing to win.
When I see Kadyrov and how he behaves, I understand the horrors of Putinism and why Ukrainians have fought so bravely against it. Dumb pro-Putin conservatives want to subject a European population to this extreme form of Oriental despotism because they hate trans.
Quotes a post by T05761; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
From my conversation with Scott Greer, on the Tim Walz pick and the phenomenon of Sportslibs, who say mind your own damn business and leave my trans son alone.
Is the whole story about Imane Khelif being a man the result of a Russian misinformation campaign?
Last year, Khelif beat a previously undefeated Russian boxer.
All the information that Khelif is transgender or a man comes from the International Boxing Association (IBA). It is run by Umar Kremlev, an acquaintance of Putin.
The IBA has been permanently banned from the Olympics for financial mismanagement and lack of transparency.
After Khelif beat the Russian boxer, she was disqualified and the Russian prospect went back to being undefeated.
Kremlev, who has a personal gripe with the Olympics because of the ban, is now going around claiming Khelif and another Taiwanese boxer are not actually women, supposedly based on tests. According to the AP, "the IBA has refused to officially say what, when or where these tests were administered, who evaluated them, or what the results meant." He's also calling the Olympics "pure devilry" and urging the current head of the International Olympic Committee to resign.
I jumped to conclusions on this, and clearly we need more information. There is no reason to take the IBA's word on anything, and we should be vigilant against foreign actors spreading misinformation in order to create division.
As an addendum here, I’ll point to the differing reactions to Ukraine. Democrats saw the war as an issue of one sovereign country invading another. Conservatives could have made reasonable critiques of US policy. But it seemed like a lot of them decided to start counting trans on each side and therefore came to the conclusion that Ukraine is bad. They say stuff like we won’t fight and die for LGBT when no Democrat is saying any such thing. It is their outlook that sees a war between two countries in those terms. If you showed a Tucker rant to a Ukrainian soldier on the frontlines they would be very confused regarding what he was talking about. It’s similarly bizarre to a lot of Americans to think about foreign policy like this.
On the "weird" debate.
Conservatives have responded to liberal accusations of "weirdness" by pointing to strange looking trans activists, pronouns, etc. I think that this misses the core reason as to why Republicans are seen as weird.
It's not about positions on culture war issues. Each side has certain views on reproduction, trans, race, etc that are outside the mainstream and deranged people within their coalition.
The key difference is that Democrats come across as normal people who take one side in the culture war. Republicans are simply driven by the culture war and nothing else.
Compare say Gretchen Whitmer to Ron DeSantis. In 2018, Whitmer ran on the slogan "Fix the Damn Roads." She has left wing views on trans issues, etc., obviously, but her presentation is that of a normal politician first and foremost. She talks about things like building infrastructure and helping our teachers or whatever. She's considered a future presidential contender.
In contrast, DeSantis thought the only way to challenge Trump was to obsess about woke, woke, woke. Many of his initiatives like not teaching third graders about gender theory or banning DEI are popular. But if you meet someone and all they want to talk about is race or gender issues, it strikes people as off.
This is even setting aside the Trump cult, which is the center of the Republican Party. The only way to challenge Trump was for DeSantis to obsess over identity issues and say he's not committed enough to fighting on them. As it turned out, Republican voters didn't respond because it's not even about social issues like woke fundamentally, it's about being entertained, and no one can match Trump by that standard.
What's happened to the state parties in the Midwest is emblematic of these differences. Michigan and Pennsylvania are swing states in presidential elections. At the state level, beginning in 2018, Democrats have been able to run normal politicians with broad appeal. Republicans have run freakshow candidates. In 2022, Josh Shapiro beat Doug Mastriano, and Whitmer beat Tudor Dixon. The Michigan GOP was taken over by a mentally unstable woman with extremist abortion views who was removed from her office but then refused to leave. This story is representative of what has happened to state Republican parties (see the tweet thread below on what has recently happened in different states).
There are normal Republican politicians, and weird Democrats. But normal Republicans don't have a chance in national politics, because of the fundamental derangement of the right wing media and influencer class. Democrats do a much better job of keeping their weirdos on the fringes and elevating people who are from the most normal part of their coalition. That's how they ended up with Biden in 2016, and why Kamala has a strong bench of generic white guys to choose from as VP. Mark Kelly is in the running because he ran against Blake Masters, and Shapiro, to remind you, only had to beat Doug Mastriano. There's no reason that the governor of Pennsylvania or the senator from Arizona can't be a white male Republican instead of a Democrat. It didn't work out that way because on the conservative side the crazies are in charge, seeking to elevate whoever will be most "based" by saying the meanest things about childless women or immigrants or adopting the latest insane conspiracy theory making the rounds on right-wing media.
The world is not your X timeline. Normal people judge movements and parties by their most prominent representatives. And by that standard, it is obviously Republicans who are the weird ones.
Making women unattractive has always been at the core of wokeness. LGBT, trans, etc can be understood as just the extreme end of that. Sydney Sweeney began the pushback, and now here we are. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/yes-sydney-sweeneys-boobs-are-anti
32 year-old Minnesota woman crashes her car. Cops find a dead 35 year-old trans woman in her back seat, apparently with her throat slit.
I haven’t been able to figure out whether the driver was also trans, although her name suggests not. The media appears not to want to tell us.
How much longer are conservatives going to be freaking out over beauty pageant winners? Ok we get it, some are trans, some fat, this is what people do now.
It’s like girls sports, where you never pay attention to the thing unless there’s an ideological angle. Similar to wokes.
Brianna Wu: "I think that the trans movement is creating enemies a lot faster than they're creating friends."
I ask her how someone actually "knows" that they are trapped in the wrong body. I found her answer very sensible.
What do you think?
Brianna was a delight to talk to and we even found common ground on trans issues. I agree that it goes too far for government to overrule the decisions of parents and she agreed schools shouldn’t be transitioning kids without families knowing. Discourse leads to understanding.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedchild indoctrinationstate takes children
Difference between a society where trans is real and they are actually effeminate gay men on some kind of gender spectrum and one where masculine bullies put on dresses and push people around for the lulz.
Quotes a post by T07371; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Years ago, I read about how Derek Black, son of the founder of Stormfront, went to college and became a leftist. Now he's TRANS and writes passages humble bragging about how older men wanted to molest him as a child.
DeSantis and Rufo didn't take over New College fast enough.
It’s going to be really interesting to watch over the next few years as universities use their “personality” criteria to try and find students that are passionate about BLM and trans but indifferent to the Middle East.
Andrew Sullivan on Katherine Maher: “She even self-flagellates over her own ‘trans-erasure.’ She is Titania McGrath — Andrew Doyles’ comic Twitter parody of a deranged SJW. Literally.”
Funniest thing about Biden giving Easter over to trans is that he announced that he does it in accordance with his constitutional authority as if he’s declaring war or something.
This appears to be American brain colonization. Russian Orthodox Church now has “chastity pledges.” Russian Supreme Court even plagiarized Scalia to ban LGBT.
The irony! They think they’re fighting American culture, they can’t escape it. https://newlinesmag.com/reportage/with-patriotism-as-a-ruse-putin-wages-war-against-gay-and-trans-people/
Canadian teacher: I have a giant trans flag in my classroom because I want children to be thinking about sex changes.
Homeschooling is up in Canada, as it is in the United States.
One can at least respect the dedication in trans. Mutilate yourself, take hormones, at least it shows commitment!
Now they're trying to make non-binary a thing. That means you get a haircut and dress like a slob? It's just too lazy. Very annoying that they're doing this.
Maybe he/she/they (I don't care enough to figure out which) is just saying they don't want to look like men, not specifically Jesse Signal. It's a reasonable point if you buy trans logic. But I understand your reading, and it shouldn't have made it through on that basis.
Someone asked why I’ve been expressing less disgust towards trans, polyamory, etc lately. In truth, it’s hard to hate these things when the other side opposes surrogacy, abortion, etc.
LGBT still makes me uncomfortable, but nowhere near valuing embryos. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/anti-surrogacy-as-a-totalitarian
I never hear about a beauty contest anymore unless the winner is trans, old, or some unexpected ethnicity. Maybe that's the only way these things get attention now and we should stop falling for the clickbait?
Quoting @disclosetv: NEW - Iranian-born Apameh S. (39) is "Miss Germany 2024"
I doubt Russia actually paying influencers or whatever ever mattered that much. But Putin giving a few speeches bashing trans was all it took to get Republicans to want him to conquer Ukraine, and so the influence operation has been a success in that regard.
“Few Americans are trans, find themselves victimized by an illegal immigrant, or get shot by police. These issues are abstractions most of the time. Pregnancy and childbirth can never be.”
Women will never stop showing up on the abortion issue. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/why-women-rebel-against-pro-life
Why do these fundamentalists think they have a right to attack other people’s religious practices? Do trans Catholics make videos of traditionalist funerals and criticize them? Hate is such an ugly thing.
Quoting @MaryMargOlohan: Yesterday, St. Patrick's Cathedral hosted the funeral of Cecilia Gentili, a transgender, atheist prostitute. Funeral was attended by hundreds of trans activists in thongs/fishnet/halter tops/fur. They celebrated the dead prostitute by mocking St. Cecilia, saying: "This whore. This great whore. St. Cecilia, Mother of all Whores!"
Putin: Russians who go abroad return home because they can’t stand unisex toilets.
Russia has made anti-trans the entire ideological justification of its civilization. A warning not to OD on right-wing nonsense.
Regarding trans, no one talks about how unfair it is to masculine looking women. It's probably harder to find dates when people suspect you might be a man. Usually women who look like men are unattractive anyway, but some can be masculine and attractive in a heterosexual way.
Japan Airlines has a DEI page.
In 2020, they stopped saying "ladies and gentlemen" to be more inclusive.
For trans employees, they have "begun using nicknames based on the gender they identify with."