The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Honored to be the subject of two questions on the Blocked and Reported Christmas Special this year. One asked which group I called the “trans of traffic,” and I couldn’t even remember the answer. I say a lot of things. https://www.blockedandreported.org/p/the-annual-blocked-and-reported-christmas
I've criticized what conservatives are doing by demanding universities crack down more on speech, but the more I think about it the more I believe that there's sound logic behind these efforts, even if some haven't fully thought things through.
Many people see free speech as a spectrum. A new policy either contributes to more free speech or detracts from it. I think that this isn't really how things work in practice. Two institutions can have identical policies, with the difference being what kind of people are in charge.
A thought experiment can demonstrate this. Let's say you're @charlesmurray and have been invited to two university campuses to talk about race differences.
University A lets students run around chanting about how much they love Hamas
University B is run by people who are heavily concerned with anti-semitism and will shut down even reasonable criticism of Israel
Which one is more likely to let a Charles Murray speech go forward? I think it's clearly University B, even though it seems to be less pro-free speech. This is because the kind of people who support Israel over Hamas are unlikely to be horrified by a frank discussion of black/white differences, etc. Meanwhile, those who indulge pro-Hamas speech are likely to have very broad definitions of "harassment" when it comes to trans, etc.
The war on the Ivy League universities then can be seen as influencing an internal struggle to give more power to people concerned with anti-semitism over those concerned with other forms of discrimination. By restricting speech on Israel/Palestine, you gain speech rights on other topics simply by disempowering leftists. This isn't because Bill Ackman (apparently the new king of American universities) necessarily loves free speech, although he might. It's that if he's running the university you'll be less able to support Hamas but more likely to have freedom on most other issues because of the kind of people he wants to get rid of.
What's become clear is that there's no political constituency for academic freedom. Republicans could have called Ivy League presidents to testify and threatened their funding over DEI, affirmative action, etc. at any time. They didn't care to do so. But the second they could appropriate the left's concepts of "safety" and "words as violence" these bumbling idiots overnight turned into ruthless political operators. It's easy to just go "Republicans are stupid, am I right?" But I think this is naive. There's a broader lesson that freedom doesn't sell well, and the only way you can motivate political action is by riling up an identity group, making them feel threatened and having them go on the offensive against your enemies.
This is of course why freedom of speech has been so historically rare. And those who have stood for freedom have done so out of expediency, because they were out of power. So the left had a "free speech" movement in the 1960s, but stamped out opposition as soon as it gained power. If you think modern conservatives love freedom now, instead of opportunistically invoking the concept when they're threatened, the last few weeks should have disabused you of that notion.
Allowing free speech is so anti-human nature, that it requires an elite consensus that stands in opposition to mass sentiment. People don't realize modern First Amendment jurisprudence was based on court decisions that lacked popular legitimacy. Look at any polling data on this. That elite consensus is now broken, and we're stuck with choosing between tribes. I'll personally sacrifice my right to praise Hamas, which I don't want to do anyway, for the sake of empowering people who will allow more real talk on genetics. I just don't see a principled free speech movement anywhere on the horizon.
Pope has luncheon with trans group.
So funny. What’s even the point of Catholicism? Feel guilty for touching yourself and then listen to the man in the dress tell you to submit to gender ideology anyway. https://x.com/readerplus_/status/1727332334687625587/video/1
Big bicycle not happy just slowing you down in traffic the old way, now wants to ban turning on red lights. They think the world should revolve around them, they’re the trans of traffic.
Another great point. When homosexuality is taboo you see the lower classes being most insane about it. Conservatives attack the kinds of deviancy they’re allowed to, hence the pedophilia craze and also the trans obsession.
Quotes a post by T29315; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Only 29% of college students would support allowing a speaker on campus who said trans was a mental disorder or that BLM was a hate group
Conservative students are more tolerant of liberal speech than vice versa
Hillsdale is the most tolerant school
Liberalism has become bad
So if you’re new to X, it’s hard to explain what a radical departure it is to see a movie about detransitioners being promoted like any other kind of speech. The prediction I made here trans dogma couldn’t survive Elon is holding up well. https://www.richardhanania.com/p/why-gender-ideology-cant-survive
Why anti-wokes should be pro-capitalist. Capitalism self corrects and ultimately bends the knee to human nature. Government programs, intellectual fads, never have such concerns. Wokeness festers forever only when it is shielded from market forces.
Victoria's Secret going back to attractive models after trying fat chicks, trans and other gimmicks for a while.
CNN: "The radical transformation of Victoria’s Secret is over...The prime objective? Improve profitability and cross back over $7 billion in annual sales."
via the great @[private account] https://edition.cnn.com/style/why-victorias-secret-is-bringing-sexy-back-bof/index.html
If you meet a “trans woman,” that is a biological man, and you touch her chest, is that considered sexual assault or is it just like slapping a guy on the chest? What about a biological female who identifies as a man? Assume no one has had surgery.
Indian Supreme Court rejects attempt to legalize gay marriage. But the court rules that trans can be married. The Chief Justice demands that the “public must be sensitized to gay rights,” and declares “queerness is not urban or elite.”
Here's the author, an accountant looking Asian guy.
Future anti-trans influencer, or so conformist he went even further than his colleagues towards buying into the trans cult?
You decide.
Never forget the true legacy of Dick Butkus, which is lying to the youth about female athletes and setting off trans mania. I hope he had time to reflect on what he did.
The base hated Paul Ryan for immigration, and the perception he was a "cuck" on identity issues, not for entitlement reform. Eric Cantor lost his seat over the same issue. I don't see evidence a combination of hard right on trans, etc. plus Ryanism on entitlements can't work
How a little remembered TV show called “Hang Time”, which ran on NBC from 1995-2000, started the trans craze and led to the rise of gender confusion among youth. 🧵
Just finished #Manifest2023. Haven't done many rationalist events, pleased to see so many readers and fans! Enjoyed meeting you all. Got to hang out with Robin Hanson again, along with others. And had my longest conversation ever with a trans woman. My horizons have expanded.
The media has become a complete monoculture on everything having to do with blacks, which actually touches on a lot, like crime, schools, etc. This is despite occasional sanity on trans and a few other issues.
I get a chuckle imagining one of these weirdos getting transported back to the Soviet Union and trying to explain their trans hammer and stickle flag to Stalin.
Here’s one thing the trans phenomenon has changed my mind about. Being a woman must in many cases be more difficult than I could have imagined for so many to go this far to de-sex themselves. This is a broad societal failure, and not just about gender ideology.