The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Why does everyone forget that of the very very small trans community, half are trans men?
The ad hominem - literally - you can’t say anything on this if you have/had a penis, drives the sectarian polarisation to the point of not just disagreement, but existential hatred
Quotes a post by T46623; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
PS. I can almost pre-program the response to this - misogynist, groomer, how dare a man express any opinion about this. But there are as many trans men as trans women, and this is an issue about human rights in which we all have a responsibility as humans
Half tuning into the #BBCDebate but I thought Starmer make a good point about the toxic divided nature of discussions of Trans people, and how he wanted to change the political culture to what people have in common — following Jo Cox’s #BetterTogether
Yet what I see regularly (and that’s without looking - they’re thrust regularly in my timeline) is some random trans woman photographed, named and mocked for merely being trans, not even activist
So any trans person is a legitimate target because of what some trans people are alleged to have done? It’s like saying in Northern Ireland in the 70s that because some Catholics/Protestants did that, we can retaliate at some other Catholic or Protestant
Firstly, two wrongs don’t make a right. And, as a journo, I know what I have witnessed and - as you might expect since trans people are such a tiny minority of the population - the power balance is by no means equal
I’m arguing my own thoughts, not others (gets me into trouble all around). But there has to be a way through this polarisation eventually. ‘Protected characteristics’ are manifold - and there must be a way to protect women’s and trans rights without them always being in conflict
Quoting @peterjukes: @[private account] I’m sure there must be a way for gender critical feminists to argue their case without recourse to ‘immutable biology’. Protected rights for reproductive services, safe spaces, sports even prison can be argued on custom, behaviour and performance
Don’t look up Humza Yousaf on this site, because all it will reveal is how the place is dominated by the racist far right, and (oddly) those obsessed with the 40,000 or so trans women in the entire UK
I think it is the key problem. I just don’t understand why this legitimate and urgent fear of men - the main cause of violence in this world - has somehow all been heaped on trans women
Just take out the ‘men can be women’ issue and this is really meant as a genuine question. Do you meet a lot of trans women? Do they affect your daily life?
Given the percentages (48k trans women out of 35m women), they would have to undermine the dignity of a 1,000.
That’s very hard work without social media enabling it
Just to clarify. It’s likely more Ukrainians have been killed in occupied Mariupol than there are declared trans women in the UK according to the last census.
But Musk’s X/Twitter would never let you know that
Quoting @peterjukes: What is wrong with Musk’s X/Twitter. Every effing day it’s Rowling or Glinner trending, while thousands are being killed in Gaza and Ukraine, unprecedented corruption in Trump and Brexit world, and again and agin Rowling or Glinner.
Does Musk have some issue here?
The actual declared figure of trans women in the UK in 2021?
48,000 out of population of 68 million (likely underreported for obvious reasons).
So actual percentage of the population causing all this moral panic and alleged oppression?
0.07%
https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/culturalidentity/genderidentity/bulletins/genderidentityenglandandwales/census2021#:~:text=48%2C000%20(0.10%25)%20identified%20as,in%20a%20different%20gender%20identity
Quoting @peterjukes: There are maybe 200,000 trans people in the UK. So we’re talking about 0.3% of the population - half of those trans men. Don’t you think it’s weird that such a small minority should receive such endless online attention?
There are maybe 200,000 trans people in the UK. So we’re talking about 0.3% of the population - half of those trans men. Don’t you think it’s weird that such a small minority should receive such endless online attention?
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] No. Rights are often in conflict. At the heart of this toxic debate is the clash between the rights of women and trans people. If you think me taking sides is going to help negotiate this clash of rights, you've another think coming
1) I am not editor of Byline Times. 2) I do not have a trans child 3) I have always said I understand the concerns about safe spaces and medical intervention in puberty.
Ideology has blinded you to facts, and given the vitriol of these attacks no wonder the far right piles in
Putin’s troll factories are still hiring.
If you’re a graduate in English and can fake following a premiere league football club, you’re in.
Training in Islamophobia, amping up fear of immigrants, trans people and all around cynicism and nihilism comes later
I’ve read it. Putin only comes across as strong to the weak, intelligent to the stupid. Opposition to him in Russia is growing (if suppressed). Why on earth you succumb to his apocalyptic thundering about 1 % or of population who identity as trans is what bothers