The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Docs shown to court - such as blog posts concerning to RCN's attendance at northern pride and fair care for trans patients show RCN balancing viewpoints as opposed to picking a side.
as he liked on soc med without being expelled from the RCN. The unwillingness to hold TiMs to account or to say no to them - which has parallels with NHS Fife and GU is symptmatic of GI. No need to say R has lied - key evidence is Fair Care for Trans Patients
someone was a thing, that it existed. (This is all from the Fair Care for Trans patients - which you can find on my website https://genderblog.net underneath the last three reports)
I was asking her about the Fair Care for Trans Patients and PM said it was about following the accepted way of dealing with T patients at the time. She accepted the position the RCN was taking at the time was to put men who ID as W into W wards.
[NC takes J to par 217]
"Likewise, a certificated sex interpretation of the conditions in paragraph 27(6) and
(7) (that a person of one sex might reasonably object to the presence of a person of the
opposite sex, and the physical contact provision) will not be capable of being fulfilled in
practice. Again, it is difficult to imagine how or in what circumstances it might be
considered reasonable for a woman to object to members of the opposite sex (in condition
(6)) where “the opposite sex” would include trans women without a GRC (who remain
legally male) but not to “members of her own sex”. This would arise if by operation of
section 9(1) of the GRA 2004 the group of “members of her own sex” were to include
biological men with a GRC, and so legally female who may be physically and outwardly
indistinguishable from the former group of trans women without a GRC. While many
women in a female-only changing room or on a women-only hospital ward or in a rape counselling group might reasonably object to the presence of biological males, it is
difficult to see how the reasonableness of such an objection could be founded on
possession or lack of a certificate. This is so especially when the distinction does not track
physical appearance or presentation, and the woman is unlikely to have any information
about the GRC at the point at which her objection might be raised."
NC another eg is at par 231 now under the heading "Single characteristic associations and charities"
"A certificated sex meaning applied to these exceptions would make it impossible for any
women’s association or charity – including, for example, a mutual support association for
women who are victims of male sexual violence, a lesbian social association, a breast-
feeding support charity – to be set up or to pursue a dedicated purpose which is directed
at the needs of biological females. To require such associations or charities to reconceive
of their objects as targeting a group that does not correspond with their original aims, and
to allow trans people with a GRC (of the opposite biological sex) to join would
significantly undermine the right to associate on the basis of biological sex (or sexual
orientation based on biological sex as we have discussed above)."
NC and it goes on at par 213:
"213. If sex has its biological meaning in this paragraph, then a service-provider can
separate male and female users as obvious and distinct groups. For example, a homeless
shelter could have separate hostels for men and women provided this pursued a legitimate
aim, which might be the safety and security of women users or their privacy and dignity
(and the same for male users). By contrast, if sex means certificated sex, the service-
provider would have to allow access to trans women with a GRC (in other words,
biological males who are female according to section 9(1)) to the women’s hostel. The
following practical difficulties would arise. First, it would be difficult or impossible for the service-provider to distinguish between trans women with and without a GRC
because, as we have explained, the two groups are often visually or outwardly
indistinguishable. Secondly and more fundamentally, it is likely to be difficult (if not
impossible) to establish the conditions necessary for separate services for each sex when
each group includes persons of both biological sexes. For example, it is difficult to
envisage how the condition in paragraph 26(2)(a) (a joint service for persons of both sexes
would be less effective) could ever be fulfilled when each sex includes members of the
opposite biological sex in possession of a GRC and excludes members of the same
biological sex with a GRC."
... and in LH column there was use of pronouns and this par says nurses have "a powerful role to play in affirming the true ID of a trans ind" - is this an obligation on your members
PM no it doesn't convey an obligation
to find
DH when asked re Dave Dawes did he hold a role at the RCN
PM he was chair of our Council
DH you were taken to Fair Care for Trans Patients... under the heading "psych support" p6
NC so okay for she/her they/them etc pronouns but not someone to dissent from GI
PM not confident - no instruction or edict to display pronouns and we have staff who are trans
NC so you can either manifest your allegiance to GI or remain silent, but you can't manifest dissent
NC 170 hits for "transgender" and for "gender critical" you get 2 results - that's a crude measure but as a crude measure it's quite telling - the RCN is much more for GI people than GC
PM we are as much for GC people as trans people - the focus of much of LGBTQ is around care
NC turn to p953 - about Rose using F CR in Darlington - stopped using hormones as he's trying to get his gf preg - so he's told colleagues he's sexually active [reads about how uncomfortable he's making people feel etc] She is describing a shockingly abusive situation
PM uncomfortable
NC can you go further
PM it's shocking and I can see why the word abusive is being used
NC you can't say it's shockingly abusive because of the grip T activism has on your org and pays your salary
PM no I disagree
NC next par - survivor of sex abuse says he's approached someone alone and persistently asked her to change - is that shockingly abusive?
PM yes
NC Bethany Hutchison was asking Nicola Ranger to affiliate with the DN union and support them and she is asking for a meeting - and that gets passed to you. - you were non-committal
PM it was at that stage - we'd normally ask for a local meeting which I arranged and it happened.
NC here on p956 your response says there will be some other Ms who will be affected - is this because you are talking about TRAs
PM we've heard from BH - we'd also want to hear from other Ms inc people potentially who are trans and others
NC pls go to p1062 - RCN doc - gender ID glossary "eunuch" - that's a pretty extreme manifestation of GI
PM I don't know
NC go back to p11 about gender-variant children being treated like trans adults - so children who self ID as a eunuch should be affirmed
PM yes
NC and this doc tells nurses to adopt an uncritically affirming approach to child trans patients
[PM is a bit lost]
NC this is an area of contention - whether to affirm children is a flashpoint between GC and GIs and the RCN tells its nurses that nurses should affirm
PM this is from 2017
NC so this position is consistent with GI
PM I accept people are making a choice about their gender
NC that's not the q - you accepted it was a flashpoint a moment ago - GI say people are whatever sex they say GC people say they might be confused or deluded - it's picked a side here
PM not sure I see it as picking a side I see the argument being made about respectiing people's individual choices.
NC pls turn to the doc to Fair Care for Trans Patients p1262 [find it here https://genderblog.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2017-Fair-Care-for-Trans-Patients-2nd-Edition-PUB-005844.pdfhttps://genderblog.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2017-Fair-Care-for-Trans-Patients-2nd-Edition-PUB-005844.pdf]
in the way toilets and CRs have been provided in recent years could be more challenging - and people who've been using one set and are now going to another - not saying that's wrong, but it will have an impact on them and as employers it hasn't been explained where there are exemption and how that translates into healthcare settings where patients have to be cared for and it sounds straightforward to move from one to the other and that's hard to implement in practice and that remains unclear
NC yes people who have taken steps to alter their appearance do cause problems
PM don't think it's the inds - defining those is still as I understand it, unclear
NC what is clear - there may be diff cases where people had altered their appearance but for the great majority of people - irrespective of it actually - there is a rule that people should not be allowed to use oppo sex facilities PM yes for toilets its clear but - practically implementing that and people dealing with that is difficult and there is a big issue with the treatment of trans patients - the majority of the time it will be straightforward, but we want guidance as we don't want our frontline staff being put in a position
NC but the real clear outcome is that nobody should be allowed to use facilities for the oppo sex
PM but no one should be discrimmed for GR and we have to balance the rights of diff groups and whilst SC is clear - balancing the rights against groups is a problem
NC yes GR have rights but if a man who IDs as a woman is told he's not allowed to use the F CR, that's not discrim against him on grounds of GR
[gives non answer. NC tries again]
PM no but if there is no suitable facilities - not a lawyer - but there needs to be somewhere for that ind to change
NC clearly he needs somewhere to go - but it is really clear it's not in the women's [goes back to JGM's advice]. All of that is nonsense isn't it? It's not kneejerk - it's complying with the law.
PM it makes sense to me
NC it's right to hesitate and dither and we should consult before we comply with the law - really saying it's okay to do that
PM yes
... says TW should not be permitted to use the W facilities - sorry p1007 4th par down - and TM not to use the mens. Also says in some circs T people might not be able to use toilets eg masc trans man bio woman whose presents as masc - so SC says they can be excluded, but T
[about LGBTQIA+]
PM I will have agreed it
NC staffer
PM comms team
NC you have pronouns in your LinkenIn profile
PM no idea
NC ever added pronouns to you anything
PM yes
NC people who see you know you're a woman
PM don't know yes probly
NC so putting pronouns in your sig is just signalling your allegiance with GI
PM don't know
NC by putting your pronouns down you are not saying that these ordinary words which we understand the meaning of are now those for people to use
PM I think some people who think they're trans and they should be addressed as how they feel comfortable
NC but you don't need to do you. you're not trans are you
PM no
NC so why do it
PM not so much about addressing me its about people who aren;'t nec clear can do the same
NC providing cover
PM helping people live comfortably
DH we've looked at some docs re trans patients which might be encountered by t M and nurses - are you aware of any Ms who are trans
PM yes
DH are you aware of Ms who have more gender crit beliefs
PM yes
DH it remains a WIP
PM yes it remains a WIP
[https://genderblog.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2017-Fair-Care-for-Trans-Patients-2nd-Edition-PUB-005844.pdfhttps://genderblog.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2017-Fair-Care-for-Trans-Patients-2nd-Edition-PUB-005844.pdf]
DH 4th doc - large bundle p275
DH what is this
PM a clinical guide to help people care for trans people
DH are there many clinical guides produced by RCN
PM many yes
DH as an RCN member what would I be expected to do with them
PM peoples choice to engage with the content or not - it's to help people with
PM "fair care for trans patients"
DH runs to p1278
J not numbered
DH using internal pages - go to the second page - do we see that this would appear to have been issued in 2017
[this is posted on my website at the bottom of yesterday's court report]
DH what would your understanding be as to the inc of such an article in the RCN mag
PM the issue of how to care for trans patients has been raised at congress - artic refers to that. It's an artic to help members understand issues for patients who are trans how best to care for
on SP's behalf for workplace rep (WR) and MG referred you back to what SP wanted.
GT my understanding SP wanted WR and assurances to get her back to work
NC look at p447 second page of MG's letter to AS - 2nd par - "the RCN now has the benefit.. [reads to it]... trans women
NC if you search RCN site for "gender critical" you find 2 results. Do you agree that if those results show what they seem to show there is "strikingly more interest" in trans rights or trans claims that GC people and their concerns
GT first time I"ve seen this certainly more
GT yes
NC do you agree that the expression LGBTQ is contentious - because there are a lot LGB people who say gender reassignment is nothing to do with them and shouldn't be lumped in with trans or queer.
GT can't really say
NC so you can't say LGBTQ is contested
GT not my area
https://rcn.org.uk sorry
NC that's a search for LGBTQ on RCN website - there were about 60 results which came back - quite a lot of content referring to LGBTQ
GT according to this
NC next search is for "transgender" - 170 results
NC now look at smallest folder on the desk in front of you pp24 to 29 pls
[GT does]
NC just pausing on p24 - do you know what TERFs stand for
GT not really
NC Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminist
GT know that only through reading the bundle - wasn't really aware before
to trans
GT didn't know that
NC NP agreed it was firmly ID'd with Gender Ideology (GI). Agree?
GT don't think I can as I'm not really familiar with it
NC back to p600 in the big bundle... this is a transcript of part of a chat on an engagement session that RCN ran on
NC by this time there had been RCN engagement sessions on the Supreme Court ruling
BH yes she said the majority of people within the RCN were for the ruling and there was a small minotity who weren't and they had to be cautious about how the presented themslves because there were people from all walks of life
NC who had to be cautious
BH the RCN had to be cautious
NC who
BH GC people had to be cautious
NC why
BH I've touched on this already - people were afraid of trans activists
BH if you could call it that we - had one meeting in may 2024 with HR and there was an RCN rep there and she just said she was in a listening role and tha's all she did
NC anything more after that?
BH no
NC did you get any help from other unions
BH Lisa was part of unison - she contact Unison and they did not respond - during our legal case "we found out that unison decided to represent the trans male. We were also subject to tweets which described us as transphobic bigots"
... he had a female name, and he was transgender, but he was 6' tall he'd come from a male prison and I didn't feel I could use female pronouns in front of the doctor
NC why not
JM he is male, and me being a nurse and my Christian values I would be deceiving myself if
Grateful to be asked for a quote for this piece by Sophie Clark at Dazed.
"The deadly implications of Wales’ trans healthcare ‘pause’."
https://www.dazeddigital.com/life-culture/article/70902/1/welsh-trans-healthcare-pause
I am glad the victims of "gender-affirming surgery" are meeting, organising and fighting. The general public will only peak when they see the photos and scars and hear the stories of how these young people were persuaded they were trans. It doesn't happen in a vaccuum.
Quotes a post by A0760; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Or vice versa. Spells it out. No activist language, covers all bases. I use trans-identifying on my blog but I think I have an informed audience there. For a mainstream outlet I think we should say “man who clams he is a woman”. Absolutely no room for doubt there.
I disagree. The brain doesn’t prioritise the word “trans” in “trans woman” because the discussion is usually about trans, so the brain lands on “woman” as the differentiator. So you’re then asking the brain to accept a fundamental nonsense - that when you say woman, you mean man, and vice versa.
Important post but I would add that most people not engaged with this get confused when they try to have to work out in a real time conversation what a trans woman is. They generally instinctively assume biological woman unless concentrating. Trying to hold a nonsensical concept in our heads is tiring and quickly stops anyone from thinking clearly. The media is complicit in this.
Quoting @jan_murray: Whenever I publish an important piece like today’s Mail story on men competing in women’s parkrun categories, one thing is almost guaranteed: some of the first criticism will be about the language rather than the substance of the story.
So I thought it might be helpful to explain how things actually work in the mainstream media - and the pressures sex-realist/ gender-critical journalists are navigating behind the scenes.
First, let’s not forget that most mainstream publications still wouldn’t even touch a story asking a question as basic as: why are men still being allowed to compete in women’s sporting categories and steal their achievements.
There are still only a handful of mainstream outlets prepared to publish these kinds of stories: the Daily Mail, Telegraph, GB News, Talk and, sometimes, The Times.
And even there, gender-critical journalists and editors can be up against it.
I regularly see people saying journalists should simply refuse to use terms such as “trans woman”, insist on “man” and “woman”, or walk away from publications that won’t use exactly the terminology they want.
But I’m afraid journalism doesn’t work like that.
Let's not forget that parts of the media have been 'captured' - as they have in most industries. Which means there are trans activists in newsrooms too. Even in outlets that will cover these kinds of stories.
And, as in other sectors, it only takes one activist - or one person with a trans identifying relative - to make everyone start treading on eggshells.
Even media regulators like IPSO and Ofcom face these kind of pressures.
So when you see a story like mine today, please don’t underestimate what may have gone on behind the scenes just to get it published.
Sometimes somebody has had to stick their neck out simply to get “she/her” removed when referring to a man - because that may still be what a publication’s style guide says.
Recently, I discovered to my horror that an important piece I had written was due to appear using “she/her” throughout for someone who was clearly male. At the last minute it was changed to “they/them”.
Still not my preference.
But better.
As an independent journalist, I also don’t have the luxury of simply walking away every time an editor makes a language choice I dislike. Sometimes you have to ask: does the benefit of getting an important story in front of hundreds of thousands of people outweigh wording that isn’t exactly what I would have chosen?
But there is another side to this.
Journalists also need to be careful not to replace activist language from one side of a contested debate with activist language from the other.
For example, terms such as “trans-identifying male” or “trans-identifying female” may be favoured by some gender-critical campaigners, but to many ordinary audiences they are unfamiliar and confusing.
And our job as journalists is not to write in the language of a movement. It is to be accurate, clear and understood.
To put this into context, if I talk to my mum about trans identifying males/females, she'll typically assume I mean the opposite.
If I say “trans woman”, she at least understands who I mean - and that I’m not talking about an *actual* woman.
So by all means challenge broadcasters and publications over inaccurate or misleading language.
Members of @JournalismSEEN do this every day - sometimes at risk to their own jobs/financial security.
But do also bear in mind the reality of getting these stories into the mainstream at all - and that the journalists doing so may already be pushing much harder behind the scenes than the public ever see.
“Attempts to introduce a trans-inclusive conversion-therapy ban have resurfaced over the years like a turd that will not quite flush.”
Quoting @jo_bartosch: Got this out this morning- The campaign has outlived Theresa May, Boris Johnson, Liz Truss, the lettuce, Rishi Sunak and Sir Keir Starmer. The draft Bill has now washed up in Andy Burnham’s in-tray. https://www.terftimes.com/p/stonewall-still-haunting-government/
My ex-friend Jon Ronson may be a case study in the corrupting toxicity of trans ideology https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/08/29/my-ex-friend-jon-ronson-case-study-toxicity-trans-ideology/
Well there we go. Surgeries cancelled and surgery referrals stopped. Good to work with @[private account] getting this across the line. Read more in tomorrow's Sunday Times.
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/transgender-clinic-wales-cancels-operations-p3gxfjp8g
Quoting @nickwallis: I suspect it is all kicking off at The Welsh Gender Service right now. They may have been sending too many people for surgery.
https://genderblog.net/welsh-gender-surgeries-could-be-stopped/
Formal confirmation has come through. The Welsh Gender Service surgery referrals and scheduled surgeries have been paused. Write up here:
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/transgender-clinic-wales-cancels-operations-p3gxfjp8g
Quoting @nickwallis: I suspect it is all kicking off at The Welsh Gender Service right now. They may have been sending too many people for surgery.
https://genderblog.net/welsh-gender-surgeries-could-be-stopped/
Confirmed. Only transgender clinic in Wales cancels all operations over safety concerns:
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/transgender-clinic-wales-cancels-operations-p3gxfjp8g
Confirmed. Only transgender clinic in Wales cancels all operations over safety concerns.
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/transgender-clinic-wales-cancels-operations-p3gxfjp8g
SV the G advises Ps that "Depending upon the circumstances of the case, a trans or non-binary person
(including those who have a GRC and / or have had gender reassignment) may
deceive a complainant as to their sex if they choose not to disclose that they are
trans / non-binary, or if they make a deliberate false assertion or lie in respect of
their sex and / or gender identity."
SV the fifth point in the G "Some trans people may be wary of revealing their birth sex due to social stigma,
transphobia or safety considerations, which may produce high levels of anxiety."
SV "it is the examination here it seems in purely sympathetic terms of why a trans person may deceive somebody about their sex, may deceive a sexual partner about their sex"
Here is the relevant bit:
How a trans or non-binary person experiences and expresses their gender can be a
complex issue. The decision on whether to prosecute must be based on the evidence in
each individual case, but the following information is provided for background context,
as it may assist prosecutors to make more informed decisions:
• Many people who have transitioned may not regard themselves as trans, but
simply as a man or a woman.
• Gender identity can be fluid and/or emergent for some persons, particularly for
young persons, who may be exploring the nature of their identity and/or sexuality,
or for non-binary people, who may identify as a man and a women or neither.
• A person whose gender identity isn’t the same as their sex may express their
gender through their speech, dress, gestures, mannerisms etc, without this
being a fabrication, a performance or a deception. (It is important to recognise
that non-trans people may also have a multitude of ways to express themselves,
even if their gender identity is the same as their sex.)
J tell me how this section helps your argument over deception
SV I will - in the trans section - it says that many people genuinely regard themselves as men or women, which suggests their culpability for deception is minimised...
[SV takes J to "trans and non-binary persons experiences" in G]
SV this advises Ps to the effect that T and NB have less culpability for a deception for which a non-trans suspect would be culpable.
... reading. Saying trans and NB makes things more "complex" and devoting most of the chapter about trans people. Consistent use of the term "sex and/or GID" equating the two. It happens 17 times throughout the G.
[SV talks about case law which includes assault by penetration includes body parts which have been surgically attached and specifies trans surgeries]
SV there cannot be a loophole whereby someone with a pseudo-penis cannot be accused of rape or conversely
It raises the prospect there is a relevant diff between trans and non trans and suggests a GID (as opposed to sex) is operative on the legal status of consent.
The motivation varies. In sex activity - the more convincing the deception the greater the need to be frank about his or her sex.
J ?
SV a trans ID male who presents very convincingly as male... in her life the fact she is not male is of no relevance and she does not have to
SV the intro to G - our central submission on this passage is predicated on an error of law - 1 that there is a relevant difference between a trans suspect and a non-trans suspect 2 that the rel difference is the suspect's GID and 3 that this has a bearing on the assessment of
SV the G is probably the most widely accessible public source on the perameters of consent to sex. It is publicly available so everyone knows what it is. People who have trans IDs and orgs who represent them are likely to look to the G so they don't commit a serious sexual...
... and Sexual Offices - Chapter 6: Consent’ . The focus of the Guidance is the asserted position that “questions of deception and consent may involve more complex issues where the suspect is trans or non-binary”...
... contains information on trans and non-binary suspects, this is because questions of deception and consent may involve more complex issues where the suspect is trans or non-binary."
... (negated). Cases in which deception as to birth sex is a live issue may involve either a suspect who is non-trans or a suspect who is trans or non-binary. Although much of this guidance...
My piece for tomorrow's Sunday Times on the Darren Rigby, the BBC apology and what it says about their treatment of trans stories. Thanks to all who spoke to me for it.
Enjoy this article for free. But buy it in paper form tomorrow!
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/media/article/bbc-apology-trans-story-darren-rigby-llq3kdqfn
So it's basically a Trojan Horse to bring in self-ID? In that case I am interested. Thanks everyone for all the info. These clauses (kindly screenshotted by @[private account] below) seem to suggest anyone (except a clinician) telling someone they are not trans is potentially criminal.
Tribunal in Leeds refusing to use neutral pronouns in court case - effectively siding with the trans-identified claimaint, as is the respondent. Intervenors out on their own in wanting to use male or neutral pronouns.
Quotes a post by A2920; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I implore the new DG to impose reality on his journalists. Tell them that sex is real. Drop the phrase "trans women" which confuses the audience and make clear that people who call themselves "trans women" are men.
... We apologise for the failures in our reporting."
This is not an outlier. This is endemic with BBC reporting on trans issues. Men who claim/believe they are women are still called women by the BBC. Or their crimes are ignored. Or both.
... these threats were directed at three all-girls' schools, related to the "misgendering" of trans girls and that Darren Rigby identified in one threat as a trans woman...
on the trans debate. It must leave the court with a serious q as to whether a fair trial can take place. There are qs as to whether this case was properly investigated. The ready engagement of C in at least
to the central point of the pleadings - that it’s about the way the case has been run and its about abuse of process. They are central to the sides of this major debate on trans issues, the use of the police and CPS
Dr Joyce is to speak at the Durham Union Society (DUS).
According to @[private account], Durham Student Union (DSU), the DSU Community Officer, DSU Trans Association, and QueerSphere have "asked DUS to account for itself.”
Contains a great quote from @[private account]
https://thetab.com/2026/06/15/conflict-over-durham-unions-helen-joyce-talk
Looking into the placement of male prisoners in the female estate and came across this @[private account] letter from a female lifer in HMP Styal complaining about the special treatment afforded to female prisoners who declare they are trans:
https://insidetime.org/mailbag/lifers-should-get-single-cells/
Suitably bleak (and brilliant) dispatch from the trans outerworld frontline by Sarah.
"What if I’m just unhappy forever no matter what I do?"
https://open.substack.com/pub/sarahmittermaier/p/what-if-im-just-unhappy-forever-no?r=bc1jk&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=email
A deep dive into what is going on at the Welsh Gender Service. Are Welsh people three times more likely to be trans than the UK as a whole? Is WGS leading the way? Or is it causing harm?
https://genderblog.net/welsh-gender-service-going-rogue/
Former BBC Editor Rob Burley on trans ideology, impartiality and the institutional capture of the BBC. A lot of journalists - not just at the BBC - have been asleep on this subject. But the BBC's betrayal matters most.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ros0so0UW58
Leading to the NHS reply:
"People assigned female at birth but living as a man may describe themselves as a "transgender man", while those assigned male at birth but living as a woman may call themselves a "transgender woman ". These terms
can be shortened to "trans man/male" or "trans woman/female."
Having clarified that by male and female, the FOI requester meant, in the NHS's language "assigned female at birth" and "assigned male at birth", the response came back as follows:
"108 Trans female
308 Trans male"
Leading the requester to ask...
therefore cannot be changed” was “vulnerable to the point that many trans advocates (some doctors and scientists among them) say sex isn’t biological and can be changed”."
"But I challenged her, suggesting that there were indeed facts: facts about the reality of sex. Asked whether it is not a fact that trans women are women, she pauses, before reluctantly answering: “No. They’re trans women".”
"Unsworth continues to insist, though, that it wasn’t until last year’s Supreme Court ruling that there were facts that you could use to challenge the “trans women are women” loyalty test...."
Looking back, she concludes that BBC News had become “increasingly unmanageable”.
In seeking to explain why - with the handling of the transgender issue in mind - she returns to the unique environment she encountered in 2018, a time of what she calls “progressive madness”.
Fran Unsworth on BBC journalists: “It was bullying,” she tells me [...] “But it wasn’t just the trans issue [...] people didn’t want to hear from certain points of view; they’d ‘no platform’ them; all that safe-spaces shit.”
https://x.com/RobBurl/status/2055553585870487694?s=20
Quotes a post by A3555; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"Critical thinking - asking whether you could genuinely draw an analogy between gay rights and transgender rights - risked putting you on the “wrong side of history”, and so it was best avoided. As one senior presenter tells me, this led to a disastrous category error."
Quoting @unherd: Inside the capture of the BBC, by Rob Burley (@[private account])
In his 13 years as a senior BBC editor, Rob Burley saw the Corporation’s defining commitment to impartiality undermined by transgender ideology, a blind commitment to Diversity & Inclusion schemes, and a culture of intolerance.
Informed by his experiences at Newsnight alongside other prestige shows, his major investigation reveals how the BBC took a side in the culture wars.
He draws on extensive interviews with current and former staff — including journalists at the very top.
Speaking out for the first time since leaving the Corporation, Fran Unsworth, the former director of BBC News, reveals in an explosive interview: “I would actually say it drove me out, just dealing with the progressive editorial issues and the bullying around them all. It was incredibly difficult.”
Read more below ⬇️
https://buff.ly/7Fv4Ry8
Oh this is goooood: "The rise in trans identification did not emerge in isolation. It emerged from a much broader cultural and psychiatric shift in which growing numbers of ordinary human experiences came to be understood through diagnostic frameworks...
there is no doubt he would have assaulted her... he has now found out where she is studyoing... he has a
well documented murderous hatred of all transgender
SV why go then?
SB "I don't remember"
SV the title of the session was "Gender Wars" - you're a trans activist - was that maybe why you were interested
SB is this the earlier session - you're making me very confused
SV I'm talking about the GW session
Trans rights campaigners behaviour exposed in Graham Linehan's appeal over alleged damage to a mobile phone. Plus loads of other weird/procedural stuff. Honestly, it's better than it sounds.
https://genderblog.net/glinner-rides-again/
What the BCA has done is expose in court the behaviours of a certain group of trans activists - infiltrating women's groups, going to their meetings and playing audio advocating violence against them and being threatening/intimidating.
... around the perimeter of the event with a loudspeaker playing, on a loop, a recording of trans activist Sarah Jane Baker shouting “If you see a TERF, punch them in
Further evidence not relied on at trial is footage taken at a LWS event shows the Complainant and Freda Wallace walking around the perimeter of the event with a loudspeaker playing, on a loop, a recording of trans activist Sarah Jane
(iii) Footage taken by Maria Maclachlan, a gender critical activist, of her conversation with the Complainant. In the conversation, the Complainant accuses Ms Maclachlan of lying about being assaulted by a trans activist (Tara
Harassment Allegation
It is the case for the Defendant that he was regarded by the Complainant, and by the trans activists mentioned above, as a particularly desirable political
On the 23rd October 2024, a third party complaint to police alleging that the Defendant had attempted to assault the Complainant on the 19th October 2024. This complaint was made by a trans activist named Michelle Louise Burrows...
On 22nd October 2024, the first allegation to the police that the Defendant was harassing the Complainant came from a trans activist named Lynsay Watson.
...first of which was made to police in 2018 by a trans activist named Stephanie Hayden. In November 2024, when the investigation into this matter was initially closed, Stephanie Hayden assisted the Complainant in drafting an
[...]
It is the case for the Defendant that the allegation before the Court is a part of a series of attempts by trans-rights activists (of whom the Complainant is one) to misuse the justice system to achieve a victory against a high-profile opponent in the ongoing debate.
It's also not in dispute that GL made posts on soc media. SB was 17yo. SB is a transgender activist. GL held opposing views to the vomplainant. Before 19 Oct GL and SB had not met in person. GL had...
On my way to the @AllianceLGB conference. Looking forward to finally meeting @[private account]. Read his story in today’s @thetimes:
‘I’m a walking example of what’s wrong about trans ideology’
Also @joannaccherry’s book is serialised in there too.
Link in the next tweet….
Great to speak to @[private account] for @thetimes. Looking forward to seeing him launch Detransitioners Pathway UK at the @AllianceLGB conference tomorrow.
‘I’m a walking example of what’s wrong about trans ideology’
https://www.thetimes.com/article/a16848cc-b57a-4608-9309-a6130931480b?shareToken=f442f88fc3f1e609e45d911ddf17f16a
Thanks @[private account]
Men. It’s transgender men. They’re not women. They’re men who claim transgender status. Men. It’s so exhausting. Stop misleading your readers.
“Transgender women banned from women's PDC darts” https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/darts/articles/c33lm6d154eo
“We do not seek to, nor do we have, any influence over the way media outlets, who are members of Pride in Diversity, report issues, including the ABC,” the statement said.
Also: “Under the AWEI scheme, the ABC earns points toward its ranking for specific editorial content, such as the trans-themed series First Day and the Innies and Outies podcast.”
Here is that story. Thanks to the @DailyMail team for helping get it over the line:
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15625107/NHS-stop-prescribing-puberty-blockers-trans-identifying-children.html
Government plans to consult with a view to banning access to cross-sex hormones on the NHS for u18s. New story:
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15625107/NHS-stop-prescribing-puberty-blockers-trans-identifying-children.html