The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Dude. Nothing you are saying demonstrates that there are more than two sexes. Because there are only two sexes. No intersex condition disproves that and even if it did, people who identify as trans don't have intersex conditions, which is the point. You can't change sex. You are either male or female and that's the end of the story.
Based on this definition, I would qualify as "transgender."
I don't have a "core understanding" of my "gender" as "feminine."
This is why this whole thing is so stupid.
"Transgender" is not a coherent, clear category of anything. It's just a way people choose to identify themselves based on a feeling or preference. You can't create a legal category of people based on a vague feeling that differs from person to person. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/04/opinion/transgender-rights-strangio-douthat.html
Ehhh I think it's the opposite of the trans thing, actually. The reason we are "accepting" of trans is because we decided we should never "shame" anyone for their "sexuality" or "identity" and we need to be more "accepting" of fetishes and weird public (and private) behaviour.
Either way, the point of letting us speak is not so that we can say mean things about "trans people," but so that we can explain how gender identity ideology harms women and kids. Most people, ten years ago, did not understand the impact this would have.
Trans activism is a cover for predatorial men. Banning "misgendering" and "deadnaming" was always about protecting male creeps and bad actors https://x.com/wesyang/status/1992780646385594859
Quoting @wesyang: The man who raped his nine-year old who identified as nonbinary before killing herself, whose death was exploited by trans activists as a suicide caused by "transphobia," now identifies as a woman while imprisoned for his rape and all record of his crime has been scrubbed from the public record.
California just made it a crime to disclose the identity of trans-identified people who have changed their names, providing state-protected secrecy for any child rapist or murderer who decides he wants a clean record.
Trans-identified people are murdered because of 'transphobia' (what you would call 'hate'). Men in prostitution are in dangerous situations and are sometimes killed as a result of drugs, crime, and because, again, the sex trade is simply a dangerous place to operate. It's also possible sometimes they are subject to violence for lying about their sex to men they are trying to bed.
Dude I'm not talking about the complimenting part. Women compliment me and other women in general all the time. I'm saying, 1) On no planet did a bunch of random chicks in the bathroom call Wu "gorgeous", 2) My point is that women don't share makeup tips in the bathroom. This is pure trans fantasy.
It’s neat that you described your fantasy of what happens in women’s bathrooms but this is not what happens in women’s bathrooms.
Also, there is not a woman on the planet who would sincerely describe Wu as “gorgeous,” out of the blue. Unless they clocked that you are a dude and are trying to win lib points by generously complimenting a trans
She... "damaged an umbrella"?!?
Trans activists are a joke and so are the authorities who cater to them.
https://x.com/MailOnlineScot/status/1983301600543125799
Quotes a post by T05590; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It is not “discrimination” or “hate” to understand that you can’t change your sex and that men should not be allowed access to women’s spaces and sports.
All trans activists have done is destroy the hard fought for rights and spaces of females; and threaten, censor, intimidate, and libel anyone who dares push back.
They know they’re losing the debate in the public realm now. Their bullying, entitlement, and generally psychotic behaviour and arguments have backfired on them, and men like Brianna Wu are too enraged about it to play “moderate” anymore.
Again, that's not how the term is used, as per trans activists. Either way, it still isn't necessary and doesn't make sense. Both women and men take hormones for all sorts of reasons (women to avoid perimenopause/menopause symptoms, for ex).
"Trans" also just means, according to the transes, anyone who "identifies" as a sex they are not. Which is not a real thing. You can't "identify" as another sex. You can't be "born in the wrong body." You can't change sex. And how you feel about gender roles does not change your biology. "Trans" is a nonsense term.
It’s never been about “trans people,” as the media, trans activists, and their pathetic handmaidens try to claim. It’s always been about *men* in women’s spaces. No one cares if a woman competes against men in sport, goes into the men’s change room, or is transferred to a female prison (not that they would)… it’s always been about *men* pretending to be women
No one ever anywhere has banned “trans people” from anything, you shameless liars. The only issue at hand is keeping *males* out of *female* spaces. No one cares about your dumb “identity”
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Sean Orr thinks that @jk_rowling's defenses of women only spaces and biological reality equates to "campaigning against trans people" https://x.com/seanorr/status/1967307530067222927
Quotes a post by T22068; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] @ezraklein The concept of 'transgenderism' is incoherent. There is no such thing as a 'trans person'. If you disagree, explain why and what you mean by 'trans people'.
Do you honestly not understand, @ezraklein, that none of this is about “trans people”—it’s about men in women’s spaces like bathrooms, changerooms, female prisons, women’s shelters, and of course it’s also about males competing as “female” in sport… are you really not getting this or are just being disingenuous?
I'd love it if you could define "trans person" — who are you referring to? Who is being "thrown under the bus" and how? Who is "unsafe" and who is making them "unsafe"? What does it mean to be "anti-trans"? Who is "anti-trans"? https://x.com/briebriejoy/status/1972379345097474460
Quoting @briebriejoy: It’s actually so sick and dark sided to argue that if we only had thrown trans people under the bus trans people would be safer now. No! We’d just have two anti trans parties.
This man is not rational and he is not sane. He is a narcissistic, dangerous, creepy trans activist like all the rest of them. And stupid to boot! Those who treated him as though he was some kind of rational centrist trying to bring sanity to the trans debate lost a bunch of credibility imo. https://x.com/BriannaWu/status/1948775547783294980
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Anyone who says such nonsense should not be taken seriously.
Claiming "trans kids" are being "banned from sports" is an outright lie.
*Males* should be banned from *female* sports because female sports are for females.
https://x.com/briebriejoy/status/1946613292585152567
Quoting @briebriejoy: “I don’t care about actual sexual violence against woman and girls. I just care about banning trans kids from sports.”
There it is.
Gender identity ideology offers a convenient reason for and solution to identity struggles and mental health problems many young people face in adolescence, but with incredibly harmful, permanent consequences.
There is no “transgender brain,” there is no “being trapped in the wrong body”—this is all nonsense and pseudoscience, yet countless people have been convinced otherwise.
I spoke with @buttonslives about a paper she co-authored @[private account], titled, “Transgender Brain Studies are Fatally Flawed,” @[private account] .
It’s amazing this insane ideology has gotten has far as it has. It has never made sense, never been coherent, and has always been dangerous.
Enough already.
The term is incoherent. I am asking YOU what YOU mean when you say "transgender person." No one is worried about whatever a "transgender person" is being in their bathroom. WOMEN don't want MEN in their bathrooms.
Do you understand that males make up half of the population? No one is concerned about "transgender athletes"—we are concerned about males competing in female sports. https://x.com/holy_schnitt/status/1940491361704407333
Quotes a post by T04117; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Tonight on the Where Are All the Women stream: trans brains, terfs wins, and OnlyFans wars. Tune in live at 6PM PT/9PM ET and join @[private account] and I in the live chat! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=24fFrezjyMs
Even if it were true that "trans people" have "different brains" than "cis people," that's not how transgenderism is determined. It's determined solely through self-declaration, so it means nothing at all. It's just a statement or a feeling.
The point is that any male can claim to be a "woman" and we are all meant to accept that in a legal sense as well as in every other sense.
Either way, you can have different brain scans all you like but that still doesn't make a man a woman. https://x.com/JessicaBRiedl/status/1939366643664064796
Quotes a post by T04592; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It does not "always come down to toilets"— it's that trans activists are always insisting they "just want to pee," and behaving as though men are being denied human rights by being expected to use the men's room. https://x.com/johnjamesni/status/1937879348846932357?s=46&t=UG-a6bb44wol6vUOu_RkiA
Quotes a post by A1465; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Normally I'm against trans-surgeries but the clear answer to this question is that these pussies need to grow some balls https://x.com/mrsunshinebaby/status/1933181334509486462
Quotes a post by T06106; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Brianna Wu wants to trans kids. He is pro-sterilizing minors. He supports the gruesome, experimental, permanent mutilation and destruction of the bodies of teenagers who have no real understanding of what they are doing to themselves. He is not a moderate. He is a narcissistic, self-interested, manipulative creep. The journalists and media personalities falling for his charade have been bamboozled, which is frankly mysterious to me as it should be very obvious that this man has been lying to the whole world from the Gamergate days on.
I am baffled by those *still* referring to Imane Khelif as "she," despite proof of maleness. He isn't even identifying as "trans" (not that I think that's an excuse), but what's the reasoning here?
This one will really blow your mind: The Canadian Medical Association is suing over @ABDanielleSmith’s Bill C-26, which protects minors from the permanent and unnecessary harm of puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and trans surgeries.
Apparently protecting kids goes against their “conscience.”
My interview with @_CryMiaRiver is now available to the public on the podcast @[private account] 🙌🚀
Hey @EmmaVigeland — Imane is biologically male, just like we all told you, but your retarded tweet calling him female is still up. Why?
The whole world knows you are full of shit on this, as well as on the trans issue as a whole. Are you ready to admit it?
https://x.com/EmmaVigeland/status/1823081056066846930
Quoting @EmmaVigeland: Imane is biologically female and identifies as a woman, but Rowling's tweet calling her a man is still up. Why?
TERFs are the real misogynists. They reinforce notions of "protecting" traditional femininity by policing who is/isn't female within inherently patriarchal binaries.
It's true. "Gender identity" is entirely a Western invention, despite trans activist insistence that biological sex/knowing the difference between a man and a woman is a "colonial" invention. Western progressives need to get out more. https://x.com/ErinFriday75490/status/1927517972031054152
Quotes a post by A0924; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is no such thing as a "trans kid" and no defense for putting healthy kids on these drugs. Anyone who claims otherwise loses all credibility imo. https://x.com/wesyang/status/1924914163354366364
Quoting @wesyang: There is no "moderate compromise" on transgenderism that includes endorsing the extreme view that some kids need to be given a repurposed off-label cancer drugs once used to chemically castrate adult sex offenders before that was judged to be a form of cruel and unusual punishment in order to affirm a delusion that can never be true
I think the sad part about what's lost on these people identifying as trans is that they think words=acceptance, but the reality of attraction is that it's not about people being empathetic or feeling bad for you... Either you're attracted or you're not, and if you're a gay man you're going to be attracted to men, just like if you're a straight man you're going to be attracted to women, not a man who says he's a woman...
Attraction isn’t just about superficial, obvious stuff… it’s about hormones, subtle biological cues, smell, etc. You can call a woman a man to be polite, but if you’re into dudes, at the end of the day it’s unlikely you’re going to be attracted to a woman, despite HRT and surgeries. You really can’t fake sex or biology.
It would be far more compassionate to stop lying to young people about this, setting them up for a lifetime of disappointment.
Of course "transgender men" will be in the women's bathroom. They're women.
You cannot possibly be this daft https://x.com/AyoCaesar/status/1915695535530398062
Quoting @AyoCaesar: That stunned silence when someone is confronted by the fact that if you force everyone who was born female to use the ladies' loo, that means transgender men will be in there too.
There is no such thing as “being born in the wrong body;” there is no such thing as being “trans.” These are not rational or coherent ideas. Why are these people discussing this as though they are saying something rational?
Hahahaha lord you should see what I’ve received over years from the trans activists empowered by the government you’re still voting for. This is nothing.
For many years, Vancouver East has been an NDP stronghold—dominated by trans activists and leftist liars who go along with the pillorying, slander, blacklisting, and threatening of women who say that men aren't women. It's time to interrupt the tyrannical control these people think they have over Vancouver, in particular, East Van.
If you live in the riding and care about democracy, free speech, and women's sex-base rights and spaces, please help me get on the ballot by signing an Electors Consenting to Candidacy form!
These conversations are long past due and the silencing of dissent on the question of transgender ideology must no longer be accepted.
People who call themselves 'trans' are welcome to live their lives in peace. No one is stopping them. Meanwhile, trans activists make women's lives a living hell. I've been fighting to protect women's sex-based rights and spaces for years. You know this. The way you've twisted reality around to avoid the truth is a wild cope.
Whether or not you are a feminist doesn't matter to me. You can do and feel whatever you like. I think the issue is more that, if you want people to take you seriously and trust you, you have to be as truthful and coherent as possible. We all mess up from time to time—that's normal—but committing to using wrong-sex pronouns weakens any argument you might make within the topic of gender identity. It makes no sense to pretend there is a separate category of "trans people," when that category is undefinable in a material sense, and it makes no sense to refer to men as "she," simply because they demand it. Like, what is your criteria for calling a man "she"? Any man who demands it? How do you determine who is a "she" and who is a "he"? Beyond that, of course, pretending men are the opposite sex because they embrace some version of gender stereotypes is a large part of the problem... Are you trying to challenge gender identity ideology or embrace it?
Islamist: women are defined by gender stereotypes
Trans activist: I believe that too!
Islamist: I am entitled to abuse women and ignore their boundaries
Trans activist: same!
Islamist: Women and girls are not deserving of respect or rights
Brianna Wu: Are we besties?
Feminists who only blame "men" for trans activism and can't look at their political failures will fail forever. Refusing to fight something as dangerous and as harmful as trans ideology because you won't stand next to women who don't share your exact politics is not just poor strategy and childish, but incredibly harmful. You are to blame as much as anyone. You lost the fight not just for your own aims, but for all women. https://x.com/MeghanEMurphy/status/1893740409504879091
Quoting @MeghanEMurphy: The feminists who demand that women pledge allegiance to their bad and irrational leftist politics or be cancelled are the reason why women failed to launch an effective challenge to transgenderism back when we could have stopped it, a decade ago. Had these women been willing to fight back without demanding everyone the fight alongside join their ideological cult we could have done something.
Instead, women like me were left fighting alone in Canada.
They put their religion ahead of women's rights and pretend that constitutes a commitment to feminism.
No. You failed. And women suffered as a result.
It makes me sick. I'm never going to get over the fact that Canadian feminists allowed the trans takeover rather than fight alongside women like me because I stood next to the 'wrong people,' fought for free speech, and generally failed to repeat after them as ordered to.
No I am not saying that. Read what I wrote again. and again, there is no "they." There is not group of people called "trans." It's impossible because the concept itself is too flimsy and incoherent.
Hating or attacking gay people because they are gay is a material thing. No one gets attacked for being "trans." Men are probably attacked for pretending to be women sometimes, but I mean, don't lie to people about your sex if you're trying to sleep with them? And don't do weird shit in public? idk, I mean you could argue people are attacked for being gender non-conforming, but that's not "trans." Again, trans isn't a coherent concept or material thing, so the term just doesn't make any sense.
There is no such thing as "a chemical induced mental illness from birth that tells a person they are the gender opposite of their physical gender." If a man thinks he's a woman, he can go see a psychiatrist I guess. I don't really care it's not my problem. Or it should not be, in any case. Trans activism certainly tried to make it all of our problems, didn't it!
The concept of “trans” is incoherent therefore the concept of “transphobia” is incoherent. What is one “phobic” if exactly? What does it mean to be “transphobic”? Nothing. It means you understand how reality and biology work and you aren’t insane.
The Conservatives win by taking on the trans issue like Trump did. This is my opinion and I hope to be proven right. Please be bold and uncompromising on this, @[private account] @[private account] https://x.com/TristinHopper/status/1887583450510532820
Quotes a post by T08630; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Canadian economy is fucked, people can’t afford to buy groceries, the healthcare system is falling apart, there are seven hour waits in the ER, people are dying on waitlists, addicts have take over the streets in places like Vancouver and Victoria and apparently nothing can be done about it, so what does @JustinTrudeau’s @[private account] government do? Hand out $40 million to keep pushing gender identity on Canadians!
The fact the rest of the world is moving on from trans insanity and the Canadian government doubles down is so insane. Read the room @[private account]
The irony is that I've been criticizing third wave feminism longer than probably anyone involved in this conversation, including Matt Walsh. BUT I also have a very good understanding of and education in the history of the women's movement, which most people don't have. Few know what they're talking about when they're talking about the "waves," and few really understand the history of the trans trend. I'm not averse to criticizing feminism's role in all this nonsense (and a lot of other nonsense), but it simply did not start with feminism. The iteration of "feminism" that embraced "gender identity" came much later, once the pervs and sexologists and postmodernists had already been on this track for decades. More than one thing is to blame here, and the fact Walsh wants to pin ALL of the blame on whatever it is he thinks feminism is, which is mostly wrong, only goes to show his intellectual laziness and obsession with his own ideology and narratives. He lacks curiosity or any interest in changing his mind when presented with new information and facts, because he's fundamentally not a curious person, interested in learning or in the truth.
Robin Morgan spoke out. So did Gloria Steinem, actually. There was also a huge rift that happened at MichFest, a longtime women-only festival that was ended a few years ago on account of trans activists. During the 70s, women were not on board with this crap. Things changed with third wave feminism. Because third wave feminism is retarded.
In like 2019 I said something similar — that the Canadian left had essentially invented and imported an idea of extreme racism, white nationalism, and racist police violence that simply did and does not exist in Canada. That they had glommed onto American race discourse that was frankly ridiculous to apply to Canada considering our vastly different demographics. I was cancelled by almost all of the leftist, “gender critical,” feminists in Canada as a result, who proved themselves to be just as addicted to wokeism as the rest of Canadian progressives, with the exception of the trans issue.
You’re missing or misunderstanding the fact and point l that transgenderism was infected by and for me… the women who attempt to trans largely do so in order to escape lesbianism and body issues that arose from trauma/sexual abuse, whereas men who say they are women do so largely on account of a fetish and/or in order to access women’s space/refuse to respect their boundaries… yes, retarded liberal women are to blame for supporting this but it didn’t come from them…
I think she's specifically talking about the men who do act like it's nbd, though, which there are plenty of... Of course tons of men oppose trans nonsense, but I was attacked endlessly in Vancouver (and across Canada more broadly) by leftist men who called me a transphobic bigot for pointing out that men aren't women, and the greatest threats always came from male trans activists. Women went after me too, of course, but they are far less scary. The men who went after me were very clearly misogynists who saw this as the perfect opportunity to get away with harassing, bullying, and abusing women free from accountability, because, you know, they were 'on the right side of history'