The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
lefty academics came up with, essentially to describe the “masculine” quality that trans men and butch lesbians have (etc.). The left’s use of “gender” in this way *is* a social construct. What it ain’t is the determiner of “man” and “woman.” Those who disagree are wrong.
This de-transitioned guy is right: some years from now we will look back on trans fad as a horrifying cult with a whole class victimized by clueless parents, doctors, and teachers. Does it feel cruel to say this? Well, increasingly, it feels cruel *not* to say it.
Really? Why are you wasting our time here, dude? People shift from "cis" to "trans" to "nonbinary" etc. all the time. And along the way, sometimes things get chopped off. Even before adulthood.
What about intersex?
What about ambiguous cases when we were never able to test any genetic material from a person before their corpses were totally incinerated?
When does "adulthood" begin?
And yes, she would need to take a stand on whether trans women are women...
I guess you did misread it. The GOP? Not about the GOP. Can't? Not the point.
It's a Republican philosopher saying, "Yeah, on the one hand, of course she's caught, unable to voice her support for trans-insanity. But on the other, actually giving a rigorous definition of *any*
This doesn't have to do with the question whether trans women are women.
*I* think they aren't women.
Can I give a definition of "woman" that I am confident would pass muster in SCOTUS cases, which would be citable by someone writing a Supreme Court opinion?
No way.
I'm a Christian conservatarian. I don't think trans women are women. I think people born with fully functioning ordinary penises can never become women.
I actually agree with what you say about the leftist agenda here.
You're just stubbornly refusing to get my point. I *also* don't think trans women are women. I *also* think the normal concept of womanhood is pretty darn clear.
BUT
Asking for definitions from a lawyer, and especially of a SCOTUS nominee in a hearing, is very consequential.
In that context the question just doesn’t serve the function you want it to.
The real gotcha question she should be able to answer “yes” or “no” on the spot is, “Are trans women women?”
@[private account] Well, this might be the difference, then, because in kindergarten that teacher *would* be indoctrinating your children into a trans ideology, including such views as:
(1) People who identify as X (man, woman, etc.) *really are in fact* X.
...
In fact, I have no issues calling her "they" in her presence. But I am not going to think of her *as* a trans man or as gender fluid or whatever category she puts herself in. It is profoundly unreasonable to ask me to share her dysphoria.
Your facile assumption that my children could not be decent and kind, because I don’t want them taught by someone pushing trans ideology (which holds that feelings determine gender, etc.), is itself an obviously intolerant and unkind point of view.
Obviously, trans people don't think they're *merely* "pretending." They "identify." Their identification creates a reality, while pretending does not. Also, delusions don't create reality but are mistaken. So they draw distinctions there, yes.
THINGS THAT SHOULD REMAIN TABOO:
- pedophilia
- child rape
- violent riots
- all violent crime
- public defecation
- shooting up in public
- racism (for real)
- puberty blockers for trans kids
- trans surgery below age 18
- supplying porn to kids in school
With me?
Quoting @lsanger: Are you in favor of at least some things remaining taboo?
It's a win-win for them. It takes us further down the path of the sexual revolution, the end point of which is total fluidity and freedom of identity and attraction. It gets kids thinking sexy thoughts, which makes all the trans indoctrination into child grooming.
Charlie makes a good point:
Transgender <=> Transhuman
Opening kids' minds to the malleability of gender softens them up to the notion of the malleability of human nature itself.
Many have noticed the connection. Is that why transgenderism is being pushed so hard these days?
Quotes a post by T00323; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Things demonized, with no debate allowed:
1/6
Criticism of the 2020 election fraud
Covid policies generally
CRT in schools
Criticism of the trans movement esp. involving kids
Criticism of open immigration practices
Donald Trump
Even on the assumption that there is absolutely nothing wrong with trans women in women's sports, even if the person is legally permitted to change in the women's locker room, it is still incredibly rude that this person would use the women's locker room with others there.
OK, is dissociative disorder becoming a new protected and valued “identity,” on a par with trans (formerly “gender identity disorder”)? I’m not making the claim—I’m asking the question.