The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
I don’t object to any trans rights or preferences as long as they don’t detract from or trample over the rights of women. If that’s unhelpful then so be it.
She wasn’t a biological woman. She was a woman. And I’ve talked to plenty of trans guests over the years. We don’t put every interview on social media.
I’ve talked to numerous trans people and campaigners on all sides about this issue, on and off air. Interesting that you should assume someone who doesn’t agree with you is ignorant of the facts. How very predictable...
Yes she was, according to those same rules. She was excluding trans women, by this argument. Yet no trans activists complained. Only when it’s an opportunity to remove the word “woman”.
What was transphobic about my response? I don’t fear or hate trans people and I don’t mock or attack them either. What basis do you have for this slur?
I would love her and support her however she wanted to live her life. In your scenario she would be a trans man and therefore not an actual man. Because she was born female. Which makes her a woman. Do you see how this works?
That precisely what trans activists (note: not most trans people) are doing to women. They are claiming that being a woman is simply a state of mind not an actual biological reality. How’s that not delegitimising women’s very existence?
@[private account] I’m not stopping anyone find their happiness. Trans activists (who don’t represent trans people) are threatening the safety of women and girls with their unreasonable demands. That is likely to have an effect on *our* happiness. It costs them nothing to let us be safe & happy.
There is no medical consensus on this. As you well know. And it’s a very reasonable comparison which exposes the absurdity of this claim that a trans woman is an actual woman. Nothing to do with gay rights.
It’s already happened in women’s prisons in the UK where male prisoners have claimed to be trans and transferred to women’s prisons and sexually assaulted female inmates. Cases have gone to court. You really should know more about this stuff before you spout your nonsense.
No, self ID for trans people would enable male sexual predators to pretend to be trans to access women’s safe spaces. That is also a risk for trans women too.
Gosh, that’s a stretch, isn’t it? I’m simply pointing out the absurdity of demanding that everyone else pretends to believe that a man is actually a woman, not a trans woman, or a woman is actually a man, not a trans man. How is that mocking trans people?
I have never mocked or derided trans people. Never have, never will. But accepting, even welcoming, trans people is not the same as being required to pretend a trans woman is an actual woman.
@[private account] I’m not remotely offended by trans people. I want everyone to live their best life. But welcoming people who feel/choose they’re the opposite sex shouldn’t require everyone else to pretend to believe they actually ARE the opposite sex. Trans men menstruate cos they’re born women
No they don’t. I’m very happy for trans people to live their lives as they choose. No issue with this at all. But trans rights shouldn’t be allowed to take away from women’s rights (safe spaces, sport etc) or their existence as something real & tangible, not a mere state of mind.
Yep, mine survives too. But trans men need sanitary pads because, despite choosing to live as men (which they are perfectly free to do) they are nevertheless born as women. Pretending men can menstruate is nonsense. Pretending women only exist in people’s minds is nonsense too.
@[private account] @[private account] On the contrary, my concern about self-ID has always been pervert men exploiting trans rights to pretend to be trans women to gain access to victims. Not an attack on genuine trans people at all.
Oh, right. Okaaaaay. So when you say “Kill all terfs”, you mean the exact opposite of that? Uh huh.
For the uninitiated, TERF stands for “trans-exclusionary radical feminist” but is simply a term of abuse for any woman standing up for the right to safe women-only spaces.
@AyoCaesar Only just seen your (deleted?) reply. That’s EXACTLY why the proposal puts girls and women at risk! Predator men (not genuine transgender people) can exploit the GRA to claim to be trans women to gain access to women only spaces. They’re already doing it in prisons.
No they don’t. Gay rights didn’t take away any rights from straight people. The trans rights currently being demanded directly take away some key rights of women and girls. Very different.