The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
‘Freedom of Information Requests revealed health board paid Trans Aid Cymru £2,400 to deliver ‘bespoke training sessions’ and handed over cash for programmes including a ‘trans inclusion session’ and a ‘male menopause’ event’ https://www.abergavennychronicle.com/news/health-board-blasted-for-woke-spending-on-transgender-training-and-solar-panels-at-ae-851593
Wow - Sue Evans reveals details of her exchanges with the BBC
‘BBC ‘infiltrated by trans activists’, Tavistock whistleblower claims’
‘Woman who exposed clinic’s use of puberty blockers on children claims corporation shut down gender-critical viewpoints’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/11/15/tavistock-clinic-whistleblower-bbc-trans-activists/
Some leaks from the staff network a:gender too
‘One source said: ‘The civil service is slashing jobs in critical areas but still using taxpayers’ money to pay a bunch of activists to run wild and push their political views instead of doing their jobs’
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/womens-rights-anti-trans-single-sex-wp0dd0w9x
This ‘warning’ came from *the Cabinet Office itself*, passed on from a ‘third party’
It described the November 1 protest over the failure of institutions to implement the Supreme Court ruling as ‘anti-transgender rights’
Fearsome capture
@thetimes
/
Everybody understands sex is real: that men aren’t women and vice versa.
It’s why those execs and editors listen to trans-identified men and do what they say, rather than listening to women. They know this too.
There’s a problem with ‘case by case’ in journalism too. It must be one rule for all - otherwise editors are relying on frontline staff to make decisions about whether people are ‘truly trans’. Just as with wards, prisons, toilets. Blanket rules are necessary.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: Gift link, paywall free
‘Why is Labour backtracking on single-sex spaces l?’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/173726f162df4c74
Classic failure of neutrality.
Consulting ‘experts on trans issues’ is seen as impartial while speaking to experts on the other side is seen as biased and inappropriate.
Clear refusal to acknowledge or even see that there’s a bias in giving ‘expert’ status to trans campaigners.
‘Hidalgo (Director of Children’s) insisted that while it was ‘vital’ for the BBC to hear from experts on trans issues it would be ‘inappropriate’ for her to ‘meet with any specific group on any side of this debate’
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/media/article/bbc-trans-ideology-childrens-programmes-chq292hfz
‘Stephanie Davies-Arai, director of Transgender Trend, said: “Taking the non-scientific, politically controversial idea of ‘gender identity’ and selling it to children as fact is not impartiality but indoctrination’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/11/14/bbc-indoctrinating-children-pro-trans-agenda/
Reposting, because it’s a shame. Deb Cohen has no idea how much she was shielded, and probably how much activists will likely be happy to exploit her now.
But she did wonderful important work on the Tavistock, and no one can walk that back.
/ https://www.theguardian.com/media/2025/nov/13/reporter-deborah-cohen-questions-claim-bbc-bias-trans-issues
Great example from @SkyNews
All you have to do is replace ‘trans women’ with ‘men’ and it’s an entirely different convo. No, they aren’t the most marginalised: no, it’s obviously not discriminatory or disproportionate.
Give over @[private account] and @[private account] ! Choose accuracy
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: Please don’t forget that the BBC is not the only outlet guilty of institutional bias on sex and gender. All broadcast outlets affirm identity as a matter of course. The only exception is GB News, but it also does use the lexicon of identity (trans woman etc)
It is convenient for other outlets to focus on every flaw except the one of which they too are guilty: inaccuracy and capture by gender identity activism.
Most press outlets adopt a similar framing: they all reported the IOC potential ban on all men in female sport as a type of woman being banned. That’s a very different conversation than banning men. That framing meaning that justification is required for ‘exclusion’.
The BBC has a greater responsibility to get it right. But it is not alone, and it never has been.
She she she
It’s untrustworthy @DailyMail
‘Gender row boxer Imane Khelif breaks silence to tease 'surprises'’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/boxing/article-15287703/Gender-row-boxer-Imane-Khelif-breaks-silence-tease-surprises-announce-plan-defend-Olympic-gold-despite-sex-tests-IOC-set-ban-transgender-athletes.html?ito=native_share_article-nativemenubutton
‘'We want a change in policy!' Darlington Nurses demand apology from NHS trust after 'traumatic' ordeal with trans colleague’ https://www.gbnews.com/news/darlington-nurses-demand-apology-nhs-trust-traumatic-ordeal-trans-colleague
‘Biological men still in HMP Downview women’s jail despite trans ruling
The Ministry of Justice has no plans to move the five prisoners six months after the Supreme Court ruling requiring single-sex institutions’
@thetimes https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/biological-men-still-in-hmp-downview-womens-jail-despite-trans-ruling-6r25bncws
‘University updates trans-inclusive advice to museums as FITA threatens litigation’
‘Freedom in the Arts has demanded the University of Leicester take down advice to museums and galleries on LGBTQ+ inclusivity’ https://www.artsprofessional.co.uk/news/university-updates-trans-inclusive-advice-to-museums-as-fita-threatens-litigation
Please don’t forget that the BBC is not the only outlet guilty of institutional bias on sex and gender. All broadcast outlets affirm identity as a matter of course. The only exception is GB News, but it also does use the lexicon of identity (trans woman etc)
It is convenient for other outlets to focus on every flaw except the one of which they too are guilty: inaccuracy and capture by gender identity activism.
Most press outlets adopt a similar framing: they all reported the IOC potential ban on all men in female sport as a type of woman being banned. That’s a very different conversation than banning men. That framing meaning that justification is required for ‘exclusion’.
The BBC has a greater responsibility to get it right. But it is not alone, and it never has been.
This is the BBC’s ‘out’ on trans: it was never originally intended to provide a shield for inaccuracy but that’s what’s happened.
https://downloads.bbc.co.uk/bbctrust/assets/files/pdf/about/how_we_govern/updated-framework-agreement-may-2022.pdf
‘The same rot runs through mainstream media across the world. In Ireland, I’ve met too many well-paid figures at RTÉ, the Irish Times and the Irish Independent who seem proud of their refusal to touch anything remotely controversial’
@stellaomalley3 https://www.spiked-online.com/2025/11/11/the-trans-reckoning-has-arrived/
‘Lucy Zelic has campaigned to protect women's sport for years. She's overjoyed that trans athletes look set to be banned from the Olympics’
Nice feature with @[private account] https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/olympics/article-15279015/Lucy-Zelic-trans-athletes-transgender-ban-Olympics-Los-Angeles-2028-IOC.html
‘Trans mum who transitioned from male to female SUES expert for discrimination after being mocked online for breastfeeding her baby’
Not a mum, ‘his’ baby, didn’t transition to female, not breastfeeding
No tag but there’s an email for the reporter https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15274697/Jennifer-Buckley-Jasmine-Sussex-transgender-breastfeeding.html
It seems so obvious, to separate fact from opinion.
But some journos sincerely hold the belief ‘trans women are women’ so very strongly that they think it’s a fact.
If they do, they think it’s their *job* to bring it to work. They don’t even think they’re doing an activism.
‘The practical consequence is that the job of keeping the council legally compliant has fallen to ordinary Bristolians….Years of training and campaigning by trans-rights groups have left an institutional imprint’
https://thecritic.co.uk/a-council-of-despair/
@[private account] has massive digital reach but a profoundly limited view. This reads as a studied effort to convince people rather than reflect public understanding.
‘Trans shooters disinformation surges after Charlie Kirk's death. Some fear retribution’ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/09/20/charlie-kirk-death-transgender-disinformation/86161156007/
Third, the inaccuracy. This wasn’t a call to ‘block’ ‘trans women’ from diversity quotas and it’s a lie to say so.
@[private account] didn’t try to block the trans quota to the slightest degree
‘There was already a separate quota for trans identities, Dr Hollowood pointed out’
/
First here’s the contempt.
‘On suspicion of’ or ‘allegedly’ - it’s pretty basic.
Secondly, the entire story would be more properly framed: ‘Call for Lib Dems to protect female quotas’ rejected’
Or ‘Debate on excluding transgender males from women’s quotas blocked’
/
This is genuinely considered to be a neutral report. However, not only is it framed around trans rights, it’s inaccurate and it includes a contempt of court.
/
‘As court documents refer to Twiggs as a 'biological male', the Daily Mail has chosen to refer to him as such’
Fair, but unnecessary. The sky won’t fall if you do it anyway. Why not be accurate for the sake of it. https://archive.ph/2025.09.20-173309/https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15115217/tyler-robinson-charlie-kirk-transgender-roommate-relationship-evil.html
This is appalling. Even ‘maybe Robin really was trans’. Does have a clue what he’s talking about. ‘True trans’ is a stubborn belief in the media class.
‘Meanwhile the college is also coming under fire from pro-trans groups over a new policy which restricts research scholarships to biological women only’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/09/20/women-only-cambridge-college-equality-law-unisex-lavatories/
Making clear @AllianceLGB is still a separate entity. @[private account] is a new trans-national affiliated organisation.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: ‘We are launching this because the organisations that once represented gay people are now entirely devoted to ‘gender identity ideology’
‘LGB Alliance relaunches as LGB International’
It aims to reverse the drop in public support for LGB because of the association with TQ.
/
The @guardian doesn’t verify 100,000
‘..the need to defend LGBTQI+ rights, which are increasingly under threat around the world..’
Depressing piece. A sentence like this is never written about the comprehensive loss of women’s rights under self-ID. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2025/jul/26/tens-of-thousands-of-people-take-to-streets-for-london-trans-pride-2025
And yet the BBC, which covers every tiny Pride event across the country, and previous Trans Pride events, didn’t show up - whether these numbers are true or not
Is it because of images like these posters👇or the images of BBC staff waving a trans flag? Both are appalling optics
Quotes a post by A2843; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘The tribunal brought by Sandie Peggie against NHS Fife and trans doctor Beth Upton, who accused Peggie of bullying, offensive remarks and misgendering..will prove a tipping point in Scotland’s reclamation of sanity on the issue of single-sex spaces’
@thetimes
@[private account]
We would beg news outlets not to be over-selective about their images from today’s Trans+ Pride March. Make sure you give a broad flavour.
@Channel4News
Parents of trans teenager who killed himself sue 'slow and casual' police who failed to find him in time | Daily Mail Online https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14942595/Parents-trans-teenager-killed-sue-police-failed.html
This BBC fact check is insanely out of date. It’s the second hit on a search so it matters. Step up.
‘What does trans mean and what is the Cass Review?’ https://www.bbc.com/news/explainers-53154286
Couple sue police force at High Court over death of transgender teenager | Radio NewsHub https://www.radionewshub.com/articles/news-updates/Couple-sue-police-force-at-High-Court-over-death-of-transgender-teenager
Bergdorf told Women’s Marchers they should stop focussing on their bodies as the source of discrimination.
But this
‘After the ruling excluding trans women from the definition of a woman - it's more important than ever to be an ally’
is editorial from @DailyMirror itself
Another🤌🏼exclusive in @heraldscotland from @[private account]
‘Fiona Macdonald, who’s been a member of the PCS union for over 20 years, believes it’s been taken over by activists who support trans rights. She says they tried to destroy her life for her gender critical beliefs’
/
The new HL ‘Trans tribunal phone notes were not checked in person’ achieves two things. It not only misses the story, deflecting from Upton’s evidence, but crucially it makes it extremely boring.
It’s counter-productive for an outlet to do this - so why?
https://www.mailplus.co.uk/scottish-edition/news/418463/trans-doctor-tried-to-mislead-tribunal-over-phone-notes-on-peggie
Still astonishing that single sex spaces became illegal in Ireland, and no one thought it newsworthy except in celebratory terms.
https://www.lewissilkin.com/en-ie/insights/2025/07/25/protections-for-transgender-employees-from-discrimination-what-is-the-law-in-ireland
/
‘Having any policy in place in Ireland which sets out that trans individuals are expected to use the toilet or changing facility which corresponds to their biological sex is highly likely to be determined discriminatory on gender grounds’
@[private account]
/
We just posted a link to the whole programme yesterday but here is the standalone clip, and it is definitely worth six minutes of your time.
https://www.channel4.com/news/more-important-than-its-ever-been-why-trans-pride-matters
‘Don’t let Newsom’s strategic shift fool you’
It’s paywalled but here are some SS. It’s long, lots more within, by @[private account]
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14572945/transgender-hollywood-stars-children-JILLIAN-MICHAELS.html
She’s right: Dems have been voting across the states to double down on sport, surgeries, hormones and affirmation.
Not actually about Hollywood parents. It’s on the ‘trans reckoning’ for the Dems and a warning that it’s a political tactic, not a moral awakening.
‘The message to parents is loud and clear: your role is optional, your voice is disposable and your children are political pawns’
Here are the stories being ignored by the BBC’s global outlets while it reports on transgender mosques. The real, lived experiences of women living under self-ID. Reminder: uniquely among UK outlets, it has a Global Gender and Identity Correspondent.
Quotes a post by A1855; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Updated overnight
‘Universities review trans policies after Sussex Uni's record £585,000 fine for failing to uphold free speech as feminist academic was 'hounded out' by activists’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14573427/universities-review-transgender-policies-free-speech-failures.html
‘Blossom, a transgender female, accused Dr Phil of insinuating that transgender females were men’
What a ridiculous sentence. The ‘female’, the ‘she’, the failure to explain that they are in fact men. What a degradation of journalism. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14572969/trans-activist-dr-phil-female-athletes-blossom.html
Good journalism is worth paying for but a couple of screenshots here
Claire Methven O’Brien is @[private account]
https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/25062581.watchdog-pressed-review-transgender-prisoner-policy/
Exclusive from @[private account]
‘Watchdog pressed to review transgender prisoner policy’
‘The call follows concerns raised by one of the SHRC’s own commissioners who questioned whether the policy is compatible with UN human rights standards’
Link next
@NursingTimes has been reluctant on the sex and gender issue so this is good to see. It highlights the religious connection four times more than is strictly necessary but apart from that.
‘Darlington nurses: trans changing room tribunal adjourned’ https://www.nursingtimes.net/policies-and-guidance/darlington-nurses-trans-changing-room-tribunal-adjourned-03-04-2025/
‘Transgender student's arrest for violating Florida bathroom law is thought to be a first’
Small sample of a great deal more coverage since we first highlighted yesterday, so it looks likely to be a case where both sides will want a precedent outcome https://www.independent.co.uk/news/florida-laws-tallahassee-utah-people-b2727094.html
Ollie’s also been in touch with heavily pro-trans Damien Lehfeldt - an ‘At-Large’ Director on the USA Fencing Board of Directors. Hope he enjoys the attention.
Story started with @icons_women 🙌 after Stephanie wisely ensured her stand was videoed.
SAY MALE
‘Fencer disqualified for refusal to compete against transgender opponent’
This is unconscionable https://www.bbc.com/sport/fencing/articles/cpdzv76gl49o
Very important point around language.
Stop saying ‘balance between fairness and inclusion’
‘Inclusion’ is inaccurate. More people are excluded than included.
‘Trans’ and ‘inclusion’ are the most misused words ever.
Quotes a post by A2676; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘Are you aware that there are cases in the courts about women objecting to trans-identified men using women's spaces’
‘I’m not aware’
Incredible. Somebody’s not doing their job.
Quotes a post by A2920; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Incredibly rare follow up of a ‘trans child’ feature. Never seen one.
‘If I'd had hormones, I think I would have thought, 'S***, I'm in too deep, I can't de-transition now', and felt stuck,' she says candidly’
Link and screenshots will follow
By @[private account]
@MailOnline
Absolutely mystifying how these activist outlets have not bored themselves into vapour after decades of this kind of content
‘Trans Day of Visibility: Where do we go from here?’ https://www.advocate.com/voices/trans-lives-matter
MP Chris Ward said ‘Trans people are among the most persecuted and least appreciated people in society’ and is still banned from Brighton Trans Pride
Wonder if this @[private account] reporter would have liked to delve a bit further https://www.theargus.co.uk/news/25055430.trans-pride-brighton-ban-labour-mps-peter-kyle-chris-ward/
Share token
‘Jail doctors who perform trans surgery on young people, says feminist activist’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/04/02/jail-doctors-trans-surgery-young-people-says-helen-joyce-uk/
It’s exactly the same problem here.
The nurses don’t care that he’s trans. They’re not transphobic. They object because he’s a man.
‘Nurses taking trust to tribunal over trans colleague’s use of changing rooms at Darlington hospital’ @itvnews https://www.itv.com/news/tyne-tees/2025-04-02/nurses-take-trust-to-tribunal-over-trans-colleagues-use-of-changing-rooms
Just to say the rest of SiJ is rightly dismayed and frustrated that the BBC is continuing to imply that the nurses are transphobic with the trans framing instead of male. Today’s tweeter 😳 hasn’t reflected that.
The report is fine but the HL and tweet are wrong. Tell the BBC.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: Dislike ‘trans’ instead of male. BUT two things
* they did the story - no mean feat
* ‘male’ in the 3rd par. The convention is to get the most important info in the top four. Normally you need an archaeology degree to find the buried fact of ‘male’. So on the whole it’s 👍
It finally happened - this was, astonishingly, Helen Joyce’s first litfest event since the publication of ‘Trans’. A testament to the power of persistence
Some noisy protesters but nothing was interrupted
Well done @HJoyceGender @bindelj @[private account]
Dislike ‘trans’ instead of male. BUT two things
* they did the story - no mean feat
* ‘male’ in the 3rd par. The convention is to get the most important info in the top four. Normally you need an archaeology degree to find the buried fact of ‘male’. So on the whole it’s 👍
Quoting @BBCNews: Staff object to trans nurse using changing rooms https://bbc.in/4cyCDrr
They don’t care one teeny, tiny bit about his being trans. They aren’t even interested. They care *only* that he’s male.
Saying they object to ‘trans’ is deliberating framing it as ‘transphobic’
Quoting @BBCNews: Staff object to trans nurse using changing rooms https://bbc.in/4cyCDrr
Accurately describing a person’s sex could become illegal in Colorado
‘Colorado Democrats roll out bill to consider 'misgendering' discriminatory
@[private account] https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/campaigns/state/3366504/colorado-democrats-transgender-bill-courts-misgender-discriminatory/
‘California lawmakers reject bills to ban trans athletes' participation in girls sports’
@AP
Inaccurate (untrue) headline which nevertheless unwittingly acknowledges that ‘trans women’ are men https://apnews.com/article/california-transgender-athlete-newsom-students-ban-bc295b65ce04e5f8df7792545263f393
There’s a claim in here rather like the one we saw in the US by Chase Strangio that giving HRT to menopausal women but not men could be illegal.
But no attempt to seek clarity in the law or to explain the adverse outcomes of cross-sex hormones.
https://www.thestar.co.uk/health/sheffield-gp-surgery-stops-hormone-therapy-for-transgender-patients-5060764
Would love to see ‘was born male’ by ‘is male’ across the board
But, step by step
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14560463/Trans-row-NHS-board-face-unlimited-fines-enforcement-equalities-watchdog.html
‘Trans protester arrested after washing her hands in a women’s bathroom’
First man arrested for breaking Florida’s law by going into Capitol women’s toilet
‘Trans people have been using restrooms aligned with their gender for generations’
@Independent https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/trans-protester-florida-capitol-arrested-bathroom-law-b2725490.html
The BBC’s global platforms have a heightened and undue interest in stories about trans-identified men. For context on India, here’s the background of the much more newsworthy issue of discrimination and male violence against women and girls there.
https://data.unwomen.org/country/india
Quoting @BBCNews: 'My Indian mum was willing to lose everything to support my trans identity' https://bbc.in/4cjhr8I
Legal expert Joshua Rosenberg on the postponement of Sentencing Council guidelines which included transgender people as especially needing a pre-sentencing report
Link next
Again, Freedom of Information requests. Vital tool. All public bodies need to be prepared.
‘Health board's 16 complaints about transgender people using NHS single sex toilets’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14550365/Health-boards-16-complaints-transgender-people-using-NHS-single-sex-toilets.html
‘Transgender people are about 1% of the US population. Yet they're a political lightning rod’
…of their own making. Always left unsaid.
@Independent https://www.independent.co.uk/news/donald-trump-transgender-republicans-gavin-newsom-fordham-university-b2723984.html
‘Activist group that helped create prison trans rules gets £500k of public money’
Well done Mail on Sunday
There’s so much more to find out https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14550411/Activist-group-helped-create-prison-trans-rules-gets-500k-public-money.html
‘When the BBC looked at similar trans equality policies at a number of universities it wasn't entirely clear whether they would be considered a challenge to free speech’
It’s pursuing this in a way it didn’t follow up Peggie or other big gender stories that sprouted many heads
Quotes a post by A3205; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There are truths in here but they’re undermined by @[private account] commitment to gender identity.
For eg: there’s now much more coverage of sex-based rights - but it’s always framed around ‘trans’.
‘Coverage of women: The world is stalling’ https://www.journalism.co.uk/news/coverage-of-women-america-is-failing-the-world-is-stalling/s2/a1231464/
‘Moment Brianna Ghey's evil killers tell police pack of lies in unseen interview after brutally stabbing trans schoolgirl to death in frenzied hunting knife attack’
@mailonline https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14542305/moment-Brianna-Ghey-killers-police-lies-stab-trans-girl.html
‘Exclusive: @[private account] admitted it doesn't have specific guidance on single-sex toilets, but DOES insist on following trans guidance which states that 'trans staff should choose to use the facilities they feel most comfortable’
@[private account] https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/snp-government-doubles-down-letting-34938842
Fact check
: there are plenty of people who suffer ‘gender dysphoria’ who are not in fact trans
: there are some activists who say you don’t have to have gender dysphoria to be trans
: self-ID campaigners want any requirement for a diagnosis of dysphoria to be removed
This is the @[private account] Guide published 18 months ago. It’s a wild read and a great haggle.
https://www.tgeu.org/files/uploads/2023/11/TGEU-Trans-Media-Guide-EN.pdf
The price demanded is set so high that outlets who ‘merely’ adopt self-ID think they’ve got a great deal. When in fact they’ve given activists just what they wanted.
Quotes a post by T09145; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Updated overnight
‘Figure of 262,000 transgender people in England and Wales in the latest census was wrong, ONS finally admits’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14541091/262-000-transgender-people-England-Wales-census-wrong-ONS-admits.html
‘All persons with gender dysphoria are trans and only trans persons experience gender dysphoria’
These cases will really drill down into the Shroedinger’s Cat of transgender status. It’s a medical condition until it’s not a medical condition.
@mailonline https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14541641/Ana-Reyes-Trump-transgender-ban.html
Goes to the OfS. See Levi Pay. However we think it then goes back to the Treasury, while Levi suggests it can be disbursed by the OfS themselves - important because they also fund a trans activist student campaign group.
Hard to know what happened between piece and headline - an activist sub, or rage bait?
Once again - trans athletes can play, they aren’t forced out or stamped out. Just not in the opposite sex category.
Here’s the piece, which is nicely put together.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/othersports/article-14534459/Lord-Coe-confirms-female-athletes-undergo-swab-tests.html
Late with this: share token. NHS Tayside.
‘Bearded trans women can be treated on female wards’
‘It says that trans people should be sent to wards that match their ‘presentation’ – a term defined as ‘the way they dress, the name and pronouns they use’ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/03/25/bearded-trans-women-treated-female-wards-scottish-nhs/
Updated this morning with more reax in @MailOnline
‘University is fined £585,000 for failing to uphold free speech after feminist professor Kathleen Stock was hounded out of work by trans activists’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14537659/university-fined-585-000-free-speech-kathleen-stock.html
‘That’s if they make it onto television at all. Trans people have been debated so intensely daily, but rarely actually given the platform to speak up’
So detached from reality.
Lorraine Kelly: 'It's my duty to stand up for trans people' https://metro.co.uk/2025/03/26/lorraine-kelly-its-duty-stand-trans-people-22792018/
'The secret pain of trans widows'
An interview with documentary maker Vaishnavi Sundar @[private account] by @[private account]
https://szegounplugged.substack.com/p/the-secret-pain-of-trans-widows?utm_source=podcast-email%2Csubstack&publication_id=1704013&post_id=159399433&utm_campaign=email-play-on-substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=play_card&r=3lemhw&triedRedirect=true
'We make up less than 1% of the population, all we want to do is be happy'
‘Trans ppl are tiny in number’ again
You’d think this might one day make one local journalist notice that if that figure is true, the power wielded is entirely disproportionate https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/whats-on/whats-on-news/we-make-up-less-1-31277245
In contrast - we’re also seeing more of this
https://www.foxnews.com/media/from-trans-man-traditional-mother-how-one-woman-broke-free-from-ideological-chains-after-finding-christ
‘Get a grip’
‘Streeting made the comments when responding to an Instagram post which attacked the government’s recent policies affecting trans and disabled people’
@PinkNews
Authored comment by @[private account] in @GBNEWS picked up by MSN
‘I asked Labour's First Minister to define a woman - her response has real consequences’ https://www.gbnews.com/opinion/labour-wales-senedd-woman-trans
‘Queer Black Mirror star Kadiff Kirwan cast in Doctor Who episode written by trans author Juno Dawson’
It just sounds so boring https://uk.news.yahoo.com/queer-black-mirror-star-kadiff-133800515.html
‘There are possible biological explanations, too’
@[private account]
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-14531793/shocking-experiences-autistic-young-women-real-reason-trans-non-binary-neuroscientist.html
‘Eastwood has spoken out about degrading conditions in hospital’
The common thread is the friend’ contact who keeps phoning up the paper
Some of its stories are less affirmative but it still dutifully pronoun defers to this unstable man
https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/transgender-killer-34289559
Moved to women’s jail, ‘shock’ decision ‘flies in the face of prison service policy’
Aug 2023
https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/controversial-scot-trans-prisoner-moved-30623928
‘Eastwood has demanded that prison officers hold her hand when she is escorted from her cell. It’s understood that prison bosses are treating the demands seriously and considering which protocols might be established in dealing with the inmate’
April 22
https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/trans-murderer-prison-identify-baby-26669658
This is so important from documentary journalist Malcolm Clark @TwisterFilm
Fetish is taboo in editorial conversations about trans-identification. It needs to be fully acknowledged as a potential driver, and normalised as discussion topic.
Quoting @TwisterFilm: 1./ 🧵The Sissy Fantasy. My latest article asks why the mainstream media was so shocked by Sam Rockwell's monologue in White Lotus? Did defenders of the trans agenda not realise his love of sissification is the erotic core of most trans identification in men?
Click on the link in my bio to read the full story. 👆👆👆
Trans Media Watch had good contacts but wasn’t as influential as AAT. BBC diversity was pretty tied in with activism generally, in the late 20-teens, but in the early 20-teens it was AAT that changed the BBC’s direction.
The BBC may be regretting the cost, the timing, the message it sends, but it’s not as if they weren’t warned. Women and LGB people warned them.
Paris Lees was a leading member of All About Trans, the outfit that persuaded BBC drama commissioners to buy more affirmative content.
A very long time in the making after the commission was announced - so much so that we contacted the BBC earlier this year to find out what happened to it
It follows a long BBC tradition of obeisance at the altar of the trans-identified personal journey. https://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/2025/what-it-feels-like-for-a-girl-first-look-cast#:~:text=What%20It%20Feels%20Like%20For%20A%20Girl%20is%20a%20raw,a%20whole%20world%20to%20explore.
Now in @[private account]
‘Nurse Punished for Saying ‘Mr’ to Transgender Paedophile’ https://europeanconservative.com/articles/news/nurse-punished-transgender-nhs-paedophile-row/
Implicitly blaming ‘transphobia’ and bullying when police rule it out has real world consequences.
Policies are built on the premise that people who identify as trans are driven to their deaths by ‘transphobia’ when in reality there are frequently, if not often, co-morbidities.
Implicitly blaming ‘transphobia’ and bullying when police rule it out has real world consequences.
Policies are built on the premise that people who identify as trans are driven to their deaths by ‘transphobia’ when in reality there are frequently, if not often, co-morbidities.
This is where it comes from
http://www.ansa.it/english/news/general_news/2025/03/24/instigation-to-suicide-probe-opened-for-trans-tiktoker_7c296bb6-e4a0-4ee0-9e8d-75e3e50666a5.html
The headline is misleading.
‘But police said the probe was not directly related to the messages he received on social media’
Very irresponsible @MailOnline
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: ‘Italian TikToker, 21, who came out as a trans woman before identifying as non-binary shoots himself dead after 'cyberbullying campaign'’
@MailOnline https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14531117/Italian-TikToker-trans-woman-non-binary-shoots-dead-cyberbullying.html
‘Italian TikToker, 21, who came out as a trans woman before identifying as non-binary shoots himself dead after 'cyberbullying campaign'’
@MailOnline https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14531117/Italian-TikToker-trans-woman-non-binary-shoots-dead-cyberbullying.html
More on Paris Green
@telegraph picks it up
As previous: it will be news to many that men are still being held on women’s wings
‘Scottish trans killer charged with attacking female prison guard in women’s wing’ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/03/24/scottish-trans-killer-charged-attacking-female-prison-guard/
Really strong column here - @[private account] is an Australian news app that’s just a year old
‘JENI O’DOWD: Transgender women playing in female soccer is woke insanity and downright dangerous’ https://thenightly.com.au/opinion/jeni-odowd-transgender-women-playing-in-female-soccer-is-woke-insanity-and-downright-dangerous--c-18139745
‘Christian Nurse Sues NHS After Punishment for Calling Transgender Paedophile 'Mister'’
Coverage in the IB Times is great. Not on the front page but clicks and scrolling will give it a bump. https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/christian-nurse-sues-nhs-after-punishment-calling-transgender-paedophile-mister-1732078
‘Trans sex offender who took 800 'voyeuristic' pictures of men in Aldi toilets jailed’
https://www.gbnews.com/news/trans-sex-offender-pictures-men-toilets-aldi-jailed
Link got lost
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/transgender-scottish-prison-service-officer-women-visitors-intimate-searches-fzgrggt0r
We haven’t posted an archive, there may be one in replies
Christian Concern @[private account] has some great writers
https://christianconcern.com/news/nurse-punished-for-calling-convicted-transgender-male-mr/
‘Smith raped eight women, tried to murder his pregnant ex-girlfriend with garden shears and indecently assaulted a five-year-old’
Demands blending make up and surgery
He’s in Barlinnie
@[private account] https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/14534557/trans-rapist-make-up-demands-barlinnie/
They take the position that the reality of sex is a belief system in the same way that gender identity is a belief system.
But: the defence of a journalist accused of breaching impartiality by saying ‘trans women are men’ would be that it is true.
/
Very distressing story in @thetimes by Jeremy Watson
Source @[private account]
Welcome the story, would like to see ‘male’ instead of ‘trans’. ‘Trans’ is why men say that want to search women - ‘male’ is why women don’t want to be searched by them.
Link next
A potential problem with GC employment cases and broadcasters?
UK broadcasters are required by a state regulator (Ofcom) to be impartial. Most take the approach that this means not taking sides on whether ‘trans women are women’.
/
Some are just one or two people. Same with the BBC. They had Global Butterflies in for training, just two men claiming to be women who turned their hobby *cough* into a job. Premise: if you’re trans you’re an expert. Only in being trans - but that’s good enough for paid workshops
‘Transgender athlete faces backlash after winning 400m race by almost 10 seconds’
@[private account] this is crazy misleading https://www.express.co.uk/sport/othersport/2031163/Transgender-athlete-Aayden-Ada-Gallagher-Oregon
This is an archive link because this piece deserves no clicks. Appalling.
https://archive.ph/2025.03.23-140352/https://www.huffpost.com/entry/trump-hitler-lgbtq-transgender-government-websites-erased_n_67ddf235e4b0c549954933c5
Also Paris Green in @telegraph being castrated on the NHS after his imprisonment. Calls him ‘she’ and ‘her’
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/11/19/trans-murderer-serving-life-will-receive-80k-gender-reassignment/
Quotes from Susan Smith of @ForWomenScot
Most people will think this doesn’t happen any more and that the problem has been sorted out after the Isla Bryson controversy. Not the case.
Thanks for covering, Daily Record
https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/trans-killers-jail-rammy-leaves-34912548
‘A trans killer has admitted culpable and reckless conduct after a female member of staff was injured at the women’s wing of a Scottish prison’
This is Paris Green - held on the women’s wing
@[private account]
‘Their Kids Said They Were Trans. Then CPS Came Knocking’
@reason magazine is meant to be outside the echo chamber https://reason.com/2025/03/22/their-kids-said-they-were-trans-then-cps-came-knocking/
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14526813/nurse-Jennifer-Melle-racism-transgender-paedophile-sex-offender-NHS.html
See also @[private account] and @[private account] for more details
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedchild predatorcrime case
‘You can’t start the conversation in spaces where the facts can’t be articulated at all, where complaints, potential disciplinary actions, and fear of being career-blacklisted hover in the air’
For more on the BBC’s history with All About Trans
We often complain about a framing that leans to trans rights over women’s rights, but this is one of the worst, because reporter Oriana Gonzalez considers this a moderate approach. It’s staggering.
‘Why gender ideology could have ‘fatal consequences’ for trans people’
‘It’s official - sex matters’
@TheScotsman https://www.scotsman.com/news/opinion/columnists/why-gender-ideology-could-have-fatal-consequences-for-trans-people-5044754
‘NHS banned from changing trans children's gender on medical records’
Bit late but very fair from the Standard, except there are no ‘trans children’ https://www.standard.co.uk/news/politics/trans-children-nhs-ban-changing-gender-medical-records-b1217886.html
Helen Belcher worked hard to turn regular media towards affirmative activism with Trans Media Watch. He has a column in @BylineTimes misrepresenting the Sullivan Review. https://bylinetimes.com/2025/03/21/the-sullivan-review-treats-trans-people-as-an-inconvenience-whose-experiences-can-be-dismissed-as-invalid/
‘One of Trump’s cabinet picks Dr Mehmet Oz is in doubt over his previous support for gender-affirming surgeries for transgender children’
(There’s no such thing as a trans kid and gender affirming surgeries is an activist term)
@Telegraph
Rob Harris did push on this issue in the news conf, great, but points off for describing Coe’s plan for women-only sport as ‘strident’
‘New IOC president must deal with Trump, Putin and transgender issue’
HL writers: It’s a women’s sport issue not trans https://news.sky.com/story/kirsty-coventry-after-her-historic-win-the-new-ioc-president-must-deal-with-trump-putin-and-transgender-issue-13332791
‘The league has been around since 2008 and competing under its current name since 2016, having rebranded from Rainy City Roller Girls to be more inclusive’
Few people know that the whole of Roller Derby was originally set up by and for women only. https://themeteor.org/2025/03/21/salford-based-sport-league-offers-an-inclusive-space-for-trans-and-non-binary-people/
‘In today’s increasingly hostile political climate, where trans rights are under constant threat, supporting trans charities and causes is more crucial than ever’
Elle joins Cosmo, Glamour and every other fashion magazine in chasing a male readership https://www.elle.com/uk/life-and-culture/culture/a64158638/trans-rights-charities/
‘Lib Dem trans row as members oppose leadership's support for making it easier to legally change gender - and back puberty blocker ban for U-18s’
@MailOnline https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14516529/Lib-Dem-trans-row-easier-legally-change-gender-puberty-blocker-ban.html
‘They’re lying to you’
Ironic, as the phrase ‘trans women’ is a lie when it refers, as it does in here, to men.
You’ll struggle mightily to find the word ‘men’ in this article. Just one, we think. But it’s all about men from beginning to end.
Yes it’s activism not journalism.
Quoting @Martina: They're lying to you about transgender women and girls in sports- this is about the most disingenuous piece, not to mention the flat out lies . Shame on USA Today for publishing this piece- this is not journalism …. https://ftw.usatoday.com/story/sports/2025/03/13/transgender-lgbtq-rights-women-sports-ncaa-debate-trump-tuberville-lies/82331359007/
‘Trans woman Chleo Sunter called ‘she’ in sex offence court hearing’
@Telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/03/20/trans-woman-called-she-sex-offence-court-teesside/
Text changed to include ‘trans’ but still says this man is a woman.
https://www.surrey.police.uk/news/surrey/news/2025/03---march/can-you-help-us-find-skyla-stone/
‘She placed particular emphasis on protecting female sport, backing a blanket ban of transgender women from competing in female Olympic sport’
She didn’t, until Coe forced her into it.
Favoured candidate of Thomas ‘passport sex’ Bach
Say MALE https://www.bbc.com/sport/olympics/articles/cy4v91e3e1wo
Thank you @[private account] for working hard to get this guest on air and online.
Your editors were wrong to say it needed another balancing guest - the BBC has historically defended stand alone ‘lived experiences’ of trans people by saying there’s balance over time and platforms.
They also talk to a trans-identified man (‘trans joy’ etc) AND ask the Rainbow Project for an interview (RP turned them down). That’s balance overkill, especially for a ‘lived experience’.
Must have been quite the battle for Chris to get this on
Justin Webb also raised this with other guests through the programme.
This is exactly the issue. It’s never just a ‘transgender people’ or ‘LGBT and Identity’ story. It’s across health, education, society, politics, policing, the entire justice system. Every specialist journalist needs to be across the law in this.
Here is is. It leads off on the impact on trans people, and it uses the language of ‘transitioning to a man/woman’ - but stating that no one changes sex is one to bookmark.
There’ll be dozens of complaints. Phone or email with an appreciation if you can.
She actually says ‘biological males’ - don’t change women’s words.
‘Radio star Lucy Zelic says controversial women's soccer team that fields trans players should be BANNED from competition after shock development’
‘White House says it will halt funds to UPenn over trans athlete’
Filled with inaccuracies
Every times it means men or male, it says trans, or women, thus making opposition look transphobic rather than rational and justified https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c8712p5y48do
‘When asked if he was concerned that many members of the trans community might take offence’
It’s not possible to be more in a bubble than asking this of a medicalised detransitioner
Ascribe sex realism to religion ✅
Ask a detransitioner if he’s offending trans people ✅
Make up for the crime of platforming a detransitioner by doubling down with:
a happy trans XY✅
complaints about access to medicalisation ✅
heavy quotes from an activist group ✅
ILGA is the International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association.
It is gender identity affirmative, and its EU arm has ‘explicitly urged politicians to keep their activities out of the public eye whenever necessary’.
@unherd
Quoting @jo_bartosch: On the €221m given by the EU to promote trans extremism. ‘ILGA-Europe has explicitly urged politicians to keep their activities “out of the public eye whenever necessary”. https://unherd.com/newsroom/why-is-the-eu-funding-the-gender-lobby/
Apart from the ‘bizarre comments’ part, this is quite balanced from @PinkNews
‘Tory MP likens trans acceptance to saying ‘two plus two equals five’ https://www.thepinknews.com/2024/03/20/nick-fletcher-conservative-mp-lgbtq-trans-debate-sex-ed/
/the claim comes from the Green Party after the debate on single sex spaces last week.
@[private account] is quoted
‘We feel unsafe’ is everywhere again. The claim has historically led to special treatment from the media behind the scenes as well as in copy
https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/25018618.tories-greens-clash-trans-exclusionary-language/
@heraldscotland on a request for ‘more support’ to LGBTQ+ staff ‘whose welfare may be negatively impacted by any increase in the use of language in the Chamber and committees that may be perceived as trans-exclusionary’
@[private account] asked for examples. None are given but
/
There's been plenty of reax from sportswomen but @mailonline just goes for Piers Morgan along with 'assigned female at birth'
'Rapinoe slams 'depraved' Trump over trans executive order'
Nonsense language, and the order was about women
https://mol.im/a/14510787 via @[private account]
Sharron Davies @sharrond62 on @[private account] as it covers the story from Jersey over the weekend on baby pronouns
https://www.gbnews.com/news/us/trans-outrage-hospitals-new-jersey-pronouns
More on Amy Hamm @preta_6 in @nationalpost
‘Criticize trans activists at your professional peril’ https://nationalpost.com/opinion/jamie-sarkonak-criticize-transgender-activists-at-your-professional-peril
‘This charter represents a critical moment in the music industry, where we finally acknowledge the unique challenges faced by trans and non-binary individuals, and take tangible steps to change that’
Trans Charter for the music industry to launch in May’ https://musically.com/2025/03/18/trans-charter-for-the-music-industry-to-launch-in-may/
‘In that brief but compelling monologue, Frank has introduced viewers to one of the most controversial ideas in the cultural battle over all things trans: autogynephilia’
By @[private account] in @unherd https://unherd.com/newsroom/did-white-lotus-challenge-the-trans-narrative-on-autogynephilia/
This study was published today and reported in the @Independent
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/transgender-policy-trump-gender-affirming-care-b2716752.html
It has a four-year follow up.
‘Gender-Affirming Hormone Therapy and Depressive Symptoms Among Transgender Adults’ https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2831643
Keith Self, the congressman who accurately referred to Sarah McBride as ‘Mr’, has spoken to @NEWSMAX https://www.newsmax.com/newsmax-tv/congress-transgender-pronouns/2025/03/17/id/1203140/
Updated
‘Veterans Affairs officials announced Monday they will phase out all medical treatments for gender dysphoria, including hormone therapy and any surgical options for transgender veterans’
@[private account] https://www.militarytimes.com/veterans/2025/03/17/va-leaders-roll-back-policy-ensuring-medical-care-for-transgender-vets/
‘Trump and his allies purport that God created two genders, male and female, and any interpretations to the contrary violate the fundamental tenets of Christianity’
Opinion in @[private account] that could do with a fact check about the reality of sex
https://time.com/7267014/trumps-anti-trans-attacks-un-christian/
Story covered by @[private account] now with quotes from @[private account]
‘Watchdog ruling over girls in care sharing rooms with 'trans' children branded 'dangerously negligent'’ https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/scottish-news/watchdog-ruling-over-girls-care-34874729