The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Listen here from the top of the programme.
Recorded i/v with the Minister Mike Nesbitt and live i/v with Alexa Moore (trans male) from the Rainbow Project. Then public contributions.
Presenter @[private account] describes PBs as ‘healthcare’.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0022429?partner=uk.co.bbc&origin=share-mobile
Terrible lack of balance here.
Designates Susie Green/Mermaids as an appropriate voice, along with a trans-identified person (male ofc) from the Rainbow Project.
Imbalance in contributors including no voices of detransitioners, desisters or people harmed by blockers.
Quoting @BBCNews: Puberty blocker ban extended to Northern Ireland https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy3l8pnld9o?xtor=AL-72-%5Bpartner%5D-%5Bbbc.news.twitter%5D-%5Bheadline%5D-%5Bnews%5D-%5Bbizdev%5D-%5Bisapi%5D
This was in May
Byline @[private account]
Recently confirmed with studies published in @NursingTimes
https://www.nursingtimes.net/clinical-archive/continence/gender-affirming-continence-care-offering-dignity-to-all-patients-12-08-2024/
https://www.gbnews.com/news/trans-men-testosterone-menopause-incontinence
Highlighting two @GBNEWS stories previously missed by us
‘Trans community blasted for ‘crazy abuse’ of detransitioners’
From the US
@[private account]
@[private account] https://www.gbnews.com/news/us/trans-community-blasted-abuse-detransitioners-traitors
@GBNEWS One of the few outlets to explain the significance
‘The court..effectively sets a legal example which could be cited by signatories of the Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women’
‘Trans madness’ tag is inappropriate https://www.gbnews.com/news/world/trans-woman-australia-paid-thousands-compensation-judge-rules-sex-not-biological
Also: HL illustrates important point
‘Trans woman wins groundbreaking case after she was kicked off a female-only app’
More neutral language is shorter and more natural.
‘Transwoman wins groundbreaking case after being kicked off/losing access to’
But it has been rejected.
‘Trans woman wins groundbreaking 'what is a woman' case after she was kicked off a female-only app’
This is a mess, nothing is clear. Very difficult to understand, compounded by the use of ‘gender’ to mean at different times ‘sex’ and ‘gender identity’
/ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13771063/Transgender-woman-wins-groundbreaking-woman-case-kicked-female-app.html
Framed around trans rights, not women’s rights. Activist language.
‘Roxanne Tickle’s win in the federal court is a historic victory for transgender women’
https://theconversation.com/roxanne-tickles-win-in-the-federal-court-is-a-historic-victory-for-transgender-women-237309
If you don’t want to give clicks to atrociously biased journalism, please just check the screenshot.
We also included a comment from Australia’s Sex Discrimination Commissioner because it’s newsworthy.
https://www.aap.com.au/news/courts-landmark-trans-women-are-women-verdict-lauded/
This is appalling
‘The exclusion of a trans woman from a female-only social media app was unlawful, according to an Australian court’s landmark ruling that is likely to have far wider ramifications in the space of trans rights’
Zero interest in the impact on women’s rights
The @guardian absolutely buries the story. No front page spot, and ‘highlighted from global editions’ has the old penguin story instead.
Unnecessary use of affirmative language, no outline of its global significance.
Appropriate image of Tickle. https://www.theguardian.com/society/article/2024/aug/23/roxanne-tickle-v-giggle-for-girls-transgender-woman-wins-discrimination-case-against-women-female-only-app-ntwnfb
‘Roxanne Tickle gets $10K compension as judge rules 'Giggles for Girls' ban unlawful’
Efficient enough from Nine News
https://www.9news.com.au/national/transgender-rights-case-roxanne-tickle-giggles-for-girls-app-federal-court-to-rule/3a009180-237c-4051-91fd-c8b8127d775d
By here:
Even if someone says they are a *trf* you do not use it. Think of other slurs that minority groups might try to reclaim. Don’t use them.
No one lives as a woman unless she is a woman. Needs attribution.
‘Inclusion’ is a positive framing, and trans usually means male.
‘Trans woman's exclusion from female app was unlawful..Ms Tickle was required to have the appearance of a cisgender woman..court heard Ms Tickle has lived as a woman’
No hope for impartiality from Australia legacy media, after a court rules sex is mutable https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-08-23/nsw-sydney-giggle-transgender-discrimination-court-judgment/104260546
Here we see both LGB and LGBT.
2013 was the year transactivists made enormous inroads into the BBC. At the end of the year the style guide was changed to ‘trans inclusive’, and remains so to this day
This could have been written so differently. The real story is that a women’s dorm and bathroom is no longer for women, and that it’s claimed you can be prosecuted for saying so.
Instead this is framed as a ‘gotcha’
Suspect is agency copy, but no excuse https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13741591/hostelworld-lyons-alter-hostel-trans-paris-olympics.html
Accurate use of pronouns and descriptive language l
‘Men who identify as women’
‘Identify’ remains a woolly term but still @MailOnline makes good choices
‘Trans-Siberian Orchestra hit with complaint for making women change with trans roadie’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13761537/trans-siberian-orchestra-sued-transgender-coworker-changing-rooms.html
‘The Olympic dream of a trans woman’
‘Valentina Petrillo's first competition with non-disabled women, in Arezzo, October 2020’ - BBC News https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/stories-57338205
At least @MailOnline talks to a lawyer and a rival athlete, and references one athlete who lost a place.
But it’s flawed by affirmation and inaccuracy. Phrases like ‘was born male and transitioned’ are a waste of digital space. No one changes sex. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/paralympics/article-13760531/First-transgender-Paralympian-Paris-2024-role-model-Games.html?ito=native_share_article-nativemenubutton
Incomprehensible unless you’re familiar with activist delivery. No concern for girls: no balance: no concern for the boys’ health: no clarity that they are in fact boys.
‘Tentative deal could allow transgender girls to keep playing on girls’ sports teams’ https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/08/17/metro/transgender-trans-girls-student-athletes-sports-nh-lawsuit-state-law/?camp=bg:brief:rss:MSN&rss_id=MSN_rss_brief
Daily Mail doesn’t just report that it’s considered a slur by many people, it tells us it *is* a transphobic slur.
‘Fury as Blake Lively repeatedly refers to transgender people as trannies in resurfaced interviews | Daily Mail Online’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-13755441/Blake-Lively-slur-transgender.html
Comment
‘The credibility of the Paralympics is already in jeopardy. Wherever transgender people may be discriminated against, it is certainly not in sport’
By Julie Bindel https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/08/17/credibility-of-paralympics-already-in-jeopardy/
/to seize on pledges to criminalise misogyny, without using their platforms to explain that such a law would include some men, and so would likely disbenefit women.
Here’s the link to the strip search story exposed by @WomensRightsNet in 2022
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10703327/Women-strip-searched-trans-officers-born-male-say-police.html?ito=native_share_article-nativemenubutton
More screenshots.
Maggie Blyth, for example, was national lead for violence and girls when police chiefs recommended that women who object to being strip-searched by a trans-identified male could be recorded as committing a hate incident.
Affirmative outlets have been known /
More trans joy. The health-ravaging impacts of gender medicalisation are ignored in favour of ‘hat-wearing as non-conformity’. Refusal of contact with a parent, over a social media ‘like’, is normalised.
@guardian doesn’t have to be impartial
It does have to be responsible
‘For trans people, the pressure to placate or conform to a family who may not have your best interests at heart means putting up with micro and macro aggressions. Close to You suggests it is perfectly reasonable to opt out’
Again - irresponsible @guardian https://www.theguardian.com/film/article/2024/aug/16/i-get-misgendered-all-the-time-i-dont-care-elliot-page-on-his-return-to-acting-on-the-big-screen
That particular Supreme Court ruling said that discrimination for sexual orientation or ‘trans status’ (not gender identity) reasons was illegal - because it was always founded on sex discrimination.
Last year it did three stories on Zooey Zephry’s ban from Montana House of /
It’s by @[private account] , who previously wrote that the word woman ‘has become a flashpoint in the culture wars between conservative and transgender activists’.
The BBC’s US team has got it completely wrong on sex and gender before and seems incapable of a balanced approach. In /
‘US Supreme Court declines to lift block on expanded trans student protections’
BBC uses a framing wholly around ‘trans’ people and uses activist language. The impact on women is given no space. Unchallenged ‘far right’ descriptor for those with concerns. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ckg21x1j54mo
The basic premises of this were so flawed the programme couldn’t get off the ground
1 trans athletes aren’t banned
2 ‘inclusion’ is an inaccurate framing
3 there’s a debate about males in female categories. There isn’t, or shouldn’t be, any debate about whether they’re women
Quotes a post by T03805; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is not tagged ‘Pride’ on BBC Online. The volume of stories promoted under that tag is now well known.
The tags Pride, LGBT and Transgender People seem to exist only to push heartwarming stories of heroism or victimhood. Not hard news like this.
https://www.bbc.com/news/topics/c9q9x1zj0j1t
Quotes a post by A2437; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Hi Ben. The universal takeaway from Cass has been the weakness of evidence for medical and social transition, the inability to determine enduring trans identities, the unknowns around hormone use, and the poor quality of research, all leading to the importance of caution 🙂
@GBNEWS consistently failing on this
‘slamming claims that she's transgender’
- what claims?
‘Musk and Trump both criticised Khelif’
- describing a person’s sex is not criticism
‘Khelif was both born and raised female’
- assigned female at birth, evidence says born male
Still on @guardian’s most read
‘Khelif faced accusations over her gender’
‘She failed a gender eligibility test’
‘Khelif was born female’
None of this has happened
‘She has never identified as trans or intersex’
and this is completely irrelevant
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/article/2024/aug/14/jk-rowling-and-elon-musk-named-in-imane-khelif-cyberbullying-lawsuit
It was legacy media which repeatedly used trans-identified males to discuss the controversy, used gender identity talking points and asked gender identity related questions - all giving rise to
Khelif’s response here - ‘I’m not trans’
Female campaigners were not crying ‘trans’
Quoting @icons_women: ‘Big shame’: Women’s Olympic boxing gold medalist Imane Khelif condemns politicians who claim he is 'a transgender,' saying it dishonors his family, Algeria, and the Arab world to identify as such.
Speculation surrounds the male boxer who failed a chromosomal blood screen to compete as female in last year's World Championships. Some believe he may have a DSD, leading to misidentification as female at birth. Regardless of any developmental syndromes or how he self-identifies, the male development pathway gives him a significant advantage over women in the ring. For this reason, all male athletes should be barred from competing in Women’s Olympic competition.
Such a vital story. Truly unflinching. The journalism that’s been missing.
It’s not like Ritchie wasn’t previously visible on social media, and others have been and still are. But legacy media has been afraid of the story.
👏 @[private account] and @[private account]
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/08/13/regret-transgender-surgery-nhs-detransition-service/
Good exclusive, marred by bias
‘Despite being born female’: tests by Khelif’s own team say otherwise
‘not identifying as trans or intersex’: with regard to sex, self-identity is meaningless
‘being backed by the IOC’: also fully irrelevant
It’s one-sided
Quoting @Variety: J.K. Rowling and Elon Musk have both been named in a criminal complaint filed to French authorities over alleged “acts of aggravated cyber harassment” against Algerian boxer and newly crowned Olympic champion Imane Khelif.
https://bit.ly/4cnVwvq
Once again BBC Nations and Regions on show as the flag-bearers for affirmation.
@BBCNews you need a variety of perspectives across time and platforms to fulfil your impartiality remit
‘Trans rapper says University of Wolverhampton was safe space’ https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cjdkez89kz2o
Also - @[private account] is obviously taking this very seriously. It’s good.
Please though - allow your reporters to say ‘male’
‘Trans’ is not a synonym for male. There were trans female athletes at the Olympics, no controversy. You need to stop using ‘trans’ when you mean ‘male’
Not long ago, this piece wouldn’t have been pitched or accepted. The response at the BBC, after ten days of Khelif and Lin, would have been ‘not more trans’. ‘that’s enough on trans issues’ ‘people aren’t interested’
Kudos to @[private account] for pursuing
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: ‘Currently, there is no unified position in sport towards transgender inclusion’
Transgender isn’t a synonym for male. Editors must start saying ‘male trans’ or ‘male in the female category’
Your audience shouldn’t be forced into second guessing. https://www.bbc.com/sport/articles/cpvymmpyjeko
This piece by @[private account]
https://www.bbc.com/sport/articles/cpvymmpyjeko
is a solid and sincere effort at balance, explains well why the Paralympics has this policy and rounds up some good voices.
But @BBCSport must stop requiring its reporters to say ‘trans’ instead of ‘male’.
Here’s why
🧵
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: ‘Currently, there is no unified position in sport towards transgender inclusion’
Transgender isn’t a synonym for male. Editors must start saying ‘male trans’ or ‘male in the female category’
Your audience shouldn’t be forced into second guessing. https://www.bbc.com/sport/articles/cpvymmpyjeko
The BBC should now lead the way back to accuracy. It’s the least it can do to start redressing the situation that it’s helped to create for these Paralympic women.
A trans athlete may be male or female. We are talking only about males. Use the right words.
It misrepresented the science and allowed affirmative producers to dominate. It repeatedly described male advantage as a ‘claim’ and elevated trans male voices over those of women.
This framing went round the world.
The current shift began about 18 months ago but is not enough
Described as ‘inclusion’ throughout.
@bbcsport
There is selective bias in the word ‘inclusion’. You are selecting out the exclusion of women.
‘World Athletics has banned transgender women’
Time to revisit the Style Guide. It’s misleading. They are no kind of woman.
‘Currently, there is no unified position in sport towards transgender inclusion’
Transgender isn’t a synonym for male. Editors must start saying ‘male trans’ or ‘male in the female category’
Your audience shouldn’t be forced into second guessing. https://www.bbc.com/sport/articles/cpvymmpyjeko
If you’re able to justify this congregational mantra then please go ahead.
Otherwise, accept its truth. Reporters with pronouns and ‘trans ally’ in email signatures have expressed their compliance with belief in gender identity, a theory which is scientifically unsupported.
The issue with ‘personal journeys’ that ‘don’t need balance’ is that it’s never just a personal journey. There’s always activism.
‘Politicians weaponising patient care to win vacuous culture wars’ 🤦♀️
This is only Glamour, but they pop up everywhere. https://www.glamourmagazine.co.uk/article/same-sex-hospital-wards-transgender-first-person
‘Under fire from women's rights campaigners for her support for trans rights, such as allowing trans women to access women-only spaces’
Women, trans, women’s rights, trans women, women-only
The missing word that would make sense of all this is ‘male’ https://www.scotsman.com/whats-on/arts-and-entertainment/nicola-sturgeon-warns-of-push-back-on-womens-rights-and-misogyny-on-the-rise-again-4615627
Tom wouldn’t be this rude and judgemental to parents who affirm a child’s trans identity.
Many journalists don’t understand that deference to one lived experience and rejection of another, combined with their public platform, turn them into activists. @tomhfh may be one of them.
Quoting @GBNEWS: Tom: Are you saying that Brianna Ghey was a 16-year old boy?
Keith: Yes
Tom: That's an appalling thing to say!
Keith: I'm sorry, but I believe it's a statement of fact
Keith Jordan, Our Duty Group: 'If a child identifies as trans at school there's been a safeguarding failure'
Exercise in capture: devoted use of activist language, and journalistic amnesia about complaints that only trans people should get trans roles.
An OK story, but only if reported properly: males seeking female roles, and the potential impact on actresses. https://apple.news/A4USdPl8qSp-C8Sf_x1kUHQ
‘Daniel Radcliffe has addressed Harry Potter author JK Rowling’s anti-trans rhetoric for the first time since 2020, saying it “makes me really sad”.
Strange piece in @Independent where the reporter’s bias is quite unabashed https://apple.news/ATkATOCcJRuO_UpNlx7fn4A
Morning @[private account]
Very fair questioning.
Would you review the language here? You’re allowed by @[private account] to clarify that ‘trans women’ are male. But you describe males as both male and female. Not every viewer will understand - it’s impossibly convoluted.
What does this mean?
‘There will be transgender patients, female patients, who do not want to go on to male wards’
It’s a complete corruption of language.
We must assume she means male when she says female, and also male when she says male. Would most viewers assume this?
Quoting @GMB: 'Do you owe her an apology?'
@[private account] questions Sir @Keir_Starmer about his previous comments when he said MP Rosie Duffield was wrong to say that only women have a cervix.
Again, the ‘trans rights’ framing. There have been many stories of women suffering because of the lack of single sex accommodation and care, including mental health care. They’re consistently ignored.
The privilege of a private NHS room shouldn’t be presented as exclusion.
Quoting @SkyNews: Transgender patients could be treated in their own room if other patients ask to be on single-sex wards, under plans by the government to update the NHS Constitution.
⬇️ Read more
https://trib.al/wW4cPmr
Gender stories have more oversight and nervous presenters are unlikely to want to change the scripts they’re offered.
The scripts they’re offered will likely be through a trans perspective, because that’s the framing from top down.
Same with BBC TV - 15' only, top line ‘trans women won’t be treated on women’s wards’. entirely a trans rights perspective, does not explain that 'trans women' are men.
Status quo ante. Still lots of work needed.
The @guardian does the exact same thing as the BBC and covers the story lowish down through a lens of trans rights.
It’s possible that they can’t see their own bias - it’s the sea they swim in.
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2024/apr/30/trans-patients-to-be-treated-in-separate-rooms-in-hospital-under-tory-plans?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other
Here’s the original http://gov.uk proposal, embedded in the Heath Secretary’s tweet.
The BBC broadcast coverage is also framing it through a trans rights perspective. Listen on R4 - bulletins only so far, at the top of each hour.
Quotes a post by T17651; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
> Dropping that line helps to imply that this is not really a very big deal, except for trans people. ‘Same-sex care has existed for years’ ‘it’s only available where possible’, the NHS will merely ‘stress’ biological sex.
And this part 👇 is completely omitted >
See the difference in top lines - the BBC default is a ‘trans rights’ perspective. No where in the piece does it make clear that ‘trans women’ are male, are men.
It also drops the line that the constitution will state unequivocally: ‘We are defining sex as biological sex’.
>
It makes clear its corporate editorial belief that gender identity is real and everyone has one. It’s not presented as a belief, but as a fact.
Single sex care affects millions more patients, but private rooms for trans-identified people are considered more important.
Most obviously, it dispenses with any NHS response and replaces it with a raging quote from Gendered Intelligence, twice as long as Maya Forstater’s quote.
The quote is from a trans-identified male, of course.
>
You can see the difference in the way @BBCNews covers this, as it views it through a lens of ‘trans rights’.
It’s a framing that runs through all BBC coverage - even the coverage of the Cass Review, basically a medical story.
> https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-68923861
Ben and his husband, a BBC journalist, have close friends with children described as ‘trans’. The presence of personal connections does seem - perhaps naturally - to cloud judgement on the issue of sex and gender.
We’ve also recommended that they consult @SexMattersOrg and @AllianceLGB to balance the in-depth interviews and focus groups with trans and non-binary people in the research which they cite in their decision-making process.
In 2018, live on air, a BBC reporter described lesbians marching ahead of Pride as 'cis women who don't want trans women to have the same rights they do'
Its specialist LGBT hub still has zero interest in lesbians who know that men aren't women
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/04/27/alternative-pride-march-could-be-held-for-fed-up-lesbians/
Language in policy at the NHS
We need the same clarity in the media: does banning ‘transgender women’ from women’s wards mean banning males or females? A third of people in the UK won’t know.
‘Chestfeeding' to be banned in NHS crackdown in @telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2024/04/27/nhs-to-limit-trans-ideology-with-new-constitution/
Stating sex is real and matters in sport, and expressing views on child medical transition, is not being ‘critical about transgender people’
@[private account]
It’s good that you’ve done this story at last, and we imagine it was a battle, but are you clear about the meaning here.
This article describes the tweets as ‘critical of transgender people’
This is Linzi’s crowdfunder page in which she describes the tweets
https://www.crowdjustice.com/case/linzi-smith-banned-spied-on/
Big contrast to how BBCNews reported Cass, the Review which sowed the seeds for the crisis. The coverage remains shocking in its focus on personal journeys of trans-identified people, but stands as the global record of a historically important meta analysis of medical transition.
Good backgrounder on the SNP and why Ash Regan, with her gender critical stance, is now so important.
‘It’s understood that tentative informal approaches by senior SNP figures to Alba had already been made on Thursday afternoon’
In @Telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2024/04/25/jk-rowling-have-last-laugh-snp-obsession-with-trans-rights/
Incredible reader response after the @yorkshirepost reports on gender identity and women and children’s rights
Women's rights, trans issues and gender dysphoria - a deluge of concern, worry and hope - you have your say https://www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/news/opinion/letters/womens-rights-trans-issues-and-gender-dysphoria-a-deluge-of-concern-worry-and-hope-you-have-your-say-4603353
Education Secretary to stop saying ‘trans women are women’
‘At the time of writing that response I didn’t have any direct experience of this topic and took advice on how best to respond’
What happens when the media curtails debate and hides the facts👆> https://apple.news/A-VzXfy0KQnuGQtNgNRx0Dg
Interesting on the dangers of suppressing free debate and normalising language that hides the truth - they feed political echo chambers. Spectator World @spectator https://archive.md/2024.04.24-120633/https://thespectator.com/topic/transgender-madness-rampant-sweden/?utm_source=Spectator%20World%20Signup&utm_campaign=5412250429-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2024_04_24_03_12&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_-5412250429-%5BLIST_EMAIL_ID%5D
> in described them as ‘trans women’ - though there’s evidence more than a third of people don’t know that this means ‘males’. There is also a total failure to include the opposite view.
This would/will be justified on the grounds that the programme is a profile, not a >
This is a profile of Paul Sinton-Hewitt - founder of Parkrun - on BBC Sounds
About 12’ in, the current CEO is given the opportunity to justify including trans-identified males in the female category.
The presenter adopts activist convention > https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001yght
Here’s the log of complaints about the Blake report on the 1pm news. Note the log misrepresents the nature of many complaints.
We know that for many the main issue was not that Blake’s trans status was not made clear. It was that his sex was not stated.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact/sites/default/files/2024-03/26%20February%20-%2010%20March%202024v.pdf
The @[private account] investigates last week’s Unherd/GDI story
‘’Anti-trans narratives' see Unherd put on advertising blacklist’
‘The Foreign Office Counter Disinformation and Media Development Programme has paid GDI £2.6m since 2019’ >
https://pressgazette.co.uk/marketing/anti-trans-narratives-unherd-advertising-blacklist-global-disinformation-index/
BBC Apologizes to J. K. Rowling for Misleading Coverage of Her Transgender Sex Offender Comments | National Review https://www.nationalreview.com/news/bbc-apologizes-to-j-k-rowling-for-misleading-coverage-of-her-transgender-sex-offender-comments/
‘Pressure mounts on NCAA to clarify stance on transgender athletes’ -WaPo
Because language around sex is so corrupted it’s hard to decipher what’s going on here - you can make a guess but probably only if you’re versed in the debate https://apple.news/AXcIuB_lZT2C5szOC-udUVQ
‘Children are presented with an array of 40 terms including ‘neo-pronouns’ such as perself, xyr, vis and eirself in materials developed by the SNP government-funded charity LGBT Youth Scotland..it’s suggested they make name and pronoun badges to share’ https://archive.ph/2024.04.22-183225/https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/04/22/scottish-school-pupils-pronoun-badges-transgender/
> not just in the subject matter but in the activist language adopted heavily.
It’s possible to write about the experiences of trans-identified people without resorting to the language of trans advocacy. ‘Anti-trans’ and ‘transphobia’ are not defined terms.
Here they/