The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Trans-identified men absolutely are trying to force their way in. They're proud of the fact. Would you like me to send you myriad examples of trans ID-ed men boasting about how they'll break the law, warning women not to get in their way and threatening violence if they do?
The distinction isn't between 'trans' and 'cis'. It's between men who want to force their way into spaces where women and girls are vulnerable, and those who don't. The former, as any nine-year-old can understand, are far more likely to be a danger to women than the men who accept that women's safety, dignity and privacy means they should stay out of those spaces. The distinction isn't between men who claim to be women and those who don't, it's the difference between men who respect women's boundaries - trans-identified or not - and those who don't. As the old saying goes, 'good men stay out so bad men stand out.'
As we both know, I've just discussed your exact words. I've just told you why it's entirely rational for women to fear trans women in their single-sex spaces. What's your response?
All available evidence shows that trans-identified men commit sexual and violent offences at exactly the same rate as other men. I've sent you the report on the proportion of trans-identified men currently in jail for sexual offences in the UK, which is actually higher than in the general male prison population. What's your response to that?
I’ve literally just answered your question. Why is it fine for women to suffer assaults, because ‘we can’t know beforehand and can arrest them afterwards’, but not fine for trans-identified men to accept risk on the basis that crimes against them can be punished afterwards?
The proportion of trans-identified men in prison in the UK for sex offences is higher than among the male prison population as a whole. How do you explain that?
He’s not policing looks. You’re using the wrong talking point. You’re supposed to say, ‘those men aren’t really trans.’ Which is his entire point. You’re asking women to accept a higher risk to themselves to accommodate your wishes.
Meanwhile, trans activists tell women they have no right to speak about themselves and their own bodies in any way that might trigger narcissistic rage in trans-identified men, apply the ideological term 'cis' to people who neither describe themselves that way nor believe in gender identities, assert the right to redefine 'woman' not by the observable characteristics of biological sex but by sex stereotypes, and seek to dictate what rights women and girls should surrender to men.
I’ve never told any trans person what they ‘should be.’ As far as I’m concerned, trans people can call themselves whatever they like and believe whatever they like about themselves. What trans people aren’t entitled to is universal agreement that they’ve changed sex, acclaim for their embodiment of sex stereotypes, the reconfiguration of laws around an objective untruth or women’s surrender of their sex-based rights.
I have never denied that people who call themselves trans exist and in the UK, they rightly have exactly the same rights as every other citizen. What you want is for women to lose their sex-based rights to accommodate men who say they're women. That's the conflict.
The electorate aren’t goldfish. Our memories are long enough to recall June 2024, when you declared that trans-identified men with penises should be able to use women’s public bathrooms. It took a Supreme Court ruling to force you to uphold women’s rights, and now you pose as our bold champion? Please.
Quoting @bphillipsonMP: The time for talk has long passed. This government is putting its money where its mouth is when it comes to supporting women and girls.
We'll back practical action to confine misogyny to the history books - in public services, workplaces, and online.
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/oct/27/uk-government-to-give-15m-to-anti-misogyny-fund-amid-manosphere-concerns?CMP=share_btn_url
‘Weak leadership combined with ideological capture, perceived prestige for the organisation, and fear had all led to children being harmed.’
Gender ideology has spread like wildfire through the NHS. The casualties: kids and whistleblowers.
Free to read.
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/sarah-redvers-tribunal-nhs-trans-doctor-qqm376zp2
Because a certain kind of man believes that not getting everything he wants from women is oppression. This applies both to incels and to the type of trans-identified man who insists that speech, laws and physical spaces should be reconfigured around his self-image.
Quotes a post by A1240; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I wrote a new piece about women’s rights and whether or not I want trans people dead. (Spoiler: I don’t)👇
https://www.jkrowling.com/opinions/an-update-to-my-essay-of-june-2020/
In fairness, there are loads of videos of gender critical people saying the equivalent about trans-identified people. They just cunningly disguise their incitement to murder as ‘we don’t want men in women’s changing rooms.’
No woman can be a trans woman. The defining characteristic of a trans women is being a man.
No study has proven that trans women don't commit sexual offences against women at the same, or higher, rate as other men. There are proportionally more trans-identified men in jail for sex offences in the UK than there are among male prisoners as a whole.
98% of sex criminals are men. 88% of victims of sexual crimes are women and girls. That's why you don't belong in spaces where women and girls are undressed or otherwise vulnerable. We are not your validation props. Campaign for third spaces if you want. Women's spaces are taken.
The 'inclusive' locker room allowed a male sex offender inside, where, predictably, he committed sex offences.
Trans-identified men, too, have committed sex offences against women and children. Here's one of many examples.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgky8ndjm4o
Men shouldn't be in women's and girls' changing rooms, period. There is no test in existence to determine whether a man is or is not a threat to women before he's committed an assault. Innumerable men who claim to be women have sexually assaulted women. A simple Google search will give you the names and histories.
Men as a group pose a threat to women, as a group. The statistics don't change when the men identify as women. On the contrary, there are currently more trans-identified men in jail in the UK for sexual offences than there are among the general male prison population.
The reason this man was able to access unclothed women is that Planet Fitness thought it was progressive to let men into women's single-sex spaces. Women have been warning for years that women and girls would be harmed if corporations and institutions decided to placate the trans lobby and admit men to changing rooms and public bathrooms. These sexual assaults were entirely preventable. I repeat: I hope the women who've been assaulted sue.
This happened because Planet Fitness allows men to use women's changing rooms. They changed their policies to allow this because trans activists convinced them that it's bigoted not to let men in. As ever, the victims of this corporate decision weren't born with penises. I sincerely hope they sue.
But it couldn’t be social contagion, folks. It’s just that young people, especially autistic, gay and mentally ill ones, are finally free to be their authentic selves.
The sudden explosion of young women who want to cut off their healthy breasts and take testosterone? Well, it’s absolutely not the newest form of self-harm, to which troubled adolescent girls are provably prone, ok? It’s not a consequence of the commonplace fear of becoming an adult woman, with all that that entails. No, there’s nothing to worry about there.
The possibility of regret? Naturally, we don’t let minors get tattoos or own guns or vote, because that would be ridiculous, but if they want irreversible surgeries and drug treatments, they must be given them, and everyone around them must immediately agree they are now the opposite sex. That’s called being kind.
And the mounting numbers of detransitioners? They were never trans, obviously, and should be mercilessly attacked, especially if they now say they were vulnerable and in a friendship group, online or off, dominated by trans identities, where transitioning was presented as a way to resolve all their social and emotional difficulties. (I have the emails).
No, there’s nothing whatsoever to see here. Keep justifying it, keep cheering it on, keep insisting that the doctors and drug companies making serious money out of it all are acting with the purest of motives. Answer every reasonable question with an accusation of hatred and bigotry. Dispel every qualm of conscience with an activist-approved talking point. Reassure yourself that everyone on your dinner party circuit agrees with you.
And when, in years to come, we’re all looking back on graphs like this, be proud that you did your bit to monster whistleblowers, parrot unevidenced claims and create the climate of fear that allowed the worst medical scandal in a century to take place.
Quotes a post by T02469; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Black women are women. Women do not make up 98% of sex offenders.
Men make up 98% of sex offenders. Proportionally speaking, there are more trans-IDed men in UK jails for sex offences than in the male prison population as a whole.
Stop comparing black women to men.
Quotes a post by T00772; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
1. Never happens.
2. If it happens, the paedophile isn't trans.
3. The real crime here is the deadnaming.
4. TERFs love it when this stuff happens.
5. OMG why do you even care?
Quoting @reduxx: UK: A trans-identified male has been sentenced to over 20 years in prison for repeatedly raping a child.
James Groves, who wears a wig and now goes by the name 'April' Groves, was convicted of 18 sexual offenses at Bristol Crown Court this month.
https://reduxx.info/uk-trans-identified-male-sentenced-to-20-years-for-raping-a-child/
I was just wondering what the approved trans activist bullshit line for refusing to look facts in the face was going to be this time. Thanks for letting me know!
Protecting the rights of women and girls is not an attack on trans people.
Propagandising suicides runs contrary to every tenet of suicide prevention.
There is no low to which serial failed litigant Jolyon Maugham will not stoop in his endless quest for donations and publicity.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
And this is why we must take all trans-identified men at their word, because until he’s assaulted a girl in a locker room or filmed himself masturbating in a women’s bathroom we can’t tell if he’s truly trans, and women and girls should be thrilled to take part in the experiment.
Being trans isn’t a mental illness, so mentally ill people can’t be trans, and no predator would pretend to be trans so trans predators aren’t trans, and all trans people are being their authentic selves unless their authentic self is a rapist in which case they’re pretending.
The definition of ‘woman’ doesn’t include men who want to be women and never has. Trans activists have tried to change the meaning of the word in law, to enable men to access women’s changing rooms, prisons and single-sex services like rape crisis centres. In the UK, they failed.
But I am replying. As I've proved innumerable times, I'm delighted to have this debate, with big accounts or small. So I'll ask again: when did I spend 1.2 billion of an unspecified currency to fight trans rights?
Your approach to debate is fascinating. You've just posted, not proof of your lie, but something that disproves your lie. You know, I'm starting to suspect you haven't got any evidence that I've spent 1.2 billion fighting trans rights.
Dearest, that's a lie, and I think we both know you know it's a lie. Now me how I managed to spend 1.2 billion of an unspecified currency on fighting trans rights.
The stupidest move trans activism ever made was trying to make 'trans women are women' the beginning and end of all argument. If your flagship motto is a self-evidently a lie, don't be surprised if people have questions. But this one comes a close second in idiocy. Trans people already have human rights. The problem is that they're demanding that women surrender theirs.
Meanwhile they ask the usual stock questions, but refuse to accept the answers.
‘Why do you care?’
I think it’s monstrous that you don’t.
‘Why do you keep highlighting the few bad apples?’
Because you want those bad apples admitted to all women’s single-sex spaces.
‘Why are you saying all trans people are rapists and perverts?’
I’ve literally never said that.
‘You realise you’re encouraging violence against trans people by pointing out these facts?’
I have never called for violence against any trans person. Meanwhile, you’re suppressing evidence of actual violence and sexual assault committed against vulnerable women and turning a blind eye to the hounding, harassment and persecution of women who oppose your movement.
And on and on, until they call me Hitler.
Every politician and celebrity still chanting ‘trans women are women’ should be asked how they square their loud commitment to ‘kindness’ with this inevitable end point. Explain how your ‘feminism’ led you here. Tell us why the abuse of these women is so unimportant to you.
Quoting @reduxx: A transgender pedophile housed in a women's prison in Minnesota has been exposing himself to female inmates and writing disturbing "poetry" about rape.
Female inmates report fearing retaliation from prison staff if they file complaints about Daniel Benz.
https://reduxx.info/us-transgender-pedophile-exposing-himself-to-female-inmates-in-womens-prison-writing-poetry-about-sexual-assault/
If men who speak up received exactly what women do, I’d have a tad more sympathy, but I doubt trans activists would be threatening to rape him into compliance.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedactivist harassmentviolence terror
I see that Stella Creasy is accusing me of leading a pitchfork mob against her, because I opined that she is less likeable and more hypocritical than the wild parakeet she mistook for an escaped pet.
For those who don’t know, Creasy is an elected politician and self-proclaimed ‘old-fashioned feminist’ who is ‘still fighting the patriarchy’. She’s more than once publicly defined herself against me (and my reaction was not to accuse her of leading a mob, even though I was probably averaging a dozen death threats a day at the point when the article below appeared.)
I thought it might be instructive for those of us who don’t share Creasy’s brand of ‘feminism’ to examine her campaigning record, so we can learn to do better.
Creasy wants women admitted to the male-only, exclusive, London-based private members Garrick Club, a change that would benefit rather privileged women like Creasy. Creasy is a mother who wants better accommodations for working mothers, a change that would benefit Creasy. Creasy takes selfies at a men-only Muslim march because that reminds everyone how non-racist she is, which benefits Creasy. Creasy asserts that ‘trans women are women’, which keeps her in good odour with her party’s most aggressive activists, and benefits Creasy.
However, keeping cross-dressing heterosexual men out of nurses’ changing rooms doesn’t benefit Creasy, because Creasy has never had to mop up other people’s piss, blood and vomit at work. Challenging the notion that a male basketball player becomes a girl if he says he is doesn’t benefit Creasy, who has no sporting ambitions. Speaking up against the patriarchy as practised by non-white men doesn’t benefit Creasy, who wants those selfie-opportunities. Criticising an ideological movement that persecutes, harasses and openly threatens women who don’t believe some women have penises wouldn't benefit Creasy, because she's already fully-signed up to self-id, where any man who says he's a woman must be taken at his word.
As the late Gloria Steinem said: ‘“Feminism has never been about getting a job for one woman. It's about making life more fair for women everywhere.’
Creasy the patriarchy-challenger is provably more than happy to cosy up to men and misogynist movements when it suits her public profile and career advancement, no matter the harms those men might be causing less privileged women. By Steinem’s definition, what Stella espouses is not feminism, but Creasyism, and I suggest the emblem for this brave new rights movement should be an indignant parakeet with severely ruffled feathers.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/life/stella-creasy-jk-rowling-wrong-woman-can-have-penis/
My position is that gender dysphoria is a real, painful condition and that for some adults, the only way they may feel able to resolve that inner conflict is transition. If that’s the road they choose I wish them long life and happiness and I would vigorously oppose any discrimination against them when it comes to employment, housing or voting rights.
I do not believe children have the capacity to consent to treatments that may leave them infertile and, in some cases, anorgasmic. Multiple studies have shown that gender dysphoria in childhood and adolescence is not uncommon, for gay kids particularly, but it also occurs in, for example, straight girls who hate the idea of becoming women and sometimes, tragically, in children who’ve been abused. The available evidence shows that in the majority of cases, gender dysphoria resolves after the person has gone through adolescence. I am strongly opposed to the experimental treatment of blocking puberty in dysphoric children. I believe trans activists have behaved hugely unethically and irresponsibly in pretending that there is good evidence that these treatments are beneficial (there isn’t), that puberty blockers are completely reversible (there is a mounting body of evidence to suggest they aren’t) or that children are likely to kill themselves if denied blockers (there is no evidence to support this and suicide prevention charities warn against making such statements, due to the very real danger of suicide contagion.)
Of course, not all trans-identified people are dysphoric. Erotic transvestism, also known as autogynephilia, (getting a sexual thrill out of dressing as/pretending to be a woman) has been around for a very long time. I believe lesbians are entitled to exclude straight, cross-dressing men from their dating pools without being accused of bigotry and worse (same goes for gay men with trans-identified women). It’s profoundly homophobic to attack gay people for being same-sex attracted.
I don’t believe anyone, adult or child, is ‘born in the wrong body.’ That is an unfalsifiable, quasi-religious belief. A person may *feel* as if they’re in the wrong body, but humans cannot literally change sex. However they identify, men don’t belong in the single-sex spaces for which women fought so hard.
It's so unlike trans activists to misrepresent opponents' arguments! I'm shocked, I tell you. SHOCKED!
Since you've innocently misunderstood the point, let me spell out the obvious even more clearly.
Let's take as an example a woman with MRKH syndrome, who was born with a congenital abnormality: an absent or undeveloped uterus. Notwithstanding that anomaly, she has a reproductive system organised around producing eggs instead of sperm, so she is unambiguously female. No male can have MRKH syndrome; one might even say that MRKH syndrome represents conclusive proof that the individual born with it is female.
I myself was born with a congenital abnormality: a bleeding disorder. I don't consider myself less human because of it, but my blood is demonstrably defective. That still doesn't make me a brand new type of human being, nor does it mean an inability to clot should be considered a standard trait of all human beings.
It's my good fortune that there's no anti-science ideological movement currently trying to hijack bleeding disorders for its own ends. Should that ever happen, though, I can promise you I'll fight to the bitter end not to have my medical history reduced to a glib and ignorant talking point, as gender identity ideologues insist on doing to men and women with DSDs.
There is zero evidence that trans-identified men pose less of a risk to women than non-trans-identified men. A disproportionately high number of trans-identified men currently in prison in the UK were convicted of sex crimes against women/girls. This was revealed by a Freedom of Information request.
Two abusive men identify as women. How do we know which one's 'really' trans? And as all available evidence show that trans-identified men have the same pattern of criminality as other men, why should women care?
Great, you can clear something up for me. What makes this particular abusive man not a woman, whereas this child-abusing 'openly transgender' legislator, who was referred to as a woman throughout his trial, is?
https://reduxx.info/first-openly-transgender-state-legislator-sentenced-to-33-years-in-prison-for-child-sexual-exploitation/
I'm shocked to hear that a man who identifies as a woman could be a danger to women and children. I've been told ad nauseam that this simply never happens. Surely it's transphobic to suggest that predators or abusers might identify as trans?
‘He was admitted to a psychiatric ward as a teenager, where he was diagnosed with depression. During his admission, he mentioned to a doctor that he had been looking into transgender communities online…’
Free to read.
https://www.thetimes.com/us/news-today/article/gender-detransitioners-sue-hospitals-in-the-us-fbbt6ww85
I've literally listed your own arguments. You say this is a completely valid trans woman and should therefore be given all rights, protections and services owed to women. Have I got that wrong? Do you not think this individual should be treated in all contexts as a woman?
What do you mean by "posting positive videos about trans people too"? Are you implying this is a negative video? The video was made by an individual who, in your own words, is "as valid as any other trans woman" and who wanted to share it publicly. What's the problem?
"Amnesty has moved so far away from their original mission... They are now acting like the types of authoritarian regimes that they have always sought to expose.” -- @[private account], granddaughter of Amnesty founder.
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/amnesty-trans-jk-rowling-trans-anti-rights-2cmn6mhb0
I’ve just seen a post from yet another man who thinks my position has shifted since I wrote my 2020 essay about gender identity ideology and the consequent clash of rights https://www.jkrowling.com/opinions/j-k-rowling-writes-about-her-reasons-for-speaking-out-on-sex-and-gender-issues/
For the avoidance of doubt, I stand by every word I wrote then. For instance: ‘woman isn’t a costume.’ If it surprises you that I say men don’t become women by wearing make up and dresses, you didn’t understand the essay. I’ve been crystal clear all along that I believe people are free to live and present themselves as the opposite sex if that’s what feels comfortable and authentic TO THEM. This appears to have been interpreted (most often, tellingly, by men) as ‘and it naturally follows that I, as a woman, will validate a man’s belief that he is now, to all intents and purposes, the same sex as me, and I will use only the speech he deems appropriate and will be very careful to protect his sensitive ego, no matter the cost to myself in pretending to believe a falsehood, or the loss of my own rights due to this pretence.’
Dress as you like within normal bounds of situational decency, wear lipstick, sequins and a beard if you want, call yourself whatever you like, have sex with any consenting adult you please: I wish you health, happiness and safety. What you don’t get is the power to compel my speech and belief.
When I call a man a man, I am speaking verifiable truth. It is essential to be able to accurately name sex when discussing fair sport, facilities and services for women and girls and the right of gay people not to be demonised for their same-sex attraction. In years to come, a lot of useful idiots are going to awake to the fact that they’ve been complicit in enormous harm done to women, girls, gay people who stood against the insanity, and some extremely vulnerable young people. I don’t doubt we’ll hear a lot of, ‘I thought I was just being kind.’ Such individuals, especially those in positions of power, should be asked why they never had anything to say about the loud, public, widespread unkindness directed against those who refused to adopt their fashionable, elitist beliefs, eg, the detransitioners being bullied and vilified by former ‘allies’, the whistleblowers who tried to stop an unregulated experiment on troubled children, the women who lost their careers and livelihoods by standing up for all women’s rights.
Some people appear to believe it a worse crime for a woman to call a man a man than for trans activists to call loudly and publicly for the assault and assassination of all women who refuse to bend the knee. I have never wished violence or any other kind of harm on a trans-identified person, but, like many other people who’ve defended women’s and girls’ rights over the past few years, I have received thousands of threats of death, rape and torture. The wilful blindness of those who bleat ‘both sides’ will rightly be judged harshly in times to come.
TL;DR Trans women aren’t women, and if that hurts your feelings, be grateful you live in a society where you are just as free to espouse gender ideology as I am to speak the truth. As Orwell said: ‘Freedom is the freedom to say that two plus two make four. If that is granted, all else follows.’
A pantomine horse isn’t a horse.
An open secret isn’t a secret.
A hot dog isn’t a dog.
A shrinking violet isn’t a violet.
Crow’s feet aren’t feet.
Fair game’s not a game.
Trans women aren’t women.
Trouble is, 'trans' isn't an adjective. 'Trans woman' is a compound noun meaning 'man who wants to be considered a woman.' If the individual being described isn't trans, he's simply a man, whereas a bespectacled woman remains a woman even if she's not wearing glasses.
First rule of trans activism: everything they do is good and pure, right up to calling for the deaths of their opponents and trying to take down rape support centres. Everything their opponents do is malicious, nefarious and proves they're secretly liquidising puppies.
C1 anti-trans rhetoricactivist harassmentviolence terror
Bizarre. I thought the condition of being trans was innate and present from birth? So why are you talking about these women's husbands 'becoming trans'?
Shout out to all trans activists sharing the blacklist of women's and gay rights organisations published by @AmnestyUK! You're demonstrating very effectively that in spite of their hasty backtrack it can be easily accessed forevermore, increasing legal liability. Thank you!❤️
Please show me where I've categorised all trans-identified men as violent. Available data shows they are as violent as any other kind of man.
I am not arguing for the removal of rights from trans-identified men. I'm arguing for women to retain the rights they fought for.
Possibly, as Minister for Health, James Murray could compel the adult gender clinics to hand over the data they refused to give to Cass. We might then find out just how much benefit these interventions confer long term, without needing to perform experiments on children too young to give meaningful consent.
Read the testimony of the ever-expanding numbers of detransitioners. Grasp that these young people, many of them extremely vulnerable - autistic, care-experienced, abuse survivors, same-sex attracted in unsupportive families - have been irreparably harmed, left with their fertility destroyed, unending medical complications and profound psychological damage.
This is a medical scandal of epic proportions and people of power and influence are still too frightened of trans activists and trans lobby groups to do the right thing and put an end to the insanity. Kids are being sacrificed to ideology and cowardice. https://x.com/GBNEWS/status/2073694623449391534/video/1
There is no evidence that trans-identified men don’t have exactly the same pattern of criminality as all other men. On the contrary, all available evidence suggests they do.
Trans women are men. All of them. It is impossible for a woman to be a trans woman. What you propose means women losing their sex-based rights. Those are the rights under discussion.
If you want to campaign for trans-identified men to have their own spaces away from other men, have at it. But you don’t want that, which proves that your priority isn’t those men’s safety. What you want is for women to sacrifice their safety, privacy and dignity to validate men’s identities. You are, in short, a men’s rights activist who berates women for saying no to your fellow men.
I do not subscribe to your ideology, which means I do not believe in ‘cis’ and ‘trans’ in the essentialist way you apply the terms. I don’t believe anyone is ‘born in the wrong body’ because I don’t believe in gendered essences or souls. Gender dysphoria exists, as does fetishism. As far as human rights go, a man’s motivation for presenting as a woman is irrelevant. Society either agrees they’re all women if they want to be, or that they’re men with diverse motivations, none of which entitle them to women’s spaces.
There are many circumstances in which I believe refusing to accurately describe the sex of a person is at best confusing and at worst dangerous. Indulging a quasi-religious ideology over clear language and objective facts has already had disastrous consequences in the contexts of safeguarding, sport, medicine and crime.
But I have exclusive rights over my own choice of language. As Mark Twain said: 'I cannot call to mind a single instance where I have ever been irreverent, except toward the things which were sacred to other people.' Both trans activists and GC people who get angry that I'm deviating from their own hard and fast language rules are demanding that I respect things that are sacred to them, but not to me.
Trying to dictate how other people express themselves provides a delicious opportunity to chide and correct and to demonstrate one's own purity and righteousness - as indeed you're currently demonstrating - but they achieve nothing except making the language police feel good about themselves. Back in the real world, women's rights remain under attack and it will continue to take time, money and concrete action to defend them. You may feel that the priority is establishing black and white pronoun rules. I happen to disagree.
Linguistic prescription is authoritarian. It’s one of the things trans activists have used, with enormous success. Seeking to control what people are allowed to say is a hallmark of cults and totalitarian regimes.
I do not subscribe to the post modern ideas that changing language changes reality, that redefining something alters its nature, that our conception of a thing is of more importance than observable facts about the thing itself. To me, this kind of thinking is a dead end full of people pontificating and obfuscating, enjoying the sounds of their own voices while the world burns outside.
Some gender critical people seem to think that demanding we all use correct sex pronouns will return the world to sanity. This is an attempt to make the tail wag the dog. You cannot fight linguistic prescription with more linguistic prescription, and no rights campaign can succeed if its adherents are more interested in creating a purity spiral than allowing the smallest space for nuance or for the complexities of human nature and feelings.
Nothing's changed. I was being honest about how I feel about an individual trans woman I know, who was a gay man pre-transition, and who I met for the first time post-transition. Objectively speaking, she has physical characteristics that make it fairly obvious she wasn't born female, but she's a gentle, funny person I've never referred to as anything other than 'she' and 'her'. I find it perfectly easy to reconcile my fond feelings towards her, and my experience of her as someone with very female-coded energy, with a belief that she hasn't literally changed sex (and incidentally, she doesn't believe she's literally changed sex, either).
Yes, the people who call themselves 'trans' exist and they deserve exactly the same rights as everyone else, which, fortunately, they already have in the UK. It would rightly be considered discrimination if a person was refused employment, housing or the vote because they identified as trans.
'Trans women are women' is a thought-terminating cliché. Men are not women. That doesn't mean they're not allowed to present themselves however they like, call themselves whatever they like and believe whatever they like about themselves. It means they haven't changed sex.
If we replace the objective, observable characteristic of sex with the unfalsifiable concept of gender identify, women and girls lose, among other things, their right to fair and safe sport and women-only spaces, including changing rooms, prison cells and rape crisis services.
Women and girls are provably more vulnerable to forms of abuse including sexual assault, harassment and voyeurism in mixed-sex spaces. There is no evidence that trans-identified men don't have exactly the same rates of criminal offending as all other men.
Trans people exist. I have no desire for them not to exist; indeed, I wish them safety, happiness and health. However, 'existence' does not, and should not, mean the violation of other people's right to privacy, dignity and freedom of speech, or the reconfiguration of society to indulge a fallacy.
No, I don't think 'all people should have the right to decide their own rights', because a pluralistic democratic society can't function that way.
Which rights are trans women and 'fans of Pride' missing?
I’ve never said Khelif is trans. Khelif, as has been proven by more than once by a sex test, is a man with a DSD. ‘When your bodies chromosomes don’t align with the sex your body is born with’ is a literally meaningless sentence.
The only prerequisite for being a trans woman is being a man. Short/French/tall women remain women if the adjective is taken away. The compound noun ‘trans women’ describes a category of men. If the individuals described weren’t trans, they’d be men who don’t identify as women.
‘Trans woman’ is a compound noun. By definition, it means ‘man who identifies as a woman.’ If the person in question was actually a woman, ‘trans’ wouldn’t be there.