The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Who knows, now that trans activists aren't only stalking, harassing, doxxing, threatening and physically assaulting women, our politicians might finally take the violence that's such a key feature of this totalitarian movement seriously. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15416739/Trans-mobs-plot-smash-offices-senior-politicians-including-Prime-Minister-Wes-Streeting.html
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentpolitical enemyviolence terror
Earlier this month, the Women’s Rights Network, who obtained police data, published a report revealing that women and girls in unisex changing rooms are being targeted by sexual predators across England and Wales. 80 sexual assaults, 16 rapes and 65 incidents of voyeurism took place in leisure centres in 2023. https://www.lbc.co.uk/article/mixed-gender-changing-rooms-magnet-sexual-predators-5HjdPCR_2/
A freedom of information request in 2024 revealed that 62% of trans-identified male inmates in UK prisons had committed at least one sexual offence.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/12/31/almost-two-thirds-of-trans-women-prisoners-sex-offenders/
When you admit men who claim to be women into spaces where women and girls are naked or otherwise vulnerable, the risk to girls and women increases. The evidence is clear and those still determined to deny it - you, @bphillipsonMP, every trans activist determined to push their unfalsifiable ideas about gender onto the whole of society - will rightly be judged by history as having enabled harm to women and girls in service of a dangerous, quasi-religious ideology.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Safeguarding is necessary where there is a proven risk of harm from one group to a more vulnerable group.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/12/31/almost-two-thirds-of-trans-women-prisoners-sex-offenders/
The Swedish study found that trans-identified men have the same pattern of criminality as other men regarding violence and sexual offending. However, Kemp claims these men are no more likely to be violent or predatory than women.
3/4
Kemp used at least one completely bogus quote in his ruling. It's also being suggested, per the Times, that he 'used AI to research other cases.'
But there's worse. Kemp misrepresents a Swedish study that looked at the pattern of criminality among trans-identified men.
2/4
C4 targetinghand-codeddenialinstitutional captureviolence terror
If a trans-identified male commits a sexual crime against a woman or girl in a formerly single sex space, he was never really trans. However, some male rapists, voyeurs and pedophiles are really trans which is why they must be housed in a women's prison.
Judge Sandy Kemp and the Judicial Office need to explain exactly how this bogus quote made its way into the ruling. Misrepresentations of the Forstater ruling are commonplace in the trans activist community, but for this to turn up in an actual court ruling is truly shocking.
Quoting @MForstater: One of the many things wrong with the Sandie Peggie judgment.
This "quote" from my judgment doesn't come from my judgment. It is completely made up. 🤯
Of course trans-identified men have the right to exist. They have the same rights to employment, housing, the vote and personal safety as every other citizen. However, they aren't entitled to enter women's reserved spaces or sports, because they are male.
AGP is literally arousal from envisioning oneself as/dressing as a woman. It is the word sexologist Ray Blanchard coined to describe men who derive sexual pleasure from the fantasy of being female, and it encompasses transvestic disorder. If you'd rather use the latter term, do please explain how a woman or girl is supposed to know whether the cross-dressing male who just entered the locker room is 'transgender and/or dysphoric', which I assume you imagine makes him harmless, or sexually excited by wearing women's clothing and being in spaces reserved for women.
Years ago, I had a private conversation with a woman younger than me about the single sex space issue. She's very bright, well-educated, liberal, and absolutely could not understand why I wouldn't be comfortable undressing, or knowing my daughters were undressing, in front of a trans-identified man. As we talked, I realised she had no understanding of a feminine-presenting man who wasn't gay. I said to her, 'what about autogynephiliacs?' She said 'what's that?' Had literally never heard the word. And when I explained, she just looked blank. To this day I don't know whether that was because she'd never heard of cross-dressing as a paraphilia, or thought I was making it up.
'He has a point, but he's too blunt.'
From the start, a key tactic of the gender identitarians has been linguistic prescription, and it's proved shockingly successful. Trans activists' shibboleths and euphemisms have been allowed to penetrate the upper echelons of our culture with devastating consequences to freedom of speech and belief. Huge swathes of liberal media, the arts, academia and publishing have thrown themselves with gusto into the defence of a quasi-religious belief causing provable real world harm, and in their arrogance they've been outraged when people they assumed were part of their In Group have refused to march meekly along in lock step.
Time and again, I've seen and heard well-educated people who consider themselves critical thinkers and bold truth-tellers squirm when put on the spot. 'Well, yes, maybe there's something in what you're saying, but it's hateful/provocative/rude not to use the approved language/pretend people can literally change sex/keep drawing attention to medical malpractice or opportunistic sexual predators. Why can't you be nice? Why won't you pretend? We thought you were one of us! Don't you realise we have sophisticated new words and phrases these days that obviate the necessity of thinking any of this through?'
As the vibe shifts, and a lot of people in the elite professions start trying to reposition themselves, the obvious place to start is, 'it's not that I couldn't see your point, but did you have to say it that way?' We dissenters were supposed to find a way of questioning the chemical castration of children while calling it 'gender affirming care.' We were meant to defend the rights of vulnerable women while also using female pronouns for male rapists. We should have found a way to discuss fairness for women and girls in sport, while pretending that the ineradicable physical advantage men have over women doesn't exist.
Either a man can be a woman, or he can't. Either women deserve rights, or they don't. Either there's a provable medical benefit to transitioning children, or there isn't. Either you're on the side of a totalitarian ideology that seeks to impose falsehoods on society through the threat of ostracisation, shaming and violence, or you're not. The alternative to being 'blunt' - using accurate, factual language to describe what was going on - was to surrender freedom of speech and espouse ideological jargon that obfuscated the issues and the harms caused. We've always needed blunt people, but we need them most of all when being asked to bow down to a naked emperor.
Quotes a post by A2152; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans people are provably one of the safest demographics in the UK. There is no 'crusade of hate' or campaign to eliminate you. You fetishise victimhood while being one of the most pandered to groups in society.
So if I understand correctly, saying 'I identify as a woman' means you're really trans, but some people who say they identify as a woman aren't trans. I'm really struggling to understand the difference.
The trans umbrella stretches over a wide array of people who have virtually nothing in common with each other, eg, trauma-experienced and often same-sex attracted teenagers who believe transition is the route to happiness and are undergoing irreversible surgeries and drug treatments (extremely vulnerable) and adult straight men with a cross-dressing fetish who retain their genitalia and are demanding access to all women’s protected spaces (not remotely vulnerable, but thoroughly pandered to, at the expense of women and girls.)
Trans people already have all the rights everyone else in society has, but some (not all) trans people demand that women give up rights: the right to single-sex spaces, to fair sport and to freedom of speech. No marginalised group has ever demanded that rights be stripped from other protected group, and no other supposedly marginalised group has ever been indulged by politicians, police and elite institutions to the extent the trans lobby has.
Just in case anyone's wondering what the deleted tweet I'm answering said, it was 'no, because I'm not a sexual predator.' I have to assume he panicked when he realised what trans activists might make of that, if they saw it.
You are wrong. There are proportionally more trans-identified men currently in UK prisons for sex crimes than among the incarcerated male population as a whole. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/12/31/almost-two-thirds-of-trans-women-prisoners-sex-offenders/
I have never said that men transition to predate on women and girls. I have said, because there's ample evidence to prove it, that some men who claim a trans identity have committed acts of voyeurism and sexual assault against women and girls in supposedly single sex spaces.
You've just said you wouldn't enter a girls' or women's single sex space because you're 'not a sexual predator.' Could you explain how women and girls are supposed to tell which trans-identified men are predators and which aren't? Because a proportion, provably, are.
Determined predators, as anyone who knows anything about safeguarding will tell you, go where the pickings are easy. If all it takes to get inside a woman's locker room is to say 'I identify as a woman', predators will do that. We know this, because they've already done it, multiple times.
A speed sign doesn't magically make cars slow down. A No Trespassers sign doesn't make the field inaccessible. Such signs are there to warn people that there will be consequences if they're disobeyed. A sign that excludes men from a space, so that women and girls can have safety, privacy and dignity has no power except the one you yourself have just acknowledged. When men who don't seek to transgress females' boundaries stay away, women can tell who the suspicious ones are, because they ignored the sign. This gives women the right to complain or protest. Men waiting outside have the right to point out to the intruder that he's going into the wrong space.
I understand that you think some of your fellow men should be allowed to use women's facilities and spaces because you think those men's feelings are more important than the safety, privacy and dignity of women and girls. That's where we disagree.
So they're safe all the way from leaving home to reaching the door of a public bathroom, but are suddenly at risk of assault the moment they enter? This seems contradict the popular trans activist argument against women-only spaces: 'you could get raped anywhere.'
So you're happy to accuse without proof, but don't want to give the proof because people on X would be mean to you? You'd be a heroine to trans activists everywhere if you did this. Surely you can dredge up just one quote, proving I'm pro-violence and anti-debate?
If you don't like people pointing out that many trans activists use precisely the tactics advocated by the world's most famous fascist, try persuading them to a) debate, b) accept women, too, have rights and c) not to try and force compliance by threats of death and violence.
Hurt feelings do not justify violence. Abusive men justify beating their female partners because the women made them unhappy. Trans activists advocate punching women who won't validate men's self-proclaimed identities. Broken hearts mend. Severed arteries don't.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
Words are not violence. When you pretend that views that oppose your own are violence, you are justifying the use of actual violence towards the speaker.
Gender ideology’s reliance on tropes and slogans like ‘words are violence’, its constant rationalisation and justification of using force against opponents and its preference for enforcing compliance through fear rather than permitting debate, are straight out of fascism’s playbook.
‘The function of propaganda is . . . not to weigh and ponder the rights of different people, but exclusively to emphasize the one right which it has set out to argue for. Its task is not to make an objective study of the truth, in so far as it favors the enemy, and then set it before the masses with academic fairness; its task is to serve our own right, always and unflinchingly.’
The words are Hitler’s, but I must have seen trans activists say the same thing, barely rephrased, a thousand times. Your movement seeks to remove rights from others. It is anti-truth and critical thinking, pro-violence, pro-dehumanisation of those who disagree with you, and you are so lacking in self-awareness you cannot see that you are precisely what you pretend to hate.
An elected representative of your own party, @RosieDuffield1, was advised by police not to attend Labour conference because of the physical risk to her from trans activists. You did nothing. You showed her no support, You criticised her for stating biological facts.
C4 targetinghand-codedactivist harassmentspeech persecutionviolence terror
'Blonde woman' = adjective + noun.
Remove 'blonde' from 'woman', you've still got a woman.
'Trans woman' = compound noun.
Remove 'trans' from 'woman', you've got a man.
If the man was actually a woman, he wouldn't be trans.
Tell me again how gender identity ideology isn’t homophobic. Would you trust this UK doctor, who was suspended from practicing by the medical council and now heads up quasi-medical trans advocacy group GenderGP, to be sympathetic to a young girl who’s attracted to other girls?
No police action was taken against any of these men.
Men publicly threatening to kill women is white noise to law enforcement in this country and trans activists know it.
What Sir Mark Rowley calls a 'toxic culture war,' I call a mass campaign of intimidation against women for standing up for their rights, and police turning a blind eye to the men publicly calling for women to be beaten, raped, hanged and decapitated.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/09/03/graham-linehan-sue-metropolitan-police-trans-tweet-arrest/
I see Nicola Sturgeon is once again complaining that I posted a picture of myself wearing a T-shirt with her name on it and the legend 'Destroyer of Women's Rights.' Apparently this didn't 'elevate the debate.'
Is there a clinical term for an individual who has extreme thinness of skin when it comes to their own perceived hurts, coupled with a rhino-hide when it comes to the fear and suffering of others?
I'm thinking in particular of the two women Isla Bryson raped, who had to watch their First Minister squirm and smirk on TV as she tried to avoid admitting he was a man; of the five survivors of male violence who were ready to give evidence to Sturgeon's committee on gender self-ID, but were told to put their concerns in writing while seventeen trans-identified people appeared in person; of the mother of a young girl with a learning disability who campaigned against self-ID because she wanted her daughter to be guaranteed same sex intimate care, should she need it (the mother was presumably one of those female opponents Sturgeon calls 'shrill' and 'hysterical' in her memoir); of the ten-year-old girl sexually assaulted in a public bathroom by a 6'5" paedophile who served his jail sentence in a women's prison because he called himself 'Katie'; of Sandie Peggie, forced to discuss her own menstrual history in public to justify not wanting to undress in view of a 6ft straight cross-dresser in the nurses' changing room; of Marion Millar, dragged into court because she tweeted a picture of suffragette ribbons; of the Scottish rape crisis centres reliant on government funding who were pressured to admit trans-identified males into their services if they wanted funding to continue.
When Sturgeon refers to an 'elevated debate', she means a discussion that takes place within a tiny, smug bubble from which regular women suffering real life consequences of her policies are firmly excluded. These faceless ants are loftily dismissed as bigots, or, to be more precise: 'transphobic, misogynistic, homophobic, maybe racist as well.'
Nicola, you hated the T-shirt picture because you couldn't ignore it, as you'd ignored so many other women trying to make you understand their concerns. Appeals to your empathy, your intelligence and your compassion all failed. Apparently the only way to get through to you is through your vanity.
"Nandy’s fashion statement is merely the latest proof that when it comes to trans ideology, Labour really hasn’t learned a thing." 🎯
https://www.spiked-online.com/2025/08/18/when-it-comes-to-trans-labour-has-learned-nothing/
We’re been told endlessly by trans activists that no minors have been given irreversible surgeries or drug treatments, that it’s a lie, a scare story, a moral panic, a myth. 🧵👇
Quotes a post by A1374; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Agreed. There's a reason trans activists want to argue about public bathrooms rather than rape crisis centres, domestic abuse shelters and hospital wards.
In my experience, this is overwhelmingly the case with older people. They assume trans women have had full sex reassignment surgery and an androphillic orientation and are genuinely incredulous at the idea that a straight man might claim a trans identification, or that gender identify ideology supports the admission of fully intact, gynephillic males into female spaces. It's so far outside their experience they think it's a far-fetched scare story.
My Boomer mother-in-law's jaw dropped when I told her how many trans-identifying kids were at my children's school. Then I told her we were out for dinner with ten friends and between us, we knew (truly knew, not just vague aware of) twenty-five trans-identified kids.
I’m entitled to say this, because I just turned 60.
A lot of older liberals (in both the US and the UK) have brought very old-fashioned sensibilities to this debate. They’re still locked into the idea that all trans women are, or were, effeminate gay men, and they’re perplexed that any woman would see them as a threat.
These are people who’ve never met an AGP in the wild, don’t understand online cultures, know nothing about trends in porn, aren’t on TikTok where ‘gender-affirming’ surgeons advertise directly to minors, and they’ve aged out of having kids at school, so have no notion that social contagion might be at play. They look round at all their similarly aged dinner party friends, none of whom are aware of any of these things either, and adopt a vibe-based position: this is gay rights 2.0, anyone who opposes it must be far-right, and thank goodness Our Sort are kinder, better, and (most importantly) far more sophisticated.
This shift in attitudes shown below isn't because of increased intolerance, but of an increase in understanding, and trans activists themselves bear the greatest responsibility for the change.
Five years ago, a lot of medical bodies (and trans activist organisations, lobby groups and virtue-signalling celebrities) were united in telling us that puberty blockers were completely reversible and harmless. As more and more evidence accrues showing actual and potential harm, public opinion, unlike trans activism, has shifted in line with the data.
Five years ago, the sophisticated, fashionable line was that sex difference didn't really matter in sport. Trans activists demanded that the women's category be destroyed to accommodate men who claim to be female, but the public wasn't willing to pretend they couldn't see the injustice right in front of their faces.
Five years ago, trans activists and professional lanyard- wearers were chiding us all to use preferred pronouns, because that was kind. Now the public see convicted rapists described as 'she' and 'her' by news outlets and are rightly enraged that journalists are feeding us ideological fiction instead of facts.
Five years ago, a lot of people, especially older ones, were under the impression that trans-identified men had all had full sex reassignment surgery and were sexually orientated towards other men. They didn't know that cross-dressing straight men were now asserting the right to enter all women's reserved spaces. They didn't know how few trans women have had 'bottom surgery.' They know now.
Trans activists are to blame for the hounding and persecution of non-believers, which has spilled into British courts. Women have had to fight all over again for rights they thought they'd have forever. The Cass Review brought shame on all who lobbied to continue a broadly unresearched and unevidenced medical experiment on minors. Trust in institutions, in academia, the media and the medical profession has been severely undermined. Politicians have beclowned themselves, willing to parrot self-contradictory slogans and outright absurdities rather than defend truth and freedom of speech.
The stark change in attitudes over the past five years is the direct consequence of the way trans activists set out to 'educate' us all. Giddy with the power they'd been handed by people in authority, they've tried to impose a quasi-religious, elitist, minority belief upon the whole of society. They can't complain (although, of course, they will) that the public has decided it doesn't want to buy what they're selling.
Quotes a post by A1326; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A large number of people (mostly men, in my experience) who're sympathetic to some of women's opposition to gender identity ideology, nevertheless think it's cruel to point out that a trans-identified man looks like a man, and unkind not to 'respect' his pronouns. They think these are 'compromises' women should be prepared to make. 'What does it matter?' they say. 'How does it hurt you?'
The psychological effects of being coerced, manipulated or pressured into doing something that is against a person's own beliefs or values are well known. 'Moral injury' occurs when a person is forced to betray deep-held convictions, or stand in silence while those convictions are being betrayed. The individual feels transgressed at a core level. The inevitable consequences are stress, anxiety and anger.
Workplaces across the west have imposed a Kafkaesque situation on women. A belief system most people consider nonsensical, but which, in elite circles, has become almost a religion, has been imposed from on high. Women are being persecuted and punished for not pretending they think men can change sex. The policing of pronouns, and the harassment and shaming of women who won't pretend they can't recognise a man when they see one, is merely the tip of genderism's gigantic, threatening iceberg.
Any man who seeks to force women to play along with the fantasy that he's female is engaging in a typically male power play. At worst, he will suffer narcissistic injury from her non-compliance, but that doesn't make him objectively vulnerable. The non-compliant woman, though, suffers lasting moral injury by being forced to participate daily in a lie - a lie, moreover, that constitutes a fundamental threat to her own rights to privacy, dignity and safety.
It has been profoundly illuminating to see how many people - possibly because their own values spring, not from a place of rationality or true conviction, but from fashion and self-interest - see male narcissistic injury as so very much more worthy of compassion than the moral injuries suffered by women.
IMO, any or all of the following:
a) It's the fashionable position in their echo chamber.
b) Naivety/lack of information.
c) Fear of ostracisation/persecution.
d) Child who's trans.
e) Lends itself to low effort virtue-signalling.
f) Great stick to batter other women with.
Quotes a post by T03263; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Useful idiots who screech 'you're evil for saying that any perverts or predators are hiding under the trans umbrella!' are the whole reason some perverts and predators have rushed to hide under the trans umbrella.
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-trans-identified-male-high-school-coach-previously-accused-of-undressing-in-front-of-girls-sent-pornography-of-himself-to-gender-critical-school-board-member/
98% of sex offenders are male, irrespective of how the men 'identify'. In the UK, a higher proportion of convicted sex offenders are found among trans-identifying men than in the general male prison population.
Time and again, some of the loudest and most aggressive activists in what you call the 'trans movement' have turned out to be dangerous and/or depraved. Sarah Jane Baker. Stephen Ireland. Peter Bright. Eric Joyce. Gordon Pike. Lexi Secker. David Challenor. Aiden Bunag. How many more rotten apples need to turn up before you accept that you've got a problem?
Every rational person can see that gender identity ideology offers predatory men opportunities and camouflage. If you genuinely cared about vulnerable people, especially children, you'd be sorting out your movement's very poor track record on rooting out the abusers lurking in your ranks, and stop pretending that pro-safeguarding people are the enemy.
He follows in the footsteps of trans-identified man Lexi Secker, who also sent me reams of abuse on here, especially for my belief that women should have single-sex spaces and rape crisis centres. Mr Secker has since been sentenced to six and a half years in jail for rape.
I was explicit about my position on this in the essay I published in 2020.
"I've read all the arguments about femaleness not residing in the sexed body, and the assertions that biological women don't have common experiences, and I find them deeply misogynistic and regressive… It isn't enough for women to be trans allies. Women must accept and admit that there is no material difference between trans women and themselves...
“As many women have said before me, ‘woman’ is not a costume. ‘Woman’ is not an idea in a man’s head. ‘Woman’ is not a pink brain, a liking for Jimmy Choos or any of the other sexist ideas now somehow touted as progressive. Moreover, the ‘inclusive’ language that calls female people ‘menstruators’ and ‘people with vulvas’ strikes many women as dehumanising and demeaning.”
I elaborated on my views in the podcast “The Witch Trials of JK Rowling.”
In February of this year I wrote in response to another male journalist on X:
“If an adult feels they can only exist comfortably and authentically in this world by dressing in the opposite sex's clothes, having surgeries and taking hormones, or in adopting one of the many gender labels, I wish them safety, happiness and health, as long as they're not harming anyone else. You, however, seem to think that for a trans-identified man to be 'comfortable' and 'authentic', everyone in the vicinity must abandon their freedom of speech and belief to accommodate his 'identity'.
“Women are not validation props, comfort blankets or support animals. We aren't a rest home for men who don't like being men. If a person's happiness and self-esteem resides entirely on whether or not they can compel everyone around them to lie, whether out of fear or pity, I would respectfully suggest they are unlikely to have a very comfortable life, and are about as far from being 'authentic' as it is possible to be.”
For five years, men have repeatedly tried to argue me out of my belief that it is anti-freedom of speech, coercive and paternalistic to tell women they must be ‘kind’ and call men women if that’s what the men want. In short, I’ve stated my position on this matter multiple times, as clearly as I can, and, with respect, I’ve already read your own arguments and I find them neither original nor persuasive.
An appalling medical experiment has been performed on troubled young people, all in service of an ideology that continues to do widespread societal harm.
https://www.city-journal.org/article/cross-sex-hormones-estrogen-transgender-affirming-care-health-risks
Attention all men telling me I look like a trans woman: I’m sensing that this isn’t meant as a compliment. In fact, the implication seems to be that trans women look male, or odd, or ugly. This is appallingly transphobic and I’ll thank you to take your bigotry off my timeline.
Sex is anatomical. 'Womanhood' and 'femaleness' are not metaphysical or mystical states. I am a woman by virtue of my anatomy.
Clearly, if I woke up tomorrow with a male body, I'd have had atypical experiences for a male, because I'd have experienced what it is to exist in the world as a female. I've given birth three times, a spectacularly life-changing experience no male has ever experienced. I've also been treated in specific, sometimes harmful, ways, because I have female anatomy.
One major difference between trans activists and me is that I believe society needs to change, whereas they believe the individual should alter themselves to fit a societal notion of what men and women are. I don't believe in codifying and reifying gendered expectations, I believe in breaking them. I'm appalled that minors are being medicalised, sterilised and deprived of sexual function because they feel discomfort with the roles they're expected to play as boys/girls.
For centuries, women have fought to be full human beings in societies that demand they demonstrate the behaviours expected of them because of their anatomy. Liberation for women does not lie in saying 'if I don't want to fulfil those expectations, I must be a man.' Liberation lies in saying 'I'm just fine as I am, and fuck your sexist notions of what a woman should be.'
Quotes a post by T05154; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
As was recently clarified by the Supreme Court, trans-identified men do not have the right under UK law to use single-sex spaces reserved for women. Such spaces include public bathrooms, which by definition aren't single-sex if men are allowed to use them.
A few years ago a trans activist on here said to me, ‘imagine if you woke up in a man’s body tomorrow. You’d still be a woman, right?’ Well, no, I’d be a man. Admittedly quite a confused man, but definitely a man. The clue would be the dick and balls 🙄
Quotes a post by T04167; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
‘there is still a decent percentage of the media class denying that “trans rights” have cost women anything.’ 👏 @salltweets
Quoting @salltweets: **A Sort Of Giggle v Tickle Update**
While there is always so much happening behind the scenes, unfortunately, there isn’t much I can say publicly because I can’t say anything until it is on public record. I’d much rather just tell everyone everything that is going on. But I can’t, yet. While I don’t respect the premise of this case, I do respect the process & rules of the court. So it is what it is.
But what I do want to say is, while I very rarely detail the emotional & mental toll of 3.5 years in federal court for knowing men are not women, and having to put your entire professional life and a large portion of your personal life on hold for that, I think it is important to occasionally talk about it.
It’s important, in part, because there is still a decent percentage of the media class denying that “trans rights” have cost women anything. This really grinds my gears. Currently, in Australia, men who claim to be women have more rights than women. We cannot legally say no to them in our spaces, events, services & sport. I think that is a significant problem. A big part of women’s rights is the right to say “no”. Also, the fact that it has been left to ordinary, every day women - most of us, busy mum’s - is relevant.
But really, I don’t talk about the emotion/mental toll, because I don’t really like complaining about it all. Yes, it sucks. Yes, it’s horrible. But that’s obvious. Also, what is obvious, is there are many women in the world going through horrific situations & I think it’s important to have some perspective on that. Basically, I’d rather have the right to fight for women’s rights than not even have that right at all. So I take the right to be able to fight for women’s rights very, very seriously, and appreciate it immensely.
Still,
I will never, ever, forgive the Australian government for leaving this issue up to a single mother whose start up was destroyed by men who claim to be women to fix this obvious problem. At best, I’ll eventually become indifferent to them. But I sure as shit will never waste a moments energy trying to forgive them.
Similarly, I will never even try to forgive nor respect the Australian Human Rights Commission as long as I live. Not only have they completely abandoned the reality of “woman”, they have ignored their mandate to “humans” and “rights” and thrown most of them under the bus to appease the desires of a very select, self-identified, few. Human rights are not human rights if they require other humans to actually give up their rights, and they have seemingly forgotten that when it comes to “trans”.
And, finally, the Australian media continues to be absolutely dismal in relation to this issue. Everything that makes it to mainstream publication is saturated with language to appease the trans demographic - whatever that is - a demographic that will not be satisfied unless total capitulation occurs. In the sporadic event that the fourth estate does acknowledge the plight of women’s rights & freedom of speech/belief in this country, it’s through gritted teeth, but most of the time they ignore it all completely, not accepting that every single absurd thing women are having to deal with in relation to trans is of great interest to many, many citizens.
I can prove this. I have the receipts. Every time there is something relating to GvT I can publicly speak about, I send out a media release. This case was allowed to be heard in federal court because it was deemed in the public interest. So the public should be informed. 99% of the time, I get zero reposes from journalists. Literally zero. Nothing makes it to publication.
Yet, the one thing that makes me the most proud is that this case is alive because of the people supporting it. No massive donors. No gifts. No ulterior motives. Only people who care about women’s rights, and rights in general. And for that, I will forever be grateful. It makes it all worth it.
I’m very optimistic.
Thank you 🩷
http://gigglecrowdfund.com
I'm so sorry to hear what you've been through. Of course you're right. Hysterectomies and the removal of breasts due to cancer are female-specific experiences, just like miscarriage and menopause. I find it grotesquely offensive when trans activists try and use such quintessentially female experiences to justify their redefinition of 'woman' to include men.
I'm not using conjecture. It is provably the case that proportionally more trans-identified men are in jail for sex crimes than among the general male prison population. It is provably the case that men - however they identify - commit the overwhelming majority of sexual and violent crimes. It is provably the case that women and girls make up the vast majority of victims of sex crimes. No amount of word salads and motte-and-bailey fallacies change these cold, hard facts.
That’s not what I asked for. You said proportionaly more women sexually assault other women/girls than trans-identified men do. Show the evidence for the very clear cut assertion you made.
Rowling blocked Hendrix for reasons she and I have talked about privately and we've made our peace. Unless its 'anti-trans' for a woman to detransition, she hasn't been remotely anti-trans. I'm interested in the 'predatory' accusation though, @[private account]. Care to explain?
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Try really hard to remain rooted in reality. Nobody wants 'all the trans people to go away.'
The fact that you think Hendrix and I can't interact without money changing hands says so much more about you than it does her or me. I am not an ATM and she isn't a grifter.
Divert even 1 ° from the approved line - trans-identified men must be considered women in absolutely all situations, no mattter the cost to women and girls - and you’ll pay. Don’t think for yourself, don’t look at concrete evidence, never apologise, just comply.
'Trans woman' is a compound noun meaning 'man who wishes to be considered a woman.' 'Trans' isn't an adjective. Remove 'trans' and you haven't got a woman, you've got a man who doesn't wish to be considered a woman.
It isn't the Supreme Court's job to go house to house and make hot chocolate for every trans person who's disappointed to learn that women have rights, too.
The misrepresentation in certain sections of the media of what the UK Supreme Court's recent ruling actually means is outrageous.
The ruling clarified that women and girls have sex-based rights under British law, and that those rights haven't changed since women gained them.
Trans activist lobby groups lied about what the law said. They claimed trans-identified men were entitled to everything women were entitled to, under the law. This false interpretation, which removed sex-based rights from women and girls and gave trans-identified men additional rights, may have been imposed upon large sections of society, but it was always illegal, as countless legal experts and grassroots women's groups fought to have recognised.
The Supreme Court restored to women rights they'd lost in practice. Trans-identified men lost nothing in law, because they'd never had the rights they claimed they had. The media types now hyperventilating in print because trans people's rights have been 'reduced' are still lying. Nothing has been taken from trans-identified people except a false belief, and women have simply regained what they should have had all along.
Yes, he was a beneficiary of the men's rights movement lurking at the heart of gender activism. When sporting bodies embrace an ideology that claims sex differences don't matter, some men, trans-identified or not, will take advantage. He's one of them.
I never said and never believed Khelif was trans. I knew* he was a man. The gender activists who created a political climate in which sex testing was seen as 'bigoted' are as culpable as the IOC for the travesty that ensued.
*via a highly credible source who saw his test results
“Nothing I can say about the violent, fetishistic narcissism at the heart of trans activism is half as persuasive as what trans activists say themselves.”
This, by @HJoyceGender, is 🎯 https://thecritic.co.uk/the-five-stages-of-victory/
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedfetish fraudpolitical enemyviolence terror
I don't think Khelif can be classed as trans, because his claim has always been that he's biologically female, not that he 'identifies' as a woman. Imo, the only relevance of trans issues to Khelif's case is that the IOC fudged the sex testing requirements because they thought taking that would keep them safe from the ire of gender activists, and screw the consequences for female boxers.
I've said this before: I have nothing but sympathy for anyone who sincerely believes they're one sex, because that's what they've been told all their life, and then finds out they're the other. That must be a truly shattering moment and I can see why said person would take refuge in denial. Some have argued 'but once puberty hit, how could he not know?' but I think that underestimates how much social conditioning and wishful thinking can blind a person to the truth.
All of that said: I have no sympathy for the people surrounding a male boxer who keep pretending, to him and to others, that he's female after seeing the test results, nor for a fully-fledged adult man who's able to comprehend that he's male and has an insurmountable physical advantage when facing a female opponent. At that point, he and everyone else involved in promulgating the lie is knowingly risking the possibility that a female opponent will suffer brain damage or death, just so he can keep winning medals. That's an outrage that far surpasses any harm done to Khelif by taking a cheek swab and accepting facts. He's free to keep boxing, just in the proper sex category. All he loses is the opportunity to cheat.
The funny thing is that by saying ‘men men’ she outs herself as knowing perfectly well that trans women are a different category of men. Get people like Yasmin hot under the collar and they slip up faster than you can say ‘but you’ve got a gender neutral bathroom in your house.’
“Finally, it dawned on me that some members of the transgender-rights movement did not seem to understand that women have human rights too.” Great article 👇 https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/05/27/i-lost-friends-when-i-changed-my-mind-on-trans-rights/
This is a lie, and an easily provable lie. I’ve spent the best part of three decades funding initiatives and donating to charities serving vulnerable women, including domestic violence shelters. The charitable trust I set up in 2000 focuses on alleviating social deprivation, with a focus on women and children, including female refugees. I’ve funded an initiative to help female ex-prisoners secure jobs, I helped fly professional women out of Afghanistan because they were in danger from the Taliban, I’ve publicly voiced my support for women’s reproductive rights, I founded and fund a women-only rape crisis centre and I’ve campaigned for and funded projects to help single mothers.
I myself am a survivor of domestic abuse and sexual assault, as trans activists never tire of reminding me, whether to hope it happens to me again, or assert, as Maugham has, that I was left with unresolved trauma that leaves me irrational on the subject of physical risk to women.
Maugham is imploding in real time because he’s furious the Supreme Court decision put him back in his box. He was wrong on the law. He pretended it said what it doesn’t. The court reaffirmed the sex-based rights of women, but Maugham’s vanity and delusion make it impossible for him to accept (yet another) loss. So his grift continues, his lies grow bigger and more obvious, and now might be a good time for him to reread the myth of Icarus, because nobody needs clairvoyant powers to foresee how this is going to end.
Jolyon, calm down. You're getting testerical.
Over the last 48 hours you've publicly alleged that I'm on an 'anti-trans crusade', that I'm 'gleefully weaponising' sexually threatening messages that are 'likely false flag', that I'm an 'amoral' person and a 'bigot' who's 'waging war' against trans people. You said all of this because I set up a legal fighting fund for women who don't have the financial means to defend their legal rights, rights they were confirmed as having by the Supreme Court ruling which you, of course, allege was the result of misconduct and bias by the judges.
As a top notch legal brain primarily known for defending an attempted tax dodge (Icebreaker), and losing, and for his many crowdfunded losses in court, including the case where you tried to shut down an LGB rights charity, I assumed you'd take it for granted that my lawyers would be keeping a close eye out for comments that stray into defamation.
If we ever end up facing each other in court, my only qualm will be that it seems such a huge waste of taxpayers' money to have to construct a courtroom large enough to accommodate your ego.
Alan 'Sarah Jane' Baker, served 30 years in prison for violent crimes. Initially convicted of kidnap and torture, he was given extra time after trying to murder a cellmate. At a Trans+ Pride event in 2023, Baker told the crowd: 'If you see a TERF, punch them in the f****** face.'
Quoting @_ConnieShaw: “These terfs are basically tosspots” shouts Sarah Jane Baker, a convicted kidnapper and torturer, at five students.
Let’s not forget that the real crime here is quoting the exact words trans-identified men have held aloft on placards while jiggling their moobs at the nearest camera.
Great piece from @[private account] on the meaning of the Supreme Court ruling on women's rights, on the unions and corporations who seemed determined to keep breaking the law, and the complete lack of leadership from Prime Minister @Keir_Starmer.
https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/unions-and-bosses-are-flouting-trans-ruling-q8rxpvb72
There is no more oppressed person on this planet than an angry white male newsreader who's milked his trans status for all it's worth and still hasn't been given his own talk show, Julie.
The faux feminists who’re acting as useful idiots for trans activism have no choice but to frame their willing surrender of women-specific rights, spaces and issues as progress. They’re classic collaborators. Secret shame hidden beneath a ton of sneery bombast.
The Supreme Court ruling has wrought no legal changes at all. It clarified that some organisations have acted illegally in letting trans-identified people use the opposite sex's protected spaces. They've been advised that they shouldn't have been doing it and must stop doing it.
Trans activists are trying to trash the career of musician @[private account] because he hasn't silenced his female partner, who speaks up in defence of women's rights.
I've just bought an album and a T-shirt at the link below.
Be a shame if anyone else did.
https://doozermcdooze.bandcamp.com/album/fire
We’re talking about reality. Some trans-identified men pose a risk to women and girls. This has been amply proven. The fact that you don’t want it to be true doesn’t make it false. No genuine dialogue is possible when one side refuses to accept a key fact.
Among the thousands of supportive emails I’ve had have been many medical people saying much the same. One of the worst was from a nurse who worked on a geriatric ward and said she’d just been given guidance on what to do with a patient with dementia who was suffering severe distress because they no longer understood what had happened to their surgically-altered body or why they were being talked about as the opposite sex. She said she’d never met or heard of any gay person with Alzheimer’s who’d forgotten that they were same-sex attracted and asked, rhetorically, why medical staff like her were pressured never to talk about the issue or ask questions. She also said her patient wasn’t the only older trans-identified person with Alzheimer’s she knew of who was deeply disturbed by changes in their body they no longer remembered wanting or consenting to.
Give me the oral histories, 16th century ballads, medieval tapestries showing trans women photographing themselves in the Ladies, cave paintings of men in suspender belts and bad make up! Let's celebrate the mysterious trans-identified men who led the fight for women's rights.
The ability to assert several contradictory things at once is one of the key features of trans activism. Sex is mysterious, incomprehensible and unknowable, yet 'man' and 'woman' can be used their ordinary biological senses without any need for DNA tests.
Will members of the Scottish parliament who posed happily in front of 'Decapitate TERFs' signs feel any differently now it's parliamentarians trans activists are saying should be beheaded?
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentviolence terror
So the police are dragging their heels on stopping males strip-searching females, which, as the Supreme Court ruling confirmed, was illegal all along. I'm sure they hope no woman decides to sue.
Of course, I'll fund her if she does.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/05/03/police-trans-officers-from-strip-search-women/
“[We were told to] offer automatic ‘affirmation’ of gender identity, even in very young children, including those with complex psychiatric conditions... Incredibly, we were also asked to accept the claimed gender identity of serious sex offenders.”
https://www.sundaypost.com/fp/transgender-ideology-pushed-by-social-care-workers-has-caused-real-harm-to-children/
In light of recent open letters from academia and the arts criticising the UK's Supreme Court ruling on sex-based rights, it's possibly worth remembering that nobody sane believes, or has ever believed, that humans can change sex, or that binary sex isn't a material fact. These letters do nothing but remind us of what we know only too well: that pretending to believe these things has become an elitist badge of virtue.
I often wonder whether the signatories of such letters have to quieten their consciences before publicly boosting a movement intent on removing women's and girls' rights, which bullies gay people who admit openly they don't want opposite sex partners, and campaigns for the continued sterilisation of vulnerable and troubled kids. Do they feel any qualms at all while chanting the foundational lie of their religion: Trans Women are Women, Trans Men are Men?
I have no idea. All I know for sure is that it's a complete waste of time telling a gender activist that their favourite slogan is self-contradictory nonsense, because the lie is the whole point. They're not repeating it because it's true - they know full well it's not true - but because they believe they can make it true, sort of, if they force everyone else to agree. The foundational lie functions as both catechism and crucifix: the set form of words that obviates the tedious necessity of coming up with your own explanation of why you're one of the Godly, and an exorcist's weapon which will defeat demonic facts and reason, and promote the advance of righteous pseudoscience and sophistry.
Some argue that signatories of these sorts of letters are motivated by fear: fear for their careers, of course, but also fear of their co-religionists, who include angry, narcissistic men who threaten and sometimes enact violence on non-believers; back-stabbing colleagues ever ready to report wrongthink; the online shamers and doxxers and rape threateners, and, of course, the influential zealots in the upper echelons of liberal professions (though we can quibble whether they're actually liberal at all, given the draconian authoritarianism that seems to have engulfed so many). Gender ideology could give medieval Catholicism a run for its money when it comes to punishing heretics, so isn't it common sense to keep your head down and recite your Hail Mulvaneys?
But before we start feeling too sorry for any cowed and fearful TWAWites who're TERFy on the sly, let's not forget what a high proportion of them have willingly snatched up pitchforks and torches to join the inquisitional purges. Call me lacking in proper womanly sympathy, but I find the harm they've enabled and in some cases directly championed or funded - the hounding and shaming of vulnerable women, the forced loss of livelihoods, the unregulated medical experiment on minors - tends to dry up my tears at source.
History is littered with the debris of irrational and harmful belief systems that once seemed unassailable. As Orwell said, 'Some ideas are so stupid that only intellectuals believe them.' Gender ideology may have embedded itself deeply into our institutions, where it's been imposed, top-down, on the supposedly unenlightened, but it is not invulnerable.
Court losses are starting to stack up. The condescension, overreach, entitlement and aggression of gender activists is eroding public support daily. Women are fighting back and winning significant victories. Sporting bodies have miraculously awoken from their slumber and remembered that males tend to be larger, stronger and faster than females. Parts of the medical establishment are questioning cutting healthy breasts off teenaged girls is really the best way to fix their mental health problems.
One seemingly harmless little white lie - Trans Women are Women, Trans Men are Men - uttered in most cases without any real thought at all, and a few short years later, people who think of themselves as supremely virtuous are typing 'yes, rapists' pronouns are absolutely the hill I'll die on,' rubbing shoulders with those who call for women to be hanged and decapitated for wanting all-female rape crisis centres, and furiously denying clear and mounting evidence of the greatest medical scandal in a century.
I wonder if they ever ask themselves how they got here, and I wonder whether any of them will ever feel shame.
.@[private account] advises trans-identified men to keep breaking the law by using women's bathrooms. This, the founder says gleefully, will mean more rapists go free, which @JolyonMaugham seems to think a fitting punishment for the women who fought to protect single-sex spaces.
All available studies show that trans-identified men commit sexual offences at the same, or higher, rates as non-trans identified men. Please explain why women and girls should let them into their spaces regardless.
Literally nobody on my side of this argument doesn’t want trans-identified people to be safe. They don’t want women and girls to be LESS safe. Fact: 100% of the men women have no need to fear are on my side, because they’re realistic about male violence and male sexual predation.
I refer you to the question I just asked: why not campaign for third spaces if it’s genuinely everyone’s safety you’re concerned about? Why are so many non-trans-identified men so eager to see women and girls forced to accept men into their spaces?
'Sweetie was a spoiled, badly trained pooch... Every outburst was met with a treat and a coo, because Sweetie had learnt early on that if he made enough noise, the world would bend to his will.'
On trans activism and obnoxious poodles, by @jo_bartosch.
https://unherd.com/newsroom/supreme-court-challenge-is-a-last-howl-from-dying-trans-activism/
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] We're admitting men might pretend to be 'trans' now, are we? This is a step forward.
You've literally spent days arguing for stripping women of their right to single sex spaces when you could have been reassuring trans-identified men they'd be safe in the men's facilities. Why is it so important to you that women and girls can't exclude men when undressed?
Funny, isn’t it, how women who’ve been raped or beaten are accused of ‘weaponising’ their trauma when they ask for male-free spaces, but trans-identified men who claim using the Gents has a higher mortality rate than armed combat are met with credulity and simpering concern.
If I understand you correctly, you’re saying some predatory men might claim to be trans to get into a women’s changing room, while also arguing that no predatory man would claim to be trans to get into a changing room.
'Trans women' are male.
If they weren't male they wouldn't be 'trans'.
Prejudice is an irrational fear or dislike.
It is entirely rational to state that a man is a man.
Only totalitarians and religious zealots insist that others parrot falsehoods on pain of retribution.
I hate to point this out*, but accusing me of hating men because I don't think trans women should be given access to all women-only spaces does rather suggest that (in spite of your feverish assertions to the contrary) you're well aware that these are, in fact, men.
*I don't.
🙄I'm married to a man, George. I do not hate men. I simply live in reality where men - however they identify - commit 98% of sexual assaults, and 88% of victims are female. Trans-identified men are no less likely than other kinds of men to pose a risk to women or girls.
Beira's Place has accepted trans-identified women who've suffered sexual assault from its inception, and the only thing I want to do about it is reassure them they're welcome. They're biological women and they're consequently as welcome as any other woman.
I've seen the prison stats in the UK and yes, at first glance that's what they seem to show, but I think one would need to be an informed statistician/academic or scientific researcher to properly analyse that data. When did the trans-identification occur, before or after conviction? Is the trans-identified individual androphilic, gynephilic or both? Do they have a proven history of gender dysphoria or is this evidence of a cross-dressing paraphilia? Such analysis is well above my pay grade. All I know for sure is that trans-identified men have never been proven to be less of a threat to women than other men, and the evidence we have to date suggests that they are, at the most conservative estimate, at least as much of a risk.
I have never framed all trans women as threats. The evidence shows that trans women commit sexual offences at the same rate as other males. You seem incapable of understanding that women, too, are human beings worthy of dignity and respect.
It seems literally impossible for certain trans activists to grasp that not everything is about them.
The only rape crisis centre in Edinburgh prior to the opening of Beira’s Place was run by a trans-identified man who publicly told potential service-users they would be ‘challenged on their bigotry’ if they didn’t agree he was a woman. Meanwhile a ‘non-binary’ man subsequently convicted of rape, and found by the sentencing judge to harbour serious hostility towards women, was permitted to access the centre’s services.
Trans-identified men in Edinburgh were better served than women when it came to accessing support after rape or sexual assault. Beira’s Place, which I founded and fund in its entirety, gives women a choice. The female-led, female-centred model of support is provably preferred by most female survivors. We know for a fact that some of our service-users didn’t seek help before we opened, because they didn’t want a male providing their therapy, or for men to be accessing what they needed to feel was a completely safe space. However, if a woman was happy with a male support worker, or with males also using the service, she could of course choose the alternative rape crisis centre.
Some men, trans-identified and not, disagree that even the most vulnerable and traumatised women should be allowed to exclude men from rape crisis centres, yet many women see a male-free space and service as the last or only chance of putting their lives back together. It takes immense courage even to pick up the phone to access help after rape. Yet, even at their worst moment, these women told by activists like Willoughby that their priority should be centering his feelings, pandering to his ‘identity’ and pretending that they don’t recognise his narcissism and aggression as a quintessentially male response to not being given what he wants, by women.
The simple truth is that no decent male, however they identify, would ever seek to breach the boundaries of women whose sense of self and safety has been shattered by their experience of male violence or rape. 98% of sexual predators are male. 88% of sexual crime victims are female. Beira’s Place exists because I saw an unmet need and the fact that we’ve been so busy since we’ve opened proves, not that women hate trans-identified men, but that this is where women feel safe enough to deal with trauma they might otherwise have had to carry with them forever.
Absolutely spot on by @suzanne_moore, who eviscerates two men whose classism has never been more in evidence than on this issue. Why listen to Keira Bell, Sandie Peggie or the Darlington nurses when women inside your hyper-privileged bubble agree with you?
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/04/24/alastair-campbell-thinks-women-fighting-trans-activism/
@[private account] @[private account] Trans-identified men haven’t had any rights revoked. Under the terms of the 2010 Equality Act, they didn’t have the right to use single sex spaces. That’s precisely what the Supreme Court has just clarified. Trans-identified men’s presence in women-only spaces is illegal.
'The most dangerous moment in a woman’s life is when she stands up to an abusive man. Some [trans activists] appear to be itching for a confrontation; it is clear that someone could get seriously hurt... Refusing to speak is taking sides.'✍️@[private account]
https://unherd.com/newsroom/starmers-silence-on-supreme-court-ruling-is-deafening/
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
Janice isn't claiming to speak for all women, @PennyRed, but given that you aren't one ('the category of "woman" does not fully describe my lived experience') it's hard to see why you should be speaking for any women at all.
Literally nobody thinks the Supreme Court ruling 'legislates trans people out of existence.' Trans people have exactly the same rights and protections they had before the ruling, and unless they've mass combusted while I wasn't paying attention, I'm fairly sure they continue to exist.
If some trans-identified people in the UK are currently experiencing rage and disappointment because the Supreme Court clarified that they don't have rights they believed they had, the responsibility lies firmly with activist groups and sections of the media who've persistently argued, falsely, that gender transition turned a person into the opposite sex for all practical purposes in the eyes of the law.
You can personally take some responsibility for that state of affairs, of course, because you've spent the last few years enthusiastically championing the removal of single-sex spaces for women and girls. Indeed, you went so far as to tell the mother of a fifteen-year-old who asked how her daughter was supposed to feel on discovering a penised stranger in the girls' changing rooms, 'I'd tell her it's rude to stare at other people's genitals.' That anti-woman, anti-safeguarding quip puts you right up there with every male creep who's spent recent years insisting women and girls have no right to privacy, dignity or safety.
You'll undoubtedly continue to offer your contributions to the debate, but don't be too surprised if a lot of old-school women (the boring kind who've been deprived of the fascinating experiences that make you non-binary and genderqueer) find it supremely easy to disregard anything you've got to say on the subject.
Quoting @PennyRed: Turner doesn’t speak for all women, and certainly not for all feminists.
TERFs seem to think this ruling legislates trans people out of existence. It does not.
Trans people will continue to exist. They will continue to deserve dignity and human rights. How is this ‘over’?
Many women are waiting to hear the Prime Minister's views on the Supreme Court ruling. After all, he's the man who decreed: 'A woman is a female adult, and in addition to that trans women are women, and that is not just my view, that is actually the law.'
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/04/17/the-daily-t-starmer-silence-trans-supreme-court-ruling/
Males with 5ARD are not female.
Trans-identified people remain protected under UK law.
The Supreme Court has confirmed that trans-identified men are not entitled to women's sex-based rights.
I'm sorry you don't have better talking points.
The fact that so many UK trans activists are shrieking about injustice says it all. You never had the rights you claim you've now lost; you had demands. Your sense of entitlement grew unchecked because cowards and idiots bowed down to your campaign of intimidation. No longer. 2/2
Winners in the UK Supreme Court today:
Women and girls, including trans-identified women (continue to benefit from maternity rights etc)
Gay people
Freedom of speech
Freedom of association
Those at risk of discrimination for a belief in the material reality of sex.
1/2
Misogyny is not 'based off the gender others perceive you as.' Prejudice against trans-identified men is real, but it isn't and never has been rooted in a belief that such men are actually women. Quite the reverse.
I'm no more denying a trans-identified man's 'humanity' by calling him a man than I dehumanise a white person by accurately naming their skin colour. You appear to believe it's every woman's duty to set aside their own interests to affirm and validate such men, but I disagree.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] Can you point to what I’ve ever said that shows I think trans people are ‘subhuman’?
I’ve just acknowledged that trans-identified men experience prejudice. It’s just not misogyny.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] Trans women don’t suffer misogyny, although some claim to experience it because they think it’s proof they’re women. Trans-identified men do experience prejudice, but that stems from some people’s dislike of effeminate/fetishistic men. Such prejudice is not misogyny.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] No trans-identified man experiences misogyny, which, by definition, is hatred of females. Trans-identified men may experience prejudice due to perceived effeminacy or for assumed deviance, but that isn’t misogyny.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] She has a female body - a body organised to produce large gametes - something no man, trans-identified or not, can ever experience. She lives life while inhabiting a female body. That’s all there is to it.
🙄The fringe idea that we all have a 'gender identity' that may or may not match our biological sex is the whole point of this discussion. Trans activists act as though the existence of 'gender identity' is a settled, self-evident point, when to the vast majority of the world it's unevidenced, quasi-religious, pseudoscientific nonsense, which has been imposed top down on our society with serious consequences for vulnerable women and troubled youth in particular.
Meaningful discussion about competing needs and rights cannot happen inside an elitist ideological bubble where everyone is forced to adopt gender ideology's approved jargon, accept its self-contradicting slogans as fact and pretend fact-light assertions and feeble sophistry are critical thinking.
You tell us to 'educate' ourselves, by which you mean, 'adopt our beliefs unquestioningly,' but at this point, most of us know your arguments off by heart. These include, but are not limited to: feelings trump facts and unless we agree we're 'erasing people from existence'; women and girls aren't definable entities, so why should they be entitled to their own sports and single-sex spaces; clownfish and people with DSDs mean sex is 'on a spectrum' and 'woman' is a set of stereotypes associated with the female sex class, so it doesn't matter if you've got a penis, if you identify with those stereotypes you're 'valid'.
The reason we haven't been won over by these talking points and remain so tragically 'uneducated' isn't that we've failed to grasp the sophistication of your world view. It's that we think you're talking unadulterated bullshit and making fools of yourselves.
Your ideology crumbles to dust if you concede that the difference between what you call ‘cis’ women and trans-identified men is that the former are female and the latter are male. You can’t explain what makes some men women without invoking the ideological concept of ‘gender identity’, an ineffable, unfalsifiable concept in which most people don’t believe. Good faith argument is not possible if one side demands submission to two unevidenced beliefs before discussion can begin. I’m afraid that when you arm yourself with trans activist clichés and regurgitate whichever one seems most appropriate in the moment, then fall back on ad hominem attacks if you meet resistance, you don’t need anyone else’s help to become to ‘some kind of caricature.’
For years now, you and your ilk have jackbooted around demanding that trans-identified men be treated in all respects and in all circumstances as identical to biological women. Even to mention physical difference was ‘transphobic’, so spare us the panicked attempts to backtrack.