The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
And if you were discriminated against for being trans - if you lost employment, or housing, or the right to vote, or to love/marry whomsoever you please, simply for being trans-identified - I’d definitely march with you. Which of these are trans people being denied at the moment?
Stereotypes are simplistic/prejudiced blanket assumptions about a demographic that don't correlate with the facts. I know all trans people aren't cheats. However, knowing you have an unfair advantage and exploiting it anyway is pretty much the textbook definition of cheating.
Commentators pretending critics of the IOC’s reliance on documents rather than sex testing think Khelif is trans are straw-manning. I don’t claim Khelif is trans. My objection, and that of many others, is to male violence against women becoming an Olympic sport.
Quoting @MForstater: "Deeply irresponsible" says @TheSun
No not the IOC for allowing individuals w XY chromosomes, testes & male levels of T to punch women for sport if their passport says "F"
But JKR for saying such a person is male.
You could not make it up.
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/29704396/imane-khelif-olympics-boxer/
The idea that those objecting to a male punching a female in the name of sport are objecting because they believe Khelif to be ‘trans’ is a joke. We object because we saw a male punching a female.
Quotes a post by T09154; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A woman who thinks trans-identified sex offenders should be in ‘the prison of their choosing’ was hardly going to balk at males in women’s sport, was she? @lisanandy told us loudly and proudly who she was pre-election. She’s one of the main reasons I couldn’t vote Labour 🤷🏻♀️
'Women and children are casualties in the uncompromising campaign waged by trans activists.'
Must read article by clinical psychologist Sandra Pertot on the aggressive, absolutist tactics of trans activists and the doctors who side with them.
https://www.genderclinicnews.com/p/no-prisoners
The grim reckoning isn’t for trans people. It’s for those who’ve caused harm, ignored plain evidence of harm and/or cheered on the dismantlement of safeguarding for women and minors.
I'm so very sorry that happened to you. This insight is so important. Nobody can justify emotional manipulation, but I've never forgotten that that doesn't mean the person attempting the manipulation isn't hurting deeply. I see a lot of 'so you're a narcissist' bandied about on here, to the extent that it completely devalues the term, and far worse is seeing it thrown at people who seem very fragile and desperate, even if they're behaving badly on social media. I find it unforgivable that a central tactic of militant gender activism is hyperbolic doom-mongering. If people don't validate your gender identity they want you to die, if you don't get to transition, you'll kill yourself, etc. None of us are capable of being our best selves when we're deeply traumatised or mentally ill, and activists insisting that there's no explanation for questioning the affirmative model for young people other than that non-believers hate trans people is outright cruelty. It isn't true, but puts really vulnerable people into constant fight mode.
That a male sexual predator was able to access the services of the Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre should beggar belief, but, of course, it doesn't. ERCC is still run by the trans-identified male who believes women who want single-sex services are bigots.
Quoting @bindelj: "A former SNP equalities officer who once told how he wanted to "beat the f***" out of gender critical feminists has been jailed for a string of sexual and physical assaults." Downing was a service user of Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre.
https://www.judiciary.scot/home/sentences-judgments/sentences-and-opinions/2024/07/16/hma-v-cameron-downing
Well, yes, it depends on how you interpret the statement. Do I believe there are people who’ve taken steps to present themselves as the opposite sex, or who wish they were the opposite sex, and call themselves trans? Yes, clearly such people exist and they deserve the same rights as everyone else.
Do I believe in the idea that we all have a gendered essence that can accidentally turn up in the ‘wrong’ body? No, I don’t.
The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) attempted to manipulate/suppress medical evidence from the Johns Hopkins University Evidence-Based Practice Centre 👇
https://segm.org/The-Economist-WPATH-Research-Trans-Medicine-Manipulated
Whistleblowers have been speaking out for years: '[Gender clinics are] risking a “live experiment” by sending hundreds for life-changing medical intervention without sufficient evidence of its long-term effects, experts have warned.' 3/10
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/calls-to-end-transgender-experiment-on-children-k792rfj7d
The usual lies are being trotted out by trans activists. 'Puberty blockers have been used for years and are proven to be entirely safe!'
But this is untrue. 'Thousands of women claim Lupron ruined their lives or left them crippled.' 2/10
https://www.statnews.com/2017/02/02/lupron-puberty-children-health-problems/
.@wesstreeting, the UK's new Health Secretary, has indicated that he plans to make the temporary ban on puberty blockers permanent. This has made the usual suspects very angry. Streeting, they say, will have 'blood on his hands.' He will 'kill trans kids.' 1/10
Woman's Hour, March 8, 2022
Emma Barnes: And Labour’s definition of a woman?
Annaliese Dodds: Well, I have to say that there are different definitions legally around what a woman actually is. I mean you look at the definition within the Equality Act and I think it just says someone who is adult and female, I think, but then doesn’t say how you define either of those things. I mean that’s then… you’ve got the biological definition, the legal definition, all of this kind of thing.
Emma Barnes: With respect I didn’t ask for that. What’s the Labour definition?
Annaliese Dodds: Well, I think with respect Emma I think it does depend what the context is, surely. You know there are people who have decided to…that they have to make that transition. You know, I’ve spoken with many of them. It’s been a very difficult process for many of those people, and you know understandably because they live as a woman they want to be defined as a woman. That’s what the Gender Recognition Act – again a Labour process – brought into place.
Emma Barnes: Context is all, but trans women are women from your perspective?
Annaliese Dodds: But, but then when you come to the Equality Act, and you know Emma I’m not going to…
Emma Barnes: No no, you’re just Shadow Women and Equalities Minister.
1/2
Quoting @10DowningStreet: Anneliese Dodds MP @[private account] has been appointed Minister of State in the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office @[private account].
She has also been appointed Minister for Women and Equalities in the Department for Education @[private account].
She will attend Cabinet.
I'm sure I'm older than you, and I well remember the fight for gay rights in the 80s. To say the choice is between 'asking nicely' and what trans activists are currently engaged in is frankly ridiculous. Never did gay rights activists demand that other protected groups lose rights. Never did gay people harangue other liberation movements, for different protected groups (women, people of colour), to centre them rather than themselves. There was no forced teaming, no demanding that anyone change the language they use to describe themselves, only a fight to have the same rights as everybody else: same age of consent, freedom to love who they loved, marry whomsoever they wanted to marry, freedom from discrimination. Every gay person I knew then was pro-freedom of speech and belief.
Gay people didn't win rights by behaving as militant trans activists behave. They didn't put on masks and rough up women. They didn't threaten opponents with death or rape or try to take away their livelihoods. They weren't declaring that straight people who didn't want to sleep with them were homophobic. As for 'standing up to the establishment,' gender identity ideology has embedded itself in the establishment to an extent the gay rights movement of the 80s could only have dreamed of.
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentideology cultlgb wedgepolitical enemyviolence terror
The gay people I know/have had contact with who're either directly involved in or supportive of LGB Alliance have concerns around militant trans activism, specifically its often abusive and threatening tactics, its frequent embrace of misogyny and homophobia, its attempts to dictate to other protected groups how they should describe/comport themselves and its practise of forced teaming. Having concerns around clashes of existing rights/activist demands, and misgivings about the harm a militant activist movement is doing to other groups is in no way equivalent wishing harm to befall any individual trans person, and I've never heard any such wish expressed by anyone I know or have heard from on this issue.
They aren't claiming to represent you. They aren't claiming to represent anyone except same-sex attracted people who feel their rights and issues have been forgotten by organisations now devoting themselves entirely to trans activism.
It isn't a female changing room if it includes trans-identified men. I hope the Darlington nurses know how many millions of women stand with them.
https://www.thenorthernecho.co.uk/news/24410259.wes-streeting-horrified-darlington-memorial-hospital-trans-row/
Quotes a post by A3013; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Setting aside the number of trans widows who’ve written to me, I’ve personally known one woman who divorced a fetishist cross-dresser. She was older than me and her ex was highly abusive. She endured years of shame, in addition to the abuse. It simply wasn’t talked about then.
A 2018 Sunday Times freedom of information request revealed that 88% of sexual assaults that happen in changing rooms take place in those that are mixed sex. No study has shown that trans-identified men don’t retain male pattern criminal offending.
Talking about women's rights and the protection thereof in the context of a general election may sound like 'yelling about trans people' to you, but I'm afraid I think the issue lies with you, not me.
I’m fine with anyone supporting the trans community. I’m not fine when that turns into removing women’s and girls’ rights. I’m especially not OK with the needs of vulnerable women and girls being framed as bigotry.
They're as likely to be a danger to girls and women as any other men. No study has ever shown they don't have male patterns of sex offending and there are proportionately more trans-identified-men in jail for sex crimes in the UK than among the male prison population as a whole.
@[private account] @Keir_Starmer And what does that translate to, in real terms? Exactly what Bridget Phillipson said earlier. Single sex spaces aren't protected. Trans-identified men with a GRC can access them too.
Under UK law, only men can commit rape, but once again female rape survivors get to watch as crown servants who're supposed to be on their side prioritise respecting a rapist's hastily and conveniently assumed 'gender identity' over victims' feelings.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13569193/transgender-Wiltshire-force-refuse-specify-rapists-biological-sex.html
The nurses who are suing County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust for letting a trans-identified man watch them change. The women and girls being robbed of sporting opportunities. It's endless.
Oh, and also, for about the millionth bloody time - this is not about trans rights. This is about THE RIGHTS OF WOMEN AND GIRLS and lobby groups' attempts to remove them.
The Times view on trans rights: Luxury Beliefs https://www.thetimes.com/comment/the-times-view/article/the-times-view-on-trans-rights-luxury-beliefs-mzsfp62b2
For those who don't know, Sarah Jane Baker is a trans-identified man who served 30 years in prison for kidnap and attempted murder. He was previously recalled to men's prison for urging the crowd to 'punch a TERF' at a London Pride rally.
Quotes a post by T03869; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
We're constantly told this is about trans rights. It isn't. It's about women's rights, and trans activist demands that those rights should be dismantled.
Quotes a post by A0507; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
How many insurance claims has Chairs 4 Trans put in this year? I refuse to be the scapegoat for another scam. While I'd never choose to be a whistleblower - I am a timorous soul by nature - fate appears to have decreed otherwise.
Never forget: there is no clash between women's rights and trans demands, but defence of women's rights is inherently hateful and transphobic.
Quoting @Kevin_Maguire: Social care? Economy? NHS? Borders?
Nah, @KemiBadenoch wants to whip up hatred against the trans minority.
No wonder they’re losing this election.
Lottery grant of half a million for lobby group Mermaids, which has been going into schools to explain how gender is a spectrum. Stonewall charging workplaces to give training, and then marking their homework. Scottish government only providing funding rape crisis centres if they agree to take trans-identified men. Jennifer Pritzer's $2 million donation to create an academic chair of transgender studies. Big pharma happily raking in the profits as young people are turned into lifelong medical patients. These, and many, many more examples of the money-making opportunities afforded by gender identity ideology, are all out there in public for you to see.
You might also like to read this: https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-document-that-reveals-the-remarkable-tactics-of-trans-lobbyists/. The tactics of gender ideologues have been highly unusual for a supposed civil rights movement.
I'll always be able to feed my family. The really brave have put their livelihoods on the line. I know women who've been physically assaulted by trans activists. The real heroines are the regular women who've fought back and I'm so proud to stand with them.
Some trans-identified men are demonstrably dangerous. How do women and girls distinguish those who are from those aren't?
https://www.sundayworld.com/crime/courts/barbie-kardashian-threats-to-kill-trial-adjourned-for-psychiatric-report/a2133909789.html
You made an unsolicited public comment you now decline to explain. Can you see why people think trans activists don’t have arguments, just ad hominem attacks and unevidenced claims?
This article features an extract from an essay I contributed to a book written by those on the frontline of the fight for women's rights in Scotland. For my full essay and over 30 others, buy 'The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht', which is published tomorrow.
https://www.thetimes.com/culture/books/article/jk-rowling-stand-up-women-trans-book-r6jlglpvq
The consequences of young women taking testosterone: "Around 87% of the participants had urinary symptoms... 74% had bowel issues including constipation or being unable to hold stools or wind in... almost half had an “orgasm disorder”..."
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/05/26/trans-problems-urinary-bowel-incontinent-young-detransition/
What interests me is that you assert that trans people are best qualified to explain what it is to be a woman, but you seem to think women don't have the right to an opinion on the subject.
'Explain how trans activism and women's rights are in conflict.'
[Gives long, evidenced list of ways in which they're demonstrably in conflict - sport, single sex spaces, loss of female honours/opportunites to men etc]
'Oh my God, why are you even talking.'
I've never met anyone who doesn't think trans people deserve the same rights and protections as everyone else. Militant trans activism doesn't want trans people to have the same rights, though. It wants women's and girls' rights and protections dismantled for the benefit of men.
Within their quasi-religious echo chamber 'trans women are women' is chanted as an unquestionable holy truth, so they're perpetually shocked by the open heresy of non-believers.
Astounding how often militant trans activists tell the rest of us, ‘so what you’re saying is, trans girls aren’t real girls’. Yes, that’s exactly what we’re saying. Girls are being robbed of honours and opportunities by mediocre, uber-privileged, establishment-enabled boys.
When trans-identified men stop sex offending at exactly the same rate as other men, as all available statistics show they do, you might have a valid argument. In the meantime, women and girls, who make up 88% of sexual assault victims, need single sex spaces.
How many assaults are acceptable to validate trans-identified men's identities? Women and girls are not support animals or human shields. Asking them to coddle male feelings when they're at their most vulnerable is grotesque. 2/3
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/03/17/hospital-told-police-patient-not-raped-alleged-attacker-transgender/
Fuck off with this 'segregation' crap. Women-only hospital wards are safeguarding, not segregation, @[private account]. The appropriation of terms relating to other groups' historic oppression is one of the most obnoxious features of militant trans activism. 1/3
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I worked as Dame Katy's PA for a while. It's a long story, but basically, I misgendered Nicola Sturgeon's cat and it was either community service working at Dame Katy's charity 'Chairs 4 Trans', or a month's jail. Believe me, if I had my time over, I'd head straight for the cell.
'After two SNP leaders who backed trans ideology have gone, will the next one stand up for reality?' ✍️Susan Dalgety https://www.scotsman.com/news/opinion/columnists/humza-yousafs-adherence-to-trans-ideology-played-a-part-in-his-political-demise-will-next-snp-leader-stand-up-for-reality-susan-dalgety-4609309
This is absolutely brilliant.
✍️@[private account], whose book 'Gay Shame: The Rise of Gender Ideology and the New Homophobia' I just bought.
https://www.spiked-online.com/2024/04/28/meet-the-mean-boys-of-trans-activism/
There have been loads of those. Over the last few months I've been told I'm trans, closeted trans, too scared to transition and (my personal favourite) that I'm a man with Klinefelter syndrome.
I certainly will take a lot away from this conversation.
As I've said publicly before (on the Witchcraft Trials podcast, for one), I've always accepted that for some people, transition is the only way to live comfortably in the world and I want those people to be given precisely the same rights to fair treatment and personal safety as anyone else. As I've also said before, I know an older trans woman, previously a gay man, who (I believe and hope) hasn't ever regretted transitioning. I'm glad you regret nothing, either. I'd like to think everyone who's transitioned feels exactly the same way, although sadly I know that's not the case. Aside from the young female detransitioners with whom I'm in direct contact, I've also heard from trans-identified men who also deeply regret their surgeries. Those men were dealing with significant mental illness when they made the decision to transition and feel that should have been identified/addressed by the medical profession before they were encouraged to take irreversible physical steps that have left them with serious health issues.
I've never once suggested that all trans women are predators, nor do I believe that, but we're clearly not going to agree on the single sex spaces issue. The argument that women will be raped/assaulted anyway, so why not let trans-identified men into their spaces, seems frankly callous to me. I can't remember a single feminist arguing that trans women don't need to go to a bathroom to get beaten up, so let them use the gents, but that's precisely the argument many trans activists use regarding women and girls. I've also said many times that I want trans women to be safe, without making girls and women less safe. I also think it's grotesquely unfair to allow trans-identified men to compete against women in sport.
What you perhaps don't realise is that it's precisely because I feel huge empathy for, and identify strongly with, people who feel different or alienated that I'm so deeply concerned that young people who fall into that category aren't being given the right support.
Anyway: we disagree, but I want to thank you again for explaining your position. I wish you nothing but a long and happy life and hope your present is full of love, as you deserve.
I've never claimed single-sex spaces have successfully kept out every man intent on voyeurism or sexual assault, but the statistics don't lie: unisex spaces are more dangerous for women and girls. As the saying goes 'good men stay out so bad men stand out.' A study done by the Sunday Times found that 88% of sexual assaults committed in changing rooms happen in those that are unisex and as we both know, nearly 90% of sexual assault victims are female.
No study has shown that trans-identified males don't retain a male pattern of criminality. That doesn't mean I think all trans women are predators, far from it, but some demonstrably are, and as a criminal defence lawyer (I have one in my family, so I know this), you'll know that sexual predators will go to literally any lengths to access victims. If claiming to be a woman is the price of entry, they will do it, and indeed already have, in many well-documented cases.
So you're right, I don't believe trans-identified men should be able to access single-sex spaces set aside for women and girls. I agree that there are many fights worth fighting currently, and I give time and money to them, too, but the prospect of half the world's population losing rights for which they've fought so hard seems to me a very important battle, and that's before we get to the rising number of minors who regret what was done to them in the name of gender identity ideology. I'm particularly worried about vulnerable girls and young lesbians being put on a medical pathway that may leave them infertile, in pain and unable to achieve orgasm. I'm in contact with quite a few such girls now and their stories are harrowing.
Thank you for the measured discussion, though. I know from previous tweets you don't like me or my views, but I appreciate you setting out your position like this.
I apologise for thinking you were a trans woman, it wasn't clear in the tweet to which I replied, only that you're trans. You seem to be acknowledging that you know what it is to be female because of your biology, as you draw a distinction between your pre-transition self and post-transition self.
You go on to say: 'I'm not a trans woman... so please don't tell me I don't know what it's like to be female,' and there, too, you seem to be acknowledging that, unlike you, trans-identified men don't know what it is to be female, because they have different biology to you.
Where we seem to differ is that I oppose changing the definition of 'women' so that men can enter single sex spaces, compete against women in sport, and take jobs and honours supposedly for women. As someone who knows what it is to be female, because they were born with a female body, do you think those things are fair or desirable? Is harm to women and girls acceptable, if done to assuage trans-identified men's feelings?
@[private account] @[private account] With respect, you joined this conversation when you’re neither a woman nor trans and your rights are in no way affected by the issue. My questions are absolutely in good faith. The OP stated that trans women are women. My question stands: what makes men women?
Nobody's pissed off or trying to silence you. I simply disagreed with your publicly expressed opinion, which is one I've seen repeatedly and indeed addressed just last week. You've replied to me many, many times, so I wasn't aware you wanted anonymity over and above your name and avatar. From now on, I'll happily hide your name.
I'm interested in whether you see any irony in telling me I'm not trans so not qualified to speak, when you have literally no idea what it is to grow up female, yet feel entitled to redefine 'woman' to include yourself?
If you genuinely think those of us who believe medical experimentation on children is wrong do so because we see trans people as subhuman, you're so lost to reason I wouldn't trust you to run a hot dog stand, let alone a major city.
Quotes a post by T09214; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Again, you prefer bromides to engaging with the issues. Young people have suffered irreversible harm. Are they supposed to feel compassionate towards the people jeering at them and threatening them for sharing their stories? Are lesbians supposed to be nice and polite towards the men trying to shame them into doing dick? Are rape survivors supposed to feel kindly towards those removing their few single-sex spaces? ‘Why can’t we all behave like we’re at a dinner party’ isn’t a solution, it’s a way of making issues invisible so people who don’t want to think about them aren’t made to feel uncomfortable. You lecture only one side in this debate and we both know why. You’re scared of the trans activists, and it’s far easier to tell women to be nice than face down the kind of people who issue death threats.
Trans-identified men have sent violent threats to women but the likes of Beth Douglas (attached) now receive double protection from Yousaf: for his so-called gender identity, and for also being, in the eyes of the Scottish government, a woman. 2/2
https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/scottish-greens-suspend-trans-activist-291739072/2
In the US, trans man Scott Newgent (@[private account]) has made it his life's mission to raise the alarm about the dangers of transitioning children. He's lost his career for speaking out. 7/13
In Canada, Kenneth Zucker, former head of the Child Youth and Family Gender Identity Clinic, was fired for questioning whether automatic affirmation of children in their trans identities was the best treatment model. 6/13
https://juliebindel.substack.com/p/a-fascinating-conversation-with-kenneth
Dr David Bell, a distinguished psychiatrist who shared Evan's and Appleby's concerns, submitted a report detailing whistle-blowers' claims, and the trust's response was to attempt to open an investigation into him. 4/13
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2021/may/02/tavistock-trust-whistleblower-david-bell-transgender-children-gids
Genitals ≠ gender, as we all know. Anyway, Voldemort knew the pixie was trans because the pixie was wearing a pronoun badge so large it was impeding its ability to fly. Therefore it was deliberate misgendering, which is of course tantamount to genocide.
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @bindelj Look, I don't want to be calling anyone a shameless charlatan, or so my solicitor says, but Dame K's made endless appeals for chairs, so why do they never seem to reach the desperate trans ladies forced to sprawl on carpets covered in fag ash? Follow the casters, is all I'll say.
In 2022 Stonewall told the world that 'research' suggests two year olds can be trans. It advocated for nurseries - NURSERIES - to start teaching kids that there are more genders than boy and girl. 2/3
In 2018, Stonewall literally told schools to shred a research pack saying there were risks to puberty blockers. "We, in the strongest possible terms, denounce and condemn this publication. If it lands on your desk, do the right thing: shred it.” 1/3
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/stonewall-tried-to-silence-warnings-of-weak-evidence-for-trans-healthcare-n299v00c3
Adult transgender clinics in England face inquiry into patient care after 'an increasing incidence of individuals seeking to "detransition"'.
6 of these 7 trusts refused to cooperate with the Cass Review.
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2024/apr/10/adult-transgender-clinics-in-england-face-inquiry-into-patient-care
Deleted my tweet about the trans woman who said gender critical people don't care about kids getting run over, because people in my mentions said how much they hated the original post, having lost young people on the roads. I'm so sorry. That post didn't need amplifying 💔
@[private account] @[private account] You're wrong. I'm well aware that some of those who call themselves trans haven't got dysphoria at all. If you'd like to give me your definition of 'trans', I'm genuinely eager to hear it.
I read Long Chu, Serrano, Tobia, Dawson, Butler, Fausto-Sterling, plus innumerable blogs and articles by the trans-identified and genderists, and I’m still told daily to educate myself by people who insist avocado trees prove a woman can have a penis.
You’ve asked me several questions on this thread and accused me of avoiding answering, so here goes.
I believe a woman is a human being who belongs to the sex class that produces large gametes. It’s irrelevant whether or not her gametes have ever been fertilised, whether or not she’s carried a baby to term, irrelevant if she was born with a rare difference of sexual development that makes neither of the above possible, or if she’s aged beyond being able to produce viable eggs. She is a woman and just as much a woman as the others.
I don’t believe a woman is more or less of a woman for having sex with men, women, both or not wanting sex at all. I don’t think a woman is more or less of a woman for having a buzz cut and liking suits and ties, or wearing stilettos and mini dresses, for being black, white or brown, for being six feet tall or a little person, for being kind or cruel, angry or sad, loud or retiring. She isn't more of a woman for featuring in Playboy or being a surrendered wife, nor less of a woman for designing space rockets or taking up boxing. What makes her a woman is the fact of being born in a body that, assuming nothing has gone wrong in her physical development (which, as stated above, still doesn't stop her being a woman), is geared towards producing eggs as opposed to sperm, towards bearing as opposed to begetting children, and irrespective of whether she's done either of those things, or ever wants to.
Womanhood isn't a mystical state of being, nor is it measured by how well one apes sex stereotypes. We are not the creatures either porn or the Bible tell you we are. Femaleness is not, as trans woman Andrea Chu Long wrote, ‘an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes,’ nor are we God’s afterthought, sprung from Adam’s rib.
Women are provably subject to certain experiences because of our female bodies, including different forms of oppression, depending on the cultures in which we live. When trans activists say 'I thought you didn't want to be defined by your biology,' it’s a feeble and transparent attempt at linguistic sleight of hand. Women don't want to be limited, exploited, punished, or subject to other unjust treatment because of their biology, but our being female is indeed defined by our biology. It's one material fact about us, like having freckles or disliking beetroot, neither of which are representative of our entire beings, either. Women have billions of different personalities and life stories, which have nothing to do with our bodies, although we are likely to have had experiences men don't and can't, because we belong to our sex class.
Some people feel strongly that they should have been, or wish to be seen as, the sex class into which they weren't born. Gender dysphoria is a real and very painful condition and I feel nothing but sympathy for anyone who suffers from it. I want them to be free to dress and present themselves however they like and I want them to have exactly the same rights as every other citizen regarding housing, employment and personal safety. I do not, however, believe that surgeries and cross-sex hormones literally turn a person into the opposite sex, nor do I believe in the idea that each of us has a nebulous ‘gender identity’ that may or might not match our sexed bodies. I believe the ideology that preaches those tenets has caused, and continues to cause, very real harm to vulnerable people.
I am strongly against women's and girls' rights and protections being dismantled to accommodate trans-identified men, for the very simple reason that no study has ever demonstrated that trans-identified men don't have exactly the same pattern of criminality as other men, and because, however they identify, men retain their advantages of speed and strength. In other words, I think the safety and rights of girls and women are more important than those men's desire for validation.
I sincerely hope that answers your questions. You may still disagree, but as I hope this shows, I’m more than happy to have this debate.
There's no difference between those who hushed up paedophile priests to protect the church and those trying to make it unsayable that some trans-identified men are sex offenders. Both prize an ideology more highly than acknowledging risk and preventing harm to women and children.
And if a non-trans-identified man with a high profile had ‘joked’ about kidnapping women, dubbed lesbians wannabe men or called a black broadcaster a ‘nasty bitch’ who ‘wouldn’t be anywhere without woke’, we all know exactly what would have happened to his career.
Stephen, that's a lie. After naming four convicted sex offenders, I explicitly moved on to role models, celebrating just a few of the wonderful trans-identified men who've taken women's jobs, their places on sports teams and who get airtime in spite of their rampant misogyny.
🎉🌼🌸April Fools! 🌸🌼🎉
Only kidding. Obviously, the people mentioned in the above tweets aren't women at all, but men, every last one of them.
In passing the Scottish Hate Crime Act, Scottish lawmakers seem to have placed higher value on the feelings of men performing their idea of femaleness, however misogynistically or opportunistically, than on the rights and freedoms of actual women and girls. The new legislation is wide open to abuse by activists who wish to silence those of us speaking out about the dangers of eliminating women's and girls’ single-sex spaces, the nonsense made of crime data if violent and sexual assaults committed by men are recorded as female crimes, the grotesque unfairness of allowing males to compete in female sports, the injustice of women’s jobs, honours and opportunities being taken by trans-identified men, and the reality and immutability of biological sex.
For several years now, Scottish women have been pressured by their government and members of the police force to deny the evidence of their eyes and ears, repudiate biological facts and embrace a neo-religious concept of gender that is unprovable and untestable. The re-definition of 'woman' to include every man who declares himself one has already had serious consequences for women's and girls’ rights and safety in Scotland, with the strongest impact felt, as ever, by the most vulnerable, including female prisoners and rape survivors.
It is impossible to accurately describe or tackle the reality of violence and sexual violence committed against women and girls, or address the current assault on women’s and girls’ rights, unless we are allowed to call a man a man. Freedom of speech and belief are at an end in Scotland if the accurate description of biological sex is deemed criminal.
I'm currently out of the country, but if what I've written here qualifies as an offence under the terms of the new act, I look forward to being arrested when I return to the birthplace of the Scottish Enlightenment.
If you agree with the views set out in this tweet, please retweet it.
#ArrestMe #AprilFools #HateCrimeActScotland
11/X
Scotland's Hate Crime Act comes into effect today. Women gain no additional protections, of course, but well-known trans activist Beth Douglas, darling of prominent Scottish politicians, falls within a protected category. Phew! 1/11
The thread has sources. Please show your evidence that trans-identifying people were persecuted, as distinct from gay people, who were indeed victims of heinous treatment by the Nazis.
Thread on the persistent claims about trans people and the Nazis 👇
Quoting @TwisterFilm: 1./ Trans Healthcare and the Nazis.
The LGBTQ+ lobby likes to claim trans people were a key target of the Nazis. They weren't. In fact, trans healthcare was pioneered by a champion of eugenics, and a surgeon who designed experiments at Dachau. His victims there were not trans.
The word ‘transphobic’, as used here, does not mean an irrational fear or dislike of trans people. It means refusing to use gender identity ideology’s jargon, refusing to parrot its slogans, refusing to accept that sex doesn't matter when it comes to sport and single-sex spaces, refusing to believe a bearded heterosexual man becomes a lesbian when he declares himself one, and refusing to believe an abusive, misogynistic male is a woman because he likes to wear mini-dresses and pout in selfies.
Like every other gender critical person I know, I believe everyone should be free to express themselves however they wish, dress however they please, call themselves whatever they want, sleep with any consenting adult who wishes to sleep with them, and that trans-identified people should have the same protections regarding employment, housing, freedom of speech and personal safety every other citizen is entitled to.
But this isn’t nearly enough for the dominant strain of trans activism, which asserts that unless freedom of speech is removed from dissenters, unless trans-identified men are permitted to strip away women’s rights, with particular reference to single sex spaces like rape crisis centres, prison cells, hospital wards, changing rooms and public bathrooms, until we all bow down to their neo-religion, accept their pseudo-scientific claims and embrace their circular reasoning, trans people are more oppressed, and more at risk, than any other group in society.
This is nonsense. 99.9% of the world knows it's nonsense. The emperor is naked. He might be wearing lipstick, but his balls are swinging in plain sight.
Quotes a post by T02256; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Nor have I forgotten India's shocking transphobia. It appears to have slipped what passes for India's mind that he's previously called a fellow trans woman a man on this very site. 3/5
Accurately sexing trans-identified men who send misogynistic abuse to women is not discrimination. 'Man' is not a slur. I know a lot of you think the UN should intervene whenever women bruise your egos, but there is no human right to universal validation.
We don't leave our doors and windows wide open when we go out because 'thieves will find a way in, anyway.' Strangely, I've never heard anyone say 'let's stop background checking teachers, because paedophiles will always find a way to interfere with kids.'
When men - all men, however they identify - are banned from women's spaces, those who disregard the ban can be challenged, inside the space and out. They mark themselves out as suspicious by breaking a rule decent men respect. Nobody claims the rule has successfully kept out every single man who wants to commit voyeurism or sexual assault. What we're saying is that allowing males into female only spaces on the basis of their claim to be a women removes an obstacle that has hitherto been *proven* to increase women and girls' safety.
88% of sexual crimes committed in changing/locker rooms happen in those that are unisex. Why? Because malign men don't have to justify their presence near unclothed women and girls. They can't be challenged. They don't stand out. This is obvious to all but the terminally naive.
It is too seldom noted that every single man arguing for the removal of single sex spaces is arguing for his *own* right to enter those spaces. I know from experience that they feign outrage when this point is put to them, gibbering that they're just being good, virtuous progressives who're standing up for trans women, that they *personally* won't be availing themselves of the new opportunities afforded them. The fact remains that instead of calling out male violence against trans women, and working to make male spaces safer, these men have thrown their energy into the fight to remove women's and girls' rights to safety, privacy and dignity.
And if anyone genuinely believes none of these enthusiastic heterosexual, non-trans-identified male 'allies' aren't personally enthralled by the idea of women and girls losing basic protections, I have several bridges to sell you.
For years now, women have been saying that self-ID will be exploited by predators and we’ve been told ‘no predator would bother to pretend to be a woman.’ Yet here we are - again.
This paedophile didn’t receive the leniency he hoped for because he claimed to be a woman, but plenty have, including Katie Dolotowski, who, in a very similar case, filmed a 12-year-old in a bathroom cubicle and attempted to rape a 10-year-old in a women’s bathroom, and served his sentence in a women’s prison.
The wilfully blind continue to insist that what is already happening couldn’t possibly happen. They wriggle like eels trying to find a loophole through which they can escape with their precious ideology intact. ‘He wasn’t really trans, though.’ ‘All groups have bad apples.’ ‘You can’t blame all trans people because some of them are rapists.’
So determined are you to cling to your absolutist slogans and your circular reasoning, you’re indifferent to the proven increased risk to women and girls. I watch you lying, equivocating and contorting yourself into knots trying to justify the unjustifiable, and I wonder when, if ever, shame will finally find you.
I'd advise you to do some research. There are proportionally more trans-identified men in jail for sexual crimes in the UK than there are in the male prison population as a whole.
Tell me, why does the argument 'it'll happen anyway, so why not make it easier?' never apply to trans-identified men? Why don't we hear 'they're going to get beaten up anyway, so let them use the gents?' Why is it only women who must accept the inevitability of rape and violence?
So you'd exclude trans women from changing and locker rooms ? Or are you comfortable holding open those doors for fellow men who identify as women, as well? You don't know how to identify those who might have malign intent, but women's safety must come second to male feelings.
So saying 'I identify as a woman' is the mark of a true trans woman, but sometimes a man who isn't trans says 'I identify as a woman', and we can tell which is which by giving them both access to the women's changing rooms, and you see no flaws in this reasoning.
The statistics don't lie. Some - not all - trans-identified males have committed sexual and violent offences against women and girls. Some male predators have capitalised on gender identity activism to claim a trans identity they never espoused pre-conviction or assault. 2/3
It is possible to want trans people to be safe and happy while recognising that there are risks to women and girls in eradicating single sex spaces. Women and girls are being pressured to surrender their hard-won rights to a group that poses a proven danger to them. 1/3
88% of sex crimes in changing rooms and bathrooms happen in those that are mixed sex. There is no evidence to show that trans-identified men do not retain a male pattern of criminal offending.
How do we safeguard women and children if the only way of weeding out ‘not really trans’ sex offenders is after they’ve committed crimes in single sex spaces?
🤣I'm heartened to see trans animal activist Dr Dame Katy Denise exposed for the mendacious fraud she is. I encourage all #ChairPoverty donors to cancel their direct debits. The less well-heeled can protest by intentionally misgendering a gerbil or other small rodent.
Gutted I didn't have "knowing what a woman is is comparable to putting trans people in concentration camps" on today's Best Trans Activist Arguments bingo card. It's particularly galling, because I only needed "your books are shit" and I'd have won the big prize 😢
This is very sad news, but on the plus side, it proves some trans people have survived me knowing what a woman is, which you've previously assured me literally kills them.
More than 70 per cent of transgender prisoners are in for sex offences or violent crimes.
"The high levels of violent crimes among male prisoners who identify as women demonstrates why they should not be detained in female prisons" https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/02/24/government-figures-70-per-cent-of-transgender-prisoners-are/
The trans activist outrage that ensues on here whenever I share my belief that jailed women shouldn't be used as validation tools or emotional support props for trans-identified male sex offenders is as revealing as it's predictable.
Such activists can't bring themselves to concede that a man who was convicted of harming women/girls ought not to be incarcerated with the demographic to whom he is a proven danger, because if they do, all their stock arguments ('no sexual predator would bother to pretend to be trans', 'no trans woman has ever harmed a woman in a women's only space', 'there is no danger in making all single sex spaces unisex') are exposed as the lies they are. If they admit that even a single man isn't a woman because he says he is, the entire edifice of gender identity ideology crumbles. This leaves activists who rely on bullying and slogans with nowhere to go but 'you hate all trans people', 'so you're saying all trans people are rapists' and, of course, 'you are causing a trans genocide.'
I think this particular issue also causes conniptions because it threatens the activists' self image. These are people who preen themselves on their kindness and virtue, so acknowledging the truth - that they're indifferent to vulnerable women being assaulted or traumatised - threatens the idea they have of themselves. They therefore double down. The prisoners complaining aren't really afraid of rape or voyeurism or violence at all, they say. They're 'not exactly delicate flowers', as one self-identified empath put it.
If you support putting violent and sexually predatory men into women's prisons, you are knowingly forcing those women to live in fear of, and, in some proven cases, to suffer abuse that many of them will have endured pre-incarceration. You are not kind. You are not righteous. Women have the basic human right not to suffer cruel and unusual punishment. #WomensRightsAreHumanRights
"...the aim is to increase the possibility for male prisoners who identify as transgender to have access to women in prison... This blatantly sees women as providing a service of “validation” and as objects...
The policy is committed to secrecy." 1/2
https://archive.ph/ZnudO