The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
I think part of the issue is that the previous Washington law at least was self-ID — so it didn’t require trans students to be on any kind of hormones in order to play on the girls team, just identifying as a girl. So I can see how that would get a bit complex.
I think it means that voters don’t hate trans people and welcome them in civic and professional life but think it’s unfair to have trans girls and women competing in women and girls sports.
Quotes a post by T20395; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"If I had to choose between trans recognition day and a madman violating international law, I would choose violating international law, which I don't even have to choose because this is a scenario I simply invented in order to not criticize a blatantly mentally unwell president"
Quoting @EWErickson: Look, I don’t think it’s appropriate. Wish he hadn’t. But if I have to choose between this and Trans Recognition Day or whatever on Easter, okay.
An insane, cruel law that throws trans people in prison for a year for using the bathroom consistent with their identity, and for five years if they do so twice. And business owners don’t even have the right to say “in my business, trans people can pee.” Just cruel.
Quoting @nytimes: Breaking News: Idaho criminalized using bathrooms, locker rooms or changing rooms, that do not correspond to a person’s sex at birth, including at private businesses. https://nyti.ms/4t7Nijz
I think trans rights are a civil rights movement. I do not think civil rights movements always win in the end, but I do think they are worth supporting even if they are currently unpopular.
I also don't think "trans rights" are currently unpopular. I think a few specific and highly controversial trans issues are unpopular (gender-affirming surgeries for minors, trans women in women's sports), largely because they really are novel and we really do not have all the answers and I think progressives have alienated people by insisting they "follow the science" when the science is still emerging and not yet anywhere near totally conclusive.
I think trans people having equal access to housing, employment, health care, and so on are obviously civil rights issues, Democrats are on the right side of them, and they should focus on those and point to Republican cruelty on the trans rights that most Americans support -- which has the added benefit of helping many many more people.
Quoting @Noahpinion: Democrats believe that trans rights -- as defined in the 2010s -- are a civil rights movement.
And Democrats believe that civil rights movements A) always win in the end, and B) are morally worth supporting even if they aren't currently popular.
My view on this is that Dems failed to talk about trans issues in the right way; they let the anti-trans movement control the narrative. They should have focused on things like ending discrimination in housing and employment, the Trump trans military ban, etc.
Quoting @daveweigel: There’s a progressive talking point about how Dems enabled a trans backlash bc they clammed up and let Rs control the story.
But Biden admin really leaned into trans visibility, and the acceptance #s went down https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/02/26/americans-have-grown-more-supportive-of-restrictions-for-trans-people-in-recent-years/
I think this is right. The mistake comes when people look at polling and assume public opinion is static. It's worth seeing where opinion is malleable and it's worth taking public opinions seriously - I do think it was a mistake to die on the hill of trans women in sports - but the fact that the anti-trans movement was so capable of shifting public opinion demonstrates that public opinion can be shifted.
Quotes a post by T04581; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The anti-trans movement did a great job at focusing the public's attention on women's sports and surgeries on adolescents. In reality, most people support the policies that will help many more trans people: Antidiscrimination laws in housing, hiring, etc. There is a path fwd
Quotes a post by T41796; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The anti-trans movement just outplayed progressives on this one, and I think progressives made a real error by trying to shout down normie concerns (fairness in sports, surgeries on adolescents) as bigotry rather than engaging in some tough questions. The anti-trans movement did a great job at exploiting those more divisive points to tar all trans activism as extreme and a threat. And now they're coming for trans people who just want to live their damn lives.
This is so depressing. Not that long ago, opposition to bathroom bills was an animating force among liberals, and those bills were defeated. Now, the basic rights of trans people to live with freedom and dignity are at risk.
Quotes a post by A1780; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.