The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
It's the Biden administration's Dept of Education that dictated who could participate with their April Title IX re-write. It's the trans women are women crowd that wants the government to dictate. The rest of us just want Title IX and women's sex-based rights to remain in tact. Again, your facts are incorrect.
Update/addition:
A culture that celebrates the non-binary “trans” kid because of identity over the math olympiad champ or the valedictorian will not produce the best engineers.
This is not a full victory. The other changes to Title IX that require schools to treat “trans”identifying students as their self proclaimed “gender” are still in place.
Women’s only spaces are not protected.
And certainly the 24 states that have already implemented the change to allow males in womens sports will continue to do so. The war on truth will continue.
Don’t get complacent.
🚨🚨🚨 Women's sports are being saved.
The Biden administration is withdrawing its Title IX proposal which forced schools to allow trans-identifying male athletes into girls' sports.
They know they've lost.
Common sense is emerging.
Your courage is making the difference.
The administration recognizes "that there are multiple pending lawsuits related to the application of Title IX in the context of gender identity, including lawsuits related to Title IX’s application to athletic eligibility criteria in a variety of factual contexts."
Not sure what a "variety of factual contexts" means... But I'll take the win.
Go team.
“Winning” means women retain (get back) their sex based rights. Women aren’t forced to give up safety, privacy and fairness to validate the identities of males who identify as “trans.”
That’s what it means.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I think there are zero examples but I could be wrong. I doubt it though. Title IX used to be the law of the land.
It's a non issue to them because they are allowing themselves to be bullied by activists who claim "trans women are women." They aren't.
But once you concede that they are, you can't very well say "but you can't compete in women's sports." So the moral of the story is: language matters; grow a spine @NCAA
Telling one trans-identified male athlete he can't compete in women's sports is bigotry.
But endless women displaced and denied opportunity is totally acceptable & not enough for the @NCAA to do the right thing.
How is this anything other than good old fashioned misogyny?
All the craziest Covid mask enthusiasts in my circle who raged about how I murdered people with my anti-lockdown views are apoplectic and shrieking “you’re spewing transphobic hate and murdering trans people!!” now.
Do they not see their pattern?
Acknowledging basic biology is not Nazi-ism.
Wanting girls to have privacy, safety and fairness is not "trans-genocide."
We aren't the extremists, they are.
Hold the line.
We're done being lectured by leftie media pundits.
We know truth when we see it.
No boys in girls sports. It isn't fair or safe.
Their messaging -- which used to work -- is falling on deaf ears.
The tide is turning.
But we need to continue to fight.
https://nypost.com/2024/11/18/us-news/john-oliver-jen-psaki-spark-high-profile-backlash-for-lecturing-democrats-on-trans-sports-messaging/
The trans women are women and you're a terf/bigot crowd is not going quietly. The fight is far from over.
We need to win the cultural battle. We need the 80+% who agree that women's sports are for XX only, to stand up and say so. Do not get complacent.
The fight to protect girls’ sports is not over, but this is a win. Especially because Judge Chatigny, who dismissed the lawsuit in 2021, switched his stance. He even acknowledged that “trans girls” are biological males, which he refused to do the first time. Truth is trending.
"The protection of the female category is absolutely non-negotiable."
Bring @[private account] on board as IOC President.
He'll protect women's sports.
https://www.foxnews.com/sports/ioc-presidential-candidate-calls-protect-women-from-trans-athletes-trump-pledges-ban-before-la-2028
Last night I stumbled upon a few people posting on Facebook (which I never look at anymore -- though I have the button clicked that when I share on IG it automatically goes to FB) that they are cutting ties with me! Because I'm a disgusting, bigoted human being. One criticism -- after attacking me for being anti-trans -- is that I was a bad gymnast! 40 years ago! Oh no! How will I go on?
I don't know any of the people posting these things. I've never met any of them. They followed me on FB.
This is the 3rd time this has happened to me. 1st, when I exposed abusers in gymnastics. 2nd, covid. Now this. I have a good track record of being right early.
But why do these people feel the need to announce they are cutting ties with me when we don't even know each other? And why do they think I'll care if they call me a shitty gymnast when I'm 55 and haven't done gymnastics in 40 years?
How lame and immature can they possibly be?
So now Democrats @[private account] and @[private account] are saying hey we need to stand up for women's sports!
Meanwhile, @[private account] voted against the Protection of Women and Girls in Sports Act.
You guys are late to the game. Cowards.
https://thehill.com/homenews/house/4979665-democrats-transgender-athletes/
Covid.
Gender ideology/Trans-ing kids/men in women’s sports.
“Everyone who doesn’t toe the @[private account] party line is a racist/fascist and doesn’t deserve to be employed or have friends.”
Why I left the left.
Covid.
Gender ideology/Trans-ing kids/men in women’s sports.
“Everyone who doesn’t toe the @[private account] party line is a racist/fascist and doesn’t deserve to be employed or have friends.”
Why I left the left.
And most women claiming to be men compete in the women’s category. Somehow they don’t need their identity validated!
https://www.thepinknews.com/2024/07/26/boxer-hergie-bacyadan-could-become-the-first-trans-man-to-win-an-olympic-medal-at-paris-2024/
It’s an article about a doctor not publishing a study. They don’t need to talk to trans people to write an article about a doctor not publishing a study.
Why don’t you speak to the results — the lack of evidence of effectiveness — instead of deflecting?
Quoting @glaad: The @nytimes is at it again: another article about trans healthcare that quotes 0 trans people, ignores context, and is critiqued for bias. Today’s piece fails to explain how the NYT itself contributes to the current climate of anti-trans fearmongering.
"If it’s dangerous, unfair & unsafe at professional and semi-professional level, it’s the same at grass-roots or pathways. The ECB can’t say: We’ll protect these females but not these females – because they’re not good enough."
Facts.
@sharrond62
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/cricket/2024/10/17/english-cricket-ban-transgender-elite-level-not-grassroots/
Here’s the oped:
https://www.wsj.com/opinion/transgender-sports-is-a-2024-sleeper-issue-ads-ohio-wisconsin-montana-2a8d044b?st=SjJdZV&reflink=article_copyURL_share
"So we’re asking you, Nike, as the biggest voice in all of sports. Will you stand up for me? Will you? Will you just do it?"
https://www.breitbart.com/sports/2024/10/09/will-you-just-do-it-athletic-brand-xx-xy-calls-nike-protect-womens-sports-trans-athletes-powerful-ad/
It’s not happening.
Ok it is happening but it’s such a small number why are you making a big deal about it?? It’s because you hate trans people!!
It is happening and it’s a good thing and you’re a bigot!
Quoting @JamieWhistle: Today @TheFP published some of the findings from @donoharm review of US insurance data.
Ok I’m watching “Will and Harper” which is annoying in so many ways having nothing to do with gender ideology and trans-ness. More on that later.
How much do you think @[private account] paid for the non stop product integration??
Trans women aren’t women. They are trans women. That isn’t disrespectful, it’s scientifically accurate. They are XY.
Pro woman and girls isn’t trans bashing. I’ve worked with many trans people. Many on my own team. Lovely humans. I got no issues. But women deserve privacy and fairness and safety in sports. That’s it.
You should mute me or block me then I won’t come up on your timeline! Problem solved!
I’m happy to do you that favor! I’ve never seen you in my timeline before so I won’t miss anything!
Congratulations to Evie Edwards who won her race in Baltimore at Charm City, despite being yelled at that "Trans women are women" while racing!
Go Evie! Nice hat! @icons_women @xx_xyathletics
No, males coming into my locker room are threatening. I grew up in gymnastics with national team coaches — people like Don Peters, now banned & Tom Burdash (also banned) — pretending to be ‘safe’ and entering our private rooms and spaces. And yes, assaulting some gymnasts. I don’t believe this is all trans people … most certainly not. But the male drive to assert dominance is a thing and certainly happens. We knew that a few years ago at the height of me too but seem to have now forgotten.
I also grew up in the sport at a time when steroid use was rampant, especially in eastern bloc countries. Interestingly the male XY testosterone advantage is greater than that of steroid use. And yet…
The assumption that you know me and that I am a hopelessly old and bigoted person is … unfounded. I believe all humans deserve to be treated w dignity and respect and have safe secure spaces and equality of opportunity. And that includes women.
Simply calling me a bigot no longer fazes me. It doesn’t engage on merits of argument and concerns, it only seeks to dismiss and vilify. Insults are the purview of those unwilling or unable to engage with facts and a well reasoned argument.
Happy to debate. Without name calling. Because that’s not a debate.
Re straight white men… don’t want them in my locker room either. Or Diddy for that matter.
The word "woman" is offensive now. It is why medical providers say dumb stuff like "cervix havers."
When used for trans people, the word is fine. Trans women are women, right?
But actual women are offensive in our very existence because we are the proof that trans women are not women. We violate the ideology by just being.
Which is why we are told to shut up & not defend our own right to privacy, safety, fairness & equal opportunity. Our silence allows the ideology to remain in tact.
No. We won't be quiet.
I realize this person is trans playing trans. Nominate Nava in the men’s category. Otherwise men get the men’s nominations and the women’s. Do you see it yet??
Men can’t become women.
But the people that utter this foolishness shouldn’t be civilly penalized or criminally charged.
People get to say dumb shit.
(Somehow I think “trans women ARE women” is not the propaganda Hillary is referring to, but propaganda it is.)
https://twitter.com/aaronjmate/status/1835886288995586318/video/1
I received about ~150 of these comments on Substack in one day! Busy bee.
Obviously a well crafted argument about trans rights.
I take everything back. Trans women ARE women and belong in my sports and spaces. We are sisters.
Read it! Enjoy.
If Arabs weren't oppressed they'd love trans people.
Intersectional oppression blah blah blah.
Quoting @icons_women: ‘Big shame’: Women’s Olympic boxing gold medalist Imane Khelif condemns politicians who claim he is 'a transgender,' saying it dishonors his family, Algeria, and the Arab world to identify as such.
Speculation surrounds the male boxer who failed a chromosomal blood screen to compete as female in last year's World Championships. Some believe he may have a DSD, leading to misidentification as female at birth. Regardless of any developmental syndromes or how he self-identifies, the male development pathway gives him a significant advantage over women in the ring. For this reason, all male athletes should be barred from competing in Women’s Olympic competition.
Trans men are competing in the women’s category. So nothing to worry about!
https://www.thepinknews.com/2024/07/26/boxer-hergie-bacyadan-could-become-the-first-trans-man-to-win-an-olympic-medal-at-paris-2024/
“The vast majority of Americans agree with us," Sey said, referencing a poll showing 69% of Americans believe transgender athletes should play on sports teams that match their biological gender. "We should not be relegated to parallel economy or second-class citizens."
At the end of the day, [customers] may come to us for the mission, but they stay for the product," she said. "I want our product to compete with Nike and Lululemon, be as good as, if not better."
Sey added, "If we don’t do that, we won’t survive."
@xx_xyathletics
Confirmation that the boxers are XY will make no difference. This is not a gotcha. Don't get so excited.
While the boxers are not trans, "trans women ARE women" got us here.
This is all brought to you by "if you say you're a woman then you are!"
And to all the "I hope Imane sues you all!" people ... for what exactly?
We need to start from scratch and unwind all of this language because this is where it leads. To XYs beating women up on television and being declared heroes and Olympic medalists.
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨HAPPENING NOW🚨
The International Boxing Association is holding a press conference in Paris to address the issues surrounding Algerian boxer Imane Khelif and Taiwanese boxer Lin Yu-Ting.
Highlights so far:
*Both boxers were initially subjected to a chromosomal test by an independent laboratory in Istanbul after the IBA received complaints from coaches and competitors during the 2022 Women's World Boxing Championships.
*Both boxers were re-tested in India again during the 2023 Women's World Boxing Championships to clarify and confirm prior results.
*Both boxers were found to have XY chromosomes.
*Both boxers were informed of the results of the tests in writing.
*Both boxers were given the opportunity to appeal the findings to the Court of Arbitration for Sport.
*The IBA offered to pay for the majority of the costs to allow both boxers to appeal.
*Lin Yu-Ting did not appeal the decision.
*Imane Khelif appealed the decision, and then withdrew the appeal.
How well acquainted are you with the gender ideologues/trans activists? They’ll give the leftie antisemites a run for their money. A lot of same folks probably. Ya know… Queers for Palestine 😬🥴
Though Khelif isn’t trans, the whole conversation is informed by trans ideology. The ideologues assert : if you say you’re a woman you are.
How dare we say someone isn’t what they “feel” they are! We will hurt their feelings!
How feelings get prioritized over safety and fairness for women is 100% attributable to gender ideology.
More than half of the arguments I read about why Khelif should be allowed to compete as a woman are "it's mean not to allow it!"
Who cares!? This is about facts, not feelings (@benshapiro, thanks for that one.)
Why are feelings prioritized above all else in the world today? Honestly it's the same reason we get drag shows at libraries (I mean, if you can't perform in front of children, it's shameful right? It'd be mean not to allow it! We need to celebrate it, in fact!) and billboards about "don't feel ashamed of your heroin addiction!"
Women's sports are for XX only. It doesn't matter if that hurts someone's feelings, whether that person is "trans" or has a DSD. It's about safety and fairness for women. Period.
Whether trans or DSD doesn’t matter.
XY matters.
Gender ideology brought us self ID…
“if you say you’re a woman you are!”
No. You’re not.
One can have empathy for Khelif’s condition and also believe female athletes deserve their own sports.
It isn’t complicated. Truth matters, IOC. You’ve failed.
Quoting @reduxx: 🚨BREAKING🚨
Algeria's Imane Khelif has just secured an Olympic medal after a 5-0 match against Hungary's Anna Luca Hámori.
This comes just hours after Reduxx reported that the European Vice President of the World Boxing Organization István Kovács confirmed that Khelif was a biological male.
Kovács also stated he had encouraged Hámori to not proceed with her match with Khelif.
Khelif if not trans but the movement informs this discussion. It’s the gender ideology movement that says “if you say you’re a woman you are. Chromosomes be damned!”
Women's sports are for females - XX.
Whether an athlete is "trans" or has a DSD and they live and present as female doesn't matter.
Women's sports are for females.
It's not complicated.
Quoting @clairlemon: Intersex athletes are not "men pretending to be women". and they're not enforcing pronouns.
I actually don't think XY athletes should compete against women in combat sports. But the erasure of Imane Khelif's intersex status to score points against trans activists is galling.
How many women and girls need to be injured for common sense to prevail? As I started this whole thread by saying, my one injury back in 1985 prompted a common sense change in gymnastics (not a sport known for common sense.)
How many is too many? I'd argue one. One injury to a female athlete by a stronger, bigger trans athlete is too many.
Change the rules. #SaveWomensSports
There have also been injuries in high school basketball and rugby. Only rugby has changed its policy, best I can glean. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/26/sports/olympics/world-rugby-transgender-women.html
In MMA fighting, trans fighter Fallon Fox severely injured another fighter in 2014. https://999thepoint.com/transgender-mma-fighter-sends-female-opponent-to-hospital/
Granted, these were all very serious injuries. In Julissa's case, her injury resulted in death.
There have already been injuries to female athletes at the hands of trans identified male athletes.
Payton McNabb, a high school volleyball player, suffered a serious concussion from a ball spiked by a trans athlete.
https://newschannel9.com/news/local/injured-nc-volleyball-player-in-spotlight-as-lawmakers-push-transgender-athlete-ban-north-carolina-cherokee-county-sports-headlines-payton-mcnabb-hiwassee-dam-high-school-highlands-high-school
“From my reporting, the reality is that from a scientific perspective, we know that there are differences in sexes, and we know the differences do tend to lead to athletic performance differences as well. However, when we look at broad-based restrictions at all levels of sport, it’s very challenging to say that scientifically that is supported in all cases…
Something that might be appropriate for swimming does not necessarily apply to basketball (😵😵), when it comes to individual sports versus team sports, as well as level of competition. So, I think the idea that transgender women have an advantage in all sports at all times regardless of any kind of medical transition, I don’t think that the scientific literature supports that at this time." @espn reporter Katie Barnes
https://www.foxnews.com/sports/espn-reporter-questions-whether-trans-athletes-advantage-womens-sports
"Polling shows that clear majorities of Americans, including a sizable slice of Democrats, oppose allowing transgender athletes to compete on girls’ & women’s teams."
It's not fair or safe & the majority of Americans know that.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2024/03/28/title-ix-trans-athletes-biden/
Listen to the audience applaud here when @CaitlinPacific says trans identified males have an advantage competing against women. And it’s not fair.
Everyone knows. The audience cheers because they want someone else to say it first so they can say it too.
.@[private account] is a hero.
Can you imagine the strength of character required to overcome what she has?
She survived a shark attack, lost an arm - at 13!! - and returned to surfing one month later. Do people not understand how super-human this is?? In addition to winning too many surfing competitions to count, she has deservedly won an ESPY award for courage.
AND she counsels youth on overcoming adversity. And is a mom of 3. HERO!
This woman is beyond courageous. And kind. She embodies strength. She is exactly the example we ought to hold up for our children.
But Rip Curl cuts her contract for expressing her views on protecting women's sports #SAVEWomensSports then features a trans surfer competing in the women's category just a few months later.
Seriously?
Shame on you Rip Curl. Shame. #ripcurl #pathetic