The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
This was part of my clash working in a gender center- the “do something” and reaching for therapy or psych meds, or trans drugs when often times these young people also had (and I wanted to first address these issues):
1. Severe sleep deficits- due in part to parenting issues- no supervision of cell phones, young people on social media at 3am on a school night- first line- parenting coaching and sleep hygiene.
2. Nutrition- and I don’t mean some crazy “micro nutrients” no basics like no one ever makes dinner- kid eats crap once a day with energy drinks. Again- basics three balanced meals, water, healthy snacks.
3. Exercise- our patients would admit 0 exercise- like won’t even walk around the block or to the bus stop. Again before a psych drug or therapy this is a first line try.
As a case manager these are all things that have to be addressed, and they are the basics- yes they are challenging, but often they required parental authority which was only undermined by the other interventions- psych meds, therapy, transition.
I always wanted to try supporting the family on these issues first- tools to control the cell phones, education about sleep hygiene, food resources if they needed assistance accessing health food, meal prepping, getting the family free or reduced gym memberships, walking programs, etc. the first “gender do something” response would be all of the above first and work on those for as long as it takes.
The Trans News Network shares their thoughts post election, “We must be willing to deceive and manipulate liberal politicians, pollsters, and journalists the same way they treat us. Pocket their concessions, then run roughshod over them.”
I am very curious about this repeated statement that trans identified children are the most vulnerable in society.
I say this sincerely as a mom of three children who were adopted from the foster care system.
I think the argument is this-
They are minors- which means all children are vulnerable- even though many could argue that most children in our society are not just well protected but live in a society of abundance and wealth virtually unmatched in history.
Then is the argument that they are Mentally ill? A small minority that faces bullying? Family rejection? Or that the discussion of the laws themselves causes distress?
What I found in the data sets from the gender center where I worked was that the majority of patients were well off, had quality health insurance, had well educated employed parents who affirmed the identity. They also had high access to technology, cell phones, computers, and went to affirming well resourced schools.
They did have some mental health comorbidities- but a large percentage were white, upper middle class, liberal affirmative families.
There was a subgroup in the data of children who had trauma histories or histories of sexual assault/were in foster care- who did develop a trans identification. There were also the young people with ASD who were struggling with identity formation while trans was being presented widely.
What I find interesting in the word use of vulnerable- is that I use it in relation to the cohort because they had a vulnerability to being susceptible to the influence of the trans identification.
I think they were vulnerable in the bioethics definition- they had reasons they were unable to protect themselves from the contagion- being vulnerable isn’t a status on its own- it’s vulnerable to something.
Just to clarify in Missouri, the question regarding trans was not sports. It was actually a bit complicated because our current ban has a future expiration date on puberty blockers and cross sex hormones.
MO already has a sports ban in place.
Also “disability” is different then “trans is mentally ill”
Disability was all the rage, accommodations were totally fine. That being trans is because I’m mentally ill was not- being trans a perfectly fine- it’s how everyone treats us is the problem.
The disability support animals- that’s a whole realm of out there. We had untrained packs of “support dogs” coming into clinic snarling and scaring the medical assistants.
Even if you have credentials, it’s never the right ones- the only credentials that they are actually looking for is that you are trans and you follow whatever the illogical argument of the week is.
The highest rate in my region also wasn’t the city proper- it was the wealthier white suburbs.
Where the young people were more likely to have personal smart phones, constant internet access, health insurance, schools inundated with trans content.
The schools unable to supply toilet paper consistently with real problems were much less likely to invent problems.
Quoting @LeorSapir: The highest rate wasn’t in Seattle.
It was the 986 ZIP area: Vancouver and Camas, where girls recently walked off a cross-country course to protest a male teammate.
There, 2.4% of teen girls (about 1 in 40) had a diagnosis in 2022. In Seattle it was 1.8%.
Wesley, so I’m not sure many republicans would be interested in dropping the religious reason for their opposition.
When we work in coalition with @LGBCourage at the state level republicans we actually came to them directly with this ask- stop referencing god, don’t drop in a bible verse in your testimony, let us lead on this with science, common sense, free speech, and LGB rights.
Often they will at least hear us out, but I understand their frustration as much as my own- they were right on this one.
They were right and it was in real part because of their religious belief- because trans has been filling a real hole for many that they see that their faith could have filled- without the physical self mutalition.
Trans is a religion- it has rituals, it promises the joy and promise land just over that next horizon, the transfiguration. But trans flips the higher power and centers it in the self.
Why would someone who has strong religious belief that has endured for centuries not seek to evoke that which has endured, that which grounded them in a morality that intuitively knew to reject trans?
Hi Sarah @[private account]
Why does public radio keep presenting anything involving trans issues as a conservative religious cause?
Your story quoted five opponents and two supporters. The supporters were a Republican legislator and @[private account] who pointed to churches as part of the effort. In the gender-medicine section, you quoted one person on each side. The message to your listeners was clear: if you support this, you're a churchgoing Republican.
That isn't the whole picture. I'm a lesbian. I'm on the left. I worked @[private account] . I'm easy to find, and I'm always willing to talk. Voices like mine are right here in St. Louis. They keep getting left out because they don't fit the story public radio has already decided to tell.
Your piece also quoted a source calling the pairing of abortion and gender medicine a cynical, calculated move by the amendment's supporters, and nothing in the story challenged that. Missouri Republicans weren't the ones who tied these issues together. The left did it years earlier, and it did so on purpose.
In ICD-10, the World Health Organization classified these diagnoses as mental disorders. Trans advocacy groups lobbied for years to move them out.- into sexual health. They won.
In May 2019 the World Health Assembly adopted ICD-11, trans now sit in a newly created Chapter 17, "Conditions related to sexual health." ICD-11 took effect in January 2022.
Trans is now classified as sexual health, it can be grouped under the same "reproductive healthcare" umbrella as abortion.
A week after Dobbs, in a special session New York's Democratic establishment- 2 Manhattan Democrats, pushed this into a vote. Its key clause protects, in a single sentence, "sex, including sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, pregnancy, pregnancy outcomes, and reproductive healthcare and autonomy."
Gender identity and abortion were written into the same constitutional language. The legislature passed it again in January 2023, and voters approved it in November 2024.
The campaign behind it was the progressive establishment. New Yorkers for Equal Rights was a coalition that raised millions of dollars. When critics asked what the gender identity language would mean for children, the campaign dismissed their concerns as misinformation.
So this pairing came from the WHO, trans advocacy groups, Democratic legislators, the ACLU & Planned Parenthood. I don't remember public radio calling that cynical.
Missouri is now putting the mirror image on the ballot. If tying these issues together is a calculated tactic when Missouri does it, why wasn't it one when New York did? A statehouse reporter should know this history and tell listeners about it.
I'm not asking you to agree with me. I'm asking you to stop treating people like me as if we don't exist. I'm available any time before Nov. 3. And would love to debate anyone in our state on trans ‘medicine’
Jamie Reed
@[private account] @HawleyMO
I have never seen the @nytimes report on suspected billing fraud or breaking of the state laws restricting puberty blockers, cross sex hormones, or surgery (in children). I have never seen investigations from the Times like these from @LeorSapir
https://www.city-journal.org/article/oregon-transgender-puberty-blocker-hormones
Another great listen from @_CryMiaRiver and @stellaomalley3
As they discuss the broad historical changes, I am drawn back to memories of serious debates from the staff of the pediatric gender center.
One especially memorable debate, was between the two co-medical directors- one arguing that we were treating a mental health condition and that the treatment was to medically transition children.
The other co-medical director did not believe it was a mental health condition- did not seem to even know that he had already drank the Kool-Aid of “ trans is healthy and good”
Finally, the doctor who believed we were treating a mental health condition sort of blurted out well then this is just cosmetic- why would we do this to children?
All while claiming to the public “the science is settled”
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/beyond-gender/id1795722610?i=1000793498794
I think a lot about the kids that were also trusted to my care when I worked in a hospital and participated in interventions that harmed them.
We had nearly 1500 unique patients.
But honestly I also think a lot about adults and young adults who have also become caught up in “trans” these are primarily women and men who are homosexuals now part of an identity that leads to medical harms.
But it might help those who identify as trans come to terms with the material physical harms of puberty blockers, cross set hormones, and surgeries and decrease seeking those harmful interventions.
A “trans kid” is either a gender non conforming young person who would grow up to be a gay man or lesbian women with their health intact if left alone.
Or a vulnerable young person being targeted by an ideology that promises lies of “authenticity” “community” “friendship” “special status” who also would grow up to have their health intact if left alone.
You are right on! Thank you so much for raising this point.
So one of the reasons why this is now considered a single issue- is because trans identification used to be considered a mental illness within the DSM.
Trans identified people found that to be stigmatizing and they didn’t want to be known as having a mental illness so they petition to have it moved into sexual reproductive health in the newest ICD international coding standard.
The reason why these are now considered a single issue is because trans reclassified itself into a sexual/reproductive category.
And very interesting sidenote, the first state that created a constitutional amendment like Missouri was actually the state of New York, which ratified an amendment in their constitution to “protect” abortion with trans.
This whole concept of linking these as one issue started from the left and trans activists themselves.
I just read the story and sent Anna an email requesting that the newsroom add resources to the end of the piece.
The therapist that they include a quote from is not even following her own professional practice guidelines with regards for how to talk about suicide.
She states that legislation has killed (trans identified) children.
With no fact checking done by the paper to these claims, or addressing that the suicide myth regarding trans identification has been dispelled.
We continue to face an uphill battle when it comes to coverage in media on this issue- but I do not want to stand by as therapists who should know better continues to fear monger in ways known to be dangerous.
So I think that your post and the attachment are just adding a layer in a different perspective to still support my underlying argument- which is that the reason why trans and abortion have been tied together is not because of some long running plot by Republicans…
“Why do I keep seeing abortion laws tied with trans law?”
Trans used to be considered a mental illness.
Trans activist petitioned to have it removed as a mental illness, and they had it moved into sexual/reproductive health.
They want their drugs/surgeries to still be paid for without the “stigma”
Because of that reclassification trans has now been considered in law to be part of sexual health, provisions and “bodily autonomy” which led Planned Parenthood to push the state of New York to codify- in their state constitution trans with abortion.
The Republican party did not start this- the legal ties that now allow these to be considered a single issue for vote voters came from democrats.
It’s not “ballot candy” it’s the legal reality that trans wanted. If you want it pulled back apart talk to them.
@[private account] @[private account]
If you seek true social change then that is the work- if you want someone to actual change you must meet them where their heart is and their mind- this is part of how the trans movement has failed.
The concept of trans cannot win hearts- and it cannot win minds because its foundation is illogical.
And it was exactly working with those in opposition to gay marriage and gay rights that lead to the true social change- because we worked with and communicated with those who did not support us. We engaged.
If you seek true social change then that is the work- if you want someone to actual change you must meet them where their heart is and their mind- this is part of how the trans movement has failed.
The concept of trans cannot win hearts- and it cannot win minds because its foundation is illogical.
OK, let’s run with your thought experiment then- I worked in a gender center we saw roughly 1500 unique patients.
If I could hypothetically brain scan them all- what percentage do you think would end up meeting the criteria based on your brain scan to warrant treatment?
And then what do you propose the doctors do or say to the patients who undergo the brain scan and don’t meet criteria yet still adamantly declare a trans identity?
It very well might be true for all ages- but I’m just trying to like understand why that age cohort seems to have really bad TDS, it’s like all the little old white haired ladies out at the No Kings rallies, but when I try to talk to them about trans, they vaguely know the talking points… but it must be fine… because TDS and the liberal brain collective says so.
I consider kids in foster care to be in a different category.
Most of the kids in foster care in our center- were still raised in their family of origin structure or ‘community’ and still had contact with that family in some way. A large number of kids in care are teenagers. These children still were still very much ‘Americans’.
I still consider them within the pool of vulnerable- but for a different reason.
What I am interested in right now is the over representation of families where one parent is an immigrant and one parent is a white American (for lack of a better term).
I see those families over represented with children/teens with trans identification and similarly children who are adopted internationally.
I’m very interested in how it appears a significant number of the CPS investigations that lead to the trans identified child being removed from the home also appears to be happening where one/ both parents are immigrants.
@[private account] has represented many such cases.
As a recovering (?) liberal I always find it very interesting when institutions seem to be colliding with first generation or immigrant families and how trans seems to be a wedge (?) in the identity formation of these first generation kids.
I almost feel like becoming an American teenager right now means going through the ritual of finding one’s gender- and for those who are also figuring out what it means to become an American, it almost feels like trans has a special way of catching these kids.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedcontagionstate takes children
I don’t know where I would be today if I didn’t go into this with daily exercise already part of my life.
Today we had an errand in the city, so I completed my morning run the park in my old neighborhood.
The neighborhood where I lived when I was hard core in the trans center.
The neighborhood where my old friends live that have never spoken to me again.
I was apprehensive, I felt fear. That fear sits quietly like a half healed blister- that becomes a bleeding mess when things happen- Charlie Kirk, specific death threats, like that.
I ran to, “May your past be the sound of your feet upon the ground. Carry On.”
And I didn’t cry, and by mile two, maybe it was the exercise endorphins, or the growing sense of peace I carry, or the knowledge that today another Democrat candidate will say “boys don’t belong in girls sports” but I just know we will eventually end this.
“No one’s ever gonna stop us now.”
Good Morning, I am looking for suggestions for books/papers/experts on two topics.
1. First generation identity formation- specifically on the over representation of trans identities in first generation kids/international adoption kids/ and their over representation in CPS investigations regarding trans.
2. The teen girls/ young adults “cheerleading” the trans identification in the teen boys. Including in romantic relationships.
If any experts that could discuss these two topics are open for an interview would like to have you on Informed Dissent.
My DMs are always open.
Dear Liberal America- if you would like to assist building back trust in our institutions please start with @[private account] and @[private account]. You can not trust what they report at all when it’s regarding “gender” or “trans”
Quoting @SwipeWright: Last week, NPR reached out to interview me about our recent HHS study on the link between Left-Wing Authoritarianism, support for clinical statements related to gender-affirmation, and support for political violence.
Normally, I would have gladly accepted. But in light of a recent interview I did for The Guardian on the study, in which reporter Melody Schreiber subsequently fabricated a fake “gotcha” moment, and which I exposed by posting the actual transcript, I decided to request that their questions and my responses be submitted in writing.
I also requested that my responses to questions be quoted in full, and if they wanted to cut them up or paraphrase my responses, then they would need my approval. The NPR website states that “For purposes of accuracy and fairness, there are times when we may want to review portions of a script with a source or read back a quotation to ensure we capture it correctly.”
My request was that, given the volatile nature of the topic, they simply extend this courtesy to me. This is especially important because my coauthors and I are forced to deal with the consequences of extreme distortions of our work. We’ve already seen ridiculous headlines saying our study claims trans people and their supporters are violent, and possibly even terrorists, and that we’re setting the stage for a “trans genocide.”
Support for political violence is rising across the political spectrum, and such extreme distortions of our work therefore put me and my coauthors at significant risk. I think my request was very reasonable. If any story requires checking in with sources to ensure “accuracy and fairness,” it’s this one.
Unfortunately, through no fault of the reporter, who ran my request by NPR’s standards department twice, my request was ultimately denied. My detailed responses will therefore not be included in the story NPR is going to run about our HHS study.
I can’t know for sure what type of article NPR is going to publish about our HHS report, but given NPR’s political skew, I predict it will not be friendly. I hope I’m wrong!
Given that likelihood, I believe it would be prudent of me to preemptively post the full, detailed answers I gave to the questions NPR sent me.
You can read those in the screenshots below, which continue in the subsequent post.
So I’ll keep saying this until I sound like a broken record the Democratic Party has been tying abortion and trans pediatric interventions together now for years.
In New York State, they actually did this exact same thing on the opposite side and enshrined it into their constitution in the exact same manner.
How is it hateful to protect kids and adolescents from irreversible medical interventions?
Who is it fringe when we had an explosion of trans identified young people- 80% were teen girls?
But there was an explosion of kids identifying as trans.
In all of the anglophone countries. And those kids sought medical interventions that caused life long harms- infertility, endocrine systems harmed, loss of sexual function.
There actually is a problem here, and those concerned are @DIAGdemocrats and @LGBCourage gays and lesbians.
I consider this the greatest medical scandal of our time.
Nothing makes me angry enough to bang out an entire Substack like @[private account] calling McNamara brilliant.
When comparing McNamara to me over who cared for more trans-identifying young people, it's like I had the whole Titanic and she had the lifeboat that broke in half.
Anyway- dropping tomorrow AM.
What if you were on the side that so hates gender non conformity that you supported the castration and sterilization of gender non conforming kids- who most likely would grow up to be gay men and lesbian women?
In the first cohort studied in the Netherlands of the first 70 kids put through this protocol for 'trans' 68 out of 70 were homosexuals.
Or perhaps it is politics itself as the one of the only mechanisms that small populations have to fight to protect themselves?
We are adult gays and lesbians and we recognize that trans target’s children who are gender, non-conforming and tells them that their bodies are the problem- that they need to have their bodies damaged in order to fit into a society.
Well @ErinInTheMorn just provided a list of democrats that need support (and possibly offers for more education) calling it the guide to anti trans democrats.
@jonahowheeler you didn’t make the list ☹️or maybe you were intentional left off 🤷♀️
https://open.substack.com/pub/erininthemorn/p/the-guide-to-anti-trans-democrats?r=py84h&utm_medium=ios
Because they don’t believe that the diagnosis is needed- they think the diagnosis is pathologizing. If they say they are trans- they are trans- and that’s enough for medicalization.
I don’t think I’ve ever mentioned this before publicly, but we should talk about it.
When we say that trans targets vulnerable populations- we rarely discuss the young people who are adoptees.
Rates of trans identification is high among teens who are adopted- especially when the adoption is international or cross cultural.
Trans medicine has always had a significant level of fraud in it!
PEDIATRIC CENTERS LEARNED THIS FROM ADULT TRANS MEDICINE.
In adult trans medicine, it was widely known that the codes were manipulated- for years they were claiming that women needed testosterone for hormone deficiencies, they would swap sex markers in charts very early on when there was no insurance coverage for any trans medicine, they would add fictitious endocrine disorders.
Fraud has been the standard practice for decades.
Quotes a post by T00781; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If I may be so bold- what Mara is still missing is the idea that the general public accepts the notions of a “trans child” this is attempting to ignore away the root of the issue- no child is trans, puberty blocker, cross sex hormones and surgeries in minors is not acceptable, safe, or supported medically.
Sarah, this is a sweeping generalization. I had one patient with no ideas about their gender identity at all on a Monday and by Friday in drama camp got in the car and told Mom they were trans.
One hypothesis- trans camp- I mean drama camp-pronoun rituals and gender exploration just released her inner trans soul.
Or… she was just a teen in a social situation with a peer group.
You can talk about whatever group you want. I think it’s really important to note that is not the group showing up in pediatric gender centers!
Explosions of tran identification occurred- in teenage girls.
If you can’t talk about the problem that affected most of the parents who are concerned, most of the clinicians who are concerned, most of the reason why politicians have been concerned, then you’re not willing to talk about the actual problem.
And…if we can’t discuss that trans identification CAN be socially mediated and spread- then we really can’t ever talk about what trans actually is- or of it should be considered a stable category that should have access to medical interventions.
What part did you find to be BS?
I worked in a pediatric gender center from 2018-2022 with over 1500 patients.
Most of my gay and lesbian friends (who are very concerned about trans) see young people taking on trans identifications.
Most of those young people are not homosexuals they are caught in a trans society contagion.
But the young homosexuals are taking on a trans identification- which has also spilled out into the middle age women (GNC lesbians) who also take on a trans identification.
This is why I read everything I can about how trans was developed- if we did not create this medical “treatment” for homosexuality where could we currently be?
Gay men no matter how GNC are never women.
Lesbian women no matter how GNC are never men.
Instead of continuing the medical experimentation to “correct” the homosexual we could have sought ways for society to accept and embrace expanded categories of the confines of male and female.
I was reading yesterday about gay men having testicles implanted into their abdomens to seek to increase testosterone (they called it glandular juices then).
We read this now as barbaric. I see it no different then injections of synthetic estrogen or penile inversions.
Lana, thank you for engaging here with me. My DMs are open if you would be willing to engage further.
Oh correct- with this current cohort the vast majority are young women caught in a socially mediated contagion.
If we are speaking sheer numbers heterosexuals have always outnumbered us. Vastly outnumbered us.
When we can look at the cohorts distinctly and place the ROGD cohort into its clear category then we see that the developmental pathway for homosexuals has been subsumed by the trans narrative.
I accept that I am in a minority- I am ok with that.
There were only 2 people in my entire state that worked as a case manager in a pediatric gender center. I was 1 of them.
My experience provided me insight into the medical outcomes for those trans identified, medical transitions are not safe, they injury the body leading to long term harms. The interventions don’t actually work as they were promised to.
Legal transitions harm society on a broad level removing sex based protections for women.
I would rather be in a minority and understand these truths then with the majority who accept without understanding what they are embracing.
What’s really not funny is that the whistleblowers from the Tavistock actually recognized this as a problem.
And as the US whistleblower who actually sat with teens who said in clinic that they would “rather be trans than gay” and then were medicalized- started on irreversible hormones… I just don’t see how this is amusing.
The developmental pathway for homosexuals has been subsumed by trans. When older gays and lesbians say, "I would have been transitioned if I'd grown up now," we are simply able to recognize that our own pathways into homosexuality have now been transformed. We are able to reflect and recognize that we—the humans we are now, with our bodies intact, our endocrine systems functional, our families, our lives—can see, with the wisdom of our age, that we escaped a cultural shift that would have also subsumed us.
For a moment, perhaps imagine what a Detransitioner might feel like going to a pulmonologist visit and seeing a trans lanyard.
Or what about a detransitioner who now has a child themselves taking their child to see that doctor today in a children’s hospital?
What about a parent whose child transitioned as a young adult, and the parent knows how much harm their young adult is experiencing and they now have to trust a doctor’s care with their other young children?
What about lesbian parents who strongly believe that trans targeting children is homophobic gay conversion?
What about an Amish family, or a traditional Catholic family? What about families who just want no politics in their children’s doctors office?
Or yes, what about the whistleblower who lost everything just wanting to take their child to simple doctors appointment and just want to talk about their own child medical care?
The doctor today, I asked her if she could perhaps not wear a trans lanyard in a children’s hospital in the visit with one of my kids. Somehow she ended up crying when I suggested providers might need to be neutral on issues like this in exam rooms.
Gays and lesbians have very different advocacy needs from those who identify as trans.
Trans identification is based on stereotypes, the medical interventions are not safe or efficacious.
Trans identification leads to the erosion of sex based rights and protections- which leads to policies and practices that harm gays and lesbians.
You can be disappointed but this is the progress that we need to protect gays and lesbians.
Saw an old friend at the gym. It’s been about 5 years.
She’s in a faded “bans off our bodies” tshirt with rainbow/trans flag colors. I’m in an @xx_xyathletics tshirt.
I know I’m the one who took the road less traveled…but I am so thankful that I did.
Hi Jerry, I also reached out to @[private account] right away and asked him to come on our podcast. All of the hosts are homosexuals, libs, and have real concerns with pediatric gender medicine. We would love to have you come on too- especially since you might not be aware that those who question trans are not just from one political party.
Oh unfortunately, it’s much more challenging than this.
There is no high-quality evidence to support the medical transition of a child.
The use of puberty, blockers cross sex, hormones, and surgeries in children is known to cause permanent harm.
When you are referencing a “trans girls” what is happening as a male has been put through a protocol that has not proven to be efficacious or safe.
Mr. Arday could have made any claim under the sun to himself in the mirror, but it was only when the world engaged with him on those claims that they achieved their social and mythical importance. Trans, with these young people and their families was the same.
The young people could claim a new name — but they needed someone outside of themselves to say it. They could claim new pronouns — but they needed you to use them, from your voice. They could write that name on their own notebooks — but they needed the teacher to call it out in morning roll call.
She documents a troubling statistic that she doesn’t even recognize is concerning, “a Wichita clinic that provides care to some 4,000 trans people”
Wichita has a population of roughly 397,000.
This is a number from a single clinic. Which means that this provider would need to see basically all of the estimated trans identified population, which is not true because there are at least 4 other clinics in Wichita.
These are needed fact checks- was the provider exaggerating? Was this over the last 10 years?
Comments are not currently open. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/03/us/politics/transgender-troops-ban.html?unlocked_article_code=1.2lA.obFy.2RqNJVN2oa9c&smid=nytcore-ios-share
Listening to @[private account] with @ezraklein this morning.
I still cannot wrap my head around why the Democratic Party cares more about “swinging” the swing voters, while ignoring they lost LIFELONG supporters over trans.
I’m not sure I can explain how much peace is in my heart just being in a place where:
My lesbian led family is not just tolerated but welcome.
There is a beach within walking distance.
There has not been a single trans flag or progress pride flag- anywhere.
Teen girls- well past puberty- who were reporting a trans identification with no previous documentation of any “gender” distress overwhelmed these centers.
I’m not sure that that should be the assumption, considering she recently removed pronouns and ditched the they/them.
Sometimes having a sibling trans- especially when you really feel like it’s not the right thing for your sibling- makes one second-guess their support.
I am conducting a non scientific survey- if you would like to participate.
I am curious if your local libraries carry any books that would be deemed gender critical.
Does your local library have @[private account] book, or @HJoyceGender or @[private account] or @KDansky or works by @[private account] ?
We have some heavy hitters scheduled for the Informed Dissent podcast coming up in August to talk all things libraries and I am looking for some info about what materials libraries carry.
If you have any other library programming stories or materials stories related to trans please DM me.
Here is the authors suggestion;
“There are two sexes: men and women.
A man can claim an identify as a woman, and the same in reverse for a woman. They have every right to do so. Their claim should be respected and they should be protected from any form of discrimination for their choice.
Their claim does not, however, alter their biological sex.
Consequently, it is legitimate in areas such as sports where a transgender person would have a competitive advantage over non-trans people to bar such participation. Similarly, a claim to a sexual identity does not give a trans woman the right to incarceration in a woman’s prison.
Finally, the debate over gender affirming surgery and hormone treatments is fraught with contradictory assertions.
For now, because there are credible scientific claims of irreversible harms, such treatments for those under 18 should be barred pending further study.”
This is culture bound- you are trans identified because of the culture you are bound to- the root- as you yourself have said over and over is homosexuality.
It’s not the greatest feeling to deal with at first- everything we “choose” is culture bound- it’s like being able to really deal with the concept that we will one day die. I don’t think I will ever accept that fully until that moment comes.
But yes- trans is culture bound- it is not a universal, nor is it timeless- the things that people point to as “trans” even “two spirit” from ancient history is homosexuality.
And homosexuality and its gender non conformity is a vast wide presentation- but it’s homosexuality.
Currently represented in the cohorts of those presenting as trans identified-
homosexuals (the cohort who has been around since the beginning) this is not currently the vast majority of those presenting as trans.
ROGD cohort is the vast majority of those currently presenting as trans.
Then a small number of individuals who have some kind of sexual paraphilia.
Then an even smaller number of those who are just seriously mentally ill.
Then let us find ways to articulate our position better.
Let us use all of the tools that are disposal, especially if we truly can consider the historical record of how gender nonconforming homosexuals have been treated by society, I think that is where the pathway out of trans is a concept lies.
I do speak with Ben, I just replied to Glinner with a similar answer, I don’t think Ben is representing a position of insanity.
I think scientifically it is reasonable to look at this record of research and say- this has been so poorly done over and over again that there might still be a question to ask here.
And I think that we have to be able to grapple with the fact that many are going to continue to believe in this concept.
What I ask from those who would put forward this position- this concept of true trans- is to be willing to look carefully and deeply at the historical notions of where trans developed, and how it collided with our societal considerations of homosexuality.
I respect Ben a lot, he has been doing some really important reporting work.
His piece- reflects a position that many take- they continue to have concerns that the research record is so poor that they feel like there is a fundamental question that has not been clearly answered. That is a perfectly reasonable scientific question.
And what adds a layer of complexity is that there are individuals who, as adults, make claims that transition has bettered their lives.
We will never have the perfect research study to answer this question- because the question itself is one that really can only be answered by an interrogation of societal level ethics.
What happens when rights collide?
How do we address the fact that homosexuals are a small minority of people- that many are gender non-conforming from a young age?
How do we make space for gender non-conforming people many of which are homosexuals (without turning it into a parade?).
And then, after we address the majority of those who would be “trans” who are actually homosexuals- then how do we address the tiny cohort of individuals who have a sexual drive that falls into something society can not accept (fetish/deviance)?
I spent nearly 5 years inside of a pediatric gender center. It is with that knowledge- seeing nearly 1500 unique “trans kids” that I must respectfully disagree with @benryanwriter.
There is no “true trans” child. There are gender non-conforming children.
There are proto gay children. There is no ‘true trans’ child.
My school aged kids go to bed at 7pm- they wake up between 6am-7am. Solid 11-12 hours. I couldn’t imagine having kids up late.
One thing I was consistently speaking with families about in the trans center was the terrible sleep hygiene.
No “bedtimes” even for the 8- 12 year olds. No quiet phone hours for the teens. I still look back at all of the other issues in these kids lives and can’t fathom how cross sex hormones was ever considered one of the solutions.
I read your piece on Landen Roupp and the Giants' Pride Night, and I want to offer a perspective your piece never considers — one from a lesbian who has been watching these events with growing unease.
I'm not here to defend a Bible verse on a baseball cap. I'm here to ask the question your piece never does: where did the money go?
The Giants sold premium special event tickets on June 12 — jerseys, fireworks, the full production — with a promise that "partial proceeds" would benefit "local LGBTQIA+ organizations." No dollar amount. No percentage. No named recipients. Just partial proceeds, floating somewhere, benefiting someone. This is standard operating procedure across MLB. The fans who paid extra to be part of something meaningful have no idea what they funded.
I am a lesbian. I am also the Executive Director of the LGB Courage Coalition and a former clinical research coordinator at the Washington University Transgender Center, where I witnessed firsthand what pediatric gender medicine does to the young people who pass through those doors. Many of them — and the evidence increasingly supports this — were proto-gay and lesbian youth who, in an earlier era, would have grown up to be people like me. Instead they were medicalized.
That is what "the community" now means in professional sports. Not gay men and lesbians. Not the people who built those communities in San Francisco across decades of real persecution. It means an institutional agenda that actively harms the next generation of gay and lesbian kids — and it is being funded, quietly and without disclosure, through the ticket prices of fans who came to watch baseball.
You write that these players can't let our community have "just one symbol of unity and love." I want to ask you sincerely: whose community? The rainbow no longer flies for the people Harvey Milk organized, or for the men lost in San Francisco to AIDS, or for the lesbians who built the institutions that held that city together through the plague years. It flies for an agenda- it has been weaponized but not by a few rogue players- and professional sports teams are now its delivery mechanism.
These nights should stop. Not because Christians are offended. Because gay and lesbian people are being used as the emotional cover for something we never consented to — and the kids paying the price are the ones who would have grown up to be us.
I read your piece on Landen Roupp and the Giants' Pride Night, and I want to offer a perspective your piece never considers — one from a lesbian who has been watching these events with growing unease.
I'm not here to defend a Bible verse on a baseball cap. I'm here to ask the question your piece never does: where did the money go?
The Giants sold premium special event tickets on June 12 — jerseys, fireworks, the full production — with a promise that "partial proceeds" would benefit "local LGBTQIA+ organizations." No dollar amount. No percentage. No named recipients. Just partial proceeds, floating somewhere, benefiting someone. This is standard operating procedure across MLB. The fans who paid extra to be part of something meaningful have no idea what they funded.
I am a lesbian. I am also the Executive Director of the LGB Courage Coalition and a former clinical research coordinator at the Washington University Transgender Center, where I witnessed firsthand what pediatric gender medicine does to the young people who pass through those doors. Many of them — and the evidence increasingly supports this — were proto-gay and lesbian youth who, in an earlier era, would have grown up to be people like me. Instead they were medicalized.
That is what "the community" now means in professional sports. Not gay men and lesbians. Not the people who built those communities in San Francisco across decades of real persecution. It means an institutional agenda that actively harms the next generation of gay and lesbian kids — and it is being funded, quietly and without disclosure, through the ticket prices of fans who came to watch baseball.
You write that these players can't let our community have "just one symbol of unity and love." I want to ask you sincerely: whose community? The rainbow no longer flies for the people Harvey Milk organized, or for the men lost in San Francisco to AIDS, or for the lesbians who built the institutions that held that city together through the plague years. It flies for an agenda- it has been weaponized but not by a few rogue players- and professional sports teams are now its delivery mechanism.
These nights should stop. Not because Christians are offended. Because gay and lesbian people are being used as the emotional cover for something we never consented to — and the kids paying the price are the ones who would have grown up to be us.
I read your piece on Landen Roupp and the Giants' Pride Night, and I want to offer a perspective your piece never considers — one from a lesbian who has been watching these events with growing unease.
I'm not here to defend a Bible verse on a baseball cap. I'm here to ask the question your piece never does: where did the money go?
The Giants sold premium special event tickets on June 12 — jerseys, fireworks, the full production — with a promise that "partial proceeds" would benefit "local LGBTQIA+ organizations." No dollar amount. No percentage. No named recipients. Just partial proceeds, floating somewhere, benefiting someone. This is standard operating procedure across MLB. The fans who paid extra to be part of something meaningful have no idea what they funded.
I am a lesbian. I am also the Executive Director of the LGB Courage Coalition and a former clinical research coordinator at the Washington University Transgender Center, where I witnessed firsthand what pediatric gender medicine does to the young people who pass through those doors. Many of them — and the evidence increasingly supports this — were proto-gay and lesbian youth who, in an earlier era, would have grown up to be people like me. Instead they were medicalized.
That is what "the community" now means in professional sports. Not gay men and lesbians. Not the people who built those communities in San Francisco across decades of real persecution. It means an institutional agenda that actively harms the next generation of gay and lesbian kids — and it is being funded, quietly and without disclosure, through the ticket prices of fans who came to watch baseball.
You write that these players can't let our community have "just one symbol of unity and love." I want to ask you sincerely: whose community? The rainbow no longer flies for the people Harvey Milk organized, or for the men lost in San Francisco to AIDS, or for the lesbians who built the institutions that held that city together through the plague years. It flies for an agenda- it has been weaponized but not by a few rogue players- and professional sports teams are now its delivery mechanism.
These nights should stop. Not because Christians are offended. Because gay and lesbian people are being used as the emotional cover for something we never consented to — and the kids paying the price are the ones who would have grown up to be us.
Culturally we are making choices for our lives based on the pathways that are provided to us based on when and where we live.
Right now we are in a culture that pushes a concept of trans- and it pushes that concept onto homosexuals (many who are non-conforming and experienced gender related distress)- and pushes that concept trying to reframe history claiming “trans always existed” when what they are citing is homosexuality,
My hypothesis is that when you look back in time, you will find consistently that gender non-conformity is homosexuality.
“They are sometimes referred to as “two spirit people” berdaches and amazons often married more conventional individuals of the same sex as themselves”
That sounds quite homosexual.
This is not a belief that “trans stole gay history” it is a belief that ‘gender’ non conformity and ‘gender’ distress indicates homosexuality- meaning that trans is another repeat of the same old- let’s fix the homosexuals- now claiming our bodies are wrong and need to be fixed.
I think it’s Senator Moody is did an excellent job questioning Shannon.
Finally someone challenged her on minors having surgery.
Chloe keeps using the word “treatments” the word needs to be “interventions”
“Treatments” sound like they are positive.
Please stop with the joint pain- these interventions are not medically sound even without any pain complaints.
Senator Baldwin is on a tangent about LGBT protections. Her story is not making sense and I am also not sure if she is a lesbian herself….
Oh wait- she is now talking about someone with a transgender kid.
Senator Kane now discussing military ban on trans identified service members. Now on some tangent about Virginia’s history.
This hearing is now a little over an hour.
Senator Marshall now- “this is a fad” asks Micelli- sadly he missing the mark.
Asking Chloe the same question again to get the answer (again) social media. She’s repeating herself.
Again- You do not have to answer the question!
Anytime you are given the chance to speak you go to your punches.
Senator Kane tells Chloe that her story is medical malpractice. And is saying that the legal system is set up to address this.
We handed him this argument and he’s saying that the answer is medical malpractice and evolving standards.
Now he’s reading a letter from a parent whose young adult transitioned- calming positive results.
He is now pivoting to the attacks on the transgender community.
Shannon is back on the medical records- no one has addressed why these records are being sought.
“These doctors have done nothing wrong” says Shannon and continues “this is so unfair”
Now question to Chloe about how she came to this conclusion that she was trans.
Ok @[private account] still going and thanks Shannon. Says there are a lot of falsehoods.
Says it is settled law that parents make decisions about health care- still no one has discussed what is required for a true medical consent from a parent for their child.
Shannon is only being thrown this same argument- government over reach- over and over.
There are plenty of ways to challenge this. Shannon is now making emotional pleas about parents who have trans identified.
Sen Baldwin laments Chloe being protested- but also that the Doctors have been protested.
Chloe’s whole testimony is personal- it’s well delivered- but very loaded language- “the transgender cult”
She is now referencing her recent canceled speech at the university.
Shannon Minter should be up next.
We live in such interesting times. I am prepping for my interview with Ken Zucker while a young man in his early twenties is reading “Before we were trans” next to me on the pool deck.
Drescher draws the line from Stonewall to his roadshow of trans psychiatrists, but it runs in only one direction. Drescher cannot ask: what if we are not the continuation of gay liberation?
What if we are gay liberation’s complete destruction?
“No matter how new age you get, old age is gonna kick your ass” -Utah Phillips
No matter how cool trans you get, testosterone is gonna destroy your vagina, your health, and you will end up with a ragged scar across your chest. -me
First you would have to define the terms “trans” and “gender non conforming” because from a clinical perspective this person does not appear to be “trans” in the way it was early clinically defined and “gender non conforming” does not need plastic- it is authentic.
My child’s high school just sent out a list of optional surveys that the sociology students are seeking peers to participate in.
First good sign- parents were sent notification and links to review.
Second good sign- of 59 surveys not a single one about trans identification.
The questions were those asked and answered in many ways before :
-isn’t most of pediatric care based on low quality evidence
-isn’t it bad that Hilary Cass hasn’t spent years working with trans identified kids
-aren’t other kids getting cosmetic surgery for different reason’s
-then there was a question about the ASPS guidelines having an age restriction that went over 18 and then a trans identified woman in hone audience interrupted and derailed the whole Q&A
-
Today at the Pediatric Academic Society meeting it was reported that 4.5% of the high school population in a county in Wisconsin was identifying trans. But that rate wasn’t of interest or concern to the presenter.
Here is where some actual investigative journalism would have been useful.
So Dad transitioned and now claims to be Mom. Dad's new partner is named- Blue- was Carly Ann Crosby. "Carly Ann" is a traditionally female name. "Blue" is not. The pattern — female birth name, gender-neutral chosen name, hyphenated surname shared with a trans-identified male partner — my suspicion is the Blue thinks that she is either a man or non binary.
The NYT had both aliases in the complaint and did not ask the most obvious follow-up question about the second defendant's identity. In a piece that centered gender identity as the animating motive for an international kidnapping. They also confuse the readers with their pronouns and calling Dad- Mom.
Come on can you at least TRY?
This week Jesse Singal published a piece reflecting on why the trans movement has failed.
This morning Ezra Klein publishes yet another piece still considering why the Democrats have failed.
Here’s a quote from Ezra, “But it’s not just that cancellation has failed to silence those it targeted; it also weakened those who used it. The Democratic Party — and the progressive movement — was ill served by the belief that it could decide the boundaries of acceptable debate.”
Trans represents the worst elements of what the progressive movement was (still does?) do to stifle debate- but the trans movement was both the worst part of and born from that silencing.
Many of the young adults in particular that embraced trans did so as a protective response to the progressive push to cancel.
When demographics are considered in the analysis of who embraced a trans or non binary identity- for every 1 Alejandra Caraballo there were 7 white middle class/affluent young women who saw the cancelation around them due to race, ethnicity, and class from the progressive movement and they did something both rather intelligent in the moment although cretinous in the long run.
They found a way to “identify” into a protected category to try to insulate themselves from the very cancelation that they would then perpetuate.
We jokingly referred to so many as “snowflakes” but what they did was create an avalanche.
Let us not forget- Kellan Baker and Chase Strangio both came out as lesbians before identifying as trans. They are gender nonconforming homosexuals who couldn't find a healthy way to grow into who they were. We are now allowing their projection — their own unresolved embodiment — to serve as the clinical and policy framework for the next generation of gay and lesbian young people. When Kellan speaks all I see is a self hating lesbian, when Chase speaks all I hear is a self hating lesbian.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Kellan Baker, a top policy wonk in gender medicine, at a 2023 conference theatrically mocked a 2022 NYT article addressing concerns about the long-term impacts of puberty blockers: "You can just feel the pearls being clutched!”
To see the whole video: https://benryan.substack.com/p/we-all-support-trans-kids-in-the
@[private account] That is not to whom I was referring- I was referring to gender non conforming youth and young people who feel distress.
How could I be referring to “trans youth” if it is a conceptual frame that I don’t agree with or believe in?
Also the question was about conversion therapy-
@[private account] I need some guidance from professional journalist and writers to assist. And I have reached out to them. The words inside the brackets are the issue- I didn’t say trans youth because I don’t utilize that as a conceptual framework.
I have sent this article and the video recording to a number of professional journalists to assess the use of brackets in a quote attributed to me.
I am fine with the inaccuracy implying I took a bus when I actually flew, but the use of brackets in a quote implying that I was talking about [trans youth] is much more concerning…
Rare emerging condition- state tracks cases- explosion of trans identifying children with a once considered rare condition and started on life altering interventions- no one tracks and considers doing so to be some kind of conspiracy.
Today the LGB Courage Coalition testified in Ohio in support of HB 693. Afterward we wrote to the Democratic members who questioned us — as gays and lesbians — to say: you cannot pivot to bread and butter issues until the party reckons with this one.
We supported the idea of the transgender child without the medical evidence to back it. Country after country in Europe has now restricted these practices after systematic review. The evidence was never what we were told it was.
The path back to disaffected liberals runs directly through this issue. They are not going to set it aside. The party needs to be able to say: we got this wrong. Until it can, many of us cannot come home.
Excellent question from Rep Matthews- he correctly recognizes that more religious families adopt from foster care or are foster parents- and when trans ideology is a requirement to be a foster parent many kids will lose out on having their forever home. @[private account] ♥️
I just found out that there is an annual protest for “trans rights” in my hometown that started because of my whistleblower affidavit. I think I would like to go tomorrow, but I know everyone will tell me it’s not safe.
You are welcomed to your belief or understanding. We continue to review the evidence, history, and clinical data.
We do not agree that there is a “true trans” and advocate that no one- regardless of age- should be subjected to the material harms inflicted by puberty blockers, cross sex hormones or surgery in the name of “gender” regardless of the pathways.
That has not been part of our messaging at all.
The concept here is that when the “ROGD” cohort or other cohorts find these interventions ceased (or are banned) there has been an argument around a concept of “true trans” that there is a small group for which this was always and should continue to be considered “treatment”.
When we ask people who the “true trans” are or for them to describe what they mean- they discuss gender non conforming homosexuals.
Our concern is not that ONLY homosexuals are targeted or have been harmed- but that the original targets were gender non conforming homosexuals and that many will still agree that cohort is ok to remain harmed when all the rest of the attention pivots away.
As state debates around trans continues a new talking point I am hearing increasingly is that national experts are to be ignored if they are inconvenient to the narrative.
So far, I’ve been told if I live in Ohio, Colorado, or Maine only then would I be welcomed as part of the dialogue.
What other issue do we silence national experts when a topic comes close to home?
We continue to be the inconvenient and silenced- @KDansky @LGBCourage @JenniferSey @[private account]
@icons_women @[private account]
Quotes a post by T15707; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is becoming a new talking point- on most issues we would absolutely welcome a national expert- but if it’s related to trans- we have somebody who could be really good (lesbian, liberal) but…we’re not gonna invite her because she’s not from the state. @KDansky @JenniferSey @Erin4Parents
It’s not just my view, even the HHS report documents that a significant driver of trans identification is and began with societal response to homosexuality especially gender non confirming homosexuals.
We have not addressed real homophobia, or the acceptance for those who are gender non conforming homosexuals.
The primary driver of trans identification is this- they are gays and lesbians.
There are currently cohorts with trans identification that fall with the large ROGD umbrella, and there are small numbers of primarily men with sexual proclivities that drive a small amount of trans identification (with an outsized influence) and then even smaller in numbers is a tiny cohort that are with pervasive significant mental illness.
I read it on your suggestion, Leor. I don’t agree that I want this movement to do better though.
I believe what’s missing is that the author continues to give value to that original conceptualization that trans exists- this piece continues to perpetuate this myth that there is a diagnosable condition that belongs within any sort of medical or mental health framework.
Of course, ‘trans’ became radicalized because the concept itself defies reality.
This was not a pin. This was a giant obnoxious lanyard with the rainbow/trans flag on it.
And this also involved me simply informing this physician that my child has a nickname, after which I got one of those stupid lectures that I used to do where she went on to explain oh I always ask people how they like to be called and what pronouns we should use because some patients are named Liam and like to be called Lynn. 🤮
My child is four.
Hi Brian, I see you are a gay man, and willing to judge me as a lesbian and my parenting based on a Twitter post - If you are willing to please read one thing today will you please read this post from my friend @[private account] https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/03/gay-boys-lgbtq-trans/686179/
Please explain the diagnostic process with which to reach a conclusion of a “true trans” presentation that fully acknowledges the breath and depth of the experience of homosexuals.
This was my comment- As a lesbian I completely agree that there is no need for a public space to fly any kind of LGBTQ flag.
In addition- many of us find certain iterations of these flags to be offensive.
The “progress pride” flag for example (the rainbow with the trans flag cut in) is offensive to many LGB individuals.
The only flags that should be flown on public buildings: the American flag, the state flag, the municipality or city flag.
As a lesbian I completely agree that there is no need for a public space to fly any kind of LGBTQ flag.
In addition- many of us find certain iterations of these flags to be offensive.
The “progress pride” flag for example (the rainbow with the trans flag cut in) is offensive to many LGB individuals.
The only flags that should be flown on public buildings: the American flag, the state flag, the municipality or city flag.
We have heard from a number of disaffected LGB individuals who watched as the orgs became captured from within that there is an age component- the trans is wrapped up in wider “woke” HR/policy shifts.
The younger staff essentially bully through a “woke” framework and push that into the org- demanding policies aligned with identify- disability, race, ethnicity, gender- once the bowing down has gained a foothold it becomes engrained into the HR culture and it’s so insidious the ‘trans’ can not be addressed because they successfully tied it all together.
I do not believe they are intentionally lying to themselves- we are all responding to the culture around us- and the cultural response to gender non conforming homosexuals is profoundly challenging- from early childhood- and in some eras even more challenging in different ways.
We have never embraced gender non conformity or homosexuality as natural and welcomed- trans has always offered a pathway out for homosexuals- homosexuality leaves the DSM gender appears.
Because we have never embraced gender non conformity or homosexuality- especially in men- the narrative offering an out of homosexuality- as a medical problem to be solved, as a way to become straight passing- accounts for many of those “classic transsexuals”
Again-with a small number of those being profoundly mentally ill or with a sexual proclivity.
But is there such a thing as “true trans” - no, the answer is no.
I have seen no evidence to support such a claim- or evidence for that supposed cohort that a transition is an evidenced based, safe, or an efficacious path.
I was on a podcast once and the interviewer said to me you don’t come across like a TERF, you come across as just being profoundly sad about all of this.
Because I am- because when you reflect on the four cohorts that make up “trans”.
1. The ROGD cohort
2. The gender non conforming homosexuals, who trans targets- the primary target
3. The small number of, primarily men, with a sexual proclivity
4. The profoundly mentally ill
None of them are served by a social, legal, or medical pathway and everyone is harmed.
But as a lesbian, I am most concerned that the primary target- will remain a target- long when most of you forget all about this.
@benryanwriter @[private account]
Quoting @benryanwriter: Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes denounces @[private account]’s article in @TheAtlantic as “absolute trash.” He faults Appel for not citing medical professionals.
“Child psychologists know the difference between gay kids and trans kids,” Hobbes insists, without citing medical profs.
I can speak to the US center where I worked- there were absolutely cases of patients saying it was easier and better socially to be trans than gay.
But another important element- we are not talking about the ROGD cohort- this is not the socially mediated group of primarily post adolescent teens girls.
The cohort being discussed is the traditionally gender non confirming/distressed child from a young age- this is the cohort included in the Dutch studies and the initial targets for pediatric transitions- and those who most likely would grow up to be gay or lesbians.
I found this paragraph- interesting? Bizarre? Hard to follow?
And somehow @LGBCourage is in cahoots with the ‘erasure’ at Stonewall?
“Jamie Reed was present at this hearing, representing the LGB Courage Coalition, a lobbying organization she and other “gender critical” and organized in 2023 (originally called the LGBT Courage Coalition). It was originally a Substack blog for anti-trans activists and conservative trans people, who were ousted from the organization due to the Trump administration’s trans erasure push, including the censoring of transgender identity at the Stonewall National Monument in the Greenwich Village neighborhood of Lower Manhattan.”
Great analysis of the recent polling regarding public support for trans.
@LeorSapir ask a critical question have pediatric gender interventions eroded trust in medicine.
I know personally it has had a chilling effect on my trust- I have also heard those defending pediatric gender interventions claim that many interventions given to children also have low quality evidence supporting those interventions.
This is not a gotcha moment and a win for trans rights activists- it’s much more of an oh shit moment- maybe children should not be routinely given SSRIs, ADHD drugs, or daily use prescriptions without strong, high-quality evidence.
A ‘spillover’ is often described as a virus “jumping” from one species to another, as though it were a singular event or an act of viral aggression. In reality, a spillover is almost never a clean jump. It is a slow, probabilistic failure of boundaries that normally hold.
A virus typically persists in what is known as a reservoir host. This does not mean the virus is benign, welcomed, or inert. The virus continues to replicate, and the immune system continues to respond, but neither overwhelms the other. If the virus killed its host efficiently, it would eliminate its own environment. Survival depends on restraint, but not harmony.
This is where the virus of trans lived- in the gender non-conforming homosexuals.
Viruses do not remain confined to their reservoir species. They are constantly shed into the environment. They regularly try to enter other species. Most of these incursions fail. The virus cannot enter cells, cannot replicate effectively, or is destroyed by the immune system. These failed spillovers happen constantly and invisibly.
When infection does succeed, the consequences are often severe because the new host has not co-evolved with the virus. In a new species, immune responses may be excessive, poorly targeted, or delayed.
This mismatch is why spillover infections are frequently more destructive than infections in the reservoir host. The damage is not only caused by the virus itself but by an immune system encountering a threat it does not know how to regulate.
This is trans in the adolescent population, this is trans spilling over into a social contagion.
Crucially, spillover is not driven by viral intention or novelty alone. It is usually the result of changed conditions (social media, cell phones, Covid, ASD). The virus may be unchanged. What has shifted is the context in which it operates.
After a successful spillover infection, one of three outcomes follows. The virus may reach a dead end, infecting a single individual without further transmission. It may cause limited transmission before burning out. Or, in rarer cases, it may adapt to the new host through mutation, enabling sustained transmission.
Only this final scenario produces an outbreak. The vast majority of spillover events never reach that stage, but their failure is what obscures how often the process is attempted.
Spillover, then, is not a leap. It is a breach—one made possible not by a single moment of viral emergence, but by the gradual erosion of the barriers that normally keep biological systems in balance.
And this is what we are fighting, this is the battle against trans. (I clearly think about this all way too much.)
Everyone deserves safe and efficacious medical care- and when it is consistently and persistently NOT provided- it’s time to ban those procedures.
https://rangemedia.co/allegations-gender-affirming-surgeon-stir-fears-trans-patients/?utm_source=ig&utm_medium=social&utm_content=link_in_bio
As the American Society of plastic surgeons recently released a position statement on trans surgeries-an article like this makes clear that many will still be performing these dangerous surgeries without an evidence base.
Everyone should be aware that unless the surgeon is actually board certified as a cosmetic surgeon then any physician can simply call themselves one.
The New York Times does not agree with you regarding trans identified people going to Iran for surgery. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/10/world/middleeast/iran-transgender-surgery.html
When people ask why there seem to be more trans-identified kids, the guide doesn’t engage the question.
Instead, it pivots to: “What if the world told you you shouldn’t exist?”
Um there was/is an actual social contagion!
@[private account] you will actually deal with this someday right?
I woke up wondering what is happening for all the trans identified Americans in Iran there for surgical tourism…hope their appointments have been canceled.
I sincerely wish you were correct in your statement- however I had young people directly say it was better to be trans than gay- as patients in the gender center