The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Then most research shows-in terms of gender transitions- that is not the case.
There will be individuals, who in the now will self report improvement (in the past studies that was primarily the homosexual women because they got from transition what they were seeking- a way to be with their partner without violence, legally, etc).
But you also have to look at the whole picture- including long term physical health. And as a society we get to factor in the societal costs of the disruption caused by transition.
So when all of that is factored in- then we see an experiment that does not have safe outcomes, or efficacious outcomes, with societal level disruptions which makes it not something that should be encouraged, covered by any insurance, or considered a ‘treatment’
Finally at its core trans attacks gender non confirming individuals- who are primarily homosexuals- and pushes regressive homophobic ideas.
So when judged by all rational mechanisms the overall concept of the trans experiment on society is a failure regardless of a few people claiming it brought them happiness.
By clinical definition in the DSM? Which DSM version?
Because there are many trans activists that would argue with you that you are incorrect about that, because the DSM requires that individuals had to experience distress.
The endocrinologist that I worked with, would actually disagree with you as well, and he was prescribing puberty, blockers, and cross sex hormones to children.
He did not require a diagnosis of gender dysphoria.
There is no “being trans” there are individuals who have experienced distress over their sexed bodies, or been caught in a socially mediated concept.
Some of those individuals believe what was sold to them, that changing their physical bodies will make something about their lives better…
But no one can change their sex and medical transitions only cause harms- physically to the individual, to the family, and to society.
I am going to keep saying this until I am blue in the face. ADVOCATES should get paid. I am sick of the double standard @[private account] asked only 1 person “are you getting paid” and that was @chloecole she knew damn well that the other side were PAID advocates. This also happened to @[private account] in New Hampshire.
If you are ever asked if you got paid to testify and you have not, simply say, “I should be and the trans activists in the room ARE so ask them”
Quotes a post by A0381; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Hi Matty, please review the NYT story https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/23/health/transgender-youth-st-louis-jamie-reed.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare
The more I think about this more frustrated I get, why is it OK that those who identify as trans get subpar mental health interventions with untrained individuals? Why doesn’t this cohort deserve real professional care?
Episode 3 of this new show “The Pitt” (it’s ER rebooted) anyway…a trans identified man just came in. Wrist is cut open, got “deadnamed” at check in. Let’s see where this goes 🙄
“It was a bunch of people politely discussing how many deck chairs on the Titanic should be reserved for transgender people,”
https://apple.news/ArB6yQGCCSrKo6PqpkFzV-g
But we have reached the point of no return, because the core truth, the core issue of all trans care is not a question of research but of ethics.
It was the question being asked at the start in 1974 in Vrje University (VU) should we cut into or hormonally disrupt the healthy body?
My answer is no, we should not. Not even for research and especially not in children. And especially not when it means harming my community, proto gay and lesbians bodies are no longer the fodder for scientific inquiry.
We are perfect just the way we are. Leave us alone.
A lot of local coverage from last night. Still waiting on the @[private account] NPR coverage…@[private account]?
Jonah Wheeler’s vote on trans ‘bathroom bill’ elicits emotions from the community https://archive.ph/2025.03.26-220241/https://www.ledgertranscript.com/Peterborough-Sharon-State-reps-Jonah-Orion-wheeler-Peter-Leishman-executive-council-Karen-liot-hill-hold-listening-session-with-voters-at-Peterborough-town-library-NH-state-house-60219302
lifelong liberal, all of the legacy gay and lesbian orgs $$ is pro trans, including supporting medicalizing children, so yes this is the resistance @LGBCourage
We also had @[private account] who gave a passionate speech on the floor in Texas.
She was primaried, in part because the legacy gay orgs have all the money and are captured by trans.
We are the scrappy underdogs- the Davids in the fight.
Informed consent means that a patient is first explained what they have been diagnosised with after appropriate testing, labs, assessment, and a differential is completed.
That does not occur in gender related interventions, because it has become a self diagnosis, I say I’m trans therefore I get what I want.
In the early Dutch treatment of adults 1/3 a were screened out and told no. If a differential was being completed now- 1/3 should be screened out in similar ways as the Dutch- and then the social contagion would screen out another huge %.
There is no differential diagnosis occuring, it’s a free for all, and if that doesn’t happen, no one is providing a real informed consent.
I don’t know how many times I heard be careful they will come after the gays next…the only thing I see is trans activists coming after free speech now.
Amie, Jonah is amazing. He could benefit from speaking with you.
Important discussion we had is that everyone incarcerated in the US should be ensured their safety and dignity. Including men in prison.
The conversation doesn’t need to be that trans identified men need to be moved for their safety.
A just society should work that everyone incarcerated is safe, has their basic needs met, and treated with dignity.