The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
I have no tolerance for people who treat trans identity abusively or tell adults they can't live their lives how they want.
But all of these issues -- most particularly the ones affecting kids -- are very new and complex. You have every right to question and debate them.
You might recall prominent Dem trans activist @[private account] -- who had a long history as a male feminist of harassing and abusing women, which is now gone to history -- praised Iran for being so progressive on trans treatments when it's actually used as a means of erasing gay people:
Trans adults deserve the absolute right to decide how they will live, and to be treated with respect and live with dignity and full equal rights. But somehow, we've accepted only bigots question if these brand new medical treatments are safe for kids:
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/14/health/puberty-blockers-transgender.html
If the trans movement has remained focus on where the gay movement always was focused - the right of *adults* to live their lives with full autonomy and to be respected in their identity - there would have been little controversy. The "live and let live" ethos prevails in the US.
One of the most dishonest debate-closing tactics has been to imply those who write a lot about trans issues (that does not include me) are creepily obsessed with what adults do to their bodies.
It's just a lie: most of the debate is about what society is doing to *young kids.*
My statement came immediately after I listened to one of the most prominent trans activists speak about their views on gender, a claim I've heard many times before. I've long had concerns about the use of regressive gender stereotypes as the basis for this discourse.
Yes, @BillKristol and the neocons at Bulwark are now hard-core trans activists.
One key to understanding neocons: they don't care about social issues at all. They'll adopt any view they have to to wield power in their new party to support Endless War and the US Security State:
Quoting @mtaibbi: The Bulwark people are trans activists now? No one thinks that’s weird?
Ever since Bernie's campaign collapsed and he decreed they all must follow him back into captivity to the Dem Party, the mainstream left has struggled so hard to find a way to distinguish themselves from their Pelosi-loving moms.
They thought trans issues could be it but, alas..
This is an informative, well-reported and valuable piece of journalism on the debate and conflicts among health care professionals about teenagers who identify as transgender and seek treatment.
It's rare to find this topic treated carefully, without one's thumb on the scale:
Quotes a post by T35576; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yes, Renee Richards has also said it would've been unfair even though she fought to compete in the WTA. She was in her 40s then. She said she would've destroyed the top WTA players if she competed earlier as a woman, and it would've been unfair.
https://www.si.com/tennis/2019/06/28/renee-richards-gender-identity-politics-transgender-where-are-they-now
In 2018, we signed with Reese Witherspoon to produce a film on Martina's unique life. Once she said the science couldn't establish the fairness of allowing trans women to compete, we couldn't get a director.
They turned a brave pioneer into an outcast.
https://theintercept.com/2020/07/14/cancel-culture-martina-navratilova-documentary/
Martina is #19 on @SInow's 100 Greatest 20th Century Athletes. After @BillieJeanKing, she was the leading pioneer of women's pro sports. One of the only openly gay celebrities of her era, she hired a trans coach in 1983: a huge gain for trans visibility.
Now: off-limits poison.
A spokeswoman for an LGBT group "urged" NYT's @[private account], when reporting on trans women in female sports, not to "platform" (ie quote) Martina Navratilova -- easily one of the top 5 most important female/lesbian athlete-pioneers of the 20th Century -- because she has wrong views.