The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
I don't think he's really interested in the historical record or he wouldn't have said what he did as he did. The "historical record" contains no evidence of transgender centrality during the riots, the aftermath or the creation of the gay liberation movement. Hint: the central figures are in the name of the movement. Hope that helps! 😉
Malcolm Michaels, drag name Marsha Johnson, had literally nothing to do with the inspiration for the creation of or the organizing of Pride - that was Craig Rodwell, a gay bookshop owner.
Johnson was a crossdressing, very low rent sex worker, who was never trans and said so - not an event planner.
Think about that next time some jadrool tries to force team LGBs to buttress Ts, who had rejected gays and lesbians completely from their groups back then. Thank Arnold "Virginia Prince" Lowman, a straight crossdresser, for that.
It was literally the Ts who originally demonized LGBs in the first place, not the other way round.
Quotes a post by T28925; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
One method that tranz trash historical revisionists like to use is to decontextualize one part of a sentence from an hour long interview and say, "Ah ha! You went home!" Yeah, as did everyone who was there as dawn broke. The trans trash split minutes after the police reinforcements arrived - we (white gay men & women) stayed until things sputtered to a close at dawn. There are pictures, too, you know. I did the only known radio interview after the first night, that still exist today, describing the start of the riot. Trans revisionists hate that interview.
"Forced teaming" is what you're "lobbying" for, not "solidarity," you phony. Trans people have made no meaningful contributions to LGB history; they wanted nothing to do with LGBs til the 90s until they finally sank ENDA with their excessive demands.
You know nothing.
We were not "LGBTQI+ADNAUSEAM", we were two gay men and two lesbians - myself, Craig Rodwell, Ellen Broidy & Linda Rhodes. You know, there are actual history books you could use to look these things up. Trans people made no meaningful contributions to the gay liberation movement and had absolutely nothing to do with the creation and organization of Pride.
Prove me wrong.
Yes. He even admits that as a trans "scholar" he doesn't wish to get bogged down by accuracy; instead, label most from then with the slur that they abjured.
I detest "Susan" Stryker.
Someone get me his deadname, pls. I'll name you in my will.
Name one trans person arrested at the Stonewall and, sit down because this will come as a shock to a historical revisionist like you, no transperson was even remotely involved in the creation or organizing of the "early Pride(s)" - as in none, nada, zero. I was there and you were not.
The term transgender was first published in an American journal by psychiatrist John F. Oliven in his medical text Sexual Hygiene and Pathology in 𝟭𝟵𝟲𝟱. He used it to describe people who desired gender-affirming medical intervention, believing it was a more accurate term than "transsexual" because sexual preference played no role in their internal gender. Now, kindly keep American history out of your mouth. Were done here, idiote.
"(H)elped a whole lot the LGBTQ+ movement." Said movement didn't exist at the time. It was the GAY LIBERATION MOVEMENT. So riddle me this: what did these heroes do at the time that was so meaningful to the struggle? Be specific; bring receipts. All that language existed back then but not as you'd have us believe today. Queer was and is a slur. Trans was used beginning in '65. I was there and you were not. Shit, your parents weren't even born then.
Using recognized references and not trans propaganda sites and blogs, show me one thing that I've rewritten. Who said I wanted to be recognized? Got a source other than your opinion? Of course not. I will certainly disagree with your implication that I'm "no better" than a drug-addled, homeless, profoundly mentally ill pimp of gay children, you ignoramus. Time to mute your dishonest account. Ta ta, shorty.
Xe paved the way for the trans moon landing in July of 1969. Without exception, all cultures owe the sum of their history and accomplishments to transpeople.
Quotes a post by T01588; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
He very much hated lesbians and argued that the L should be dropped back then. I never heard that he changed his mind about that. @[private account]'s version is straight up hagiography of that massive scumbag with all of the many "blemishes" sandblasted away. Grok uses trans activists in lieu of historians.
No, he wasn't leading the first Pride march at any point. That's me, second from the left wearing a marshal armband and carrying our sole bullhorn as we started to march. He was finally banned from Pride in '73. A junkie, child pimp doesn't have lots of fans, you know.
Now, for extra credit, point out all the trans people in this photo from the only commemorative booklet of that first march.
They actual think he used the name "Marsha" for other than drag. They don't even know stopped doing drag five years before his suicide. They don't know that in the Village most of his friends knew him as Mikey. They get all their history from trans propaganda pieces plastered onto the internet by today's trans historical revisionists. Why are these youngsters all so profoundly ignorant? Why, growing up on the internet, of course. AI will crush them - they'll never even see it coming. People who have never lived without a phone are truly witless.
I could go on but I don't care about their lives. They mean nothing and will live up to that observation.
Hugs, young lady.
🤣🤣🤣 Now you're citing the notoriously inaccurate @TheAdvocateMag. What trans propagandist website in lieu of a real historical, reliable source will you be citing next, @PinkNews?
Fucking amateur.
AI isn't an accepted history source. Two male prostitutes who were crossdressers that were executed for being gay under the anti-gay law that applied solely to homosexuals, Paragraph §175, is not evidence of a trans genocide by the Nazis. The other two alleged trans "victims" were Jews who were persecuted under the anti-semitic laws.
None of us do mornings well at our age. Then the trans historical revisionists show up and the day goes downhill from there. I improve my mood by going to the Pinned Tweet on @[private account] and using the PayPal link to drop a couple of £s to help the bunnies. Helping CCRR do good for our needy long earred friends lifts my spirit everytime. 😉
Quotes a post by T00335; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yet, despite all the evidence to the contrary, @[private account] (D-NY) would have you believe that anarchists, Antifa and Trantifa aren't real.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: An Antifa blog site is issuing a call for further attacks on @ICEgov facilities across the country.
The post also explains Antifa's ideology: sociopathy, chaos, destruction and violence for the sake of "becoming ungovernable." This is why Antifa's focus changes from Occupy-related rioting to BLM to trantifa. Anything they can use to incite violence, they will exploit.
"Every fist that hurls a piece of concrete through a bank or an ICE agent's car window has the potential to ignite a wildfire ... For some of us, chaos and destruction are the only activities in which we experience life as liberated creativity." https://archive.is/q892K
No one cares about your delusions. You're the one who came to my TL to say that a man can be a woman. I've made no effort to enforce speech as the trans activist did and you support.
This should make clear how the public feels about your abusive effort. I will delete you from my TL because you have nothing meaningful to offer there but attempt to hold court, and eliminate your ability to create such false content easily.
Stonewall was a Mafia run bar with a predominantly white clientele. The bar wasn't broadly welcoming to drag queens. Mostly young white gay men initiated the riot. Instead of a baseless, screencapped assertion, perhaps consider reading a history book or looking through the collection of photos from the riot taken by Fred McDarrah. Stay off trans propaganda sites. They have an agenda that isn't supported by proper research. Back then, crossdressers wanted nothing to do with us and prohibited gays from joining their groups like FPE and the Beaumont Society.
Also, my tweet did not say that "no trans person stood up for gays." That's a lie and you know it. Your group supports the work of a person who has accepted $15K of funding from an anti-gay hate group, so you and LGB Coalition disgust me. You want to accuse anyone of hate, start with her. I'm unimpressed with the lot of you.
You are so full of yourself that you can't even resist here telling me what to do, as though that is your place. You want to keep this up and keep sending shitty Replies into my TL, "head writer"? Then you'll reap the whirlwind.
Lord, spare me the critiques of a self-inflated, mediocre activist from a toxic, self-important group that behave like a roving gang of TRA thugs. Fuck you and fuck your group. I'll block who I chose to, despite lacking your permission, you dishonest, unimportant, pissant.
You're conflating criticizing transgender activism with standing up for gays and lesbians, two very different, not synonymous things, and that's not even factoring in who has the greater, effective reach.
Name one trans person who's stood up more for gays or lesbians than Graham Linehan @Glinner.
It's a trick ask since the only thing that trans people have ever done for lesbians and gays is to transplain to us why we owe them for everything that we alone have done for ourselves.
Quoting @TwisterFilm: A straight Irishman called Linehan is defending gay rights better than the most prominent gay Irishman. Go figure. 🤷♂️👇
The hot weather has brought the TQ+ crazies out to say "see, we told you so, pick mes!"
A case application to SCOTUS from the losingest county clerk in Kentucky, Kim Davis, represented by counsel, Matt Staver, a former dean from a scandalous university who organizes support riots, er, rallies for his client in Peru (the country, not the Vermont town) isn't quite the case that the trans historical revisionists think that it is. Their fundie needs argument puts VA v Loving on the religious chopping block, too.
Ain't gonna happen.
https://www.newsweek.com/supreme-court-faces-decision-same-sex-marriages-2111822
'Fraid not.
I particularly disliked their line, "but this time, we fought back." They were under arrest inside the bar and in custody. The riot, the resistance, the uprising, all occurred outside the bar. The trans boyfriend of the bar's operator took off running and was never seen again during the following nights of rioting. Trans people didn't play a meaningful part in the start or the continuance of the rioting. That's a made up part of the story.
Today's Stonewall Inn @[private account] has totally bought into the historical revisionism of the trans narrative. They also claim to be the "Birthplace of The Gay Rights Movement." The gay rights movement predates the existence of the Mafia run bar that exploited the gay community by decades.
The Stonewall Inn has always been a detriment to the gay community. Nothing has changed there.
Prior to the 1990s trans organizations prohibited homosexuals from joining their organizations. The first schism in the so-called community occured in 1903 over Magnus Hirschfeld's trying to shoehorn the groups together with his "third sex" nonsense. @[private account] pls note.
"Dirty" Mike Umbers, the landlord, ran a child porn studio in the building nextdoor to the vaunted STAR House of prostitution. The "landlord" also ran his own straight house of prostitution. Where the fuck do you think those kids worked when they weren't being trafficked on 42nd street as a part of Matty "The Horse" Ianniello's operation?
Get off of Wikipedia and read a book, ya df. Start with either of the two meticulously researched on the topic by Philip Crawford based on FOIAed FBI docs. Male trans identifying Wikipedia editors tend to avoid that sort of referencing in their articles.
You know, for someone who can't read, isn't it amazing that I've gotten published in the NYTimes, the Village Voice, other publications and online, and a forward for one book on the Stonewall riots?
It had always been LG only for literally two generations. @[private account] doesn't know its own history. The Human Rights Campaign founder, Steve Endean, opposed conflating LGB issues with the unrelated T issues. The two got mixed together as a part of a T plan, not an LGB plan, only in the mid 90s. Don't believe that? Confirming documentation is available at the Transgender Archive.
It's time to get back to that before everything that's been gained goes down the drain being created by the groomy excesses of TQ+ ideological claptrap.
Quotes a post by A1465; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
We know a lot more about what happened that night than people choose to find out by just doing some thing as simple as getting off the internet, stop citing articles written by trans partisans, and reading any real history book rather than the smack that gets published every Pride month like clockwork. Malcolm Michaels was 40 blocks away getting high on a whore stroll uptown. That he wasn't there is a known fact that even he eventually acknowledged (after first lying about where he was and what he did). We weren't led or inspired by drug-addled, homeless, profoundly mentally ill, criminal pimps of children like him and his partner in child pimping, Rae "Sylvia" Rivera. Rivera never showed up at all, another known fact.
I wish that all the young people trying to trans Malcolm Michaels, drag name Marsha Johnson, daily on this app would look at what he said about his doing drag in 1988, four years before his suicide. There are no comparable videos of him ever saying that he was trans. All of it is a myth.
HT @[private account]
Quotes a post by A3131; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yes. I'm using old stats that I have. The new stats show a marked increase. I believe their are other factors at play regarding the new stats that I've yet to see studies about, so I use the older conservative stats. There'll be an association with trans activism in the end that'll account for part of the increase, I believe.
Pride institutions jumped the trans shark a decade ago. Corporate calculations have determined that their time on the money churn ride for the exclusionary, fetishistic, gender idiocy parade is past. The ka-ching is over.
Good.
Quotes a post by A1052; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
While I'm disappointed in some, I feel that it will be impossible for her to gain the kind traction she had with the trans community based on her past virulent condemnation of so many real, effective LGB activists. She's a fraud and too many people here know that.
Name someone trans or of color who was a member of the entirely white, lesbian and gay staffed Christopher Street Liberation Day Umbrella Committee. Your rhetoric notwithstanding, you know squat about who did what, don't you?
No one trans played any role in the creation or organization of the first Pride. In fact, the only crossdressers to contact the Christopher Street Liberation Day Umbrella Committee before the march, the Queens Liberation Front, declined to play any active role despite the march organizing committee being open to all through subcommittees to all in the community. The correspondence still exists. We certainly were not inspired or led by the drug-addled, criminal, homeless, crossdressing, pimp of children depicted in your photo, Rae "Sylvia" Rivera. Nor was he present during the Stonewall riots at any point. Keep American LGB history out of your mouth.
Thirty people care what you think. I'm not one of them. Scroll on to some trans Kool-aid account if you're looking for that kind of forced validation. I'm all out here.
You're free to give Erica Moise @legaltweetz all the benefit of the doubt that you'd like, just as I'm free to not to buy the self-described Trans Jesus's current Road to Damascus schtick. She's an extremely hateful, if less than artful, liar. She claims to be open to discussion with people of differing views but in the end it's always her way or else.
We all rejected them then because of their trafficking gay children. Get off the internet and read a history book or a fact checked article:
https://www.spiked-online.com/2024/01/14/sylvia-rivera-the-dark-truth-about-a-trans-icon/
Twenty-four years after Stonewall, Rae "Sylvia" Rivera told historian Martin Duberman that he didn't want to be a woman twice during an interview. Ten years later, when he was dying and needed housing he told the owners of the building in Brooklyn who were trans that he was trans. "And the grift goes on... 🎶"
Trans exposé hate videos are a compilation of every lie that anyone's ever told about you. It's a Terf right of passage. The problem for them is that the only people who watch their videos already hate the shit out of you, speaking of silos.
These are people who describe themselves variously as detransitioning or detransitioners or rational trans or the reasonable ones. Rational or reasonable is under considerable dispute since their views are of considerable risk to the health, safety and wellbeing of children and women. Homophobia is the anchor to much of what they espouse.
Some of the most notable supposedly trans figures from 60s maintained that they were not women for decades after Stonewall in both recordings and record interviews with historians.
**cough** 'Mikey' Malcolm 'Marsha Johnson' Michaels **cough** **cough** Rae 'Sylvia' Rivera **cough**
The only ones trying to rewrite LGB history are trans historical revisionists like yourself. Prove he was there when the riot started or did anything meaningful by using verifiable citations, not partisan Pride month online essays Shame on you!
Malcolm Michaels, drag name Marsha, was a gay man, not trans. He was a profoundly mentally ill and incapable of properly leading his own life, let alone others. He ran a house of prostitution for underage youth, teaching them the ropes of the prostitution trade and how to steal. He was 40 blocks away when the riot broke out and played no role in its instigation.
I was there and he was not.
https://www.spiked-online.com/2023/01/28/the-myth-of-marsha-p-johnson/
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] "STONEWALL ITSELF!" Bwahahaha! Ha! You mean the organization that announced it was throwing lesbians and gays under the bus for the trans crowd? You dipshits couldn't possibly be using a fundraising grift as a reliable source, could you? Utterly risible.
As with so many things, you have no idea why I'm here. You're also a liar who when caught, doubles down but in a sleazy, evasive manner.
Do you know that we kept minutes of our CSLDUC meetings, right from the very first one in our apartment? They're on file in two major libraries - NYPL and UCONN.
Being a trans realist is just a plus.
Now, prove something that you'd like people to believe about your Mother of Pride fiction.
You're out of your league, child.
Everytime some trans Reddit historian cites the "but muh trans 'Miss' Major Griffin-Gracy was at Stonewall" myth, I'm remind of this historical autopsy of the Major Gracy claptrap by the inimitable @[private account].
Quotes a post by T17899; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Have they no shame? Trantifa extremist elements seek to destroy a BUNNY RESCUE. Please give them a follow to show solidarity with and Pride in GC followed bunny rescues
TRAs are this heartless.
Quotes a post by T00895; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
One of the most enduring myths that we hear during Pride Month about the life and death of Malcolm Michaels, drag name Marsha Johnson, is that he was murdered. There is no supportive evidence for that claim. There as ample evidence to believe that Michaels took his own life. Transgender historical revisionists often cite a Netflix so-called "documentary" as proof of the murder claim. As @[private account] definitively shows in the 🧵 below, nothing could be further from the truth.
Bookmark and RT this 🧵 everytime this month that you see the lie that Malcolm Michaels was murdered.
Quotes a post by A3131; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It's dawn here in Vermont at 4:37 AM on June 1, 2025 and you know what that means, don't you? It's Pride Month again. What better way to celebrate it than to read a debunking 🧵 from @[private account] regarding one of the most enduring myths of the Stonewall era: that Malcolm Michaels, drag name Marsha Johnson, ever identified as transgender.
Spoiler alert: He didn't.
Quotes a post by A3131; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Considering how hard the queer activists have been coming at gays and lesbians to convert into Ts, anyone could have seen this coming. It turns out that it wasn't the straights who were coming for us after all.
https://www.newsweek.com/transgender-gay-lgbtq-pew-poll-2078622
Media coverage everywhere today does a piss poor job of covering the contributions of the trans community to the gay rights movement.
Until the mid 1990s there was a significant divide in the movement acknowledged and underscored at the Third Annual Conference of Transgender Law and Employment by trans jurist Phyllis Frye. As a matter of fact, from the 1950s until the 1990s, trans groups prohibited homosexuals from joining their organizations (FPE in the US and the Beaumont Society in the UK) due to their "undesirability". Then, oddly, as transpeople realized the advantage of affiliation with gay organizations, the narrative was flipped to proclaim that gay people today would not have the rights that they do were it not for vast contributions of "transwomen of color," despite the ample historical evidence to the contrary.
Facts are stubborn things.
could you let Erica know that my DMs are open to her? I can't imagine why those mean, old transgender identifying men have turned on her. I've forgotten all about those Spaces where she and they joked about my passing soon. She has me blocked. Must be a mistake.
As @MrAndyNgo continues to report on the "Zizian" transgender terrorist cult story unfolding across the country, one of those Mafia family tree thingies becomes more and more necessary to keep the various characters straight.
Quoting @MrAndyNgo: Little is known about what "Ziz" Trantifa terror cult member Michelle Zajko was doing in Vermont. She is registered to receive mail at a property on Webster Road in Coventry, Vt.
Essex County State’s Attorney Vince Illuzzi told reporter @[private account] that a person with a sword-type weapon was seen at the property last month. This was before the media or law enforcement widely disseminated Michelle Zajko's name and photo. https://www.mychamplainvalley.com/news/local-news/zizian-cult-could-be-tied-to-border-patrol-agent-death/
In 2022, a sword was used by "Ziz" members in Vallejo, Calif. to impale and stab an assassination target. Curtis Lind used a firearm to shoot them in self-defense, killing one and injuring another assailant. The group allegedly sent another member with a blade to assassinate the 82-year-old last month before he could testify at trial.
Zajko, whose parents were shot execution-style in late 2022, is a person of interest for federal and @[private account] authorities. She remains at large. Her firearms were used by the Vermont duo involved in the deadly shooting of the Border Patrol agent near the Canadian border. http://www.andy-ngo.com
C2 false claimshand-codedcrime caseideology cultpolitical enemyviolence terror
The administration is going to keep drawing water from this well because the American public has had it with the transgendering of everyfuckingthing. 8 in 10 want transwomen out of women's sports, a 25% increase in just a couple of years. That's because the entire country has been peaking and the Dems refuse to acknowledge that Americans have this exactly right.
Everytime the Dems respond by calling the issue "a distraction" (see Sen Corey Booker) they loose more of the middle who are being peaked by the excesses of gender ideology. The response from gender ideologues has been to double down on their excessive demands and now claim that a genocide is underway in America, with gender cult leader wannabes declaring that anyone not fully onboard the trans train is a reincarnation of Hitler, blah blah blah. Anytime a Dem tries to respond thoughtfully, the hard left of the party savages them (see Rep Seth Moulton).
Unless the Dems change course, they're going down with the genderists in 2026.
The so-called "trans genocide" is the only genocide in recorded human history where no one is being legislated out of society, rounded up, put into camps or liquidated, and where the numbers of the group purportedly being targeted only continue to grow.
Quotes a post by A1408; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.