The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
The Committee will hear from:
Thursday 12 November
Police Scotland
Community Leisure UK
NHS Scotland
Scottish Prison Service
For Women Scotland
Sex Matters
Women’s Rights Network Scotland
Thursday 19 November
Equality Network
Scottish Trans
LGBT Youth Scotland
Equality and Human Rights Commission
Thursday 26 November
Simita Kumar, Minister for Equalities and International Development
Quotes a post by T41979; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“If the minister can’t explain what it is that’s presently lawful that the bill is going to make unlawful, that that means there’s a serious problem with the bill, frankly.” https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/09/trans-bill-violates-rule-of-law-says-lord-macdonald/
At a recent event in Edinburgh, the organisers asked a trans group to speak. The man who took the mic came out with a tirade - not about VAW but women who want female only services.
The event was apparently supported by Trade Unions & @[private account] funded orgs.
Quotes a post by A1766; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"This bill — which you may not be surprised to learn was drafted with the help of Stonewall — is the latest mutation, a protest against For Women Scotland’s victory at the Supreme Court last year, a temper tantrum by legislation."
https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/trans-ideology-parents-gender-identity-5jp6dhsbc
“Mothers are often closest to their children – they need to be brave and strong and look after their children. If parents are criminalised and families divided, it is mothers who will be affected.”
Well said @[private account] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/07/labour-mps-urge-burnham-to-scrap-trans-bill/
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedchild indoctrinationstate takes children
Solidarity to @[private account], this is sickening.
Sadly, women who speak out have to contend with some very unwell men.
https://www.terftimes.com/p/trans-threat-police-finally-make-arrest/
Activists would have sought to suppress the Tavistock trans clinic scandal using the Government’s new conversion therapy law, according to one of the whistleblowers who exposed it. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/06/tavistock-scandal-would-be-suppressed-by-new-trans-laws/
No, you didn't.
And:
There was evidence against Brand
Who, TAF, do you think stopped trans id men being able to identify into women's spaces in the UK? We did (not "we" in the abstract)
We have been calling for inquiries in grooming gangs.
Now trot off and read up.
"Parents are (or should be) allowed to set boundaries for their children. It is not suppressing a child’s identity to tell them they are not in fact a cat just because they say they are."
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/05/labours-trans-law-disaster-young-girls/
FWS1 is settled law. The court found that:
By incorporating those transsexuals living as women into the definition of woman the 2018 Act conflates and confuses two separate and distinct protected characteristics. (§ 39)
“transgender women” is not a category for these purposes; it is not a protected characteristic and for the reasons given, the definition of “woman” adopted in the Act impinges on the nature of protected characteristics which is a reserved matter. (§ 40)
Changing the definitions of protected characteristic, even for the purpose of achieving the Gender Representation Objective, is not permitted and in this respect the 2018 Act is outwith legislative competence. (§ 40)
.@[private account] appears to be unaware of FWS1. FWS2 was, indeed, decided on the narrow point of those with GRCs because the Inner Court had ALREADY ruled that trans-id men without a GRC were men in law & thus not eligible to be included in services & spaces for women.
Quoting @MForstater: We are in court again today to hear the City of London's arguments
Here is their skeleton argument
https://sex-matters.org/posts/publications/defendents-skeleton-in-r-sex-matters-v-city-of-london/
Oh look, trans activists are using DSDs to push their warped ideas about sex. How original.
Introducing the concept of a third sex in law has been damaging to those with DSDs.
Quoting @TheAdvocateMag: On Intersex Awareness Day, Zach Eisenstein explains why political attempts to define sex as strictly male or female ignore scientific reality. https://www.advocate.com/opinion/two-sexes-myth-intersex-awareness-day?utm_campaign=mrf-twitter-TheAdvocateMag&utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&mrfcid=202610316ae33540f30f4a61227235c7
It's been really horrible. Apparently, we laugh at migrants drowning and the murder of trans people. They are all over his thread and he has said nothing to stop the abuse.
Now confirmed that the suspect in the lamppost case is a trans-identified man. @[private account] claimed they had arrested a woman, contrary to their own policy.
https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/16782713/cops-gender-storm-male-suspect-listed-woman
It's not consistent - some journalists avoid pronouns entirely and other editors have been happy for journalists to use "he". The Courier was very good on this in the reporting on the Sandie Peggie case. And this is the Record on Euan Weddell.
https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/scots-trans-campaigner-vows-use-37505952
“No adult has considered that maybe they are creating the environment where children might want to identify as transgender.
“There's real incentives for children to do that.”
Care inspectorate guidance raises red flags.
https://www.scotsman.com/education/new-care-home-guidelines-incentivise-young-people-to-identify-as-transgender-8953641
TACC & others have written a seven page letter to the Supreme Court complaining that FWS v Scottish Ministers is included in the exhibition The Law and Us.
It reproduces the wholly false narrative that trans activists were not allowed in the court.
"No event in history, including the murder of six million Jews, is so tragic that 21st-century gender warriors can’t appropriate it."
@[private account] on the astonishingly tasteless appropriation of the Holocaust by trans activists.
Quoting @unherd: ‘Trans activists are clearly happy to push aside victims of horrendous violence to create a disproportionate narrative of persecution.’
Read @[private account] on the Holocaust denial smears against JK Rowling 👇
https://buff.ly/wSJW49I
No, Jono, she didn't. "Trans people" were not sent, wholesale, to the camps. There were about 4 individuals who were - arguably - trans but were also gay and/or Jewish.
This is like saying the Nazis sent people with ginger hair to the camp because some victims might, incidentally, have been ginger. And there were probably more than 4 of them!
They attacked a clinic run by a gay Jewish man. That does not mean "trans people" were the targets of the Holocaust.
Actually, the Nazis were rather fond of cross-dressing. Which you would know if you were really a historian.
It rather trivialises the murder of 6 million Jews to say that this event ranks on the same scale of industrial slaughter, but then maybe that is your aim?
Top notch reporting, even aside from the defamation. It claims she's "made comments such as ‘trans girls aren’t real girls’", suggesting this is a direct quote, but the linked article doesn't include anything to back this up.
SPS has refused to answer a question from @[private account] as to whether trans-identified male prisoners are still permitted to participate in programmes and activities in the female estate.
https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/26257574.sps-fails-answer-questions-trans-prisoner-policy/?ref=twtrec
During the GRR late night sittings, a woman emerged very distressed from the female toilets after several trans-id men entered. One - who has a reasonably high profile - cornered her at the sink & attempted to engage her in conversation about adjusting his bra strap.
Men should be in a male prison and the prison service has a duty of care to all in prison. Women are not human shields.
Presumably, you don't care if trans-id male rapists abuse women?
Following a report in @TheScotsman that a council spokesman claimed trans identified men were using the women-only Willow service, we are pleased to say we have received confirmation from @[private account] that the service is for biological women only.
This is the man Eva refers to: a former SNP candidate (and rugby prop) called Stephen "Alexandra" MacRae. MacRae was the first man in the UK to be sent to the female estate in 1998. Pollock claims the policy only began in 2006.
https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/uks-trans-politicians-including-snp-36978523
Of course, sadly, this happens in men's prisons but it's not because the victims are trans. Steph, essentially, thinks this select group of men should be given protection, but not the rest.
No one is "applauding rape" because it's not happening.
Most trans-identifying men are already in the male estate and they have included rapists like Bryson as well as some of the most dangerous sex offenders in Scotland. The notion that these men are vulnerable is laughable.
Quotes a post by A2279; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“The real cost to the government comes, of course, from their complete and utter failure to consider women’s rights and their insistence on obeying the trans lobby groups who consistently give advice that misrepresents the law."
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/female-inmates-urged-to-sue-snp-government-over-trans-jail-policy-8s97h6gqg
“The government must now reflect on the corrosive effect funded lobbyists have had on single-sex provision — including Scottish Trans, the Equality Network and Stonewall — as well as the DEI consultants who operate with no understanding of law.”
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/trans-inmates-to-be-moved-from-womens-jails-after-snp-climbdown-pk2zxxs03
We realise many of the people who need to read this (on Bluesky & Reddit) won't see or understand, but some labour under an illusion that male trans prisoners in the female estate "pass" & are no risk.
This was never true - as AA's testimony makes clear.
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/female-inmate-threatened-sexual-abuse-transitioning-man-xg35lck28
Trina Budge, co-founder of For Women Scotland, said: "Linda Pollock developed the unlawful policy for transgender prisoners and defended it vigorously in an affidavit given to the Court of Session.
"Following the court's judgment, it is painfully clear Ms Pollock intends keeping the unlawful policy in place and continuing the ongoing harm to female prisoners.
"Her action is tantamount to misconduct in public office and if she can't, or won't, do her job properly and uphold the law, then she should be immediately replaced with someone competent."
Quotes a post by A0038; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
1. No one is celebrating violence.
2. Where was your outrage when these men attacked women?
3. 80% of trans-identified men were already in the male estate - there are no reports of rape. Most of them are terrifying.
https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/15896608/sinister-male-trans-criminals-scotland-female-jails/
Sutherley said: “I cannot tell you how relieved I am because the presence of men in women’s prisons has caused nothing but fear, intimidation and worse conditions for women."
https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/i-locked-up-trans-prisoner-37321986
Jolly M repeats the line currently bandied about on Reddit - where was the representation of trans people?
Here's the thing. Scottish Trans, Stonewall, LGBTYS etc were perfectly entitled to intervene if they so wished. They didn't. That isn't our fault or the fault of the court.
James Morton of STA drafted prison guidance back in 2013. In 2018 Morton wrote:
"We strategised that by working intensively with the Scottish Prison Service to support them to include trans women as women on a self-identification basis within very challenging circumstances, we would be able to ensure that all other public services should be able to do likewise."
It should be noted that Scottish Trans didn't even bother to turn up for the Case Conference which resulted in Riley being held in solitary. They have a nerve using his death when they failed him in life!
Scottish Trans are catastrophizing (naturally) about the prison judgment. Using the Riley case is extremely dishonest as he did not want to be sent to the female estate. Link to a thread on this case in next tweet.
https://www.scottishtrans.org/statement-on-scottish-prisons-ruling/
Nope, not because he is trans, because he's an aggressive & unpleasant individual who supports a groups which targets & threatens MPs & feminists.
Naturally, it's provoked a load of nasty replies because these are kind, reasonable people...
Rogue charity Scottish Trans is using public money to say that the @EHRC guidance must break the law.
They don't want to find solutions & third spaces, they want women's spaces.
But this is all hot air. They can't defend this legally. Time to defund & ignore them!
Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
Amanda Clark - Liberal Democrats
Jim Fairlie - Scottish National Party (SNP)
Roz McCall - Conservative and Unionist Party
Helen McDade - Reform UK
Luke Thomson - Labour Party
Fairlie is one of the two SNP GRR rebels who remain in the party seeking re-election. He has also not signed the Out for Indy trans pledge https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/snp-candidates-vow-fight-bodily-autonomy-trans-people-jsc3wzff7
His main challenge will come from the Conservatives.
What "history"? Are you going to recycle the lie about Stonewall?
In the UK, trans didn't want to help LBG get equal marriage and groups like the Beaumont society were rabidly homophobic.
When we read the SNP pledge to “do all we can to ensure trans people’s identities are recognised”, we were gobsmacked.
Does John Swinney think an interview about the next Isla Bryson will go better for him?
https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/16213173/campaigners-fear-snp-greens-gender-ideology
Glasgow Kelvin and Maryhill
James Adams - Labour Party
Thomas Adkins - Scottish Common Party
Aimee Hope Alexander - Reform UK
Daniel Bowman - Conservative and Unionist Party
Bob Doris - Scottish National Party (SNP)
Iris Duane - Scottish Green Party
Daniel Khan-O'Malley - Liberal Democrats
Shockingly, MiC has this as a marginal between SNP and Greens. The Green candidate Duane is one of the more notorious trans activists. YouGov, OTOH, thinks Doris will return ahead of Labour.
East Lothian Coast and Lammermuirs
Miles Briggs -Conservative and Unionist Party
Morgwn Davies - Independent
Nigel Douglas - Reform UK
Tim McKay - Liberal Democrats
Paul McLennan - Scottish National Party (SNP)
Martin Whitfield- Labour Party
The old East Lothian seat has lost Tranent and has been relocated from the South Scotland region. Paul McLennan of the SNP won in 2021 with a 1,179 majority over Martin Whitfield. It was previously held by Iain Gray of Labour. YouGov predict that Labour could take this seat from the SNP
Paul McLennan sat on the LGBTI+ CPG which pushed for GRR. He introduced a motion last November with the assistance of Scottish Trans to mark Trans Day of Remembrance (he also blocked us the day after he was elected).
Both @[private account] (Con) & @[private account] (Lab) were MSPs in the last Parliament.
Almond Valley
Angela Constance- Scottish National Party (SNP)
Damian Doran-Timson - Conservative and Unionist Party
Malcom Kevin Jones - Reform UK
Caron Marianne Lindsay - Liberal Democrats
Jordan Stokoe- Labour Party
Almond Valley has moved from the Edinburgh and Lothian region. It’s been held by Justice Sec, Angela Constance since 2011 and, again, it is a safe SNP seat. While we don’t expect Ms Constance to break ranks anytime soon, we were cheered by her robust speech when laying the SSI to add sex to Hate Crime, especially her response to Maggie Chapman’s complaints about “trans exclusionary language”. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BkvcTQeK7kc
Today in @[private account], @[private account] asked @[private account] why @[private account] is not following the law & why they are not consulting with FWS but only Trans activist groups. She also draws attention to the cost of court cases & says that more will come.
Also on the panel was the chair of the Scottish Youth Parliament. They are also keen on all things trans - we wonder how included any rep would be who argued against it?
SYP got £430,339.68 from SG last year.
https://syp.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/4.-Gender-Affirming-Care.pdf
Talat wanted everyone to know that we all had to watch for the "far right" who were "weaponising" women's issues. Neither she nor Sturgeon, on the previous day, explained which issues, who the far right are & how they are doing it (& through whom). The real far right are horrible, but these days, it's hurled at anyone who has the temerity to disagree on trans issues. They risk devaluing the term &, ironically, making people more dismissive when really dangerous individuals are on the scene.
The Young Women's Movement say "We are a trans-inclusive organisation, and transphobia is not welcome at our events". They were keen supporters of GRR (they wanted it to go further & incl children under 16).
Many men are in danger in prison - men with special needs, gay men, old men, etc. Do you think women should be their human shields as well?
Have you ANY idea who the trans id men in Scottish prisons are & what they have done?
It's not discriminatory to put men in men's prison.