The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
With Dem lawmakers unwilling to represent their constituents, given the opportunity, as you note, the majority of Washingtonians — regardless of party — voted for 638. But characterizing it as a “trans sports ban” implies that some students are excluded from sports. Inaccurate and confusing language is a feature of this movement, not a bug, making it all the more necessary to use clear language. No one is banned from sports. 638 preserves sex-based teams and protects the rights of girls to fair and safe competition.
Axios’ @[private account] wrote an article about I-638, Washington’s ballot initiative that would ensure fair and safe competition for girls by restricting girls’ sports to females, or as Melissa deceptively puts it, “ban trans girls from girls’ sports.”
She neglects to mention that the physician she quotes about the scary initiative and the dreaded “invasive sex-verification exams,” Dr. Grace Shih (who she describes as “a University of Washington School of Medicine professor and UW family medicine doctor”) provides “gender-affirming care” within UW Medicine’s Transgender & Gender Non-Binary Health Program (https://depts.washington.edu/tgnbhealthprogram/provider/grace-shih/). This is not unbiased journalism, it’s activism and her goal is to keep her readers misinformed about I-638.
@axios, do better.
Quotes a post by T13413; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It might be because they require drugs and surgeries, and external validation to “be trans.” If legislation and waning public enthusiasm makes their interventions unaffordable, and people realize they don’t need to go along with the delusion or tolerate the intrusion of men into women’s spaces (and vice versa), they’re left with just the claim, which is meaningless. But then, so is the rest of it.
The question isn’t just "how do we get a generation of trans youth to survive, to organize for liberation?” The question is how do they create trans youth to justify their own identities if kids can’t be indoctrinated and medicalized. With any luck, and as distressing for them as it will be, between bans, increased awareness, and the natural course of teen trends over time, the social contagion will burn out and this cohort will be an island.
Because they believe it is unkind not to. Or because they believe friends/family members who say the drugs/surgeries have helped them while dismissing the negative health impacts. Or because they don’t want to hurt the feelings of someone close to them who has adopted a “trans identity.” Or because they are actively participating in or encouraging someone to get these interventions and want to see themselves as virtuous. Or because they don’t want to risk losing social status. Or a combo.
They will not budge until the evidence of harm is in their face or until someone of a higher social status gives them permission to consider the alternative.
“Trans voter”: a euphemism for people who are particularly vulnerable to a social contagion that rejects objective reality and glorifies harmful body modification to mimic the superficial qualities of the opposite sex, and who have been convinced that to undertake these modifications is a noble cause. They have, with good reason, expected this belief system to be fully embraced by the Democratic Party despite all evidence that it is both incoherent and dangerous.
Exhibit A:
Quotes a post by T16674; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Yes, the whole trans thing is regressive BS, but still, no, women shouldn’t be allowed to have sex-segregated spaces.”
The problem isn’t that people like this don’t know that women are adult human females. The problem is that they don’t believe women matter.
Quotes a post by A0267; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Was assigned male at birth” seems like a simple, clear statement of fact. But it’s actually packed with deception.
1. Activists always use the past tense for sex (“was assigned”) and contrast it with present tense verbs like “identifies as” for gender nonsense because they want to trick you into believing the lie of “transitioning” — changing from one state to another. But males never stop being male. This alleged murderer did not stop being male. He is and has always been male. He is a man. Male and woman are mutually exclusive categories. Woman are female. And he is not female, so he is also not a woman.
2. Sex is observed. It is an objective fact, not something that is “assigned” or conferred upon you. Sex recognition is an evolved skill which all sexually dimorphic species develop instinctively. It is not a construct. It is not taught. It is an innate ability.
3. Sex is fixed at conception, not birth. Activists cling to the word “birth” to associate sex with things like your “birth name” or “birth town.” Names can be changed. People can move from place to place. But this framework does not apply to sex because sex is immutable.
Mr. Day is a man who says he’s “trans.”
He is a male murder suspect.
He is not now, nor has he ever been, female.
Quotes a post by T02475; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Whether no males or 100 males are attempting to enter any women’s professional leagues is completely irrelevant. What is your concern around establishing a clear policy of who is eligible to be drafted into women’s professional leagues? What is the problem with clearly stating that these leagues are for female players (this includes trans-identified females, by the way)? What is the practical outcome you believe will be avoided if these policies are not clarified?
Thank you for this balanced reporting.
But please note: “Transgender female” refers to a female (someone born on the developmental pathway to produce eggs rather than sperm) who typically wants to be interpreted as male. You meant to refer to males who want to opt into the female sports category. “Male” and “female” refer to the two immutable sexes. “Transgender” is incoherent as a category but includes people who self-declare as the opposite sex.
You can drop “biological.” Men are adult human males, whether or not they reject their sex.
The issue here is men being allowed in women’s sports despite clear issues of safety, fairness, dignity, and opportunity. “Identity” claims don’t change that. Hormone levels don't change that. No men are any kind a kind of woman, and they simply don’t belong in women’s sports, as Sophie Cummingham so clearly stated.
It’s imperative that journalists use consistent, clear, non-ideological language to avoid confusing your viewers — we already have a massively misinformed populace due to biased and unclear media coverage.
For comprehensive information for journalists on covering this topic, head to our “Fighting Media Bias” page: https://www.di-ag.org/fighting-media-bias
For information about the issue of men in women’s sports, head to https://www.di-ag.org/womens-sports
For information about Democrats for an Informed Approach to Gender (DIAG), please go to https://www.di-ag.org or contact our media liaison at [email address].
Thank you for standing up for women and girls!
Now for the “You can disagree and still be kind” part:
“Trans women” and “trans men” are not coherent categories. Don’t mistake a movement that feeds off of the vulnerable for a social justice cause. In the words of destransitioner Michelle Alleva, “Transition is a process of destruction.” Enabling, validating, or celebrating self-destructive behaviors is not kindness. Not even close.
Thank you in advance for not mistaking this dose of reality for unkindness.
This is a mess. Ignoring the obvious — that male and female are sexes, what defines “discrimination”? What defines “respect”? How do you impose those requirements? What even defines “transgender”? Why is it acceptable to risk harming anyone without collecting and assessing the relevant data on those who already underwent interventions, but more importantly, what are the medical goals here?
The mealy-mouthed, confused advice from strategists (and and instructions on how to avoid answering questions completely) suggests an utter contempt for voters and continued willful ignorance of the societal impact of ignoring the realities of biological sex and the nightmare-level medical harm associated with the “gender-affirming care” pathway.
Until this stops being purely about winning elections, continued strategizing of words without meaning is all we’ll get on this issue.
TOMORROW, 8pm ET! @LeorSapir joins us to discuss the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) lawsuit alleging that the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) made false and misleading claims about pediatric “gender medicine” that its members profited from.
A bit. We received the “Why do you care?!” bit, and “Have you met a trans person?” — straight out of the playbook. One MD said we were wrong but wouldn’t engage and one confused passerby called us “pedophiles.” Mostly it was MDs reading our signs and then scurrying away.
Hey @[private account]. If you thought you could ignore this, you were sadly mistaken. This will be a 95/5 issue. “We turned our backs on incarcerated women, many of whom have experienced violence at the hands of men!” is probably not going to play well as a campaign slogan.
“Female inmates there — whom I have interviewed extensively as part of my research on the impact of gender ideology in custodial settings — describe the facility as ‘a haven for sexual predators who pretend to be transgender.’ They all requested anonymity, fearing retaliation, both from the prison administration and the trans-identified inmates, many of whom they described as both volatile and threatening.”
“Early last year, California state Sen. Shannon Grove (R) introduced a bill to make her state’s women’s prisons establish separate units for trans-identified male inmates, limited to sleeping quarters and other intimate spaces. Meals, recreation, work and other general programming would have continued alongside the female population. But Democrats rejected this compromise as discriminatory, even after it was further narrowed to apply only to sex offenders.”
https://thehill.com/opinion/criminal-justice/5674651-mci-framingham-sex-offenders/