The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Human Rights Campaign president Kelley Robinson, on Spanberger winning after deluge of GOP trans ads:
"Voters weren’t fooled by millions of dollars in cruel, transphobic ads and sent a message that they want real leadership that delivers results for their lives and livelihoods, not tired hate, division, and chaos."
Another Virginia seat to watch: Ian Lovejoy (R) v Elizabeth Guzman (D). Guzman authored pro-trans legislation in 2022 that Rs characterized as punishing parents if they didn't accept kid's gender identity. Center of Lovejoy's ads.
Guzman up 13 points
https://enr.elections.virginia.gov/results/public/virginia/elections/2025-November-General/ballot-items/01000000-1238-16ac-496e-08ddfb9ffbc8
From the exit poll in VA: 52% say support for trans rights has "gone too far," but Spanberger won nearly a quarter of those voters. https://www.cnn.com/election/2025/exit-polls/virginia/general/governor/0
"In response to a list of questions from NOTUS, Moulton committed to 'support and lead legislation like the Transgender Bill of Rights' if elected as senator." https://www.notus.org/campaigns/seth-moulton-democrats-ed-markey-trans-rights-2026-election-massachusetts
Yes, this is my point. For example: The Trans Journalists Association advises against "using biological in reference to people," such as "biological males." But Minock and the Nextar debate moderators used that term. https://styleguide.transjournalists.org/
Quotes a post by T08499; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Another note on this. The only Spanberger/Earle-Sears debate was hosted by Nextar - like Sinclair, a conservative media company. Its LGBTQ question was phrased this way:
"Should transgender girls who are biological males be allowed to use girls bathrooms and play on girls sports teams?"
That is not the language Democrats or progressives and LGBTQ groups use. The ACLU wrote last month that "transgender girls are not 'biological males' as many politicians accuse them of being."
But that's how the network put it, and that's how the Trump administration puts it. Progressives are not able to enforce use of the inclusive language they prefer - the language they believe is scientifically and morally correct.
https://www.aclu.org/news/lgbtq-rights/whats-at-stake-as-the-supreme-court-takes-up-transgender-sports-bans
Markey said that "trans rights are human rights" during speech; not a new statement for him but louder in context of primary challenge. Message: Moulton reacted to Trump win by asking if the party could give ground on the trans sports issue, Markey never will.
Sen. Ed Markey, facing a challenge from Rep. Seth Moulton, wore a trans rights flag during his No Kings Speech.
(Moulton said after election that he didn't want his daughters "getting run over on a playing field by a male or formerly male athlete," condemned by LGBTQ groups.)
Here was the round with Spanberger's concession on naked men in women's rooms:
Q: Should transgender girls who are biological males be allowed to use girls bathrooms and play on girls sports teams? You have 60 seconds.
SPANBERGER: I'm a mother of three daughters in Virginia public schools, and nothing is more important to me than their safety and their experience in schools. I'm also a former federal agent, and I worked to investigate crimes against children, and so nothing is more important to me than the safety of all of our children. And that work, in part, has earned me the endorsement of Virginia's Police Benevolent Association related to what's happening in our schools and each individual community.
I think it's important that we have parents and teachers and administrators making decisions about their individual schools, not politicians, and if we are talking about the safety of our children, I would ask why my opponent continues to support efforts to defund public safety, an effort carried on continually by this administration.
Q: Once again, the question was, should transgender girls who are biological males be allowed to use girls bathrooms and play on girls sports teams in K through 12? You have 15 seconds to clarify.
SPANBERGER: In cases across Virginia, I think it's incumbent upon parents and educators and administrators in each local community to make decisions locally.
EARLE SEARS: Nude men in locker rooms. That's what this is about.
SPANBERGER: There should never be nude men
in locker rooms.
EARLE SEARS: Oh my goodness! We finally have her saying that. But you voted for that!
Quoting @daveweigel: Significant moment in VA Gov debate: Earle Sears goading Spanberger on the question until the Democrat said "there should never be nude men in locker rooms."
That's a break from the inclusive NoVa gender policy at issue in the campaign. When Rs push, they gain ground.
WES interrupts Spanberger's wind-up on the transgender question; steps on it when she says she's against naked men in women's locker rooms (news).
Evades Q on rescinding Youngkin's sports order: "In each local community, decisions should be by local parents and administrators."
Spanberger also hasn't provided very good sound to use. The clip of her in first WES schools/gender ad was this, which obviously packs less punch than "every transgender inmate in the prison system would have access."
Quoting @KFILE: The Trump transgender ad and was also an economy ad — (internal number showed it raised Trump’s standing on who would handle the economy better) — Sears has just done anti-trans agitprop in a way that’s not connecting with any voters.
Reid, the first openly gay GOP statewide nominee in Virginia, has been as aggressive as WES in attacking gender medicine.
“LBG without the T” mindset. https://www.advocate.com/news/stonewall-protest-trump-transgender-erasure
Quotes a post by T07095; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Edwards signed an abortion ban but vetoed a ban on "gender-transition care for transgender minors."
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/30/us/louisiana-transgender-care-ban-minors.html
AMERICANA is out - state politics news, Kimmel aftermath, the move against "trantifa," and more https://www.semafor.com/newsletter/09/19/2025/semafor-americana-air-force-won?utm_source=headernewsletterlink&utm_medium=americana
Ken Martin: "We have to use that same tenacity that we've had here in Minnesota to reverse Donald Trump's ban on trans Americans serving in the military, and we have to stand up for every LGBTQ kid and their families who want to play sports just like every other kid."
I’m at the LGBTQ caucus, where MN Rep. Leigh Finke, author of state trans refuge bill, says the gender critical movement is “the most successful political campaign of my lifetime.”
Quoting @daveweigel: DNC members now watching a polling presentation that says “tough on crime” messaging is less powerful than “serious about safety” messaging.
One reason I asked Sen. Slotkin if she agreed with SCOTUS's rulings in Skrmetti and Mahmoud - high-profile trans rights cases - is that Dems barely talked about them.
The usual response now is to say "we see you, we hear you" and move on fast.
One thing Dems took from the Harris experience - where the most damaging clip was her talking to a trans rights group on video - was to stop providing sound on these issues. Some good @[private account] on this. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/07/13/us/politics/democrats-transgender-rights.html
Quoting @greg_price11: Virginia's Democrat nominee for Governor Abigail Spanberger was asked if she thinks boys should be able to use the girl's bathroom and play in their sports.
She refused to answer the question.
One exchange that didn't make print: Asked about the SCOTUS decisions on trans rights/parental opt-out, which few Dems have commented on.
Quoting @daveweigel: Talked to @[private account] in Michigan. Would she ditch the filibuster to ban gerrymandering? Would she recognize Palestine as a state? Is she willing to risk a shutdown over Medicaid funding? Only one way to find out (clicking)
https://www.semafor.com/article/08/05/2025/slotkin-to-democrats-keep-it-simple-on-the-economy
I note in there that one PA Dem state senator gave a floor speech explaining that she thought trans athletes shouldn't compete in women's sports, but she hasn't been discussing this further like Wheeler.
Rest of Dems have just voted w Rs then never talked about why.
Late to this @[private account] story, but he noticed something I noticed in May: Some Democratic state legislators are starting to vote for "anti-trans" bills, but they almost never explain why. (Jonah Wheeler in NH has been the exception.)
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/07/13/us/politics/democrats-transgender-rights.html?unlocked_article_code=1.WE8.s5TA.NROsR-Jk0EyR&smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare
Beshear, whose wins over Rs who ran trans-focused ads have made him sort of a Dem strategy consultant, says Trump's "obsession with culture war issues" has distracted people from a failure to lower costs.
Another way to look at this... have you seen many Pennsylvania Democrats comment on Penn changing its trans athlete policy since Tuesday? https://www.nytimes.com/2025/07/01/us/penn-title-ix-transgender-swimmer-trump.html
Quoting @daveweigel: With SCOTUS taking up a trans athlete case, I'm thinking of @[private account]'s story on Ds after Skrmetti.
Ds denounce the rulings... but then move on and don't say they'd reverse them. A bit like how they responded to Students for Fair Admissions.
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/18/us/politics/democrats-supreme-court-transgender-ruling.html
With SCOTUS taking up a trans athlete case, I'm thinking of @[private account]'s story on Ds after Skrmetti.
Ds denounce the rulings... but then move on and don't say they'd reverse them. A bit like how they responded to Students for Fair Admissions.
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/18/us/politics/democrats-supreme-court-transgender-ruling.html
The other headline here is Dems saying the party spends too much time on trans issues, though the party position at this point (in Congress and in states they don’t control) is that only Rs are talking about that, it’s a distraction, etc
Quotes a post by T08767; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The big @[private account] story about the ACLU's Skrmetti loss gets at the basic strategic disagreement - whether to pursue Sarah McBrideism and gain ground incrementally, or whether to win the Judith Butler language war on what gender means.
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/19/magazine/scotus-transgender-care-tennessee-skrmetti.html
Asked for a message to trans people who feel abandoned: "The queer and trans community just want to live their lives and be left alone."
"They say don't make it a top priority. I say, well, someone's life is a top priority."
"There needs to be a more robust Democratic Party, and I don’t think sternly worded letters always get it done."
"That's why I think it's a mistake to focus just on economics and let trans children get bullied. We look weak."
Mara Kiesling’s interview w Harris lives in their heads, and they don’t want to say something else that can boomerang against them.
Next test of this will be when the Skrmetti decision comes down, next month. https://www.semafor.com/article/11/12/2024/after-a-stinging-loss-democrats-debate-over-where-to-draw-the-line-on-transgender-rights
Wrote about the Dem state legislators who are breaking from the party and supporting "Protect Women's Sports" bills - very few explaining their votes, as LGBT groups condemn them https://www.semafor.com/article/05/16/2025/in-states-some-democrats-back-anti-trans-bills?utm_medium=americana&utm_campaign=flagshipnumbered4&utm_source=nowcta
"A small group of Michigan House Democrats broke with the majority of their party to vote for a resolution urging the Michigan High School Athletic Association (MHSSA) to ban transgender girls from girls' sports."
Quotes a post by T03605; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The governor of California just took Bill Maher’s position on trans people in sports - they don’t need Rahm to do this for them!
Quoting @rachaelmbade: There's a reason Republicans fear @[private account] -- he'd try to yank the Dems back to the center and get them back in touch with voters, which is a threat to the GOP
Problem for Rahm is the left (and even some in traditional Ds) appear to want none of that. And so far it seems the party has learned little from the 2024 election...
Great @jmart column.
Beshear's veto message on KY's omnibus trans restrictions bill is already a key 2028 document. https://apps.legislature.ky.gov/record/22rs/sb83/veto.pdf
Quotes a post by T07949; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Oh - just read NYT on this. Someone texted the website fact to me while I was getting coffee, didn't see NYT story https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/13/nyregion/stonewall-transgender-parks-service.html?smid=nytcore-android-share
Quoting @daveweigel: The official National Park Service site for Stonewall has changed references to "LGBTQ+" into "LGB."
On left, archived homepage from 11/4/24. On right, homepage today.