The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
High schoolers aren't good survey respondents. They think it's funny to self-report that they're trans.
This makes estimating trans percentages very difficult.
Students who self-report being trans also often report being blind, deaf, armed, obese, 7-foot crackheads in gangs.
I have some questions about parts of this.
> But I wish he'd given more consideration to the question of whether male-typical levels of testosterone increase the propensity for such behaviors in males. The answer to that question is "yes."
This is most of what the post is focused on, and the answer I arrived at was 'minimally'. The observed effects are small. Do you mean something besides 'effects of variation within the male-typical range of testosterone levels'?
For example, testosterone does predict sex drive in the physiologically normal range for males, and experimental administration supports it having effects on sex drive without impacting physical aggression, even when men are just brought up to normality from a hypogonadal state.
> This pattern is not caused by small differences in T level; it is about large and impactful differences between the sexes in testosterone over a lifetime, that exist for a reason.
How do you know this? It doesn't seem driven by T per se, and there are lots of other T-independent sex differences, many of which could drive it.
> Evidence suggests that "sex-typical behavior" (with wide variation!) in male animals (including humans) is elicited once T passes something like a relatively low but male-typical threshold T level, at different phases of life.
I would love to see citations on this. I couldn't find evidence for the threshold effect, and could only find evidence against it in the data on hypogonadal males and CAH patients. AFAICT, the threshold is just hypothesized or built on ambiguous animal evidence.
> Again, environment matters tremendously, but it is not the source of the sex differences in basic reproductive behaviors.
Agreed. Nothing in the post contradicts this. What I did write, however, is that testosterone's explanatory power for the sex difference in aggression is less than popular accounts suggest.
---
This nonlinearity theory actually seems quantitatively very difficult to justify. It requires that violence is almost unrelated to testosterone levels within the normal ranges for both sexes, but that in the in-between range, there's a 20-60x increase in the slope, which then flattens out again.
Basically the only sampling we have that speaks to this has to do with boys going through puberty. But they don't fit: violence (and other delinquency) peaks later and is basically unrelated to the levels experienced throughout puberty. We also have hypogonadal males we can look at, and trials with them don't speak to this either. They do not suddenly become relatively extremely violent when they're dosed up to normal levels, but they do start acting more motivated, happy, confident, etc.
For PCOS/CAH, there should be large jumps in aggression, but there aren't, accounting for confounding. And CAH boys go the other way. Castration also drops men to near-zero T, but it doesn't bring them to female rates of aggressiveness.
We also have data on both male and female violent criminals, and their testosterone levels are not that much higher than normal people. For women, they don't even get in the range where the slope must be getting steeper. For men, they're well beyond it.
And though I didn't mention it in the article because it's obviously a very select sample with poor controls, we have a handful of studies on trans men, who do move through the range the slope should get steeper: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0018506X20302385, http://www.jahonline.org/article/S1054-139X(25)00827-4/abstract (linking because I didn't link them in the article, yet). The most we see with them is a short-term self-reported bump in aggression-proneness, but not anger or hostility, and nothing that persists through a year.
I really don't see why we should believe in a nonlinear T-effect theory.
The interesting thing here is that males score like males and females score like females, regardless of trans identity.
There's no significant difference between the scores for trans women and cis men or cis women and trans men.
This matches the brain size differences by group.
Quotes a post by T09179; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If you're incapable of thinking about causal identification, I think you should not read observational studies.
They'll rot your mind and kill your epistemics. You'll wake up one day thinking that eating apples torches your testicles and touching receipts makes you trans.
Nope.
And the study participants were: "aged 18 years or older, current residen[ts] in a participating city, [with] no previous participation in NHBS during the current survey cycle, [had the] ability to complete the survey in either English or Spanish, and ability to provide informed consent." The transgender supplement "was limited to persons who (1) reported a gender identity of women or transgender woman, and (2) were assigned male or intersex at birth." They were gathered by snowball sampling—since the trans community is small—and the initial seeds were primarily Black, because the study runners wanted good coverage of that population given its "HIV prevalence estimates are higher".
This statistic is pretty insane.
The CDC surveyed trans women and almost half had HIV.
Quoting @cremieuxrecueil: AIDS has never really been *just* a gay disease, slogans aside.
Statistically, a gay man needs to bottom 50 times with an infected person before he has a >50% chance of catching HIV, so even for the average gay man, it should take at least two weeks.
>I need to incorporate recovered data reanalyses
>where the evidence is 'LA-selective' vs 'mixed PUFA'
>where the results aren't informative about the modern day because of trans fats and margarines, captive audiences, results coming from within-person models instead of randomization, attrition and exposure issues aplenty, etc.
OK, now hopefully you will recognize that these are a small and especially weak part of the overall literature.
The Islamic regime's Iran is a bizarre place.
Source: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/10/world/middleeast/iran-transgender-surgery.html
Reading material:
https://archive.md/vUhtG
https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-29832690
https://www.dw.com/en/iran-how-transgender-people-survive-ultraconservative-rule/a-57480850
Did you know Iran has some of the highest rates of transgender surgery?
In 1987, Khamenei met a trans male and issued a fatwa recognizing gender reassignment to help fix a "trapped" soul in a wrong body.
So now, they often compel gays (homosexuality is illegal) to transition.
In this meeting, the president of the AMA exaggerated the trans suicide rate upwards by at least 3,846-fold.
Perhaps he believes his numbers, in which case he's been misled. Or perhaps he's one of the people who believe it's useful for providers if people believe this lie.
Quotes a post by A0873; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Hear, hear!
I've written something on this: https://www.cremieux.xyz/p/beware-the-man-of-many-studies
(Updating, not the trans thing. I refuse to read either report.)