The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
You can’t trust most surveys on trans surgery satisfaction because of the sunk cost fallacy and the survivorship bias.
If you had a surgery that destroyed all sexual function, it would certainly be difficult to come to terms with your mistake.
Being “trans” simply means that steps have been taken to mimic the opposite sex.
It is not some feeling that comes from within and it does not carry any biological markers. That is subjective and cultish pseudoscience.
Detransitioners are a case in which a transition has taken place and we are now trying to grasp at what we can to physically and emotionally recover.
One of the first “trans kids” was also one of the first detransitioners.
He was experimented on by John Money at John Hopkins and committed suicide by 38 years of age.
His name is David Reimer.
This message is tone deaf in multiple dimensions. The documentary wasn’t about trans people it was about DETRANSITIONERS and our experience.
It’s also about a medical industry that has destroyed families and put profits over people for as long as it has existed. It continues to destroy, I am proof of that, so are the others in the documentary.
We exist and children deserve to grow up whole. @elonmusk
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I wouldn’t be surprised if detransition rates were fairly low anyways as detransitioning itself is incredibly difficult. It’s already shameful to admit a huge life decision was a mistake, but it’s also near impossible to fully reverse and you lose your support from within the trans community and even from your own doctors.
There’s a major survivorship bias in trans activism for kids specifically.
They hoist up all these kids coming from extremely privileged, upper middle class families, either homeschooled or in private school, in a two parent household.
Transitioning is not why your child is successful…
I’ve had my fair share of people being jerks while I was trans but it was never quite as cruel as the treatment I‘ve continually been subject to since I’ve stopped transitioning.
This is a talking point to appear less radical than you actually are.
The truth is, if you were elected in California and not Nebraska, you’d be voting Yes on bills that would yank kids from parents arms, throw them in foster care, and start them on the trans medical fast track.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedchild indoctrinationpolitical enemystate takes children
In the last decade, there has been a 4000% rise in trans identifying young females. Fertility rate is around 2 children per woman. We cannot afford to wait any longer to push back on gender ideology for so many reasons.
US Population decline is massive reason.
Quotes a post by T07536; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I feel for the trans identified individuals that regret what they’ve done but feel like there is no point of return.
I will admit, it is not an easy bandaid to rip off, it is extremely difficult socially and physically but it all works out in the end.
I am here for you.
The “trans kids’” communities are overrun with pedos. I was groomed, I was warned by older transsexuals about it, I know other kids who have been groomed in these groups. Stuff like “send me progress pics”
In the 50s the women were expected to cook, clean, and raise kids.
In the 2020s If you cook, clean, and raise kids you are a woman.
Trans ideology in a nutshell.
It’s weird participating in a congressional hearing and having representatives actively denying that kids get trans surgeries.
It’s clear they’re digging for that out of context sound bite.
You have a smooth brain if you think the nation should turn a blind eye to these experiments.
Especially since the trans activists ultimate goal is to make the child property of the state like in California.
They aren’t playing by the arbitrary rules Hutchinson is setting
C2 false claimshand-codedmedical harmstate takes children
This is why the older male trans activists want to transition children so badly.
They are living their deluded dream vicariously through the children of others.
Transitioning earlier is disastrous a child’s development and health.
Biological males should not be allowed to participate in women’s sports, period. Allowing trans identified males who began medicalization prior to or during puberty incentivizes childhood transition.
They’re locking children into a trans identity at 3 years old.
Quoting @againstgrmrs: Child transition is being banned all over Western Europe, but UCSF Benioff Children's Hospital's website proudly asserts that they start seeing kids as young as 3 for "transgender, nonbinary, or gender-diverse children"
There is no such thing as a nonbinary 3-year-old. That is absurd. Affirming a young child's nonbinary identity, something which has never existed, puts them at a higher risk of starting puberty blockers and hormones.
The fact that parents are placing their toddlers on a fast-track to mutilation should concern everybody.
#GaysAgainstGroomers
Nobody is actually wondering why trans people aren’t happy.
All the things that make them different and unique have been medicalized and destroyed using some of the worst drugs ever created and experimental surgeries.
Quotes a post by T06689; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I recently recorded a video with a parent from @[private account] on busting the trans suicide myth.
The suicide myth is essentially a series of logical fallacies that are used to manipulate vulnerable children into believing that there are only two options for their future: transition or death.
I can’t wait to share it with all of you!
Looking back on this tweet from October of last year.
It’s clear that many have ran out of patience with the trans activists since then.
Quoting @ChloeCole: I hope the radicals realize that when we reform the practice of “gender affirming care” on minors, they could’ve had a seat at the table if they just attempted compromise instead of vicious ad hominem attacks on concerned parents, detransitioners, feminists, etc.
AMC and @[private account] are cowards for caving to the radical trans mob and cancelling the screenings for @[private account] documentary.
Covering up a worldwide sterilization campaign is unconscionable and we deserve to hear the truth.
Went out on the street in Chicago a couple days ago to have conversations with people on the trans medicalization issue. I’ll post videos soon.
Biggest takeaways are:
Detransitioners change minds.
Vast majority of people just think transing kids is flat-out wrong!!
Unique personalities have been turned into a medical pipeline.
Most people in support, especially physicians just assume the science surrounding child transition is good and have never actually looked into it.
Sexual trauma from a father figure or similar male role model can cause a boy to reject a male identity or to perceive his genitals as an attack vector for more assault and want them gone.
The trans community will latch onto that self-hate and call it gender dysphoria.
Most kids really have no interest in “pride” and they don’t buy into gender ideology.
Many of my old friends have told me that they go along with it in order to not appear transphobic. Its dangerous though because it enables my trans identifying friend to make terrible life decisions with no pushback.
My guess for a lot of them would be an early childhood sexual trauma that halts emotional development and isn’t being treated correctly due to the onset of a transgender identity. https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1115396109
Constantly wielding the threat of suicide like a sword will create a negative social effect that harms trans identified individuals.
Imagine telling a little girl again that they are so weak that words like “she” or “her” can kill and that everyone who doesn’t go along with this lie wants you dead… I’m sure that won’t make her completely miserable her entire life 🙄
Quotes a post by A1164; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Another statistic she likely used was from a study about detransition that only included trans people (Lol). Participation in the study was limited only to those who had detransitioned in the past but still identified as trans — again, not people like me. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-020-01743-6
Not only that, but my parents were emotionally manipulated by being presented with a false dilemma — “would you rather have a dead daughter or a living son?” — despite the fact that suicidality is routinely overexaggerated in trans-identified youth. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-022-02287-7
Key and immediate takeaways from The NYT hit piece this morning...
We are gaining significant ground in the discourse
This article represents a departure from many of the narratives the mainstream coverage of the "trans kids" debate has been pushing in the last year.
The Live son or dead daughter fallacy is ironically... Dead💀
The NYT fails to juggle narratives. In their attempt to undermine the testimonies of detransitioners like @[private account], @[private account], and I, they interview individuals that have stopped treatment due to health complications but STILL IDENTIFY AS TRANS. The problem with this is the central argument to allowing kids to undergo these treatments is essentially that they will literally die if they do not. These individuals are actually just fine and demonstrates that the rush to transition is unnecessary and potentially dangerous.
Kids are no longer "born in the wrong body"
If detransitioners exist at all, then kids are not, in fact, born in the wrong body. The leading cultish dogma is that being trans is inherent to the soul, that there is some external, immeasurable, innate, condition that is transgenderism. Detransitioners disprove this entirely. Detransitioners represent far more than just regret, we prove that gender dysphoria can be mitigated through addressing underlying comorbid mental health conditions and is not in fact, innate.
Thank you NYT
The New York Times has conceded in the first couple sentences that surgeries like the double mastectomy I had at 15 years old do in fact happen, this is enough for the vast majority of Americans to wince immediately. They have also proved that they are not above writing a hit piece on an 18 year old trauma survivor if it fits a desired narrative.
Any attempted empathy in this article was embarrassing and dull, we are talking about kids getting sterilized, this isn't like picking the wrong ice cream flavor.
None of this makes up for the fact that it will never be okay to sterilize, castrate, or mutilate a child for a political ideology.
Mainstream media is dead :)
In the year that I’ve been going to hearings in state legislatures, the opposition has gone from “please start caring about trans kids!” to “why do you care so much about trans kids?”
The reason it needs to be said is because many trans activists will lie and say that many aspects of transitioning are completely reversible. I hear it all the time. Caution is needed.
Reddit thinks they’re onto something, just one small problem… both pictures have my dog in them.
The GOP cloned my original body and also my dog. Who is a covert trans woman btw.
There was a Munchausen’s by proxy Mom at the Louisiana hearing that said her child eating lots of green veggies was an early sign that her kid was trans.
Older trans people often blame their shortcomings on being unable to transition as a minor as if that wouldn’t be riddled with serious health complications. Similar to a rosy retrospection bias.
If your adult life is unfulfilling, it’s not because you went through puberty. Look inwards, not at your body.
Chris should be much more careful. For example, I never encourage detransition I have tons of trans kids in my DMs asking if they should detrans I say “you need to look within and answer that question for yourself.” I’ve also never said detransitioning saved my life. It’s two months, it’s way too soon to be glorifying it. It’s so irresponsible.
Mainstream trans activists endorse political violence, the @Riley_Gaines_ and @BillboardChris incidents are just the beginning. They know the end of their movement is upon them.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
If gender can be determined through brain scans, then doctors peddling this ideology should be scanning before every gender dysphoria diagnosis… but they don’t because there’s NO physical markers for being trans, it’s exclusively in the mind.
Quoting @buttonslives: A video clip shows Matt Walsh caught off guard during a Q&A when a woman claims that brain studies validate the identities of transgender people. The “brain sex” argument is used to justify medically transitioning minors & more—learn how to debunk it here:
https://buttonslives.substack.com/p/debunked-the-transgender-brain-sex
I was trans from age 12 to 16. I’m not saying that they’re lying about how they feel, I’m just saying that being trans can’t be accurately described in any other way. Transitioning is an action, if you are transitioning you are trans. If you have gender dysphoria but you decide not to transition you aren’t transgender.
Being trans is just the action of presenting physically and socially as that of the opposite sex.
It’s not some innate, spiritual experience but that’s how the trans activists portray it. What they call “science” is just a new religion. We as humans are in constant search for greater purpose.
@[private account] And I went on Jack’s show and said “hey this isn’t about trans or guns, this is about mentally unhealthy individuals getting their problems ignored due to the affirmation only model!”
Most of the trans people brandishing those weapons are the mentally unwell radicals that have a very short fuse due to their untreated comorbid conditions.
I’m all for people exercising 2A rights but I do think we need to screen for mental health issues before being able to purchase.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedmental illnessviolence terror
Trans identified female kills 6 people including 3 kids, “days of vengeance” are being hosted across the country, activists are storming Capitol buildings, the trans community has become extremely violent, the president jokes about it and the media says trans people are the real victim here.
Wake up.
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
Violence from the trans community is going mainstream.
Leaders within the community have a chance to squash it now but it will be interesting to see if they can save their dying movement.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
@[private account] @ConceptualJames @RepMTG @BillboardChris @alexstein99 @Heritage @[private account] @[private account] @Moms4Liberty @[private account] Yeah, she has a trans grandson as well
When we choose speak out about transition regret, we often lose our family and most certainly all our friends.
Also, yes, because all of the pro-trans communities we used to be a part of victim blame.