The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
3) Anyone can “be trans” so esp white, straight, upper class dudes can swap “oppressor” for “oppressed” status.
4) “Gender identity” has wormed its way into laws in a way that other DEI crap has not (other DEI has been implemented via soft policies, not codified into law). 3/3
It’s important to understand that the proportion of the population of women who are exclusively same-sex attracted has always been and remains stable and very low (around 2%). These self-label trends pushed by “trans/queer” ideology don’t change anyone’s orientation, but do sadly shove a lot of lesbians into hormonal closets & self-censorship.
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Wanna know why young lesbians transition?
The term “lesbian” has fallen out of fashion.
Most of the Gen Z-ers who use the term to describe themselves are men.
The actual lesbians have either become ‘queer’, non-binary or have transitioned.
“Anti-trans” is not:
- Anti-LGB
- Anti-sex stereotype nonconformity
- Anti-“existence” of people who wish they could be the opposite sex
“Anti-trans” is:
- Pro-material reality
- Pro-women’s rights to safety, dignity, privacy & equal opportunities
- Pro-children’s right to grow up healthy
- Pro-acceptance of same-sex attraction & sex stereotype nonconformity
- Pro-ethical medicine & mental health
- Pro-human flourishing
I contend there is no version of “trans” that is “less far, less fast” that would ever land in a sustainable place in any rational, secular, liberal society, due to the fundamentally counterfactual and inherently harmful premise of “trans.”
One reason the “trans” fantasy was always doomed eventually to be rejected wholesale is that the entire concept of “being trans” conflates boxes humans can reject/opt out of (eg sex stereotypes) & boxes no one can opt out of (ie, being human, being sexed genetically, immutably).
Quoting @JustineBateman: Yes. There are those who want to limit ALL of us by assigning boxes. But, people are not just one thing, ever. And certainly not over long periods of time.
Amazing how the self-described “reasonable, moderate trans people” can’t see how inverted these complaints are:
— “Outing” someone’s sex isn’t a thing; we already know & if we don’t, we have a right to know. Correctly classifying your sex is never “dehumanizing”, it is accurately humanizing you; pretending to be opposite sex or sexless is what is dehumanizing.
— No one is taking away employment rights that are already covered under sex discrimination laws (no firing for non-conformity with sex stereotypes) plus Bostock (no firing for “transgender status”)
— Self-described “trans people” need the same health care as everyone else needs; the only specialized health care might be the need for doctors to help people who have shut down their endogenous hormone production use correct-sex exogenous hormones, & help ameliorate the downstream negative health impacts caused by genital mutilation surgeries.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Really good analysis here: “But the reality is that embracing rights claims, in lieu of sober policy analysis, has become a deeply embedded feature of contemporary liberalism… It is precisely why Democrats will struggle to walk back their support for radical transgender policies. Democrats spent years lecturing the public that boys’ participation in girls’ sports and mastectomies for teen girls who identify as boys are non-negotiable ‘civil rights.’ If they change course now, they will either have to admit they were wrong before or become rights-violators by their own definition.”
Bet HHS in 2025 will correct these lies: “Health equity” is a scam deteriorating the quality & equality of medical care; gender-believers need access to reality-based health care systems same as everyone does. It is not a human right to access med-tech induced health destruction. And P.S. “Nonbinary” is even sillier & less meaningful than “transgender.” No self-respecting adult, much less adults in HHS, should use the term “nonbinary” unironically.
Quoting @HHSGov: Trans rights are human rights. HHS is proud to commit to increasing health equity and providing access to care for transgender and nonbinary Americans. 🏳️⚧️
#TransgenderAwarenessWeek
“transgender” or “gender identity” or “gender expression.” Everything that should be protected is already protected by sex discrimination laws; everything desired by gender-activists that isn’t already covered under sex discrimination (such as demanding women-only spaces… 3/4
People using the “trans” label already have all the rights they can ever expect to have in a secular, liberal society (ie, where no one’s religion is adopted or promulgated by the govt & equality under the law is paramount). Eg protection from being fired is already available 1/4
2) Not many “trans rights” advocates/allies want any kind of gatekeeping or screening for “Who is really trans.”
3) We have now seen & learned that ANY legal sanction falsifying sex benefits men’s emotional desires at the direct expense of women’s material safety & needs. 3/3
be legally female if you’re on estrogen &/or castrated) would be bad public policy — we can’t ethically condition a benefit on bodily self-harm. And there is no requirement (medical, “therapist letter,” etc) that can make “Who is trans?” objective or risk-free to women. 2/3
Even if Republicans wanted to call a truce in the gender wars by landing in a place where “true trans” was validated but self-ID wasn’t, that landing place isn’t feasible:
1) “Trans” has collapsed into self-ID, & trying to enforce a medicalization requirement (eg, you can 1/3
Quotes a post by A2782; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Part of the “trans” craze: boring “oppressor”white dudes become super-special “marginalized” victims under the DEI rubric…it’s not historic that a white male won a congressional seat, but b/c Tim “Sarah” McBride pretends to be a woman, his election is lauded as groundbreaking.
Quoting @michaeljknowles: 4/ When Tim first claimed to be "Sarah," he said that identifying as trans felt “mutually exclusive” to achieving his political career goals. But, his career shows the opposite. Once a mere white guy, Tim suddenly could claim DEI privilege.
& became a set of “human rights” demands & the numbers & impacts became visible, opposition has only grown. This isn’t a “backlash against trans,” it’s a rejection of a bold, authoritarian, top-down elitist manufactured attempt to gaslight the Western world into abandoning 6/7
kindness for a tiny number of dysphoric people” trope worked for quite a while — until the nebulous, subjective description of “trans” made clear that it’s a label anyone can throw on and demand rights-infringing privileges. When “trans” escaped the sexology/psychiatry field 5/7
where a few people quietly adopted opposite-sex names & tried to “pass” but didn’t raise much fanfare or cause many problems for women/kids/LGB, followed by the past decade where “trans” became a civil rights & medical cause celebre. This is why the “But it’s just a bit of 4/7
There never was widespread “trans acceptance.” The movement to defend women’s rights, protect kids from brainwashing & lifelong health dysfunction, & support LGB people against denial of sex & sexual orientation, isn’t a backlash or backtracking of “acceptance” but a response 1/7
Quoting @ylukem: The trans community became bold and started honestly revealing their intentions publicly.
Now trans acceptance has dropped and the public are voting against them.
Good.
Back in the closet with you 👋
Adding to this great news is the specific good news that this appellate court looked at the same question SCOTUS is taking up in the Skrmetti case (oral argument will be Dec 4) & decided “transgender” isn’t a group deserving heightened scrutiny, b/c 1) it isn’t an immutable characteristic, 2) “trans people” have never been legally excluded from civic participation; 3) the ACLU et al have done such a good job brainwashing politicians & invading institutions that it can’t be said that “trans” is a politically powerless group. (Ok the court didn’t say it’s because of ACLU but still.)
Quoting @CEJacksonLaw: This decision today from the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals, reversing a federal judge’s injunction stopping Indiana from enforcing its law banning “gender transition” medical interventions for minors, signals a significant shift in the gender war in favor of Team Reality. Just reading the 80 pages of discussion that *doesn’t* used genderized language nearly brings me to tears: there is hope yet for our legal system to return to sanity & throw off the gender chains that have distracted us from real problems for too long.
https://adfmedialegalfiles.blob.core.windows.net/files/IndianaMedicalOpinion.pdf
The entire movement pushing “trans” is word games, played for the purpose of liberating men’s most hedonistic sexual demands, denigrating women, & perpetuating male dominance, thru an anti-social, anti-human flourishing agenda to “transcend” norms, standards, & objective truths.
Quotes a post by T18488; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
That number would probably be even lower if the q. was phrased accurately (Do you support males in female sports categories?) instead of genderized language (“transgender athletes playing on the team that matches their gender identity even if different from their gender assigned at birth”).
Quotes a post by A3162; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Any project, research, study, or grant premised on “transgender” or “gender identity” being real, meaningful things requiring special treatment in medicine or law, should automatically be chopped as wasteful spending. Scared resources should focus on actual problems, not men’s sexual gratification at the expense of women and children.
Quoting @elonmusk: All actions of the Department of Government Efficiency will be posted online for maximum transparency.
Anytime the public thinks we are cutting something important or not cutting something wasteful, just let us know!
We will also have a leaderboard for most insanely dumb spending of your tax dollars. This will be both extremely tragic and extremely entertaining 🤣🤣
Speaking of govt “waste fraud & abuse,” spending money on any research, trainings, or studies premised on “transgender people” as some special class of humans, or on “gender identity” as a mystical channel to override sexed reality, should per se constitute waste, fraud & abuse.
There’s no such thing as “trans” or “c!s.” Everyone can and does understand that humans are each only male or female, immutably since birth, and we also understand that not liking that reality — even really really really not liking it — will never be reason to deny or falsify someone’s sex, whether via obfuscatory language, false legal documents, or fraudulent access of males into female spaces. No, we do not need to “better understand” what it is like for a boy or man to really really truly really want to be female — HE needs to better understand how to cope with reality.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yes. There’s no right or wrong way to be a girl or boy including loving or hating sex stereotypes. Being same-sex attracted is fine. Feeling uncomfortable going through puberty is normal, but growing & developing is healthy & good. Sexism exists but it is wrong & can be confronted w/o hiding femaleness. Beta males are still boys & men; trad masculinity isn’t the end-all of being a true or good man. Choosing or changing sex isn’t possible. Sex classifications are normal & routine, & often necessary to protect women & children, not unfairly discriminatory. Gnostic dualism (sacrifice of body to liberate the soul) isn’t an ethical reason for rational society to support or fund med-tech health destruction. “Transgender” & “intersex” people are all just males or females, immutably so since their birth. Only women can get pregnant & be mothers. Lesbians don’t have penises. Boys shouldn’t play in girls’ sports. Men shouldn’t be housed in women’s prisons.
All these basics truths can now be said, as often & loudly as needed to break the spell of the most pernicious secularized gnostic dualism cult & medial scandal to ever ensnare the Western world.
Quoting @BillboardChris: The entirety of gender ideology needs to be destroyed.
Stopping the medical transition of kids is the first and most important step, but it doesn’t stop there.
All of gender ideology is based on a foundation of lies, and playing along with any of it is a fool’s endeavour.
The theory of gender identity ideology must be reduced to a laughing stock, and be understood for the fraud that it is.
There is no such thing as transgender.
We are all men, women, boys, and girls.
If only this was a sincere ask…the girls and boys using the “trans” label are not being left alone, which is the whole problem: the med-tech industry is profiting off ruining their health; the practice of medicine is destroying its credibility by buying into a pseudo-religion instead of promoting their health; the mental health field is abdicating its responsibility to get to the bottom of mental/emotional distress without scalpels & hormones; the Big LGBTQ Machine is brainwashing these kids into a life of deception, fantasy, parental alienation, unchecked sexual kink, unfulfilling adult relationships, lack of sexual function, inability to create their own children, & fragile, self-centered, entitled demands to be “validated” at the expense of women’s rights & child safeguarding…The whole problem is that “gender” ideologues refuse to leave these kids alone.
Quotes a post by T07111; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Transgender” was invented in academia & quickly exported to “social justice activism” for the singular purpose of thrusting the “trans” concept onto huge cohorts of children, to take the focus off the sexual fetishes of grown men who will never pass as women but want to get their rocks off making us all pretend. “Transsexual” would have exposed the “trans/queer” agenda of sexualizing kids to justify the sexual kinks of adult men. So they went with “transgender” & “trans” because that sounds like a special group of identifiable kids who just need some special treatment. The reality is no one, much less a kid, “is transgender” (or transsexual), and it is finally becoming ok to just say so.
Quotes a post by T00216; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Harming transgender people” is code for “Refusing to let dangerous men hide their true identity behind woman face.”
“Transgender rights” is fundamentally at odds with safeguarding.
Quotes a post by A2445; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Setting aside the issue of whether “true transsexuals” are a thing, if we can make gender-activists have to defend “transsexual kids” or “transvestite kids” instead of “trans kids” or “transgender kids,” we will quickly prevail in protecting kids from medicalized “identities.”
Quoting @BuckAngel: Stop using children as a political pawn! These are biological boys and that is a FACT. Maybe stop pushing this issue in schools and leave the kids alone. Its all so gross. It is NOT transphobic to talk about biology which is the whole reason you are a transsexual.
Chopping up young people’s healthy bodies “For Gender” is something only unscrupulous, mediocre snake-oil doctors do. Their opportunistic profit-seeking (hidden behind being an “ally for trans human rights”) days are ending soon, and they will forever shame their profession.
Quoting @libsoftiktok: HOLY SHLIT: Dr. Javad Sajan, the Seattle doctor who offers gender transitions to minors was forced to pay $5 million for illegally manipulating customer ratings with unlawful non-disclosure agreements.
He was forced to pay restitution to 21,000 Washington residents for attempting to lie about his own reputation.
In fact, in order to stand by and for lesbians and gay men, you have to stand against the “trans/queer” agenda of sex denial (hence sexual orientation denial) & sexualization of kids (a canard gays had to fight against for decades & that thanks to force-teamed “LGBTQ” is back).
Quoting @againstgrmrs: There were no 'anti-LGBTQ' ads.
There were ads about self-ID laws, child sex changes, and media hits highlighting the unfairness of males in female sports.
None of this is anti-gay in the slightest. Stop lying to gays and lesbians and telling us that the world is against us.
Seriously, talk to a “trans widow” and then see if you can handle the cognitive dissonance of standing up for sex-based reality & women’s rights, while at the same time chumming around with & treating with kid gloves the really nice, reasonable-sounding men-LARPing-as-women.
Quotes a post by T01686; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yeah this is exactly why Americans are giving Trump a second term; while Democrats are to blame for refusing to Just Say No to a “trans” agenda that rolls back women’s rights by at least a century, we were equally as turned off by editors & reporters who writhe in ecstasy at calling men “she/her” to try & gaslight the public into believing female athletes are just being mean by not wanting “this woman” on their team. It didn’t work, and now reporters who wrote this way are just risible panderers.
Quotes a post by T15356; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Correct. Support for “trans rights” (specifically, the fact that “trans rights” erase sex-based rights crucial for women), isn’t an issue that disappears just by being very quiet about it in the 3 months leading up to an election. Kamala was VP in an Admin that turned Title IX into a men’s rights rule & didn’t need to shout about that for voters to understand what side she is on.
Quotes a post by A1691; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The way this reason was phrased/framed wasn’t strong enough; it isn’t just that voters resent “focusing on transgender issues instead of issues affecting the middle class” but voters realizing that “trans issues” are precisely contrary to the interests of the middle class.
The iron fist of gender ideology is loosening. Democrat pundits may continue to double down, but they all received the clear message that Americans instinctively understand that “trans rights” is code for male domination over women, & “queer joy” is code for anti-social sexualization of children, & we’re going to soon notice fewer pronouns in bios/email signatures & reporters “slipping up” by correctly sexing people once in a while.
Quotes a post by A3055; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Interesting. If HRC disavows the congressman for apostasy from the gender-cult, more & more Americans will see how anti-woman, anti-social & dictatorial Big LGBTQ really is. If HRC lets it go, more & more Americans will sense how shaky & unsustainable the “trans/queer” agenda is.
Quoting @benryanwriter: NYC progressive activist Jason Rosenberg calls on @[private account] to rescind its backing of @[private account] for his remarks about natal boys playing on girls’ sports teams.
Nah, it doesn’t “need to stop,” it needs to swell from a trickle to a flood of Democrat elites/leaders who have always known that “gender identity” trumping sex is batsh*t crazy continuing to find the words to say “This isn’t a civil rights issue. People who call themselves ‘trans’ have all the human rights they need, & it’s unacceptable to give them special privilege to destroy sex classifications, brainwash kids, or make anyone pay for med-tech body modifications.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: “Dems going after trans people this week should be ashamed of themselves,” writes @[private account] after Trump closed with ads attacking Kamala on trans-related policies and the Dems lost big across the map.
“NY @[private account], MA Rep. Seth Moulton, @MattYglesias, and others are, at least in part, blaming transgender people and Dems’ support for transgender people’s equal treatment for Dems’ showing following a glut of anti-trans ads run by Rs,” Chris Geidner writes. “To varying degrees, the three men’s responses to the 2024 election suggest, if not outright say, that the Democratic Party must fundamentally rethink parts of itself.
“This is a problem for multiple reasons — and must stop.”
In the not-distant future, we will analyze the how & why so many Boomers coddled Gen Z to reify Tumblr neologisms & incoherent concepts (such as “transgender” & “nonbinary” & “pansexual”). It will involve something about desperation of older adults to stay relevant, cool, & “in.”
Harris/Walz trumpeted gender identity ideology similarly: vapid, illogical, deceptive & nihilistic on the substance but rhetorically preaching “beautiful joy empathy & unity.” Turns out Americans see thru “trans joy” & “gender euphoria” & want real solutions to actual problems.
Quotes a post by T00738; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
FWIW based on having served inside the first Trump administration, advisors closest to Trump “get it” — more now than in 2020 — that there isn’t a “LGBTQ community,” that we normal gays & lesbians want nothing to do with the “trans” agenda, and that LGB have the rights we needed.
Quotes a post by A1442; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Even with a flawed framing of the question (“Has support for transgender rights gone too far?”), it is undeniable that ordinary Americans perceive the tension between “trans rights” & girls/women’s rights & have given a temporary mandate to Republicans to rewind the insanity.
Quoting @benryanwriter: AP VoteCast: About half of voters said support for transgender rights has gone too far
Trump and Vance made attacks on transgender rights a central part of their closing argument, and findings from AP VoteCast, a sweeping survey of more than 115,000 voters nationwide, suggest that those arguments may have resonated with some voters.
About half of voters overall said that support for transgender rights in government and society has gone too far, according to VoteCast, while about one-quarter said support has been about right and about 2 in 10 said support has not gone far enough.
The vast majority — around 8 in 10 — Trump voters said that support for transgender rights has gone too far, while Harris voters were more divided.
Yes but he could be in a House led by Republicans, alongside a Senate run by Republicans, directed by a White House run by a Republican, such that “trans” won’t get traction the way it has over the last four years. It will be a fascinating litmus test to see how many GOP congresspeople refuse to call him “Congresswoman.” We may want to send every Member a copy of “Pronouns Are Rohypnol…”
Quotes a post by A0966; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Khleif has never claimed that “identity” makes him female, so you’d think governing bodies could comfortably rule on his eligibility as a matter of facts/evidence of M vs F without it being a “trans” issue, but gender activists have successfully infected institutions with the mind virus of “inclusivity” making them allergic to relying on facts over feelings.
Quoting @OliLondonTV: Piers Morgan reacts to the release of French medical records which prove Imane Khelif is a MAN.
“Confirmation of what some of us said at the time: Khelif is a biological man. The gold medal should now be stripped and awarded to the best actual woman.” - @piersmorgan
National Health Service (NHS) “Gender identity is a way to describe a person’s innate sense of their own gender, whether male, female, or non-binary, which may not correspond to the sex registered at birth.”
Stonewall “A person’s innate sense of their own gender, whether male, female or something else, which may or may not correspond to the sex assigned at birth.”
Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD) “Gender identity is a person’s internal, deeply held sense of their gender. For transgender people, their own internal gender identity does not match the sex they were assigned at birth.”
World Professional Association of Transgender Health (WPATH) “Gender identity is a person’s intrinsic sense of being male, female, or an alternative gender. This internalized sense of gender is not necessarily visible to others and may differ from the gender role traditionally associated with a person’s sex assigned at birth.”
American Psychological Association (APA) “Gender identity refers to a person’s deeply-felt, inherent sense of being a boy, a man, or male; a girl, a woman, or female; or an alternative gender (e.g., genderqueer, gender nonbinary, gender-neutral) that may or may not correspond to a person’s sex assigned at birth.”
World Health Organisation (WHO) “Gender identity is defined as a person’s deeply felt internal and individual experience of gender, which may or may not correspond with the sex assigned at birth, including the personal sense of the body and other expressions of gender, including dress, speech, and mannerisms.” United Nations (UN) “Gender identity reflects a deeply felt and experienced sense of one’s own gender, which can include being male, female, a blend of both, or neither, and it may correspond to or differ from the sex assigned at birth.”
Human Rights Campaign (HRC) “Gender identity is one’s internal, deeply held sense of their gender. For transgender people, their sex assigned at birth and their own internal sense of gender identity are not the same.” Mayo Clinic “Gender identity is the personal sense of one’s own gender. Gender identity can correlate with a person’s assigned sex at birth or can differ from it. Gender expression typically reflects a person’s gender identity.”
Short essay quoting the circular, ineffable attempts by pro-“trans” orgs (including major medical associations) to define “gender identity.” Judges must see how stupid it is to erase a factual characteristic (sex) in order to “validate” a fake one.
https://www.andrewdoyle.org/p/what-is-gender-identity?utm_medium=ios
How, precisely, does one go about “lying about being trans”? What are the objective criteria for “being trans”? Which self-proclaimed sex “identity” claims must we “validate” versus which ones much we dismiss?
This the Biden-Harris perversion of Title IX: Law student faces a Title IX charge “That he ‘aggressively pointed’ at the transgender student and ‘purposefully referred to her as a man in front of classmates, law school faculty and administrators, and guests.’ He now faces a disciplinary hearing that could result in community service, suspension, or even expulsion.”
Quotes a post by A1880; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Look at key outsiders he has said will have strategic roles in his next administration: Elon, who gets the “trans” issue, RFK Jr, who gets the connection between “gender medicine” and “Make America Healthy Again.” These aren’t right wing conservatives but Democrats who want govt to be efficient, rational, & ethical again.
Adults should be embarrassed to spend time on the job on silly crayons-&-scissors kindergarten playtime that actually represents a “trans/queer” push to infantalize adults & adultify children in a rainbow fantasyland victimizing women, kids, & LGB, instead of legit health care.
Quotes a post by T20667; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When “gender medicine” was based on “treatment” of a “diagnosis” of “gender dysphoria” (or prior, “gender identity disorder”) there was never a solid conceptual or evidence basis for it (esp if laws remained rational & refused to “validate” the lie of “sex change”). But at least as a med issue there could be limits, assessments, evaluations, screening people in & out for such “treatment.”
Once Big LGBTQ picked up the cause of “trans/queer,” no limits could possibly remain in place b/c “trans” got linked to “GAC” *as a civil right.*
Step 1: refuse to acknowledge “trans” or “having a gender identity” as a rights issue.
Step 2: Relegated back to a medical/psych issue, demand evidence-based & a priori ethical standards be applied to “gender identity,” which should knock out any claim that medical interventions are necessary.
“Transgender” is a politicized spiritual belief system, not an inherent (much less immutable) characteristic. As such, there are no rights due to individuals identifying that way that are not already due to everyone (eg the right to hold & express political & religious beliefs).
The problem is that the woke left has allowed Queer Theory ideology to compel them to prioritize a fake, made-up, manufactured group (“trans”), & that ill-defined, nebulous, artificial group inherently denies the reality &/or rights of actual groups (women, kids, LGB, disabled).
Quoting @thepeacepoet99: Who knew that the woke left are a bunch of ‘ableist’ people who will make fun of the disability of their political opponents.
The woke left is a contingent of hypocrites who break their own virtue signalling rules to insult those they disagree with.
Just look at the comments.
“Fortunately, sound guidance exists that avoids blanket exclusions of trans participants from the category in which they identify & thus avoids discrimination.” Appalling advocacy for male domination of female athletes by a group daring to still call itself “for women.” 1/2
Quotes a post by T13055; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Gender ideology’s “queering” of language isn’t like political correctness pressuring use of “kinder softer” words to describe real phenomena (eg “disabled” instead of “handicapped”). Genderism thrives off neologisms to describe invented, nonexistent things (eg “trans kids”) 1/2
Well sure, Americans unthinking enough to call themselves “LGBTQ+” buy into the same weird religious cult Harris & virtually all elected Dems promote — the “gender” “trans” “queer” nonsense that ordinary gay & lesbian Americans reject wholesale as the antisocial trainwreck it is.
Quoting @PinkNews: Vast majority of LGBTQ+ Americans back Harris over Trump ahead of US election
https://www.thepinknews.com/2024/09/18/vast-majority-of-lgbtq-americans-back-harris-over-trump-ahead-of-us-election/
“Trans people have always existed.” No, but people who see the grass as greener on the other side of the M/F divide have always existed. In no era of history including our own should the medical, legal, or social response be to facilitate illusion rather than resilience.
When “trans” & “queer” ideologies are force-teamed onto advocacy for homosexual tolerance in a pluralistic society, LGB face renewed homophobia from the right & the left as “LGBTQ” pushes sex (& thus sexual orientation) denialism plus decimation of sexual norms & safeguarding.
Ok some details weren’t correct (eg, the male Olympic boxer doesn’t identify as trans, & male swimmer Lia Thomas broke women’s records but not Olympic ones), but the thrust of Trump’s venting is entirely true: schools are hiding “gender identities” from parents & fostering a school-to-surgery pipeline, men are invading women’s sports & folx are cheering to watch men beat up women in boxing rings. So The Advocate does not so much a debunking as a minor correction to essentially accurate depictions of the absurdities of gender ideology.
Quoting @TheAdvocateMag: Donald Trump spewed anti-trans lies at Tucson rally for 7 minutes. Here are the claims debunked https://www.advocate.com/election/donald-trump-transgender-lies-rally?utm_campaign=trueanthem&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook
Unsurprisingly, the article fails to break down “identity” by homosexual versus “trans” or “queer” (or whatever the “+” might be). Dollars to doughnuts, the % of population who are same-sex attracted is stable (& small) over time, while these ridiculous spikes reflect TQ vogue.
Quoting @TheAdvocateMag: LGBTQ+ Population in the U.S. Grows by Over 2 Million https://www.advocate.com/news/lgbtq-people-america?utm_campaign=trueanthem&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook
No person is “an LGBTQ+ judge” and such a label is insultingly nondescriptive. If the appointee is a lesbian woman, say that. If she just labels herself “queer” or “trans,” tell us that so we’ll know that at best this new judge likes meaningless labels & at worst adheres to an anti-gay, anti-child safeguarding ideology.
Quoting @TheAdvocateMag: Joe Biden makes history with 12th Senate-confirmed LGBTQ+ judge https://www.advocate.com/joe-biden-makes-history-with-12th-senate-confirmed-lgbtq-judge?utm_campaign=trueanthem&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook
There is no “real story of transgender kids in sports”…there is only the story of politicians converting to the weird fake religion of “gender identity” & using govt & institutional power to force girls to give up their rights to female-only sports & cheer for the cheating boys.
Quotes a post by T02503; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
If we keep saying it, politicians will eventually get it: gay & lesbian Americans know that “trans” & “queer” are homophobic ideologies, there is no “LGBTQ community,” & putting men into women’s prisons & sterilizing confused youth (many LGB) is a huge contemporary scandal.
Quoting @bourne_beth2345: The governor of California just made this parody video -- oh wait, it's not parody. 😂😂🤣
"As other states roll back LGBTQ rights and demonize this diverse community, we have your back. We will keep your trans kids safe. Happy Pride, California! 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️"
@GavinNewsom and First Partner @[private account]
@elonmusk
@[private account]
2 points about the legalities of housing male criminals in women’s prisons help explain why it is a challenge for those of us trying to stop this barbaric practice via lawsuits:
1) like defining “sex” in laws, having single-sex prisons has been such an obvious need that there’s no precedent establishing women’s *right* to be housed away from men.
2) The fact that female inmates are sometimes abused *by male prison staff* is used in court to argue “Refusing to house male inmates with women won’t eliminate abuse of female inmates so we might as well give the male criminals what they so desperately desire.”
The first point highlights how first & second wave feminism overlooked the need to demand legal protections uniquely needed by women, focusing instead on the necessary (but insufficient) need for legal enforcement of strict equality (treat men and women the same) where that was the problem (eg, don’t take sex into account when hiring or firing or admitting students). That’s a gap in the law that we now need to fill: female-only spaces were actually never legally demanded and won; such spaces were *permitted* not required, & often sprang up due to common sense but not legal victory.
The second point highlights how the justice system still acts on longstanding stereotypes & assumptions that women are less worthy than men: eg, women may get raped no matter what, & our fear of abuse is really just speculative harm & females being hysterical, and perhaps most disturbingly, women are just non-men anyway so why not let men-who-claim-not-to-be-men join a space labeled “for women.”
Men’s emotional distress if prevented from subjugating women by forcing mixed-sex prisons is taken more seriously by the legal system (right now) than women’s distress over the risk (and likelihood) of assault, harassment, unwanted impregnation, loss of dignity, & deprivation of the chance to rehabilitate in a female-only environment. Overall the legal system has helped women only insofar as what women wanted was to be treated *the same* as men; it has never really recognized that genuine equality often requires that women have our own spaces, away from men. Another way to put it: the law has tried to move away from relying on sex stereotypes that disadvantage women, but the law has so far ignored the fact that sex differences exist in material reality apart from stereotypes & those differences often mean women have needs that don’t apply to men.
It’s the regressive wolf of sexism dressed up in progressive sheep’s clothing. But this new sexism is worse legally because men are actually aiming (and often succeeding) to establish the legal right to abuse, torment, mock, & degrade women — something liberal democracies slowly but steadily eradicated over the past century (eg, laws allowing men to rape their wives). Now men have figured out that the DARVO of “trans” is a gift from the gender gods to ensure men remain in total control over women.
Quotes a post by T16983; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There’s really no excuse for media outlets already panned by the woke left (eg, Fox News) continuing to use language designed by & for promotion of gender identity ideology. Truth & clarity favor saying, eg “Man wins title in women’s cycling” not “Transgender athlete wins title.”
Thankfully for gender activists, “It’s only a tiny number” was always a red herring (“trans” has no defined limit on who can claim it), so evidence shattering that comeback to female athletes forced to watch their competitions & records smashed by men won’t really matter, right?
Quotes a post by T06314; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Imagine being a lesbian org raising money to help women crush their breasts…Portland Lesbian Choir thinks “Pride” means hiding from womanhood & committing self harm to deny being female. Trad religious groups couldn’t do a better job shaming lesbians than “trans/queer” ones do.
parents crafting fantasy-saturated environments, short-term shallow “trans joy” over lifelong health & competence, the fragility & insecurity of desperate reliance on external validation & struthious avoidance of facts, & self-centered apathy to harms inflicted on others. 2/2
The sooner unthinking adults trying to be “allies” grasp this the better chance homosexuals have of avoiding backlash from being linked to “trans/queer” reality denial & boundary-busting…you can support tolerance for LGB or homophobic & antisocial TQ degeneracy, but not both.
Quotes a post by A2445; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When media notice a man taking over a female space but label him a “trans person” or “transgender” or “transgender athlete,” it boosts the false narrative there’s a group of humans “who are trans.” Men are cheating dominating & invading women’s spaces. Not “trans people.” Men.
Gender believers manipulate people in part by egocentrically insisting there’s a group of people (“trans”) suffering unique distress that can be “cured by kindness” (the kindness of pretending women aren’t a sex class). Truth is, people using a “trans” label & wanting special 1/2
I don't anticipate SCOTUS will overrule its 2020 decision in Bostock. Which means over time we will likely be stuck with an interpretation of anti-sex discrimination laws including both "homosexual status" and "transgender status" (SCOTUS' phrasing). But that only means that where sex is irrelevant, so is homosexuality or "transgenderism." Eg, if it's illegal to fire an employee because of their sex, it's also illegal to file them because they are homosexual or subscribe to "trans" beliefs.
So what SCOTUS likely will (or should) clarify, is that it isn't illegal discrimination based on "gender identity" to maintain a single-sex space, because it's a scenario where sex IS relevant, and sex cannot remain the relevant characteristic while also making "gender identity" relevant.
For similar reasons, SCOTUS should also clarify that it isn't illegal discrimination to refer to men as male (eg, refuse to use "preferred pronouns") or to document or record everyone's sex in demographic or statistical records: the pronoun issue implicates free speech, compelled speech, & compelled beliefs; data collection is another space where sex IS relevant, so "gender identity" can't also be relevant.
If there is a lasting legal argument for allowing "men into women's spaces," it needs to be because the case is made that the space under discussion doesn't need or deserve to be single-space to begin with -- not that "gender identity" presents a legitimate exception to separation based on sex, because a space is either sex-separated or mixed-sex; even one "exception" allowing in a man converts a female space into a mixed-sex space.
I don’t think we disagree; I don’t think I’m expressing my point clearly, but/c I’m not saying we shouldn’t ever use the ideological terminology — it’s just that we shouldn’t describe the core problem using that lingo. Th problem isn’t “trans athletes” it’s men in women’s categories. The *reason* this is now a problem is because men are using ideological labels like “trans” & unprovable concepts like “gender identity” to justify fitting into women’s categories.
I guess my irritation is that as soon as as we lead with using the made up “trans” label, we are giving up framing the issue in material reality and letting the issue be framed in the way that assumes premises of the postmodern ideological framework. The issue is men in women’s sport; we can explain if need be, why men are insisting on getting into women’s sport (ie, they are using the label “trans”…), but the issue should be framed in reality, not ideology.
This ad annoys me every time it pops up. PragerU is on the right side of this issue…but could you stop using the phrase “trans athletes”?? No one “is trans” as though that’s an immutable characteristic — the issue is simply whether it’s fair for men to compete against women (no need for “biological” as a modifier either; there’s no other way to be a woman).
Quoting @prageru: Is it fair to let trans athletes compete against biological women? Make your voice heard by signing the petition to Save Women's Sports.
Having similar thoughts…the ineffable way “trans” & “gender” are used makes me think “gender identity” falls apart too; no gender advocate has ever defined (or even described) “gender” w/o circularity & contradiction, nor how “gender” can be an “identity” that overrides sex.
2) “trans” demands are for exceptions to sex classifications that society uses & women need, to track facts, evaluate equality gaps & take safeguarding measures (like single-sex spaces) — & even one deliberate misclassification ruins a data set or destroys a single-sex space. 2/2
The notion that gender activists make demands for “a tiny % of the population” is misplaced: 1) literally everyone can be “trans” b/c it’s a self-applied label (not an immutable characteristic) so there’s no coherent or stable measure of what % of people are in the category; 1/2
Anti-social, norm-rejecting, self-involved individuals who want to use nonsensical neolabels for themselves like “trans” or “queer” or “pansexual” are free in a liberal society to do so, but they have as much claim for such labels to prompt legal rights as “goth” or “emo.”
I love that @[private account] has substantive conversations w/ guests who are influential but not necessarily aligned w/ “trans activism” or GC positions. It’s probably rhetorical, but to answer the question in the title of this latest two-part episode: No.
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/heterodorx/id1602842758?i=1000655219543
It isn’t shocking to see some trad religions jump on the gender train. Many conservative sects strictly apply sex stereotypes & would rather a masculine girl or feminine boy “become their true self” (aligned w/ stereotypes). Liberal sects uncritically think “trans” is Gay 2.0.
Quoting @JamesEsses: Nothing to see here. Just a religious movement (@[private account]) glorifying the irreversible surgery performed on healthy breasts of women for a mental health condition.
One consequence of gender activists’ insistence that “being trans” is a joyous spiritual journey of (often med-tech enabled) authenticity, & that “gender identity” must be validated always in all ways w/o any evidence of “dysphoria,” is Team Reality does a lot less of “omg gender dysphoria must be so painful I have so much sympathy & want to be as gentle & kind as possible just please if you could just avoid letting male criminals bunk with women & maybe at least test T levels of a person-born-male before letting him dominate a female sport then we can all have our rights okkkk?” Dysphoria just means distress. Life is full of it. We can all find tools to deal with it in the real world that don’t involve stomping on women or wasting an adolescence navel-gazing.
Happy Mother’s Day to “trans” widows who have had to endure the gaslighting abuse of a husband & father to your kids claiming to have become their “mother.”
This is one of the most twisted claims of “trans” & “queer” ideology: that men can be mothers. Women who celebrate it are incomprehensibly self-hating & child-harming.
https://www.businessinsider.com/transgender-wife-struggle-mother-our-kids-2024-5
A rant by a lesbian mom who won’t let my kids anywhere near anything labeled “LGBTQ+”, feels Pride has become Shame, and is acutely embarrassed by the claim to a MONTH of shoving rainbow slogans down everyone’s throats & garish, infantilizing, dictatorial flags on buildings & crosswalk murals, and the condescending, regressive “inclusion” mottos splashed everywhere by institutions & corporations actively erasing the female sex class and safeguards for women & children to propagandize “trans” & “queer” and pretend to take seriously something as meaningless & incoherent as “non-binary” while tripping over themselves to give men props, privileges, & engraved invitations to mock, degrade, & subjugate women: the more outrageous the domination, the louder the accolades & slobbering praise.
LGBTQ+ has become the solar eclipse ending LGB’s day in the sun of Western societal tolerance & acceptance. “Queering” (ie, rejecting, annihilating, reversing) social norms, standards, boundaries & value judgments certainly liberates some people — but nihilistic, hedonistic, ego-driven liberation without social constraints isn’t good or positive by measures of human flourishing, healthy development, or liberal society.
When chaos fills the vacuum after institutions & governments have “queered” away objective rules designed to promote balance between individual freedoms & social order, brute force & strength enforce personal desires & whims — most often at the expense of those who cannot defend themselves against raw power: children, women, people with disabilities.
This doesn’t necessarily mean all anti-social or unhealthy individual self-expressions (eg, kinks, fetishes, paraphilia, gender-faith) should be banned or punished by law, but such harmful practices certainly shouldn’t be celebrated, facilitated, encouraged, venerated, promoted, sacralized, shielded from social opprobrium, or exhibited to kids.
If homosexuals hope to maintain or restore the social bargain reached in the 2000s, that LGB are welcome to full civic & social participation (eg, a woman’s spouse being a woman doesn’t cause ostracism or negative treatment or even raise many eyebrows) on the premise that we are normal members of society who happen to have same-sex partners & we have enough self-respect not to need or demand that sincere religious disapproval of homosexuality be squashed by official power, then LGB need to not just distance from “LGBTQ+” but denounce that cultish societal pariah with all the indignant disdain we can muster.
TQ+ is a parasite feeding off LGB goodwill earned over decades by gays & lesbians — and now evaporating in a few short years due to TQ+ using our own organizations & channels (eg, school “inclusion resources”) to push gender religion, reality denial, kink/fetish celebration, & boundary/safeguarding evisceration, causing substantial harms mainly to women & children AND OURSELVES (disintegrating the very concept of homosexuality & shoving cohorts of gay men & lesbian women into closets constructed of sex stereotypes, med-tech body modifications, & shame for the bigoted, oppressive act of rejecting opposite sex partners).
And heterosexuals who see the absurdities & dangers posed by “LGBTQ+” need to push back, backlash, resist, object, & refuse to be coerced into silence & false consensus by the “LGBTQ+” hostile takeover of LGB causes & organizations.
It isn’t anti-gay to keep TQ+ far away from our kids — it’s homophobic not to.
(END RANT)
The Cass Review is the opposite of politicizing the issue; the focus was entirely on evidence & didn’t start from any political premise (eg, “trans is a bad thing” etc). It assumed “trans” ID is just great, we just need to make sure that’s the right choice for each person.
When you hear “trans rights” or “nondiscrim based on gender identity” you can be sure the gender crowd isn’t asking that people who believe in a GI that’s more real than sex not be punished for believing it, but that any & all classifications based on sex be based on GI instead.
Fact: The Biden Title IX Rule makes sexual orientation a basis for sex discrim.
Fact: The Rule refuses to define sexual orient.
Fact: The Rule forces everyone into a GI (“trans, NB, or cis”) — nothing is sex-based.
=> Sexual orient. will protect any imaginable paraphilia. 1/2
Quotes a post by A2585; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Gender activists are correct to insist that “trans rights” don’t conflict with women’s rights — but only because the demands of men to be classified as women aren’t rights to begin with.
An impressive collection of the only arguments gender pushers have:
- Slogans (“GAC is lifesaving!”)
- Appeals to experts who broke the chain of trust (“major med assoc”)
- Lies (“blockers are reversible”)
- Internal illogic (is “gender dysphoria” needed to be “trans” or not??)
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Shameful. Or just cringe-worthy b/c so predictable.
“Nat’l Women’s Law Center Intervenes In Defense of Transgender College Athletes”
“As a women’s rights organization…we feel called upon to defend” women (j/k, we defend men’s desires at women’s expense.) https://nwlc.org/press-release/national-womens-law-center-intervenes-in-defense-of-transgender-college-athletes/
Age-old, mundane trad sexism is the core of gender identity ideology — examining the history of PREA, the US federal law (Prison Rape Elim Act) from 2003 aiming to curb sexual violence in prisons AND carving out special rights for “transgender” prisoners, you can feel the recoiling of male politicians repelled by male-on-male sex, & their disdain for men who can’t cut it as “real men” so (shrug) they might as well be women.
The litmus test question isn’t What Is a Woman? (we all know the answer); it’s What Is a “Trans” Person? (no one knows the answer).
And perhaps law should stick to official recognition of categories that are factually, objectively real, definable, & in need of legal protection.
All “transgender women” are men self-identifying as women. There’s no therapist letter, fraudulent government ID, injection, pill, patch, or surgery, that converts a man into any type of woman; “transgender woman” always means self-identified: a woman by gender-faith, not fact.
Quoting @Telegraph: A leading industry group is facing scrutiny over guidance that allows self-identifying transgender women to use single-sex spaces
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2024/05/05/hr-body-attacked-self-id-policy-womens-toilets/
A lot of schools buy the activist argument that you can’t deny access based on “gender identity” or disclose a kid’s “identity” to parents, b/c it could “out someone as trans.” 1) No one has a right to hide the fact of their sex & 2) We already know who the boys & girls are. 1/2
Language matters. “Mean girls object to trans girl competing” paints a different picture from “Female athletes object to boy competing in girls’ category.” Media across political lines persist in language obsequious to gender ideology that pretends boys are a subset of girls.
The other problem is the category “trans people” can’t be defined to exclude anyone b/c it’s purely subjective, making it impossible for laws purporting to honor “gender identity” to exclude anyone for any purpose or motive, resulting in evisceration of sex-based categories. 2/2
When most people hear “Don’t discriminate against trans people” most agree…the problem is the gender crowd has convinced lawmakers that “discrimination” = “not exempting us from fact-based sex classifications,” not just, eg “Don’t fire me for believing in gender identity.” 1/2
“Trans” doesn’t describe a definable “people.” “Transphobia” just means heresy against a sexist pseudo-religion posing as a civil rights movement, grifting on goodwill for LGB people who sought tolerance, hoodwinking secular govts into endorsing an illogical anti-woman faith.
Quotes a post by T19715; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Compromise b/w women’s rights & “trans rights” fails to see gender identity ideology is all or nothing: either sex is self-chosen or it’s factual. Pretending men are women “sometimes” fails to protect women as a class. Policymakers must choose: women, or men who wannabe women.
Technically, SCOTUS found "transgender status" covered by the sex discrimination prohibition of Title VII. That wasn't good enough for the Biden Edu Dept though - they said "lower courts applying Bostock have referred to gender identity as the salient characteristic & so do we."
Every week, month, year a young person hides out in a “trans identity” is time lost developing healthy resilience for being a girl (or boy) despite unfair sex stereotypes. Adults who encourage youth to evade growing up instead of guiding them through it, are failing Adult 101.
Quotes a post by A2909; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
We have the TQ+ element of the acronym that used to stand for gay rights to thank for this sentiment rearing its head. We had a 10-20 yr period of earned goodwill in society based on “homosexuals are just normal citizens” until we let “trans” & “queer” open floodgates of recruiting youth to “born in wrong bodies” & “celebrate kink.”
Quotes a post by T16513; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Sadly, the Biden gender-hacks gutting Title IX have 2 excuses: 1) SCOTUS’ inept Bostock decision accepting “trans status” as sex discrim & 2) 2nd wave feminism fought for strict equality, not single-sex spaces, which have only ever been allowed - not required. We have work to do.