The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
I also think it’s helpful to back away from using euphemistic language; it’s not possible to “go from male to female,” and there’s no coherent, stable definition of “transgender.” We need to describe what we’re talking about rather than use ideologically-driven misleading labels.
“Walking out of surgery to no longer have breasts isn’t authentic it’s just what I chose to do to present a more masculine appearance; that doesn’t make me more authentic…B/c I am trans doesn’t mean I have valid or authentic reasons for wanting cosmetic surgery.”
As to parents who jump on the gender train, it’s not $$ but a child who “needs” life-altering drugs/surgeries is still unusual, so parents get attention & “brave & stunning” praise. Once “trans” has made youth drugs/surgeries common, some parents will lose motive to “trans” kids.
But it’s never been about “rights” for “trans” people. It’s about using as pawns people confused & distressed about how they feel about their bodies or sex stereotypes, & using as cover LGB people, to validate male fetishes & make $$ medicalizing invented trans/queer identities.
Very perceptive, WSJ. Now do the “trans” rabbit hole.
Quoting @genspect: Wall Street Journal: Tik Tok’s algorithm “can send users down rabbit holes of narrow interest, resulting in potentially dangerous content such as emaciated images, purging techniques, hazardous diets and body shaming” https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-tiktok-inundates-teens-with-eating-disorder-videos-11639754848
“As the dad of a gender confused teen son who believes in the ideology, I decided to take a look... Turns out, as usual in the world of trans ‘medicine’, this concept is based on flawed science, even more flawed analysis…& then ridiculous leaps of logic” https://pitt.substack.com/p/is-gender-innate-spoiler-no
@[private account] But there’s no equivalence b/w LGB & “trans” because “trans” isn’t a coherent concept, and there’s no right legally or morally to demand to be treated as a member of a group you aren’t part of.
@[private account] Talking in terms like LGB & “trans” being allies suggests a false equivalence, as though it’s two groups each fighting for legal or social acceptance or rights of an equivalent nature for analogous reasons.
@[private account] B/c “trans” isn’t a definable characteristic or cohesive life experience or class or category of people. And the sooner LGB realize it, the sooner we can salvage societal tolerance of homosexuality, save women’s rights & stop a generation of kids turned into lifelong patients.
Doesn’t all the alleged murder & violence against “trans women” ostensibly happen *because they are trans* so…if they are stealth & passing, no danger, & if they don’t pass then no GRC helps prevent that kind of alleged violence…right? So still no reason to change “legal sex.”
That’s a good one; quite similar as to legal fiction concerning all kinds of biographical “facts” about the protected person. I suppose gender activists would argue that a GRC is needed to “protect the life” of “trans” people, just like witnesses in mafia trials? Except…
We don’t “want trans men to stop being transmen,” we simply see through the charade & acknowledge the reality that no human has ever or can ever change his or her sex. There are women & men; using a “trans” label hasn’t changed that or created a new sex category of human.
Quotes a post by T15064; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Antidote to the rainbows & glitter false advertising of “trans” pushed by schools and institutions that should know better than to glamorize experimental fantasy-chasing body modification.
Excellent critique of that flawed, agenda-driven piece from Time mag claiming that hormones cause positive outcomes for “trans” youth. @genspect & the knowledgeable parents it platforms, are helping us hold activists accountable for misinformation.
https://genspect.org/a-parent-responds-to-time-article-on-poorly-designed-trevor-project-survey/
So far, federal courts have almost entirely sided with the ACLU-backed male athletes. Judges’ rationales: there aren’t enough “trans” athletes to have much impact; “experts” say men will die unless we validate them; there’s no difference b/w a “trans girl” and “other girls.”
@[private account] @SwipeWright Males and men work just fine for me, but to each her own! No one can explain a stable meaning of “trans-identifying” so when it matters I’d rather describe than use a short-cut phrase. Eg, “no male athletes in women’s sports, even men who lower their circulating testosterone.”
It’s so crucial to see “parents as stakeholders” weigh in on WPATH SOC 8 and point out the fuzzy terminology, express desire to throw as many kids as possible under the “trans” umbrella (by referring now to “gender diverse kids”) & failure to show evidence about desistence.
Quoting @genspect: We have just published an open letter in response to WPATH’s proposed SOC8. WPATH is allowing public comment on SOC8 until 1159 pm EST tomorrow (Dec. 16). Make your voice heard! Fill out WPATH’s survey, and email them a letter as well! Links to follow. https://genspect.org/open-letter-in-response-to-wpath-soc-v8/