The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
The “why” is interesting. The medical providers and NGOs are true believers in transgender ideology, but there are also several incentives that keep them locked into their beliefs and make them less willing to consider that they might be wrong. It becomes a kind of self-reinforcing system of ideological conviction and self-interest.
Many of the smaller clinics that primarily use monthly membership-based services have waitlists 3-6 months out because they are seeing an influx of patients, both from in-state (as larger hospital systems shut down their gender services) and from out-of-state referrals. They are making a fortune.
They get positive attention from left-wing media as the heroes who are continuing to provide “lifesaving care” in spite of the bans. Their professional identity, sense of purpose, and moral self-image are all invested in that ideology. Likewise, the NGOs would cease to have a purpose and couldn’t fundraise without sustaining this narrative.
The alternative, recognizing that they might actually be causing harm, would be unbearable. So they have to keep believing and continue transitioning as many children as they can.
Yes, they were originally a gay rights organization founded in 2011 to advocate for legalizing same-sex marriage in the South. But like so many of these NGOs, they experienced mission drift after same-sex marriage was legalized nationwide in 2015, the same year as the “transgender tipping point.”
Sadly, many of the children they are harming today might otherwise have grown up to be healthy gay adults, had they not been led to believe that their sex nonconformity meant something was wrong with their bodies that needed to be corrected through medical interventions.
I know what you mean. I had always been a live-your-life-the-way-that-makes-you-happy kind of person, but it really does feel like it goes against nature not to have kids. From an evolutionary psych perspective, I’m more inclined to believe women who say they’re happier after having kids than deliberately childless women who say they’re happy, which seems a little more like cognitive dissonance to me.
And to your point about politics, when I took more trans-friendly stances 3-4 years ago, I would often receive pushback along the lines of, “You don’t have kids, so you don’t get it.” My views have undergone revisions and continue to be revised. And though this isn’t a recent realization, it has become clearer to me over time that when you’re a parent, you have to make quick judgment calls about whether someone is safe or unsafe to have around your family. And trans-identified people do not pass that test.
I recently had the opportunity to put together a talk in New York. I titled it “How Bad Ideas Become Bad Policy,” and invited @SwipeWright, @[private account] , @[private account], and @[private account] to speak with me.
I come from a liberal background. My first major break with the left came over trans issues. As my reporting expanded, I began seeing the same thinking errors driving progressive policy on mental illness, crime, child welfare, education, homelessness, drug policy, and more.
That is what moved me rightward: realizing the same bad ideas were producing bad policy across very different issues, with results that were not only ineffective, but harmful.
It usually begins with a real problem. But progressives misidentify the cause and build policy around an idealistic picture of human nature rather than a realistic account of behavior and incentives.
That often means attributing problems to external forces, such as systems, discrimination, poverty, and stigma, while giving too little weight to individual factors and personal responsibility.
They favor policies that feel compassionate in the short term, even when they produce worse outcomes over time. They let moral narratives outrun facts. They treat unequal outcomes as proof of injustice. They misplace empathy on wrongdoers instead of those harmed by their actions.
They prefer broad, population-wide solutions over targeted interventions for the smaller group driving the problem. They defer to ideologically aligned experts and rely on weak research when it confirms their beliefs.
That was the purpose of the talk: to show how the same errors pervade many different policy areas, and to highlight the @ManhattanInst's work offering better solutions grounded in data and reality.
No, I have never believed in “true trans.” I have said in the past that transgender people exist only in the “making up people” sense. Much of my work involves trying to disabuse people of the “born that way” narrative of trans identity. https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-medicine-biological-bias-gender-affirming
As some might remember, I worked as an investigative reporter on the "sex and gender beat" at @realDailyWire for about 6 months and publicly quit in early 2023. I regret leaving the way I did.
Writing and communicating about pediatric gender medicine, especially prior to the release of the Cass Review, often required a gentler approach when trying to persuade moderates and people left of center. Because I was focused so narrowly on that issue, I developed a blind spot when it came to other trans-related issues concerning women’s safety and fairness, which often require a firmer approach.
I have since come to appreciate the different factions in the coalition working to make progress on these issues, and the different approaches they bring to that work. It was wrong for me to tell others how to talk about these issues, and I have not done so for a long time.
I stayed in touch with people from The Daily Wire and continued to support their work. I’ve always respected @JeremyDBoreing's vision for creating cultural alternatives for conservatives. I want to see conservatives make cultural and policy wins, and I want to help where I can.
Colin and I watch @benshapiro's show regularly, and now Jeremy’s. At some point, I refollowed @MattWalshBlog and @michaeljknowles, and I think their work is valuable. I didn’t understand Matt Walsh’s humor at first, but now I think he might be the funniest person on this website.
I am very grateful to Jeremy for giving me the opportunity to discuss my recent articles with him, both my cultural piece in @TheFP about my desistance from an autism diagnosis and my investigation into California’s youth mental health policies for @[private account]. His podcast is a meaningful addition to the cultural work he has been building for years.
Quoting @JeremyDBoreing: Autism has stopped being a diagnosis and has now become an identity.
Christina Buttons (@buttonslives) was diagnosed at 30. It brought her relief — but it also gave her permission to stop becoming the person she was capable of being.
I was struck by the piece she wrote for @TheFP, so I sat down with her this week to talk about the diagnosis-as-identity trap, the California machine turning public schools into mental-health clinics, and why agency is the most counter-cultural idea in modern American life:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e31FY5QeTqY
Advocates for school-based health centers are pushing to make puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones available through clinics located on K–12 school campuses.
In states with “mature minor” doctrines, that model could open the door for students to obtain these drugs without parental knowledge.
In Seattle, SBHC providers already prescribe birth control to suppress menstruation for girls who identify as transgender. They currently refer youth to gender clinics, but seek to prescribe puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones on campus.
Hormonal birth control is already a routine service at many SBHCs.
California partners with the California School-Based Health Alliance, which seeks to create “truly affirming and equitable spaces where LGBTQIA+ youth can thrive.” Gender-related drugs do not appear to be part of California’s SBHC model... yet.
Read my latest investigation for @[private account]:
https://www.city-journal.org/article/california-youth-mental-health-crisis
My new article is generating a lot of conversation on BIueSky. Trans activist Alejandra Caraballo is right to point out similarities between trans and autism identification. The explosion in both diagnoses is a result of social contagion, not an innate biological condition.
I wrote about Jonni’s story, and I can confirm that he was on puberty blockers, as I have reviewed his full medical records. https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-medicine-biological-bias-gender-affirming