The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
The fiction I’m referring to is the claim that “trans kids” represent a natural kind, that is, a biologically discrete category. The fact that you received puberty blockers and call yourself “transgender” does not establish that.
Evidence and explanatory power, not appeal to authority, should decide whether the alternative theory we present in our review article outperforms the innate trans-identity narrative.
No, I do not think “trans is real.” I am currently writing a review article with @SwipeWright on the studies often used to claim it is an innate condition, and what we believe these studies more plausibly show.
I never said that being an extremely sex-nonconforming child can’t be distressing; they are often bullied. But treating distress plus sex nonconformity as representative of a “natural kind” (i.e., “trans kids”) is a form of psychological essentialism.
That’s correct. But when we’re talking about young children, “trans kids” usually refers to the sex-nonconforming, proto-gay pathway of trans identification.
“Trans kids” are a fiction that steers otherwise healthy masculine girls and feminine boys in an unhealthy direction, by introducing an ideological framework that treats their bodies as problems to be chemically and surgically altered.
Quotes a post by T05064; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Men who identify as trans also tell me they are really women because they have a special ladybrain, so I tend to take everything else they say with a grain of salt.
To date, no research has established that “transgender” is an innate biological trait.
In practice, much of the trans etiology literature that claims a biological basis hijacks findings from other conditions and presents them as proof that trans is biological too. This is especially true for research on intersex conditions (now called DSDs), from which the terms “gender identity” and “sex assigned at birth” were stolen. They are useful in the narrow DSD context but are ill suited when applied to trans.
Studies comparing trans identified groups with controls sometimes report small differences; these are correlations, not causes. Once confounding variables are controlled, the effects usually shrink or disappear. If any remain, they are too broad and nonspecific, appearing across many other conditions, so they cannot be narrowed to a distinct “transgender” biology.
There are potentially innate factors that can make someone more susceptible to adopting a trans identity, including homosexuality, autogynephilia, and childhood gender nonconformity. Environmental factors also matter, such as cultural influence and peer contagion.
“Transgender” is a cultural story many assumed science would validate; the evidence has not. It is a choice to believe it is innate and immutable despite what the research shows, and it is a choice to adopt the transgender label, to socially transition, and to pursue medical interventions.
To date, no research has established that “transgender” is an innate biological trait.
In practice, much of the trans etiology literature that claims a biological basis hijacks findings from other conditions and presents them as proof that trans is biological too. This is especially true for research on intersex conditions (now called DSDs), from which the terms “gender identity” and “sex assigned at birth” were stolen. They are useful in the narrow DSD context but are ill suited when applied to trans.
Studies comparing trans identified groups with controls sometimes report small differences; these are correlations, not causes. Once confounding variables are controlled, the effects usually shrink or disappear. If any remain, they are too broad and nonspecific, appearing across many other conditions, so they cannot be narrowed to a distinct “transgender” biology.
There are potentially innate factors that can make someone more susceptible to adopting a trans identity, including homosexuality, autogynephilia, and childhood gender nonconformity. Environmental factors also matter, such as cultural influence and peer contagion.
“Transgender” is a cultural story many assumed science would validate; the evidence has not. It is a choice to believe it is innate and immutable despite what the research shows, and it is a choice to adopt the transgender label, to socially transition, and to pursue medical interventions.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is code for concern about social contagion of trans identities in youth. I’ve interviewed liberal moms who say they’re channeling all their energy into anti-smartphone activism because they worry their kids will encounter gender ideology but don’t want to be labeled bigots.
Quotes a post by T03384; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
My timing isn’t wrong. The Democratic Party added “gender identity” to its national platform in 2012, and expanded to “Transgender Rights” in 2016.
https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/2012-democratic-party-platform
https://democrats.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2019/07/2016_DNC_Platform.pdf
I used to think the Democratic Party was the “party of science” and I see now that was because I had a very superficial understanding of politics. The veneer is gone. This is a party of deference to authority and epistemic arrogance.
The Democratic Party forfeited any claim to science when it embedded trans rights in its platform and helped drive the worst medical scandal in recent history: experimenting on gender-nonconforming, often proto-gay kids; stunting healthy development with puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries with no proven long-term benefit and mounting evidence of harm; trying to obfuscate the sex binary; denying obvious social contagion in teenage girls; denying autogynephilia as a primary motive for heterosexual men who identify as trans; and insisting on an “innate trans identity” that has never been scientifically demonstrated.
They will carry this shame as standard-bearers of pseudoscience for the foreseeable future, and no ritual invocation of “peer review,” “intellectual values,” or “critical inquiry” will absolve them.
Quotes a post by T01227; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It’s true. Trans research co-opted the concepts originally used in early intersex (DSD) research. If you think about it, “gender identity” and “sex assigned at birth” make sense within that narrow context. Those concepts were later hijacked and misapplied by trans research.
"We trust the doctors."
Gender clinicians tell unwary parents that their child's trans-identity is a medical condition that requires medical treatment. These parents’ deference to authority, unaware that the field is driven by ideology rather than evidence, is their fatal flaw.
I just realized the FIRE student survey was college age adults. Williams Institute, U.S. adults 18+: 2022 report (2017-2020) was ~1.3M identified as trans (0.5%). 2025 report (2021-2023) was ~2.1M (0.8%).
I think the Williams Institute offers one of the more comprehensive CDC-based estimates: 2022 (using 2017–2020 data) found ~300,000 U.S. students in grades 9–12 (1.4%) identified as trans; its 2025 update (2021–2023 data) puts it at ~724,000 (3.3%). https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/Trans-Pop-Update-Aug-2025.pdf
Sorry, I thought you were asking about the proportion of autogynephiles to homosexuals in adult male cohorts in clinic samples. Adult clinic studies are separate from minor clinic studies. Among minors, the ratio of boys to girls flipped between 2006 to 2013. Clinics that once saw mostly young proto-gay boys now see mostly girls consistent with an ROGD pathway. A major problem in current research is the failure to delineate these pathways. It often uses a broad “transgender and gender diverse (TGD)” umbrella that obscures important differences. My talk argues this is not one condition, and research methods should reflect that.
Here’s a summary of the talk @SwipeWright and I gave 2 weeks ago at @genspect’s conference on the bioessentialist narrative of transgender identity, and why the studies claimed to support it do not, in fact, demonstrate that people who identify as transgender are simply “born that way.”
The gist of it goes like this: “Transgender” makes up a heterogeneous group with several known pathways to identification with the label. These pathways may be associated with innate factors, but “transgender” itself is a culture-bound framework.
The pathways include homosexual (early onset, most often associated with proto-gay young boys), autogynephilic (late onset, typically seen in heterosexual adult men), and, more recently, rapid-onset gender dysphoria (most often associated with adolescent females who have comorbidities).
How we interpret psychological distress is shaped by the narratives around us. Through our culture, people with these susceptibilities are learning to interpret the distress they experience through the transgender framework.
The transgender framework today commonly conceptualizes “transgender” as a biological or medical condition, and “gender identity” as innate and immutable. This is not supported by evidence.
This is a real problem because, when psychiatric distress is recast as biological/medical, people are more likely to choose medical interventions. They may later regret them when they realize they were not given accurate information about their condition.
This bioessentialist framing is derived from studies of brain structure, twin concordance, genetics, and hormonal influences in trans-identified populations that compare them with non–trans-identified controls. The differences found often reflect poor control of confounding variables (especially sexual orientation and sex nonconformity) and often shrink or disappear once those confounders are controlled.
We do not dispute that group-level differences exist. We dispute their interpretation, given methodological weaknesses and the neglect of prior research on homosexuality and sex nonconformity.
Our talk will appear on Genspect’s YouTube channel, and we’re planning to publish more on the topic.
Good analysis. Escape from reality is key because they are social outcasts, and it is painful. That’s the appeal of trans identity: it gives their pain a story—“You were born into a special category of person that explains why you are different and not accepted by everyone else.”
The Democratic Party struck a deal with the devil when it embedded “trans rights” into its platform. For a time, it claimed the moral high ground, hailed as the next frontier of civil rights.
But under competitive pressure from alternative media, the once-impenetrable wall of mainstream outlets—the de facto PR arm of the party—is yielding, and the public is starting to see what that agenda actually entails.
The party is trapped: it can’t retreat without enraging its radical base, and it can’t stop the steady erosion of support among ordinary voters. It will reap the consequences for years to come.
It’s not their fault. The blame lies with the doctors who frame trans identity to parents as a medical condition requiring medical treatment.
The parents genuinely believe they have no other choice but this path for their child. They “trust the science,” and an entire wall of U.S.-based medical organizations endorses it.
What parents don’t realize is that it’s a huge lie built on a faulty research base. No one is born “transgender.”
I gave my first joint talk with @SwipeWright this weekend at the @genspect conference in Albuquerque, where we delivered an important message about the biological origins of trans-identity: no one is born “transgender.”
I should add that my statement about the shooter not identifying as trans at the time of the attack comes from a coworker, who said he had been presenting as male and using male pronouns for the past year.
With the help of relevant experts, I examined the studies often cited to support the claim that “gender identity” is innate and immutable. The evidence points to “transgender” as a cultural label for a set of beliefs, not a fixed biological condition. https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
Because the shooter didn’t identify as trans at the time of the attack, trans activists will claim he was never “really trans.” That assumes they are set apart by a fixed biological condition, yet no solid scientific evidence supports such a belief.
Quotes a post by T02734; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
We are worsening mental health for people who might otherwise develop resilience. In the case of the shooter, who likely had severe mental illness, I’d speculate it went untreated and was instead met with ineffective and even harmful distractions like trans ideology.
For the medical establishment to go on deceiving patients into believing that “transgender” is a biological condition one is born with, for which drugs and surgery are treatment, is unconscionable.
“Transition” is doctor-enabled self-harm, and the practice should end entirely.
Quoting @michaeljknowles: For the good of society and especially for the good of the poor people who have fallen prey to this delusion, transgenderism must be eradicated from public life entirely—the whole preposterous ideology, at every level.
Can you imagine any other condition where children receive irreversible, life-altering medical interventions, yet when parents ask what causes the condition, the "experts" can’t give a coherent answer?
This is Cincinnati Children's pediatric gender clinic FAQ: a vague hand-wave about "genetics," "physical differences," and "areas of the brain that are different sizes."
In reality, none of these lines of research have panned out as causes of trans-identity, because the real answer is that it isn't a biological condition — it's an ideology.
Roughly half the U.S. population at some point embraced the pseudoscientific belief in a biological condition called “transgender” that a small number of children are claimed to be born with, and backed hormonally and surgically altering their sex traits. That’s no small number.
Quoting @MotherJones: “There’s a lot of attention being spent on an issue that only affects a very, very, very tiny part of the population.” https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2025/01/heres-the-real-number-of-children-receiving-gender-affirming-medical-treatment/
It’s a victimhood-based movement aligned with modern therapy culture and the tendency to reinterpret past experiences through a trauma lens, with most activists being leftist.
Leftist journalists love covering it so they can lump it in with religious group homes and conversion therapy camps of the past to give it an anti-right slant.
Paris Hilton even converted from conservative to progressive—anti-Trump, pro-abortion, pro-trans—to appeal to liberal audiences when she took up this activism.
I wrote an entire policy research report with detailed recommendations. I am currently highlighting anti-treatment activist behavior to help generate interest in this issue because it is a real problem.
To compare me to a trans-identified person happy with their transition is just baffling to me. The vast majority of youth who go to residential treatment are helped by it, it is a vocal minority of activists trying to destroy it.
https://manhattan.institute/article/the-radical-movement-to-divest-from-youth-residential-treatment
"Trans-identified people" refers to those who identify as trans or have taken steps to transition, whereas "trans people" implies the existence of a distinct, innate category.
To learn more about the studies used to support the claim that trans-identified individuals are “born that way,” read these two articles in @[private account].
🔗: https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
(co-authors @SwipeWright @[private account])
🔗: https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
Alan Cumming, while guest-hosting @[private account] recently, said that “trans people are born with something special and magical about them,” perpetuating the myth that they are born that way.
That claim rests on a flawed body of research. It begins with a socially defined identity, then looks for biological traits shared by those who adopt it.
When a shared characteristic is found in a portion of the studied population, it is often taken as evidence that it is in some way responsible for causing the identity. But that is backwards.
Being transgender is not a biological category. It is a label people adopt for many reasons.
These studies rarely control for confounding variables, which better explain the observed traits. The research finds correlation, not causation. It does not prove people are born trans, only that certain traits are more common among those who identify that way.
Alan Cumming is right about one thing: trans people are like superheroes because both are fictional.
“If people feel”—NO. The answer to that should be NO YOU MAY NOT HAVE CROSS SEX HORMONES TO ALTER YOUR SECONDARY SEX CHARACTERISTICS. NO YOU MAY NOT HAVE MUTILATING SURGERIES. NO YOU ARE NOT BORN INTO A SPECIAL CATEGORY OF PERSONHOOD CALLED “TRANSGENDER.” NO TO ALL OF IT.
The belief that being transgender has a biological basis can profoundly shape how individuals understand themselves.
When reinforced by medical professionals and institutions, it carries authority few feel equipped to question.
Far less attention was given to follow-up studies that challenged the original claims. Once researchers controlled for sexual orientation and cross-sex hormone use—both known to affect brain structure—the results no longer held. @[private account] @SwipeWright https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
Between 2014 and 2017, brain studies on trans-identified individuals peaked. Some appeared to show that certain brain regions in trans-identified males resembled those of females. These studies received significant media attention and fueled the idea of a "brain-body mismatch."
Alongside cultural forces, the medical and scientific establishment has also helped shape beliefs about transgender identity.
Doctors and researchers began searching for biological explanations, and many people found those ideas persuasive.
The surrounding culture plays a significant role in how they come to understand themselves.
With the mainstreaming of transgender identity in media and public discourse, it is not surprising that more young people have begun identifying as trans.
If being transgender isn’t a fixed biological condition but rather about how you choose to view yourself, does that mean there’s a possibility you could change your mind in the future if presented with new information?
Dr. Helen Webberly continues to promote the claim that trans-identified people are “born that way.” She should know better.
There is no solid evidence to support this view. The studies most often cited seeking a biological etiology for trans identity frequently fail to control for confounding variables, making their conclusions unreliable.
The similarities observed in studied trans-identified populations mostly involve sex-atypical traits commonly found in same-sex attracted individuals.
These findings are routinely misrepresented as evidence that transgender identity has a biological basis, creating the illusion of scientific support where none has been convincingly demonstrated.
In reality, “transgender” is a popular cultural story. It offers people an explanation for their distress and prescribes extreme body modification as treatment.
As a medical professional, Webberly has a responsibility to communicate evidence accurately, not to legitimize a pseudoscientific narrative that encourages young people to interpret psychological suffering as a medical condition requiring lifelong intervention.
Quotes a post by A1195; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’m sorry for the pain you were in. I can relate in some ways. I had severe mental health issues as a kid, was frequently hospitalized for self-harm, put on a lot of meds, and never got a satisfying explanation. I understand the pull of a narrative that suddenly makes all your suffering make sense when nothing else has.
In your case, having a DSD might explain why your body felt foreign. But feelings like wanting to be the other sex, or feeling disconnected from your body, also appear in youth who later grow up to be gay. That’s why I question whether these experiences reflect a distinct biological condition—or whether the transgender label is a way of making sense of distress rooted in other causes.
Thanks for explaining. But if you didn’t know about LGBT or gender dysphoria until age 17, then it sounds like the distress you experienced as a child was related to the effects of a DSD—and only later interpreted through the transgender framework. That’s exactly the kind of cultural reframing I’m questioning. Were you sent to conversion therapy because you were seen as gay, or because you acted in ways that didn’t match typical male behavior?
I'm not trying to erase you. I'm questioning whether being transgender is truly a biological condition, or more of a cultural narrative layered onto underlying factors—in your case, a disorder of sex development. When did you first come across the concept of transgender, and did the belief that it’s biologically based influence how you understood yourself?
It sounds like you’re saying you have Klinefelter syndrome (XXY with androgen deficiency), which is a disorder of sex development. There are no brain scans capable of diagnosing an individual as transgender—brain studies only compare group averages. Adopting a transgender identity and transitioning seems more like a coping mechanism for sex atypicality than evidence of a distinct biological condition.
I was wrong and TERFs, gender-criticals, and conservatives were right all along to “hold the line” and refuse to give an inch to any aspect of transgender ideology. I’m sorry I ever doubted their approach.
Matt, I conducted an informal survey of detransitioners, many of whom began transitioning as minors. A full 85.7% said their healthcare providers told them that being transgender is a biological or medical condition they had no control over.
That’s blatant misinformation—and it played a major role in their decision to transition. No child or adult can give informed consent when their doctors misrepresent the nature of their condition. These providers have shown themselves to be untrustworthy.
The idea that people are “born transgender” stems from flawed interpretations of studies. I’d be glad to explain what those studies set out to find—and what they really say—if you’re interested.
It all comes down to the belief that transgender people are “born that way.” Without it, no one would support medicalizing minors. People think it’s a biological condition beyond their control—but it’s a belief system imposed on gender nonconforming youth.
Yes, we should ban it—because parents are being misled by doctors who ought to know better. They’re told that being transgender is a biological condition, when in fact the studies used to support this claim have been widely misinterpreted. “Trans kids” are made, not born.
I haven’t weighed in on any pronoun debates in a long time because, at some point, I realized I was wrong.
I’ve been reporting on the transgender issue for three years now, and even in that short time, my views on this and other topics have gradually shifted. I expect they’ll continue to.
While I never explicitly argued that people should use gender pronouns, I did defend their use in certain contexts. I thought I was being strategic, trying to guide others toward what I saw as a more effective or persuasive approach.
Over time, I came to see that within this broader coalition, our goals often overlap, but they’re not always the same—and we’re speaking to different audiences, using different strategies to make progress.
My focus is on the medicalization of minors who identify as trans. That’s shaped an approach grounded in empathy for kids and vulnerable adults caught up in gender ideology. Others are more concerned with safeguarding women’s spaces or ensuring fairness in women’s sports—issues where drawing firm lines makes sense.
My approach works for what I’m trying to do, but I’ve come to respect that others know best how to communicate with their own audiences.
There isn’t one correct way to engage with this issue. I’ve used my liberal background to connect with people who might not otherwise listen. Conservatives speak to their base. Radical feminists speak to theirs. We’re all trying to solve different parts of the same problem. And in a way, that’s something to appreciate.
Neuroscientist @[private account], evolutionary biologist @SwipeWright, and I—an investigative reporter who has spent the past three years researching and writing about this issue—coauthored a piece in @[private account] examining the transgender brain studies. https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
There is no brain scan that can determine whether an individual is transgender.
Brain imaging studies do not detect individual differences; they compare group averages. And studies involving transgender-identified participants often fail to control for key confounding variables, such as cross-sex hormone use and same-sex attraction.
In studies claiming to find cross-sex brain features in transgender groups, the effect is overwhelmingly driven by the inclusion of same-sex attracted people—whose average brain structures differ slightly from those of heterosexual peers.
This is significant because, especially in earlier research, those who identified as transgender were often gay.
These early studies received widespread media attention and helped fuel the narrative that transgender people, like gay people, are “born that way.”
That narrative is false—yet these flawed studies continue to be cited in legal briefs and medical guidance as supposed evidence that being transgender is a biological condition.
More rigorous studies that controlled for sexual orientation and hormone use found no evidence of cross-sex brain structures in transgender-identified participants. Their brains matched their biological sex.
These findings are largely ignored—because they undermine the politically useful belief that transgender identity is rooted in biology.
Generally yes, that is often what is detected when researchers look for a biological explanation for being transgender, because many trans-identified people in those studies are gay. https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
Read an article I coauthored with @SwipeWright and @[private account] on the flaws in transgender brain sex studies:
🔗 https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
And another piece I wrote addressing the rest of the studies often cited to claim that being transgender is a biological condition:
🔗 https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
Not likely. While some studies suggest that abnormalities in white matter tracts like the IFOF may be associated with distorted body perception or body image disturbances, these findings aren’t specific to gender dysphoria—they also appear in conditions like anorexia, autism, and others. So while this may offer some insight into the mechanisms behind body perception, it doesn’t provide evidence for a biological basis of a transgender identity.
People who believe there’s a biological basis for being transgender often misunderstand what the studies used to support that idea are actually observing.
There are different types of people who adopt the trans label:
– Gender nonconforming children who often grow up to be gay
– Adult heterosexual males with a paraphilia
– Adolescents in distress who latch onto a trans identity as a framework for that distress
These groups may share certain biological traits. But those traits don’t prove that “transgender” is a biological condition.
The traits being studied often reflect other factors—most commonly same-sex attraction—which many researchers fail to control for.
So these studies aren’t uncovering the biology of being trans. They’re documenting traits found in people who adopt the label for different reasons, and then wrongly treating those traits as proof of a biological identity.
“Transgender” isn’t a biological condition. It’s a cultural narrative—used by different people to make sense of different internal conflicts.
For gender nonconforming children, it offers a socially acceptable explanation that displaces the reality of emerging same-sex attraction. For adolescents with ROGD, it gives shape to diffuse psychological distress. For autogynephilic males, it functions as a shield, concealing the underlying paraphilic drive.
The idea that “transgender” represents a unitary biological condition—rather than a label adopted by people with different psychological profiles, developmental pathways, or sources of distress—is one of the most profound scientific and medical failures of our time.
Stanford Scales Back Trans Care for Minors Amid Federal Crackdown
https://www.kqed.org/science/1997491/stanford-scales-back-trans-care-for-minors-amid-federal-crackdown
The illusory truth effect is the tendency to perceive repeated false information as true. The more often we hear it, the more convincing it becomes—regardless of its accuracy.
Repetition makes a statement feel familiar, and familiarity creates a sense of trust. Over time, we start to mistake that feeling for truth.
That’s how belief in “trans children” and unquestioned support for “gender-affirming care” went mainstream. Media outlets, advocacy groups, and medical organizations all echo the same claims. They assert that these claims are backed by a vast evidence base and a scientific consensus.
But that supposed consensus is often circular. Medical organizations frequently cite each other’s guidelines—guidelines that rely on the same limited evidence—rather than conducting independent, rigorous reviews, all while benefiting from authority bias.
Search engines and AI language models further entrench this effect by surfacing what’s most repeated, not what’s most accurate.
Most people don’t have the time—or the reason—to dig deeper. So they trust what sounds authoritative, unaware that the “truth” has been manufactured through repetition.
A recent study from University of Michigan researchers tested how best to indoctrinate young children into gender ideology.
The most effective method? A “realistic story” about a child who identifies as transgender—in this case, I Am Jazz, featuring Jazz Jennings.
People need to understand what parents are up against. The story they’re told about the existence of “transgender children” is framed as settled science, reinforced by nearly every major medical organization.
It’s everywhere—on the news, in schools, in search results, and in AI-generated answers. In every direction they look, the same message appears.
So when a doctor tells them their child is transgender and presents it as a biological condition the child has no control over, that carries enormous weight. The doctor then steers them toward medical intervention as the only available treatment to help their child live as their “authentic self.”
They’re also warned that not affirming could lead to their child killing themselves. That kind of emotional blackmail makes it even more difficult to choose otherwise.
There is a power imbalance between doctors and patients, who are seen as trusted authority figures. Left-leaning parents in particular are less likely to question what they believe is a scientific consensus.
The blame lies squarely on doctors and the medical establishment, who are misinforming patients and their families, both about the condition and the evidence for the treatment.
Quotes a post by A0447; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I relate a lot to Cale and other detransitioners who’ve said that as teenagers, they didn’t fit in, hated themselves, and wanted to become someone else. That was me too. I didn’t transition, but I know what it’s like to be in pain and desperate for a story that explains it.
As a teenager, I was in and out of hospitals for self-harm, cycling through psychiatrists, put on one medication after another. No one gave me a satisfying explanation, so I went looking for one. I tried on different diagnoses, hoping one would fit.
I never went down the trans path, but I’ve followed others that felt just as convincing. In the end, I realized a diagnosis is superficial—and there’s no way around the hard work you have to put into your life to actually improve it.
Cale had been diagnosed with a personality disorder, but after discovering transgender narratives online, she thought she knew better. And it’s easy to see why.
Story one: There’s nothing wrong with you. You don’t need to change who you are—just your body. Your distress is the result of a biological condition. Take medication, alter your appearance, and live as your true self. The problem isn’t internal—it’s society.
Story two: Your brain is disordered. You’ll face mood swings, instability in relationships and work, stigma, endless therapy, and meds that don’t really resolve the problem. There’s no clear solution—just a long, difficult road ahead.
For a teenager in pain, one of these stories offers hope. The other doesn’t.
Certain diagnoses offer stories about yourself that are difficult to resist—like being trans, autistic, having ADHD, or others. They say: there’s nothing wrong with you, you don’t need to change, you have a biological condition, and society should accept you exactly as you are.
Quoting @genspect: Detransitioner Cale: “I was diagnosed with personality disorder and I was like, ‘No, they don't know what they're talking about, I'm transgender…. and I wanted it now I really wanted all the hormones all the surgeries everything.’”
🧵There’s an Instagram creator I follow called “Mister Mainer” who makes really funny dog videos. He puts wigs on his dogs, gives them voices, and creates characters—one of them is a realtor named Karen Bark.
The videos are very entertaining, and he’s built a large following—close to 2 million on Instagram, and over 20 million on TikTok.
Lately, though, he’s been posting nonstop leftist political content—“trans rights,” “No Kings” (promoted as protesting fascism), and anti-deportation videos.
He recently lost two sponsors because they have policies against working with political creators.
He framed it as being dropped for supporting human rights.
The difference is that gender nonconformity is real, while “transgender” is an ideological framework layered over it. “Being trans” is not a biological condition—it’s a fiction.
Ideologues are the only ones who have difficulty with this.
You’re misrepresenting my view. I don’t “admit” that gender identity is innate—I reject that framing entirely. Acknowledging that prenatal hormones can influence sex-atypical traits is not the same as claiming there’s a fixed, internal identity that overrides biological sex.
Gender identity is not a scientific fact—it’s a term that was created in the context of intersex research to describe which sex someone with ambiguous genitalia tended to align with. It served a narrow, practical purpose. When it was later adopted by trans research, it was turned into a vague, self-referential concept used to justify identity claims that have no objective basis.
You’re accusing me of convoluted thinking, but your view depends on a loosely defined construct that can’t be measured or tested. My view is actually more straightforward: sex is real, gender nonconformity exists, and some people find presenting as the opposite sex more tolerable. That doesn’t require ideological leaps or metaphysical claims about identity.
Gender-nonconforming children suffer when adults mislead them into believing they were born with a scientifically unsupported condition called “transgender,” and steer them toward social and medical transition instead of accepting them as they are.
Quoting @SenWarren: Trans kids suffer when they don't get medically-necessary care. This is a brazen political decision by the Supreme Court.
My heart is with trans kids and their loved ones. I won’t stop fighting to make sure they can be exactly who they are.
Children who are gender nonconforming—many of whom would grow up to be gay—may experience distress related to their nonconformity and, if taken to a doctor, might be diagnosed with gender dysphoria. In that sense, sure, they “exist.” But rather than telling such a child they are transgender and setting them on a path toward social and medical transition, they should be supported in expressing their gender nonconformity as a normal part of human variation—and taught that it doesn’t have to mean anything more.
Science doesn’t “disagree”—some researchers who interpret the evidence a certain way do. I don’t deny that many transgender-identifying people have traits influenced by genetics or prenatal hormones, like gender nonconformity, same-sex attraction, or DSDs.
But interpreting that as proof that “transgender” is a discrete biological condition is a mistake.
“Gender identity,” as defined by the paper as “one’s psychological sense of their own gender,” relies entirely on self-report. It lacks independent, observable criteria and cannot be tested or falsified. That makes it scientifically weak and not useful as a scientific concept.
“Transgender” is the current dominant cultural explanation for why some people experience their sex-atypical traits—and any associated distress—in a particular way.
Neither “gender identity” nor “transgender” are objective categories discovered through scientific investigation—they are stories Western culture tells to make sense of certain human experiences.
My interpretation is that sex hormones in the womb cause gender nonconformity, but transgender is not a biological condition—it’s how some people make sense of that nonconformity in a culture that offers “transgender” as an explanation.
In its response to SCOTUS, @[private account] declares it a fundamental fact that “transgender youth exist.”
But there’s no empirical evidence that “transgender” is a discrete biological category—it’s a belief system imposed on vulnerable youth.
Twin studies are often cited to claim that transgender identity is innate and immutable. But as I showed in this recent thread, those claims fall apart under scrutiny—despite what “gender-affirming” doctors like Jack Turban want you to believe. https://x.com/buttonslives/status/1935015260164887002
Quoting @buttonslives: 🧵 Jack Turban is once again promoting his book Free to Be as an authoritative source on the science of transgender identity.
In a recent thread, he claims twin studies suggest a genetic or innate basis.
But that’s not what the research actually shows.
Claims of “immutability” are based on misunderstood research. The studies often cited actually point to gender nonconformity and same-sex attraction—not an innate transgender identity. I break this down in my @[private account] piece: https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
Justice Barrett wrote that transgender status isn’t immutable like race or sex. It can’t be identified at birth, develops at different ages, and some people detransition. For that reason, it doesn’t qualify for heightened legal protection.
In the Opinion of the Court, the Supreme Court affirmed the Sixth Circuit’s judgment, which declined to treat transgender status as a protected class—partly because it is not “defined by obvious, immutable, or distinguishing characteristics.”
🧵A key claim behind medical interventions for minors is that being transgender is innate and immutable—something you're born with and can't change.
In Skrmetti v. U.S., the Supreme Court addressed that claim. “Immutable” appears 19 times in the ruling.
If you want to learn more about the studies claiming trans identity is innate, I reviewed every major type cited in the “immutability” brief filed in Talbott v. Trump and broke it down in @[private account].
https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
This misunderstanding is fueled by misinformation from Turban and other activists who push the idea that being transgender is innate and biological—because that narrative is used to justify irreversible medical interventions for minors.
The twin studies support my view—not Turban’s. There are innate traits common among people who identify as trans, like gender nonconformity and same-sex attraction.
But today, these traits—and the distress they may cause—are often mistaken for an innate trans identity.
🧵 Jack Turban is once again promoting his book Free to Be as an authoritative source on the science of transgender identity.
In a recent thread, he claims twin studies suggest a genetic or innate basis.
But that’s not what the research actually shows.
People are resistant to the truth about the trans issue—the fact that transgender identity isn’t a fixed, biological condition, and that there’s no reliable evidence supporting the “gender-affirming” model of care—because accepting it calls into question the reliability of the institutions behind it. The implications extend far beyond this one issue.
People trust institutions because it gives them a sense of security. They don’t want to look behind the curtain—they want to believe someone competent is in charge.
But accepting the truth means acknowledging that nearly the entire medical establishment, along with major institutions and media outlets, embraced a model that was never grounded in sound evidence—and punished those who raised concerns.
We like to think there are guardrails—that science is self-correcting, that experts don’t all move in lockstep, and that prestigious credentials ensure sound judgment. But the trans issue forces a reckoning with the possibility that this trust was misplaced.
It’s deeply disorienting to realize that sense of security was an illusion. I know—because I experienced it.
And once you see that, the harder question follows: if gender medicine was driven more by ideology than by evidence, what other areas of “settled science” might rest on equally shaky ground?
It’s far easier to dismiss objections than to confront the scale of the failure—especially when the consequences are irreversible, and the ones paying the price are children and vulnerable adults.
Dr. Karla Solheim writes that her regular patients had to jump through hoops for a hysterectomy—while trans-identified patients were approved right away.
She had assumed all this time there was a strong evidence base, but when she went looking, it was nowhere to be found.
🚨There’s a new gender surgeon whistleblower: Dr. Karla Solheim, an ob/gyn from Iowa.
She went from performing hysterectomies on trans-identified patients to questioning the evidence after growing concern for her patients—including a detransitioner and one nonbinary-identified.
I won’t return to the Democratic Party unless it fully renounces medical transition for minors, admits there’s no such thing as a “trans child,” and acknowledges the role it played in convincing vulnerable kids to believe they were “born that way.” Never mind I’m still too angry.
It’s hard to say what was most irritating about this “middle ground” article on trans issues, but Leor covers it all in this excellent thread.
I don’t want to vote for a party because it takes the “popular” stance—I want to vote for a party because its stance is the RIGHT one.
Quoting @LeorSapir: Jonathan Cowan, president of the liberal think tank @[private account], writes in @[private account] on how trans issues are liability for Democrats, and how they can moderate.
We should welcome perspectives such as these, but I think Cowan still gets it wrong.
Thread 🧵
Reading that gave me the ick—and I’m one of the people the author writes about: a former Democrat who switched sides over the trans issue. Unlike him, I actually did my research. There’s no good evidence for “gender-affirming care.” It shouldn’t be offered to minors AT ALL.
Well for one thing, being gay is a biological condition people are born with and “transgender” is not. https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
Yes, it’s often claimed that “gender identity” is innate and immutable, especially in legislation seeking protection for “transgender status.” My article reviews four study types used to support this claim and what I think they actually show. https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
Do you think I’m planning to hack Google Scholar and delete every study looking for a biological cause of trans identity? 😂 No—I plan to cite those studies in my own paper and explain what I think they’re actually showing. That’s how science works!
What on earth are you talking about? “Destroy people from studying a subject”? 😵💫 I’m not trying to prevent anyone from doing anything. I’m providing an alternative explanation for what researchers have claimed is a biological basis for trans identity.
Over the past few years, exposing the weak evidence base for “gender-affirming care” was key to helping lawmakers restrict it for minors.
Our next target for demolition is the foundation of trans ideology—the studies on “gender identity” used to claim people are born trans. 🧨
Quoting @SwipeWright: 🚨As the U.S. enters an era of legal warfare over pediatric “gender-affirming” care, it’s time to shift the terms of debate from outcomes to the foundational premises of the practice.
No amount of reported benefit can salvage a practice rooted in pseudoscience. 🧵
A transgender person is just someone who has taken social or medical steps in order to be perceived as the opposite sex, but it is not a fixed, inborn biological condition.
Right. I would say no one is born transgender, and with gender dysphoria, it’s a bit more nuanced—but even in childhood-onset cases, I still wouldn’t say anyone is born with it, because it’s not a medical condition in the traditional sense.
I’m writing more that explains this in depth, but the basic idea is that gender nonconformity—preferences, behaviors, physical traits that don’t align with sex-based stereotypes—seems to be innate. It’s often associated with same-sex attraction or intersex conditions. There also appear to be people with an innate predisposition toward distress, neuroticism, or what some might call a negative emotional temperament.
When you combine those traits with social factors—like whether someone is accepted or rejected for being gender nonconforming or gay—it can lead to persistent distress. If that child is taken to a psychiatrist, the distress might be labeled gender dysphoria. Once that diagnosis is accepted and validated, the child may begin to internalize it as part of their identity.
But most DSM-defined disorders (excluding a few like schizophrenia) aren’t discrete medical conditions—they’re categories used to describe different ways psychological distress presents. Hence, no one is actually born with gender dysphoria—they’re born with factors that can predispose them to developing it.
I interpret the phrase “trans people exist” as the belief that being transgender is a biological condition. But studies often cited to support that claim misread evidence of gender nonconformity and same-sex attraction as proof of an innate trans identity. https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
Always impressed by how well @DouglasKMurray stays informed on so many different topics. @BillMaher should read my latest article—I review the different types of studies used to claim people are born transgender and explain what they’re actually detecting: https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
Trans-identification is a coping mechanism for gender-related distress—not an inborn condition. The distress is real, but the focus on “gender” can resolve if people are given accurate information. Understanding this is essential to making informed decisions that minimize regret.
Researchers have been studying trans brains since brain imaging became available. The reality is, the differences they observe are largely attributable to the fact that most subjects in these studies are homosexual.
You’re talking about something else entirely now. Just read the article—it’s very straightforward. The transgender brain studies did not control for confounding variables. Once they did, the “brain/body mismatch” disappeared.
Gender nonconformity, or sex atypicality, describes behavioral, cognitive, and morphological traits that diverge from typical male or female developmental patterns.
There is no such thing as a brain/body incongruence. https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
Gender nonconformity has a biological basis. It is natural human variation. Not adhering to sex stereotypes doesn’t make someone “incongruent” with their sex.
“Gender incongruence,” “gender identity,” and “trans identity” are ideological overlays on top of gender nonconformity.
Quotes a post by A0364; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It’s called gender nonconformity, and there is a biological basis for it. It’s a natural part of human variation—and it doesn’t make someone incongruent with their sex. “Gender identity” and “trans identity” are ideological layers placed on top of gender nonconformity.
The immutability argument hijacks biological evidence of gender nonconformity to promote a medicalized, politicized fiction.
Ultimately, trans identification is a choice—a coping mechanism for gender-related distress—not a hardwired biological condition. https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
Activists layer this evidence of gender nonconformity with the ideology of “gender identity,” claiming sex-atypical traits reflect a mismatch between identity and sex. This is used to argue trans people are “born that way.” In reality, it’s a political interpretation.
Gay people and those with intersex conditions are more likely to adopt a trans identity. So when researchers study trans-identified people, the biological differences they find come from gender nonconformity—misread as evidence of a biological basis for trans identity.
Liberal support depends on viewing “transgender” the same way as being gay: born that way, can’t change it, it’s who they are. That’s why they’re on board with transing kids. The immutability argument informs medical guidelines, legislation, and much more.
The brief cited studies on brain structure, twin concordance, genetics, and prenatal hormone exposure to claim that gender identity is “innate,” “deep-seated,” and “impervious to change,” and that a “scientific consensus” supports the biological basis of trans identity.
In Talbott v. Trump, Judge Ana C. Reyes asked both parties to brief the court on “questions of biology,” prompting plaintiffs to submit a 5-page brief arguing that transgender identity is both innate and immutable, and constitutes “a discernible class.” https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.276845/gov.uscourts.dcd.276845.57.0.pdf
🧵 Transgender people are not “born that way.”
The studies used to support that claim rely on biological evidence of gender nonconformity—traits linked to same-sex attraction or intersex conditions—and are misrepresented as proof that being trans is a biological condition.
PBS was instrumental in promoting the idea that transgender people are “born that way,” but has never retracted or corrected that false narrative, even though it’s not supported by evidence.
My new article exposes the flimsy science behind claims that trans identity is a fixed biological condition. It challenges a legal brief in the trans military ban case and sets the stage for my broader effort to dismantle the “immutability” argument. https://www.city-journal.org/article/trump-transgender-military-ban-talbott-v-trump-science
Brain scans, twin studies, genetics, prenatal hormone exposure—none of it proves people are born transgender. In my latest article, I explain what these studies are actually identifying and how they’re being misused to push a false biological narrative.
I totally get this inclination. Psychiatry has done so much harm—what is it even good for?
I was introduced to psychiatry in early adolescence. It taught me to see my struggles as symptoms, gave me diagnoses that framed mental illness as a lifelong brain disease I’d never recover from, and put me on copious amounts of psychotropic drugs that didn’t help. In many ways, psychiatry contributed to my suffering, and once I let go of the psychiatric framework and put in the work to improve my life, things actually got better.
However, I can’t ignore that some people truly need psychiatric care—those experiencing psychosis, people living on the streets who can’t care for themselves, and youth in crisis who need to be stabilized. Psychiatry still has a purpose.
But something has to change. Psychiatry and big pharma spent billions on public education campaigns and ads to spread the “chemical imbalance” narrative and the brain disease model—and they've made no real effort to correct the misinformation. That framing still shapes how the public thinks about mental health.
Too many ordinary traits and struggles are being pathologized. People tend to treat DSM diagnoses as medical explanations, but most are just descriptions and categories of the different ways distress manifests—not why.
The entire problem with the trans phenomenon boils down to people believing gender dysphoria is a fixed, inborn medical condition that children will never grow out of—which is obviously not true.
Depression, for many people, is a normal response to life—a sign that something needs to change, not necessarily a cue to medicate.
We also need to rein in the overdiagnosis of ADHD and mild autism. There’s no objective test for them. But we live in a culture of self-diagnosis, “neurodiversity,” and over-identifying with diagnostic labels—and that’s a problem.
It encourages people to see their traits as fixed and unchangeable, which kills motivation to improve and causes overreliance on medication. It robs them of agency, causing people to believe they can’t change their behavior and thought patterns—even when cognitive tools could help.
Life is hard. Psychiatry should concern itself with the seriously mentally ill, and we should learn how to deal with life’s challenges in other ways.
Quoting @MattWalshBlog: The “chemical imbalance” theory of depression was a lie. ADHD was a lie. “Gender affirming care” was a lie. The psychiatric industry has lied about so many things and hurt so many people in the process. Why would you trust them about anything ever again?
I have an article coming out Tuesday on the different types of studies claiming biological evidence for trans identity—it’s a preview of a larger project. For now, see this piece by @SwipeWright, @[private account], and me that focuses on the brain studies. https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
Transgender people aren’t “born that way.” Research used to claim they are steals biological evidence of gender nonconformity, same-sex attraction, and intersex conditions—then tries to pass it off as proof of a biological basis for trans identity. And I am going to prove it.
Quoting @patrickbetdavid: What’s the one issue you’re willing to die on a hill for?
No matter what cost.
But you must recognize that I wasn’t calling you a homosexual, as you claimed—I was identifying what appears to be your pathway to trans identification. I tend to write in a precise and clinical way, but that’s not a reflection of any animus toward you.
I wasn’t trying to be hurtful. There are several known pathways to trans identification—homosexual, autogynephilic, and, more recently, rapid-onset. You seem to fit the classic homosexual pathway, given your early gender-related distress and attraction to males.
It’s not a study—it’s an article. You’re dismissing my argument out of hand without engaging it. I haven’t changed, and I’ve never spoken about trans people in dehumanizing ways—including in this post. We just disagree on etiology. I don’t think less of you.
It does not appear to be a biological condition. The most cited studies searching for a biological basis for trans identity are actually uncovering evidence of same-sex attraction.
Transgender people are victims.
…but not for the reason they think.
They’re victims of a medical establishment that deceived them into believing that being transgender is a biological condition they were born with—and that hormones and surgeries are “healthcare.”
I know how you feel because I feel the same way. I wish I had the capacity to be a friend to every one of these lost people, because that’s what they really need. It would take a lot of time to build trust, get them off the trans nonsense and help them find real purpose in life.
A few years ago, my friend told me I couldn’t bring Colin to her destination wedding when she found out he was my date. She said she was worried his presence would offend her nonbinary and trans guests. I declined to attend alone. A lot of old friends have stopped speaking to me.
In 2015, Nonprofit Quarterly reported a major funding drop to LGBT orgs as gay marriage neared legalization. To “maintain relevance,” LGBT orgs needed to "shift focus." Trans issues became the next big crisis—and the donor dollars returned.
I have many friends who are gay, and some who are trans-identified too—my feelings about them have nothing to do with my argument. The research claiming to find a biological basis for trans identity is actually identifying markers of same-sex attraction and gender nonconformity.
All but one U.S. medical org endorses youth transition. I’m a journalist. I don’t write about eliminating people—I write about what the evidence says on medical transition and trans identity. What about Yarden Silveira, is that a human enough story? https://www.city-journal.org/article/yarden-silveira-death-transgender-surgery-complications
You were born a gender nonconforming gay male and that caused you a lot of distress—which I sympathize with—but you were not born a transgender person. That was a pathway you chose to try to alleviate that distress. The research supports my view.
I’m not misleading anyone. Much of the research claiming to find a biological basis for trans identity is actually detecting same-sex attraction or gender nonconformity. This is the focus of my work this year—more publications are coming. https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
Most DSM-defined disorders aren’t biological conditions—they simply categorize the ways distress can manifest.
All evidence points to gender nonconformity being innate, and transgender identity being a chosen way to act out the distress it can cause.
The two aren’t the same. A transgender person is someone who has taken social or medical steps to simulate the opposite sex.
Most DSM-defined disorders don’t identify causes—they categorize how distress manifests. I don’t believe “gender dysphoria” is innate. I believe gender nonconformity—traits, behaviors, or preferences atypical for one’s sex—is innate. In people prone to distress or neuroticism, this can lead to a fixation on their nonconformity, which may develop into what the DSM describes as gender dysphoria.
This “right to exist” framing asks us to believe people are born into a special category of personhood called “transgender.” But being transgender isn’t a biological condition—it’s a chosen identity. And if you can opt into a marginalized identity, you’re not really marginalized.
Quoting @GovPritzker: There are trans Americans right now looking out at this world and wondering if anyone is going to stand up for them and for their simple right to exist.
Well, I am. We are. We will.
I like this a lot. I have nothing but love for the people who are hurting, confused about their identity, and lied to by the medical and psychiatric community into believing they were born into a special category of personhood called “transgender.” I just want to help them.
Given the prevailing "gender-affirming" model, the absence of care pathways for detransitioners, and the callousness of the more than a dozen doctors he encountered, it’s hard to imagine Yarden’s story ending in anything but tragedy. And sadly, it did. https://www.buttonslives.news/p/yarden-silveira-the-trans-origin
He entered adolescence at the worst possible time: the “transgender tipping point” in 2014, when trans narratives gained mainstream traction and (now-debunked) biological explanations for trans identity were widely promoted.
He was gay and exhibited gender nonconformity, traits closely associated with a higher likelihood of trans identification... especially now that "transgender" is increasingly defined as an "umbrella term" that encompasses simple gender nonconformity.
Yarden Silveira, a young detransitioner believed to have taken his own life, had every vulnerability stacked against him. Here, I examine those vulnerabilities. https://www.buttonslives.news/p/yarden-silveira-the-trans-origin
On Detrans Awareness Day, I shared Yarden Silveira’s story, which focused on his complications from surgeries, the doctors who failed him, and his death.
Today, on Trans Day of Visibility, I have a new article that examines the influences that led him to adopt a trans-identity.
If U.S. scientists are among the world’s intellectual elite, why do so many endorse the idea that certain people are born into a special subtype of human called “transgender”? Anyone with basic critical thinking skills and a willingness to examine the literature can see that the evidence used to claim “gender identity” is innate and immutable actually reflects findings related to sexual orientation and sex-atypical traits (i.e., gender nonconformity). There is no evidence that people are born transgender. Yet the standard of care in the U.S. involves sterilizing and surgically altering youth and vulnerable adults—committing them to a lifetime of medicalization based on a mix of arrogance and ignorance. Needless to say, my faith in U.S. scientists has taken a serious hit.
@[private account] For many, the only difference between a detransitioner and someone who still identifies as trans is time. I maintain that both should be treated with compassion.
Back in 2009, I found it believable—like many others did—without having looked deeper into the research. That’s why Dick Wolf used the trans child narrative in a storyline; it made for a compelling plot. But it wasn’t true.
At the time, when transgenderism was rare, the idea made sense to people: gonads and the brain develop at different stages in utero, so it seemed plausible that, in rare cases, they could be misaligned.
My article with @SwipeWright & @[private account] critiques transgender “brain sex” studies as an intro to a larger project. Next week, I cover four study types used to claim people are born trans, also a preview of a larger project.
https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
In the last few years, exposing the weak evidence base for “gender-affirming care” was key to helping lawmakers restrict it for minors. Now, the next target for demolition is the foundation of trans ideology—the studies on “gender identity” used to claim people are born trans. 🧨
Quoting @SwipeWright: Last week, the American Psychological Association released a statement about Trump's EO on the biology of sex.
In a section titled "What the Science Says," the APA makes several embarrassingly false statements due to their blind commitment to sex pseudoscience.
THREAD 🧵
Be firm, but not unnecessarily cruel to people who identify as trans.
Yes, transgenderism, broadly speaking, should be made uncool, but treat individuals who identify as trans as if they were loved ones groomed into a cult.
They’ve been led to believe—by the authority of nearly every major U.S. medical organization—that being trans is a fixed, biological condition they were born with and have no control over. That belief was nurtured by their trusted healthcare providers.
We need to reeducate them by exposing how these authorities distorted the science and explaining what the research actually says.
These are people in distress, struggling with their identity. They have anchored their distress in this belief and tied their identity to it. Changing that mindset takes patience—someone willing to plant the seed of doubt and nurture it until they’re ready to let go.
Show them the path out—don’t push them further in.
Quotes a post by T02774; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
In the last few years, exposing the weak evidence base for “gender-affirming care” was key to helping lawmakers restrict it for minors. Now, the next target for demolition is the foundation of trans ideology—the studies on “gender identity” used to claim people are born trans. 🧨
For anyone wondering, the own-body perception studies by no means show a causal link.
Abnormalities in body perception networks in the brain are associated with many other conditions, including body dysmorphic disorder, anorexia, body integrity identity disorder, schizophrenia, and autism.
Stay tuned for additional articles from us addressing all of the different types of studies used to claim that being transgender is an innate condition one is born with.
This narrative persists today because no one has truly set out to correct it—until now. @[private account], @SwipeWright, and I are working on a larger project to dismantle it once and for all. Here’s our new article laying the groundwork: https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
In 2014, the children's book I Am Jazz quickly became a sensation, later inspiring the hit T.V. series of the same name. In it, the trans-identified boy explains, “I have a girl brain but a boy body. This is called transgender. I was born this way!”
This narrative was born from flawed studies that failed to control for key confounding variables—completely invalidating their findings—yet the media promoted them uncritically as proof that transgender people are “born that way.”
🧵The narrative that transgender people possess a “brain sex” mismatched with their body has permeated our culture.
In 2009, on the massively popular show Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, psychiatrist George Huang explained that a trans-identified boy had a “female brain”:
New study finds transgender people have brains that match their gender identity
999K❤️200K♻️
Study widely praised as proof that trans people are ‘born that way’ failed to control for key confounding variables
8❤️1♻️
Quoting @cremieuxrecueil: I found a bad trend in some data, society is dying.
10k❤️2k♻️
When analyzed properly, there is no trend in the data.
43❤️6♻️
Our new article, “Transgender Brain Studies are Fatally Flawed,” is just the beginning. It previews a larger project that @SwipeWright, @[private account], and I have planned this year to critically examine the biological arguments for “innate gender identity.”https://www.city-journal.org/article/transgender-brain-sex-studies-flawed
NEW from me, @SwipeWright, and @[private account]: We examine the “brain sex” studies, which have long been misinterpreted as evidence that transgender individuals have brains resembling the opposite sex—an argument central to justifying the transition of minors.
I just heard from Yarden's family, and they are happy with how I told his story. I'm grateful to them for helping me share it. Detransitioners are the reason I became a journalist three years ago—when the mainstream media was failing to expose the poor evidence propping up "gender-affirming care."
It’s important to remember that parents are often victims in these tragedies too. There is a tendency to blame them or detransitioners themselves for supposedly making bad judgments.
However, I maintain that the blame should fall squarely on the medical establishment, which has led youth and their parents to believe that being transgender is an innate condition—that a person can have an opposite-sex brain and that hormones and surgeries can align the body with their "gender identity."
It’s pure pseudoscience, but when nearly every major medical organization in America endorses it, it becomes dangerously convincing.
Time will show that this is a medical scandal—that no one is "born in the wrong body"—but how many more lives will be ruined before then? On Detransition Awareness Day, help spread awareness.
#RememberYarden #DetransAwarenessDay
Quoting @buttonslives: Yarden Silveira's story is among the most tragic cases of detransition you will ever read. His scathing Yelp reviews of the surgeons who harmed him briefly surfaced on social media last year, but his full story remained elusive. My new investigation for @[private account], featuring interviews with his family, uncovers the tragic truth of Yarden Silveira.
As a vulnerable autistic teenager, Yarden was encouraged by healthcare providers to medically transition. After suffering severe, life-threatening complications from a botched vaginoplasty—and after more than a dozen "gender-affirming" doctors refused to treat his surgeon-inflicted injuries—he is believed to have ended his life at just 23.
Yarden's suffering from complications was so unbearable, he is believed to have taken his own life. His final wish was accountability from the medical establishment. Please help ensure his story reaches as many people as possible. https://www.city-journal.org/article/yarden-silveira-death-transgender-surgery-complications
His WPATH-affiliated therapist encouraged him to transition. At 16, he socially transitioned—this was 2014, the year dubbed the "transgender tipping point," when the media popularized transgender ideology, leading to a surge in youth identifying as transgender.
Yarden was a gay, autistic teenager struggling to find an identity. At 15, he came to believe he was transgender, telling his family he had a "female brain" after encountering flawed studies claiming transgender people have brain regions that resemble the opposite sex.
If you’re a detransitioner or someone who has desisted from a trans identity and I’m not following you, let me know and I’ll follow. My DMs are open if you’re looking for support or just want to talk—I’ll do my best to help.
You know what’s weird? There’s another trans-identified Hollywood starlet besides Hunter Schafer who also got started as a kid testifying in bathroom bill legislation—Nicole Maines. What a strange coincidence.
I largely agree, but I want to add my perspective. Many who identify as trans feel it’s a biological or medical condition—not just because doctors and researchers often mislead them into thinking it is, but also because of their own experiences with gender nonconformity.
Gender nonconformity—preferences, behaviors, and physical traits that don’t align with sex-based stereotypes of males and females—is biological. It’s a normal and natural part of human variation—some girls are more masculine, and some boys are more feminine—but this can be uncomfortable for some. It’s especially common among same-sex attracted and autistic individuals.
Gender dysphoria is a psychiatric condition, distinct from a medical or biological one. It can be understood as mental distress and discomfort stemming from unhappiness with one’s gender nonconformity. But as you suggest, this doesn’t necessarily mean gender dysphoria (like many other DSM-defined disorders) is a meaningful condition beyond categorizing how someone’s distress manifests in this particular way.
Distress is shaped by interpretation, and once people assign a specific cause to it, they often fixate on that explanation and seek solutions based on it.
Cultural and social influences play a major role in this process, leading people to adopt from the “symptom pool.” With trans narratives so widespread now, individuals may begin to see their gender nonconformity as something negative that needs correction. They often fixate on their sex characteristics, believing that changing them will resolve their distress.
Transgender refers to someone who has taken social and medical steps to be perceived as the opposite sex, ostensibly to relieve what they believe is gender dysphoria. But major medical groups and activist organizations no longer define it this way. They conflate gender nonconformity with trans identity, leading people to interpret their gender nonconformity as evidence of an underlying trans identity. Many researchers also conflate the two, allowing activists to present it as proof that trans people are “born that way.”
Being transgender itself isn’t a biological condition. There’s no such thing as an innate gender identity or mismatched brain sex. No objective test can distinguish a trans-identified person from a non-trans-identified one. Trans identification isn’t a singular experience—it has multiple pathways, including homosexual, autogynephilic, and rapid-onset. I’m focusing here on the homosexual pathway rather than the autogynephilic one, as I think it’s more relevant to youth, research, and policy debates.
I also found Mina at a park! 😂 But I like using the same argument that some trans women do when they say they’re biological women: “I’m biological, aren’t I??”
Dear Democrats, you sold out troubled, autistic, and gay youth to the trans insanity. Have some humility—you deserved to lose. This is not the time for protests; it’s time to reflect on the irreparable harm your party has caused to the nation’s most vulnerable.
You’re talking about a trans activist—there’s a distinction between someone who identifies as trans and someone who actively pushes gender ideology on others, which doesn’t require being trans.
Yes. Important to remember that many current trans-identified people are future detransitioners and should be treated with compassion, regardless of their trans-status.
For the past three years, my work has centered on this: Most young people transitioning today are being misinformed by their doctors and therapists into believing that being transgender is a biological condition, which undermines their ability to give informed consent.
Identify however you want as an adult—be trans if that’s your choice—but only if it’s an informed decision, made with the understanding that you don’t have an underlying biological condition and are simply more comfortable presenting as the opposite sex. Be real. Don’t justify your choice with pseudoscience.
I don’t have politically extreme views—quite the opposite, I’m very open-minded. I follow Awais and subscribe to his Substack. I’m planning to read the articles he suggested and consider his viewpoints. However, his pseudoscientific beliefs about trans identity severely limit his credibility in my eyes, as someone who has been reporting extensively on the topic for almost three years. I can’t help but take that into account when evaluating his viewpoints on other subjects.
In the article, I argue that gender nonconformity—encompassing physical traits, preferences, and behaviors that deviate from what is considered typical for males and females—is biological. However, “transgender” is now commonly used as an umbrella term that is conflated with gender nonconformity. While biological factors may be associated with trans identity, trans identity itself is not an inherent condition one is born with.
Additionally, the presence of comorbid conditions simply indicates that they are mentally unwell, with trans identity being one way they express their distress.
https://www.buttonslives.news/p/free-to-believe-in-gender-pseudoscience
A transgender person is someone who has taken social or medical steps to be perceived as the opposite sex. Transgender is not an innate or biological condition one is born with.
A thread debunking the “science” of trans-identity:
Quoting @buttonslives: The concept of innate gender identity is used to justify medically transitioning children. Here’s why it’s pseudoscience 🧵
I review the biology chapter of @[private account]'s new book, which claims "transness has an innate biological basis."
@[private account] No one can get an individual brain scan to confirm their trans identity. Brain scans can identify group differences, but as I explained in the thread, the shift toward femaleness in the brains of trans-identified males disappears when controlling for sexual orientation.
A thread and accompanying article I wrote on why biological factors are associated with being transgender—but being transgender itself is not an inborn trait. 🧵
Quoting @buttonslives: The concept of innate gender identity is used to justify medically transitioning children. Here’s why it’s pseudoscience 🧵
I review the biology chapter of @[private account]'s new book, which claims "transness has an innate biological basis."