The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Gender clinics are “transing” gay adolescents amid celebration of transgender identities and a surprising increase in homophobia especially among the young, according to Laura Edwards-Leeper, who served as the founding psychologist at America’s first specialist paediatric gender clinic.
Link below to full news report …
Despite new cautious guidelines issued in 2022 by Sweden’s National Board of Health and Welfare, child and adolescent psychiatrist Dr Sven Román warns that “the current situation for young transgender people remains catastrophic” and represents “the biggest medical scandal Sweden has ever seen”.
“Affirmative treatment continues to be practised, despite the healthcare system having officially declared a precautionary principle,” Dr Román says.
“The doctors at the specialist clinics for gender dysphoria—who, in my view, have committed thousands of irreversible acts of abuse against children and young adults with gender dysphoria—remain in their posts. They have understood nothing. Their clinics are akin to fanatical religious sects.
“And the authorities’ monitoring of compliance with the National Board of Health and Welfare’s new recommendations, dated December 2022, is a complete farce.”
Link below to full global roundup of gender clinic news …
I wonder if constant propaganda from the trans medical lobby, plus captured medical colleges and clueless or activist media coverage, help explain the judge's conclusion below ...
“Gay rights sought freedom from psychiatric and medical interventions,” Dr Stella O’Malley said. “Trans activism sought access to medical interventions while simultaneously arguing that transgender identity was not pathological.”
Link below.
“My own Queensland Greens had, reportedly, according to one of the attending delegates to the state council in 2019, passed a motion declaring the trans issue to be the most important facing the Greens. (Climate change? Biodiversity?)”
@[private account]
https://arena.org.au/the-greens-the-left-and-the-world/
“This [Australian ‘online safety’] legislation is the culmination of decades of progressives equating words with physical violence.”
One target of the new law will be “hostile attitudes towards women or gender equality,” which is open to misuse by trans rights activists, given that Australia is the land of self-declared gender identity unmoored from the reality of binary sex.
Quoting @shellenberger: Wow, wow, wow. I just left the National Press Club where Minister of Communications @[private account] spoke. She repeatedly and brazenly lied about the fake accounts, claiming they were only for enforcement, even though the legislation says in black and white that the eSafety Commissioner can use them in unlimited ways for "educational" and "promotional" purposes.
One big moment came when a Politico reporter got up and said something about how mean people like @PaulineHansonOz were to eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman-Grant. Seriously. A supposed reporter was white-knighting for a government official during the official Q&A. The same reporter had come up to me before Wells' speech and asked if I had criticized Inman-Grant. Who needs government censors when you have Politico?
After he asked his question, Wells showed the most emotion, describing online criticism of Inman-Grant as "abuse." She also talked about her own staff's supposed suffering. I kid you not. The mask dropped, and you could see what really upset her: people — including a sitting Senator — criticizing government officials.
After gaslighting the audience about fake accounts, Wells repeatedly insisted the government wasn't trying to censor content. She said this after filling her speech with examples of content she claimed harmed people. You couldn't make it up.
This legislation is the culmination of decades of progressives equating words with physical violence. Wells cynically compared her legislation to prevent psychological "harm" to various laws that protect people from physical harm, like seat belt laws.
BTW, Wells never said what content it was that she thought caused eating disorders. Pictures of skinny women? Dietary advice? Who knows. Nobody asked.
Another important moment came when Wells explicitly said Australia would be pursuing censorship alongside other nations, including the UK, France, and Spain—all countries where governments risk losing power to populists.
I spoke with Julie Inman-Grant before the speech began and asked about the fake accounts. She insisted they were there just for enforcement, and when I asked why the law allowed them to be used for government propaganda, she said she might write an "enforcement memo," which, of course, would have no impact on the legislation.
After her speech, I went up to Wells and asked if she was seriously saying the legislation didn't allow the government to use fake accounts for government propaganda. She refused to answer. A man who said he was from the National Press Club stepped in front of me and said I could interview her afterward. But that wasn't possible because they rushed her out the back to avoid any difficult questions.
So there you have it. The pettiest people in Australia are seeking to silence citizens and their political opponents in the name of protecting children. These deeply intolerant and cynical people want to control what you can see and say online. And they're doing it with most of the media's support. Australia has reached a new low in its rapid descent into dogmatism, intolerance, and censorship.
Interim advice on puberty blockers in Australia has been delayed.
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler had promised it would be "completed in the middle of 2026".
Now the government says this interim advice "will be available in late 2026", Rachel Baxendale reported in The Australian today. https://www.theaustralian.com.au/health/medical/health-regulator-refuses-to-answer-questions-over-its-ties-to-gender-activists/news-story/50d69a9bf93dcc16c77f871982c356ba
The government did not give a reason, but a spokeswoman said: "It is important that this process is driven by evidence and is conducted by our most eminent medical researchers and clinicians, engaging with Australians with lived experience."
There is a conflict between the inevitable conclusion of any credible systematic review--that the evidence for puberty blockers is very weak--and pressure on the government from the trans medical lobby to carry on regardless.
The completed national guideline is still scheduled for issue in 2028, according to the National Health and Medical Research Council.
The NHMRC has changed its timeline for interim advice on blockers; they are to be developed by October 2026. https://www.nhmrc.gov.au/health-advice/guidelines-care-trans-and-gender-diverse-people/guideline-development
Public consultation on this draft interim advice is scheduled for November-December 2026.
Confusing the innocent
Trans ideology is not only disorienting for the young but seeks to coerce the rest of us into affirming what we know to be false
Link below to full news report ...
The state of South Australia (SA) has decided not to revive transgender surgery in public health, The Advertiser newspaper reports.
Flinders Medical Centre had offered such surgery until 1988.
A 2023 SA Statewide Gender-Diversity Model of Care, reportedly co-designed with trans lobby groups, includes taxpayer-funded surgery.
In one draft, this model of care proposed trans surgery for minors in the adult services of public health, which would be the most radical step yet in Australia.
Now, however, SA Health says: “Currently, with increasing service demand for elective procedures already available within the SA public system, it is not feasible to implement the gender-diversity surgical model and there is no proposed date for its introduction.”
Link below to more global news …
“Trans-denial” will not be tolerated in a new special interest group within the Australian Association of Psychologists Inc.
The minutes of the August 7 meeting of the Diverse Sexes, Sexualities and Genders—Allies Welcome Group recorded that it was “Not explicitly stated during the meeting but it seemed clear through the discussion that trans-denial and other discourse widely accepted within the queer community as problematic will not be acceptable within this group. The unanimous preference is for affirming practice.”
Across four pages of minutes and a charter, the words “safety”, “safe” or “safer” are used 17 times without clear definition.
In the code of conduct for psychologists, issued last year by the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency, “safe” or “safety” appears 74 times. “
“Cultural safety” is said to require “respect” for diverse “gender identities”. What respect means in this domain is not explained.
It seems that dissent from the gender-affirming model is deemed unsafe, as if it inflicts a psychological injury.
For more global news on gender clinics, see link below.
A grant of AU$10 million to a La Trobe University centre and two Australian trans medicine lobbies, ACON and Thorne Harbour Health, “will exacerbate health and wellbeing risks for young Australians with gender incongruence or dysphoria and channel them towards unproven medical interventions with irreversible effects,” according to Genspect, which advocates for non-invasive responses to youth gender distress.
The grant is to enable a voluntary training and accreditation scheme to deliver “safe, inclusive and affirming care for LGBTIQA+ people”.
Genspect board member and paediatrician Dr Gary Geelhoed, a former Chief Medical Officer of Western Australia, said that “‘affirming care’ when applied to gender-confused young people is not a synonym for safe care”. He said this treatment model encourages “the use of puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and surgery, including for minors”.
Link below for more global news on gender clinics ...
America | A new report from the medical watchdog group Do No Harm has documented little-known state funding for transgender ideology. “Taxpayers are not only paying for irreversible and dangerous treatments for children through Medicaid. They are also funding the state-run programs that encourage children down the gender-ideology path in the first place,” James Eller, the group’s director of government accountability, wrote in The Wall Street Journal.
“Through public funding for state education and healthcare programs, taxpayers are unwittingly complicit in physically harming vulnerable children.” His report focuses on the state of Colorado’s “gender-affirming pipeline”.
The “I Matter” program delivers “gender-affirming care” therapy sessions to children as young as ages 6-9. “Colorado children currently have access to taxpayer-backed therapy aimed at affirming a ‘gender identity’ that doesn’t match their sex,” Mr Eller said.
“Meantime, at the University of Colorado School of Medicine, taxpayer funding supported the indoctrination of future physicians. Documents show that the ‘LGBTQ+ Health’ curriculum—a mandatory course for all first-year medical students in the 2024-25 class—was heavily influenced by external advocacy groups that support child transgenderism.”
Link below to more global news about gender clinics ...
Remember when political journalists confidently (& wrongly) claimed that under-18 trans surgery was not allowed in Australia?
https://www.genderclinicnews.com/p/truth-cuts-deep
A former president of Australia’s transgender medical lobby has claimed that puberty blocker drugs will now attract federal subsidies under the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS).
“So, the maximum monthly price will be $25! That’s right, you read it correctly! These are scripts that can be written by GPs [in primary care],” Brisbane GP Fiona Bisshop, a past president of the lobby group, the Australian Professional Association for Trans Health, said on Facebook.
If Dr Bisshop is right, this federal intervention could sidestep the Queensland State Government’s policy to prohibit any new referrals of minors for hormonal treatment with puberty blockers in the public health system.
A PBS relaxation could also be seen to pre-empt imminent advice on puberty blockers from the National Health and Medical Research Council, which has been commissioned by federal Health Minister Mark Butler to draw up a new national treatment guideline.
Multiple systematic reviews overseas have found the evidence to be weak and uncertain for the use of puberty blockers with gender distress. In addition to Queensland, other jurisdictions with policies to restrict this use of puberty blockers include New Zealand, the UK, US Republican states, Finland and Sweden.
After an emergency “out-of-session” meeting on July 30, Australia’s federal Pharmaceutical Benefits Advisory Committee (PBAC) has recommended that the puberty blocker Triptorelin be given “unrestricted” status on the PBS. An unrestricted drug attracts a federal subsidy “for any therapeutic use”. The PBAC recommendation requires the approval of Minister Butler.
Link below to full story ...
A distinguished pediatrician who went public with his view that gender-distressed teenagers cannot possibly consent to transgender mastectomies has been hit with a complaint from the health professions regulator.
The Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency surfaced a six-month-old anonymous complaint against Professor Gary Geelhoed within days of him challenging AHPRA over its treatment of Queensland psychiatrist Dr Andrew Amos, who was banned earlier this year from social media commentary on pediatric medical transition.
Professor Geelhoed, a former chief medical officer of Western Australia and ex-director of the emergency department at the Princess Margaret Hospital for Children, was quoted in a January 2026 article in The Australian, which reported that the Perth Children’s Hospital gender clinic enables the referral of teenage girls to the private sector for double mastectomies to “affirm” their trans identities.
Link below to full story ($) in The Australian newspaper ...
“After everything that’s happened in recent years with trans activists in particular, why are [UK] police still so willing to be used as private bully squads whenever they snap their fingers? The police really need to get a grip.”
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/trans-activists-police-campaigner-22k5z5cz8?utm_term=Autofeed&utm_medium=Social&utm_source=Twitter#Echobox=1786127078
"Whenever I make the case to other trans people that we need to stop making demands on cis people’s feelings, beliefs, and speech — and instead appeal to common principles like liberty and equality — I am met with choruses asking me, incredulously, “Where’s your self-respect?” This further complicates the picture; it seems that self-respect is curiously tied up in the active antagonism of the majority."
https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/i-dont-need-you-to-believe-im-a-woman
The Netherlands | In the OpinieZ magazine, Johan Bolhuis, Affiliated Professor at the University of Cambridge and Professor Emeritus of Cognitive Neurobiology at Utrecht University, suggests that conflicts of interest have impaired the independence of the Dutch Health Council committee tasked to give advice on paediatric medical transition.
“Although the committee consists solely of academics, its report is rife with unscientific terms such as ‘gender identity’, ‘cisgender’ and ‘sex assigned at birth’,” he writes. “By consistently using this terminology, the impression is given that these are factual scientific concepts.”
“The [council’s] report seeks to paint a picture that transgender care in the Netherlands—the birthplace of the Dutch Protocol—is in excellent order, in contrast to neighbouring countries. In our country, puberty blockers and hormones are said to be a last resort, used only when long-term therapy proves insufficient.
“The reality is quite different. A recent study by the Amsterdam UMC [gender clinic] shows that 82 per cent of adolescents who registered at the gender clinic between 2009 and 2019 went on to undergo medical transition. Apparently, the ‘(…) carefully structured process, with an extensive exploratory and diagnostic phase, careful assessment of indications and support from multidisciplinary teams’ has little effect on the vast majority of adolescents.”
Link below to more global news on gender clinics…
Germany | A legal analysis by Professor Liane Wörner of Konstanz University and her colleagues warns that treatment of minors with puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones or trans surgery is "highly controversial in terms of their benefits, risks and legal admissibility".
The Journal of International Criminal Law published her paper in 2025 but it was recently shared by a prominent German child and adolescent psychiatrist. The paper invokes Germany’s civil and criminal prohibition on the sterilisation of minors.
"High standards must therefore be applied to medical indication, risk-benefit assessment, capacity to consent and legal admissibility—in the tension between self-determination and the best interests of the child."
The authors cite "the absence of reliable data" when considering whether puberty blocks themselves offend the sterilisation ban.
"However, a significant risk of criminal liability remains, as the almost invariably subsequent continued treatment with cross-sex hormones [after puberty blockers] threatens the loss of reproductive capacity.
"Ultimately, this remains sufficient to establish the conditions for a causal link between the risk and the actual occurrence of grievous bodily harm involving the loss of reproductive capacity (Section 226(1)(1) of the German Criminal Code)."
Link below to more global news on gender clinics ...
A former clinician at the famous Amsterdam VUmc gender service, clinical psychologist Dorine Sellenraad, says she doubts the Dutch claim to greater caution than overseas colleagues when it comes to gender dysphoria diagnosis and treatment.
She worked in the clinic from 2000 to 2001 with adult patients. “Leading clinics such as the VUmc should advocate for psychological transgender care, but they do not,” she told GCN.
“What I hear is that the regular gender therapists are inclined to conduct young adults into the somatic pathway [of hormones and surgery] when these young adults ask for exploration.
“What we practitioners in [specialist mental health care]—who work with young adults (18-25)—see more and more is that these young adults who are referred to us with a possible autistic disorder, trauma complaints, anxiety, sadness and personality problems, also have a somatic treatment process going on for gender dysphoric complaints, whether or not at the VUmc.
“These young adults themselves make no connection between the various problems and their gender dysphoria and most of the time we are not being approached for consultation by the gender therapists. Now it may be the case that patients themselves do not say anything about other problems to the gender practitioners. This is one of the reasons why a good diagnostic procedure [that includes taking a patient’s history from sources other than the patient] is required.”
Sellenraad said she attended a 2024 meeting at the VUmc where the case of a patient with gender dysphoria and several other problems was discussed. She said she was struck by the ease with which a VUmc clinician had recommended hormones.
“I fear that the Health Council [in its recent report on paediatric medical transition] relies too much on what is said and written, and has not investigated enough how it works in practice.”
Link below for more global news on the gender clinic controversy. ..
A recent Australian court appeal involved a disputed supervision order over a 27-year-old trans sex offender.
There was evidence about the trans-identified male offender's "gender-affirming treatment", namely an oestrogen implant and cyproterone acetate, a testosterone blocker.
Psychiatrist Dr Darjee testified that the offender's most recent testosterone level was less than 0.3 nmol/L. The level for a healthy man is over 11 nmol/L.
Dr Darjee, paraphrased by the judges, had said "that when treating a cis man to reduce their sex drive to reduce risk of sexual offending the aim is to achieve less than 4.0 nmol/L to significantly reduce libido while levels of less than 1.7 nmol/L are regarded as 'castrate' levels in men and are incompatible with male sexual urges, drive, or libido."
"He concluded that based on hormone levels and low sexual drive, the appellant currently posed a low risk of sexual offending," the judges said.
So, in the case of a trans-identified male, attaining a testosterone level below 1.7 nmol/L is "gender-affirming". For a healthy male, it is "castration".
A tool to predict the risk of a male sex offender doing it again, known as Static-99R, featured in the case.
Dr Darjee was cautious about the applicability of Static-99R to trans-identified males.
"He stated that for a transwoman early in transition the base rate of risk associated with male persons may apply but the further a person has transitioned to being female biologically, socially, and psychologically, the less likely it is that the Static-99R risk level will have validity or utility," the judges said.
But another expert, a psychologist Mr Candlish noted guidance from the developers of Static-99R that the tool could be applied to "anyone assigned male at birth, regardless of their gender identity or presentation at the time of the assessment," the judges said.
The appeal failed, with the court concluding that the trial judge was right to regard the offender as an unacceptable risk in need of a supervision order.
Link to the judgement below.
Sorry for the sorry
The nurses' union says its apologies imply no wrongdoing by author Jason Watson, yet his paper debunking the 'trans suicide narrative' remains retracted
Link below to full news report ...
"Puberty blockers, as we know, can be lifesaving care for many young transgender people."
So said Australia's Chief Medical Officer, Professor Michael Kidd, who serves as the key medical adviser to Health Minister Mark Butler and his Department.
That "lifesaving" claim leapt out at me when I was searching parliamentary records for any mention of the gender dysphoria guideline project assigned to the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC).
In Senate estimates last December, Professor Kidd was present when Liberal Senator Alex Antic was asking why the nation was slow to follow other jurisdictions in restricting puberty blockers.
Professor Kidd mentioned the NHMRC guideline project and declared: "Puberty blockers, as we know, can be lifesaving care for many young transgender people."
We can't know that, according to numerous systematic reviews. If we did know, why ask the NHMRC to review the evidence base?
Last week I put three questions to the Health Department: does Professor Kidd still make this "lifesaving" claim; what is his evidence; and has he advised Minister Butler that blockers "save lives"?
The Department did not answer those questions, but said "longer-term evidence to inform treatment protocols is still developing"; the NHMRC was undertaking "a comprehensive review" of the de facto national guideline from the Royal Children's Hospital Melbourne, and was developing new national guidelines.
"This will ensure that Australia has the most appropriate national guidelines of clinical practice and that families have the utmost confidence in the health care young people receive," the Department's spokesman said.
Link below...
Silent treatment
When the American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) decided to look into transgender surgery in 2021, they unsurprisingly contacted the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), seeking to understand the evidence base for WPATH's treatment recommendations.
The response?
"Silence for a year, no response, no emails, no phone calls, nothing," according to ASPS past president Dr Scot Glasberg. Eventually WPATH pleaded litigation for refusing to discuss the evidence base.
Dr Glasberg asked why "a reputable organisation"—one that claimed to follow evidence—would “not want to show us their methodology tables?”
Link below to full news report ...
Transgender surgery is like the abandoned practice of frontal lobotomy, according to prominent US plastic surgeon Dr Scot Glasberg.
He suggested the argument for stopping under-19 trans surgery was the same for lobotomies—“there was no evidence to show that [these interventions] were of any benefit, and we were harming people in the process”.
He also cited the recent comprehensive Finnish registry study which found that the psychiatric needs of young people increased after gender medical treatment.
Dr Glasberg said this study was important because it highlighted the risk that “it actually could be worse for these children” after gender transition. “I thought, this is pretty telling.”
Dr Glasberg is a past president of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons which earlier this year became the first major US medical association to adopt a policy advising against the gender medicalisation of adolescents.
He was speaking at a London conference on “Rethinking Youth Gender Medicine” hosted by the Society for Evidence-based Gender Medicine and the Clinical Advisory Network on Sex and Gender.
Full news report below.
Silent treatment
How WPATH went quiet when asked about the evidence. Plus, an argument for raising the minimum age for transgender surgery
Link to full article below
At last, Australia's first female prime minister, Julia Gillard, has spoken about the 2013 change to anti-discrimination law which appears to allow subjective "gender identity" to trump biological sex.
At a public event in the UK, Ms Gillard responded to a question about the erasure of women & girls in the statute, The Australian newspaper has reported.
These issues, the former PM said, "were not raised by anyone [back then] because they simply weren’t a matter of public discourse the way they are today.”
"It was a different time. So it is an error to uplift what we know now and the public discourse now and just putting it down to 14 years ago."
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/no-public-debate-julia-gillard-rows-back-on-her-changes-to-sex-discrimination-act/news-story/b7115f531f99334e138166ccd3174646
It would be interesting to hear from the legally trained politician Mark Dreyfus KC.
He was the attorney general who pushed through the 2013 changes whereby definitions of "woman" and "man" were removed from the Sex Discrimination Act.
Not only that. The invisible and changeable concept of "gender identity", untethered from biological sex, was introduced as a characteristic to be protected from discrimination.
The real-world effect, so far, has been to demote the sex-based rights of females, while promoting the demands of trans-identifying males.
https://gigglecrowdfund.com/
In his second-reading speech to Parliament in March 2013, Dreyfus said the Gillard Labor party government had taken the trouble to "ensure the definitions [in the amendment] are meaningful".
For gender identity, the government adopted a definition recommended by a Senate committee.
Gender identity was defined as "the gender-related identity, appearance or mannerisms or other gender-related characteristics of a person (whether by way of medical intervention or not), with or without regard to the person’s designated sex at birth".
"Opposite sex" in the Sex Discrimination Act was replaced by "a different sex".
Meaningful?
Dreyfus was not alone in projecting confidence on matters little understood.
In his 2013 speech, former Liberal party Senator Simon Birmingham, one of the "moderates" who opposed One Nation party motions for an inquiry into supposed sex changes for minors at gender clinics, explained the superiority of the term "different sex".
"The use of 'different' rather than 'opposite' reflects the recognition in the bill of those whose sex is categorised as intersex or by reference to their gender identity," Birmingham said.
Did he really think intersex people--those with male or female disorders of sexual development--constitute a third sex? Or that trans-identifying people constitute a different sex?
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/understanding-the-sex-binary
In the Journal of Controversial Ideas, philosophers Alex Byrne and Moti Gorin ponder what is meant by the term “trans kids”.
They reject the view that the trans child is nothing more than a cultural fiction; they also disagree with the formulation “that some children are transgender, just as some children have brown eyes or are naturally outgoing”.
Instead, they conclude that trans kids are “created”.
“[A] social process that in part involves classifying people as transgender children is responsible for new transgender children, molding them from the raw material of cross-sex identification and behavior.”
This, they say, poses a new question: “whether we should continue to create” trans kids.
Link below.
Death & the Dutch protocol for paediatric gender transition ...
The Amsterdam clinic, home of the widely adopted Dutch protocol, has no good basis for its recent claim that, after three decades of research, clinicians can have “more confidence” in the use of puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and trans surgery.
This is the critique of a new paper in the European Journal of Developmental Psychology by psychiatrist Dr Kathleen McDeavitt and J Cohn of the Society for Evidence-based Gender Medicine. The authors said the Dutch research lacked “methodologically robust” designs, and the Amsterdam clinicians had ignored six years of high-quality systematic reviews confirming the weakness of the evidence base.
Child and adolescent psychiatrist Dr Annelou de Vries and her Dutch colleagues had underplayed the risks when relegating the death of one patient in their pioneering study to the “methods” section of a paper, according to the McDeavitt-Cohn paper.
“They did not explain that this death was directly attributable to the penoscrotal hypoplasia caused by [puberty blocker]/oestrogen exposure. Consequently, the mortality associated with the Dutch protocol approach has never been identified as a harm by systematic reviews.”
Link below.
Press release https://www.gezondheidsraad.nl/documenten/2026/06/30/persbericht-bij-advies-transgenderzorg-voor-jongeren
Guidance on Transgender Care for Young People https://www.gezondheidsraad.nl/documenten/2026/06/30/advies-transgenderzorg-voor-jongeren
More here https://www.gezondheidsraad.nl/documenten
Background news report https://open.substack.com/pub/genderclinicnews/p/probe-the-protocol?r=130uly&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web
The Health Council of the Netherlands, home to the internationally adopted Dutch protocol of paediatric medical transition, has issued its advice following concerns expressed in the country's Parliament.
The press release states there is evidence of "beneficial mental health effects" from puberty blockers & cross-sex hormones, but says nothing about the quality of that evidence.
"The treatments may also have adverse effects, but the Health Council sees no reason, based on the limited data available on this, not to offer the treatments," the press release says.
"Hormone treatments can also have undesirable effects, for example on bone health. Little data is available on possible effects on, for example, cognition, or on long-term effects."
The council plays the "to do nothing is to do harm" card. (The council's review was marked by conflicts of interest.)
The council suggests the true rate of regret or detransition is unknown.
"There is insufficient data available on this, partly because many studies are of short duration and have a high dropout rate.
"The Health Council recommends conducting further research into the number of people who stop treatment and/or experience regret, and into the experiences and care needs of this group."
The council finds that paediatric medical transition is consistent with the legal framework in the Netherlands. This was a concern raised in 2024 in the House of Representatives.
"During the extensive exploratory phase that is characteristic of transgender care in the Netherlands – as well as throughout the rest of the care pathway – there is scope for providing information to the young person and their parents, and for the reflection required to give voluntary informed consent to any hormone treatments.
"It may assist healthcare providers in transgender care if the due diligence standards for obtaining informed consent for hormone treatments are further clarified during the revision of the guideline."
Links below.
The UK's ruling Labour Party government has introduced a draft “trans-inclusive” criminal law against “conversion practices” with penalties up to five years’ prison and unlimited fines.
A conversion practice could be conduct with the intention of causing someone to “believe that they have or do not have” a particular sexual orientation or trans identity. There is conditional protection for those providing “health care services”, but not for parents.
Bev Jackson, co-founder of the LGB Alliance, said the law would “criminalize a parent who says: ‘No, you’re a boy. Maybe you’re gay. That’s fine: Let’s get you some therapy to explore the causes of your distress’. It will criminalize a parent who says ‘No, I refuse to pay for binders, blockers, testosterone. You’re a girl. It’s fine to be a lesbian.”
US detransitioner Jonni Skinner, a young gay man, said he believed such conversion practice bans were “a work around to solidify the affirmation-only approach to pediatric gender distress into law—[something] which has already and will continue to have catastrophic consequences for gay, gender non-conforming, and other vulnerable youth into the future.”
In the UK Parliament, Labour MP Tonia Antoniazzi asked if the draft law would allow “detransitioners to bring retrospective cases against therapists and professionals who transitioned them using that affirmative approach”.
The parents’ group Bayswater Support said the new statute would “harm the very people it purports to protect by enshrining in law a belief that is inextricably bound up with rejection of the body and psychological distress”. “Individual parents, parent-led support groups like Bayswater Support and healthcare professionals (including the NHS paediatric gender services) continue to be subjected to a barrage of false accusations that they are engaging in ‘conversion’. This draft bill adds the threat of criminal prosecution to those wildly inaccurate claims.”
The Free Speech Union (FSU) has begun a petition against the draft law. “Speech is always curtailed in the name of preventing ‘harm’,” the FSU said. “But stopping parents talking honestly to their children about the risks of irreversible medical procedures will cause actual, real-world harm. This is a fight we have to win.”
Columnist Sonia Sodha saw Labour’s draft law as a device “to smuggle a new concept into criminal law of an undefined ‘gender identity’ that is defined nowhere else in [UK] law, and which pulls against the emerging medical consensus that children and young people don’t have fixed ‘gender identities’, their identities are in flux”.
In her analysis, barrister Sarah Phillimore found no sign that the bill’s drafters had considered its likely effect on the family justice system. In the worst-case scenario, she said, prosecution of parents for a conversion practice could lead to orders for removal of the child, or even all their children.
Link below.
"The online school [during COVID] was just the nail in the coffin. I got cut off from in-person contact with all of my friends, I had nothing to do except sit and ruminate ...
"And I started watching a lot more trans content on YouTube and TikTok. I was depressed and self-harming. I didn't want to be alive."
Cristina Hineman, "a very girly kid" who knew she was same-sex attracted from age 12, was prescribed testosterone on the day of her first appointment with Planned Parenthood. She was just 18.
https://www.iwfeatures.com/documentary/meet-the-detransitioner-suing-planned-parenthood/
Of course, the ABC should've published Sall Grover's opinion article.
Where was the three-week editorial vetting process when the ABC published a polemic by a trans-activist humanities academic last year arguing that it's no big deal to give kids puberty blockers?
https://www.abc.net.au/religion/prescribing-puberty-blockers-to-trans-teens-medical-ethics/105161888
Quotes a post by A1607; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“The pattern of transgender ideology has been relentless: enforce the narrative, punish dissent.
“Doctors investigated. Women sued. Parents sidelined.
“State the obvious - that sex is real, binary, immutable and observable - and you become the villain.” https://www.skynews.com.au/insights-and-analysis/divisive-classroom-guide-lays-bare-scale-of-trans-insurgency-targeted-by-pauline-hanson-in-her-press-club-speech/news-story/06331816711f80b3acffa078737962a0
Senator Hanson's comments on the trans movement start at the 38-minute mark of her speech https://youtu.be/wkZ9Q3kOgR8?si=bBI297eiC20hPMoo
One Nation's gender clinic inquiry blocked in the Senate in 2022 https://www.onenation.org.au/labor-and-greens-deny-inquiry-into-gender-dysphoria
The party has made other attempts to set up an inquiry
Germaine Greer on trans https://youtu.be/7B8Q6D4a6TM?si=Ntp76NmJ_N2kA4Ey
Her "lop off your dick" comment https://www.independent.co.uk/news/people/germaine-greer-defends-grossly-offensive-comments-about-transgender-women-just-because-you-lop-off-your-d-k-doesn-t-make-you-a-woman-a6709061.html
Evaluation of treatment guidelines commissioned by the UK Cass Review
https://adc.bmj.com/content/archdischild/109/Suppl_2/s65.full.pdf
"Human rights chief blasted by parents over backing for youth gender treatments" https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/human-rights-chief-blasted-by-parents-over-backing-for-youth-gender-treatments/news-story/f3f7eb17ddcf344e93cf2ee7306ffd60
Coverage of the debate over paediatric gender medicine https://www.genderclinicnews.com/
"The transgender ideology has penetrated almost every [Australian] regulatory authority, and it is supported by the Sex Discrimination Commissioner, Dr Anna Cody, who in government I would sack. So, too, the head of the Human Rights Commission, Hugh de Kretser."
That was Senator Pauline Hanson, leader of Australia's populist-right One Nation Party, speaking at the National Press Club in Canberra earlier today. In opinion polls, One Nation's primary vote is higher than that of the governing centre-left Labor Party at the moment.
In her speech, Senator Hanson quoted Australian feminist Germaine Greer's forthright rejection of the idea that a man can become a woman.
"Yet we have almost every instrument of government dedicated to a transgender ideology, which seeks to redefine humanity," Senator Hanson said.
She referenced the influence of ACON, a former gay rights body turned trans activist lobby. Many government agencies and corporations pay to compete in ACON's Australian Workplace Equality Index. They do so by changing their workplaces to accommodate the idea that people can have a "gender identity" untethered from biological sex.
ACON promotes puberty blockers to stop a child's natural sexual development. And ACON's Kaleido clinic in Sydney provides cross-sex hormone drugs for minors whose "gender identity" is deemed to be at odds with their healthy bodies.
At the press club today, Senator Hanson said: "I am not opposed to transgender people. I am simply saying that a transgender woman should not be allowed into women's sport or into a woman's changing room, and likewise a transgender man."
"Yet we have the Human Rights Commission, the Sex Discrimination Commissioner, regulatory authorities, the Office of Women and large sections of the Labor Party, the Liberal Party and the Greens unprepared to articulate the biological truth.
"[Mr] de Kretser, the head of the Human Rights Commission, wants more power, basically to control the debate about what is a woman. And this stuff is going on in schools."
In April, also at the press club, Mr de Kretser was asked why his commission promotes puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones when "the science is unsettled and there are serious unresolved risks to a child’s rights, and questions over whether a child or adolescent can genuinely give informed consent to interventions that may affect their fertility and sexual function ..."
He defended the commission's advocacy for paediatric medical transition as coming from a "human rights point of view".
Minors in Australia's public children's hospitals are given blockers and hormones in line with a treatment guideline which scored 19/100 for its "rigour of development" in an international, peer-reviewed evaluation commissioned by the UK Cass Review.
One Nation's attempts to establish an inquiry into Australia's paediatric gender clinics have been blocked by other parties.
Today, Senator Hanson described transgender ideology as "explicitly subversive" and "a militant force through society [that] must be confronted".
"There seem to be no boundaries, as it has become part of the propaganda being imposed on kids in classrooms.
" ... don't expect the Labor Party to confront this real issue. They are in bed with it.
"Australia deserves a voice in all this. Only One Nation will provide the strenuous opposition that is needed. This whole subversive transgender insurgency must be dismantled."
Links below.
Austria | The Transgender Centre Innsbruck has enjoyed uncritical media coverage as it pitches a Pride Month story in which judicious gender clinicians declare an “Access to care problem in Austria”, according to Faika El-Nagashi, a former Green politician and founder of @[private account] .
With 800-900 patients, about a third of them under age 18, the Innsbruck clinic’s claims—that puberty blockers are reversible, hormones reduce depression and suicide, and treatment regret is only 1-3 per cent—were not challenged in reporting by the daily tabloid Heute nor by the public broadcaster ORF.
In Heute, parents were advised to be open and supportive when a child “asks whether they are living in the wrong body”. This media promotion brought a sharp rebuke from Daniela Karall, President of the Austrian Society for Paediatrics and Adolescent Medicine.
Speaking to a Catholic-affiliated bioethics institute IMABE, Dr Karall said open debate had to include the risks and shortcomings of potentially lifelong medicalisation.
The author of the IMABE article wrote: “The term ‘sex reassignment’ inadequately describes the reality, emphasises Karall. Biologically, the sex remains the same; healthy organs are removed, and the surgically created equivalents—neovagina or neophallus—are prostheses that can never functionally match the original, not even in terms of sexual sensation.”
Click below for more global news briefs on gender clinics ⤵️⤵️⤵️
Clive Hamilton, professor of public ethics at Charles Sturt University, has joined the gender medicine debate as a principled sceptic.
Writing independently on his Substack, Professor Hamilton surveys the Australian scene, noting:
* the mistreatment of dissenting psychiatrists Dr Jillian Spencer and Dr Andrew Amos
* the overweening influence of trans rights lobby ACON;
* the “highly partisan” role of the Australian Human Rights Commission as an “enforcer of gender ideology”;
* and the “craven” conduct of universities.
https://www.genderclinicnews.com/p/gender-fraud
“Any act that might be considered a conversion practice is already illegal. The sole purpose of new legislation would be to ensure that therapists, and other professionals working with children, automatically affirm every child who says they are trans,” says @AllianceLGB in opposing a “trans-inclusive” conversion therapy ban promised by the UK government.
“The abhorrent, historical abuses suffered by gay people are being used by trans lobbyists to convince the public that this legislation is needed”.
https://www.genderclinicnews.com/p/gay-history-hijacked?utm_medium=ios
UK dismantles the Dutch protocol
Plus: US judges veto secret gender change; in defence of Dr Amos; American medical consensus undone; hypocrisy on UK trial oversight; Australia's trans-activist broadcaster; Fox Varian aftershocks
Gender Clinic News global roundup, link below.
“How can someone strongly oppose the practice of female genital mutilation — even if the under-age girl and her parents consent — yet still support transgender surgery on minors, which is arguably more invasive, disfiguring and life-altering?” https://thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/5763312-transgender-surgery-minors-debate/