The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
NEWS: Membership in the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) declined by 14%, from 4,162 to 3,572, between 2023 and 2025, per this slide from the organization’s conference, happening now in Mexico City.
During this period, subpoenaed records greatly embarrassed the institution, revealing it suppressed evidence reviews about pediatric gender medicine when it didn’t like the results.
Past president of WPATH Dr. Eli Coleman said in his presentation that the organization needed to increase its numbers and blamed the declining membership on the attacks WPATH has sustained.
"In a Substack post on this topic in January, investigative journalist Benjamin Ryan linked to a 2025 scientific paper showing that, while testosterone suppression reduces athletic performance in transgender women who have undergone male puberty, substantial advantages in muscle strength, power, size and aerobic capacity can remain.
"Ryan also pointed to a 2020 review published in Sports Medicine that found transgender women typically lose just 5% of their muscle mass after a year of testosterone suppression, meaning much of the strength and muscle advantage gained during male puberty can remain after hormone therapy."
https://benryan.substack.com/p/there-is-a-vast-over-inflation-of?utm_source=publication-search
Quotes a post by A1857; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Seattle Times says there's 'no serious scientific evidence' trans athletes have an advantage over women
The paper's Initiative 638 coverage drew pushback over a disputed paragraph on transgender athletes' advantages, writes @[private account] for @Outkick and @FoxNews.
https://www.foxnews.com/outkick-sports/seattle-times-says-no-serious-scientific-evidence-trans-athletes-advantage-over-women
The Seattle Times says there's 'no serious scientific evidence' trans athletes have an advantage over women
The paper's Initiative 638 coverage drew pushback over a disputed paragraph on transgender athletes' advantages, writes @[private account] for @Outkick and @FoxNews.
"In a Substack post on this topic in January, investigative journalist Benjamin Ryan linked to a 2025 scientific paper showing that, while testosterone suppression reduces athletic performance in transgender women who have undergone male puberty, substantial advantages in muscle strength, power, size and aerobic capacity can remain.
"Ryan also pointed to a 2020 review published in Sports Medicine that found transgender women typically lose just 5% of their muscle mass after a year of testosterone suppression, meaning much of the strength and muscle advantage gained during male puberty can remain after hormone therapy."
The Seattle Times claims: “There is no serious scientific evidence that trans girls or women are better athletes than cisgender girls or women. A few transgender girls have won at the high school level, but across the U.S., just a few trans women have competed at elite college or professional levels, and none have dominated their sport.”
This is a remarkably befuddled and misleading way to couch the debate. For starters, it is without question that those who have undergone male puberty maintain a considerable athletic advantage over those who have not. And research suggests that even sustained testosterone suppression and estrogen treatment does not erase these advantages.
Even prepubescent boys tend to have athletic advantages over girls.
The research into these questions could be stronger. But it does exist. And the research claiming the contrary is considerably flawed.
@FondOfBeetles help me out here!
Politico has garbled what Owens said, writing: "The fresh legal move is the latest development in a sprawling legal case brought by the Macrons after the podcaster falsely claimed in multiple episodes of her podcast 'Candace' that Brigitte is a transgender man."
Owens has claimed Brigitte is a biological man, aka a transgender woman.
The electorate is generally supportive of transgender rights—eg: non-discrimination in housing and employment—and the dignity of trans people, but are less supportive of minors receiving mastectomies to transition genders; and they are concerned that it is unfair for those born male to participate in girls’ and women’s sports. These beliefs are only in conflict with one another if one simplistically labels them as “pro-trans” or “anti-trans.” Is it “anti-trans” to believe that Fox Varian had a strong case and that she received a life-altering mastectomy in error, for example?
The Trans Issue Is Still Democrats’ Biggest Loser
The same states that elected Democrats en masse approved new restrictions on males in girls’ sports and youth transition surgeries.
https://www.thefp.com/p/the-trans-issue-is-still-democrats?utm_source=gift-article#skip_deep_link
In which Chris Geidner @[private account] expresses his seething disdain for NYT for reporting that even a majority of Democrats don’t support cross-sex participation in girls and women’s sports, lamenting that the Times didn’t subsequently report “facts and studies and evidence” on the matter.
Geidner’s problem is that he is a strict Manichean thinker, and cannot conceive that the public is broadly concerned about fairness for girls and women, and that they do not think it fair to short change their needs for the sake of trans inclusion. Nor does he understand that research supports the notion that those born male maintain a competitive advantage over those born female in sports, even after sustained gender-transition treatment. So had the Times reported on such research this would have only undermined his political position.
Geidner does not understand that the success of these state ballot initiatives is not an aberration or in conflict with the Democratic electorate, but is in fact the most powerful signal to date of what Democrats actually think.
And his comparisons to the effort to legalize same-sex marriage are weak, because those rights never infringed on those of others as cross-sex sports participation does.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
Harvard Law School clinical instructor and trans activist Alejandra Caraballo says that every time she visits her native Florida, “everyone is so mean and on edge all the time.”
Scott Wiener, who was elected on Tuesday to replace Nancy Pelosi in the House, excoriates the Trump administration for its efforts to foster research that would tie transgender identity to violence.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Friday 10pm ET update: The final results are in for all but 1 of the 32 House, Senate and governor's races in which the Democratic candidate went against the transgender orthodoxy.
The Dems have seen 29 wins and two losses:
Blake Gendebien (D) lost in NY-21 to Anthony Constantino (R)
Dan Osborn (I) lost the Nebraska Senate race to Senator Pete Rickets (R).
The New York Times suggests that Mary Peltola (D) will eke out a win in the Alaska Senate race.
As for the state ballot measures, there were only two losses for those concerning transgender issues: Washington Initiative 1, concerning the parents' bill of rights; and the Missouri mixed proposition repealing the abortion-rights amendment and banning pediatric gender-transition interventions for minors.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
No states with restrictive laws related to transgender identity went from Republican control to a Democratic trifecta on Tuesday. Not even Texas, even if Dems now control all major statewide offices. Meanwhile, about 30 major Democratic candidates won this week who pushed against trans orthodoxy during the campaign, such as by openly opposing cross-sex sports participation.
Almost all these races have been called. It’s been almost a clean sweep in these races of Dems who challenged the transgender platform. I have the full account here:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Out of 32 races in which Dem candidates pushed back against trans orthodoxy, there has been one loss and two haven’t been called yet. https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke?r=7wxo1&utm_medium=ios
Out of 32 races in which Dem candidates pushed back against trans orthodoxy, there has been one loss and two haven’t been called yet. https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke?r=7wxo1&utm_medium=ios
Maybe they were waiting for the results? https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/05/us/transgender-athlete-bans-referendums.html?unlocked_article_code=1.OVE.x1Fk.xO2mcEfqE-0a&smid=url-share
Transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed theorizes that in their finger-pointing post mortem, Republicans will fault their focus on trans issues for their steep losses.
Do people think there is truth to this?
I have all the updates on these races of Dems who crossed trans orthodoxy listed in my Substack, which I keep updating as races are called.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
Erin Reed is misrepresenting, or likely misunderstanding, the nature of my question, which is whether laws restricting trans rights that were passed by legislators are treated differently than those passed by vote by state residents when it comes to lawsuits seeking to overturn them.
Are laws passed by referendum able to be overturned via state courts in a way that those passed by the legislative are not? I’m unclear.
The Supreme Court blessed state bans of pediatric gender-transition treatment and bans of cross-sex sports participation. A couple of state courts systems have blocked the pediatric gender-transition treatment bans. I’m not sure what’s up with such state-courts litigation based on the sports restrictions. Meanwhile, Reed is bullish that state referendums on these matters can be overturned in state courts. I asked one law expert and he said he expected these laws could be overturned via state courts.
Reed of course knows that I know there is such thing as a state court system. But she routinely attacks me in the worst faith.
Transgender activist Erin Reed expects that newly blue statehouses will repeal state bans of pediatric gender-transition treatment. Do we expect to see this?
Now that the Democrats have swept back into power, transgender activist Erin Reed is envisioning a maximalist transgender agenda to sweep through newly blue statehouses. This after liberal Washington state just passed a cross-sex sports participation ban and Colorado appears poised to do the same and to ban youth gender surgeries.
Do we think that the Democrats will be eager to spend their new political capital on these issues? Might doing so lead to a backlash to the backlash?
Reed also overlooks that almost all the major races in which a Democratic candidate challenges the trans orthodoxy saw a victory for the Dem, including the top four she called upon her supporters to aid in their defeats.
I asked constitutional law professor Josh Blackman of S. Texas College of Law Houston about threats of legal challenges to state initiatives restricting trans rights. He said: "I think state courts will find those initiatives to be unconstitutional under the state constitution."
Quoting @benryanwriter: NEWS: Liberal Washington state has passed a ban on biological males participating in girls’ sports.
This could trigger a wave of similar attempts at such state referendums in other blue states. It speaks to how unpopular cross-sex participation in sports actually is.
11:30pm ET Wed update: Democrats have enjoyed 28 wins out of 29 races called out of the 32 in which they challenged the transgender platform.
For the 8 state initiatives, there have five wins and one loss, with three still undecided.
The 2 new candidate wins include:
Rep. Laura Gillen: NY-4, wins against Jeanine Driscoll
Rep. Adam Gray: CA-13, vs. Kevin Lincoln
And Washington's I-638 passed, banning cross-sex participation in girls' sports. Girls must get their health care provider to verify their sex to play. There are threats of a legal challenge. I asked constitutional law professor Josh Blackman, who told me: "I think state courts will find those initiatives to be unconstitutional under the state constitution" of initiatives such as these.
Ms. Gillen voted yes on the 2025 service-academy amendment and on HR 2616.
Mr. Gray voted yes on all five 2025 amendments from the defense-policy bill, the amendment that bars providing gender-transition interventions to minors through through the Exceptional Family Member Program, the Pentagon’s program for dependents with special medical or educational needs; the Mace amendment barring covering gender transitions at any age by TRICARE, the military health program; the Mace amendment barring cross-sex participation in women’s sports for midshipmen and cadets; one that would bar the Pentagon form inquiring about gender identity on surveys and forms; and another that would restrict single-sex spaces on military installations by biological sex. He voted no on the 2026 Mace amendments, however.
For the full tally see the quote tweet:
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
In exit polls, @NBCNews found that 52% of Americans think that support for transgender rights in society has gone too far (77% of Republicans said this, compared with 21% of Democrats). Otherwise, 26% think it has not gone far enough and 22% think it has been about right.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
Trans activist-Substacker Erin Reed proclaims the Midterms a resounding victory for the trans cause. What she overlooks is the sweeping victories by Dems who have gone against the trans platform in their votes or stated positions.
For all the details, see the quote tweet.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
Debunking podcaster and Seattle resident Michael Hobbes expresses his disgust that his fellow Washingtonians appear close to banning cross-sex sports participation.
“This deranged ballot initiative is winning in Washington State. I'm so pissed,” he says.
“Washington's ballot initiative banning trans girls from sports is such a fucking clown show.”
“Eat shit ghoul, do girls who don't want their genitals inspected also have ‘voices that matter.’”
The claim that all girls must have their genitals inspected to okay sports is false. Their healthcare provider must verify their biological sex through a number of means, which can also include a cheek swab. However, the American Academy pediatrics already recommends general inspections for teens as a part of their annual check ups.
Quoting @benryanwriter: NYT's @[private account] reports that a ban on cross-sex participation in girls' sports in Washington state appears on track to pass.
This would be a seismic loss for the transgender movement to see such a loss ushered in by voters in a bright blue state.
This is a very common sentiment on Bluesky. Aaron Huertas says:
“Just want to say this out loud: the Democrats who bus-tossed trans people gained nothing and rode the same exact anti-corruption / affordability wave everyone else did, including Democrats who stood their ground on civil rights.
“There is NO EXCUSE for caving into bigotry against trans people.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: 8:40am ET Wed. update: The Dems have enjoyed 26 wins of the 27 Democratic races to be called (out of 32 total) in races in which the candidates have gone against the transgender platform.
Dan Osborn, an independent, is at this point the only loss to Dems in this group, to Senator Pete Ricketts. His race was always going to be the hardest of the 32 I'm following.
Also, Arizona Proposition 318 has PASSED. It restricts cross-sex sports participation.
Wins include:
Aaron Ford: Nevada governor, won against Gov. Joe Lombardo
Rep. Kim Schrier: WA-8, won against Spencer Meline
Rep. Susie Lee: NV-3, won against Marty O’Donnell
Rep. Marcy Kaptur: OH-9, wins against Derek Merrin
Nancy Lacore: SC-1, wins against Jenny Costa Honeycutt
The Arizona proposition would broaden and refine the 2022 state sports law that already bars cross-sex participation into girls and women’s sports at every public school and college, and at private schools that compete against them. The proposition would more clearly define sex—as sex registered on a person’s original birth certificate—and would extend the restrictions to cover athletic associations and facilities, including sports-related locker rooms and restrooms. It would also broaden who has a right to sue under the law to include any athlete, not just any student.
Mr. Ford said in January: “I personally do not support trans athletes competing in sports opposite their gender assigned at birth. But let’s be clear, Lombardo doesn’t care about this issue; he’s only using it as a political ploy.”
Ms. Shrier voted yes on Nancy Mace’s amendment in 2025 in a defense bill that barred cross-sex sports participation in women’s sports by cadets or midshipmen in military academies.
Ms. Lee doesn’t support cross-sex participation in girls and women’s sports when fairness or safety is at issue. She voted yes on the 2025 service-academy amendment. But she opposed HR 28, as “government overreach” because, per a press release from her office, it would “open the door to genital exams for girls and women participating in sports.”
In a September ad, Ms. Kaptur said: “I voted with Republicans to keep transgender ideology out of our schools because parents know what’s best for their kids.” She also said in a separate ad that “boys should not play in girls’ sports.” She voted yes on HR 2616.
Ms. Kaptur was among the four that most earned the ire of transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed, who urged her followers to help Ms. Kaptur lose.
Ms. Lacore's campaign manager told the Post and Courier she doesn’t support cross-sex participation in girls’ sports leagues and that she might back related federal legislation.
See the link in the quote tweet for the full run down:
These 32 Dem candidates turned against trans orthodoxy and have overwhelmingly won:
Quoting @benryanwriter: 8:40am ET Wed. update: The Dems have enjoyed 26 wins of the 27 Democratic races to be called (out of 32 total) in races in which the candidates have gone against the transgender platform.
Dan Osborn, an independent, is at this point the only loss to Dems in this group, to Senator Pete Ricketts. His race was always going to be the hardest of the 32 I'm following.
Also, Arizona Proposition 318 has PASSED. It restricts cross-sex sports participation.
Wins include:
Aaron Ford: Nevada governor, won against Gov. Joe Lombardo
Rep. Kim Schrier: WA-8, won against Spencer Meline
Rep. Susie Lee: NV-3, won against Marty O’Donnell
Rep. Marcy Kaptur: OH-9, wins against Derek Merrin
Nancy Lacore: SC-1, wins against Jenny Costa Honeycutt
The Arizona proposition would broaden and refine the 2022 state sports law that already bars cross-sex participation into girls and women’s sports at every public school and college, and at private schools that compete against them. The proposition would more clearly define sex—as sex registered on a person’s original birth certificate—and would extend the restrictions to cover athletic associations and facilities, including sports-related locker rooms and restrooms. It would also broaden who has a right to sue under the law to include any athlete, not just any student.
Mr. Ford said in January: “I personally do not support trans athletes competing in sports opposite their gender assigned at birth. But let’s be clear, Lombardo doesn’t care about this issue; he’s only using it as a political ploy.”
Ms. Shrier voted yes on Nancy Mace’s amendment in 2025 in a defense bill that barred cross-sex sports participation in women’s sports by cadets or midshipmen in military academies.
Ms. Lee doesn’t support cross-sex participation in girls and women’s sports when fairness or safety is at issue. She voted yes on the 2025 service-academy amendment. But she opposed HR 28, as “government overreach” because, per a press release from her office, it would “open the door to genital exams for girls and women participating in sports.”
In a September ad, Ms. Kaptur said: “I voted with Republicans to keep transgender ideology out of our schools because parents know what’s best for their kids.” She also said in a separate ad that “boys should not play in girls’ sports.” She voted yes on HR 2616.
Ms. Kaptur was among the four that most earned the ire of transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed, who urged her followers to help Ms. Kaptur lose.
Ms. Lacore's campaign manager told the Post and Courier she doesn’t support cross-sex participation in girls’ sports leagues and that she might back related federal legislation.
See the link in the quote tweet for the full run down:
Thanks to all who have been reading my midterms coverage about the Dem candidates who despite challenging the trans orthodoxy have overwhelmingly won. See my full write up in the link below. And kindly s—scribe!
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
Leading transgender activists Alejandra Caraballo and Erin Reed each urged their followers not to vote for four Democratic candidates who took stands against the trans platform.
All four have won:
Josh Turek, Iowa Senate: WON. DDHQ and NBC by 11:09 PM ET; 50.9 to 46. Flipped the seat.
Rep. Marcy Kaptur, OH-9: WON. AP and CBS early Wednesday; 53 to 47.
Rep. Kathy Castor, FL-14: WON. AP at 8:13 PM ET; 51 to 46.
Rep. Henry Cuellar, TX-28: WON. AP at 12:31 AM ET.
For more on similar races, see the quote tweet.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
8:40am ET Wed. update: The Dems have enjoyed 26 wins of the 27 Democratic races to be called (out of 32 total) in races in which the candidates have gone against the transgender platform.
Dan Osborn, an independent, is at this point the only loss to Dems in this group, to Senator Pete Ricketts. His race was always going to be the hardest of the 32 I'm following.
Also, Arizona Proposition 318 has PASSED. It restricts cross-sex sports participation.
Wins include:
Aaron Ford: Nevada governor, won against Gov. Joe Lombardo
Rep. Kim Schrier: WA-8, won against Spencer Meline
Rep. Susie Lee: NV-3, won against Marty O’Donnell
Rep. Marcy Kaptur: OH-9, wins against Derek Merrin
Nancy Lacore: SC-1, wins against Jenny Costa Honeycutt
The Arizona proposition would broaden and refine the 2022 state sports law that already bars cross-sex participation into girls and women’s sports at every public school and college, and at private schools that compete against them. The proposition would more clearly define sex—as sex registered on a person’s original birth certificate—and would extend the restrictions to cover athletic associations and facilities, including sports-related locker rooms and restrooms. It would also broaden who has a right to sue under the law to include any athlete, not just any student.
Mr. Ford said in January: “I personally do not support trans athletes competing in sports opposite their gender assigned at birth. But let’s be clear, Lombardo doesn’t care about this issue; he’s only using it as a political ploy.”
Ms. Shrier voted yes on Nancy Mace’s amendment in 2025 in a defense bill that barred cross-sex sports participation in women’s sports by cadets or midshipmen in military academies.
Ms. Lee doesn’t support cross-sex participation in girls and women’s sports when fairness or safety is at issue. She voted yes on the 2025 service-academy amendment. But she opposed HR 28, as “government overreach” because, per a press release from her office, it would “open the door to genital exams for girls and women participating in sports.”
In a September ad, Ms. Kaptur said: “I voted with Republicans to keep transgender ideology out of our schools because parents know what’s best for their kids.” She also said in a separate ad that “boys should not play in girls’ sports.” She voted yes on HR 2616.
Ms. Kaptur was among the four that most earned the ire of transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed, who urged her followers to help Ms. Kaptur lose.
Ms. Lacore's campaign manager told the Post and Courier she doesn’t support cross-sex participation in girls’ sports leagues and that she might back related federal legislation.
See the link in the quote tweet for the full run down:
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
Harvard Law School clinical instructor and trans activist Alejandra Caraballo anticipates that the Democratic rout has signaled the end of anti-transgender politics. This after Dems who took stands against trans activism have won sweepingly.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
Here are estimates, in ET, of when we will know the results of the remaining races in which Dems cut against transgender orthodoxy or transgender rights were on the ballot:
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
After infuriating transgender activists with this ad and compelling them to urge people to help him lose, Josh Turek, a Democrat, won his Senate race in Iowa.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Iowa Senate candidate Josh Turek’s campaign ad coming out against major tenets of transgender activism has ignited a fire of fury on Bluesky, with leading activists such as Erin Reed demanding followers not vote for him and ask for their money back.
That is correct. And yet these Dems running in purple or red districts all saw cause to make an issue of it and to position themselves against tenets of the trans movement. Examining the outcome of their elections is important. These results are newsworthy. That is my job, to report the news, and not to pay heed to petulant insults that would have me refrain from doing so.
John Fetterman has company in the extremely tall congressman department as Scott Wiener takes Nancy Pelosi’s SF seat. Wiener was accosted by a YIMBY activist this summer and driven out of a trans-rights event over his position on Israel, denounced as accordingly not queer. He rose above it. He is extremely tall.
Quotes a post by T40746; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
2:05am ET update: There have been 22 wins by 22 Democrats whose races have been called out of the 32 candidates for House, Senate or governor who went against transgender orthodoxy
New race:
Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez: WA-3, wins against John Braun
She voted yes on the 2025 Mace service-academy amendment; H.R. 498; and H.R. 2616: In July, she told CNN following the Supreme Court’s decision permitting restricting girls and women’s sports to those born female: “Local communities are in the best position to make these decisions” and “the rush to moralize is not necessarily productive.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
1:15am ET update: Dems have won 21 of 21 races called in which the candidates went against the transgender platform
The latest wins:
Christina Bohannan: IA-1, wins against Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meek
Rep. Henry Cuellar: TX-28, wins against Tano Tijerina
Rep. Tom Suozzi: NY-3, wins against Mike LiPetri
In an October ad Ms. Bohannan said: “As the only one in this race who ran track in high school, it matters to me that girls’ sports are fair,” suggesting that she opposed cross-sex participation in girls and women’s sports.
Mr. Cuellar @[private account] ast a number of votes for bills that would counter the main tenets of transgender activism, including those that would make it a violation of Title IX for schools receiving federal funds to permit cross-sex participation in girls and women’s sports; the two 2026 Mace amendments; HR 2616; and HR 498, which would bar coverage of gender-transition interventions by Medicaid for minors.
In November 2024, @[private account] told The New York Times: “The Democrats have to stop pandering to the far left.” He further said: “I don’t want to discriminate against anybody, but I don’t think biological boys should be playing in girls’ sports.” And then he finally said: “Democrats aren’t saying that, and they should be.” He also voted for the 2025 service-academy amendment.
For all the details of these and other races, see the link in the quote tweet:
Quoting @benryanwriter: 11:05pm ET update: Dems have won all 9 Dem races called in which the candidates crossed the transgender platform.
Former Senator Sherrod Brown: Ohio U.S. Senate, beats Senator Jon Husted.
Amy Action: Ohio governor, beats Vivek Ramaswamy.
Mr. Brown has responded to attacks on his positions regarding trans issues by emphasizing, in a campaign ad, that the law in Ohio already bars gender-transition interventions for minors.
In June, Ms. Acton told the Toledo Blade: “I do not support boys playing in girls sports. This is already settled law in Ohio, and as governor I will enforce and uphold the law.”
1:00am ET update on state measures related to transgender and gay issues:
Called:
Missouri Amendment 3: FAILED. Repeal of the 2024 abortion amendment as well as a constitutional ban on gender-transition interventions for minors.
Vermont Proposal 4: PASSED. Would add sexual orientation, gender identity and gender expression to the state constitution’s guarantee of equal protection.
Virginia Question 2: PASSED. Protecting same-sex marriage.
Nebraska 442: PASSED. This initiative enshrines into the state’s constitution a rule impacting all public schools, including colleges, and the private schools that play them: that those born male cannot play on the girls or women’s teams.
Not called:
Arizona 318: yes 56.8%, no 43.2%. Will almost certainly pass.
Washington I-638: yes 56.7%, no 43.3%. Will likely pass.
Washington I-1: trailing, 47.2% to 52.8%. Will likely fail
Colorado 134: yes 51.7%, no 48.3%. Unclear on how this will go.
Colorado 135: yes 51.1%, no 48.9%. Unclear on how this will go.
See the link in the quote tweet for the full details of these measures
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
12:15am ET update: Dems have won 15 out of 15 races called among the 32 in which the candidates went against transgender orthodoxy.
The first loss of the night for those seeking to curtail trans rights comes in the Missouri Amendment 3, which would've been a repeal of the 2024 abortion amendment as well as a constitutional ban on gender-transition interventions for minors.
The new Dem wins include:
Xavier Becerra: California governor, wins over Steve Hilton
Rep. Don Davis: NC-1, wins over Laurie Buckhout
Rep. Shomari Figures: AL-2, wins over state Rep. Rhett Marques
Rep. Terri Sewell: AL-7, wins over Ammie Akin
Iowa State Senator Sarah Trone Garriott: IA-3, wins over Rep. Zach Nunn
Lindsay James: IA-2, wins over Joe Mitchell
Mr. Becerra told CBS News California that sports governing bodies “should decide who plays in the sport.” He continued: “There’s nothing in the Constitution that says that you are entitled to play a sport.”
Mr. Davis voted present on HR 28; yes on all five Sept. 10, 2025 National Defense Authorization Act amendments; yes on H.R. 3492, a bill that sought to criminalize gender-transition treatment for minors; and yes on H.R. 498, H.R. 2616 and both July 2026 Mace amendments. In a recent ad, he said that “there’s real concerns about fairness and safety.” He said that “states should decide what’s right for protecting women and girls, and North Carolina has decided.”
In a statement to Fox News Digital in July, Mr. Figures said: “As I have said before, I do not believe that men should be allowed to participate in women’s sports.” He voted yes on the 2025 Mace amendment concerning military insurance coverage and on both July 2026 Mace amendments.
Ms. Sewell voted yes on two amendments to a defense bill introduced by Rep. Nancy Mace, Republican of South Carolina, in July that: 1) barred medical coverage of gender-transition interventions for members of the military, military retirees and their dependents; and 2) barred cross-sex participation in girls’ sports in K-12 schools on military bases.
In an August 2026 campaign video she said: “I oppose letting men in women’s locker rooms and voted to let parents, not politicians, make decisions for their kids.”
In a September ad, she said that “all children are made in the image of God” and “we need common sense rules to keep sports fair for boys and for girls.” She concluded: “Parents know what’s best for our kids. Washington needs to stay out of it.”
To see details about all these races, check out the link in the quote tweet:
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
NYT's @[private account] reports that a ban on cross-sex participation in girls' sports in Washington state appears on track to pass.
This would be a seismic loss for the transgender movement to see such a loss ushered in by voters in a bright blue state.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
11:35pm ET Update: Dems win all 12 seats called out of 32 in which they challenged the transgender orthodoxy. New races called include:
Josh Turek: Iowa U.S. Senate, beats Rep. Ashley Hinson
Adam Hamilton: Kansas U.S. Senate, beats Senator Roger Marshall.
Rep. Vicente Gonzalez: TX-34, beats Eric Flores
In July, Mr. Turek, a former Paralympian, told The New York Times: “As someone that spent a lot of my life in high-level sports, I don’t believe that biological males should compete against females in sports.” He opposes gender-transition surgeries for minors. In an October ad, he said that he opposes “males competing in female sports, something that is already illegal in Iowa... I’m against taxpayers paying for sex changes, too.”
Trans activist-Substacker Erin Reed said in a livestream on Monday evening that she is convinced Mr. Turek “hates trans people.” He was at the top of her list of four Dem candidates she called on her supporters to help lose.
Mr. Hamilton said in an October debate: “There are two genders, male and female” and “I have a 12-year-old granddaughter. I don’t want biological men or boys competing against her that could harm her.”
Mr. Gozalez voted yes on a slew of trans-related measures, including the following 2025 amendments: the restriction on providing gender-transition interventions to minor dependents in the military; the Mace military insurance coverage ban; and the ban on asking about gender identity on Pentagon forms. He also voted yes on HR 3492, which would make it a federal crime to provide gender-transition interventions to minors; HR 498; HR 2616; and both July 2026 Mace amendments. In an October 2024 adhe said: “I have never promoted sex changes.”
To see all the races, check out the link in the quote tweet:
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
11:05pm ET update: Dems have won all 9 Dem races called in which the candidates crossed the transgender platform.
Former Senator Sherrod Brown: Ohio U.S. Senate, beats Senator Jon Husted.
Amy Action: Ohio governor, beats Vivek Ramaswamy.
Mr. Brown has responded to attacks on his positions regarding trans issues by emphasizing, in a campaign ad, that the law in Ohio already bars gender-transition interventions for minors.
In June, Ms. Acton told the Toledo Blade: “I do not support boys playing in girls sports. This is already settled law in Ohio, and as governor I will enforce and uphold the law.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
With 62% of the votes in, Colorado's two measures that would restrict transgender-related rights are ahead.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
10:35pm ET: Of seven races called of 33 Dem races in which they have cross the trans platform, all seven have won. The new races called include:
James Talarico wins Texas Senate Race, beating Ken Paxton
Rob Sand: Iowa governor, wins against Zach Lahn
Rep. John Mannion: NY-22, wins against vs. Kailee Buller
While Mr. Talarico has a history of expressing broad support for the major tenets of the transgender movement, he has recently dialed back some of those positions. He told @FoxNews in September: “I oppose trans athletes playing in girls’ sports if it endangers safety or fairness.” He also asserted: “There are not six sexes, there are two.” Regarding his previous claim that “God is nonbinary,” he said: “I’ve missed the mark on some of my past statements.” He has also said he would support a national ban on gender-transition surgeries for minors, enraging trans activists.
In an interview with @jmart of @[private account] in August, Mr. Sand said: “I just think girls’ sports are for girls and boys’ sports are for boys.”
Mr. Mannion voted yes on Nancy's Mace’s amendment in 2025 in a defense bill that barred cross-sex sports participation in women’s sports by cadets or midshipmen in military academies.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
10:05pm: Four of 32 races of Dems crossing the transgender platform have seen victories for all four of those Dems
Dr. Annie Andrews: South Carolina U.S. Senate, wins against Sen. Darline Graham
In an Oct. 8 ad, Dr. Andrews said: “I want you to hear me loud and clear: I don’t support biological men playing women’s sports and I don’t support and haven’t ever performed gender surgery for minors.”
Also, Virginia Question 2 Passes: It repeals the 2006 same-sex marriage ban made moot by the 2015 Supreme Court decision overturning such laws. It affirms that two adults may marry “regardless of sex, gender or race” and requires equal treatment under the law of all marriages.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
Transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed has established Josh Turkek, the Dem running for Senate in Iowa, as her bête noire for his stance on trans issues, her number one she wants to lose.
With 16% of the vote in, he is at 62.2% to 35.4% for Hinson.
9:00pm ET update: Two new victories for Dems in the House who crossed the transgender platform
Rep. Eugene Vindman: VA-7, wins over Doug Ollivant
Colin Allred: TX-33, wins over Patrick Gillespie
In an Oct. 2024 ad in his race for Senate, Mr. Allred said: “I don’t want boys playing girls’ sports.”
Mr. Vindman voted yes on HR 2616 in May, which would impact elementary and middle schools receiving federal aid and require parental consent for accommodating certain facets of a social gender transition at school; it also would bar federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) of 1965 funds for the teaching of “gender ideology.” The bill has stalled in the Senate. At a tense King George County Democratic Committee meeting in August, he said: “I care deeply about my kids, and that’s what I voted on.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
The first race has been called among Dems who have crossed transgender activists: Rep. Kathy Castor: FL-14, vs. Mike Beltran.
Ms. Castor is one of the four who Erin Reed has told her supporters not to vote for.
Asked her position on “biological men, in women’s sports” at a candidate forum in October, she said: “The answer is no.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
James Talarico has earned the ire from trans activists for flip flopping on trans issues. But he said in September: “The way I fought for trans kids in the legislature is how I will fight for them in the U.S. Senate. And my position hasn't changed.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
No calls yet for my scorecard on the races in which Dems have cut against the transgender platform, but stick around, I'll update this live every 30 minutes.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
Trans-activist Substacker Erin Reed lambastes Democratic candidate for Iowa Senate Josh Turek for reporting that he voted a split ticket. She questions those who have criticized her for encouraging her followers not to vote for him for defying some of the tenets of trans activism.
I’ll be following the major races tonight in which Dems have crossed the red line that Reed and others in her camp have drawn:
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
I think that the voters aren't going to the polls with these issues at the forefront of their minds, but that if there isn't any sense that cutting against the grain where trans activism is concerned comes with any cost, this could open the door for more Dems to do so. The ballot initiatives are the rare chance for voters to directly weigh in, however.
The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
I'll be keeping a live scorecard tonight of all the midterm races in which Democratic candidates went against the transgender movement, as well as various state measures that would either restrict or expand transgender-related rights.
Follow along at the link in the quote tweet, which I'll update regularly.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
More than perhaps any other Democratic candidate, Josh Turek has enraged transgender activists: https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/2114195314064441746?a=2P3IIo19w8mR1hWVdYA&s=20
Quoting @benryanwriter: Iowa Senate candidate Josh Turek’s campaign ad coming out against major tenets of transgender activism has ignited a fire of fury on Bluesky, with leading activists such as Erin Reed demanding followers not vote for him and ask for their money back.
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
Today, four states vote on measures that would restrict transgender-related rights. Two other states, VT and VA, will vote on expansions of LGBTQ-related rights.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
The Transgender Movement’s Election-Night Reckoning
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dozens-of-democratic-candidates-broke
32 Democrats defied trans activists on girls’ sports or minors’ transitions. Five states put trans questions directly to voters. Here is every race and measure. I’ll provide results as they land.
Recently, Harvard Law School clinical instructor and trans activist Alejandra Caraballo published a data-analytics report about the New York Times’ coverage of transgender issues.
A source of mine put her writing through an AI detector and found most of it was AI generated.
The “Why This Matters” section, for one, yielded a 73% AI likelihood.
See the 🧵⬇️ for the reads on the other sections.
Here we have @TaylorLorenz down shifting into full-on conspiracy theorizing about @JonHaidt, claiming, absent evidence:
“He is not some crusader against social media, he's a crusader for The Heritage Foundation's authoritarian tech policies. He thinks that IG Reels is turning kids gay. He's an idiotic old man and no academic who actually studies the topics he talks about takes him seriously.”
This is remarkable talk from someone who purports to be a journalist and to be concerned with being factual, even as she accuses Haidt of spreading misinformation.
I am not certain what she is referring to about the gay thing. But she appears to be referring to statements Haidt has made that teenage girls are particularly subject to social contagion and that this, fueled by social media, may help explain the recent surge in trans identification among biological girls.
Harvard Law School clinical instructor and trans activist Alejandra Caraballo falsely claims that Hannah Barnes @[private account] never speaks to transgender minor patients for her reporting. Barnes’ book, Time to Think, was based in part on interviews with such patients.
The influential transgender activist Substacker Erin Reed has demanded that her 132,000 subscribers not vote for four Democratic candidates who had come out against tenets of trans activism, including Josh Turek, for Senate in Iowa, and in the House, Marcy Kaptur in Ohio, Kathy Castor in Florida, and Henry Cuellar in Texas.
All these candidates are running in competitive races that, in the Senate in particular, could decide the balance of power in Congress. Transgender activists such as Reed have sought to hold the line and see to it that Democrats who defy their wishes are punished so as to ensure that the Democratic party at large will continue to serve as a firewall.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Iowa Senate candidate Josh Turek’s campaign ad coming out against major tenets of transgender activism has ignited a fire of fury on Bluesky, with leading activists such as Erin Reed demanding followers not vote for him and ask for their money back.
Activist-Substacker Erin Reed, who’s responsible for the false claim that 450K trans people have fled red states since ‘24, falsely claims trans people comprise nearly 3% of the population. The correct figure is ~1%. By her own measure, trans people have evacuated red states so en masse, there wouldn’t be enough left to swing a race there.
In response to transgender activists insisting that Josh Turek must lose for coming out against cross-sex sports participation, @mattyglesias has pointed out that he’d be better for the trans movement than his Republican opponent.
This logic has not gone over well on Bluesky, where purity tests reign supreme.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Infuriated transgender activists are hoping that Democratic candidates in red areas who have taken stands against cross-sex sports participation or even federal funding for gender-transition treatment will lose. Victory by such candidates, activists such as Harvard Law School clinical instructor and trans activist Alejandra Caraballo fear, could further erode the transgender movement’s political capital. Losses, on the other hand, could provide an opportunity to blame their positions on trans issues.
Infuriated transgender activists are hoping that Democratic candidates in red areas who have taken stands against cross-sex sports participation or even federal funding for gender-transition treatment will lose. Victory by such candidates, activists such as Harvard Law School clinical instructor and trans activist Alejandra Caraballo fear, could further erode the transgender movement’s political capital. Losses, on the other hand, could provide an opportunity to blame their positions on trans issues.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Iowa Senate candidate Josh Turek’s campaign ad coming out against major tenets of transgender activism has ignited a fire of fury on Bluesky, with leading activists such as Erin Reed demanding followers not vote for him and ask for their money back.
Iowa Senate candidate Josh Turek’s campaign ad coming out against major tenets of transgender activism has ignited a fire of fury on Bluesky, with leading activists such as Erin Reed demanding followers not vote for him and ask for their money back.
Sydney Bauer laments that the debate over trans inclusion in sports use to center around kids being categorized according to gender identity, which “feels so out of contact with how it’s [now] talked about because [of] the legitimization of the idea of ‘biological sex.’”
This raises the question of whether the default position has always been to see humans according to gender and whether the concept of biological sex is a recent metaphysical invention, a mere social construct devised to oppress.
If you want to read more on the subject, here is my complete archive of my 25 years of coverage of the HIV epidemic. I don’t write about it that much anymore, in part because I needed to move on, but also because HIV activists have sought to blacklist me because of my trans coverage. This sometimes makes it such a pain to come up with sources that it’s not worth the trouble. https://www.benryan.net/hiv.html
While most Americans support some but not all tenets of transgender activism—eg: they support job and housing protections but not cross-sex sports participation—activist-Susbtacker Erin Reed puts plainly why the leading voices in the trans movement do not believe they should give up even an inch of ground: the slippery slope theory.
This investigation in @TheNation about the downfall of Scientific American presents a neat parallel to the question of whether the downfall of the transgender rights movement can be blamed on its political excesses prompting a backlash, on cynical rightwing exploitation, or a combination of both.
After @[private account] became nakedly leftwing in recent years under Laura Helmuth (who posted scathingly about Trump supporters after the 2024 election results came in and was pressured to resign), this attracted the ire of the Trump administration, which in turn put pressure on its corporate owner, which ultimately offloaded the company to a small firm, which proceeded to gut the magazine.
Would none of this have happened had SciAm stuck strictly to the science and not come out swinging in the left-wing approach to the culture wars? We'll never know.
https://www.thenation.com/article/society/scientific-american-springer-nature-trump/
JK Rowling, in a new essay about her positions about sex and gender, writes:
"What to the average person seems so obvious as to barely need stating – that women who’ve been raped would rather not discuss the details of their rape or their subsequent trauma in the presence of men they don’t know, whether or not the men are wearing dresses – is seen as not only irrational, but actively harmful and cruel, by many trans activists. Beira’s Place has been defamed as ‘anti-trans’ and ‘anti-rights’, the latter by Amnesty International, which has whole-heartedly embraced gender identity ideology and is now behaving exactly like the kind of authoritarian, speech-censoring, witch-hunting governments it once stood against (the irony is not lost on me; I once worked for them).
"As everyone knows, I’m in the privileged position of never needing to work again and of not needing state run services, but I once lived hand to mouth. I was one of the women who couldn’t afford to insulate herself from potential physical harm and who fell into the categories of both domestic abuse and sexual assault victim. Large numbers of women who’ve never been poor, who’ve never worked the kind of job where they’d be vulnerable to predatory men and who’ve never needed a rape crisis centre have spent the last few years vilifying members of their own sex for fighting to retain their hard-won rights and single-sex spaces, in ways that have shocked and disgusted me. I freely confess that I feel an extra layer of abhorrence for any woman who claims to be a feminist while doing it."
Quoting @jk_rowling: I wrote a new piece about women’s rights and whether or not I want trans people dead. (Spoiler: I don’t)👇
https://www.jkrowling.com/opinions/an-update-to-my-essay-of-june-2020/
A Washington Post/ABC News/Ipsos poll asked which party, the Democrats or the Republicans, respondents trust to do a better job handling transgender issues. They replied:
•Democrats: 38%
•Republicans: 29%
•Both equally: 5%
•Neither: 27%
Meanwhile, trans activists, who are all far left wing, have been campaigning against Acton because she won't adhere to their demands for open cross-sex participation in sports.
No, I am referring to sex, not gender. Sex is biological, objective, fixed and binary. Gender is social, subjective and subject to alteration. A transgender person seeks to live as the opposite sex, and in this case to participate in the sports category of the opposite sex.
Trans activist Andrea James has wielded outsize influence by gaming the search engine system to place her pages attacking those who express skepticism of pediatric gender medicine high up on their Google search results. But now AI is upending online search and is primed to see through her pages as disingenuous and nowhere near as important compared with other online information about the person.
Quotes a post by A1220; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Fantasy novelist Catherynne M. Valente insists that if a child tells their parents they are transgender and the parents don’t react by going full tilt into mega transgender advocacy, they are invalid parents. She says that parents put their kids at risk in sports leagues all the time, therefore their expressed concerns about gender-transition interventions are disingenuous.
Quotes a post by T25143; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Memories of the wrath Gay unleashed upon me when I had the gall to tweet in February 2023, after she and a bunch of people signed that appalling letter condemning the NYT for their trans reporting, that the signatories were "upset with the Times over its coverage." Gay got very upset over this and dragged me hard.
Words that do not occur in the NIH's new Office of AIDS Research's overarching research plan for 2026-2030:
Transgender, gender, gay, LGBT, stigma, racism, structural, social determinants, harm reduction, syringe, substance use, drug use, mental health, sex work, incarceration, homelessness, underserved, marginalized, minority (as a population term), DEI, equity (except in the name of the HOPE Act), or disparities (except in a sentence describing the old 2015 framework).
"Men who have sex with men" once, but not the research priorities. "Black" and "Latino" appear once each, in an infographic along with "men who have sex with men."
The Trump administration has sought to purge the NIH of words it sees as tainted by DEI.
70% of new HIV cases are in gay and bisexual men, also known as men who have sex with men.
HIV disproportionately impacts black and Latino Americans.
Transgender women also have a very high HIV rate.
The plan emphasizes implementation science—or getting the tools to fight HIV to work in the real world. Traditionally, doing so means paying close attention to the demographic groups among whom HIV is most common.
Erin Reed Has Been Hiding AI-Generated Text in Her Reporting For Years
https://theneedlenews.com/2026/09/erin-reeds-ai-journalism-career/
Erin Reed, owner of the news outlet Erin in the Morning, has been hiding AI-generated text in her reporting for years, and passing it off as her own writing. There is clear and convincing evidence that Reed has been copying from large language models for the vast majority of her independent journalism career, and that this has fundamentally altered how she presents her stories to her audience.
The Needle reached this conclusion by analyzing every article she published to her outlet, Erin in the Morning, from its founding in July 2022 through Aug. 2026. This includes all 754 articles on her solo byline, totaling 713,163 words.
We then used machine learning and stylometrics to analyze the growing influence of large language models (LLMs) on her work. Our analysis shows that Reed’s writing changes at the same time (and in the ways) that AI models changed. LLMs tend to be more long-winded than humans, and Reed’s writing has gotten more long-winded since the release of ChatGPT. Over a three year span, her writing went from being at grade level for a high school junior to being as difficult to read as an academic paper.
The differences are visible line by line. The paragraphs which we can prove Reed pasted from somewhere outside her normal editing process are longer, more complex, and far harder to read. The stuff she is pasting without proper citation is stylistically different from her other paragraphs. Those style differences largely match the known tells of LLM writing.
Since Feb. 2026, at least 60% of her sentences show signs of AI influence. Erin Reed’s writing style now more closely resembles the writing style of an LLM than it resembles her own writing from before the release of ChatGPT less than four years ago.
The rise of LLM-written text also saw her use em dashes for the first time. While she claims that she has “always” used a lot of em-dashes, the mark was not written in her articles a single time before the release of ChatGPT. Her recent writing uses them 3-4 times as often as the average human author.
Her articles are also full of errors, many of which are directly attributable to LLM hallucinations. In one case, this resulted in her referring to a trans man journalist by the women’s equivalent of his real name. This and dozens of other unacknowledged errors are still visible in her reporting.
She once denounced another news site for feeding her own article into an LLM and publishing it as their own. According to all available evidence, she makes articles in a similar way.
Reed has never told her readers that she uses LLMs to generate any portion of her articles. She is hiding her reliance on LLM writing from her readers, and presenting the machine’s work as her own.
Trans-Activist Substacker Erin Reed is Taken to Task for Using AI In Her Writing
It's been quite obvious to me over the past year in particular that Erin Reed's famous red-line fact checks of science she dislikes have become more sophisticated. And I have presumed that is because she is using AI to generate her work, at least partially.
I have myself long documented the many erroneous claims that Reed has published over time, in particular about pediatric gender medicine and the Cass Review. She is routinely unrepentant when challenged about publishing false claims, and will double down and resort to ad hominem attacks to deflect.
I've noticed in recent months that even Bluesky users are starting to pick up on Reed's untrustworthiness and are souring on her. They fault her for being excessively pessimistic in her reporting and for using scare tactics to drum up clicks. And they recognize that she often cannot be trusted to publish accurate information.
This speaks to a wider problem in the shift to independent-writer media accounts, given they are only beholden to their paid subscribers. There is no higher editorial authority to ensure that they are taken to account if they make mistakes. Audience capture is a serious problem.
Quoting @kittypurrzog: Trans news outlet The Needle is coming for one of the biggest names (and biggest bullshitters) in trans media
A new YouGov poll found that 45% thought the state or local government should make decisions about cross-sex participation in sports.
45% said they were more likely to vote for a candidate who supports banning cross-sex participation.
42% said politicians should not focus on trans issues.
37% said Dems focus too much on such issues. The same percentage said so about Republicans.
Quoting @benryanwriter: A new YouGov poll finds that just 41% of respondents support adults having access to gender-transition treatment, compared with 40% opposed.
As for bans of minors accessing such interventions, just 38% supported them and 45% opposed (the adult question did not concern bans, just access).
How Pediatric Gender Medicine Leverages CPS to Keep Parents In Line
There are myriad examples of people in the pediatric gender field in the US and Canada either advocating for or using child protective services as leverage to coerce or force parents into consenting to gender-transition interventions for their children. 🧵⬇️
For one, in this video I obtained from a conference of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, Ren Massey, a Georgia psychologist, suggested bringing in line parents wary of gender-transition interventions by introducing the specter of a CPS call. “There are at least some child protective service workers who are willing to enforce the need for affirmation by parents, at least with social transition needs, names, pronouns, etc.,” Massey said. “Even letting parents know that if that’s true where you are practicing, that might get their attention a little bit.” https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/2039318181647384967/video/1
Quoting @LeorSapir: Child protective services investigate parents for refusing to “affirm” their children as the opposite sex.
In some cases, CPS remove children from their parents’ custody.
@[private account] @Heritage with an important new fact sheet on this aspect of the “gender identity” debate.
C4 targetinghand-codedinstitutional capturemedical harmparent abuserstate takes children
It’s the state politicians that were politically involved, not the national ones. Also, Biden and Obama did a lot of change the administrative state on behalf of trans civil rights, including in changes to Title IX. So a lot of this stuff wasn’t as visible if you’re just paying attention to Congress. But it caused a lot of changes and people noticed. They weren’t imagining things.
YouTube star and bestselling writer John Green’s family will not be watching the new Harry Potter show on HBO, given, he says, that @JK_Rowling “supports the erasure of trans people.”
Quoting @VanityFair: John Green on J.K. Rowling:
“I think it’s important when we talk about her to talk about the fact that supporting her work now is directly supporting efforts at the erasure of trans people, and that makes me really sad.
I think about all the trans friends I have who have Deathly Hallows tattoos,” Green continues, “and how heartbreaking it is for them to have someone who created something that matters so much to them really betray them.” Will he watch HBO’s upcoming 'Harry Potter' show? “No. No. No.” https://vanityfair.visitlink.me/sb7Y_M
We went straight from the trans activist protest to the @jessesingal and @helenlewis show at the Village Underground.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Protesters are assembling at @[private account] in East Midtown Manhattan to protest the settlement the hospital reached with the Justice Department to keep shuttered its pediatric gender clinic and to pay an $8.5 million fine.
Nell Minow blocked me after she posted a non-sequitur about the American Academy of Pediatrics. Below is her original post that was the basis of my fact check and her reply to me.
As for the AAP, they do not issue practice guidelines for gender-transition treatment for minors. They only issue a policy statement, which essentially establishes a treatment philosophy for care providers: that they should follow what's known as the gender-affirmative method (which lends considerable deference to the child's self perception and wants).
It is the Endocrine Society and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) that issue practice guidelines.
WPATH's 2022 guidelines eliminated age restrictions on all gender surgeries but phalloplasties. WPATH did so because of pressure it received from a major Biden administration health official and the AAP itself. The AAP threatened that if WPATH did not remove the age restrictions, the AAP would campaign against the care guidelines. So WPATH caved.
In other words, the AAP, behind the scenes, was extremely eager to get rid of age restrictions on gender surgeries.
See:
https://benryan.substack.com/p/scoop-the-unredacted-email-that-shows
Mandani Lambasts NYU
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has issued a blistering statement in response to @[private account] entering a settlement with the DoJ to keep its pediatric gender clinic closed:
“Today’s decision by NYU Langone to enter into a settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice is yet another alarming example of a private institution caving to pressure from the federal government that will have real and serious consequences for young trans and gender nonconforming New Yorkers. The settlement politicizes families’ most private medical decisions, vilifies lifesaving care, and undermines professional medical judgment," @ZohranKMamdani said.
He continued:
"Even more concerning, NYU Langone's decision to settle comes just two weeks after Mount Sinai decided to enter into a similar settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice—ending the availability of certain gender-affirming services for trans youth and promoting so-called 'detransition services.'
"While this is a frightening time for the LGBTQIA+ community in general, and particularly for the trans community, I want New Yorkers to know that New York City will continue to protect, support, and cherish trans and gender nonconforming New Yorkers. In the face of these attacks, my administration proactively invested $15 million to ensure access to gender-affirming care, and our City’s hospitals continues to provide this lifesaving care to those who need it.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: BREAKING: Two More Major Hospitals Reach DoJ Settlements to Keep Youth Gender Clinics Shuttered
👉Substack link: https://benryan.substack.com/p/two-more-major-hospitals-reach-doj
The Justice Department announced that NYU Langone and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center had joined four other major hospitals in reaching such settlements, to the dismay of trans activists.
Two additional major hospitals today reached settlements with the Department of Justice to keep their pediatric gender clinics shuttered. This development amounts to more victories for the Trump administration as it wages a whole-of-government campaign to destroy what remains of the beleaguered field of pediatric gender medicine.
Facing accusations of potential violations of federal law, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center—the largest medical provider in Pennsylvania—and NYU Langone have each agreed to cease providing gender-transition interventions to minors, according to a Justice Department news release. NYU Langone will pay an $8.5 million penalty and UPMC will pay $950,000.
“The Department of Justice is fighting to protect our nation’s children and working tirelessly to reach agreements with hospitals to end so-called ‘gender affirming care’ for minors,” Attorney General Todd Blanche said in the release. “Today’s resolutions send a clear message: hospitals that target children in these practices and then fraudulently obtain payment for the procedures will be held to account.”
“In working towards these resolutions,” the news release stated, “the United States acknowledged that both NYU and UPMC took significant steps entitling them to credit for cooperation with the Department in its investigation, including ongoing cooperation in the Department’s investigation of other entities potentially violating federal law in connection with the provision of sex-rejecting procedures to minors. At all times during the investigation, NYU and UPMC remained cooperative and solutions-driven.”
New York’s Mt. Sinai earlier this month reached a similar settlement to keep its pediatric gender clinic closed, joining a roster of hospitals to have capitulated in the face of the Trump administration’s threats to this field that includes Texas Children’s Hospital, the Cleveland Clinic and Connecticut Children’s Medical Center. Mt. Sinai agreed to pay a monetary penalty and to put $2 million toward patients who have been harmed by gender-transition interventions they received as minors.
There was no mention in the news release on Friday of UPMC or NYU Langone being compelled to provide treatment for so-called detransitioners.
The Justice Department made clear in the release that it is continuing to target other major hospitals, suggesting that more such settlements may be on the horizon.
FOR THE FULL ARTICLE: https://benryan.substack.com/p/two-more-major-hospitals-reach-doj
BREAKING: Two More Major Hospitals Reach DoJ Settlements to Keep Youth Gender Clinics Shuttered
👉Substack link: https://benryan.substack.com/p/two-more-major-hospitals-reach-doj
The Justice Department announced that NYU Langone and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center had joined four other major hospitals in reaching such settlements, to the dismay of trans activists.
Two additional major hospitals today reached settlements with the Department of Justice to keep their pediatric gender clinics shuttered. This development amounts to more victories for the Trump administration as it wages a whole-of-government campaign to destroy what remains of the beleaguered field of pediatric gender medicine.
Facing accusations of potential violations of federal law, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center—the largest medical provider in Pennsylvania—and NYU Langone have each agreed to cease providing gender-transition interventions to minors, according to a Justice Department news release. NYU Langone will pay an $8.5 million penalty and UPMC will pay $950,000.
“The Department of Justice is fighting to protect our nation’s children and working tirelessly to reach agreements with hospitals to end so-called ‘gender affirming care’ for minors,” Attorney General Todd Blanche said in the release. “Today’s resolutions send a clear message: hospitals that target children in these practices and then fraudulently obtain payment for the procedures will be held to account.”
“In working towards these resolutions,” the news release stated, “the United States acknowledged that both NYU and UPMC took significant steps entitling them to credit for cooperation with the Department in its investigation, including ongoing cooperation in the Department’s investigation of other entities potentially violating federal law in connection with the provision of sex-rejecting procedures to minors. At all times during the investigation, NYU and UPMC remained cooperative and solutions-driven.”
New York’s Mt. Sinai earlier this month reached a similar settlement to keep its pediatric gender clinic closed, joining a roster of hospitals to have capitulated in the face of the Trump administration’s threats to this field that includes Texas Children’s Hospital, the Cleveland Clinic and Connecticut Children’s Medical Center. Mt. Sinai agreed to pay a monetary penalty and to put $2 million toward patients who have been harmed by gender-transition interventions they received as minors.
There was no mention in the news release on Friday of UPMC or NYU Langone being compelled to provide treatment for so-called detransitioners.
The Justice Department made clear in the release that it is continuing to target other major hospitals, suggesting that more such settlements may be on the horizon.
FOR THE FULL ARTICLE: https://benryan.substack.com/p/two-more-major-hospitals-reach-doj
Now everyone is throwing another casting-related fit because Greta Gerwig is suggesting that, what, Aslan is transgender?
Prepare for this movie to do $2B global box office easy. If the anti-woke campaign against The Odyssey is any guide.
Quotes a post by T28312; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Jesse Thorn, host of @[private account]’s Bullseye makes non-evidence-based claims about gender-transition surgeries for adolescents.
There is no evidence that such surgeries prevent suicide. There is so little research about them, for starters. And Finnish research into the connection between cross-sex hormone treatment and suicide in youths did not find such a link.
As for medical necessity, this is a term that WPATH spliced into its trans care guidelines for adolescents knowing they did not have the research to back it up. What they wanted was to ensure that insurers covered such medical interventions.
As for “rare,” during the several years leading up to these practices being widely banned, about 1,000 biological girls had a gender transition mastectomy annually. That is according to an analysis by @LeorSapir. Some people think that is a high number. Others think it constitutes rarity.
One question that supporters of these practices have always been unable to answer is this: If the need for these mastectomies is so intrinsically dire, why were there not waves of suicides among teenagers wanting their breasts removed prior to the 2010s?
Joining in with the general anti-AI, anti-data center ethos that has calcified on the far left, @ACLU spokesperson Gillian Branstetter @[private account] draws a connection between data center construction and the right’s use of transgender matters as a wedge issue in the midterms:
“The fact that Musk himself is sponsoring so many of the anti-trans ads this cycle presents a pretty golden opportunity for Dems to point out that of course the guy who literally wants to build a gas-powered data center in your backyard wants this election to be about trans people,” Branstetter says.
Gordon Guyatt, who faced intense pressure from transgender activists after his renowned lab published a series of systematic literature reviews about gender-transition interventions for youths early last year, takes another step into the trans-advocacy arena, expressing enthusiasm about a paper that lambasts the use of evidence-based medicine principles to cast doubt on pediatric gender medicine.
Skeptics of this field have reacted to Guyatt’s heel turn with dismay, accusing him of betraying the fundamental principles of evidence based medicine, a discipline he helped found, by putting his finger on the scale of a contested medical issue.
Quotes a post by T03939; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
McBride called for moderation in a conversation with @[private account]. Such remarks have led transgender activists to condemn her as a traitor by the dominant voices on Bluesky.
Quoting @benryanwriter: This video with @SarahEMcBride in conversation with @[private account] for @[private account], has now been posted: https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/rep-sarah-mcbride-does-not-want-to.
Key Democrats running in highly competitive races have hedged on a few key trans issues, namely in their expressed opposition to cross-sex participation in sports and gender-transition treatment for minors.
On Bluesky, these shifts have been perceived as assertion that trans people have no right to exist writ large and as the beginning of a slippery slope that some have called a march toward genocide.
This despite the fact that these Democrats have not changed their positions on adults’ right to transition or trans people’s access to preferred bathrooms.
Meanwhile, Rep. Sarah McBride, the first openly transgender member of Congress, has argued in opposition to the far-left positions that dominate on Bluesky. She has called for wider tolerance among Dems of positions that are otherwise considered utter heresy by trans activists.
More signs that even transgender people are starting to sour on Erin Reed:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Bluesky has been steadily souring on transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed in recent months, with posters calling her out for shoddy, erroneous reporting, and now for advocating sacrificing vital Democratic seats in favor of hardline policies on trans issues. In the back foot, at least theoretically, she is not backing down, saying:
“The vitriol directed at me and other members of the trans community for having the audacity to declare our votes are not to be taken for granted.
“By cisgender people who otherwise have called themselves allies.
“I wish it weren’t so utterly predictable.”
In a Substack, @ACLU spokesperson @[private account] explains why transgender activists such as herself insist upon maximalist positions and decry Democratic politicians making any concessions regarding the principle tenets of the movement.
Branstetter expresses concern of a slippery slope and a mistrust of liberal politicians remaining on the side of the trans movement while well-funded conservative campaigns plan to keep advancing policies that ever encroach upon the movement.
What do y’all think of what she wrote?
Quoting @benryanwriter: On Bluesky, Will Stancil lambasts transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed for her hardline policies on Democratic politicians’ stance on trans issues. Reed said it was better that Republicans should win than Dems give even an inch on such matters. Stancil said he was “shocked by this.” He called it “Unbelievably foolish, short-sighted, self-sabotaging nonsense.”
He continued: “I'd argue that there are certain viewpoints and claims that are so ill-conceived and detached from reality that they should be discrediting for the person who is making them. ‘We must defeat Democrats in swing states, in 2026, to teach Third Way a lesson about moderation’ is easily on that list.”
People on X routinely accuse anyone who has anything to say, for good or bad, about transgender children of pedophilia. Vance continues the tradition:
Quoting @Acyn: Vance on Talarico: A guy that age who was so obsessed and focused on transgender children. I don't know about you, but I never want to see that guy's web browser history.
In the eyes of many activists on the left, there are no downsides to or tradeoffs from including those born male in girls and women’s sports. So when any politician opposes such inclusion, such activists invariably do not see this as genuinely representing an effort on the politician’s part to protect the rights of girls and women. They only see it as a craven political move meant to exploit a political wedge issue at the expense of a vulnerable minority.
Hence, instead of acknowledging that, for example, there is scientific evidence suggesting that even sustained treatment with hormone blockers and estrogen does not fully erase the competitive advantage of male puberty, such activists only see the issue from the perspective of trans people’s civil rights. Exclusion is part of a larger genocidal project, they think. Walker Bragman, for one, does not believe this research is valid; so there is that dimension to the argument as well.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Bluesky has been steadily souring on transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed in recent months, with posters calling her out for shoddy, erroneous reporting, and now for advocating sacrificing vital Democratic seats in favor of hardline policies on trans issues. In the back foot, at least theoretically, she is not backing down, saying:
“The vitriol directed at me and other members of the trans community for having the audacity to declare our votes are not to be taken for granted.
“By cisgender people who otherwise have called themselves allies.
“I wish it weren’t so utterly predictable.”
Bluesky has been steadily souring on transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed in recent months, with posters calling her out for shoddy, erroneous reporting, and now for advocating sacrificing vital Democratic seats in favor of hardline policies on trans issues. In the back foot, at least theoretically, she is not backing down, saying:
“The vitriol directed at me and other members of the trans community for having the audacity to declare our votes are not to be taken for granted.
“By cisgender people who otherwise have called themselves allies.
“I wish it weren’t so utterly predictable.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: On Bluesky, Will Stancil lambasts transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed for her hardline policies on Democratic politicians’ stance on trans issues. Reed said it was better that Republicans should win than Dems give even an inch on such matters. Stancil said he was “shocked by this.” He called it “Unbelievably foolish, short-sighted, self-sabotaging nonsense.”
He continued: “I'd argue that there are certain viewpoints and claims that are so ill-conceived and detached from reality that they should be discrediting for the person who is making them. ‘We must defeat Democrats in swing states, in 2026, to teach Third Way a lesson about moderation’ is easily on that list.”
In response to Will Stancil’s scathing criticism of her zero-tolerance policy on Dems giving an inch on trans issues, Erin Reed stood her ground, saying:
“I stand by my post here. I’ve watched us go from one or two local dems to 26 national and statewide dems embracing anti-trans views, with some embracing REALLY bad ones. And I’ve watched what happens when you don’t cut that cancer out. One thing though: do present my side fairly please. In the post you see there, I advocate for not voting for the WORST of the offenders. Where you draw that line is up to you. For me, a candidate calling me a man and advocating for care bans and funding bans, such as Turek, crosses that line.”
On Bluesky, Will Stancil lambasts transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed for her hardline policies on Democratic politicians’ stance on trans issues. Reed said it was better that Republicans should win than Dems give even an inch on such matters. Stancil said he was “shocked by this.” He called it “Unbelievably foolish, short-sighted, self-sabotaging nonsense.”
He continued: “I'd argue that there are certain viewpoints and claims that are so ill-conceived and detached from reality that they should be discrediting for the person who is making them. ‘We must defeat Democrats in swing states, in 2026, to teach Third Way a lesson about moderation’ is easily on that list.”
In the wake of Lilly Wachowski accusing Rowling of genocide, @JK_Rowling’s agent, Neil Blair, has issued this statement to Entertainment Weekly:
“Freedom of speech is a principle we should all cherish. What matters is that J.K. Rowling’s views, as with anyone else’s, are represented accurately, fairly and respectfully and that individual opinion does not detract from those views,” Blair said. “To correct Lilly Wachowski, through The J.K. Rowling Women’s Fund, J.K Rowling supports women taking legal action in the UK to preserve their existing rights under the Equality Act 2010, which are often overlooked or threatened. She does not support legal actions aimed at harming transgender people or efforts to limit trans rights.”
Blair added, “People are free to disagree with her views but seriously defamatory allegations of this nature, even outrageously invoking the Nazi’s and the genocide that they committed, should never be presented as fact when they are clearly fabricated and not based on any evidence.”
The statement has only enraged people on Bluesky.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Is it JK Rowling’s personal project to sweepingly exterminate transgender people?
I cannot recommend more highly the UCLA sociologist Rogers Brubaker’s new book, Gender Identity. It is a dispassionate tour de force assessing where this category of personhood came from, how it came to be formalized and institutionalized, and how it possesses a perhaps irreconcilable tension between granting rights and validating individuals’ selfhood on one hand and alienating people and and causing backlash on the other.
From the final page of @[private account]’s book:
“Yet even in the hyperpolarized US, where gender identity has been drawn into the vortex of the culture wars, the controversy over the category ‘gender identity’ cannot be plotted solely on a left-right axis. The recent years of intensifying attacks from the culturally conservative right have also seen the emergence of critiques of gender identity from the culturally liberal center and center-left and from some feminists, gay men and lesbians, and transgender people themselves. The emergence of these critiques - which are compatible with an insistence on the dignity, safety, and rights of transgender people - is a reminder that the controversy over gender identity cannot be reduced to a struggle between progressive defenders of the ‘civil rights issue of our time,’ as President Biden put it, and reactionaries who think transgender people have ‘no right to exist.’ It is a more complex struggle over how to think about sex and gender as principles of vision and division of the world: a struggle over the relation between the sexed body and gendered feelings, between what is given and what can be chosen, between nature and culture. It is ultimately a struggle over the nature and limits of self-determination in an interdependent world.”
In WPATH's Own Videos, Doctors Describe Billing Gender-Transition Care Under Alternative Diagnoses
A psychiatrist called switching to "unspecified endocrine disorder" a way to "work around" the system. A Utah OB-GYN said she billed that way for 14 years. The Trump administration calls such coding fraud.
When New York City’s Mt. Sinai Health System reached a settlement with the Justice Department last week to keep its pediatric gender clinic closed, much of the public debate over why the hospital had capitulated focused on the Trump administration’s efforts to obtain patient records via subpoena. This overlooked the mounting efforts by Republican lawmakers more broadly and the Trump administration in particular to leverage accusations of fraudulent medical billing to target doctors in this field and drum them out of providing gender-transition interventions to minors.
A spokesperson for Mt. Sinai said last week: “The settlement is complex, but at its core reflects Mount Sinai’s commitment to safeguarding our patients’ confidential information and protecting our clinicians.”
Those last few words, protecting our clinicians, at least theoretically could refer to protecting clinicians from prosecution or civil lawsuits for the use of non-gender-identity-related diagnosis and procedure codes when seeking reimbursement for puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones or gender-transition surgeries to treat gender dysphoria in minors.
Last year, I obtained several hundred videos from conferences held by the World Professional Association for Transgender Health and its US affiliate, USPATH, between 2021 and 2023. These videos were subject to a subpoena by the Alabama attorney general, Steve Marshall, as part of his defense in a lawsuit against the state’s ban on gender-transition interventions for minors. I covered how these videos portrayed the besieged field of pediatric gender medicine in a report for Compact magazine earlier this year and have been serially publishing key videos on my Substack since then.
I have newly scoured these videos for conference speakers addressing the use of alternative procedure or diagnosis coding in transgender care. I found a number of examples, video clips of which I have published and analyzed below. None of them included speakers specifically referring to minors in the moments when they made such references to coding choices, mind you. But in at least some cases, the wider context of their presentations or their response to audience questions did not rule out that minors could be included in what they were suggesting or recalling about coding practices.
In American medicine, physicians use diagnosis codes from the ICD system, which specify the condition being treated, and procedure codes known as CPT codes, which indicate the actions the physician took to treat the condition. These codes are integral to obtaining reimbursement for services. Insurers require diagnosis codes to serve as an appropriate justification for the corresponding procedure.
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services on Aug. 13 published a scathing report bearing the incendiary title “Wolves In White Coats: How Doctors and Hospitals Pushed and Profited from the Fraud of ‘Gender Medicine.’” Much of the report is devoted to examining how leaders in pediatric gender medicine advocate the use of alternate codes when seeking insurance reimbursement for gender-transition interventions. These practices, the report asserts, have become widespread in this field.
The report serves as an ominous warning to health care providers still practicing in what remains of a field that the Trump administration has seen considerable success in destroying outright.
“When healthcare providers use fraudulent medical coding to obtain payment from the federal government,” the HHS report asserts, “they may be liable under the federal False Claims Act, which carries fines and imposes damages of ‘3 times the amount of damages which the government sustains.’”
To follow federal regulations, the report asserts, physicians treating patients for transgender-related purposes are meant to use a number of ICD diagnosis codes related to gender identity, sex reassignment or “dual role transvestism.”
But it has become common for medical providers to use alternate diagnosis codes, according to the report—in particular those related to endocrine disorders.
This includes, the report states:
“Endocrine disorder, unspecified,” coded as E34.9. Using this code in place of a gender-related diagnosis (e.g., gender identity disorder, F64.0) violates CMS guidelines for the simple reason that gender dysphoria is not an endocrine disorder, since it exhibits no hormonal abnormalities. In fact, the only endocrine disorders these patients have are the ones created by their doctors through the use of sex-rejecting interventions. Yet it appears that healthcare providers are misusing this code. In a 2016 studytitled “Identifying the Transgender Population in the Medicare Program,” CMS’s Office of Minority Health acknowledged that proxy diagnosis codes are being substituted for gender dysphoria. In the methods section, the authors explain that they included the ICD-9 diagnosis code for Unspecified Endocrine Disorder in their analysis because it is “frequently used by the transgender community to combat the perceived stigma of a GID diagnosis.”
The report goes on to note that a 2023 study also finds such use of alternative billing codes.
The report further notes an analysis of medical-claims data by Leor Sapir, a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute who studies pediatric gender medicine, that found an almost 30 percent increase in endocrine disorder, unspecified diagnoses in minors between 2020 and 2022. Dr. Sapir asserted in 2025 that this was likely the product of a “greater willingness” by medical providers to use endocrine disorder codes over gender identity disorder codes in pediatric care of patients with gender dysphoria.
The authors of the HHS report analyzed health insurance databases covering 2015 to 2025 and found that insurers were billed nearly $50 million for puberty blockers for patients age nine to 17 under endocrine disorder codes, excluding precocious puberty. There was nearly $11 million in billing for 13- to 17-year-olds using a precocious puberty diagnosis code.
The report asserts that “this data strongly suggests a pattern of potentially fraudulent billing that relies on miscoding for endocrine disorders to justify the prescription of puberty blockers.”
WPATH, the report goes on to state, has promoted “the misleading use of several ICD-10 codes” in its training presentations.
Teddy Goetz
Dr. Teddy Goetz is a psychiatrist who currently works at the Mid-Atlantic Permanente Medical Group. Dr. Goetz, who identifies as nonbinary, was a coeditor of a controversial text put out by the American Psychiatric Association’s publishing arm in 2023 outlining how to apply the gender-affirming method to the care of what these days are known as gender-expansive patients.
Dr. Goetz spoke at USPATH’s 2021 conference.
The moderator, taking an audience question, asked about how to move away from a distress-based model of care for transgender patients, in which it is required that they harbor distress related to their gender identity to qualify for a diagnosis that will justify gender-transition treatment.
“We can think about it in the terms of billing codes,” Dr. Goetz replied. When a patient first presents, Dr. Goetz said, a doctor could use a gender dysphoria-related billing code to process a prescription for gender-transition treatment such as testosterone. But if this treatment ultimately attenuates the patient’s dysphoria, Dr. Goetz said, “Then you could switch your billing code to ‘unspecified endocrine disorder,’ for example, saying that their body produces less testosterone than it should for them to feel their best. So there are different ways that you can work around that. And thinking about moving towards euphoria and away from dysphoria.”
Addressing a common conundrum that expands well beyond transgender medicine, Dr. Goetz continued: “But our current health care system in the United States is really set up against a preventive health care model and towards more of a responding-to-active-problems model.”
It remained unclear whether Dr. Goetz was referring to treating pediatric patients when describing these billing practices. What is evident, however, is that Dr. Goetz, who at the time was a medical resident at the University of Pennsylvania, was then working at least part of the time at a children’s hospital. At one point during the conference session, Dr. Goetz made a specific reference to “the children’s hospital where I do work in addition to the adult hospital.”
A spokesperson for Kaiser Permanente provided me a statement indicating that “We understand” that Dr. Goetz “was speaking hypothetically” at the conference. “Dr. Goetz is an adult psychiatrist and does not provide care to, nor prescribe puberty blockers or hormone therapy to Kaiser Permanente pediatric patients,” the statement continued.
Bluesky users have issued a torrent of criticism of James Talarico for asserting that sex is binary and that otherwise there are rare cases of DSDs. The general principle that transgender activists and their allies demand politicians espouse is that sex is a spectrum and is fungible. Many researchers disagree.
Is it JK Rowling’s personal project to sweepingly exterminate transgender people?
Quoting @NYMag: Lilly Wachowski didn’t mince words when asked about J.K. Rowling and fans who want to watch HBO’s upcoming ‘Harry Potter’ show. “If you support ‘Harry Potter,’ you’re supporting trans genocide,’ the director said. https://www.thecut.com/article/lilly-wachowski-says-jk-rowling-funds-trans-genocide.html?utm_campaign=nym&utm_medium=s1&utm_source=twitter
A central argument levied by transgender activists, Parker Molloy among them, is that overwhelming public opposition to the principal tenets of this movement is inorganic and is largely or completely the product of cynical persuasion campaigns waged by conservatives.
Senator Ed Markey of Massachusetts responds to James Talarico taking a measured stance against some of the key aims of transgender activism amid a bruising Senate race in Texas:
“In Massachusetts, we have a responsibility to protect the vulnerable and stand up for those who need it. We don’t throw trans kids under the bus for political points. We protect them—and all of our neighbors—because trans rights are human rights.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: Talarico supports a national ban on gender-transition surgeries for minors. However, since the American Society of Plastic Surgeons recommended against its members doing such surgeries earlier this year, reports suggest they have already all but ceased.
On Bluesky, there will be no concessions on the principal aims of transgender advocacy.
Ian Boudreau sums it up:
“People get confused about the trans sports thing because at a glance it seems like a small issue that impacts a very small number of people and thus makes sense as a "reasonable" concession. But it isn't, because conceding that is accepting that a kid's trans identity is on some level fraudulent.”
In response to James Talarico coming out against pediatric gender surgeries and stating a qualified opposition to cross-sex participation into girls’ sports, Imani Gandy posted on Bluesky:
“Team Blue No Matter Who is going to have their work cut out for them because I for one refuse to entertain voting for or even saying nice things about someone who wants to compromise on trans rights.
“Like get the fuck away from me.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: Talarico supports a national ban on gender-transition surgeries for minors. However, since the American Society of Plastic Surgeons recommended against its members doing such surgeries earlier this year, reports suggest they have already all but ceased.
Transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed, responding to James Talarico’s expressed opposition to cross-sex participation in girls’ sports, insists that this does not endanger safety or compromise fairness.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Both @ElonMusk and trans activist Erin Reed have attacked Democratic candidates Sherrod Brown and Josh Turek for their positions on transgender issues, but for opposite reasons.
Both @ElonMusk and trans activist Erin Reed have attacked Democratic candidates Sherrod Brown and Josh Turek for their positions on transgender issues, but for opposite reasons.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed has branded the following politicians anti-trans for defying the movement on any measure. Reed is among the most prominent such activists who subscribes to the maximalist philosophy that there can be zero compromise in this movement.
Reed writes:
Alabama
Shomari Figures, U.S. House, 2nd District (incumbent). Voted yes on Nancy Mace’s NDAA amendments banning gender-affirming care for transgender service members, one of only five Democrats to do so.
Terri Sewell, U.S. House, 7th District (incumbent). Voted yes on Nancy Mace’s NDAA amendments banning gender-affirming care for transgender service members, one of only five Democrats to do so.
Alaska
Mary Peltola, U.S. Senate candidate; former U.S. representative for Alaska’s at-large district. One of only six Democrats to vote for the 2024 NDAA, which contained severe anti-trans and anti-DEI amendments.
California
Xavier Becerra, candidate for governor. In a May interview, argued that nothing in the Constitution entitles transgender people to play sports, and that if “rules don’t let you play a sport because of who you are,” that is acceptable. This is the position the Supreme Court ultimately took.
Adam Gray, U.S. House, 13th District (incumbent). One of only three Democrats to vote for a bathroom ban on military bases for transgender people, along with a sports ban, a gender-affirming care ban, and several other anti-trans amendments to the NDAA.
Indiana
Beau Bayh, candidate for secretary of state. Called transgender women “men,” and said, “I think we should not have men playing women’s sports, and our state has already passed a law outlawing this.”
Iowa
Josh Turek, U.S. Senate nominee. Actively opposes transgender participation in sports, on the record.
Rob Sand, Democratic nominee for governor. Actively opposes transgender participation in sports, answering “no” when a conservative radio host asked whether “biological males” should play women’s sports.
Sarah Trone Garriott, U.S. House candidate, 3rd District. Running an anti-transgender ad stating that she “opposes letting men in women’s locker rooms” and that “politicians have become too extreme on these issues.”
Louisiana
Cleo Fields, U.S. House, 6th District (incumbent). Voted for the “Stopping Indoctrination and Protecting Kids Act,” which would strip funding from schools that support transgender people, along with several other anti-trans bills.
Mississippi
Jeffrey Hulum III, Democratic nominee for the U.S. House, 4th District; currently a state representative for District 119. In the Legislature, he voted for Mississippi’s anti-trans incarceration bill.
Nevada
Aaron Ford, candidate for governor. Stated, “I personally do not support trans athletes competing in sports opposite their gender assigned at birth.”
Susie Lee, U.S. House, 3rd District (incumbent). Explicitly voted for Nancy Mace’s military trans sports ban amendment in the FY2026 NDAA.
New York
Tom Suozzi, U.S. House, 3rd District (incumbent). Blamed transgender people for Harris’s loss and voted for a trans sports ban in the military.
Laura Gillen, U.S. House, 4th District (incumbent). Voted for the “Stopping Indoctrination and Protecting Kids Act,” which would strip funding from schools that support transgender people, along with several other anti-trans bills.
John Mannion, U.S. House, 22nd District (incumbent). Explicitly voted for Nancy Mace’s military trans sports ban amendment in the FY2026 NDAA.
North Carolina
Don Davis, U.S. House, 1st District (incumbent). Voted for Nancy Mace’s amendments barring TRICARE coverage of transgender care for service members and dependents, a sports ban, and the “Don’t Say Trans” bill. He also voted yes on Marjorie Taylor Greene’s bill criminalizing gender-affirming care.
Ohio
Sherrod Brown, U.S. Senate candidate; former U.S. senator for Ohio. Released an ad in 2024 featuring Lia Thomas’s picture, stating that the practice had “already been banned in Ohio” and that Brown would not “let transgender biological men participate in women’s sports.”
Amy Acton, Democratic nominee for governor Affirmed her support for Ohio’s trans sports ban and called transgender girls “boys,” then skipped the listening session her own campaign scheduled with local transgender advocates.
Marcy Kaptur, U.S. House, 9th District (incumbent). Voted for the “Stopping Indoctrination and Protecting Kids Act,” which would strip funding from schools that support transgender people, along with several other anti-trans bills.
Texas
Henry Cuellar, U.S. House, 28th District (incumbent). A stalwart opponent of transgender rights in Congress, voting for nearly every anti-trans bill or provision.
Colin Allred, U.S. House candidate, 33rd District. Released a campaign ad in 2024 saying he “didn’t want boys playing in girls sports.”
Vicente Gonzalez, U.S. House, 34th District (incumbent). A stalwart opponent of transgender rights in Congress, voting for nearly every anti-trans bill or provision.
Virginia
Eugene Vindman, U.S. House, 7th District (incumbent). Voted for the “Stopping Indoctrination and Protecting Kids Act,” which would strip funding from schools that support transgender people, along with several other anti-trans bills.
Washington
Marie Gluesenkamp Perez, U.S. House, 3rd District (incumbent). Criticized Democrats for framing trans sports bans as “about love vs. hate,” saying “we miss some of the nuance,” and has taken multiple anti-trans votes, including a vote to defund public schools that support transgender people.
Kim Schrier, U.S. House, 8th District (incumbent). Voted for the trans sports ban amendment to the NDAA in Congress.
Transgender activist-Substacker Erin Reed has branded the following politicians anti-trans for defying the movement on any measure. Reed is among the most prominent such activists who subscribes to the maximalist philosophy that there can be zero compromise in this movement.
Reed writes:
Alabama
Shomari Figures, U.S. House, 2nd District (incumbent). Voted yes on Nancy Mace’s NDAA amendments banning gender-affirming care for transgender service members, one of only five Democrats to do so.
Terri Sewell, U.S. House, 7th District (incumbent). Voted yes on Nancy Mace’s NDAA amendments banning gender-affirming care for transgender service members, one of only five Democrats to do so.
Alaska
Mary Peltola, U.S. Senate candidate; former U.S. representative for Alaska’s at-large district. One of only six Democrats to vote for the 2024 NDAA, which contained severe anti-trans and anti-DEI amendments.
California
Xavier Becerra, candidate for governor. In a May interview, argued that nothing in the Constitution entitles transgender people to play sports, and that if “rules don’t let you play a sport because of who you are,” that is acceptable. This is the position the Supreme Court ultimately took.
Adam Gray, U.S. House, 13th District (incumbent). One of only three Democrats to vote for a bathroom ban on military bases for transgender people, along with a sports ban, a gender-affirming care ban, and several other anti-trans amendments to the NDAA.
Indiana
Beau Bayh, candidate for secretary of state. Called transgender women “men,” and said, “I think we should not have men playing women’s sports, and our state has already passed a law outlawing this.”
Iowa
Josh Turek, U.S. Senate nominee. Actively opposes transgender participation in sports, on the record.
Rob Sand, Democratic nominee for governor. Actively opposes transgender participation in sports, answering “no” when a conservative radio host asked whether “biological males” should play women’s sports.
Sarah Trone Garriott, U.S. House candidate, 3rd District. Running an anti-transgender ad stating that she “opposes letting men in women’s locker rooms” and that “politicians have become too extreme on these issues.”
Louisiana
Cleo Fields, U.S. House, 6th District (incumbent). Voted for the “Stopping Indoctrination and Protecting Kids Act,” which would strip funding from schools that support transgender people, along with several other anti-trans bills.
Mississippi
Jeffrey Hulum III, Democratic nominee for the U.S. House, 4th District; currently a state representative for District 119. In the Legislature, he voted for Mississippi’s anti-trans incarceration bill.
Nevada
Aaron Ford, candidate for governor. Stated, “I personally do not support trans athletes competing in sports opposite their gender assigned at birth.”
Susie Lee, U.S. House, 3rd District (incumbent). Explicitly voted for Nancy Mace’s military trans sports ban amendment in the FY2026 NDAA.
New York
Tom Suozzi, U.S. House, 3rd District (incumbent). Blamed transgender people for Harris’s loss and voted for a trans sports ban in the military.
Laura Gillen, U.S. House, 4th District (incumbent). Voted for the “Stopping Indoctrination and Protecting Kids Act,” which would strip funding from schools that support transgender people, along with several other anti-trans bills.
John Mannion, U.S. House, 22nd District (incumbent). Explicitly voted for Nancy Mace’s military trans sports ban amendment in the FY2026 NDAA.
North Carolina
Don Davis, U.S. House, 1st District (incumbent). Voted for Nancy Mace’s amendments barring TRICARE coverage of transgender care for service members and dependents, a sports ban, and the “Don’t Say Trans” bill. He also voted yes on Marjorie Taylor Greene’s bill criminalizing gender-affirming care.
Ohio
Sherrod Brown, U.S. Senate candidate; former U.S. senator for Ohio. Released an ad in 2024 featuring Lia Thomas’s picture, stating that the practice had “already been banned in Ohio” and that Brown would not “let transgender biological men participate in women’s sports.”
Amy Acton, Democratic nominee for governor Affirmed her support for Ohio’s trans sports ban and called transgender girls “boys,” then skipped the listening session her own campaign scheduled with local transgender advocates.
Marcy Kaptur, U.S. House, 9th District (incumbent). Voted for the “Stopping Indoctrination and Protecting Kids Act,” which would strip funding from schools that support transgender people, along with several other anti-trans bills.
Texas
Henry Cuellar, U.S. House, 28th District (incumbent). A stalwart opponent of transgender rights in Congress, voting for nearly every anti-trans bill or provision.
Colin Allred, U.S. House candidate, 33rd District. Released a campaign ad in 2024 saying he “didn’t want boys playing in girls sports.”
Vicente Gonzalez, U.S. House, 34th District (incumbent). A stalwart opponent of transgender rights in Congress, voting for nearly every anti-trans bill or provision.
Virginia
Eugene Vindman, U.S. House, 7th District (incumbent). Voted for the “Stopping Indoctrination and Protecting Kids Act,” which would strip funding from schools that support transgender people, along with several other anti-trans bills.
Washington
Marie Gluesenkamp Perez, U.S. House, 3rd District (incumbent). Criticized Democrats for framing trans sports bans as “about love vs. hate,” saying “we miss some of the nuance,” and has taken multiple anti-trans votes, including a vote to defund public schools that support transgender people.
Kim Schrier, U.S. House, 8th District (incumbent). Voted for the trans sports ban amendment to the NDAA in Congress.
They actually did not. In Hecox/BPJ, they all ruled that Title IX excludes trans females for the purpose of sports. They ruled that sex under the statute refers to biological sex.
One thing that’s amazing about the response from trans activists and their allies to the Mt Sinai settlement is almost all the blame has been put on the hospital. Almost no one has said: “Wow, the Trump administration really must’ve had Mt Sinai over a barrel to get them to capitulate like this, all things considered.” Almost everyone thinks the hospital is being craven and cowardly. Make of that what you will.
Quoting @benryanwriter: BREAKING: Major New York Hospital Settles With DoJ Over Youth Gender Clinic, Keeps It Shuttered
Substack link: https://benryan.substack.com/p/major-new-york-hospital-settles-with
Given Mt. Sinai Health System had a large pediatric gender clinic and is in a blue state with a supportive attorney general, this settlement serves as a grim harbinger for this beleaguered field.
Mt. Sinai Health System in New York City, which until early this year operated a substantial pediatric gender clinic, has reached a settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice in which it will keep the clinic shuttered, pay a monetary penalty, and provide treatment to those who were harmed by gender-transition interventions they received as minors.
Given Mt. Sinai operates in a Democrat-led state with an attorney general, Letitia James, who is broadly supportive of gender-transition interventions for minors, this settlement serves as an ominous harbinger for what remains of the embattled field of pediatric gender medicine as the Trump admin has sought to destroy it.
According to an analysis of medical billing records conducted by the nonprofit Do No Harm, which opposes pediatric gender medicine, Mt. Sinai’s billing for related services was in recent years the highest in the nation.
While the precise details that triggered the settlement remain opaque, the Trump administration had apparently accused Mt. Sinai that it had violated federal law by submitting fraudulent billing codes for gender-transition interventions.
Mt. Sinai has agreed to pay an undisclosed monetary penalty and to dedicate $2 million to patients who, in the words of a Justice Department release on the settlement, have suffered “harmful consequences” of the gender-transition interventions they received as minors.
“In working towards this resolution,” the release states, “the United States acknowledged that Mount Sinai took significant steps entitling it to credit for cooperation with the Department in its investigation. At all times during the investigation, Mount Sinai remained cooperative, proactive, and solution-driven, as evidenced by its multimillion-dollar commitment to detransition care.”
“The Department of Justice is committed to holding accountable medical providers that violate federal law and endanger children through so-called gender-affirming care,” Attorney General Todd Blanche @AGToddBlanche said in a statement. “This agreement puts an end to these practices at Mount Sinai and provides meaningful relief for individuals who have already suffered harm.”
I got a quote from @BradLander, who is the former NYC comptroller and the Democratic nominee to replace @[private account] in New York's 10th congressional district, on the deal Mt. Sinai cut with the DoJ to keep its pediatric gender clinic closed:
“Gender-affirming care saves lives, respects the rights of patients, and reflects that health-care is supposed to be between providers and patients, not between providers and the Trump Administration," Mr. Lander said.
"I recently met with families of trans kids, some of whom moved to New York because of our legacy of inclusion, who now feel like refugees forced to look for a new home that will protect their kids’ well-being. Shame on Mt. Sinai for capitulating with this settlement, which violates that legacy of inclusion, their own Hippocratic oath, and New York’s human rights laws.”
I wrote the following in response to Mr. Lander's press contact:
"Note, however, that only one study has ever directly assessed whether there was an independent, statistically significant difference in the suicide death rate based on whether youths attending gender clinics received cross-sex hormone treatment. Conducted based on comprehensive national health records in Finland, the 2024 study found no such association."
I'll let you know if Mr. Lander's office replies.
Quoting @benryanwriter: BREAKING: Major New York Hospital Settles With DoJ Over Youth Gender Clinic, Keeps It Shuttered
Substack link: https://benryan.substack.com/p/major-new-york-hospital-settles-with
Given Mt. Sinai Health System had a large pediatric gender clinic and is in a blue state with a supportive attorney general, this settlement serves as a grim harbinger for this beleaguered field.
Mt. Sinai Health System in New York City, which until early this year operated a substantial pediatric gender clinic, has reached a settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice in which it will keep the clinic shuttered, pay a monetary penalty, and provide treatment to those who were harmed by gender-transition interventions they received as minors.
Given Mt. Sinai operates in a Democrat-led state with an attorney general, Letitia James, who is broadly supportive of gender-transition interventions for minors, this settlement serves as an ominous harbinger for what remains of the embattled field of pediatric gender medicine as the Trump admin has sought to destroy it.
According to an analysis of medical billing records conducted by the nonprofit Do No Harm, which opposes pediatric gender medicine, Mt. Sinai’s billing for related services was in recent years the highest in the nation.
While the precise details that triggered the settlement remain opaque, the Trump administration had apparently accused Mt. Sinai that it had violated federal law by submitting fraudulent billing codes for gender-transition interventions.
Mt. Sinai has agreed to pay an undisclosed monetary penalty and to dedicate $2 million to patients who, in the words of a Justice Department release on the settlement, have suffered “harmful consequences” of the gender-transition interventions they received as minors.
“In working towards this resolution,” the release states, “the United States acknowledged that Mount Sinai took significant steps entitling it to credit for cooperation with the Department in its investigation. At all times during the investigation, Mount Sinai remained cooperative, proactive, and solution-driven, as evidenced by its multimillion-dollar commitment to detransition care.”
“The Department of Justice is committed to holding accountable medical providers that violate federal law and endanger children through so-called gender-affirming care,” Attorney General Todd Blanche @AGToddBlanche said in a statement. “This agreement puts an end to these practices at Mount Sinai and provides meaningful relief for individuals who have already suffered harm.”
A back and forth between Bluesky and trans activists and Republican officials over the shuttering of the Mt Sinai pediatric gender clinic and the larger Trump administration project against the signature aims of transgender advocacy:
Quoting @benryanwriter: BREAKING: Major New York Hospital Settles With DoJ Over Youth Gender Clinic, Keeps It Shuttered
Substack link: https://benryan.substack.com/p/major-new-york-hospital-settles-with
Given Mt. Sinai Health System had a large pediatric gender clinic and is in a blue state with a supportive attorney general, this settlement serves as a grim harbinger for this beleaguered field.
Mt. Sinai Health System in New York City, which until early this year operated a substantial pediatric gender clinic, has reached a settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice in which it will keep the clinic shuttered, pay a monetary penalty, and provide treatment to those who were harmed by gender-transition interventions they received as minors.
Given Mt. Sinai operates in a Democrat-led state with an attorney general, Letitia James, who is broadly supportive of gender-transition interventions for minors, this settlement serves as an ominous harbinger for what remains of the embattled field of pediatric gender medicine as the Trump admin has sought to destroy it.
According to an analysis of medical billing records conducted by the nonprofit Do No Harm, which opposes pediatric gender medicine, Mt. Sinai’s billing for related services was in recent years the highest in the nation.
While the precise details that triggered the settlement remain opaque, the Trump administration had apparently accused Mt. Sinai that it had violated federal law by submitting fraudulent billing codes for gender-transition interventions.
Mt. Sinai has agreed to pay an undisclosed monetary penalty and to dedicate $2 million to patients who, in the words of a Justice Department release on the settlement, have suffered “harmful consequences” of the gender-transition interventions they received as minors.
“In working towards this resolution,” the release states, “the United States acknowledged that Mount Sinai took significant steps entitling it to credit for cooperation with the Department in its investigation. At all times during the investigation, Mount Sinai remained cooperative, proactive, and solution-driven, as evidenced by its multimillion-dollar commitment to detransition care.”
“The Department of Justice is committed to holding accountable medical providers that violate federal law and endanger children through so-called gender-affirming care,” Attorney General Todd Blanche @AGToddBlanche said in a statement. “This agreement puts an end to these practices at Mount Sinai and provides meaningful relief for individuals who have already suffered harm.”
The Guardian repeats the zombie statistic that was a product of activist-Substacker Erin Reed’s misreading of multiple data sets—that 400,000 transgender people have fled red states since the 2024 election. There is almost no chance this statistic is correct. And yet the Washington Post and now The Guardian have repeated it without verifying the statistic.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Guardian makes false or unsupported claims about pediatric gender medicine.
No one has ever surveyed American doctors about their support for this field. While most medical societies support it, that support is not based on a vote by members. The American Academy of Pediatrics has gone to great lengths to thwart efforts by dissident members to put the matter to a vote.
Gender treatments do not “demonstrably” reduce suicide, because no study has ever shown such an effect. Only one study has ever directly assessed whether giving cross-sex hormones to treat gender dysphoria in youths was associated with a lower suicide death rate. Based on comprehensive Finnish health records and published in 2024, the study found no such association. It found that while elevated among youth attending gender clinics, suicide death remained rare.
I get the same vapid as hominem attacks about my reporting about transgender issues: that they are based on an “obsession.” People such as yourself make these underhanded accusations because you can’t argue on the substance. Read my work, engage with it, and come up with a real response that isn’t a base schoolyard insult or accusation.
States Sue Over Move to End to Federal Funds for Youth Gender Transition Treatment
The Trump administration wants to bar Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program from paying for gender-transition medication and surgery for transgender adolescents.
Twenty-one states led by Democrats sued on Wednesday to block a Department of Health and Human Services plan to bar federal payments from Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program for gender-transition medication and surgery to transgender adolescents.
The new rule, announced last month, is set to go into effect in October.
The lawsuit, filed in federal court in Massachusetts, argues that the new rule oversteps the Trump administration’s authority and fails to justify its restrictions. The suit said the rule violates the law by blocking reimbursements for treatments that some states have determined to be medically necessary.
“We will not stand by as the Trump administration oversteps its authority and twists the facts to justify its bad-faith agenda against transgender Americans,’’ Rob Bonta, the attorney general of California, said in a statement. “We will continue to fight to secure access to medically necessary care and protect transgender individuals’ abilities to prosper as their authentic selves.”
Gift link: https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/02/us/politics/youth-gender-transition-lawsuit-federal-money.html?unlocked_article_code=1.-FA.OHFp.h7fmb6B9g3yu&smid=nytcore-ios-share
In a viral Bluesky post, The Verge asserts: “As a new Harry Potter trailer makes the rounds, it bears repeating that there’s no way to watch this show without supporting J.K. Rowling’s bigotry and the structural violence she’s inflicting on the trans community.”
A @WSJ report last year found that the business of Harry Potter continues to boom, efforts to protest @JK_Rowling over her statements about sex and gender issues notwithstanding.
Rep. Sarah McBride Says Dems Are "Rightfully Moving Away" From Telling Voters They Are "Bad People" For Holding Heterodox Positions On Trans Issues
In an interview today with @[private account] of @[private account], Rep @SarahEMcBride, the first openly transgender member of Congress, said Democratic candidates running in states like Ohio or Iowa "should articulate what their genuine position is on" transgender issues, "and that is ultimately going to result in many of these candidates in red states having heterodox positions on specific policies, whether it be gender or guns." She continued: "That truth can also coexist with the truth that we need to be respectful of one another."
Rep. McBride said:
"I think the challenge for us before, which I think we're rightfully moving away from, is that for too many voters, they interpreted the way our our coalition [the Democrats] talked about a lot of these issues as a sign that we thought they were bad people, that we did not like them or respect them, and I think we are rightfully moving away from that. And I think it's both demonstrating in real time to these voters who might disagree with me on a lot of issues.
"That just because we disagree, I do not think they're a bad person. In fact, I value them as neighbors. I want to be in conversation with them. That is pluralism in practice. That is democracy in practice. And in so doing, I think it makes them care about those issues less because it makes them realize that if I don't believe that their particular position on any specific policy is going to determine whether I think they're good or bad, then they aren't going to misinterpret that issue as the top priority for me or my party."
Asked by Lakshya Jain about Amy Acton in Ohio or like Rob Sand in Iowa, each of whom have expressed opposition to cross-sex sports participation (much to the fury of hardline trans activists like Erin Reed), Rep. McBride said:
"I think two truths can exist here as these candidates navigate terrain that is far more conservative than the terrain I'm navigating on the whole in Delaware. The first is that candidates should run based on what they genuinely believe and feel. I mean, I think they should they should they should articulate what their genuine position is on this, and that is ultimately going to result in many of these candidates in red states having heterodox positions on specific policies, whether it be gender or guns, the the list goes on. That truth can also coexist with the truth that we need to be respectful of one another. That doesn't just mean respectful in the debate; it also means respectful in how we're talking about the communities impacted by these policies, and it would be my hope, as I have articulated to candidates that I have spoken with, that regardless of whether you agree with me on individual policy positions, that let us let us all speak about the people that we are seeking to represent, and that includes LGBTQ people with respect."
Zero-tolerance policies on trans inclusion in women’s sports has collided with hardening public opinion. The most prominent trans activists will tolerate no dissension, for fear of a slippery slope. But has this ardent opposition fomented a backlash that has fulfilled that fear?
Quotes a post by T06999; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Regardless, it is unlikely that trans issues were central to Markey’s victory, should he prevail. It’s more that deep-blue Massachusetts prefers a progressive candidate in general compared with a moderate one.
Expect transgender activists to react with delight should Rep Seth Moulton lose the Democratic primary for Senate in Massachusetts as hard as he is expected to. Erin Reed has already started celebrating, even with 1% of votes tallied. Moulton expressed misgivings about biological males participating in girls’ sports and trans activists and their allies reacted with abject fury.
Reed’s claim that Moulton “made targeting trans people a centerpiece of his post-2024 positioning” is wildly hyperbolic. He made a remark on the subject to NYT about sports in Nov 2024 and later defended it. More recently, he has been compelled to walk back his remarks. But none of this was how he sought to center his political identity; it was just the most controversial thing he said, so it became central in the minds of at least some of the public.
Moulton cosponsored the Transgender Bill of Rights and the Equality Act, voted against the House Republican bill barring cross-sex participation in school sports in spring 2024, and has a 100 percent HRC rating.
The majority of Americans, including most Democrats in at least some polls, agree with Moulton’s concerns about cross-sex participation in sports.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The people of Worcester, MA are no fan of Seth Moulton.
Left-wing pundit and @[private account] contributor Katelyn Burns predicts Seth Moulton will go down in flames in today’s Democratic primary as the congressman faces the incumbent, Senator Ed Markey. Rep Moulton has infuriated transgender activists for questioning the fairness of cross-sex participation in girls’ sports. The congressman has posted dismal polling stats.
The latest in the battle over trans inclusion in sports:
Minnesota Lynx head coach Cheryl Reeve is sporting a “Trans Kids Belong” shirt during the game against the Fever today. The Fever player Sophie Cunningham recently came out as opposed to cross-sex participation into girls' and women's sports. Then a co-owner of the Seattle Storm was suspended for 5 games by the WNBA for confronting two girls at a game who were sporting T-shirts opposed to cross-sex participation.
Ken Jennings speaks out: “I stand with my trans friends.”
After igniting a firestorm of anger on Bluesky after he was accused of transphobia for using NYT Games and then reacting with snark to being dragged over it, Ken Jennings has addressed the controversy.
“I don’t think there’s an issue today I care about on a personal level more deeply than trans rights. And it’s rough out there right now. Bigots on one side of the political aisle and too many cowards on the other,” Jennings insists, seeking to distance himself from right-wing forces who presumed he might be aligned with their, as he sees it, transphobic takes on this issue.
He continues:
“Anyone who knows me even a little, or has even followed me long on social media, already knows this about me. Our institutions are literally trying to erase trans people right now, and it pisses me off. A snarky reply to one bad take on Bluesky doesn’t mean that’s changed at all.
“My TV job is apolitical, but I’m proud that one of the things we make is a space that’s trans- and nb-friendly, and that’s not going to change either.
“So that’s the thing to know, if you’re a tabloid that’s going to name-check me in another round of transphobic shit about Bluesky discourse. I don’t stand with you. I stand with my trans friends and family members.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: There is an uproar on Bluesky after Ken Jennings issued a snarky reply to a trans woman, Gwen Pepperoni, dragging him for playing NYT Games, which she said was “an insult to trans people.”
Jennings replied: “This may be true of others but I actually got express permission from the trans community to keep NYT games and recipes. I also have a news subscription, which is arguably worse, so I had to specifically send in a written request. Took 30 days but I got approved.”
An eruption of anger ensued. Jennings was told to fuck off, that he’s tone deaf, that he was essentially giving himself a pass to say the N word, that he doesn’t have to suck, and so on.
This after Jennings tangled with Jesse Singal over pediatric gender medicine earlier this year and was pronounced a hero by the trans community on Bluesky.
Trans activists believe that to remain faithful to the cause you cannot have anything to do with the Times. So anyone who even plays Spelling Bee is by extension aiding a trans genocide.
Amnesty International's UK arm has apologized and retracted its claims after declaring that a roster of gender-critical groups were hate groups, including a Scottish sexual-violence support shelter founded by @JK_Rowling. JK Rowling launched a campaign to sue and financially support lawsuits against Amnesty by others in the wake of the list's publication.
Amnesty's retreat has enraged transgender activists, who have accused Rowling of engaging in lawfare and silencing debate. Those criticizing Amnesty have lodged similar accusations at the organization, accusing it of using its heft to silence people expressing genuine concerns about women's safety and the treatment of vulnerable children with gender-related distress.
Amnesty's move follows the Southern Poverty Law Center declaring various groups that express skepticism about pediatric gender medicine as hate groups, including @SEGM_EBM
Amnesty UK writes:
An Apology for A Growing Threat briefing, published on 8 July 2026
We apologise for the publication of the briefing “A growing threat: the anti-rights movement in the UK.” This document should never have been published, and full responsibility for this error rests with Amnesty International UK.
The briefing was taken down within 48 hours of publication, as soon as management were notified of its existence, was not actively promoted, and will not be republished. We have an ongoing internal investigation into how this briefing came to be published.
Whilst we do not share the views of all these organisations, we recognise the concerns raised by those labelled as “anti-rights” in the document. To be clear: this labelling does not represent our institutional position, and we apologise for its inclusion. In particular, we apologise to Beira’s Place and other groups, which we categorised as gender critical organisations, which we should not have collectively labelled as anti-rights. We have also taken down an earlier more discursive briefing (entitled Like A Snowball) which also referenced a wide range of organisations.
AIUK holds itself to the highest standards of research, evidence and editorial oversight in all its publications. We have concluded that this briefing fell significantly short of those standards. We will commission an independent external review to learn from this moment.
AIUK remains fully committed to defending the human rights, dignity, and equality of all marginalised groups, including women, girls, and members of the trans community.
31 July 2026
A prevailing theme on the left in the discourse about transgender issues is that people are forbidden to ask questions, and anyone who does ask questions is presumed to be operating in bad faith and is told to sit down, shut up, and fall in line.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Progressive journalist Imani Gandy insists that there “is no good faith concern” about biological males participating in girls and women’s sports. “None.” Anyone who expresses concern about the subject, she insists, is at minimum an unwilling puppet of a political project. Those who do not have concerns, she says, are the “normal people.”
“You can't have good faith concerns about a few dozen people playing fucking sports. Shut up and stop it.”
There is exactly one study that directly addresses that question and I was the only one to cover it: https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
Some people don’t even bother to hide their antisemitism anymore. Sean M. Brooks, a former educator, penned a rant on Substack about a set of transgender dolls and sneeringly pointed out that both the creators were Jews. When I asked why he did that, he said: “Who created transgenderism dipshit? Answer that question and then have a seat.” In other words, he’s giving voice to the age-old stereotype of Jews being part of a nefarious global cabal.
'More Hair, Less Hair, Larger Boobs, Less Boobs, No Boobs' How the 'Embodiment Goals' Premise Is Taking Over Youth Gender Medicine
https://benryan.substack.com/p/more-hair-less-hair-larger-boobs
At the 2022 WPATH conference, trans providers dismissed the gender binary a "project of colonialism" and looked witheringly upon psych assessments for youths seeking gender-transition interventions.
The poll in question, which relied on a very small sample to come up with the 9% figure, did not say that that percentage of trans people *fled red states*. It said that 9% of trans respondents to the poll *moved from any state to any state*.
This is not to say that trans people are not fleeing red states. There is obviously plenty of impetus to do so. But one cannot rely so heavily on this weak and vague bit of polling data to conclude that anywhere between 140,000 (as Liberal Currents claims) to 400,000 (as Erin Reed and subsequently the Washington Post claimed) trans people have fled red states since Trump retook the White House.
Funding for the global HIV response plunged in 2025, with devastating consequences
Declines in US disbursements drove an unprecedented 25% drop in funding from donor governments, putting decades of progress at risk
27 July 2026 (Rio de Janeiro, Brazil) – Funding for the global HIV response plunged in 2025 – entirely due to a steep decline in US support – putting decades of progress at risk, according to reports from UNAIDS and KFF released at AIDS 2026, the 26th International AIDS Conference.
Convened by IAS – the International AIDS Society – AIDS 2026 opened in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, bringing together approximately 7,000 scientists, policy makers, healthcare providers, funders and people living with and affected by HIV from around the world.
At a press briefing ahead of the opening session, global health leaders called on donor governments to sustain robust support for the HIV response, and on low- and middle-income countries to continue stepping up their own investments where possible.
“We come to Rio de Janeiro at a moment of real danger for the HIV response,” Beatriz Grinsztejn, IAS President and AIDS 2026 International Co-Chair, said. “Never has donor funding fallen so far, so fast, and those most vulnerable are already paying the price. Donor countries are choosing to walk away while many high-burden countries remain shackled by debt they cannot escape. We must rethink outdated models, rebuild whathas been broken, and rise to ensure the response gets the resources it needs.”
The first report, from KFF and UNAIDS, found that the 25% decline in donor government funding marks the largest single-year drop since international funding scale-up began, driven by funding delays and project cancellations tied to changes in the US global health response last year.
The second report, from UNAIDS, published alongside the analysis, found that domestic HIV financing increased by 4% in 2025, accounting for nearly 60% of total HIV funding, as countries worked to offset declines in international support. More than 55 countries have committed to increasing domestic HIV investments in 2026.
The report also found that in 2025, there were 1.2 million new HIV acquisitions and 570,000 AIDS-related deaths as the world fell short of its global AIDS targets. New HIV acquisitions are rising in many countries, including Brazil, Pakistan, the Philippines and Madagascar. At the same time, countries such as Kenya, Lesotho, Rwanda, Zimbabwe and Eswatini continue to make progress towards the 2030 targets despite an increasingly difficult funding environment.
Taken together, the two reports show a global HIV response under more severe strain than at any point since the funding scale-up began in 2002.
“The era of relying on international aid is over,” Winnie Byanyima, Executive Director of UNAIDS, said. “Countries cannot wait, and they cannot go backwards. The world must urgently fix the broken global financial system and accelerate debt restructuring so governments can invest in what matters most: the health, education and futures of their people.”
“Fund this response like lives depend on it, because they do,” Erika Castellanos, Executive Director of Global Action for Trans Equality (GATE), said. “People living with HIV are not a line item in a budget. We are the ones holding this response together while decisions are made far from their consequences. Let us be in the room when those decisions are made, not informed of them afterwards.”
“African countries must continue to strengthen domestic investment and make HIV a national priority,” Mathume Joseph “Joe” Phaahla, South Africa’s Deputy Minister of Health, said. “At the same time, no country can replace the scale of international partnership that has driven the global HIV response for decades. Ending the HIV pandemic will require stronger domestic financing, sustained international support and shared responsibility.”
Devastating news for anti-woke Odyssey haters: The film is a financial juggernaut and has amassed $639 million globally in 10 days. It will probably cross the threshold into profitability in the next few days.
Variety reports: “Over the weekend, The Odyssey generated $128.3 million from 81 overseas markets, a remarkable 10% decline in holdover territories. It’s the best second weekend hold for a movie that opened above $100 million, according to Universal, which backed the $250 million-budgeted film.”
Not only has the campaign to savage the film for casting a black woman and a trans man failed miserably, but it may have only stirred more interest in the film.
As many transgender activists and their allies savage basketball star Sophie Cunningham for expressing opposition to cross-sex participation in girls and women’s sports, trans political operatives Brianna Wu calls for acceptance of Cunningham’s position.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Transgender medical care access for young people
Decisions about whether or when minors access transgender medical care should be made by parents—not politicians. Like other medical care, transgender medical careis not one-size-fits-all. It refers to a suite of treatment options, and treatment plans
are individualized and unique to each patient’s needs. This medical care is backed by extensive research, and every major medical association opposes bans on care for
trans youth. Parental consent has always been and should be required for minors to receive ongoing transgender medical care.
Parents’ decisions about the types of treatments that transgender teens do—or do not—receive are complex, intensive, and they must be made by doctors and families together. Parents should certainly not be criminalized, nor should politicians overrule parents seeking medical care for their child. Parents know their child best, and
politicians shouldn’t interfere with parents’ rights.
The Center for American Progress, WaPo reports, “says decisions involving transgender athletes should be left to schools and sports groups, an approach many Democrats already take. But the CAP paper explicitly says restrictions on transgender participation ‘may be appropriate’ and that ‘all athletes deserve fair competition and a level playing field.’”
The crowd on Bluesky is infuriated.
Progressive journalist Walker Bragman denounces basketball star Sophie Cunningham as a “bigot” and a “right-wing favorite” for asserting she does not support transgender girls and women playing in girls and women’s sports.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Basketball star Sophie Cunningham says she stands by her words after she told ESPN she was opposed to cross-sex participation in girls’ sports. She says she has never been a particularly political person but she believes in protecting the female category.
Federal judge blocks DOJ subpoenas for NYC transgender minors’ medical records
Judge Katherine Polk Failla (SDNY) has issued a temporary restraining order barring the Justice Dept. from obtaining identifying health records of minors who received gender-transition treatment at NYU Langone, Mount Sinai and other NYC hospitals from 2020 to 2026, and barring NYU from producing them.
Failla also provisionally certified a class of all such patients, finding they were likely to prevail on claims that the subpoenas violate constitutional privacy protections and the Fourth Amendment, and that NYU’s compliance would breach physician-patient confidentiality under NY law.
From the English translation of the executive summary of the new Dutch advisory:
"The council is unable to comment on the number of people who regret undergoing hormone treatments in the Netherlands. There is too little data on this." https://www.healthcouncil.nl/documents/2026/06/30/transgender-care-for-adolescents
Transgender pundit Katelyn Burns insists Ohio governor candidate Amy Acton, a Democrat, is “adopting the right wing extremist framing of trans issues” after Acton said she did not support cross-sex participation in girls’ sports—a position held by close to or over a majority of Democrats, depending on the poll.
1,700 H.I.V. Treatment Sites Closed After Trump Aid Cuts, a Study Finds
New research also shows that children and high-risk adult populations have been particularly affected.
The Trump administration’s cuts to the largest global H.I.V. program last year resulted in sharp drops in both prevention efforts and treatment for the people most at risk from the disease, according to the first large survey of organizations that had received the funds.
The findings show a grimmer picture of the impact of the cuts than the State Department’s data, released in April, which seemed to suggest that the program had helped to treat about as many people last year as it had in 2024.
To comply with the administration’s policies, the new survey, conducted by the H.I.V. charity amfAR, found, three-quarters of the organizations stopped providing services to those at highest risk from H.I.V. — sex workers, men who have sex with men, transgender people and people who inject drugs. The results are scheduled to be presented next week at a large international AIDS conference in Rio de Janeiro.
A second study, conducted by a multinational group of scientists, which will also be presented at the conference, found that the cuts had disproportionately affected children with H.I.V. The program, called the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, or PEPFAR, supported treatment for about 77,000 fewer children in 2025 than it had the previous year, representing a 14 percent decline, the study found.
Many people have lost research grants because they believe that some people are transgender, for example. The very purpose of granting OMB this power is to grant them ideological control over government spending. This is explicit. They say it is to bring spending in line with the Trump administration’s priorities. This is by definition ideological.
Meanwhile, in their protracted tantrums, the anti-wokesters are trying to rewrite the rules of Hollywood box office expectations to make out like The Odyssey has actually underperformed and is therefore a failure thanks to casting a black actress and a trans man.
Charlie Kirk’s alleged killer is not transgender and therefore not taking hormones and therefore could not experience any mood-altering effects of hormones.
I think she’s right in that a small number of voters and activists on the left can make it very uncomfortable for Dem politicians who move rightward in trans issues, including sinking them in a primary. This is one reason Dems prefer to just say nothing on this issue right now. The cost for either side is higher if they say something than if they say nothing.
I disagree, and Seth Moulton is the prime example of how The Groups ensure that their more fringe positions hold sway over even moderate Dems. He said one thing to the Times about his concerns about natal boys in girls’ sports in Nov 2024. Activists have made him pay a heavy price ever since. Markey has exploited this, showing up to a No Kings rally draped in a trans pride flag. Moulton has cried uncle and sworn fealty to the trans cause. He was one of the only Dems in Congress to protest the Hecox ruling. So whereas, overall, Dems would only be joining with public sentiment to express reservations about cross-sex participation in girls’ sports, if they have any risk of being primaried from the left, doing so could cost them their seat.
Transgender influencer Jesse James Rose claims that as "a twinky pre-transition college student" Rose was paid by Lindsey Graham "a fat stack of cash to do unspeakable things to him in a hotel room while he wore red lingerie."
Rose suggests that Graham paid Rose enough to establish "financial security (& a lack of student loans)."
The consequences from the left of saying that men cannot get pregnant are far worse for people in this position than the blowback from conservatives for saying that men can. These are carefully calculated positions, taken irrespective of what the person actually believes. Even taking a position like, “Of course, by definition, only biological women can get pregnant; but there are natal women who live as men and it is only kind to respect their wishes to observe them as such” is unacceptable according to the current mores that define transgender activism. This fact corners people such this man into making absolutist statements that confound and enrage more people than if they’d taken the nuanced stance.
Quotes a post by T04560; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Women’s soccer star Megan Rapinoe asserts that the “whole point” of the Washington state ballot initiative requiring athletes to prove they are natal girls to play in girls’ sports is to drive girls out of sports, given some will not be able to afford the DNA test or will refuse to submit to what Rapinoe characterizes as invasive and potentially traumatizing genital inspections. She also suggests that it is discriminatory to limit these restrictions to the female category.
“Attacks on trans girls are feints to throw us off balance and distract from the real issues impacting all Americans, like the costs of groceries and gas, healthcare, and housing. If we really cared about safety and fairness in sports, we’d be breaking down barriers facing girls at every level, protecting them from sexual violence and harassment, and paying professional women athletes on the same scale as their male counterparts,” she writes.
Her essay does not specifically address questions of fairness should natal boys play in girls’ sports or address privacy considerations in locker rooms.
Yes, I have interviewed many families who have made that observation independently. This conflicts with your claim that a single independent observer came up with the idea that clusters of teen girls are adopting trans identities due to internet influence. Your claim was never about researchers. It was about non researchers coming up with this observation.
That is correct. The thesis that there has been socially mediated transgender identity adoption after puberty among natal girls in particular has been independently observed by countless everyday people. The fact that someone posted about it online a decade ago is not the defining reason for anyone thinking this is a phenomenon. The only reason why there has been limited academic scholarship on the subject is because activists turned it into a verboten topic and threaten those who broached it with career ruination.
People pretend as if only one person ever could have observed that droves of teenage natal girls were adopting trans identities in clusters. Parents have been independently observing this all over the country for well over a decade. It is not an original observation!
Why do transgender activists typically not acknowledge that social influence can play a role in the formation of transgender identities?
Quoting @benryanwriter: All this raises the question of whether, in the minds of transgender activists, it is at least possible that some adolescents have adopted transgender identities as a result of social influences. There are plenty of youths who have reported doing so and then come to regret adopting the identity, in particular if it led to irreversible medical interventions. And just because some might have come to their identity this way, this does not mean that all have.
Why is it the habit of activists to speak in such black or white terms about this very important question? Many parents have independently observed this phenomenon of apparent social contagion. Are they all wrong? Are they all bigots for holding this theory? Is it not alienating to these parents to be told that they are bigots for not hewing to the party line that all expressions of transgender identity are authentic and healthy?
No sign of the word "contagion" or the certainty about the theory that Branstetter claims Haidt professed. Nor was he talking about trans people in general. He was talking about adolescents, in particular biological girls, who have a long history of latching onto social trends.
Thanks. If I were trans, I would not want anyone who was not best served by transitioning to transition. I find it baffling that most trans people don’t think this way and call for better research into what’s driven the unprecedented surge in gender dysphoria in youths. Instead we are offered simple explanations that no one with eyes actually must believe.
From a commenter on my Substack, a story of a care system that refuses to believe parents’ assessments of their own children and weaponizes their intuitions against them:
“I am also a parent of a trans-identified girl, whose trans ID emerged in 2021 along with a cohort of her friends, at the tail end of COVID. About five or six months into her trans identification, aged 11, we brought her to the local youth mental health assessment centre because she was refusing to go to school and saying she was having suicidal thoughts. The intake clinician immediately reported us to MCFD because my daughter said we wouldn’t buy her a binder or direct the school to change her name and pronouns. My husband had tried to explain some of the background as to why we thought her trans ID might be a maladaptive coping mechanism and he said the worker was becoming increasingly angry at his refering to our daughter as ‘she’ and by her name. In a report which was later sent TO MY CHILD (which we intercepted) we saw that the worker misrepresented that we refused to participate in a safety plan, which along with being ‘insufficiently supportive’ of her gender identity was the pretext for the report to child protection.”
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedchild indoctrinationcontagioninstitutional capturestate takes children
The true rate is unknown due to insufficient research. I was referring to detransitioners who have issued public testimony about what led them into a trans identity and back.
All this raises the question of whether, in the minds of transgender activists, it is at least possible that some adolescents have adopted transgender identities as a result of social influences. There are plenty of youths who have reported doing so and then come to regret adopting the identity, in particular if it led to irreversible medical interventions. And just because some might have come to their identity this way, this does not mean that all have.
Why is it the habit of activists to speak in such black or white terms about this very important question? Many parents have independently observed this phenomenon of apparent social contagion. Are they all wrong? Are they all bigots for holding this theory? Is it not alienating to these parents to be told that they are bigots for not hewing to the party line that all expressions of transgender identity are authentic and healthy?
As you can see from the passage of The Anxious generation to which Gillian Branstetter @[private account] refers, the @ACLU spokesperson misrepresents it in three key ways.
1. She refers to “transgender people” in general, as if @JonHaidt had said that trans people of all ages adopt their identities thanks to internet influence. But Haidt was referring narrowly to adolescents, and mostly to adolescent natal girls.
2. She exaggerates the certainty with which Haidt presented this theory. She makes it seem as if he said this theory is a fact. Whereas in fact, he said the theory may be true.
1. Haidt did not use the word “contagion.” He wrote that the rise in dysphoria diagnoses “may also be related in part to social trends.” And he said various factors “indicate that social influence and sociogenic transmission may be at work as well.”
ACLU spokesperson Gillian Branstetter denounces Jonathan Haidt for asserting in The Anxious Generation that teenage girls are especially prone to social influences and many of them have likely adopted transgender identities due to influences channeled through the internet.
Internet culture reporter and content creator @TaylorLorenz approves of Branstetter's scorn of the NYU psychologist's argument.
The Times, meanwhile, has routinely covered the subject of the Trump administration subpoenaing records of young transgender patients:
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/24/nyregion/transgender-youth-medical-records-doj-judge.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/02/us/transgender-minors-medical-records-lawsuits.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/08/20/us/politics/trump-transgender-children-care-subpoena.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/07/10/health/transgender-medicine-minors-trump-subpoena.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/12/nyregion/nyu-langone-transgender-care-grand-jury.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/05/nyregion/trump-administration-investigating-gender-treatments-at-mount-sinai.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/01/us/justice-department-lawyers-judges-trump.html
Looking back on Seth Moulton’s November 2024 assertion that “as a Democrat, you’re not even allowed to have that debate” about trans inclusion in girls’ sports, debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes retorts: “are you fucking kidding me.”
After Moulton said that, he was subjected to such intense blowback from the left that he has totally recanted his remarks and done a complete 180. Getting the message, almost no Democrats in Congress said a word about the Supreme Court decision on this question.
Hobbes, however, seems to be aware of some environment in national politics in which other Democrats are freely debating this subject.
No Cameras, No Recordings: What a Top Trans Medicine Doctor Told Her Field Behind a Conference's Closed Doors
https://benryan.substack.com/p/no-cameras-no-recordings-what-a-top
Dr. Madeline Deutsch led the US branch of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health through some tumultuous times, in part by squelching public expressions of dissent.
Singal had a lot to say about this study, which found that a high rate of the participants’ siblings started identifying as trans. https://open.substack.com/pub/jessesingal/p/childhood-gender-research-is-increasingly?r=7wxo1&utm_medium=ios
At USPATH 2023, Dr. Mai Flemming, of San Francisco General Hospital and UC Berkeley University Health Services, said of the connections between abortion and trans care:
"The fight is connected because the people behind it are connected, and because the people who access the care are the same people. People who need gender affirming care are people who need abortions. People who need abortions are people who need gender affirming care. And so we can't think of them as siloed. And we really need to think of them as a single set of people and a single fight."
Note that the WaPo makes no reference to the fact that the 400,000 figure comes from Erin Reed.
This problem speaks to the sway that Reed holds over many influential intellectuals. This despite the fact that her reporting is often egregiously erroneous. Even trans advocates on Bluesky have started to speak out about this serious problem. But otherwise, given Reed is independent, there is no accountability.
This Washington Post article claims that an NORC survey found 400,000 trans people have recently fled to another state.
As @kittypurrzog pointed out on @[private account], the 400K figure was, with some faulty math, extrapolated by Erin Reed based on the NORC survey, which included just 10 trans people who said they’d fled a state. The survey did not provide a representative sample either. So this figure has been all but plucked out of the air and was not actually reached by NORC themselves. It is a figment of Erin Reed’s work with a calculator.
This is not to say that trans people are not fleeing red states. But it is extremely unlikely that 400,000 of them have.
Wes Streeting's replacement as health secretary in the UK appears to be as critical, or more critical, than Streeting on trans issues. At least he is now. In this exchange, a journalist tears into him for his past positions on the matter.
Quotes a post by T28008; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network says SFPD “assaulted and injured hundreds” of trans people at SF Pride and calls Scott Wiener’s harassment at the Trans March a “ploy.” What’s documented: 5 arrests after marchers tagged buildings, including the 250-year-old Mission Dolores chapel, with one person allegedly spray-painting a bystander and another charged with spitting in an officer’s face. 20 more arrests came at an unpermitted street party where two Waymos were vandalized into inoperability. Wiener, a Jewish Democrat with arguably the strongest trans-rights legislative record in the country, was surrounded and chased out of a march he’d attended for 22 years, for insufficient hostility toward Israel. The group’s statement declares trans liberation and Palestinian liberation one struggle. In Gaza, homosexuality is punishable by up to a decade in prison.
C1 anti-trans rhetoricactivist harassmentislam link
The International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network has posted a lengthy diatribe against congressional candidate @[private account] defending those who shouted him out of last weekend’s transgender rights march and denouncing his policies as running contrary to the aims of the transgender movement. 🧵
Transgender patients seek to hold Children’s Hospital Colorado in contempt for not resuming gender-transition treatment.
The doctors refuse to abide by a state Supreme Court ruling that they resume prescribing. But they refuse, for fear of sanctions and even prosecution.
The New York Times published this article about the CDC’s second report about what would become known as AIDS (the first such report was the previous month) 45 years ago today.
About 700,000 Americans and 43 million people worldwide have since died of HIV-related disease.
HIV was identified as the cause of AIDS in 1983. The first HIV antibody test was approved in 1985.
1987 saw the first drug approved to treat HIV, AZT. But it was largely ineffective as monotherapy and was initially given at an excessively high dose. Effective combination HIV treatment was not approved until 1996. That swiftly ended the crisis years of the epidemic in the US.
Under the Bush administration, the US launched PEPFAR to treat HIV in poor nations abroad in 2003. The program, which has been vastly compromised by the destruction of USAID and other changes under Trump, is credited with saving 25 million people from dying of AIDS.
The first single tablet HIV regimen was approved in 2007. Today, most people treat HIV with a single, highly tolerable pill taken once daily. The life expectancy of someone diagnosed with the virus today is only a bit less than normal.
I started doing HIV related work as a teenager in 1995 and began covering the epidemic as a reporter in 2001. I don’t cover it much anymore for various reasons. One is migrating to other interests, another is NBC shutting down it’s LGBTQ vertical, and another is because the advocacy community in that world has largely blacklisted me due to my trans reporting. So sometimes it is very cumbersome to get sources.
The heterosexual man who identifies as queer who hounded Scott Wiener out of the trans rights march was evidently particularly enraged with Wiener’s YIMBYism, such as this:
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Sorry, those are not analogous. The straight guy who identifies as queer because he is sexually adventurous and therefore he gets to tell Scott Wiener whether he is queer enough to show up to a trans march is not himself an oppressed minority.
Caitlyn Jenner remains at least a peripheral character in one of the most successful reality TV franchises. But given Jenner is a Republican, this has proved inconvenient to say the least for a transgender activist movement that is grounded in progressive political principles.
Ruling on Trans Athletes Gave the G.O.P. a Win. Most Democrats Looked the Other Way.
While Republicans celebrated the ruling, many Democrats stayed quiet on an issue that had proved divisive in the last election.
The Supreme Court’s decision on Tuesday to uphold restrictions on transgender female athletes drew a largely muted reaction, with Democrats mostly staying silent on an issue about which the vast majority of Americans agree.
None of the Democrats most often mentioned as potential presidential contenders in 2028 reacted publicly to the Supreme Court ruling. Most Democrats competing for key congressional seats stayed similarly quiet.
Most other Democrats stopped talking about trans politics long before the court’s ruling this week. In June, which is L.G.B.T.Q. Pride month, no Democratic candidate mentioned the word “transgender” in their TV ads, according to data from AdImpact, a media tracking firm.
Tim Miller suggests that a heterosexual man who identifies as queer does not likely have standing to police the inclusion of a gay man into a trans rights march based on whether the gay man's Israel stance invalidates his queerness.
Quoting @Timodc: If you are a straight guy with kinks who likes anime, that is really putting you on the outskirts of the LGBQIA/s+ coalition - at best. As such screaming at a gay about how they are banned from queerness bc of Israel is a no. I discuss w @[private account].
Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez stands out among Democrats for expressing concern for fairness in sports with the participation of transgender females in girls and women’s sports, saying:
"At those town halls, what I saw was that the people who were the most upset, a lot of them had spent the last 12 years driving their girls to sports practice and they view their best shot of their student getting a college education as an athletic scholarship. And so when we rush to moralize and be like 'this is all about love vs. hate,' I think we miss some of the nuance." https://x.com/atrupar/status/2072340951213687109/video/1
This review by Emma Hilton @FondOfBeetles found that "the muscular advantage enjoyed by transgender women is only minimally reduced when testosterone is suppressed." https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3
If you’re implying that with time, science will increasingly solidify that natal males maintain an athletic advantage notwithstanding any form of gender-transition treatment, and if society prioritizes fairness over inclusion, per se, then yes, it is likely that time is not on the side of transgender females seeking to participate in girls and women’s sports. However, by banning such inclusion, this makes this much harder to study, at least in the US.
This statement encapsulates what is known as sex stereotype theory, which posits that sex-related restrictions can refer more broadly to gender-related expression rather than simply biological sex. The conservative justices did not buy it in the trans sports case.
Quoting @LeorSapir: This is how Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson ends her dissent in the sports ruling from yesterday.
responds to Caraballo’s insistence that sex is not binary, asserting that such claims, including the assertion that those who doubt them are bigots, have only alienated many people who generally support transgender people.
Quoting @jessesingal: 5/ Saw this via @benryanwriter and it's just the same syndrome. All the biotech in the world doesn't change the fact that almost everyone is one sex or the other. Caraballo and others have promoted really tendentious accounts that attempt to ~problematize~ this but we're like 10
While in recent years the public has become increasingly opposed to cross-sex participation into women and girls’ sports, an attorney representing transgender athletes anticipates that with time the pendulum will swing in the other direction.
Quotes a post by T27651; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Nation’s justice correspondent writes about the SCOTUS sports decision: “See, people always want to make this just about ‘sports,’ but the real upshot here is that, 6-3, trans women can't make a claim under the Equal Protection Clause. And if they can't do that, it's hard to see how they have constitutional rights.
“Clarence Thomas wrote a whole concurrence just to say that he thinks trans people don't exist. There's no extra *law* there or anything. Just fired off a couple of paragraphs to say that transgender is not a thing and people who think they're trans are crazy.”
(True: Thomas reduced transgender people to individuals with gender dysphoria.)
Quoting @benryanwriter: Supreme Court OKs State Bans on Transgender Sports Participation, in Landmark Ruling
The court found that barring biological males from girls and women’s sports did not violate the Constitution or Title IX, regardless of whether athletes had medically transitioned, I report for The @[private account].
The Supreme Court’s conservative supermajority ruled that a pair of Republican-controlled states did not, between them, violate the Constitution or federal law by barring biological males from participating in girls and women’s sports. Specifically, the court ruled that such policies violated neither the Equal Protection clause nor Title IX, notwithstanding the fact that the two plaintiffs, who were born male, each identified and presented as female and had undergone sustained gender-transition treatment.
The landmark ruling, issued Tuesday and written by Justice Kavanaugh, handed a bruising, if generally expected, defeat to the transgender cause. The justices ruled six to three, with the conservatives in the majority, on the constitutional question, finding that the state laws did not violate the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. The court ruled unanimously that one state’s ban did not violate Title IX, although the three liberal justices argued that the associated case’s plaintiff should have been permitted to continue pursuing her lawsuit under the constitutional question.
Justice Kavanaugh, who has a history of coaching youth sports, wrote that “the Title IX regulations guarantee ‘equal athletic opportunity.’ The regulations cannot and do not guarantee every student a spot on a team’s roster.” He further wrote: “No student-athlete on either side of the issue, whether a biological female or transgender, deserves to be ostracized or vilified.”
The decision effectively gives the court’s blessing to similar bans on transgender inclusion in girls and women’s sports that Republicans have passed in just over a majority of U.S. states.
GIFT LINK: https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-oks-state-bans-on-transgender-sports-participation-in-landmark-ruling?gift=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJnaWZ0RnJvbSI6InZxNzh1eGgyMDJjeCIsImlhdCI6MTc4MjgzNTgwNiwiZXhwIjoxNzg1NDI3ODA2fQ.33_SZKmAm9KBOvkcY5ll8YfoHPnCfeUoFLVvAXEp8NM
In the wake of the Supreme Court decision permitting states to bar those born male from girls and women’s sports, transgender pundit and MSNOW scribe Katelyn Burns puts her perspective plainly:
“if you're trans, you have to live. one day you can live to see these guys all die.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: Supreme Court OKs State Bans on Transgender Sports Participation, in Landmark Ruling
The court found that barring biological males from girls and women’s sports did not violate the Constitution or Title IX, regardless of whether athletes had medically transitioned, I report for The @[private account].
The Supreme Court’s conservative supermajority ruled that a pair of Republican-controlled states did not, between them, violate the Constitution or federal law by barring biological males from participating in girls and women’s sports. Specifically, the court ruled that such policies violated neither the Equal Protection clause nor Title IX, notwithstanding the fact that the two plaintiffs, who were born male, each identified and presented as female and had undergone sustained gender-transition treatment.
The landmark ruling, issued Tuesday and written by Justice Kavanaugh, handed a bruising, if generally expected, defeat to the transgender cause. The justices ruled six to three, with the conservatives in the majority, on the constitutional question, finding that the state laws did not violate the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. The court ruled unanimously that one state’s ban did not violate Title IX, although the three liberal justices argued that the associated case’s plaintiff should have been permitted to continue pursuing her lawsuit under the constitutional question.
Justice Kavanaugh, who has a history of coaching youth sports, wrote that “the Title IX regulations guarantee ‘equal athletic opportunity.’ The regulations cannot and do not guarantee every student a spot on a team’s roster.” He further wrote: “No student-athlete on either side of the issue, whether a biological female or transgender, deserves to be ostracized or vilified.”
The decision effectively gives the court’s blessing to similar bans on transgender inclusion in girls and women’s sports that Republicans have passed in just over a majority of U.S. states.
GIFT LINK: https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-oks-state-bans-on-transgender-sports-participation-in-landmark-ruling?gift=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJnaWZ0RnJvbSI6InZxNzh1eGgyMDJjeCIsImlhdCI6MTc4MjgzNTgwNiwiZXhwIjoxNzg1NDI3ODA2fQ.33_SZKmAm9KBOvkcY5ll8YfoHPnCfeUoFLVvAXEp8NM
Supreme Court OKs State Bans on Transgender Sports Participation, in Landmark Ruling
The court found that barring biological males from girls and women’s sports did not violate the Constitution or Title IX, regardless of whether athletes had medically transitioned, I report for The @[private account].
The Supreme Court’s conservative supermajority ruled that a pair of Republican-controlled states did not, between them, violate the Constitution or federal law by barring biological males from participating in girls and women’s sports. Specifically, the court ruled that such policies violated neither the Equal Protection clause nor Title IX, notwithstanding the fact that the two plaintiffs, who were born male, each identified and presented as female and had undergone sustained gender-transition treatment.
The landmark ruling, issued Tuesday and written by Justice Kavanaugh, handed a bruising, if generally expected, defeat to the transgender cause. The justices ruled six to three, with the conservatives in the majority, on the constitutional question, finding that the state laws did not violate the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. The court ruled unanimously that one state’s ban did not violate Title IX, although the three liberal justices argued that the associated case’s plaintiff should have been permitted to continue pursuing her lawsuit under the constitutional question.
Justice Kavanaugh, who has a history of coaching youth sports, wrote that “the Title IX regulations guarantee ‘equal athletic opportunity.’ The regulations cannot and do not guarantee every student a spot on a team’s roster.” He further wrote: “No student-athlete on either side of the issue, whether a biological female or transgender, deserves to be ostracized or vilified.”
The decision effectively gives the court’s blessing to similar bans on transgender inclusion in girls and women’s sports that Republicans have passed in just over a majority of U.S. states.
GIFT LINK: https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-oks-state-bans-on-transgender-sports-participation-in-landmark-ruling?gift=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJnaWZ0RnJvbSI6InZxNzh1eGgyMDJjeCIsImlhdCI6MTc4MjgzNTgwNiwiZXhwIjoxNzg1NDI3ODA2fQ.33_SZKmAm9KBOvkcY5ll8YfoHPnCfeUoFLVvAXEp8NM
In the wake of the heterosexual man who identifies as queer policing gay politician Scott Wiener's right to attend a trans-rights march in San Francisco, we have this NYT opinion piece on the implications of conflating gay with queer:
Quotes a post by T08861; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
NEWS: The Supreme Court has upheld state laws barring biological males from girls' and women's school sports.
In a 6-3 decision, the court ruled that West Virginia and Idaho did not violate the Equal Protection Clause or Title IX by limiting female teams to biological females.
Justice Kavanaugh wrote the majority, joined by Roberts, Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch and Barrett. The ruling resolves two cases, West Virginia v. B.P.J. and Little v. Hecox, brought by athletes who were born male, identify as female and have undergone gender-transition treatment.
The court held that schools may set eligibility for women's and girls' sports based on biological sex. It rejected the argument that athletes who took puberty blockers or hormones are entitled to an exception.
The majority again declined to decide whether transgender status warrants heightened constitutional protection. As in last year's Skrmetti ruling, it said these laws turn on biological sex rather than transgender status.
The justices also held that the scientific debate over athletic advantage did not change the outcome. Even if some transitioned athletes retain no advantage, the court said, the sex-based line still survives intermediate scrutiny.
Justice Sotomayor dissented, joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson. She accused the majority of a "diminished view of equal protection" and of ruling "unencumbered by fact or law." She would have sent B.P.J.'s case back for factfinding.
The dissenters also said Hecox's case was moot and should have been dismissed.
The ruling effectively blesses similar bans now on the books in 27 states, and joins a string of recent losses for the transgender cause.
Hasan Piker says he thinks that Scott Wiener should’ve known he would be screamed out of a woke space like the trans rights rally, not noting that Wiener has attended it for 22 years without incident and that he is a leading advocate of the trans cause.
Tomorrow, June 30, is the final day of the Supreme Court's term. The transgender sports cases, Hecox and BPJ, will be released around 10am ET.
Quoting @benryanwriter: There was no decision from SCOTUS on the transgender sports inclusion cases. Those will very likely come on the court's next, and last, day of the term, sometime between Tuesday and Thursday.
There was no decision from SCOTUS on the transgender sports inclusion cases. Those will very likely come on the court's next, and last, day of the term, sometime between Tuesday and Thursday.
Quoting @benryanwriter: It's another big decision day at the Supreme Court. Starting at 10am ET, the court will release some of the remaining eight decisions, including the two cases about whether states can ban cross-sex participation into girls and women's sports, Hecox and BPJ. Stay tuned...
After Mayor Daniel Lurie accused sex and relationship coach Dimitry Yakoushkin of targeting state senator Scott Wiener with antisemitism as he sought to eject him from the trans rights march, and Wiener said his behavior crossed a line, Yakoushkin denies he was harassing Wiener.
Meanwhile, @[private account] has pointed out elsewhere that much of the invective was about Wiener’s YIMBYism.
Quoting @benryanwriter: SF Mayor Daniel Lurie lambasts the invective that sex and relationship coach Dimitry Yakoushkin @[private account] shouted at State Senator Scott Wiener over Gaza at the trans rights march as “targeted, hateful, and antisemitic.”
After a c-gender heterosexual man spewed invective at him and told him he was not welcome at the trans rights march in SF, openly gay state senator Scott Wiener turned around and celebrated LGBTQ pride in the city.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Dubler lambastes @[private account], who is neither gay nor transgender, for gatekeeping the trans rights march in SF when he screamed invective at state senator Scott Wiener.
Quotes a post by T33073; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Queer has a diffuse definition. To me it is essentially synonymous with gay, but can also include being bisexual or trans. From what I understand, you are none of those things. You are a c-shet man. So that raises the question of why you had the right gate keep an LGBTQ space and determine whether a gay man had the right to be there.
I recommend this Medium essay by @[private account], the man who spewed invective at Scott Wiener at the trans march, on his experiences with tinkering with how he presents himself on Tinder and how that impacted the types of women who expressed interest .
https://yakoushkin.medium.com/wipe-right-what-i-learned-about-the-tinder-wealth-bump-2073997c30d2
I’ve surveyed Bluesky and while the Scott Wiener harassment incident is not huge news over there, the overwhelming share of the reactions have been one of indignation and horror, in particular given Wiener’s steadfast advocacy for transgender rights. They also believe the incident was antisemitic. There are some exceptions, mind you. See the 🧵
Quoting @daveweigel: “You stopped being queer the moment you started supporting Israel, you piece of shit.”
The man who screamed invective at Scott Wiener at the trans rights march claims Wiener, a gay Democrat, is a Log Cabin Republican.
I asked Claude to break down his politics and it said: “Wiener is genuinely hard to pin down on a simple left-right axis because he’s ideologically heterodox — which is exactly what makes him interesting. The short version: he’s a center-left technocratic progressive, closer to the Obama-Pelosi-Schumer mainstream of the Democratic Party than to the AOC/Bernie Sanders wing, but well to the left of anyone you’d call a centrist in the national sense.”
Of 213 Dems in the House, Claude said about 60-80 would be to his left.
Quotes a post by T02920; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
SF Mayor Daniel Lurie lambasts the invective that sex and relationship coach Dimitry Yakoushkin @[private account] shouted at State Senator Scott Wiener over Gaza at the trans rights march as “targeted, hateful, and antisemitic.”
Quotes a post by T18387; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Does anyone know why the people at the trans march in SF were so apoplectic with Scott Wiener? What has he said regarding Gaza to cause all this tumult?
Researchers Argue In WPATH’s Journal that Scientists Should Stop Recording the Biological Sex of Trans Study Participants
A new editorial in the International Journal of Transgender Health, the official journal of WPATH, argues that collecting “sex assigned at birth” data in health research is harmful to trans participants and should be abandoned unless absolutely necessary. The authors, based at the Murdoch Children’s Research Institute in Melbourne, claim the practice undermines rigor, causes psychological distress, and strips trans people of agency.
The irony is that one of the papers they cite to support greater scientific rigor, a 2024 Nature paper by Arnold et al., argues precisely the opposite: that male-female comparisons remain indispensable to biomedical research and should not be discarded.
The editorial describes a randomized controlled trial of a mental health intervention for trans youth in which the research team decided, on the advice of a lived-experience advisory group made up of trans young people, not to collect sex assigned at birth data at all. That decision is held up as a model for the field.
Senior author Ken Pang discloses receiving honoraria from WPATH for giving talks through its Global Education Institute.
California state senator Scott Wiener, who openly gay and is the favorite to win Nancy Pelosi’s seat in Congress, is ejected from a San Francisco trans rights march for his support of Israel:
Quoting @daveweigel: “You stopped being queer the moment you started supporting Israel, you piece of shit.”
Update: SCOTUS's next decision day is Monday. There are eight decisions left to be issued this term, including the two transgender-sports-inclusion cases, Hecox and BPJ. So we may see them Monday at about 10am.
Quoting @benryanwriter: SCOTUS Watch
This morning could see the release of Supreme Court decisions about the two cases of transgender female athletes who sued states over laws that bar them from the girls and women's sports teams. They are expected to lose. Stay tuned...
SCOTUS Watch
This morning could see the release of Supreme Court decisions about the two cases of transgender female athletes who sued states over laws that bar them from the girls and women's sports teams. They are expected to lose. Stay tuned...
“Samuel Lau, a spokesman for the Human Rights Campaign, an L.G.B.T.Q. advocacy group, disputed the argument that activists have been bullying on trans rights.”
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/24/us/politics/gay-marriage-backlash-republicans-trans-rights.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share
The NYC pride parade’s grand Marshalls are demanding that the parade exclude presence by hospitals, including Mt Sinai and NYU Langone, that have caved before the Trump admin and shuttered their pediatric gender clinics.
Per The Advocate, “Pride grand marshals including Bowen Yang, Dominique Jackson, Peppermint, and Jay Walker of Gays Against Guns, have signed on to the effort. Former grand marshals, including Raquel Willis, Michelle Visage, TS Madison, Ceyenne Doroshow, and Jazz Jennings, have also signed on.”
Walker in particular was instrumental in getting the NYC pride parade to forbid NYPD members from marching in uniform. He has also sought to bar all police presence from even guarding the parade, claiming that the mere presence of police makes transgender people feel unsafe.
Norway just found three Oslo University Hospital researchers guilty of scientific misconduct, for analyzing transgender minors' health data without their consent.
The clinic (NBTK) holds Norway's monopoly on youth gender care. The team wanted to track outcomes among the more than 1,700 youth referred to the clinic since 2000. The ethics board said yes, but only if they garnered patient consent. The researchers asked for a waiver for this requirement three times and were denied. So they built an internal "quality register," called it quality assurance rather than research, and published anyway.
Patients later found, via access logs, that their charts had been read. Some recognized themselves in supposedly anonymized papers. Notably, the complaint came from a trans patient organization, not gender-critical activists.
Norway's privacy laws have made it essentially impossible for researchers there to produce the type of long-term outcome studies that their Finnish neighbors have.
This amounts to a collision between privacy rights and the evidence gap that Norway's own health watchdog flagged when it deemed these treatments in youth are experimental.
The researchers say they were conducting quality improvement, given they were not introducing new interventions or data, just analyzing what was on hand. The committee said you can't relabel a rejected study to dodge the ethics ruling you already lost.
Two papers may be consequently be retracted. Politicians are demanding an external probe.
The BBC deliberately excluded from their reporting about this case details about to motive of the person who targeted girls’ schools due to accusations of misgendering. This is part of a larger pattern within the BBC in which it favored in its reporting the political causes of the transgender movement and downplayed angles that would reflect poorly on the movement.
Quoting @nickwallis: I love the BBC. It gave me everything I have (well, them and ITN who have been amazing as well). But there is an internal civil war going on and this article tells you everything you need to know:
"... we apologise for the failures in our reporting."
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0e20ll9gz2o
Aggrieved Former Patients Object to Appointment of Canadian Pediatric Society’s New President
The founder of a pediatric gender clinic in Ontario, Dr. Natasha Johnson, who now leads the nation’s association of pediatricians, has said that parents’ objections to gender-transition treatment should be ‘deprioritized,' I report for The @[private account].
A prominent Canadian pediatrician, Natasha Johnson, has staked her career on the principles of diversity, equity, and inclusion. Accordingly, a decade ago she established a pediatric gender clinic at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, to serve the needs of the fast-growing population of youth who are distressed about their gender or have otherwise adopted a transgender identity.
So when the Canadian Pediatric Society announced last month that it had appointed Dr. Johnson as its next president, this was widely interpreted by Canadian physicians as the medical association burnishing its own DEI bona fides and squaring itself against the Trump administration’s aggressive opposition to medicalized gender transitions for minors.
Amid roiling political conflicts south of the border about the safety, efficacy, ethics, and wisdom of providing puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and gender-transition surgeries to treat gender-related distress in adolescents, Dr. Johnson has maintained in public statements that young people’s satisfaction with these interventions in Canada is extraordinarily high.
And yet, while Dr. Johnson is on record pointing to at least some verifiable research to back up that assertion, The New York Sun spoke with three families who offered detailed accounts of their experiences at her gender clinic that sharply conflict with such a rosy portrayal of patient outcomes. It is, of course, entirely possible these families’ negative experiences with Dr. Johnson and her colleagues reflect only a small minority of those who have attended the McMaster gender clinic. Rare is the doctor with a 100 percent satisfaction rate. Nevertheless, the families collectively told the Sun they remained outraged that they did not receive from Dr. Johnson what they consider to be equitable and inclusive care for their particular needs.
One former patient of Dr. Johnson’s, Faith Groleau said she was fast-tracked for testosterone treatment by Dr. Johnson as a teenager despite serious mental health conditions, proper attention to which Ms. Groleau later concluded should have overridden the impulse to medicalize her adolescent detour into a masculine identity. Ms. Groleau, 26, eventually stopped taking the powerful cross-sex hormone and detransitioned, meaning she reverted to presenting and identifying as her birth sex. Saddled, most noticeably, with a permanently masculinized voice as a consequence of her treatment, Ms. Groleau came to fault Dr. Johnson for what she characterized as “extreme negligence.”
“She didn’t do her job of vetting me at all,” said Ms. Groleau of Dr. Johnson’s care. “She just sent me onto a pipeline of destruction.”
The Sun also conducted interviews with two other families who asked to have their identities shielded — including a mother and daughter who requested to be known by first-name pseudonyms and a husband and wife who agreed for their child’s story only to be used as background reference for this article. All three families shared medical records, and in some cases email exchanges and other documents, that detailed their experiences at the McMaster gender clinic.
Centrally, the families all faulted Dr. Johnson, who is not a trained mental health professional, for engaging in what is known as diagnostic overshadowing: focusing myopically on a gender-related diagnosis at the expense of attention to what the families argued to the Sun were more pressing mental health concerns. Dr. Johnson, the families said, egregiously put these three adolescent patients on a fast track to receive gender-transition interventions. This included approving a biological girl, who at the time identified as male, for a double mastectomy just as she turned 16, even as her mental health rapidly deteriorated. The girl later detransitioned and came to bitterly regret the surgery.
Their stories offer testimony to the ongoing debate within the pediatric gender medicine discipline over whether minors seeking gender-transition interventions should undergo a comprehensive psychosocial assessment by a mental-health professional before being approved for irreversible modifications to their sex characteristics.
Dr. Johnson has made conflicting statements on the matter. All three families who spoke with the Sun about her gender clinic said that while a social worker was on staff, the adolescents in these families were not provided a formal assessment by a mental health professional before being approved for gender-transition medications.
The parents who spoke with the Sun uniformly expressed alarm and offense that, as they reported, their expressed concerns about the prudence of providing gender-transition interventions to their seriously mentally ill children were essentially dismissed and even stigmatized by Dr. Johnson. All three families reported that Dr. Johnson did not take kindly to having her authority challenged, and that in the face of pushback about her proposed or past gender-care plans, her typically pleasant demeanor could turn on a dime and become intimidatingly hostile and defensive.
In some cases, these families said, Dr. Johnson pitted children against their parents, and in one case, pitted divorced parents against one another when it came to fraught decision-making about initiating gender transition interventions. Her office even called child protection services to report one mother for merely expressing concerns about her daughter undergoing a mastectomy, the mother reported.
Dr. Johnson, who along with communications representatives from McMaster did not respond to repeated requests for comment, is on the record asserting that, as a matter of course, parents’ objections to their children receiving gender-transition drugs should at least generally not interfere with a child’s expressed desire for such medications. In a presentation she gave at the 2022 conference of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH, a video of which the Sun obtained, Dr. Johnson said that such feelings on the part of parents “should not be prioritized.”
Ms. Groleau said she took great offense to the suggestion. “My mother was absolutely correct in being concerned because I did detransition,” she said.
NEWS: SCOTUS Decision in Mirabelli v. Bonta Prompts 9th Circuit to Block California Law Barring School Policies That Alert Parents to Kids Identifying As Transgender At School.
"Relying entirely on the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Mirabelli v. Bonta (2026), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit yesterday enjoined enforcement of key provisions of California’s AB 1955—the state law that prohibited school districts from adopting parental notification policies regarding a minor student’s “gender identity.”
"In City of Huntington Beach v. Gavin Newsom, a three-judge panel held that AB 1955 forbids the very parental notification policies the Constitution requires under Mirabelli and granted a preliminary injunction on behalf of seven parent-plaintiffs. The panel had twice previously denied injunctive relief in the case, but reversed course in light of the Supreme Court’s ruling in Mirabelli, the landmark parental rights case brought by Thomas More Society on behalf of California parents and teachers."
California State Senator Scott Wiener, who is running to fill Nancy Pelosi's SF seat in the House of Representatives after she retires, asserts that the FTC's lawsuit against WPATH is "just bigotry by a regime dedicate [sic] to the elimination of trans people."
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Britain’s Study of Puberty Blockers Will Mostly Be a Pointless Waste
https://benryan.substack.com/p/britains-study-of-puberty-blockers
The study’s leaders have announced it will proceed after all. But absent a planned 2nd phase to study cross-sex hormones, the trial is likely to amount to not much more than a $14 million cash sink.
King’s College London on Friday announced that, after a period of reflection and regrouping amid outcry from all sides, the leaders of the much-debated, much-ballyhooed National Health Service clinical trial of puberty blockers for gender-distressed youths would continue largely as planned.
The study’s design has received just a few tweaks, most notably the addition of new minimum ages for participants: 11 years old for natal girls and age 12 for natal boys.
Otherwise, it’s full steam ahead for the £10 million, or $14 million, study.
But anyone who understands even the basic parameters of how pediatric gender medicine works—and what the central purpose of this medical field is—can see that this clinical trial, which if designed properly might have afforded the world some desperately needed insights into these controversial medical practices, is headed straight into the scientific abyss.
Blockers are supposed to be the warm-up act to the main event, in which, at least in theory, people who identify as transgender spend a lifetime on cross-sex hormones—or, in the case of natal females in particular, they stay on testosterone long enough to permanently deepen the voice and prompt the permanent growth of facial and body hair.
Considering all this, why in heaven’s name isn’t the NHS planning to study cross-sex hormones in youths?
Is this study simply an expensive charade to kick the political can down the road?
Johanna Olson-Kennedy, the nation’s top pediatric gender medicine doctor, said at a WPATH meeting that she is not interested in talking about whether her patients are truly trans or not.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Johanna Olson-Kennedy: “I think that a lot of this conversation...gets talked about through a lens of ‘How can we make sure people are really trans,’ right? And ‘They’re not going to regret their decision later?’” But “that’s actually not the discussion that I’m interested in participating in," she said. "I’m interested in discussing and having a conversation about giving the very best possible care to trans young people—the care that they need and deserve.”
To read my article in @[private account] about the 100s of videos I obtained from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and its US offshoot, USPATH: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
I will be publishing the most notable conference videos on my Subsack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
The FTC has sued WPATH, alleging its trans-care guidelines amount to fraud. I am in the process of publishing highlights of the 100s videos of WPATH conferences I obtained and covered this winter for Compact: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
Quoting @benryanwriter: HOW GENDER MEDICINE SET ITSELF UP FOR DISASTER
For @[private account], I report on what the 100s of WPATH conference videos I obtained tell us about this troubled field: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
👉I 'll be publishing the conference videos on my Substack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
As I write for Compact magazine:
This catalogue, which the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH, fought to keep shielded, provides a rich account of how leading figures in pediatric gender medicine approached scientific research, drove the evolution of medical practices, and strategized politically during a critical turning point in this field’s brief and tortured history. The two years following Chase Strangio’s 2021 address were a period in which statehouse Republicans escalated their attacks on this field. The WPATH conference presenters largely responded to the political siege by doubling down. Rather than engage in soul searching over whether their methods in pediatrics were ethically sound and whether any criticisms had merit, they overwhelmingly stuck to their guns.
Presenters frequently downplayed fundamental hazards about irrevocably altering adolescents’ bodies. Meanwhile, a parade of systematic reviews—the gold standard of scientific evidence—was concluding that the evidencebacking pediatric gender medicine is weak and inconclusive. These findings have led health authorities in a number of European nations, concerned about risks such as infertility, to reverse course. They reclassified pediatric gender-transition interventions as experimental and sharply restricted minors’ access.
Not WPATH. The organization remained on an inexorable trajectory in the opposite direction, toward its eventual head-on collision with the second Trump administration.
For highlight clips, see the 🧵👇
A key element of the lawsuit concerns the secrets WPATH kept about why they took the age limits out of their trans-care guidelines:
https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/2067357441743024162?s=20
Quoting @benryanwriter: The FTC has sued WPATH, alleging fraud in part over the removal of the age limits in their 2022 trans-care guidelines.
I previously reported:
Did a WPATH Leader Lie About Why Age Limits Vanished From Their Trans-Care Guidelines?
https://benryan.substack.com/p/did-a-wpath-leader-lie-about-why
A video I obtained of a 2022 World Professional Association for Transgender Health conference shows Dr. Scott Leibowitz making demonstrably false claims about why the age limits were removed.
Notice that in its defense against the FTC lawsuit, WPATH did not say that its trans-care guidelines are "evidence based". Instead, they said: "WPATH has been committed to developing guidelines informed by established scientific standards, expert consensus, and patient centered values." (Emphasis mine.)
Whereas on their website, WPATH said that the most recent version of the guidelines were "the first to be developed using an evidence-based approach." (Emphasis mine.) https://wpath.org/publications/soc8/soc8-history/
WPATH Statement on the U.S. Federal Trade Commission, States’s Announcement of New Complaint
Washington, DC – Today, the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) issued the following statement in response to the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC)’s announcement that it has filed a new complaint with the states of Alaska, Iowa, Nebraska, and Texas:
“This is the second time this year the Trump Administration has abused the authority of its agencies to interfere with Americans' rights to seek and obtain the healthcare that should be decided between a patient and their physician. The first attempt, the FTC’s improper requests to WPATH for protected information was struck down by a federal judge. As an end-around, the FTC has now purportedly brought a similarly baseless actual complaint and has enlisted the administration’s go-to, obedient state attorneys general to help do its unlawful bidding.
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission is not a medical provider and has no place interfering with the process of individualized medical decision-making and. The FTC also does not have any jurisdiction over WPATH and its noncommercial speech. The state claims have similar factual and legal flaws.
In previously ruling against the FTC, a federal district court has already found WPATH is in a strong position to prove that the FTC is acting out of pure retaliation as part of the federal government's relentless and targeted campaign to undermine gender-affirming care by attacking the First Amendment rights and the independence of professional medical organizations. We expect the same result when we oppose this latest attack on WPATH and its mission to promote evidence-informed care and guidance for doctors and their patients.
For more than 50 years, WPATH has been committed to developing guidelines informed by established scientific standards, expert consensus, and patient centered values. WPATH supports individualized patient care, not a “one size fits all” approach.
Transgender and gender-diverse patients deserve the highest level of care from their medical professionals
Quoting @benryanwriter: US FTC to Sue Transgender Health Nonprofit (WPATH) Over Youth Care Standards
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission and four states are suing a nonprofit focused on transgender health for allegedly making misleading statements about the benefits of gender-affirming treatments for young people, a senior FTC official said on Wednesday.
The expected lawsuit against the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) is the latest move by the Trump administration and Republican-led states to limit gender-affirming medical care for transgender youth. Texas, Iowa, Nebraska and Alaska are planning to join the lawsuit.
The FTC and states are expected to say that the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, a group that issues recommendations for the care of transgender patients, misled doctors and families regarding the risks associated with some treatments. The FTC is to say the group overstated the link between gender-affirming care and preventing suicide by children and teens experiencing gender dysphoria, a condition marked by distress experienced when a person's gender identity doesn't align with their sex assigned at birth. The FTC is expected to allege the group sought to have more treatments covered by insurance so that its members could benefit financially.
Here is the 127-page legal complaint as the FTC sues WPATH:
https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/WPATH-Complaint-Redacted.pdf
The FTC alleges WPATH developed its trans-care guidelines for adolescents (called the SOC-8) with conflicted authors, removed age limits due to political pressure (not evidence), misrepresented weak evidence as high-quality, suppressed Johns Hopkins reviews, and falsely claimed gender-transition interventions are “lifesaving” and “reversible.”
Core complaint: member profit over scientific integrity.
Quoting @benryanwriter: US FTC to Sue Transgender Health Nonprofit (WPATH) Over Youth Care Standards
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission and four states are suing a nonprofit focused on transgender health for allegedly making misleading statements about the benefits of gender-affirming treatments for young people, a senior FTC official said on Wednesday.
The expected lawsuit against the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) is the latest move by the Trump administration and Republican-led states to limit gender-affirming medical care for transgender youth. Texas, Iowa, Nebraska and Alaska are planning to join the lawsuit.
The FTC and states are expected to say that the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, a group that issues recommendations for the care of transgender patients, misled doctors and families regarding the risks associated with some treatments. The FTC is to say the group overstated the link between gender-affirming care and preventing suicide by children and teens experiencing gender dysphoria, a condition marked by distress experienced when a person's gender identity doesn't align with their sex assigned at birth. The FTC is expected to allege the group sought to have more treatments covered by insurance so that its members could benefit financially.
FTC, States Sue World Professional Association for Transgender Health Over Deceptive Claims Regarding the Treatment of Children
Agency and state partners argue WPATH’s illegal claims profited its members
https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2026/06/ftc-states-sue-world-professional-association-transgender-health-over-deceptive-claims-regarding-treatment-children
US FTC to Sue Transgender Health Nonprofit (WPATH) Over Youth Care Standards
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission and four states are suing a nonprofit focused on transgender health for allegedly making misleading statements about the benefits of gender-affirming treatments for young people, a senior FTC official said on Wednesday.
The expected lawsuit against the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) is the latest move by the Trump administration and Republican-led states to limit gender-affirming medical care for transgender youth. Texas, Iowa, Nebraska and Alaska are planning to join the lawsuit.
The FTC and states are expected to say that the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, a group that issues recommendations for the care of transgender patients, misled doctors and families regarding the risks associated with some treatments. The FTC is to say the group overstated the link between gender-affirming care and preventing suicide by children and teens experiencing gender dysphoria, a condition marked by distress experienced when a person's gender identity doesn't align with their sex assigned at birth. The FTC is expected to allege the group sought to have more treatments covered by insurance so that its members could benefit financially.
A paradox of running a suicide-prevention nonprofit is that talking about suicide can in certain contexts fuel suicide, which is highly socially contagious.
Do those who beat the drum about trans-youth suicides set up an expectation that members of this population will invariably kill themselves absent securing gender-transition interventions?
For every time a doctor tells a parent in front of their gender-dysphoric child, “Would you rather have a live son or a dead daughter?” does this instill in the child the premise that they should commit suicide if their parents deny them these drugs?
Quotes a post by T06998; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Children’s Hospital doctors refuse to provide gender-affirming care to trans youth, fearing criminal charges
Children’s Hospital Colorado was forced to resume gender-affirming care through a court order, but the doctors who work there won’t do it.
https://coloradosun.com/2026/06/16/transgender-gender-affirming-care-childrens-hospital-colorado/
There is no evidence that these medical interventions prevent suicide. I covered the only study to directly address the suicide question here: https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
More Than One in 250 Biological Girls in Oregon Between 2016 and 2023 Were on Testosterone by Age 17, New Study Finds
GIFT LINK: https://www.nysun.com/article/more-than-one-in-250-biological-girls-were-on-testosterone-by-age-17-in-oregon-from-2016-to-2023-study?gift=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJnaWZ0RnJvbSI6InZxNzh1eGgyMDJjeCIsImlhdCI6MTc4MTUzMTQ2NCwiZXhwIjoxNzg0MTIzNDY0fQ.lfSKWwkBGvsfO20e7ZdoIRwxO9YZLtd-nUYXz1kucqY
The rate, from a new study of data about insured adolescents, represents an average over the seven-year period. Given the swift increase in usage over time, the rate was likely much higher by 2023.
(This is an expanded version of my newsletter account of this study, with more commentary. For example, the passage below.)
A child psychologist who helped establish the field of pediatric gender medicine in the United States two decades ago, Laura Edwards-Leeper, has emerged in recent years as a prominent critic of what she has characterized as the field’s flagging observation of important safety guardrails. She recently relocated to the Midwest after spending about a decade practicing in Oregon.
In an interview with The New York Sun, Dr. Edwards-Leeper conjectured that two main factors were likely driving what she characterized — in contrast to the papers’ authors — as notably high rates of gender-transition medication uptake among minors in her former home state. First, she said, “Oregon is arguably the most trans-affirming state in the nation.” This includes in school curricula, which, she said, “encourage students of all ages to contemplate their gender identity.”
Second, Oregon health care providers are also “extremely supportive of trans people,” Dr. Edwards-Leeper added. Many pediatric providers “value their patients’ bodily autonomy regardless of age” and are concerned that denying youths prompt receipt of gender-transition drugs will harm their mental health.
Dr. Edwards-Leeper said that the pediatric gender medicine field has undergone a sea change over the past decade in providers’ attitudes about conducting comprehensive psychological assessments of minors as a condition of approving them for blockers or hormones. Her own vocal advocacy for such assessments, which she sees as vital, has largely fallen on deaf ears in Oregon. Many of her former colleagues there, she said, have come to see such assessments as unnecessary and egregiously burdensome to vulnerable young patients.
“Unfortunately,” Dr. Edwards-Leeper said, “this shift occurred as the mental health complexity of this young patient population was increasing. In other words, thorough assessments to help determine whether medical interventions would be beneficial were removed when they were needed most.”
The fact that a transgender person would wear their opposite-sex partner’s clothes seems utterly run of the mill to me. Why you people think you’re scorning points by bringing it up over and over is beyond me.
“The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and its European counterpart (EPATH) have issued a joint statement expressing their “deep concern” regarding NHS plans to suspend hormone prescriptions for trans under-18s in England."
https://www.thecanary.co/uk/analysis/2026/06/11/nhs-international-trans/
Mamdani insists his administration “will not back down in the face of federal attacks against trans New Yorkers.” But in effect it already has. He pledged $65 million in his campaign to back gender-transition treatment for New Yorkers of all ages. But the $15 million he has pledged toward such treatment will only go to people age 19 and older. The Trump administration’s attacks have focused on gender-transition treatment for people under age 19. Multiple large pediatric gender clinics in New York have shuttered accordingly.
It is unclear, then, who this new funding is actually for, since such treatment is already widely covered by insurance, including Medicaid; and clinics like Callen-Lorde already serve low income trans patients. Perhaps it is just for uninsured transgender adults? Unclear.
In 2016, @JesseSingal reported on the imbroglio that engulfed Dr Zucker: https://www.thecut.com/2016/02/fight-over-trans-kids-got-a-researcher-fired.html
Are Democrats Dropping WPATH?
At a Washington hearing on gender transition procedures, all mention of the alleged leading authority in U.S. transgender medicine was omitted by the party’s senators and their invited expert witness, writes @LeorSapir for @[private account].
https://www.city-journal.org/article/senate-hearing-gender-transition-wpath
Make sense of this political contradiction:
Trans activists are furious with James Talarico for coming out against pediatric gender surgeries at the same time that Republicans are claiming he is all-in for child gender-transition interventions with an AI generated fake video.
Quotes a post by T06993; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I was proud to contribute to @[private account] this year in my coverage of the subpoenaed World Professional Association for Transgender Health conference videos (see my pinned tweet).
Quotes a post by T05730; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Democratic politicians who seek to track to the center on trans issues invariably pay a heavy price from transgender activists and their allies. But unlike Mass. Rep Seth Moulton, who faces a primary in which his opponent is hounding him over his questions about trans girls in girls’ sports, Talarico is up against Ken Paxton, an ardent opponent of pediatric gender medicine.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Bluesky users express their rage and disappointment over James Talarico coming out against gender surgeries for minors. Many of the comments repeat the false claim that minors do not receive such surgeries. They blame @jbarro and @mattyglesias for, as they see it, normalizing Democratic politicians coming out against such policies.
James Talarico comes out against gender-transition surgeries for minors. But how common are they?
According to an analysis by @LeorSapir at the @ManhattanInst, about 1,000 minors per year underwent gender-transition mastectomies from the late 2010s to early 2020s. States then started widely banning them. And since the second Trump administration, even programs providing these surgeries in blue states have started shutting down for fear of threats from the Trump administration.
Other types of gender-transition surgeries in minors have always been very rare. There are the occasional vaginoplasties. We know from a video I obtained of a WPATH conference that OHSU had a policy of providing them to minors, largely 17 year olds.
In January, the first detransitioner to bring a medical malpractice lawsuit to trial was awarded $2M after she sued her plastic surgeon and psychologist over the gender-transition mastectomy she received at age 16 after publicly identifying as transgender for just under 12 months.
NYC parents say Mount Sinai plans to share trans children's records with Trump administration
Two parents of trans children who received gender-affirming care at Mount Sinai Health System said representatives of the hospital network called them on Thursday and said their children’s health information would be shared with the federal government.
“ I was blindsided by this because we're not even receiving care there anymore,” said Dawn Gabriel, one of the parents.
She said her 17-year-old son received gender-affirming care at Mount Sinai until the health system informed her earlier this year that it was discontinuing such services for minors.
The other parent, who asked not to be identified out of concern for their family’s safety, said a Mount Sinai social worker told them during a three-minute phone call that the records would be shared in response to a federal subpoena.
Trans activists are often very critical of Jeremy Peters of NYT. And yet he and Adam Nagourney wrote this comprehensive article documenting Republicans' use of trans issues as a new wedge issue after gay marriage was legalized. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/16/us/politics/transgender-conservative-campaign.html
There are two basic responses to the Gallup poll showing declining support for gay rights:
1. This is all because transgender activists pushed too hard and alienated the general public to LGBTQ rights in general.
2. Republicans are at fault for cynically pushing transgender issues as a wedge issue as part of a larger long-term project to undermine all LGBTQ rights.
Most people making these claims on social media seem to insist these two forces are mutually exclusive.
But are they?
Trans Minors Sue to Stop Justice Department Access to Medical Records
The Trump administration says it is investigating off-label medication use and fraudulent billing. Families say the inquiry is a new way to press hospitals to end the care.
Gift link: https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/02/us/transgender-minors-medical-records-lawsuits.html?unlocked_article_code=1.nFA._pr5.-JzMESI162u6&smid=nytcore-ios-share
NEWS: A federal appeals court has kept in place an order barring the Trump admin from expelling transgender servicemembers already in uniform, ruling the policy likely violates their constitutional right to equal protection.
But the same fractured panel cleared the ban to take effect for new enlistees.
"At this preliminary stage, I conclude that the Hegseth Policy is both arbitrary and based upon animus, and for those reasons the Policy violates Plaintiff-Appellees' constitutional right to equal protection of the law," wrote Judge Robert L. Wilkins.
All of this remains preliminary. The panel sent the case back to the trial court, and the final outcome will turn on a full trial on the merits, where the ruling, by the court's own acknowledgment, could change.
It’s not just kids: Trump’s crackdown on trans healthcare extends into adulthood
Conservatives have long argued they want to end transition care for minors, but federal policies have increasingly limited adult access. More restrictions are on the way.
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/trump-transgender-healthcare-gender-veterans-federal-employees-rcna346425
California governor Tom Steyer says he is in favor of cross-sex sports participation in high school, citing the strain of being a transgender youth and high suicidality.
Quoting @MarcoFoster_: Tom Steyer: “I’m totally in favor of trans athletes in high school. When you understand the vulnerability, the stress, the danger of being a trans kid and you understand almost half of them try to commit suicide. Then you think we’re gonna punish those kids, we’re gonna cut them off from team sport. It’s like, no we’re not”
Rep. Sarah McBride, who followed Barney Frank’s being the first openly gay member of the House by becoming the first openly trans member, pays tribute to her predecessor as a trailblazer.
McBride’s kind words stand in stark contrast to comments from trans activists such as Parker Molloy, who has leveraged Frank’s death at 86 to savage him over his positions on trans issues.
Quotes a post by T00999; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
In 2021, Dr. Olson-Kennedy Was Eager to Publish Her Youth Gender-Medicine Data. By 2023, She Wasn't.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/in-2021-dr-olson-kennedy-was-eager
In a 2021 plenary address, the lead investigator of the $10 million Trans Youth Care Study previewed one-year results and promised five-year data was coming. It still hasn't come.
NYU’s Student Government Assembly is urging the university to reconsider selecting Jonathan Haidt as commencement speaker, arguing his views on DEI, transgender identity and social justice are out of step with the values and diversity of the Class of 2026. The letter says students feel “disappointment, disgust, defeat, and embarrassment” over the choice of @JonHaidt and accuses NYU of prioritizing a narrow ideological narrative over students’ experiences.
I am in the process of publishing the scores of conference videos from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) that I reported on for the @[private account] article in the quote tweet. So far, I've added seven videos to this collection: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-still-dont-know-what-to-do-doctors
Quoting @benryanwriter: HOW GENDER MEDICINE SET ITSELF UP FOR DISASTER
For @[private account], I report on what the 100s of WPATH conference videos I obtained tell us about this troubled field: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
👉I 'll be publishing the conference videos on my Substack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
As I write for Compact magazine:
This catalogue, which the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH, fought to keep shielded, provides a rich account of how leading figures in pediatric gender medicine approached scientific research, drove the evolution of medical practices, and strategized politically during a critical turning point in this field’s brief and tortured history. The two years following Chase Strangio’s 2021 address were a period in which statehouse Republicans escalated their attacks on this field. The WPATH conference presenters largely responded to the political siege by doubling down. Rather than engage in soul searching over whether their methods in pediatrics were ethically sound and whether any criticisms had merit, they overwhelmingly stuck to their guns.
Presenters frequently downplayed fundamental hazards about irrevocably altering adolescents’ bodies. Meanwhile, a parade of systematic reviews—the gold standard of scientific evidence—was concluding that the evidencebacking pediatric gender medicine is weak and inconclusive. These findings have led health authorities in a number of European nations, concerned about risks such as infertility, to reverse course. They reclassified pediatric gender-transition interventions as experimental and sharply restricted minors’ access.
Not WPATH. The organization remained on an inexorable trajectory in the opposite direction, toward its eventual head-on collision with the second Trump administration.
For highlight clips, see the 🧵👇
'You Could Be Vulnerable': How a Trans-Care Leader Told Doctors to Handle Nonbinary Surgeries Without Outcome Data
https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-still-dont-know-what-to-do-doctors
At a 2022 conference, an author of the new transgender-care guidelines urged clinicians to spread responsibility across a team — acknowledging both the absence of long-term evidence and the potential for patient regret.
I have published a Substack appendix to this article that includes all the internal documents that I used as source material for my reporting:
How Trans Activist Erin Reed Won a Battle Against Youth Gender Medicine Skeptics
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-trans-activist-erin-reed-won
I obtained a trove of internal communications documenting how Ms. Reed's advocacy led the body that oversees continuing medical education for doctors to void a course that cast doubt on this field.
Transgender Activists Sink Medical-Education Course Skeptical of Gender Transitions for Minors
https://www.nysun.com/article/transgender-activists-sink-medical-education-course-skeptical-of-gender-transitions-for-minors?gift=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJnaWZ0RnJvbSI6InZxNzh1eGgyMDJjeCIsImlhdCI6MTc3ODA4Nzc5OSwiZXhwIjoxNzgwNjc5Nzk5fQ.B-PL2CDFsWrSZf32r_i19fDys9VaqbMII9RY_Vm71jg
I report for The @[private account]: The campaign to void the course is part of an effort to discredit a major youth-gender-medicine critic.
A campaign by transgender activists has succeeded in overturning the accreditation of a course series for doctors that cast doubt on the controversial practice of providing gender-transition interventions to minors.
Following a short investigation, the national body that regulates continuing medical education for doctors deemed that the courses did not present a “fair and balanced” account of the relevant science.
I Detransitioned. My Body Will Never Be the Same.
Doctors told me I was transgender at 13. I’m 23 now, permanently altered, and fighting to make sure it never happens to another child.
By @[private account] for @TheFP
I’m a gay man who testified last month against what has been called a lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender-rights bill. I was there because I believe the proposed law could silence the one kind of help that could have saved me from years of anguish and a future permanently marked by what was done to me as a child.
I grew up in a fundamentalist Christian town in rural Michigan with 2,500 people, one red light, and a pervasive drug problem. My parents split when I was a baby: My biological father was a deadbeat I’ve met only a handful of times; my mom worked constantly as the primary breadwinner for our family, building multiple small businesses in the car world.
From my earliest awareness, I knew I was not like other kids—and certainly not like other boys. I moved and spoke in ways others called “girly.” I loved dress‑up games, butterflies, and anything pink. I was obsessed with The Princess and the Frog and looked up to Disney princesses more than any male character. I also knew, from a very young age, that I liked boys. I didn’t have words for it then, and in the world I grew up in, it was considered sinful and shameful. But the feeling existed long before I had any name for it.
https://www.thefp.com/p/i-de-transitioned-my-body-will-never-be-the-same
It’s worth noting that the same people who are falsely claiming The Protocol doesn’t include the voices of trans youth were also widely campaigning for trans people to blacklist Azeen and refuse to speak to her for her reporting.
This Pulitzer finalist designation serves as a rebuke to all those who signed the notorious “Times contributors letter” smearing the paper’s coverage of trans issues as well as GLAAD’s simultaneous attacks on the paper for the same reason in February 2023.
The same trans activists who run campaigns demanding that trans people blacklist The New York Times and never give its journalists interviews turn around and fault @NYTimes for not quoting trans people enough. (They also think @GLAAD is a reliable source.)
https://www.advocate.com/news/new-york-times-transgender-stories
Detransitioning is not relevant to the question of the outcome of fertility. Also, when people try to couch these figures in numerical terms rather than per capita rates, they lean on the simple fact that trans kids are a much smaller population.
I've updated my Substack on the pediatrics panel to account for all the protests during and following the event: https://benryan.substack.com/p/transgender-activists-target-pediatric
The Pediatric Endocrine Society takes a stand against the panel held yesterday at the pediatrics conference in Boston that included four skeptics of pediatric gender medicine. They sent this missive to their members:
"Many of you may have voiced disapproval and dismay that the Pediatric Academic Societies (PAS) Annual Meeting had a session entitled 'A Scientific Dialogue on the Care of Transgender and Gender Diverse Youth.' PES is not a member of the Pediatric Academic Societies, and we neither submitted nor endorsed this symposium. Prior to and during the meeting, we had been in communication with some of PAS leadership about our serious concerns with the design of the session and with allowing the session to move forward in its planned format.
"While the description advertised the session as a scholarly review, the panel was made up entirely of individuals who have espoused views that run counter to the bulk of the primary literature and the advice around care provided by the vast majority of major medical associations. While PES welcomes different points of view, we believe that presentations at conferences should be as evidence-based as possible. Our views in support of thoughtful, optimal care of transgender and gender diverse youth have been stated previously."
Quoting @benryanwriter: Controversial Pediatric Gender Panel Draws Trans-Activist Push for Cancellation
https://benryan.substack.com/p/transgender-activists-target-pediatric
Trans-activist Substacker Erin Reed has prompted an uproar over a panel of skeptics of pediatric gender medicine slated for Sunday at the Pediatric Academic Societies meeting in Boston.
Transgender activists and their allies are in an uproar over an upcoming medical-conference panel concerning pediatric gender medicine that features skeptics of this field whom activists accuse of being anti-trans.
Since the prominent trans-activist Substacker Erin Reed published an article about the panel on Tuesday, conference organizers have apparently been inundated with tens of thousands of emails demanding it cancel the panel, in particular due to the panelists’ connections to a small nonprofit known as the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine, or @SEGM_EBM.
This burgeoning deplatforming campaign raises questions about the place that the free exercise of scientific ideas has within a medical field as peerlessly politicized as pediatric gender medicine. As transgender activists seek to shut down what they argue are toxic fringe positions akin to climate-change deniers, a relatively small but determined collection of scientific and medical experts have remained committed to publicly scrutinizing this field and defending themselves against what they say are baseless accusations that their perspectives are rooted in bigotry and animus.
Transgender activist and Substacker Erin Reed proclaims victory in the wake of the panel today of pediatric gender medicine skeptics at the pediatrics conference in Boston after 106 attended the 8am session and many cheered the disrupters. Anna Hutchinson explained during the session why they were not there promoting conversion therapy, as she did in a 2025 paper that Reed is either unaware of or has discounted after she accused Hutchinson this week promoting such treatment.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Controversial Pediatric Gender Panel Draws Trans-Activist Push for Cancellation
https://benryan.substack.com/p/transgender-activists-target-pediatric
Trans-activist Substacker Erin Reed has prompted an uproar over a panel of skeptics of pediatric gender medicine slated for Sunday at the Pediatric Academic Societies meeting in Boston.
Transgender activists and their allies are in an uproar over an upcoming medical-conference panel concerning pediatric gender medicine that features skeptics of this field whom activists accuse of being anti-trans.
Since the prominent trans-activist Substacker Erin Reed published an article about the panel on Tuesday, conference organizers have apparently been inundated with tens of thousands of emails demanding it cancel the panel, in particular due to the panelists’ connections to a small nonprofit known as the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine, or @SEGM_EBM.
This burgeoning deplatforming campaign raises questions about the place that the free exercise of scientific ideas has within a medical field as peerlessly politicized as pediatric gender medicine. As transgender activists seek to shut down what they argue are toxic fringe positions akin to climate-change deniers, a relatively small but determined collection of scientific and medical experts have remained committed to publicly scrutinizing this field and defending themselves against what they say are baseless accusations that their perspectives are rooted in bigotry and animus.
Kale Edmiston, the trans academic who disrupted today’s pediatrics panel featuring skeptics of pediatric gender medicine by speaking out of turn, is known for having lied, claiming to be a coauthor of WPATH’s adolescent trans-care guidelines in 2023 as he falsely claimed Jesse Singal had misinterpreted a sentence that he falsely claimed to have written. Scott Leibowitz, who actually coauthored that guidelines chapter, publicly confirmed Edmiston was lying.
See: https://open.substack.com/pub/jessesingal/p/that-might-have-been-the-strangest
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Boston conference panel featuring four skeptics of pediatric gender medicine went off this morning with minimal disruptions. I obtained video and audio of the surrounding protests, one of the disruptions from a WPATH leader, and the moderator, Dr. Rauch, introducing the panel.
I've dropped all of that into an update to this Substack I published on Friday if you want to take a look:
https://benryan.substack.com/p/transgender-activists-target-pediatric
Otherwise, the videos are below. They feature:
*Protests outside the conference hall, including a marching band.
*Kale Edmiston, a neuroscientist by training and a coauthor of one of the chapters of WPATH’s Standards of Care, disrupting the panel and interfacing with the panelists.
*A protester being dragged away.
Many of you will be surprised to learn that Erin Reed has a habit of publishing claims about her adversaries that are not firmly nestled in a bed of truth. https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/transgender-activists-target-pediatric
Update: This panel has not been canceled, despite the better efforts of infuriated transgender activists. It is set for Sunday at 8am in Boston.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Controversial Pediatric Gender Panel Draws Trans-Activist Push for Cancellation
https://benryan.substack.com/p/transgender-activists-target-pediatric
Trans-activist Substacker Erin Reed has prompted an uproar over a panel of skeptics of pediatric gender medicine slated for Sunday at the Pediatric Academic Societies meeting in Boston.
Transgender activists and their allies are in an uproar over an upcoming medical-conference panel concerning pediatric gender medicine that features skeptics of this field whom activists accuse of being anti-trans.
Since the prominent trans-activist Substacker Erin Reed published an article about the panel on Tuesday, conference organizers have apparently been inundated with tens of thousands of emails demanding it cancel the panel, in particular due to the panelists’ connections to a small nonprofit known as the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine, or @SEGM_EBM.
This burgeoning deplatforming campaign raises questions about the place that the free exercise of scientific ideas has within a medical field as peerlessly politicized as pediatric gender medicine. As transgender activists seek to shut down what they argue are toxic fringe positions akin to climate-change deniers, a relatively small but determined collection of scientific and medical experts have remained committed to publicly scrutinizing this field and defending themselves against what they say are baseless accusations that their perspectives are rooted in bigotry and animus.
'We need to reassess': The evolution of one gender care doctor
She was one of the first doctors in Canada to provide hormones to trans-identifying youth. She now believes most kids should not be medicalized.
https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/evolution-transgender-care-doctor
The Shocking Secrets of Madison Square Garden’s Surveillance Machine
Famously vengeful Knicks owner Jim Dolan has long spied on people at his iconic arenas.
@[private account] goes deep inside the operation that allegedly tracked a trans woman, lawyers, protesters, and more, by @[private account].
https://www.wired.com/story/madison-square-garden-jim-dolan-surveillance-machine/
I recently got into an agonizing back-and-forth with Health Nerd @[private account] about the new Finnish study that suggested youths on gender-transition drugs worsen psychologically. He wasn't listening to a word I said, so I asked the study's senior author detailed questions about the paper, as well as a Swedish expert on the subject, and published their responses in this Q&A. I hope their words will help people better understand the nuances and complexities of this research.
The Author of the Controversial Finnish Study on Youth Gender Care Responds to Critics
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-author-of-the-controversial-finnish
A new study found a surge in psych care typically reserved for severe mental health problems following gender-transition interventions in youth—prompting sharp pushback from transgender advocates.
This @WSJ oped is way too confident in interpreting the findings of the new Finnish study on youth gender-transition treatment. It doesn’t acknowledge that the study relied on a proxy measure of severe mental health problems that has limitations. https://www.wsj.com/opinion/finland-study-transgender-children-8ac44768?st=9wh7Ad&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink
The only time she doesn’t speak in a phony voice is in the car to Charlotte’s wedding when she says she has cancer.
I always wondered why the Jezebel keyboard warriors never got her and John Mulaney canceled for doing blackvoice (see: the trans sex worker episode).
No one has done more to delegitimize assessments in the clinical and research arena than Johanna Olson-Kennedy. She said at a recent WPATH conference that she is not interested in talking about ensuring whether kids are “really trans.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: Johanna Olson-Kennedy: “I think that a lot of this conversation...gets talked about through a lens of ‘How can we make sure people are really trans,’ right? And ‘They’re not going to regret their decision later?’” But “that’s actually not the discussion that I’m interested in participating in," she said. "I’m interested in discussing and having a conversation about giving the very best possible care to trans young people—the care that they need and deserve.”
To read my article in @[private account] about the 100s of videos I obtained from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and its US offshoot, USPATH: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
I will be publishing the most notable conference videos on my Subsack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
I reported for @[private account] on the 100s of conference videos of a trans-medicine organization that I obtained:
Presenters often refashioned assessment to affirm identity and reduce barriers to treatment and surgery. This dovetailed with an intense focus on how to preserve access, expand capacity, and circumvent any obstacles, whether from parents, insurers, legislators or care providers’ reluctance or inadequate training. This paradigm shift further merged with the repurposing of the gender-affirming care model away from addressing psychopathology and toward serving the patient’s so-called “embodiment goals.”
This term, which intertwines metaphysics with plastic surgery, was uttered ten times in a session at the 2023 conference that offered a master class in the Olson-Kennedy school of thought. A team of self-described “providers, clients, advocates and activists” presented an assessment model they had spent two years developing. As Amelia Brewer, an Oklahoma counselor, advised against “lengthy or unnecessary protocols,” the corresponding slide asserted that “one session may be sufficient.” All the slides warned: “DO NOT COPY OR RECORD.”
A session for the American Psychological Association’s Division 39’s annual meeting in NY this month is a workshop addressing “the oppressive nature of gender assessments” for adults and minors with gender dysphoria. This includes “how to advocate for loosening/abolishing gender assessment guidelines.”
“This workshop will address the oppressive nature of gender assessments and shift toward a practice of respecting patient bodily autonomy within institutions that call us to be gatekeepers of life-affirming care. Along with an informational slide deck and discussion with peers, this workshop will provide participants with resources for navigating requirements for trans mental health assessments while maintaining patient autonomy, including: collaborative assessment writing, tools for how to find/understand/critically assess legal and insurance-based requirements, how to advocate for loosening/abolishing gender assessment guidelines, and further reading on the role of mental health practitioners in the oppression of trans communities.”
Did a child psychiatrist in the pediatric gender medicine space lie to colleagues at the World Professional Association for Transgender Health's conference re: the American Academy of Pediatrics successfully pressuring them to remove the age limits in their trans-care guidelines?
Quoting @benryanwriter: Did Dr. Scott Leibowitz lie at the 2022 WPATH conference about the drama behind the trans-care guidelines?
Subpoenaed emails reveal that child psychiatrist Dr. Scott Leibowitz, coauthor of the adolescent chapter of WPATH's 2022 revision to its trans-care guidelines, was aware that the AAP successfully pressured the group into removing age limits. The emails also reveal his coauthors expressed concern that bowing to outside pressure on this issue would mean not putting such a change through a process of reaching consensus called the Delphi process. Indeed, they did not put the change through Delphi.
And yet in WPATH's 2022 conference, Dr. Leibowitz got up and claimed that every part of the chapter was put through the Delphi process.
As I wrote in @[private account]:
https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
Referring to the use of the Delphi process to reach internal consensus in the chapter’s development, Leibowitz said, “Every single statement that you had was voted on and went through that process.” Leibowitz said this after having, in an email to coauthors of the pediatrics chapters the previous month, recapitulated the group’s concerns about potentially skirting the Delphi process if they removed the age limits under political pressure from Levine (who later denied the pressure campaign). At the conference, Leibowitz said that an age limit “also adds an arbitrary element to the guidelines,” and assured the audience that the age-limit issue “was thought through a lot, and there was a lot of discussion about it.”
That discussion had included a September 9, 2022, email Dr. Jon Arcelus, cochair of the guidelines committee and a transgender medicine specialist at the University of Nottingham, sent to Leibowitz, Coleman, and other WPATH leaders. In it, Arcelus spelled out the AAP’s demands, including “to remove ages” from the guidelines.
Leibowitz did not mention to conference-goers the Biden administration’s contribution to any discussion about age limits or the AAP’s successful effort to get them removed from the guidelines.
To see all the WPATH videos I obtained: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
Did Dr. Scott Leibowitz lie at the 2022 WPATH conference about the drama behind the trans-care guidelines?
Subpoenaed emails reveal that child psychiatrist Dr. Scott Leibowitz, coauthor of the adolescent chapter of WPATH's 2022 revision to its trans-care guidelines, was aware that the AAP successfully pressured the group into removing age limits. The emails also reveal his coauthors expressed concern that bowing to outside pressure on this issue would mean not putting such a change through a process of reaching consensus called the Delphi process. Indeed, they did not put the change through Delphi.
And yet in WPATH's 2022 conference, Dr. Leibowitz got up and claimed that every part of the chapter was put through the Delphi process.
As I wrote in @[private account]:
https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
Referring to the use of the Delphi process to reach internal consensus in the chapter’s development, Leibowitz said, “Every single statement that you had was voted on and went through that process.” Leibowitz said this after having, in an email to coauthors of the pediatrics chapters the previous month, recapitulated the group’s concerns about potentially skirting the Delphi process if they removed the age limits under political pressure from Levine (who later denied the pressure campaign). At the conference, Leibowitz said that an age limit “also adds an arbitrary element to the guidelines,” and assured the audience that the age-limit issue “was thought through a lot, and there was a lot of discussion about it.”
That discussion had included a September 9, 2022, email Dr. Jon Arcelus, cochair of the guidelines committee and a transgender medicine specialist at the University of Nottingham, sent to Leibowitz, Coleman, and other WPATH leaders. In it, Arcelus spelled out the AAP’s demands, including “to remove ages” from the guidelines.
Leibowitz did not mention to conference-goers the Biden administration’s contribution to any discussion about age limits or the AAP’s successful effort to get them removed from the guidelines.
To see all the WPATH videos I obtained: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
As I reported for Compact after obtaining 100s of videos of conferences by a top transgender-medicine organization, presenters almost never put into plain language that there were any scenarios in which it was unethical to provide minors with potentially sterilizing treatment.
Quoting @benryanwriter: “How many people have heard the adolescent say, ‘I don’t want to talk about that. I’ll just adopt’?” child psychiatrist and WPATH board member Dr. Scott Leibowitz said at a 2023 WPATH conference of his patients’ blasé attitudes toward fertility preservation, I report for @[private account]. “We’ve all heard them say that over and over.”
But very few conference presenters suggested they observed any ethical red line that would trigger a refusal to provide a minor a potentially sterilizing intervention. Instead, their roadmap out of this ethical thicket was invariably guided by more fertility counseling, more education, and more informed consent.
To read my Compact article: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
To see the WPATH conference videos I obtained: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
Chase Strangio's 2021 Warning: 'Decisions to engage with people like Abigail Shrier…are going to cost people lives.'
https://benryan.substack.com/p/chase-strangios-2021-warning-decisions
I obtained 100s of conference videos that the World Professional Assoc. for Transgender Health fought to shield, including one in which Mr. Strangio contradicted his recent claims to Ross Douthat.
The Evolution of the @ACLU's Chase Strangio From 2021 to 2025:
On engaging with critics:
2021, at the conference of the US branch of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (USPATH): “[D]ecisions to engage with people like @AbigailShrier…are going to cost people lives”
2025, to the @NYTimes' Ross Douthat @[private account]: “I’ve always been open to dialogue.”
On sex-based competitiveness in sports:
2021, at USPATH: There are “so-called fundamental differences between boys and girls, between men and women.”
2025, to Douthat: “I accept the premise that, in the aggregate, men have athletic advantages in a majority — though not all — sports.”
On trans inclusion in sports:
2021, at USPATH: “[W]hen you have young people who know who they are, we should absolutely not be undermining that by telling them they have to participate in sports based on their assigned sex at birth.”
2025, to Douthat: “I am not disputing that there are conversations to be had about how we manage the inclusion of trans people in sports.”
To see the full USPATH video, go to the quote tweet:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Chase Strangio's 2021 Warning: 'Decisions to engage with people like Abigail Shrier…are going to cost people lives.'
https://benryan.substack.com/p/chase-strangios-2021-warning-decisions
I obtained 100s of conference videos that the World Professional Assoc. for Transgender Health fought to shield, including one in which Mr. Strangio contradicted his recent claims to Ross Douthat.
Chase Strangio's 2021 Warning: 'Decisions to engage with people like Abigail Shrier…are going to cost people lives.'
https://benryan.substack.com/p/chase-strangios-2021-warning-decisions
I obtained 100s of conference videos that the World Professional Assoc. for Transgender Health fought to shield, including one in which Mr. Strangio contradicted his recent claims to Ross Douthat.
I Obtained 100s of Conference Videos From the Leading Transgender Medical Association
https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
To build off my major report for Compact on these videos from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), I will be publishing the most notable videos on Substack, starting now.
Kellan Baker, a top policy wonk in gender medicine, at a 2023 conference theatrically mocked a 2022 NYT article addressing concerns about the long-term impacts of puberty blockers: "You can just feel the pearls being clutched!”
To see the whole video: https://benryan.substack.com/p/we-all-support-trans-kids-in-the
Quoting @benryanwriter: Kellan Baker counseled against saying “gender-affirming care.” Messaging research indicated that when people hear it, he said, “they think ‘trans kids in the driver’s seat.’” But he said this was an accurate assessment. “I think we all support trans kids in the driver’s seat because it’s their bodies, it’s their lives,” he said.
“But when you think about folks who don’t know trans people, they are very scared by the idea that young people are making irreversible decisions and that no one else has any oversight over those decisions.”
To read my article in @[private account] about the 100s of videos I obtained from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and its US offshoot, USPATH: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
I will be publishing the most notable conference videos on my Subsack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
Leading pediatric gender medicine doctor Johanna Olson-Kennedy said at a 2023 conference that she is not "interested in" assessing whether her patients are "really trans." The leading advocate against such assessments, Olson-Kennedy was sued in 2024 by a detransitioner.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Johanna Olson-Kennedy: “I think that a lot of this conversation...gets talked about through a lens of ‘How can we make sure people are really trans,’ right? And ‘They’re not going to regret their decision later?’” But “that’s actually not the discussion that I’m interested in participating in," she said. "I’m interested in discussing and having a conversation about giving the very best possible care to trans young people—the care that they need and deserve.”
To read my article in @[private account] about the 100s of videos I obtained from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and its US offshoot, USPATH: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
I will be publishing the most notable conference videos on my Subsack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
These are chart reviews, so it's a bit hard to know what the data means. But I covered that study here:
https://archive.is/20240918222133/https://www.nysun.com/article/new-evidence-challenges-institutionalized-belief-that-transgender-teens-become-transgender-adults-undermining-core-defense-of-medical-gender-transitions-for-minors
See highlights from the 100s of conference videos from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health that I obtained: https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
Kellan Baker, an influential policy adviser to the transgender-medicine field, said at a 2023 trans-medical conference that trans kids are “in the driver’s seat” directing their own access to gender-transition drugs. But he advised conference-goers to keep this secret:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Kellan Baker counseled against saying “gender-affirming care.” Messaging research indicated that when people hear it, he said, “they think ‘trans kids in the driver’s seat.’” But he said this was an accurate assessment. “I think we all support trans kids in the driver’s seat because it’s their bodies, it’s their lives,” he said.
“But when you think about folks who don’t know trans people, they are very scared by the idea that young people are making irreversible decisions and that no one else has any oversight over those decisions.”
To read my article in @[private account] about the 100s of videos I obtained from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and its US offshoot, USPATH: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
I will be publishing the most notable conference videos on my Subsack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
I obtained hundreds of videos of conferences held by the World Professional Association for Transgender Health and reported about them for @[private account]:
Quoting @benryanwriter: HOW GENDER MEDICINE SET ITSELF UP FOR DISASTER
For @[private account], I report on what the 100s of WPATH conference videos I obtained tell us about this troubled field: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
👉I 'll be publishing the conference videos on my Substack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
As I write for Compact magazine:
This catalogue, which the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH, fought to keep shielded, provides a rich account of how leading figures in pediatric gender medicine approached scientific research, drove the evolution of medical practices, and strategized politically during a critical turning point in this field’s brief and tortured history. The two years following Chase Strangio’s 2021 address were a period in which statehouse Republicans escalated their attacks on this field. The WPATH conference presenters largely responded to the political siege by doubling down. Rather than engage in soul searching over whether their methods in pediatrics were ethically sound and whether any criticisms had merit, they overwhelmingly stuck to their guns.
Presenters frequently downplayed fundamental hazards about irrevocably altering adolescents’ bodies. Meanwhile, a parade of systematic reviews—the gold standard of scientific evidence—was concluding that the evidencebacking pediatric gender medicine is weak and inconclusive. These findings have led health authorities in a number of European nations, concerned about risks such as infertility, to reverse course. They reclassified pediatric gender-transition interventions as experimental and sharply restricted minors’ access.
Not WPATH. The organization remained on an inexorable trajectory in the opposite direction, toward its eventual head-on collision with the second Trump administration.
For highlight clips, see the 🧵👇
“Any form of ageism is unethical,” Simona Giordano, a bioethicist at the Univ of Manchester and WPATH ethics committee member, said in 2022 regarding providing gender-transition interventions to minors. “Refusing to treat someone because they are too young is as unjust as refusing to treat someone because they are too old. Decisions shouldn’t be based on age, but on capacity to benefit from treatment.”
To read my article in @[private account] about the 100s of videos I obtained from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and its US offshoot, USPATH, scroll up.
OHSU Performed Vaginoplasties On 17 Year Olds
Oregon Health & Science University urologist Dr. Geolani Dy said that for “a lot” of the hospital’s young patients, the timing of a vaginoplasty (a surgery that includes castration) “will fall around the seventeen-, eighteen-year-old age range.”
Dr. Dy said this during a presentation at the 2021 conference of the US offshoot of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, USPATH.
See the main post in the thread for my article in @[private account] and my companion post with dozens of clips like this one.
Johanna Olson-Kennedy: “I think that a lot of this conversation...gets talked about through a lens of ‘How can we make sure people are really trans,’ right? And ‘They’re not going to regret their decision later?’” But “that’s actually not the discussion that I’m interested in participating in," she said. "I’m interested in discussing and having a conversation about giving the very best possible care to trans young people—the care that they need and deserve.”
To read my article in @[private account] about the 100s of videos I obtained from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and its US offshoot, USPATH: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
I will be publishing the most notable conference videos on my Subsack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
Kellan Baker counseled against saying “gender-affirming care.” Messaging research indicated that when people hear it, he said, “they think ‘trans kids in the driver’s seat.’” But he said this was an accurate assessment. “I think we all support trans kids in the driver’s seat because it’s their bodies, it’s their lives,” he said.
“But when you think about folks who don’t know trans people, they are very scared by the idea that young people are making irreversible decisions and that no one else has any oversight over those decisions.”
To read my article in @[private account] about the 100s of videos I obtained from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and its US offshoot, USPATH: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
I will be publishing the most notable conference videos on my Subsack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
HOW GENDER MEDICINE SET ITSELF UP FOR DISASTER
For @[private account], I report on what the 100s of WPATH conference videos I obtained tell us about this troubled field: https://www.compactmag.com/article/how-gender-medicine-set-itself-up-for-disaster/
👉I 'll be publishing the conference videos on my Substack: https://benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained-100s-of-conference-videos
As I write for Compact magazine:
This catalogue, which the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH, fought to keep shielded, provides a rich account of how leading figures in pediatric gender medicine approached scientific research, drove the evolution of medical practices, and strategized politically during a critical turning point in this field’s brief and tortured history. The two years following Chase Strangio’s 2021 address were a period in which statehouse Republicans escalated their attacks on this field. The WPATH conference presenters largely responded to the political siege by doubling down. Rather than engage in soul searching over whether their methods in pediatrics were ethically sound and whether any criticisms had merit, they overwhelmingly stuck to their guns.
Presenters frequently downplayed fundamental hazards about irrevocably altering adolescents’ bodies. Meanwhile, a parade of systematic reviews—the gold standard of scientific evidence—was concluding that the evidencebacking pediatric gender medicine is weak and inconclusive. These findings have led health authorities in a number of European nations, concerned about risks such as infertility, to reverse course. They reclassified pediatric gender-transition interventions as experimental and sharply restricted minors’ access.
Not WPATH. The organization remained on an inexorable trajectory in the opposite direction, toward its eventual head-on collision with the second Trump administration.
For highlight clips, see the 🧵👇
Any parent who has kids at a private school in a blue city can tell you how trans identities can sweep through friend groups among adolescent natal girls in particular. But you’re not allowed to talk about this because of how aggressively such ideas are policed and people are accused of high social crimes for expressing them. Again, I think you should stop and consider how much of a free speech issue is at play here and how you are perhaps unwittingly joining an anti-intellectual mob.
Interesting theory, but if you subscribe to the theory that Jon Haidt can transmit unhappiness through social networks then it would also hold that social media can transmit unhappiness and that distressed teenage girls can adopt trans identities as a maladaptive coping mechanism after their social networks similarly adopt such coping mechanisms. Your theory would also require that the youth mental health crisis’ onset was the spring of 2024, after the publication of Haidt’s book.
Ask yourself how the youth presenting at gender clinics went from a scant population of natal boys first presenting in early childhood until about 2012, when these clinics suddenly saw a surge of adolescent natal girls all distressed about their gender. Now 3% of adolescents identify as transgender. This is a phenomenon totally without parallel in the history of what today we call gender identity. Why did this phenomenon start in 2012?
I studied gender dysphoria. Both sides tried to shut it down.
Activists challenged the work; conservatives championed it, then defunded it.
Adam Omary is a research fellow at the Cato Institute’s Center for Global Liberty and Prosperity.
At a neuroscience conference in 2024, a researcher was presenting data on how puberty blockers harm brain development in rodents. I asked about possible neurological side effects in human children with gender dysphoria receiving similar interventions. The expert, who’d been answering audience questions in detail and with enthusiasm, suddenly became evasive. We don’t know, they said. We can’t generalize our findings to humans.
But modern neuroscience rests on the assumption that animal models tell us something meaningful about human brains. We justify human trials for nearly every psychiatric drug on the strength of animal data. The researcher in front of me had built a career on precisely these extrapolations. To suddenly disclaim them wasn’t science. It was politics. I left that conference having made up my mind: I would give up my position on the Human Connectome Project, an initiative that maps the brain, and study gender dysphoria instead.
Transgender issues fascinated me because they spanned so many disciplines — psychiatry, endocrinology, bioethics, social policy — and because the politicization of the topic had left so much basic research neglected. The polarization was especially striking given how much quiet consensus existed. According to Pew Research Center surveys in 2022 and 2025, most Americans believe gender is determined by sex at birth. Most favor requiring transgender athletes to compete on teams matching their biological sex. Most support protecting transgender people from discrimination. But most also draw a line at irreversible medical interventions on minors. These aren’t fringe positions. Yet for years, many academics apparently hesitated to say such things out loud.
The study I ended up conducting tracked more than 11,000 American children in a nationally representative sample, documenting changes in gender identity and mental health from ages 8 to 15. In 2016, less than 1 percent of the sample identified as transgender or nonbinary. By 2023, that number had risen to nearly 10 percent of females. The vast majority identified as nonbinary rather than transgender and re-identified as cisgender within a year.
The pattern looked less like an inborn mismatch between brain and body and more like a symptom of the broader turbulence of puberty. Children already struggling with depression or anxiety were more likely to later identify as transgender, but gender incongruence did not predict later mental health. Kids who spent more time on screens were also more likely to identify as transgender. The profiles of those who would later identify as transgender resembled those at risk for eating disorders and self-harm, which also spike in adolescent females. But in the prototypical case, “she/they” rarely met diagnostic criteria for gender dysphoria, let alone medical sex reassignment. For most of these adolescents, this appeared to simply be identity exploration during a time of stress.
That did not stop my work from becoming controversial. Most graduate students in Harvard’s Psychology Department would not associate with me when I became outspoken about this issue. Formal complaints were made against me at the university, not for any specific act of harm but because my research was considered a form of hostility.
Yet for all of the deserved criticism higher education has recently faced, these were mere social frictions. After Steven Pinker, a psychology professor and longtime champion of academic freedom at Harvard, agreed to oversee my dissertation when no other faculty member would, I was able to do exactly the work I set out to do. My research proposals passed ethics reviews. My committee provided constructive feedback. Academic freedom is only as strong as the people who uphold it, but our institutions themselves are robust.
That is worth stating plainly in the aftermath of the Trump administration freezing more than $2 billion of Harvard’s federal grants over allegations of discrimination and lack of viewpoint diversity. My own National Institutes of Health fellowship — which had funded the very type of research that conservatives had celebrated as a corrective to progressive orthodoxy — was among the casualties.
Ironically, the Republican movement that eagerly cited the possibility that some gender dysphoria involves social contagion and prior mental health issues was now defunding the science that tested those very hypotheses. Meanwhile, the progressives within the academy who made my daily life difficult never actually stopped my work. The liberal institution of Harvard protected my right to do it.
The easy interpretation — that both sides are full of hypocrites who only support free inquiry when they like the answers — is too cynical to be fully satisfying and too accurate to be dismissed.
What my research actually showed, and what neither side wants to hear, is that both are partly right. Most adolescents with gender dysphoria are going through a turbulent period of identity exploration that will resolve on its own. But a small minority of people have a biologically grounded experience of gender misalignment. The only way to support them is individualized care, guided by evidence rather than ideology.
I became a scientist because I believed that science was about finding the truth. That belief has been tested from every direction over the past four years: by activists who thought my questions were harmful, by colleagues who thought I was putting my career at risk, by a government that decided the whole line of inquiry was expendable. But the fact that I was able to pursue this work at all, when the incentives pointed overwhelmingly toward silence, is itself a kind of evidence. Academic freedom is embattled but alive.
Hobbes fails to understand that the original reporter who published the AMA’s statement saying it sided with the ASPS on youth gender surgeries was not Jeremy Peters, it was Andrew Jacobs, who could in no way be considered a part of this supposed “anti-trans braintrust.” Peters was only reiterating what Jacobs originally reported.
And yes, the statement was a shift, otherwise the AMA wouldn’t be trying to walk it back and say they were misquoted. Because the AMA knows that the statement reads as if they did make a shift in policy.
Hobbes is pointing to this WPATH FAQ without acknowledging (or knowing) that it actually misrepresents what the organization’s trans-care guidelines, The Standards of Care Version 8 (SoC 8) says. WPATH famously removed all age limits (except for phalloplasty) in the SoC 8 when it was published in Sept 2022 under pressure from the American Academy of Pediatrics.
A Wall Street Journal report found that the enmity toward @JK_Rowling over her stance on transgender issues had not appeared to impact the multi-billionaire business of Harry Potter. But The Verge says that every dime of that is unethically spent.
"This policy is common sense," Bob Costas tells @CNN of the IOC policy excluding biological males from the women's category in the Olympics. He also emphasizes that there are bad actors who leverage animus against trans people for political gain and that this is bad.
Quotes a post by T23292; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Jeremy Peters at the Times quotes the @NRO quoting the AMA. Now the AMA says the quote was wrong. How did it become wrong and why is the AMA first claiming as much six weeks later? https://www.nytimes.com/2026/03/16/us/politics/dr-oz-transgender-meeting.html
NEWS: Transgender women athletes banned from Olympics by new IOC policy on female eligibility
LAUSANNE, Switzerland (AP) — Transgender women athletes are now excluded from the Olympics after the IOC agreed to a new eligibility policy on Thursday which aligns with U.S. President Donald Trump’s executive order on women’s sports ahead of the 2028 Los Angeles Games.
“Eligibility for any female category event at the Olympic Games or any other IOC event, including individual and team sports, is now limited to biological females,” the International Olympic Committee said, “determined on the basis of a one‑time SRY gene screening.”
It is unclear how many, if any, transgender women are competing at an Olympic level. No woman who transitioned from being born male competed at the 2024 Paris Summer Games.
The eligibility policy that will apply from the LA Olympics in July 2028 “protects fairness, safety and integrity in the female category,” the IOC said.
Internet-culture reporter @TaylorLorenz attributes legislative efforts to protect youth from social media to anti-trans animus:
“It’s shocking how the motivation behind almost every single bad tech bill is about hating LGBTQ people and specifically trans people.
“It underpins absolutely everything. We have anti-LGBTQ hate groups leading the messaging on these ‘social media addiction’ trials and MSM repeating it verbatim, it’s really bad.”
This presumes that treating the dysphoria with hormones was invariably the right choice, especially given the seething disdain that many in the gender medicine world hold toward any form of assessment that might want to know whether this kid’s transgender identity was deeply felt or whether it was a manifestation of some other issue.
Arguing against laws banning pediatric gender-transition treatment, transgender left-wing pundit Parker Molloy draws an analogy to vaccination policies.
She omits the fact that laws do mandate vaccinations as a condition of attending school, although there are loopholes.
Strangio could’ve compromised on prisons but chose not to. He could’ve agreed to segregated housing for trans women in men’s prisons. But he wouldn’t back down from “trans women are women,” and that has likely worsened the cultural and legal backlash.
The ACLU I suppose might’ve stopped the momentum of the process that brought Skrmetti to the Supreme Court. But someone else could’ve just brought it there anyway. And the big fear was that Boe v Marshall would progress enough to dump a massive evidential record before the Supreme Court and summarily humiliate WPATH in particular. So people say ACLU opted to head that off. It didn’t work, since the WPATH records were still unsealed. But fewer people paid attention to them absent the Supreme Court drawing attention.
Then there’s just Strangio’s stubborn personality and confrontational style, which has alienated a lot of people.
The Evolution of Chase Strangio:
2021: People who say that sex is binary are anti-trans.
2025: "I am very hesitant to announce things as transphobic without having an opportunity to try to have conversations."
Quoting @benryanwriter: ACLU litigator Chase Strangio in a 2021 Medium essay: "The assumption behind the anti-trans rhetoric is that there is a single biological characteristic that one can locate and name that demarcates the so-called biological line between the binary of maleness and femaleness."
Actually, there is: the gametes. There is no spectrum. They do not come in size medium. There is only large or small.
ACLU litigator Chase Strangio in a 2021 Medium essay: "The assumption behind the anti-trans rhetoric is that there is a single biological characteristic that one can locate and name that demarcates the so-called biological line between the binary of maleness and femaleness."
Actually, there is: the gametes. There is no spectrum. They do not come in size medium. There is only large or small.
I once had an editor at a major MSM outlet tell me that they couldn’t run my article on the trans kids stuff because they were afraid of the GLAAD truck.
Quoting @benryanwriter: A false claim from @GLAAD: "The science is settled."
How GLAAD Changed Under Sarah Kate Ellis:
Hernon Graddick, the former head of @GLAAD on gender transitions for kids: "I think we need to correct what's wrong...particularly the medicalization of children...Teenagers and kids should not be given the power to make these life-altering decisions that medicalization causes."
Sarah Kate Ellis @[private account], the current head of GLAAD: "In terms of trans kids and gender-affirming care. The American Medical Association has confirmed that these are safe procedures. This is finished business. It's politicians and junk science who's creating some kind of debate or argument about this."
These quotes and so much more are in @[private account]'s new podcast series for Andy Mills' Reflector, "Strange Bedfellows," which tracks how the LGBs merged with the Ts, got queered by the Qs, and may be facing a divorce.
Abby Stein, a member of NYC Mayor Mamdani’s health team and a transgender woman, suggests on NY1 that his administration is working on means to ensure minors’ access to gender-transition treatment, which she asserted dramatically lowers suicide death risk. During his campaign, @ZohranKMamdani @[private account] pledged to spend $65 M in city funds on gender-transition projects interventions. But he took office only to find a massive hole in the budget. And NYU Langone and Mt Sinai have shuttered their pediatric gender clinics in the face of threats from the Trump admin. But NY AG Tish James has threatened to sue NYU if they don’t reopen.
Three percent of teenagers reported identifying as transgender by 2023, up from close to zero 15 years prior.
Does this make them the smallest and least significant demographic as David Roberts asserts they are?
Here is a longer, six-minute clip of the interview with Lurie Children’s Dr. Robert Garofalo, who describes how his pediatric gender clinic responds to parents asking whether their children are really transgender:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D1zyADqL_28
I do believe that it's possible to talk about the complex ethical questions at play in the trans-sports issue without losing one's head and resorting to a lot of ugliness and name calling.
That said, given the zero-sum and high-stakes nature of collegiate and elite sports, there are going to be winners and losers in this debate. Unlike with the question of pediatric gender medicine, in which the treatments only directly affect the patient, with sports there are going to be winners and losers. There is unlikely to be a compromise that makes everyone happy.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Research suggests that gender-transition treatment does not fully erase the competitive advantages conferred by male puberty and that even prepubescent boys have a small advantage over girls.
Some people argue that, these findings notwithstanding, inclusion should trump all (see: @EmmaVigeland of @[private account]). Others cannot seem to explain their reasoning. They rely on accusations of bigotry, as @[private account] has here, or other emotional appeals to justify inclusion. Others engage in denialism, falsely claiming that there is no competitive advantage conferred by male puberty or that Lia Thomas' time on estrogen erased that advantage for her.
Above all, it's important for us to clearly establish what fairness means in sports and why there is a female category. And based on those reasons, what values should determine who gets to play and in what category?
https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/japplphysiol.00615.2024
I appreciate making those distinctions and stating your reasons clearly. I much prefer this to sweeping accusations of throwing people under the bus. In competitive sports, this raises the question of whether one group is being favored over another for this bus-throwing business. In other words, if inclusion must trump all, but trans women maintain a competitive advantage in the women's category, then aren't women being thrown under the bus?
The Blueskyites are having a fit over the tweet below. To which I reply: What if the therapists have no systematic, or accurate, way of discerning a gay child from a trans child? And what if children and adolescents, known for shifts in identity, are mistaken about who they are? And what if this mistake leads them to undergo irreversible treatments and surgeries?
Quoting @benryanwriter: I can assure you, having spoken to child psychologists at length about this very question, that they are not the bearers of some sort of cosmic intuition that discerns gay from trans in children. Nor has the field of pediatric medicine sought to systematically grapple with this question of how to separate one child from another. Some of the biggest names in the field simply leave the matter up to the kid, asserting that kids “know who they are.”
Two civil-rights lawsuits assert that this did in fact happen to the plaintiffs: Shapeshifter v Fenway and Garcia-Ryan v Callen-Lorde. These gay men each allege that the LGBTQ clinics violated their civil rights by misinterpreting their internalized homophobia as gender dysphoria warranting a medicalized gender transition. Both men received vaginoplasties, only to realize they were gay and not trans.
Quoting @benryanwriter: IN DEFENSE OF EFFEMINATE GAY BOYS
If anyone had suggested that I might really be a girl, I don’t know how I would have responded, by @[private account] for @TheAtlantic.
GIFT LINK: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/03/gay-boys-lgbtq-trans/686179/?gift=KkbsgAqgmImeUM71Y0bfDLYjEv4OtjbAPG_MGSHk8zI&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share
Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes, who was born in the mid-1980s, did not confuse his homosexuality with a trans identity or experience gender dysphoria as a child, therefore this does not happen to any child, he says.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes denounces @[private account]’s article in @TheAtlantic as “absolute trash.” He faults Appel for not citing medical professionals.
“Child psychologists know the difference between gay kids and trans kids,” Hobbes insists, without citing medical profs.
In 2019, Ed Yong took a stab at the issue:
Young Trans Children Know Who They Are
A new study shows that gender-nonconforming kids who go on to transition already have a strong sense of their true identity—one that differs from their assigned gender.
https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2019/01/young-trans-children-know-who-they-are/580366/
The War on Trans Kids Is Totally Unconstitutional
States do not have a defensible reason for denying children recommended medical care.
By Ronald J. Krotoszynski, Jr.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/05/anti-transgender-children-laws-unconstitutional/618864/
This 2023 article was cowritten by a transgender man:
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/01/detransition-transgender-nonbinary-gender-affirming-care/672745/
Take Detransitioners Seriously
Some people reverse their gender transition. Understanding their experience is crucial.
By Daniela Valdes and Kinnon MacKinnon
I can assure you, having spoken to child psychologists at length about this very question, that they are not the bearers of some sort of cosmic intuition that discerns gay from trans in children. Nor has the field of pediatric medicine sought to systematically grapple with this question of how to separate one child from another. Some of the biggest names in the field simply leave the matter up to the kid, asserting that kids “know who they are.”
Garcia-Ryan v Callen-Lorde and Shapeshifter v Fenway Health both argue that this very thing happened to the plaintiffs—two gay men who underwent vaginoplasties after, they assert, they and their care providers misinterpreted them as trans women.
Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes denounces @[private account]’s article in @TheAtlantic as “absolute trash.” He faults Appel for not citing medical professionals.
“Child psychologists know the difference between gay kids and trans kids,” Hobbes insists, without citing medical profs.
Quoting @benryanwriter: IN DEFENSE OF EFFEMINATE GAY BOYS
If anyone had suggested that I might really be a girl, I don’t know how I would have responded, by @[private account] for @TheAtlantic.
GIFT LINK: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/03/gay-boys-lgbtq-trans/686179/?gift=KkbsgAqgmImeUM71Y0bfDLYjEv4OtjbAPG_MGSHk8zI&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share
IN DEFENSE OF EFFEMINATE GAY BOYS
If anyone had suggested that I might really be a girl, I don’t know how I would have responded, by @[private account] for @TheAtlantic.
GIFT LINK: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/03/gay-boys-lgbtq-trans/686179/?gift=KkbsgAqgmImeUM71Y0bfDLYjEv4OtjbAPG_MGSHk8zI&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share
N.Y. Attorney General Orders Hospital to Resume Youth Transgender Care
NYU Langone Health had stopped providing puberty-blocking medication and hormone treatments after the federal government threatened to pull its funding.
Brad Lander @bradlander, Dem candidate for Congress in Brooklyn, looking to unseat Dan Goldman @[private account], speaks at a protest over NYU Langone shuttering its pediatric gender clinic, saying that the Trump admin’s attack on trans kids is the first step in a fascist takeover.
18 year old transgender activist speaks at protest in front of NYU Langone over the hospital shuttering its pediatric gender clinic. The youth recalls being denied an appointment for gender-transition treatment at Mt Sinai before turning 18 and now the hospital’s moving of the goalpost to age 19 in the face of the Trump admin’s threats.
“Gender-affirming care is life-saving care and we will win,” says New York State assemblyman and congressional candidate Alex Bores @[private account] at a protest before NYU Langone over its shuttering of its pediatric gender clinic. He accuses the Trump admin of a campaign to erase transgender people. Bores seeks to replace Rep Jerry Nadler in NY-12, up against Kennedy scion @[private account] Jack Schlossberg.
The World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH, tells a brazen falsehood in its statement responding to the American Society for Plastic Surgeon's position statement advising against gender transition surgeries for patients under age 19. WPATH claims that its "cautious guardrails" for such surgeries "acknowledge that there is no definitive age or 'one-size-fits-all' approach for every patient, which is
why they are built on case-by-case assessments."
Internal emails subpoenaed by Alabama's attorney general, Steve Marshall, demonstrated in 2024 that the American Academy of Pediatrics and Biden administration health official Admiral Rachel Levine pressured WPATH to remove the age limits on gender transition surgeries in the revision of its Standards of Care trans-care guidelines in 2022. WPATH caved and did so at the 11th hour. Then they concocted a story to tell the public about why they did this: that they preferred individualized care and age limits got in the way of this.
WPATH is still telling this false story, despite the fact that it has long since been made public why they removed age limits in the SoC Version 8.
Journalists Should Not Use the Term “Assigned Sex at Birth” When Covering Transgender Issues
https://benryan.substack.com/p/journalists-should-not-use-the-term
A political-activist term misappropriated from the intersex context, it sticks a thumb on the scale regarding a contested legal issue about which reporters should strive to observe neutrality.
The ACLU has sued Kansas over its law invalidating the driver’s licenses of transgender residents.
“SB 244 is a cruel and craven threat to public safety all in the name of fostering fear, division, and paranoia,” said the ACLU’s Harper Seldin.
https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/transgender-kansans-challenge-state-law-invalidating-their-drivers-licenses-and-allowing-them-to-be-sued-for-using-public-restrooms
All the recent increase in trans identification has been in people born after 1980. Look at the charts at the end of this: https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim?r=7wxo1&utm_medium=ios
After encouraging Jesse Singal to kill himself last year, cranky podcaster Noah Kulwin @[private account] is now resorting to the age-old false tale that Singal goes around harassing trans people. This as people on Bluesky are threatening violence against Singal as we speak.
Quotes a post by T13008; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
For @[private account], @JesseSingal writes:
The A.P.A. presents a particularly striking case of why transparency is important. In 2024, it published what it touted as a “groundbreaking policy supporting transgender, gender diverse, nonbinary individuals” that was specifically geared at fighting “misinformation” on that subject. But when I reached out to the group this month, it pointed me to a different document, a letterwritten by the group’s chief advocacy officer, Katherine McGuire, in September in response to a Federal Trade Commission request for comment on youth gender medicine.
The documents, separated by about a year and a half (and, perhaps as significantly, one presidential election), straightforwardly contradict each other. The A.P.A. in 2024 argued that there is a “comprehensive body of psychological and medical research supporting the positive impact of gender-affirming treatments” for individuals “across the life span.” But in 2025, the group argued that “psychologists do not make broad claims about treatment effectiveness.”
In 2024, the A.P.A. criticized those “mischaracterizing gender dysphoria as a manifestation of traumatic stress or neurodivergence.” In 2025, it cautioned that gender dysphoria diagnoses could be the result of “trauma-related presentations” rather than a trans identity, and noted that “co-occurring mental health or neurodevelopmental conditions (e.g., depression, anxiety, autism spectrum disorder) … may complicate or be mistaken for gender dysphoria.” It seems undeniable that the 2025 A.P.A. published what the 2024 A.P. A considered to be “misinformation.” (“The 2024 policy statement and the 2025 F.T.C. letter are consistent,” said Ms. McGuire in an email, and “both documents reflect A.P.A.’s consistent commitment to evidence-based psychological care.”)
He overlooks the fact that transgender identification in minors went from vanishingly rare to 3% in under 15 years and society is indeed responding to that dramatic shift.
Unheard Testimony From WPATH's President Elect In the Historic Detransitioner Lawsuit: "A reasonable surgeon would have put on the brakes."
https://benryan.substack.com/p/unheard-testimony-from-wpaths-president
Dr. Loren Schechter, the president elect of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, provided damning testimony against the plastic surgeon in this medical-malpractice trial.
Imagine if Wired had published a cover like this with stereotypes about other minority groups.
What might those covers had looked like if the secret power cliques were black, Native American, transgender or autistic people?
California state senator Scott Wiener, who is running for Nancy Pelosi’s seat in Congress, calls for a federal transgender civil rights bill as Republicans escalate their efforts to pass transgender-related restrictions.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Kinnon Ross MacKinnon is a transgender man and an academic at York University. He is also one of the only academics with the courage to study detransitioning, making him a top expert on the subject. Andrea James would have you believe his estimate range is “anti-trans extremism.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: As Andrea James knows, I said that we don’t know what the detransition rate for youth is but that maybe it’s 5%-10%. And as James also knows, I got that estimate from Kinnon Ross MacKinnon, who is a trans man and one of the only researchers courageous enough to study detransitioning. James thinks she knows better than MacKinnon what the estimate range should be, but I don’t know how she or anyone else would claim a greater authority on the subject.
As for writing for The Free Press, I took the story of the detransitioner trial to them because I knew they were the best outlet for it. This allowed me to write a long feature, get top notch editing, and get a lot of eyeballs on the piece.
Otherwise, the piece stands for itself. I have not heard any of these critics say a single thing about what was wrong with the actual content of the article. There’s just all this needling around the edges. That’s what James does. She can’t find anything substantive to say so she just twists the truth and cooks up her usual sloppy buffet of drama.
I have had to block the gender critical em masse because they got so incredibly nasty over the pronoun issue. My life is so much more calm without them nagging me. Anyone who corrects my pronouns when I call a trans woman “she” gets an automatic block.
As Andrea James knows, I said that we don’t know what the detransition rate for youth is but that maybe it’s 5%-10%. And as James also knows, I got that estimate from Kinnon Ross MacKinnon, who is a trans man and one of the only researchers courageous enough to study detransitioning. James thinks she knows better than MacKinnon what the estimate range should be, but I don’t know how she or anyone else would claim a greater authority on the subject.
As for writing for The Free Press, I took the story of the detransitioner trial to them because I knew they were the best outlet for it. This allowed me to write a long feature, get top notch editing, and get a lot of eyeballs on the piece.
Otherwise, the piece stands for itself. I have not heard any of these critics say a single thing about what was wrong with the actual content of the article. There’s just all this needling around the edges. That’s what James does. She can’t find anything substantive to say so she just twists the truth and cooks up her usual sloppy buffet of drama.
The Good Law Project’s false and misleading claims about suicides in youth who identify as trans in the UK have people falsely claiming the increase followed Streeting’s continuing of the post-Cass ban. This is false. The increase occurred in 2021-2022, over two years before the ban. Plus, only 1 in 4 of the suicides were in youth diagnosed with gender dysphoria, a requirement to even try to get puberty blockers and hormones. See: https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/britains-good-law-project-again-claims?r=7wxo1&utm_medium=ios
As for what Cass recommended, she called for gender-transition drugs to be limited to a clinical trial. Some have falsely claimed she called for even greater access than before. This is false, if what was meant by that was access in everyday practice not restricted to research settings.
Quoting @benryanwriter: NEWS: Long-awaited British child puberty blocker trials paused after watchdog concerns
Scheme open to those as young as eight faces growing backlash.
A trial of puberty blockers for children will be paused following concerns from the healthcare regulator.
The Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) has stepped in amid a growing backlash over the experiment, which was open to those as young as eight.
In a letter to those running the trial, the MHRA said it wanted to discuss introducing a minimum age of 14 for participants.
A group of over 70 New York State legislators have demanded that NYU reverse the shuttering of its pediatric gender clinic in the face of threats from Trump. The letter includes the claim that gender-transition treatments for minors are "lifesaving," which is not supported by the research.
They write to the dean:
"We urge you to reconsider NYU Langone's recent decision to discontinue the Transgender Youth Health Program. Gender affirming care is essential healthcare, and disruption to treatment can have dangerous effects on patients, including higher rates of depression and increased attempts at self harm. We are disturbed by this decision and request you immediately reinstate care for transgender and gender expansive youth.
"This announcement comes as the Department of Health and Human Services is about to finalize a rule that would prohibit institutions providing gender affirming care for transgender and gender expansive youth from receiving any Federal funding. While we appreciate these attacks from the Federal Government have created a confusing regulatory environment for hospitals, we cannot allow young people in need of care to bear the brunt of this confusion and be denied access to lifesaving healthcare services.
"Your decision is not only harmful to New York families, it may be in violation of New York City and New York State Human Rights Laws. In a letter sent to hospitals last year, Attorney General Letitia James has made it clear that refusing services based on a protected status, such as gender identity or a diagnosis of gender dysphoria, is considered discrimination under New York law. We call on NYU Langone, one of New York's most powerful healthcare institutions, to stand with us and with our trans community and immediately reverse this decision."
Julia Serano is among those who argue that it never would have occurred to the public or researchers that adolescent transgender identification in at least some cases was driven by social influences had it not been for an obscure web forum in the mid-2010s suggesting as much.
This includes, for example, parents who have observed that in quick succession, a substantial proportion of their child’s small private school 6th grade class began to identify as transgender.
Nor would it have ever occurred to pediatricians or gender clinic staffers that social influences might have been driving the sudden exponential growth in gender dysphoria among patients following the onset of phone-based social media in about 2012.
Among those who believe that the theory of social contagion had a single source, the 4th Wave Now web site, is debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes, who has spoken at length on his podcasts about how were it not for that site, Lisa Littman @[private account] never would’ve coined the term rapid-onset gender dysphoria, and apparently no one would be wondering if social contagion was driving the explosive growth in gender dysphoria and trans identification among adolescents, which went from vanishingly rare in the 2000s to 3% today.
To be more specific, the question that no one has ever been able to satisfactorily answer is this: What exactly is it about my covering the delicate ethics of providing irreversible medical interventions that change the bodies of minors to treat gender-related distress among them is rooted in animus toward transgender people in general?
And to turn the tables, what is it about people who would profess to know my personal beliefs that motivates them to resort to base ad hominem attacks in an effort to discourage me from or punish me for covering this subject rather than actually engaging with the specifics of my reporting and taking issue with any particular article I wrote?
Transgender Map: Keeping Circular Reasoning Alive
People who Andrea James does not like are transphobic. How does Andrea James know this? Because they are branded as transphobic on the web site she runs to smear people she does not like.
Quotes a post by T06613; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Two years ago, WPATH suggested in a statement that the majority of adolescents who identify as transgender would do better to undergo a medical transition.
There has been a recent surge in trans identification in youth. I sent emails to many pediatricians looking to see if they had any thoughts as to why. I sent that email with the full knowledge that it would be posted online. Which it was. I stand by that email.
Publishing the truth about public opinion is not anti-trans. It is journalism. @[private account] and @[private account] have nothing to apologize for. People's totally unhinged responses to their reporting is what should be cause for reflection.
Claiming that a woman getting her breasts done or a man getting a chin implant amounts to gender-affirming care requires two things:
1) It requires that everyone is on board with the expression "gender-affirming care" in the first place. I do not use this expression in my writing, because it is a medical term with a political messaged baked in. It presumes that doctors are invariably affirming the correct gender, per se. Thus, it precludes the very possibility of detransitioning. Medical terms should be as neutral as possible and not come with promises they cannot keep.
2) It ignores the fact that was gender-transition treatment actually does is it changes sex characteristics to make them more like those of the opposite sex. Cosmetic surgery that enhances someone's natal sex, such as by making a woman curvier or her lips larger or expanding the width of a man's jaw or making his muscles larger, accentuates attributes related to their birth sex.
Also, by making this comparison between gender-transition surgeries and elective plastic surgeries, people such as @JillFilipovic actually de-emphasize the fundamental need that transgender people assert they have to undergo these surgeries. It couches them as elective cosmetic surgeries, which raises the question of why insurance would cover them and why they should be described as beneficial to mental health and even "life saving".
Quoting @JillFilipovic: Gender-affirming surgeries out of control
NEWS: After the California attorney general sued Rady Children’s for shutting down their gender clinic for fear of losing Medicaid funds under Trump’s threats, a judge has ordered the hospital to resume treatment, at least for now. https://voiceofsandiego.org/2026/02/11/rady-childrens-hospital-must-continue-trans-care-for-now/
A missing piece of the puzzle pertaining to why Democrats pay a price for their positions on trans issues is that much if not most of the action occurs on the state and local level. National politicians tend to engage in less direct politicking about these issues than state legislators, governors, mayors and attorneys general. This leads to the false claim that Democrats aren't really doing much regarding trans issues, that only Republicans are taking action.
We see, for example, states passing sanctuary laws to try to guarantee minors' access to gender-transition drugs. We see state AGs such as Leticia James in New York or the AG of California, threatening to sue or outright suing hospitals for shuttering their pediatric gender clinics. We see Gov Tim Walz vowing to protect trans kids. We don't see that level of direct action from Dems in Congress.
What we have seen is that any national Dem politician who speaks up and raises what amount to normie questions about trans issues is subjected to a concerted and organized campaign by activists and what one could call The Groups to silence them. Rep @[private account] of Massachusetts expressed concerns about fairness in sports and was so inundated with anger that he back pedaled.
Quoting @daveweigel: There’s a progressive talking point about how Dems enabled a trans backlash bc they clammed up and let Rs control the story.
But Biden admin really leaned into trans visibility, and the acceptance #s went down https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/02/26/americans-have-grown-more-supportive-of-restrictions-for-trans-people-in-recent-years/
There's a live video right now by @[private account]'s @[private account] and @[private account] about their white-hot polling on trans issues:
https://open.substack.com/live-stream/116297?utm_source=live-stream-share-button
Does Filipovic err in using the overly broad term “anti-trans” to characterize nuanced attitudes?
The typical American supports anti-discrimination statutes for trans people in housing and employment, but has concerns about the safety and wisdom of giving minors irreversible gender-transition interventions and about the fairness of natal males participating in girls and women’s sports.
Does holding these nuanced opinions make a person “anti-trans”?
Quoting @JillFilipovic: The anti-trans movement did a great job at focusing the public's attention on women's sports and surgeries on adolescents. In reality, most people support the policies that will help many more trans people: Antidiscrimination laws in housing, hiring, etc. There is a path fwd
The New York Times reports that NYU Langone has shuttered its pediatric gender clinic in the face of the Trump administration’s threats of withdrawing Medicaid funding.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/02/17/nyregion/nyu-hospital-transgender-youth.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share
Quoting @benryanwriter: According to Manhattan’s Borough President, a number of New York City hospitals have capitulated in the face of threats from Trump and will cease proving gender-transition interventions of patients under 19. Mamdani has proposed spending tens of millions of city funds to provide such interventions, however.
The NYC borough president wrote the following to the NYS health commissioner:
https://www.nysenate.gov/newsroom/articles/2025/brad-hoylman-sigal/letter-new-york-state-department-health-gender-affirming
Dear Commissioner McDonald:
As you know, recently at least two New York hospitals have confirmed they have paused providing gender affirming care to new patients under the age of 19.
In response, on February 3, 2025, Attorney General James sent a letter to all hospitals and medical providers across New York State that stated in no uncertain terms:
Electing to refuse services to a class of individuals based on their protected status, such as withholding the availability of services from transgender individuals based on their gender identity or their diagnosis of gender dysphoria, while offering such services to cisgender individuals, is discrimination under New York law.
We are writing to request that the New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH) issue a directive to all hospitals and medical providers alerting them to the Attorney General’s position and ordering them not to halt gender affirming care because it is a violation of New York State law.
On February 11, during the Health/Medicaid Joint Budget Hearing, Senator Hoylman-Sigal asked you what NYSDOH was doing to protect the wellbeing of young transgender people in response to the Trump Administration's directive. You responded that NYSDOH was sending out guidance to hospitals “today or tomorrow” — but as of today, almost a week later, no guidance has been publicly posted. You elaborated that it was “really important” for hospitals and health care workers to understand their obligations to provide necessary care, continuity of care, and to not discriminate against patients —and yet, as far as we are aware, hospitals that paused providing gender affirming care to new patients under the age of 19 have not resumed scheduling appointments.
If these hospitals do not reverse their decisions and other healthcare providers follow, lives will be put at risk. Therefore, it is imperative that all providers be made aware of their legal obligation to provide any New Yorker with life-preserving gender affirming care, including those under 19. While it is our sincere hope that all New York hospitals and healthcare providers will prioritize the safety and well-being of their patients — especially during this period of uncertainty — we need clear directives from the NYSDOH to help ensure they do so.
Please advise us what steps NYSDOH is taking to address this pressing matter (including by sharing any guidance that NYSDOH has provided to hospitals) at your earliest possible convenience.
Here is Dr. Loren Schechter, head of gender affirming surgery at Rush University Medical Center in Chicago and the president-elect of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) on his own practices in minors in the recent detransitioner trial. As you can see, he is dramatically more cautious about providing such surgeries to minors than Dr. Loren Serletti, who was the other plastic surgeon expert witness in the case. I wrote about the contrasts between teh two here: https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-historic-detransitioner-lawsuits
Ryan Cooper, senior editor at The American Prospect, is in the crowd of people who believe that @[private account] and @[private account] should not inform the public that the principle tenets of transgender activism are a major liability for Democrats.
Quoting @benryanwriter: A majority of voters oppose minors' access to gender transition drugs, as do 31% of Harris voters and 36% of Harris voters who are parents, @[private account] finds for @[private account].
I call these concerns “the chief tenets of the transgender advocacy movement” rather than framing it as a matter of civil rights. Because this raises the question of how we know whether a child is truly transgender and what that actually means. Saying that giving children these drugs is a matter of trans rights per se forecloses on those unanswered questions.
Transgender activist and pundit Parker Molloy claims that by reporting that support has eroded for the main tenets of transgender activism, @[private account] is running “anti-trans pieces.”
Would Molloy prefer that @[private account] and @[private account] keep these facts secret?
Quoting @benryanwriter: A majority of voters oppose minors' access to gender transition drugs, as do 31% of Harris voters and 36% of Harris voters who are parents, @[private account] finds for @[private account].
Jill Filipovic on the complex dynamics between the far left and the right that have likely influenced the public's perceptions on the core tenets animating transgender activism:
Quoting @JillFilipovic: The anti-trans movement just outplayed progressives on this one, and I think progressives made a real error by trying to shout down normie concerns (fairness in sports, surgeries on adolescents) as bigotry rather than engaging in some tough questions. The anti-trans movement did a great job at exploiting those more divisive points to tar all trans activism as extreme and a threat. And now they're coming for trans people who just want to live their damn lives.
The World Professional Association for Transgender Health calls their trans-care guidelines The Standards of Care. In a medical-malpractice case, the question is whether the doctor departed from the standard of care. But the president elect of WPATH says its SoC is not the soc.
Quoting @benryanwriter: WPATH's Trans-Care Bible "Is Not Considered the Standard of Care"—Unheard Testimony From the $2M Detransitioner Lawsuit
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-historic-detransitioner-lawsuits
The 3-week trial heard from two highly credentialed plastic surgeons who painted vastly different—and at times remarkably revealing—portraits of gender-transition surgery for minors.
The backlash to the principle tenets of transgender activism is real
In polling for @[private account], @[private account] finds that a majority of Americans and a considerable faction of Harris voters, albeit not a majority, oppose gender-transition drugs for minors and allowing K-12 athletes to compete according to their gender identity. Harris voters who are parents are more opposed to these concerns than Harris voters as a whole.
Quoting @benryanwriter: A majority of voters oppose minors' access to gender transition drugs, as do 31% of Harris voters and 36% of Harris voters who are parents, @[private account] finds for @[private account].
The World Professional Association for Transgender Health’s Standards of Care “is not considered the standard of care.”
—Dr. Loren Schechter, WPATH’s president elect
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/the-historic-detransitioner-lawsuits
Quoting @benryanwriter: WPATH's Trans-Care Bible "Is Not Considered the Standard of Care"—Unheard Testimony From the $2M Detransitioner Lawsuit
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-historic-detransitioner-lawsuits
The 3-week trial heard from two highly credentialed plastic surgeons who painted vastly different—and at times remarkably revealing—portraits of gender-transition surgery for minors.
British transgender activist Mallory Moore responds to Hilary Cass’s interview with tectonic anger, in particular over Cass’s words of caution that socially transitioning kids could lock in a trans identity that they might’ve otherwise grown out of, putting them on a path to lifelong medicalization and sometimes “brutal” surgeries. 1/2
Quoting @benryanwriter: An interview with Hilary Cass:
WPATH's Trans-Care Bible "Is Not Considered the Standard of Care"—Unheard Testimony From the $2M Detransitioner Lawsuit
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-historic-detransitioner-lawsuits
The 3-week trial heard from two highly credentialed plastic surgeons who painted vastly different—and at times remarkably revealing—portraits of gender-transition surgery for minors.
Others suggest that just maybe at least some of the three percent of the young people identifying as transgender have done so purely or largely out of a response to social cues they have absorbed from social media in particular.
Some argue that for at least some youth with gender dysphoria, they are channeling their underlying mental health problems into gender dysphoria, and that their trans identity and search for treatments and surgeries that will alter their sex characteristics amount to a maladaptive coping mechanism that will not address their underlying psychopathology.
According to Imara Jones, author of the podcast series “The-Anti-Trans Hate Machine,” which has chronicled the mounting public opposition to the major tenets of trans activism, 3% of all people have always been transgender. This is just the first generation to have felt free to unveil this fact.
Quotes a post by T04255; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
They Questioned Trans Medicine for Kids. The World Is Just Catching Up.
Jamie Reed @JamieWhistle, Jesse Singal @JesseSingal, and Emily Yoffe @[private account] on exposing the harms of child gender transition for @TheFP.
https://www.thefp.com/p/they-questioned-trans-medicine-for
Twenty-three percent of 18 to 29 year olds report being LGBTQ, overwhelmingly due to reported bisexuality.
Three percent of those young adults report a transgender identity, compared with 1.3% of 30 to 49 year olds and less than 0.5% of older cohorts.
Quotes a post by T03074; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
History Is Repeating Itself In the Battle Over Conversion Therapy
https://benryan.substack.com/p/history-is-repeating-itself-in-the
@[private account] guests on my Sustack: The mental health profession learned a hard lesson after mistreating gay people during the 20th century, only to repeat those same mistakes—albeit in the name of undoing them—with trans patients.
You could always acknowledge that @TheAtlantic is famous for its reporting that has been skeptical of pediatric gender medicine, most notably by @JesseSingal and @HelenLewis, dating back to 2018. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/07/when-a-child-says-shes-trans/561749/?gift=KkbsgAqgmImeUM71Y0bfDPzRNPDOUWz5HZOWGx964Dc
Dr. Hilary Cass argues that socially transitioning children can lock in a trans identity that could lead to lifelong medicalization and the need for difficult surgeries when the kid otherwise would’ve likely grown out of gender dysphoria.
Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes dismisses this argument with the wave of a hand and calls it “bigotry.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: An interview with Hilary Cass:
Children 'weaponised' by both sides of trans debate, Cass says
Children have been "weaponised" by both sides of a toxic debate about transgender rights, the author of a government review into the treatment of children and young people questioning their gender has said.
Dr Hilary Cass told Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg "people at the extremes" had caused "quite a lot of distress for young people".
She also suggested "unrealistic images and expectations on social media" had misled children, and that if some young people had "taken more time" they might not have pursued medical treatments.
Her 2024 review found gender medicine had been operating on "shaky foundations" when it came to evidence for medical treatment.
Jessica Kant complains that the right-wing is stirring manufactured outrage about transgender people.
Two weeks ago, the first detransitioner lawsuit to go to trial reached a $2M verdict and then the ASPS came out against youth gender surgeries. She makes no mention of either of these major events.
I gave about 20 interviews to TV, radio and podcasts about covering the trial for @thefp. All of the requests came from conservative or heterodox media. All of them.
So my question for Jessica is this: Why is the liberal media ignoring one of the biggest stories in trans medicine of the past few years? She says this is all a moral panic. But what is the flip side of that phenomenon? It’s when there is actual news and journalists choose to ignore it.
Here’s another way of framing this story:
Transgender Activists Demand Answers From Surgeon Group Recommending Kids Keep Body Parts
"Let's be clear: this is not a serious response from unbiased plastic surgeons."
https://www.dailywire.com/news/transgender-activists-demand-answers-from-surgeon-group-recommending-kids-keep-body-parts
Quoting @benryanwriter: Tensions Flare Within Plastic Surgery Group Over New Policy Opposing Youth Gender Surgeries
https://benryan.substack.com/p/tensions-flare-within-plastic-surgery
I report: An American Society of Plastic Surgeons task force charged with examining the issue of such surgeries was, to their chagrin, cut out of the loop when the ASPS board issued its new policy last week.
I wrote about the question of whether there is an intersection between a professed transgender identity and violence for @UnHerd following the Charlie Kirk murder. https://unherd.com/2025/09/the-science-behind-trans-violence/
C2 false claimshand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
I wrote: https://archive.is/20240927142356/https://www.nysun.com/article/the-aap-files-inside-feud-within-american-academy-of-pediatrics-torn-over-transgender-issues-about-groups-decision-to-hold-meeting-in-anti-lgbtq-florida-of-ron-desantis
Jonathan Howard has said repeatedly that he doesn’t know much about trans issues and thus shouldn’t weigh in on it. But he did and Jesse Singal fact checked him. So now Howard is saying he doesn’t have experience in trans care and it’s therefore Singal who is ignorant on the subject. Despite the fact that Singal is by far the most knowledgeable reporter on the pediatric gender medicine beat who changes the course of history on this topic with his reporting, Howard dismisses him as a “do nothing pundit.”
Fact checked by Jesse Singal after he cited a study that is essentially bunk as evidence of pediatric gender medicine’s efficacy, NYU neurologist-psychiatrist says he won’t debate trans issues and then clearly blames Jesse for MAGA.
I’m this convo with @[private account] about the $2M detransitioner lawsuit, I made reference to this 2022 AAP conference at which Dr. Morissa Ladinsky, head of the U of AL’s youth gender clinic, appeared to glorify suicide when she said a 16 year old trans kid “stepped boldly in front of a tractor trailer, ending her life.” Then Dr. Landinsky repeated the refrain, saying “this teen *boldly* ended her life.”
She later expressed regret for what she said.
“I regret my choice of words that has been interpreted to glorify self-harm. This was never my intent. In discussing the tragic event, I sought to convey my work toward a day when no teen feels they must take their life,” she said. “Any suicide is devastating, and I want anyone who is struggling to know that help is always available.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: Watch My Substack Live with Katie Herzog. Plus: On the Hypocrisy Of Dr. Blair Peters, aka "Queer Surgeon," Griping About the ASPS's Opposition to Pediatric Gender Surgeries
https://benryan.substack.com/p/watch-my-substack-live-with-katie
I was delighted to finally join one of my favorite podcasts, where Katie and I talked about this watershed week in gender news and, of course, how glad we were the dreaded Jesse Singal wasn't there.
After Jesse Singal demonstrated that Jonathan Howard didn’t know much about trans medicine and thus wasn’t in a position to write about it, Jonathan Howard endorses the premise of staying in one’s lane and says that, in fact, it is Jesse who is clueless about medicine.
Howard says he doesn’t know much about trans medicine, which is why he doesn’t talk about it. But he did talk about it in an essay that Jesse fact checked, and Howard is responding like this:
Jonathan Howard has gotten it into his head, meanwhile, that I am personally responsible for the MAHA movement because once I published an essay on Vinay Prasad’s Substack about trans medicine researchers deceiving the public. This is bonkers conspiracy thinking by Howard.
Britain’s Good Law Project Again Claims the NHS Caused a Surge of Trans-Youth Suicides—Without Proving Its Case
https://benryan.substack.com/p/britains-good-law-project-again-claims
GLP has falsely claimed the NHS all but eliminated access to puberty blockers starting in 2021 and that this led to a suicide surge, based on data too unspecific to connect such deaths to NHS policy.
Once again, Britain’s Good Law Project (GLP) has made a damning accusation connecting National Health Service (NHS) England’s imposition of what it claims was a restrictive policy on minors’ access to gender-transition drugs to suicide deaths among trans youth.
On Saturday, the liberal legal nonprofit issued a press release claiming:
“New data shows surge in trans kids’ suicides following healthcare rollbacks: A freedom of information request by Good Law Project has found that deaths by suicide of trans young people under 18 surged following the withdrawal of gender-affirming health care.”
The release reported the following numbers of suicide deaths among minors identifying as trans:
*5 deaths in 2019-2020
*4 in 2020-21
*22 in 2021-22
*10 in 2022-23
But GLP is misrepresenting the history of puberty blocker access in England in an apparent effort to buttress its long-standing claims on the matter, in particular to accuse the NHS of causing a wave of deaths by denying gender-transition treatments to youths.
(Click the link above to read all about it in my essay.)
How Can Doctors Like This Provide Competent Care To Their Patients?
Some beef with Dr. Jonathan Howard, by @JesseSingal.
https://jessesingal.substack.com/p/how-can-doctors-like-this-provide
Dr. Jonathan Howard, a neurologist and psychiatrist at @[private account] Health, is furious at Michael Shermer, the founding publisher of Skepticmagazine.
Howard is an impressive figure. Like many doctors at university-affiliated medical centers, he also serves as a professor, in this case at the @[private account] School of Medicine. He has, according to his biography, “authored and edited multiple textbooks” on multiple sclerosis, his area of specialty.
Why is Dr. Jonathan Howard furious at @MichaelShermer? It has to do with a recent exchange between Senator Josh Hawley and an OB-GYN named Dr. Nisha Verma. Hawley, seeking to make a point about “gender ideology” (as he might call it) during a hearing, repeatedly asked Verma if men can get pregnant and Verma could not give a straight answer. Shermer chimed in to suggest an answer Verma could have given that accounts for the fact that, as Shermer (and anyone else using the traditional, biological definition of the term) sees it, men cannot, in fact, get pregnant.
That’s why Howard is furious, and that’s why he wrote a deeply aggrieved article in Science-Based Medicine about Shermer’s bigotry. The headline? “The Anti-Trans Obsessions of ‘Skeptic’ Michael Shermer: Hallucinating Imaginary Demons to Empower Actual Villains, Once Again.” The subheadline? “I want to demonstrate to Michael Shermer that it’s possible for men like us to not talk about trans people constantly. If I can do it, so can he.” (If you’re unfamiliar with Science-Based Medicine’s strange recent trajectory, see here or here.)
Not only does Dr. Jonathan Howard of NYU Langone Medical Center disagree with Michael Shermer that men can’t get pregnant — Howard thinks that to even ask this question puts other humans in danger.
That probably sounds like a caricature on my part, or a sloppy and inaccurate gloss of Howard’s actual views. But that’s exactly what he wrote
A new meta-analysis in JAMA Pediatrics (including 137 studies and 131,000+ transgender/gender-diverse youth) finds very high pooled rates of distress: ~49% report suicidal ideation, ~26% suicide attempts, ~47% self-injury.
The study estimates suicidality prevalence only. It does not assess whether puberty blockers, hormones or surgery affect or are associated with suicidality or suicide deaths.
It’s always great to talk with @BuckAngel, who as the number one trans man in America is nevertheless hated by trans activists for being some sort of, what, transphobe? We talked about the historic $2M verdict in the detransitioner lawsuit. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PiShn8t1NiE
Wow, Erica Anderson, a veteran psychologist, trans woman and former head of WPATH’s US arm, does not mince words about the psychologist in the detransitioner lawsuit. Nor did she on the stand. She landed blow after blow on Kenneth Einhorn for what she characterized as shoddy and rushed care.
The case called into sharp question the “gender affirmation” ethos and how it can shortchange troubled youth who need an adult who is willing to get them to stop and reflect, as opposed to providing what in this case was characterized as tacit approval for having a mastectomy at age 16.
Quotes a post by A0849; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
It should not come as a surprise to anyone that Andrea James, who runs a defamation website devoted to terrorizing journalists away from covering pediatric gender medicine, mischaracterized my words about detransitioning rates. I said that the numbers are unknown and are maybe 5-10%, but there isn’t enough research at this time. I got that estimate from one the only researchers with the courage to research the subject, Kinnon Ross MacKinnon of York University, who is a trans man. Is he an anti-trans extremist?
Please tell me how it is laundering anti-trans extremism for me to report about this historic detransitioner lawsuit.
The jury didn’t think the trial was anti-trans extremism. They awarded the plaintiff $2 million. And by the way, politics never came up in the trial.
As for being invited to go on CBS News: Kudos to them for being the *only* mainstream media outlet to invite me on. I’ve been inundated with requests from right-wing outlets. NPR? Not so much.
Quoting @benryanwriter: On @CBSNews, I reported on the $2M judgment in the 1st detransitioner civil suit to go to trial. I recalled the mother saying her daughter’s psychologist browbeat her into consenting to a gender-transition mastectomy for the 16 year old. But then the president-elect of WPATH testified that such surgeries, in fact, are not a form of suicide prevention, full stop.
This is what the AAP’s 2018 policy statement on the gender-affirming care method says about gender-transition surgeries for minors:
“Surgical Affirmation: Surgical approaches may be used to feminize or masculinize features, such as hair distribution, chest, or genitalia, and may include removal of internal organs, such as ovaries or the uterus (affecting fertility). These changes are irreversible. Although current protocols typically reserve surgical interventions for adults, they are occasionally pursued during adolescence on a case-by-case basis, considering the necessity and benefit to the adolescent’s overall health and often including multidisciplinary input from medical, mental health, and surgical providers as well as from the adolescent and family.”
Regarding insurance coverage it recommends: “that insurance plans offer coverage for health care that is specific to the needs of youth who identify as TGD [trans and gender diverse], including coverage for medical, psychological, and, when indicated, surgical gender-affirming interventions.”
Quotes a post by A2457; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Erin Reed is unhappy with medical organizations coming out against providing gender-transition surgeries to minors, writing:
The Cowardice Of American Medicine On Trans Youth Care
After capitulation by hospitals across the country, the ASPS and AMA have both thrown trans kids under the bus on surgical care.
The first year of the Trump administration has offered a master class in how powerful institutions capitulate to right-wing pressure rather than defend the marginalized people who depend on them. That pattern has played out across American life—from newsrooms to elite universities to television networks—but few sectors have folded as quickly or as completely as medical institutions facing federal threats over transgender care. Now, after a bruising week of far-right pressure and coordinated messaging, one of the most consequential shoes has dropped. The American Society of Plastic Surgeons, led by a president who has donated heavily to the Trump campaign and to Ted Cruz, has issued a statement opposing gender-affirming surgeries for patients up to age 19—a move subsequently pseudo-endorsed by the American Medical Association and further bolstered by a lawsuit led by a detransitioner and backed by the current president-elect of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health.
This week, the American Society of Plastic Surgeons released a statement concluding that “ASPS recommends that surgeons delay gender-related breast/chest, genital, and facial surgery until a patient is at least 19 years old.” Notably, 19 years of age is explicitly the age mentioned in Trump’s executive order, including a whole extra year of adulthood for no discernable reason. In justifying that position, the statement cites the Cass Review, which was advised on by members of anti-LGBTQ+ hate groupsand has been rejected by multiple major medical organizations worldwide. Shortly after the ASPS announcement, the American Medical Association issued a statement concurring in part, writing, “In the absence of clear evidence, the A.M.A. agrees with A.S.P.S. that surgical interventions in minors should be generally deferred to adulthood.” Taken together, the statements represent a significant departure from prior approaches to transgender youth surgical care. It is notable, mildly so at least, that the AMA’s use of the word “generally” leaves open the possibility that specific clinical indications—such as chest masculinization surgeries for some transgender youth with exceptional dysphoria—may still be permitted.
Yes, We Need Both the Term “Biological Sex” and the Word “Cisgender”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/yes-we-need-both-the-term-biological
An ode to qualifiers, which bring clarity during confusing times amid the ideological—and rhetorical—battles over transgender identity.
My thoughts on the term "biological sex":
Yes, We Need Both the Term “Biological Sex” and the Word “Cisgender”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/yes-we-need-both-the-term-biological
An ode to qualifiers, which bring clarity during confusing times amid the ideological—and rhetorical—battles over transgender identity.
Quotes a post by T21649; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Just 5 years ago, the AMA said that if kids couldn't get gender-transition surgeries, they'd commit suicide. Now they say it's probably not a good idea to give surgeries like these to kids. What changed? Not a thorough internal analysis, it would see. https://www.ama-assn.org/press-center/ama-press-releases/ama-states-stop-interfering-health-care-transgender-children
I reached out for GLAAD and HRC today for comment about the ASPS recommending against providing minors with gender-transition surgeries. No reply. I wonder if GLAAD is ever going to update this claim that “Every major medical association and leading world health authority supports health care for transgender people and youth,” after which they proceed to complain about the spreading of disinformation.
I did not say that. And by saying “trans people” you are eliding the crucial distinction between the ethics of providing these interventions to adults vs minors and the fact that I almost exclusively write about pediatric and not adult gender medicine.
This is the one about the trans woman who had cancer surgery and sued when they were talking about her while she was under anesthesia and there were the issues with her pronouns in the EMR?
This attack on my work over on Bluesky is so typically narrow minded and myopic, given that, as this court case demonstrated in unsparing and excruciating detail, Fox Varian, the plaintiff, *was not transgender.* She got sucked up into the trans-care system and came out maimed.
I would ask people such as this Bluesky crank if they care anything for people like Fox. They seem very eager to dismiss her suffering as acceptable collateral damage for a higher cause.
Dr. Loren Schechter, the head of gender-affirming surgery at Rush University Medical Center in Chicago and the president-elect of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), testified that gender-transition surgery is not form of suicide prevention. https://www.thefp.com/p/a-legal-first-that-could-change-gender
A Legal First That Could Change Gender Medicine
At 16, Fox Varian got a mastectomy while undergoing a gender transition. She sued her psychologist and plastic surgeon for leaving her ‘disfigured for life.’ Benjamin Ryan reports from the courtroom.
Read the @TheFP article: https://www.thefp.com/p/a-legal-first-that-could-change-gender
Follow and support my Substack, where I cover pediatric gender medicine: https://benryan.substack.com. I was the only reporter to attend the entire three-week trial and will be providing more in-depth reporting and commentary on the case.
The opening of my Free Press article:
Fox Varian had a turbulent childhood. Her parents split when she was seven, triggering a three-year custody battle that ultimately saw her estranged from her father. She suffered from a constellation of mental health problems, including depression, anxiety, and social phobia. She was diagnosed with autism and bounced around various schools. Her first period sent her into a meltdown, and she battled disordered eating and body-image issues. By mid-adolescence, she was completely lost.
At 15, she began questioning her gender during sessions with her psychologist. She changed her birth name, Isabella, to Gabriel, which she saw as androgynous. Over the next two months, she cut her hair short, began binding her breasts, switched her name again, to Rowan, and started telling people she was transgender.
In December 2019, 11 months after she started this public social transition, Varian underwent surgery to remove her breasts. She was 16 years old.
Varian, who adopted the name Fox at 18 and is now 22, is one of thousands of minors who underwent gender-transition surgery over the past decade. And she is just one of the young people who have come to regret permanently addressing what was only a temporary identity shift.
Three years after her mastectomy, Varian stopped identifying as transgender and began a process known as detransitioning. In May 2023, she filed a medical malpractice lawsuit against the two principal Westchester County, New York, care providers who oversaw her gender transition: her long-time psychologist, Kenneth Einhorn, and Dr. Simon Chin, who performed the mastectomy.
On Friday, a jury in White Plains, New York, awarded Varian $2 million in damages. Varian’s case is the first malpractice suit from a detransitioner to go before a jury, and I was the only reporter to attend the entire three-week trial. Represented by personal-injury attorney Adam Deutsch, Varian said she had been injured by the defendants due to their deviation from standard practices and a lack of informed consent. While there are no guarantees in medical malpractice lawsuits, legal experts believe Varian’s victory could inspire a wave of similar cases that would significantly disrupt pediatric gender medicine.
Matt Walsh misunderstands how the vast majority of the detransitioner lawsuits operate, and indeed how the trial that was decided on Friday (which I was the only reporter to attend in its entirety) was structured.
These lawsuits don't ask whether these medical interventions should be provided to children, but whether the care-provider defendants departed from what's known as the standard of care when they cared for the plaintiff. Because pediatric gender medicine is made up of (like it or not) widely accepted medical practices (meaning widely accepted by care providers, not politicians or pundits), these cases don't seek to go after those practices. They seek to penalize providers who were notably reckless in engaging in those practices.
There are two exceptions: a pair of lawsuits against Callen-Lorde in New York and Fenway Health in Boston, which are both LGBTQ community health centers, each make civil rights claims. These lawsuits claim the clinics violated the civil rights of gay men for not discerning that they were not transgender women and therefore should not have received gender-transition interventions, but in fact suffered from internalized homophobia. I spoke with the attorney behind those ambitious cases and she said she does indeed want to go after the World Professional Association for Transgender Health and take down their practice guidelines.
Quoting @MattWalshBlog: With a detransitioner winning a 2 million dollar medical malpractice settlement (which should have been 100 times higher), the total collapse of the trans movement is officially upon us. In the next few years, every Frankenstein gender butcher and perverted "medical professional" who profited off of the sexual mutilation of children will be sued into oblivion. The story should end with these mad scientists convicted in a court of law and hanging from the gallows. Instead it will end with them bankrupted and disgraced, which isn't as good but will have to be good enough.
As the years pass, those who supported this madness will quietly retreat and pretend that none of this ever happened, or at least that they had no hand in it. We shouldn't let them. The trans movement will go down as the most deranged form of mass hysteria that human civilization has ever seen. We should make sure that history accurately records who went along with it and who had the courage to stand against it, even when the hysteria was at its peak and there was little to be gained, and much to lose, in doing so.
The people who fell on the wrong side of this issue should never be trusted again. They should be shamed and disgraced and forced to live with the humiliation for the rest of their days. We cannot stop the rats from fleeing the ship. But we can remember their names .
I've never gotten any precise sense from that crowd what constitutes "rare".
And in one breath, leaders in pediatric gender medicine will decry the scrutiny they receive as disproportionate to how few children receive these interventions, and then they'll bemoan how inaccessible the interventions are and how important it is to provide them to many more minors.
In 2024, WPATH went so far as to suggest in a statement that the majority of minors who identify as transgender (an estimated 300,000 13 to 17 year olds ident as trans) would do best to go on cross-sex hormones: https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/1780335676367487173?s=20
Quoting @benryanwriter: WPATH responds to the Cass Review, which lambasted them for, it said, exaggerating the strength of the evidence behind its guidelines and citation “circularity”. WPATH dismisses Cass as based on a “false premise” that non-medical means are best for most kids with gender distress.
Another way I make everyone mad is by saying:
Yes, We Need Both the Term “Biological Sex” and the Word “Cisgender”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/yes-we-need-both-the-term-biological
An ode to qualifiers, which bring clarity during confusing times amid the ideological—and rhetorical—battles over transgender identity.
Agree to disagree about pronouns! I too struggle to understand the legal system. We're all here learning...
https://benryan.substack.com/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred
How Harvard Teed Up the False Claim That the 'Vast Majority of Minors Getting Gender-Affirming Surgeries Are C-s Kids'
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
An opaquely written Harvard study and linked press release prompted false reporting that gynecomastia surgeries for boys are vastly more common than gender-affirming surgeries for trans
NYU neurologist/psychiatrist Jonathan Howard has been making a stink over @MichaelShermer's recent statements about transgender issues on @[private account]'s show.
Here, Howard cites a @Harvard study that falsely claimed youth "rarely" get gender-transition surgeries. In fact, about 1,000 minors got a mastectomy for this purpose annually in recent years, before state bans set in.
I wrote about that Harvard study when it came out. I demonstrated how its authors had quite evidently sought to mislead the public about this issue: https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
So, in fact, it is not Shermer who is "making things up" about this point in particular, it was Harvard researchers that at least effectively did so.
As for expressing concerns about minors getting these surgeries, I would like Howard to look into the eyes of the mother who testified in the detransitioner civil trial that I just finished attending yesterday (the plaintiff won a $2M judgment against her care providers; my article on the suit will run in a major outlet next week) and tell her that the loss of her daughter's breasts when she was 16 amounts to a false concern.
GOP candidate calls for executing parents & doctors who help trans kids
“I know that’s gonna make people’s ears ring, but that’s a gross great sin.”
Tennessee state Rep. Monty Fritts (R), who is running for governor, has said he’d like a law to execute “those who commit an assault on the sanctity of life,” including those who assist children in securing gender-affirming medical care.
“I think we need a law in Tennessee that would allow for capital punishment for those who commit an assault on the sanctity of life,” he said in a recent conversation with Connor B., the host of the Christian Nationalist podcast Forge and Anvil.
Fritts then said he thought four things would “require” capital punishment that also “aligns with scripture.”
“I think that anyone who would try to disfigure a child through hormones or surgery, you might be eligible to capital punishment,” he said, adding, “I know that’s gonna make people’s ears ring, but that’s a gross, great sin.”
This question from @[private account], the journalist behind the podcast series "The Anti-Trans Hate Machine," has driven an avalanche of responses.
What do you think?
Quotes a post by T04255; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Here's an interesting lawsuit by @TheFIREorg:
Illinois bars groups from calling themselves "Democrats" or "Republicans" without official approval from the state party establishment. This is a problem for Democrats for an Informed Approach to Gender @DIAGdemocrats.
FIRE states:
CHICAGO, Jan. 27, 2026 — Like most Americans, you’ve probably criticized the Democrats or the Republicans at some point. But imagine that the next day, state officials told you to go down to party headquarters and request a permission slip to continue speaking out.
What seems like an absurd hypothetical is the reality in Illinois, where nonprofits are barred from operating in the state if they mention either “democrats” or “republicans” in their title unless they go to the parties for permission. Now, with the help of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, one group of dissident Democrats is suing to strike down Illinois’ unconstitutional law — permanently.
“Illinois can’t get around the First Amendment by outsourcing censorship to party bosses,” said FIRE attorney Daniel Zahn. “No American — Republican, Democrat, or independent — should have to bend the knee before a political party to participate in the political system.”
Democrats for an Informed Approach to Gender is a charitable organization composed of current and former Democrats who disagree with the party’s stance on transgender issues. The all-volunteer organization believes it offers a unique perspective by voicing their belief that the current Democratic Party consensus is contrary to “core liberal values,” such as “promoting evidence-based medical care,” “protecting vulnerable children and adults,” and “upholding the rights of women and girls.”
“The Illinois Democratic Party doesn’t get to decide whether we can call ourselves 'Democrats,'" said DIAG Board Secretary Jenny Poyer Ackerman. "DIAG was founded on our belief in open inquiry, challenging ideological conformity, and above all, the freedom to speak out. Backing down would go against everything we believe in."
DIAG has successfully registered as a nonprofit at a national level and has been able to solicit donations in 37 states, but was rejected when it attempted to register to solicit donations in the Prairie State for being in violation of a provision of Illinois law. “To get qualified in Illinois, you will need [an] approval letter . . . saying it is ok to use ‘Democrats’ in your name,” explained Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias’ rejection letter.
Without that letter, DIAG is banned from conducting affairs in the state and could face fines or jail time if it engages in constitutionally protected speech like soliciting donations, sponsoring lectures, or meeting with supporters in Illinois. Based on previous disagreements with the Democratic establishment — the Colorado Democrats denounced DIAG last year and demanded a name change — DIAG has every reason to believe that the Democratic Party of Illinois will deny it approval. But more to the point, its leaders refuse on principle to seek a permission slip from a party whose platform it has criticized and plans to criticize in Illinois.
Illinois’ law violates the First Amendment by restricting Americans’ speech only when they broach a specific topic: political parties. The law even lists specific words that are banned absent permission. Using a name with “republican” or “democrat” or “democratic” automatically requires outside party approval, while “green” or “libertarian” might not.
As a result, the Democratic Party has a veto over groups like DIAG, and Republicans get a veto over groups like Log Cabin Republicans. But absurdly, it also means the Democratic Party has a veto over organizations like the Democratic Socialists of America, or even Federation for a Democratic China, simply because those organizations choose to use the word “democratic” when describing their beliefs.
The Supreme Court has previously held these sorts of “content-based” speech restrictions are only constitutional when they’re the least restrictive way to achieve a compelling government interest. But Illinois doesn’t have any compelling interest here. Its provision only serves the interests of the entrenched political parties.
Now, FIRE is suing Giannoulias in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois not only to obtain an injunction stopping him from applying the name provision to deny DIAG’s application but also to halt enforcement of the law across the board.
“The Democratic and Republican parties don’t have a monopoly on the concepts of what is democratic or republican,” said Zahn. “When the government tries to give them that monopoly, it’s absurd and unconstitutional.”
A sign of potential waning trans identity in European children:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Generation Z and the trans trend: Numbers are declining, the gender hype is over. (English Translation by ChatGPT)
Feeling like you belong to a different gender is a passing trend among Generation Z, as indicated by declining numbers. The activism of doctors, politicians, and the media is losing momentum. This ultimately benefits young people themselves.
Anyone who in recent years dared to speak of social contagion—that is, imitation—when discussing the growing number of transgender adolescents was almost treated as a threat to child welfare. Doing so was seen as an attack on the young person’s physical and psychological integrity, as a challenge to their self-understanding.
Activists branded anyone transphobic who questioned the rising demand at gender clinics, which led to ever more treatments. It made no difference how much one emphasized that this did not mean denying that people can be born in the wrong body or that transgender identity exists.
Yet it should give pause when a phenomenon suddenly appears in such high concentration within a specific age group, often without signs in childhood—namely among members of Generation Z, now between 15 and 30 years old. Or when far more girls than boys now want to be boys rather than the other way around. To this day, no one has an answer.
But skeptics were told that none of this mattered: people who struggle with their gender know best what is right for them, even when they are very young. Their wishes must be supported unconditionally.
Numbers among boys “in free fall”
And now this: various studies and statistics suggest that being trans is a trend—or may have been, at least in part. The entire gender debate, so heavily driven by ideology, appears to be losing momentum and influence.
The British-Canadian political scientist Eric Kaufmann analyzed surveys of students who identify as neither female nor male. While the focus was on nonbinary identity, he also sees broader trends among transgender individuals reflected there. In 2023, 8 percent of students at one of the American schools studied identified as nonbinary; by 2025, the figure had fallen to 2 percent. Elsewhere, it dropped by half.
“The numbers among boys are in free fall,” Kaufmann wrote on X when presenting his report titled The Decline of Trans and Queer Identity among Young Americans.
Naturally, the scholar was attacked for this—something he could expect, given that he holds conservative positions in many areas and thus belongs to a minority in academia. He was branded far-right online; colleagues accused him of methodological flaws and argued that the time period studied was too short to speak of a shift in sentiment.
Linguist bids farewell to gendered language
Kaufmann’s findings are supported by linguist John McWhorter, a contributor to The New York Times, which hardly has a reputation for excluding sexual minorities. McWhorter also supported the “pronominal revolution,” including the use of the plural “they” for nonbinary individuals.
But McWhorter, who teaches at Columbia University in New York, now also observes a reversal in gendered language. At the end of the year, he included the pronouns “he” and “she” in his list of “Words and Phrases of 2025,” writing: “Binary genders are making a comeback, along with the pronouns most closely associated with them.”
Psychology professor Jean M. Twenge also wanted to know what was happening and now provides figures from representative national surveys. In 2024, the number of 18- to 22-year-olds identifying as trans fell by half compared with 2022. The same was true for nonbinary individuals. Year of birth played an important role: “Americans born in the early 2000s were more likely to identify as transgender than those born before or after them.”
Discovering trans identity during COVID
What happens culturally in the U.S. often reaches Europe with a delay. Identity politics, which began at American universities, is a prime example. It now appears to have peaked.
The waning interest in the gender revolution is not only noticeable in the media. Activism around the topic of “trans,” which had also captured doctors, politicians and teachers, is weakening. There are signs of this in Switzerland as well—for example, in demand at specialist centers.
At the gender clinic of the Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Psychotherapy Department at the University of Zurich, registrations for gender incongruence rose steadily from 2016 and peaked in 2021 at 134 registrations. It was the time of COVID. By 2024, the number had dropped by more than half to 60.
For a time, it really did seem fashionable to define oneself as trans or nonbinary. Activist professionals often explained the rise in diagnoses as a positive effect of increased awareness: previously, transgender identity had simply not been recognized or treated; information and role models had been lacking. But if the numbers are now falling again, this can hardly be attributed to a lack of education. Quite the opposite.
Imitation effect via TikTok
Young people searching for an identity imitate one another; that is how trends emerge. One wants to be noticed and to belong. Everything is in flux; things quickly lose their validity. The mind is in turmoil, the body is changing—more dramatically for females than for males.
During the pandemic, when adolescents were locked in their rooms at home for weeks, they spent even more time on social media. Not only did the isolation leave many psychologically fragile; there they also found a possible explanation—and solution—for their suffering.
Parents suddenly found themselves confronted with their daughter’s nonbinary identity, something they had never noticed before. Then she came out as trans and wanted to be addressed as a boy. Since then, she socializes only with people from the trans community. This is what one hears in self-help groups of desperate parents.
It was also easy to see a gender transition as the solution to all problems. The gender debate of recent years was so dominant. It was led by a small but loud minority, yet they held discursive power. Strangely enough, everything seemed to revolve solely around sexual identities and orientations, of which there were more and more. Society was fixated on gender and sexuality as if it had no other concerns.
Trump bans gender surveys
A cultural shift is now underway. But activists and their supporters prefer to speak of a “culture war from the right” rather than asking whether identity politics may have gone too far. They attribute the declining number of people identifying as trans or nonbinary solely to the changing political climate: those affected, they argue, no longer dare to answer honestly.
What is true is that right-wing conservative parties, which are gaining strength in many countries, do not place the interests of trans people at the top of their agendas. While then–Vice President Kamala Harris introduced herself with her pronouns (“she/her”) in certain circles, Donald Trump, at the beginning of his second term, removed a third gender category from passports. More broadly, he is fighting anything related to trans issues.
Trump is responding with questionable severity to the gender hype of recent years. He has ordered that large, publicly funded surveys on gender identity—such as those analyzed by psychologist Twenge—should no longer be conducted. Ironically, these surveys would likely continue to produce data that Trump would welcome: that the downward trend is continuing.
The American president is no better than the trans activists; in fact, they resemble each other. Both mix facts and values. Eric Kaufmann criticized Trump’s ban on studies with the words: “Asking questions about transgender is not the same as advocating transgender.”
Applied to those who label researchers like Kaufmann transphobic simply because they deliver a message they do not want to hear: collecting data is neither for nor against the outcome.
No fear of moral pressure
Nevertheless, the gender debate has normalized. Finally, things can be said that must be sayable in an open and free society. One may fear, because of leaders like Trump, that the pendulum will swing too far in the other direction. Still, one should not forget how moralizing and repressive the discourse was, and how much was taboo.
In the future, people will be astonished that a biologist at a university could be bullied and canceled simply for holding the view that there are two biological sexes—an opinion shared by the large, silent majority.
It is necessary that various European countries, including Switzerland, debate banning medical treatments for children and adolescents that have lifelong consequences and lack a solid scientific basis—without ideological blinders and without fear of being co-opted by the “wrong” side. It serves the interests of young people themselves.
Sounds like he’s pointing to the ACLU’s decision to argue for an as-applied EP challenge rather than arguing, as Strangio has historically, that all trans girls and women should be able to participate in girls and women’s sports regardless of their gender-transition-treatment status. This argument excludes many trans girls and women and acknowledges that they hold a competitive advantage in girls and women’s sports.
Generation Z and the trans trend: Numbers are declining, the gender hype is over. (English Translation by ChatGPT)
Feeling like you belong to a different gender is a passing trend among Generation Z, as indicated by declining numbers. The activism of doctors, politicians, and the media is losing momentum. This ultimately benefits young people themselves.
Anyone who in recent years dared to speak of social contagion—that is, imitation—when discussing the growing number of transgender adolescents was almost treated as a threat to child welfare. Doing so was seen as an attack on the young person’s physical and psychological integrity, as a challenge to their self-understanding.
Activists branded anyone transphobic who questioned the rising demand at gender clinics, which led to ever more treatments. It made no difference how much one emphasized that this did not mean denying that people can be born in the wrong body or that transgender identity exists.
Yet it should give pause when a phenomenon suddenly appears in such high concentration within a specific age group, often without signs in childhood—namely among members of Generation Z, now between 15 and 30 years old. Or when far more girls than boys now want to be boys rather than the other way around. To this day, no one has an answer.
But skeptics were told that none of this mattered: people who struggle with their gender know best what is right for them, even when they are very young. Their wishes must be supported unconditionally.
Numbers among boys “in free fall”
And now this: various studies and statistics suggest that being trans is a trend—or may have been, at least in part. The entire gender debate, so heavily driven by ideology, appears to be losing momentum and influence.
The British-Canadian political scientist Eric Kaufmann analyzed surveys of students who identify as neither female nor male. While the focus was on nonbinary identity, he also sees broader trends among transgender individuals reflected there. In 2023, 8 percent of students at one of the American schools studied identified as nonbinary; by 2025, the figure had fallen to 2 percent. Elsewhere, it dropped by half.
“The numbers among boys are in free fall,” Kaufmann wrote on X when presenting his report titled The Decline of Trans and Queer Identity among Young Americans.
Naturally, the scholar was attacked for this—something he could expect, given that he holds conservative positions in many areas and thus belongs to a minority in academia. He was branded far-right online; colleagues accused him of methodological flaws and argued that the time period studied was too short to speak of a shift in sentiment.
Linguist bids farewell to gendered language
Kaufmann’s findings are supported by linguist John McWhorter, a contributor to The New York Times, which hardly has a reputation for excluding sexual minorities. McWhorter also supported the “pronominal revolution,” including the use of the plural “they” for nonbinary individuals.
But McWhorter, who teaches at Columbia University in New York, now also observes a reversal in gendered language. At the end of the year, he included the pronouns “he” and “she” in his list of “Words and Phrases of 2025,” writing: “Binary genders are making a comeback, along with the pronouns most closely associated with them.”
Psychology professor Jean M. Twenge also wanted to know what was happening and now provides figures from representative national surveys. In 2024, the number of 18- to 22-year-olds identifying as trans fell by half compared with 2022. The same was true for nonbinary individuals. Year of birth played an important role: “Americans born in the early 2000s were more likely to identify as transgender than those born before or after them.”
Discovering trans identity during COVID
What happens culturally in the U.S. often reaches Europe with a delay. Identity politics, which began at American universities, is a prime example. It now appears to have peaked.
The waning interest in the gender revolution is not only noticeable in the media. Activism around the topic of “trans,” which had also captured doctors, politicians and teachers, is weakening. There are signs of this in Switzerland as well—for example, in demand at specialist centers.
At the gender clinic of the Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Psychotherapy Department at the University of Zurich, registrations for gender incongruence rose steadily from 2016 and peaked in 2021 at 134 registrations. It was the time of COVID. By 2024, the number had dropped by more than half to 60.
For a time, it really did seem fashionable to define oneself as trans or nonbinary. Activist professionals often explained the rise in diagnoses as a positive effect of increased awareness: previously, transgender identity had simply not been recognized or treated; information and role models had been lacking. But if the numbers are now falling again, this can hardly be attributed to a lack of education. Quite the opposite.
Imitation effect via TikTok
Young people searching for an identity imitate one another; that is how trends emerge. One wants to be noticed and to belong. Everything is in flux; things quickly lose their validity. The mind is in turmoil, the body is changing—more dramatically for females than for males.
During the pandemic, when adolescents were locked in their rooms at home for weeks, they spent even more time on social media. Not only did the isolation leave many psychologically fragile; there they also found a possible explanation—and solution—for their suffering.
Parents suddenly found themselves confronted with their daughter’s nonbinary identity, something they had never noticed before. Then she came out as trans and wanted to be addressed as a boy. Since then, she socializes only with people from the trans community. This is what one hears in self-help groups of desperate parents.
It was also easy to see a gender transition as the solution to all problems. The gender debate of recent years was so dominant. It was led by a small but loud minority, yet they held discursive power. Strangely enough, everything seemed to revolve solely around sexual identities and orientations, of which there were more and more. Society was fixated on gender and sexuality as if it had no other concerns.
Trump bans gender surveys
A cultural shift is now underway. But activists and their supporters prefer to speak of a “culture war from the right” rather than asking whether identity politics may have gone too far. They attribute the declining number of people identifying as trans or nonbinary solely to the changing political climate: those affected, they argue, no longer dare to answer honestly.
What is true is that right-wing conservative parties, which are gaining strength in many countries, do not place the interests of trans people at the top of their agendas. While then–Vice President Kamala Harris introduced herself with her pronouns (“she/her”) in certain circles, Donald Trump, at the beginning of his second term, removed a third gender category from passports. More broadly, he is fighting anything related to trans issues.
Trump is responding with questionable severity to the gender hype of recent years. He has ordered that large, publicly funded surveys on gender identity—such as those analyzed by psychologist Twenge—should no longer be conducted. Ironically, these surveys would likely continue to produce data that Trump would welcome: that the downward trend is continuing.
The American president is no better than the trans activists; in fact, they resemble each other. Both mix facts and values. Eric Kaufmann criticized Trump’s ban on studies with the words: “Asking questions about transgender is not the same as advocating transgender.”
Applied to those who label researchers like Kaufmann transphobic simply because they deliver a message they do not want to hear: collecting data is neither for nor against the outcome.
No fear of moral pressure
Nevertheless, the gender debate has normalized. Finally, things can be said that must be sayable in an open and free society. One may fear, because of leaders like Trump, that the pendulum will swing too far in the other direction. Still, one should not forget how moralizing and repressive the discourse was, and how much was taboo.
In the future, people will be astonished that a biologist at a university could be bullied and canceled simply for holding the view that there are two biological sexes—an opinion shared by the large, silent majority.
It is necessary that various European countries, including Switzerland, debate banning medical treatments for children and adolescents that have lifelong consequences and lack a solid scientific basis—without ideological blinders and without fear of being co-opted by the “wrong” side. It serves the interests of young people themselves.
When a person purporting to be a journalist claims, falsely, that Jesse Singal has dismissed transgender identity as a “hoax” and a “social fad”:
Quoting @benryanwriter: He has never said that. He has argued that it requires a certain level of blindness not to think that at least some of the sudden burst of gender dysphoria and trans identification among adolescents natal girls in particular must be driven by social media. Within that assertion is the type of nuance that Bluesky forbids. And within that assertion is the validation of people who are truly transgender and the discernment of them from people who would not be best served by medically transitioning and whose medical transition will ultimately one day undermine the entire transgender movement and make things harder for people such as yourself.
But ask yourself if anyone in Jesse’s position would go on a show entitled “The Anti-Trans Hate Machine” and think they were going to get a fair shake.
He has never said that. He has argued that it requires a certain level of blindness not to think that at least some of the sudden burst of gender dysphoria and trans identification among adolescents natal girls in particular must be driven by social media. Within that assertion is the type of nuance that Bluesky forbids. And within that assertion is the validation of people who are truly transgender and the discernment of them from people who would not be best served by medically transitioning and whose medical transition will ultimately one day undermine the entire transgender movement and make things harder for people such as yourself.
Singal is not a provocateur on trans issues. Anyone who claims that hasn’t read his work. He is a dedicated science journalist who is routinely mischaracterized by people looking to exploit him, in particular hiss willingness to cover a taboo subject with circumspection, for their own activist goals.
Dr. Laura, who is transgender, weighs in on Tish James' firing of Glenna Goldis, calling it a "tactically stupid move":
https://x.com/datadriven_tdoc/status/2014679180256956663?s=20
Quotes a post by A0696; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Another California hospital drops gender-affirming procedures, prescriptions
The hospital, which says it acted after a federal threat to pull reimbursement, will continue offering counseling, mental health resources and care coordination.
Under the threat of losing federal reimbursement, Rady Children’s Hospital in San Diego notified families Tuesday that it will stop offering direct forms of gender affirming care, including “medical interventions, procedures and prescriptions,” limiting its offerings to supportive services such as “counseling, mental health resources and care coordination.”
The move, which was immediately decried by the region’s main transgender advocacy group, comes as many children’s hospitals pull back on such care, which President Donald Trump targeted with an executive order shortly after beginning his second term in office.
In Colorado, the Options for Ari, a Transgender Teen, Begin to Disappear
The Trump administration has used an array of pressure tactics to try to end treatments for minors, even in states that want to keep them.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/19/us/politics/colorado-transgender-treatments-trump.html
“As-applied” means they say that the plaintiffs should be treated as a special sub category since they’re on gender transition drugs. All trans girls and women’s don’t apply to their argument, just the ones on treatment. They’re arguing that this sub subcategory should be treated as similarly situated to girls and women under the EP clause.
Parker Molloy says the question of whether a man can become a woman is “completely irrelevant to policy” one week after the ACLU sought to win an “as-applied” challenge to trans sports restrictions that under the Equal Protection Clause sought to have trans girls and women who had undergone gender-transition treatment to be treated like girls and women.
Parker Molloy, trans progressive pundit: “‘Can a man become a woman?’ is not a question anyone asks in good faith as it's a complete misunderstanding of what being trans is.”
Veronica Ivy, trans cyclist: “I am a biological woman.”
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/yes-we-need-both-the-term-biological
Quotes a post by T04639; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’m not sure what your threshold for “being done” is, but perhaps 20,000 minors in recent years have undergone treatment with puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones or gender-transition surgeries in recent years. I spent the past week attending the opening phase of the nation’s first medical malpractice lawsuit concerning a detransitioner. A 22 year-old woman is suing her psychologist and plastic surgeon for personal injury for clearing her for a mastectomy when she was 16 and had been identifying as trans for only about a year.
Flipping the script and calling cosmetic procedures “gender-affirming care” presumes that people believe that the term when applied to transgender people is based in pure logic and not at least partially in vapid rhetoric. The term has an activist argument baked in that presumes that the gender that is being affirmed is the correct one, so to speak. It excludes the possibility of erroneously transitioning someone who would only go on to detransition. It would be like calling chemotherapy that was not 100% effective “cancer curing treatment,” thus selling at least some patients a false promise. https://benryan.substack.com/p/journalists-should-not-use-the-term
It is, however, a question with legal implications with respect to transgender inclusion in single-sex spaces. If the answer is an unqualified yes, then the argument for exclusion loses its legal heft. If the answer is no or some sort of nuanced response, inclusion rights become more complicated.
Likely contenders for the 2028 Dem presidential nomination are not eager to go on the record about transgender issues, with sweeping evasions from them about pediatric gender-transition treatment, trans inclusion in sports, and whether a man can become a woman, Axios reports.
“Psychoanalysis rejects science at its own peril
“One of the most polarising and urgent questions facing our field and healthcare more broadly is whether body-altering, sex-trait-modifying endocrine and surgical interventions are safe and effective, particularly for young people. Psychoanalytic writing, and indeed most mainstream publications in the field of psychiatry and psychology, fail to acknowledge that the evidence base for gender-affirming medical interventions is weak and controversial. Instead, the benefits of medicalised gender change are assumed to be an open and shut case. Analysts who unquestioningly support transition misrepresent the evidence base and distort the work of those with different perspectives (D’Angelo
Citation 2025). Discrediting the work of those with whom we disagree as not being analytic was a strategy employed by analysts defending their position on homosexuality for decades after it was removed from the DSM. The same tactics are being used today against those who question the gender-affirming medical approach or who seek to explore the psychic organisation and psychodynamics of trans identities (see, for example, Gozlan Citation
2025; Saketopoulou Citation
2022). Like the American Psychological Association and the American Psychiatric Association, the American Psychoanalytic Association has made clear that it fully supports medical transition (American Psychiatric Association Citation 2020; American Psychoanalytic Association Citation
2023; American Psychological Association Citation 2015). In an email circulated to the entire membership of the American Psychoanalytic Association in 2024, the Committee on Gender and Sexuality claimed that groups raising concerns about gender affirming medical care are circulating ‘disinformation and misinformation.’ In a striking reversal, so-called attempts to address misinformation have become weaponised as part of a relentless attack on what science is increasingly telling us about adolescent gender transition, and on clinicians who dare to draw attention to the risks.”
Just to be clear, this paragraph comes from a long paper about the differences vs overlaps in how psychotherapy does vs should approach treating people who are gay vs trans. He’s not saying that the purpose of therapy should be reconciling with one’s sexed body, but that for some people it can be. And he is saying that it is a mistake to presume that psychotherapy, if it involves exploration of the roots of trans identity, is de facto practicing the type of conversion therapy that proved so damaging to gay people in the 20th century when psychotherapists considered homosexuality a pathology. He says that that presumption is causing harms to some patients by limiting the breadth of the therapy that they might receive with respect to gender identity exploration. He characterizes psychotherapy as a practice as suffering from a Greek tragedy: By seeking to avoid repeating the sins of the past the profession has only ensured doing so.
A psychoanalyst speaks to the contrasts between treating gay and transgender patients:
Quoting @benryanwriter: “Trans is not the new gay: How psychoanalytic elitism and the rejection of science are creating a repetition of the past
“Today, a pressing concern for psychoanalysis is to avoid repeating [the] history [of the field’s harms to gay people] when theorising about and working with transgender people. Psychodynamic explorations of trans identity formation are being framed as new iterations of conversion therapy, wrongly implying coercion and falsely conflating psychodynamics with pathology. Furthermore, the author cautions that unquestioning gender affirmation shares an important conceptual similarity with gay conversion therapy, in that it can collude with a wish to eliminate a shame-filled or hated part of the self. In our haste to avoid repeating the past, psychoanalysis is deploying the very same tactics that insulated its stance on homosexuality from revision and course correction, but now with regard to trans.”
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00207578.2025.2591921
Robert Garofalo, leading pediatric gender medicine specialist from Lurie Children’s, most known for the video in which he says there is no method to assert whether a child is truly trans (clinics just ask the child), reports on a recent conference in London: “[W]e talk openly about a range of topics, the limitations and challenges of the informed consent process, the strength and weaknesses of the current evidentiary research base, the different ethical and legal doctrines that guide our work and decision making.
The psychologist led her to believe that she had to consent to surgery immediately lest her daughter kill herself. Under such pressure, she did not appear to think there was any time for a second opinion. Note that the psychologist was only repeating a mantra that has been repeated from every direction by the trans advocacy movement: that absent gender-transition intervention, minors with gender dysphoria are at an extremely high risk of suicide.
Thanks. I’m no fan of Greenwald, if for no other reason than he professes to be an expert about too wide an array of subjects for any one person to retain supreme knowledge about. I haven’t really followed Taibbi much, but listened to @[private account]’s pod about him. The pod inaccurately characterized Jesse Singal as tracking rightward; anyone who claims that about Jesse has not listened to his routine and emphatic expressions of left-wing political positions and values. Jesse mostly criticizes the far left from the left. People perhaps wrongly think Jesse leans right because trans issues are so politicized and anyone who is mad about those who critique trans activism assume those make such a critique do so from a political and not just scientific position. Also, Taibbi is suing the guest on the show for defamation. So who knows what’s true about him. One thing I can say is that it’s a shame when reporters start Substacking full time and they wind up doing less or no real reporting and largely just write takes (which I can attest get better traction).
I think the bulk of it is that people know what the verboten topics are and they know better than to explore them at all. Also, they don’t include as outcomes in their research matters that might prove politically inconvenient. An academic told me that a grad student in his department wrote a single short essay for a lay publication about a verboten topic in the trans world and they share a concern that it may have ended her job prospects. It wasn’t even widely read.
“Trans is not the new gay: How psychoanalytic elitism and the rejection of science are creating a repetition of the past
“Today, a pressing concern for psychoanalysis is to avoid repeating [the] history [of the field’s harms to gay people] when theorising about and working with transgender people. Psychodynamic explorations of trans identity formation are being framed as new iterations of conversion therapy, wrongly implying coercion and falsely conflating psychodynamics with pathology. Furthermore, the author cautions that unquestioning gender affirmation shares an important conceptual similarity with gay conversion therapy, in that it can collude with a wish to eliminate a shame-filled or hated part of the self. In our haste to avoid repeating the past, psychoanalysis is deploying the very same tactics that insulated its stance on homosexuality from revision and course correction, but now with regard to trans.”
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00207578.2025.2591921
US Dept of Education targets schools in blue states, including CA, MA, WA, NY (including NYC), and NV, over trans-inclusive sports policies:
“Today, the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights (OCR) initiated investigations into eighteen educational entities in ten states based on complaints submitted to OCR alleging that they have violated Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 (Title IX).
“The complaints assert that these entities, which range from K-12 school districts to postsecondary education institutions to state departments of education, maintain policies or practices that discriminate on the basis of sex by permitting students to participate in sports based on their ‘gender identity,’ not biological sex. These policies jeopardize both the safety and the equal opportunities of women in educational programs and activities.”
https://www.ed.gov/about/news/press-release/us-department-of-educations-office-civil-rights-initiates-18-title-ix-investigations
Journalist @[private account] asserts that when Rep @[private account] (D-Mass.) expressed concerns about whether “biological boys should be playing in girls’ sports,” this, in Willis’ words, meant Rep Moulton “went so far as to parrot vile anti-trans talking points.” https://ballsandstrikes.org/law-politics/trans-sports-cases-supreme-court-backlash/
I don't know if one could call that statement smart or not. It represents a common philosophy among transgender advocates. Whether it was a savvy legal strategy is a different question.
It’s likely a strategy to avoid having the court define sex and saying it doesn’t include gender identity, which could be used against transgender inclusion in other single-sex spaces.
What the ADF attorney is not acknowledging is that prior to about 2016, no one needed to define sex under the law because it had a nearly universally shared definition across society. The trans advocacy movement and the backlash against it has changed that.
What ADF is not acknowledging is that prior to about 2016, no one needed to define sex under the law because it had a nearly universally shared definition across society. The trans advocacy movement and the backlash against it has changed that.
Quoting @JackThompsonFOX: Alliance Defending Freedom attorney John Bursch called Block's argument "completely bizarre."
"It says a lot that he felt and the ACLU felt that he had to tell the court not to define sex in order for them to survive this case."
The ACLU evidently does not want sex to be defined in the sports ban cases before SCOTUS.
If the court were to define sex and to state explicitly that it does not include gender identity, this likely could provide devastating for the trans movement, legal experts have told me. It could be used as a precedent off of which to segregate single-sex spaces based on biological sex, including bathrooms and locker rooms, prisons, and domestic violence and homeless shelters.
Quoting @JackThompsonFOX: The attorney representing a trans athlete in West Virginia argued to the Supreme Court that the definition of 'sex' should not be used when ruling on how to enforce Title IX during oral arguments today. I asked the ACLU's Joshua Block what his definition of 'sex' is after the hearing, and he did not provide his definition, and insisted it's not what's at issue in the case. He then dodged any further questions.
“We do not have a definition for the court.” —the lawyer representing the plaintiff in the Idaho trans sports ban case, when asked for a definition of sex by Justice Alito
Quotes a post by T34666; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
NYT reports: The Supreme Court's "conservative majority showed no signs of an inclination to strike down state laws barring transgender athletes from participating in girls’ and women’s sports."
Today, the Supreme Court holds historic oral arguments on state bans restricting school sports for girls and women by biological sex. Transgender advocates are concerned that a ruling could have sweeping implications trans civil rights. I reported on the cases for @[private account]:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Supreme Court To Grapple With the Role of Transgender Athletes in Sports
I report for @[private account]: On Tues, the justices will hear oral arguments about Idaho & West Virginia laws that restrict those born male from sports specifically for girls and women.
https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
This is a common argument among transgender advocates: that they should not give an inch on trans inclusion in sports due to slippery-slope fears.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Supreme Court To Grapple With the Role of Transgender Athletes in Sports
I report for @[private account]: On Tues, the justices will hear oral arguments about Idaho & West Virginia laws that restrict those born male from sports specifically for girls and women.
https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
The question is not whether one trans student one or lost, it is whether on balance, as a group, they hold a competitive advantage due to sustained exposure to testosterone. Present exposure to testosterone isn’t necessarily the most relevant factor. A history of a sustained exposure to testosterone is what is most relevant.
The claim by NPR that there is only a handful of trans youth playing sports is belied by survey data, reported by @[private account], that 19% of trans and gender expansive youth play sports. That translates, based on data from a CDC survey, to about 135,000 middle and high school students.
Notice how @[private account] doesn't even mention the review papers by @[private account] and @Fondofbeetles finding that trans women on gender-transition treatment maintain a competitive advantage in women's sports. I spoke with Dr. Joyner and other experts who criticized the methodology of the IOC study. They all called its conclusions weak and unreliable. https://www.npr.org/2026/01/11/nx-s1-5671203/supreme-court-weighs-bans-on-trans-athletes-in-womens-and-girls-sports-teams
Media outlets that claim that transgender women have no competitive advantage over women in athletics are not making evidence-based claims.
Two recent review papers, by @[private account] and @Fondofbeetles, have found that even after sustained testosterone suppression and estrogen treatment, biological males still maintain a competitive advantage in women's sports. The research is less clear about those who have undergone pubertal suppression and then estrogen treatment starting soon after puberty's onset. However, Dr. Joyner's research indicates that prepubescent boys have a small but significant competitive advantage over girls, likely because of exposure to testosterone in utero and a surge of T during "mini puberty" during infancy.
Sources: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39716906/
Quotes a post by A0452; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The head of the NCAA said off the top of his head in Dec. 2024 that there were around 10 openly transgender athletes in the NCAA. But there aren't exacting accounts of middle or high school players. We just have national survey data.
For more on why I use certain words and not others when writing about transgender issues, see: https://benryan.substack.com/p/journalists-should-not-use-the-term
Given that transgender status is based on having a cross-sex gender identity, I defend the use of the expression “people who identify as transgender.” Furthermore, as Chase Strangio asserted under questioning by Justice Alito in Skrmetti, gender identity can be fluid. Therefore, suggesting that the identity is not necessarily fixed is appropriate.
Advocates of inclusion of transgender girls and women in girls' and women's sports often assert that evidence of their winning championships are rare and their participation is slight. However, given recent survey data, it appears that about 135,000 trans youth participate in middle and high-school sports. How this breaks down by biological sex is unknown, but among adolescents, natal girls identifying as male are more common than natal males identifying as female.
Quoting @benryanwriter: According to a 2023 @[private account] report, 19 percent of transgender and “gender expansive” youth played sports. While this rate is disproportionately low, the Williams Institute estimates based on a federal survey conducted that same year that some 724,000, or 3.3 percent, of 13 to 17 year olds identified as transgender. This suggests that perhaps 135,000 such middle and high-school students engaged in athletics at that time. An estimated 8.3 million high schoolers participate in sports, according to the National Federation of State High School Associations. Comparable figures for middle school sports participation are less clear. https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
The Supreme Court has displayed a long reluctance to adding new categories of people who receive protection under the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. In Skrmetti, the pediatric gender-transition treatment case, Chief Justice Roberts sidestepped the question. However, in their concurring opinions, Justices Alito, Thomas and Barrett all indicated that they did not think that transgender status qualified as what's knows as a quasi-suspect class. So it appears very unlikely that the court will declare trans people as such a class. More concerning to the transgender advocacy movement is that this case could prompt the court to explicitly rule that trans people do not qualify for such protection under the Equal Protection clause. This could close future legal avenues for the trans movement.
Quoting @benryanwriter: After years of sidestepping the question, the Supreme Court could finally determine whether transgender status itself is considered a protected class under the Equal Protection Clause, as is sex — a determination with profound implications for civil-rights law. https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
The transgender sports bans that the Supreme Court will consider tomorrow will likely see the justices wrestling with questions of how the Equal Protection Clause and Title IX apply to laws barring from the female category biological males who identify as female and who have taken gender-transition treatment.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The trans-sports ban cases before the Supreme Court raise critical questions about how the Equal Protection Clause of the 14thAmendment applies to restrictions on transgender athletes competing on teams traditionally reserved for the opposite sex. The court will also be asked to consider how such laws square with the aims of Title IX, the federal law governing sex-based opportunities in education, and its associated regulations pertaining to sex-segregated sports teams. https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
Dr. Michael J. Joyner @[private account], an expert in exercise physiology and coauthor of one of the more recent review papers, told the Sun: “We summarized the clear cut evidence showing that biological males have an advantage in every key physiological domain relevant to sports performance. These advantages are not fully reversed or eliminated by testosterone suppression.”
In interviews, Dr. Joyner and other sports-physiology experts expressed confidence in such findings. These experts also questioned the validity of a recent, widely touted study conducted on behalf of the International Olympic Committee, published in 2024, that suggested that transgender women taking gender-transition treatment do not hold physiological advantages in women’s athletics in at least some domains. The critics called the study’s methodology weak and its findings unreliable. https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
According to a 2023 @[private account] report, 19 percent of transgender and “gender expansive” youth played sports. While this rate is disproportionately low, the Williams Institute estimates based on a federal survey conducted that same year that some 724,000, or 3.3 percent, of 13 to 17 year olds identified as transgender. This suggests that perhaps 135,000 such middle and high-school students engaged in athletics at that time. An estimated 8.3 million high schoolers participate in sports, according to the National Federation of State High School Associations. Comparable figures for middle school sports participation are less clear. https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
Ethics and Public Policy Center senior fellow @[private account], spoke squarely from the conservative camp when he told the Sun: “These cases should decisively defeat the claim of transgender ideologues that biological males who identify as female have a federal legal right to invade facilities and teams reserved for actual females.”
https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
ACLU litigator Chase Strangio, who is transgender, said in a recent podcast interview with @[private account] that those pushing for the sports-ban laws have “tricked” the public “into co-opting an anti-trans narrative that is really about building fascist institutions.” https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/2009800159916691650?s=20
Quoting @benryanwriter: In a pod with @[private account] about Tuesday’s oral arguments at SCOTUS about state laws restricting sports by natal sex, ACLU litigator Chase Strangio asserts that the public is being “tricked into co-opting an anti-trans narrative that is really about building fascist institutions.” https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/translash-podcast-with-imara-jones/id1527477503?i=1000744306389
After years of sidestepping the question, the Supreme Court could finally determine whether transgender status itself is considered a protected class under the Equal Protection Clause, as is sex — a determination with profound implications for civil-rights law. https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
The trans-sports ban cases before the Supreme Court raise critical questions about how the Equal Protection Clause of the 14thAmendment applies to restrictions on transgender athletes competing on teams traditionally reserved for the opposite sex. The court will also be asked to consider how such laws square with the aims of Title IX, the federal law governing sex-based opportunities in education, and its associated regulations pertaining to sex-segregated sports teams. https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
Supreme Court To Grapple With the Role of Transgender Athletes in Sports
I report for @[private account]: On Tues, the justices will hear oral arguments about Idaho & West Virginia laws that restrict those born male from sports specifically for girls and women.
https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-to-grapple-with-the-role-of-transgender-athletes-in-sports?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
A group of healthcare providers post an Instagram video decrying HHS’s efforts to clamp down on pediatric gender-transition treatment, saying that the Trump administration will not stop with transgender minors. If their care is taken away, they say, “no patient is safe.” https://www.instagram.com/reel/DTRFZtqEURM/?igsh=dm9qeDc3NjM4cTNk
One of the legal experts I spoke with said he thought that like with Skrmetti, they’ll strip all notions of transgender identity out of the ruling and just say that dividing based on sex is permitted under Title IX and that the plaintiffs are similarly situated with males, therefore this is no discrimination and no violation of Title IX or the Equal Protection Clause. They might also find the Idaho case moot due to the plaintiff withdrawing from any effort to participate in college sports. And the West Virginia case might get remanded to the district court for further debate on that level. Otherwise, the chance that this court will decide that trans people are a quasi-suspect class is next to zero. The court has always been reluctant to add new groups under the EP clause and three of the justices already said in their Skrmetti concurring opinions that they don’t think that trans people counted as a quasi-suspect class.
Thanks to Greg for identifying early evidence of the trans world adopting the concept of sex assignment, having appropriated the term from the intersex context. It would take until the 2010s for the trans world to begin widespread use of the term “sex assigned at birth.”
The term “sex assigned at birth” did not come into vogue in the trans context until the 2010s. You can see from the chart above that it began soaring in use in medical literature in 2014. Regardless of the route it took to get there, it was coined in the intersex context. And yes, it is a term grounded in activism. And it is an illogical term, given that sex is not externally assigned except in extremely rare cases of ambiguity, it just is.
Strangio is arguing in particular that the sports case might season Title IX or the 14th Amendment in ways that would leave others besides trans people vulnerable. He didn’t specify how. But this article talks about how the end of the Chevron doctrine could leave the sports elements Title IX vulnerable, since they’re based on regulations and not the statute or its amendment. https://thehill.com/opinion/4558681-title-ix-sports-are-booming-theyre-also-a-legal-house-of-cards/amp/
In a pod with @[private account] about Tuesday’s oral arguments at SCOTUS about state laws restricting sports by natal sex, ACLU litigator Chase Strangio asserts that the public is being “tricked into co-opting an anti-trans narrative that is really about building fascist institutions.” https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/translash-podcast-with-imara-jones/id1527477503?i=1000744306389
In a statement to @NYPost on Tues about @CBSNews' word choice when discussing transgender issues, remarks that have gone quite overlooked, @BariWeiss put the matter plainly:
CBS News is “a news organization that speaks plainly and clearly to its audience,” Weiss said. “Our audience is well aware of what biological sex is. There is no need to put it in quotation marks as if it’s an alien dialect or an obscure technicality.”
https://nypost.com/2026/01/06/media/cbs-news-staff-clashed-over-transgender-language-in-internal-email-blow-up/
Quoting @benryanwriter: Journalists Should Not Use the Term “Assigned Sex at Birth” When Covering Transgender Issues
A political-activist term misappropriated from the intersex context, it sticks a thumb on the scale regarding a contested legal issue about which reporters should strive to observe neutrality.
In its contribution to the media coverage of @BariWeiss’s young tenure at the helm of @CBSNews,The @Guardian reported this week about a recent dust-up among CBS staffers over the proper terms to use when covering transgender issues.
Noting this was an example of “cultural clashes on issues that align with” Ms. Weiss’ “worldview,” The Guardian reported:
"A prominent correspondent at the network wrote in an email…that CBS 'should refrain from adopting terminology advocated by the movement', referring to guidance from the Trans Journalists Association’s stylebook about how to use the phrase 'biological sex'.
"This didn’t go over well with a CBS producer, who responded angrily: 'It’s a TJA style "guide" – that’s what I’m trying to do. Guide us to better coverage.'”
If indeed CBS seeks to produce journalism without fear or favor about highly contested subjects of national importance, the correspondent was correct about the path to better coverage. Much of the nomenclature that the transgender movement has pushed journalists to employ comes with baked-in activist conclusions. What’s more, a lot of these terms are nonsensical. While it’s vital that reporters respect transgender people’s dignity, journalists need not heed pressure campaigns demanding that they totally overlook objective, scientific reality.
Regarding the term “biological sex,” which is reviled by many transgender advocates, the alternative they typically press reporters to use is “sex assigned at birth.” Journalists who are neither activists nor pundits and who at least strive for neutrality in their reporting should not use that term for two reasons:
1) It is unscientific doublespeak. In all but the rarest exceptions (which I will go into) sex is not “assigned,” it is observed and documented at birth.
2) It is a political-activist term that takes sides in a complex, multi-pronged debate. This includes unsettled policy questions about trans people’s right to access single-sex spaces, including prisons, domestic violence and homeless shelters, bathrooms and locker rooms, and sports teams.
To read my full essay, click here: https://benryan.substack.com/p/journalists-should-not-use-the-term
You're looking at it in too narrow a way and are being distracted by the fallacy of an identity itself causing risk. It is not the identity, but the sexual behaviors that are linked to that identity that cause the risk. I get extremely irritated when people say reductive things like "all people engaging in high risk behaviors are more vulnerable." Simply engaging in unprotected sex is not enough to quantify someone's risk. You are expressing this as a binary equation, but risk exists on a continuum. You also have to take into account the background HIV infection rate in their pool of sex partners and whether that population is on HIV treatment. An affluent white heterosexual man who has sex without a condom every night of the week with women for a year has a near zero chance of getting HIV because of all those factors. Whereas a black trans woman would probably contract HIV within a few weeks that way due to the types of partners she is inclined to have and the mechanics of how HIV transmits.
Transgender women have a very high HIV rate. Of any subgroup broken down by sex, sexual orientation and gender identity, trans women have the highest rate. If I had to guess, I'd say something like 25% of trans women in the use have HIV. Some injection drug user populations at a certain point in history might have had a higher rate, but probably not more recently. Various reasons might account for the very high rate in trans women, including poorer access to routine health care (where they might be treated for STIs, which can fuel transmission, and get access to PrEP), a higher rate of sex work. Various mental health and related drug-use problems might fuel transmission (depressed people or those high on meth might be less inclined to observe safer sex practices).
Journalists Should Not Use the Term “Assigned Sex at Birth” When Covering Transgender Issues
A political-activist term misappropriated from the intersex context, it sticks a thumb on the scale regarding a contested legal issue about which reporters should strive to observe neutrality.
In its contribution to the media coverage of @BariWeiss’s young tenure at the helm of @CBSNews,The @Guardian reported this week about a recent dust-up among CBS staffers over the proper terms to use when covering transgender issues.
Noting this was an example of “cultural clashes on issues that align with” Ms. Weiss’ “worldview,” The Guardian reported:
"A prominent correspondent at the network wrote in an email…that CBS 'should refrain from adopting terminology advocated by the movement', referring to guidance from the Trans Journalists Association’s stylebook about how to use the phrase 'biological sex'.
"This didn’t go over well with a CBS producer, who responded angrily: 'It’s a TJA style "guide" – that’s what I’m trying to do. Guide us to better coverage.'”
If indeed CBS seeks to produce journalism without fear or favor about highly contested subjects of national importance, the correspondent was correct about the path to better coverage. Much of the nomenclature that the transgender movement has pushed journalists to employ comes with baked-in activist conclusions. What’s more, a lot of these terms are nonsensical. While it’s vital that reporters respect transgender people’s dignity, journalists need not heed pressure campaigns demanding that they totally overlook objective, scientific reality.
Regarding the term “biological sex,” which is reviled by many transgender advocates, the alternative they typically press reporters to use is “sex assigned at birth.” Journalists who are neither activists nor pundits and who at least strive for neutrality in their reporting should not use that term for two reasons:
1) It is unscientific doublespeak. In all but the rarest exceptions (which I will go into) sex is not “assigned,” it is observed and documented at birth.
2) It is a political-activist term that takes sides in a complex, multi-pronged debate. This includes unsettled policy questions about trans people’s right to access single-sex spaces, including prisons, domestic violence and homeless shelters, bathrooms and locker rooms, and sports teams.
To read my full essay, click here: https://benryan.substack.com/p/journalists-should-not-use-the-term
One week after Trans News Network was taking to task for publishing a stream of falsehoods and unsubstantiated claims about NYT that TNN refused to acknowledge or correct, GLAAD nominated them for an Outstanding Independent Journalism Award.
In a national poll of 1,055 LGBTQ adults in May/June 2025, including 111 transgender and nonbinary people, the Movement Advancement Project found that since Nov. 2024:
•55% of transgender respondents have taken steps to be less visible as an LGBTQ person in their community, such as at work or school, compared to 24% of all LGBTQ respondents.
•43% of transgender people have considered moving to a different state, compared to 25% of all LGBTQ people.
• 9% of transgender people report they’ve actually moved to a different state since November 2024, as have 5% of all LGBTQ people.
•36% of transgender people have considered finding a different job or place of work, compared to 18% of LGBTQ people.
•22% of transgender people have actually changed jobs or workplaces since November 2024, as have 11% of all LGBTQ people.
The term "sex assigned at birth" ONLY applies to these rare cases where it's possible that doctors will incorrectly sex a baby on sight. All the other scenarios and figures you're throwing at me are just a bunch of muddled straw man arguments. More importantly, none of this has anything directly to do with transgender people.
I never said sexed bodies don't cause distress; I simply didn't address that issue. But no one assigned trans people's sexed bodies to them, they were simply born with those bodies. But what IS assigned to pretty much everyone are gendered expectations that align with their sex and by association their sexed bodies. These are cultural choices that people make to expect that boys will do certain things and girls will do other things.
This proposed public-private funding structure in Vermont is similar to what Mandani wants to do in New York City, providing tens of millions of taxpayer funds to support gender-transition treatment, including to minors.
As I wrote in June for the @[private account]: "Mr. Mandami’s detailed policy platform, the young state assemblyman calls for spending $65 million to 'expand and protect gender affirming care citywide … for both transgender youth and adults.'"
Erin Reed writes about Vermont: https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/vermont-bill-would-create-state-trust
My coverage of Mandani's proposals from June: https://www.nysun.com/article/breakout-new-york-mayoral-contender-zohran-mamdani-wants-to-spend-65-million-on-medical-gender-treatments-for-minors-and-adults?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
Follow my Substack for updates on pediatric gender medicine: https://benryan.substack.com
Her arguments are bonkers. She's trying to argue that by changing sex characteristics via hormones or surgery that that actually changes someone's underlying sex. This is false, because no interventions can provide a natal male functioning ovaries nor a natal female functioning testicles. Those are required to produce hormonal levels, either testosterone or estrogen, endogenously that put someone in the male or female range. None of this means that people can't be treated as the opposite sex, including under the law, if they seek to be. In short, in this article, she bends the reality of biology to make a legal argument. As for DSD cases, the rate of infants born with genitalia that might throw off the simple sexing of the baby at a glance of their genitalia is about 0.02%. Debate and nomenclature pertaining to these very rare cases has been misappropriated to apply to transgender people who were born with a clear and obvious sex but whose gender identity conflicts with their sex.
What is indeed “assigned” at birth is the set of gendered expectations that go along with someone’s sex, such as how someone is expected to dress, what type of toys they should play with, what sex of friends they should have, etc. It is those deeply ingrained cultural expectations that many transgender people find especially intolerable.
The Bluesky folks are over there painting it as having been a big conservative plot to start using the term “biological sex” about a decade ago. But before then, there was no need, in discussions about law in particular, to use a qualifier before the word “sex.” The concepts of male and female sex were universally understood.
But given how the trans movement changed the concept of sex, misappropriating the term “sex assigned at birth” from the DSD context, for one, it became necessary to use terms like “biological sex,” “natal sex” or “birth sex” to distinguish between an individual’s underlying sex and their gender identity and how they might have changed their body through cross-sex hormone use or gender-transition surgeries.
One need not have been a conservative or have been influenced by conservative groups to have intuited that the use of these qualifiers became necessary during the 2010s.
Also, the use of these qualifiers need not imply that anyone is opposed to transgender people living and being treated as their own gender. Saying someone is “biologically male” does not inherently preclude supporting their effort to transition genders and to take estrogen, get breast implants, etc. These words are needed simply for clarity. Such clarity can be very important, for example, in medical records, so doctors know whether to screen a patient for cervical or prostate cancer even if they present as male or female, respectively.
Lastly, it quite annoying that I cannot directly respond to the Bluesky people about this since they have all blocked me in an effort to support the boundaries of their echo chamber.
Sexing a baby at a glance is 99.98% accurate and all this talk of DSD conditions is just a straw man where transgender people are concerned. Also, all people with DSDs have one of the two sexes. And more modern techniques are more better at determining this at birth in the even if ambiguous genitalia.
Lots of ping ponging in Colorado over gender care for kids. Today’s news:
https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/judge-rejects-dojs-subpoena-childrens-hospital-colorado-over-transgender-care-2026-01-06/
Quoting @benryanwriter: Children’s Hospital Colorado has suspended gender-affirming care for transgender youth amid a new federal investigation
HHS has referred the hospital for investigation by the agency’s Office of the Inspector General.
https://coloradosun.com/2026/01/02/childrens-hospital-colorado-gender-affirming-care-kennedy/
See, that actually makes sense: When we are born with our specific sex, society does generally assign a host of gender-related expectations on us. We do not ask for these and some people grow to resent them. For trans people in particular, these expectations can become wholly intolerable. I just wish we could remain in the land of reality when we talk about these very real issues that many people, myself included, face. Most of my friends were girls when I was a kid and I found the expectation that I had to play sports because I was a boy quite burdensome indeed!
Someone is over on Bluesky dragging me about this post. But his entire thread concerns people with DSD conditions, not trans people. Which only underlines my point: The term "sex assigned at birth" has been misappropriated by trans activism to apply to people whose gender identity is different from their sex.
He is also incorrect about his claim that nothing has changed in the ability to discern the sex of babies with DSDs since the 60s. Newer technologies have made this process much more precise.
He also exaggerates how commonly babies are born with genitalia that is ambiguous enough to throw off sexing based on a simple glance at the genitals. The true figure is 0.02%, not 0.5%, as he claims.
Sexing a baby at a glance is 99.98% accurate, people.
The Times didn’t mention in its fact check that the Trans News Network post misquoted this Jeremy Peters article in a way that quite changes the implication of the quote, by omitting the word “often.”
I support that. For one thing, if someone has changed their name and sex marker in their government documents, it is not a reporter's place to override that.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred
"Assigned sex at birth" is a term coined for infants with differences of sex development (DSD), which used to be called intersex conditions (itself a misnomer, since sex, based on which gamete the body is geared around producing, is binary). The term has been misappropriated by the transgender movement to suggest that sex is anything but fixed.
A furry explained this situation to me. He said that within the wider queer community, furries work both to defend their sexual proclivities and their radical-queer mindset toward sexuality as well as their honor. So to have someone within the queer community attack their sexuality and compare it to a loathsome outside group, the incels, enrages them. My source said this is not a new schism but represents a long running tension between subsets of the LGBTQ community. He also said that Molloy’s response to the sexualization of the characters was likely more grounded in feminism than in her being trans.
Quoting @benryanwriter: In a brouhaha tailor made for @[private account], furry fury has erupted on Bluesky after the typically popular transgender pundit Parker Molloy expressed misgivings about adding bodacious breasts to AI-driven characters. The pile-on has led Molloy to leave BS, which is typically a haven for transgender voices. This suggests a schism, perhaps, between the furry and non-furry (“hairless”?) factions of the queer community?
Will someone who understands such byzantine politics please explain this to me? I know from the most recent Blocked and Reported that there’s big drama about putting breasts on My Little Pony characters and there’s this whole subculture of adult men who are into MLP. Are they now colliding with rank and file trans advocates?
The Trans News Network Q&A that The New York Times asserts is riddled with errors: https://transnews.network/p/a-directive-from-above-former-nyt-editor-lays-out-how-the-paper-pushes-anti-trans-bigotry
The New York Times responds to a recent Q&A with a transgender former editor from the Times that was published by Trans News Network and went viral on Bluesky. TNN refused to publish any of their responses challenging the Q&A's false claims.
https://www.nytco.com/press/fact-checking-false-claims-about-our-gender-identity-coverage/
"Fact-Checking False Claims about our Gender Identity Coverage
"Factually inaccurate criticisms of New York Times journalism present a false picture and promote misunderstanding of our coverage on gender identity.
A recent post from Trans News Network included numerous falsehoods about New York Times stories on gender identity and maligned some of the journalists involved in the work.
"Our coverage is guided by facts and questions, and reflects the experiences of those we interview. Our work has deeply and accurately covered the lives of trans people and the bigotry they face. Discussions about the cultural changes around gender are part of our coverage, too, as well as fiercely contested medical and legal debates about interventions for adolescents. In all of this work, our journalists are dedicated toward one aim: fair-minded, fact-based reporting.
"The post from TNN featured an interview with a former editor on the International desk at The Times who was not involved in these coverage decisions. Despite numerous inaccurate statements, the author conducting the interview did not seek comment or check facts with The Times before publication and has refused to make substantive corrections or include a statement that The Times provided about the interview. Though presented as news, it did not meet the most basic journalistic standards of fairness or accuracy.
"Here is a small sampling of inaccuracies, which range from easily disprovable facts to wholly invented conspiracy theories:
"—The post claims multiple times without evidence, including in the headline, that upper leadership at The Times issued directives to attack trans people. This is false. It also claims these stories were done to please the Trump administration. This, too, is false.
"—It claims that a 2023 article about parental rights did not directly quote the young person at the center of the story. This is false.
"—It claims that The Times responded to a protest by publishing an Opinion column the next day. This is false. Columnists voice their own opinions, and their columns are generally written and scheduled days in advance, as this one was.
"—It claims that a UK reporter was assigned to cover the Cass report and wrote a draft that was killed because the story was given to the Science desk. This is false. No UK correspondent was assigned or drafted a story about the Cass report. The Science and London teams had discussed and coordinated coverage of the Cass report in the weeks before its expected release, and had agreed that the news would be covered by science.
"There are numerous other errors of fact as well. The article also falsely says that the first person quoted in a 2024 story about transgender activists was J.K. Rowling. Additionally, Virginia Hughes is wrongly identified as 'co-head' of the Investigations desk; that is not her role."
In a brouhaha tailor made for @[private account], furry fury has erupted on Bluesky after the typically popular transgender pundit Parker Molloy expressed misgivings about adding bodacious breasts to AI-driven characters. The pile-on has led Molloy to leave BS, which is typically a haven for transgender voices. This suggests a schism, perhaps, between the furry and non-furry (“hairless”?) factions of the queer community?
Will someone who understands such byzantine politics please explain this to me? I know from the most recent Blocked and Reported that there’s big drama about putting breasts on My Little Pony characters and there’s this whole subculture of adult men who are into MLP. Are they now colliding with rank and file trans advocates?
At Middlebury, She Hoped to Start Fresh. In Trump’s America, It Seemed Impossible.
Lia Smith was a senior at Middlebury College, a transgender woman and, for a time, an athlete on the school’s diving team. But she struggled to feel accepted, and in October, she took her own life.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/05/us/middlebury-college-trans-student-suicide.html
Even more than with Skrmetti, there are legal onion layers that have to be peeled before the Supreme Court even gets to the question of sex-based competitiveness in sports and the mitigating impact of testosterone suppression and estrogen treatment, and it might not in these two sports cases (Hecox and BPJ). So while it might seem to the causal observer this case might hinge on the question of “what is a woman?” and “do biological males belong in women’s locker rooms,” the reality is a lot more complex than that. After all, in the end, Skrmetti didn’t hinge upon whether gender transition treatment is safe and effective, but on the notion that the Tennessee ban hinged upon diagnosis and not identity. That said, a legal expert I talked to today thinks that the justices will finally rule on whether transgender status amounts to a quasi-suspect class like sex.
Quoting @xx_xyathletics: On Jan 13th, join us for a rally on the Supreme Court steps in Washington D.C. That’s the day opening oral arguments begin for 2 cases centered around the protection of women’s sports. Men and women are different. And women and girls deserve their own sports. This is what is at stake. This is what we are fighting for.
Note: While some of the scientific debates are a matter of dispute in the two cases to be heard in oral arguments before SCOTUS next week regarding trans sports bans, the question of testosterone being the driver of real sex-based differences in athletic ability is not up for debate; both parties agree on this.
In which the authors of a new book arguing for trans inclusion in sports, Fair Play, argue that sex segregation in sports is based on sexist stereotypes and suggest that it should be abandoned. 1/2 https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/there-is-a-vast-over-inflation-of
Quoting @benryanwriter: "There Is a Vast Over-Inflation of What Testosterone Does": a Kinesiologist Casts Doubt on Sex-Based Athletic Differences
https://benryan.substack.com/publish/post/183291140
I spoke with the authors of a new book calling for radical inclusiveness for trans youth in sports, in advance of the Supreme Court's oral arguments this month on state restrictions on such inclusion.
The book casts doubt on the power of testosterone on determining competitiveness in sports. It insists that sex is not binary. And it goes so far as to suggest that there shouldn’t even be sex segregation in sports at all.
"There Is a Vast Over-Inflation of What Testosterone Does": a Kinesiologist Casts Doubt on Sex-Based Athletic Differences
https://benryan.substack.com/p/there-is-a-vast-over-inflation-of
I spoke with the authors of a new book calling for radical inclusiveness for trans youth in sports, in advance of the Supreme Court's oral arguments this month on state restrictions on such inclusion.
They sidestep the issue of fairness according to sex boundaries and pose wider questions about the broader meaning to the term, pointing to people such as Michael Phelps who harbor biological advantages in sport. And they assert that trans people are structurally disadvantaged, which makes it harder for them to achieve excellence in sports. More broadly, they argue that inclusion is a better baseline policy and that it is to everyone’s benefit to observe a more inclusive system.
What you hear from Dr. Baeth in my interview about trans inclusion in sports, linked below, is a reflection of the tendency among certain academics, in particular those who lean left, to attribute differences between people not to intrinsic factors or personal agency but to structural and socioeconomic differences. Such arguments de-emphasize membership to disadvantaged groups, such as being female, nonwhite, or of low socioeconomic status or lesser education as the driver of inequality and instead fault the difference on structures imposed on such groups by those in power. There is little room for personal agency or genetics in these arguments. One cannot blame the victim, so to speak. Everything is the fault of those in power.
Examples that come up in my own reporting work include attributing higher HIV transmission in young black gay men to homophobia and racism rather than to, at least in part, personal behavior patterns; or in this case, attributing women’s lesser athletic prowess not to their endogenously lower testosterone, but to structural lack of opportunity and the burden sex stereotyping. This despite research suggesting that women, on average, will never be as strong as men no matter how hard they try.
This mindset contrasts sharply with conservative attitudes, which emphasize the importance of grit, rugged individualism and personal striving.
I’d be curious to hear from philosophers and other academics if there is an established term for this common intellectual framing among liberals that impacts how academics conceive of myriad inequalities in fields such as medicine, physiology and public health. @robkhenderson @[private account] @[private account] @[private account]
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/there-is-a-vast-over-inflation-of
Children’s Hospital Colorado has suspended gender-affirming care for transgender youth amid a new federal investigation
HHS has referred the hospital for investigation by the agency’s Office of the Inspector General.
https://coloradosun.com/2026/01/02/childrens-hospital-colorado-gender-affirming-care-kennedy/
The following things cannot all be true:
1. Testosterone doesn’t determine competitiveness between the sexes.
2. Going on blockers and estrogen slows down trans women.
3. Steroids provoke an unfair advantage in sport and are justly banned.
"There Is a Vast Over-Inflation of What Testosterone Does": a Kinesiologist Casts Doubt on Sex-Based Athletic Differences
https://benryan.substack.com/publish/post/183291140
I spoke with the authors of a new book calling for radical inclusiveness for trans youth in sports, in advance of the Supreme Court's oral arguments this month on state restrictions on such inclusion.
The book casts doubt on the power of testosterone on determining competitiveness in sports. It insists that sex is not binary. And it goes so far as to suggest that there shouldn’t even be sex segregation in sports at all.
@[private account], note that one of the nation’s most prominent and influential trans activists has refused to read your article. https://open.substack.com/pub/americandreaming/p/memory-hole-archive-sex-and-transgender?r=7wxo1&utm_medium=ios&shareImageVariant=overlay
On the contrary, the cases, which concern minors and adults alike, ask whether the care providers followed the standard of care, including whether they provided a psychosocial assessment as recommended by WPATH and whether they provided the patient proper informed consent. Two cases accuse clinics of violating the civil rights of gay men by failing to recognize that they were not trans but suffered from internalized homophobia manifesting as gender dysphoria.
The detransitioner civil suits, of which there are about 30 to date, call into question the attitude, expressed by Decker below, that patients seeking gender-transition drugs or surgeries are, simply, responsible for their choices.
Are minors responsible?
Are people with multiple psych diagnoses responsible?
Most of these lawsuits are structured to argue that the mental health providers and doctors who cared for the plaintiffs did not meet the standard of care for such treatment. So this could mean the psychologists referred an adolescent for blockers, hormones or surgery after only a cursory assessment. Or it could mean that the doctors failed to provide the patient and, in the case of minors, their guardians, proper informed consent, warning of them of all the potential negative ramifications of the treatment.
Two of the cases take direct aim at the World Professional Association for Transgender Health's Standards of Care, the widely referenced trans-care guidelines. They make civil rights claims against two major LGBTQ community health clinics, @[private account] and @[private account]. They allege that these clinics violated the civil rights of gay men by failing to determine that their gender dysphoria was, in fact, an outgrowth of internalized homophobia. The plaintiffs, who are natal males, each underwent gender-transition interventions to transition to women, and later detransitioned. One of them, Paul Garcia-Ryan, was featured in Pamela Paul's coverage in @[private account]: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/02/opinion/transgender-children-gender-dysphoria.html
Quotes a post by T02312; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.